Pierpont syndrome associated with the p.Tyr446Cys missense mutation in TBL1XR1

The spectrum of neurological presentation in individuals affected by TBL1XR1 gene defects

BACKGROUND

TBL1XR1 encodes a F-box-like/WD40 repeat-containing protein that plays a role in transcription mediated by nuclear receptors and is a known genetic cause of neurodevelopmental disease of childhood (OMIM# 608628). Yet the developmental trajectory and progression of neurologic symptoms over time remains poorly understood.

METHODS

We developed and distributed a survey to two closed Facebook groups devoted to families of patients with TBL1XR1-related disorder. The survey consisted of 14 subsections focused upon the developmental trajectories of cognitive, behavioral, motor, and other neurological abnormalities. Data were collected and managed using REDCap electronic data capture tools.

RESULTS

Caregivers of 41 patients with a TBL1XR1-related disorder completed the cross-sectional survey. All reported variants affecting a single amino acid, including missense mutations and in-frame deletions, were found in the WD40 repeat regions of Tbl1xr1. These are domains considered important for protein-protein interactions that may plausibly underlie disease pathology. The majority of patients were diagnosed with a neurologic condition before they received their genetic diagnosis. Language appeared most significantly affected with only a minority of the cohort achieving more advanced milestones in this domain.

CONCLUSION

TBL1XR1-related disorder encompasses a spectrum of clinical presentations, marked by early developmental delay ranging in severity, with a subset of patients experiencing developmental regression in later childhood.

Expanding the genotypic and phenotypic spectrum associated with TBL1XR1 de novo variants

BACKGROUND

The TBL1XR1 gene encodes the protein transducin-beta-like 1 receptor1, widely distributed in the pituitary, hypothalamus, white and brown adipose tissue, muscle, and liver. Current evidence suggests that heterozygous TBL1XR1 pathogenic variants can lead to a wide spectrum of phenotypes. This study aims to reveal the clinical phenotype and genetic profiles of de novo TBL1XR1 variations and summarize the relevant clinical and genetic features.

METHODS

We analyzed four new cases harboring de novo TBL1XR1 variants and reviewed all reported cases.

RESULTS

All probands suffered from global developmental delay. Moreover, patient 1 exhibited susceptibility to startle, patient 2 had hypovitaminosis D, short stature and hyponatremia, and patients 3 and 4 both presented with ASD (Autism spectrum disorder) and short stature. They all had a de novo TBL1XR1 variant (NM_024665.7), c.1184A > G (p.Tyr395Cys), c.1108G > A (p.Asp370Asn), c.1047 + 1G > C, and c.1097C > T (p.Ser366Phe) respectively. In addition, pooled analysis of 51 cases showed that they had speech impairment (38/39), intellectual developmental disorder (28/28), global developmental delay (42/42), and hypotonia (24/27), and some of them had epilepsy (10/22), ASD (13/25), and developmental regression (4/13).

CONCLUSIONS

We report four new patients with de novo TBL1XR1 variants and provide a comprehensive overview of 47 previously reported individuals with TBL1XR1 variants, enriching the genotypic and phenotypic spectrum of TBL1XR1-related disease. This report further validates the pathogenicity de novo TBL1XR1 variants.

A novel de novo pathogenic variant in TBL1XR1 as a new proposed cause of Pierpont syndrome

TBL1XR1, which encodes transducing β-like 1 X-linked receptor 1, is implicated in both Pierpont syndrome and intellectual developmental disorder, autosomal dominant-41 (MRD-41, OMIM #616944). While both conditions are autosomal dominant, variants associated with Pierpont syndrome are believed to behave in a dominant negative fashion, whereas those causing MRD-41 result in haploinsufficiency. Here, we present a patient with a de novo novel variant in TBL1XR1 (c.977G > A,p.S326N) identified by trio exome sequencing. Though a different variant at this same residue has previously been associated with MRD-41, our patient's presentation is suggestive of Pierpont syndrome. The patient's clinical phenotype, which includes short stature, developmental delay, dysmorphic craniofacial features, and plantar fat pads, more closely resembles that of known patients with Pierpont syndrome than MRD-41. Furthermore, this missense variant is directly adjacent to one previously associated with Pierpont syndrome and exists in the same region as all variants associated with Pierpont, on the inner surface of a WD40 ring. We propose this variant is a newly identified cause of Pierpont syndrome.

Novel Arthrogryposis Multiplex Congenita Presentation in a Newborn With Pierpont Syndrome

Pierpont syndrome is a rare and recently described multiple congenital anomaly syndrome, classically characterized by global developmental delay, distinctive facial dysmorphic features, and abnormal fat distribution in distal limbs. Only few cases were previously documented. We report a case of a term male neonate admitted to the neonatal intensive care unit because of feeding difficulties. Intrauterine growth restriction, microcephaly, and bilateral equinovarus foot were diagnosed in the second trimester, and prenatal array comparative genomic hybridization showed no abnormality. Physical examination revealed bilateral flexion deformities of wrists, elbows, knees and clubfoot, large hands and feet, deep palmar and plantar grooves, and calcaneo-plantar fat pads. Craniofacial dysmorphism, axial hypotonia, and hypoactivity were also observed. Due to the presence of congenital and non-progressive joint contractures, arthrogryposis multiplex congenita (AMC) was considered. A comprehensive diagnostic workup, including a Next Generation Sequencing target panel, was performed but did not establish a diagnosis. The clinical exome identified an heterozygous pathogenic variant in the TBL1XR1 gene (NM_001321194.1: c.1337A>G, p.[Tyr446Cys]), allowing Pierpont syndrome diagnosis. Our case stands out for reporting the novel AMC presentation in a Pierpont syndrome newborn. The broader and precocious genetic testing proved to be an essential clarifying diagnostic tool. Our patient supports the relation between the p.Tyr446Cys sequence variant in TBL1XR1 gene with this rare syndrome, reinforcing its association with a distinctive and recognizable phenotype, as well as expanding its clinical features to include AMC.

Rare variant of TBL1XR1 in West syndrome: A case report

BACKGROUND

West syndrome (WS) is an epileptic encephalopathy (EE) that begins in children 4-7 months of age (in rare cases older than 2 years). To date, over 30 genes that have been reported to be related to WS. Reports involving the extremely rare pathogenic gene, transducin beta-like 1-X- linked receptor 1(TBL1XR1) are quite limited.

METHODS

We performed exome sequencing (ES) of family trios for this infant. We also collected and summarized the clinical data for reported heterozygous germline variants of TBL1XR1. Moreover, we reviewed all published cases and summarized the clinical features and genetic variants of TBL1XR1.

RESULTS

ES revealed a de novo variant in TBL1XR1 [NM_024665.5: exon4: c.187G > A (p.Glu63Lys)]. This variant was classified as likely pathogenic according to the ACMG (American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics) guidelines and was verified by Sanger sequencing. Further conservation analyses revealed a high conservation among several species. There was clinical heterogeneity among all patients with TBL1XR1-related West syndrome.

CONCLUSION

Our results expand the pathogenic variant spectrum of TBL1XR1 and strengthen the pathogenic evidence of TBL1XR1 in West syndrome.

Novel De Novo TBL1XR1 Variant Causing PIERPONT Syndrome in an Indian Child: A Case Report and Genotype–Phenotype Review of Reported Patients

The transducin β-like-1 X-linked-receptor-1 gene (TBL1XR1) encodes for the TBL1XR1 protein which is involved in transcription. Single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) in the TBL1XR1 gene have been reported to be associated with Pierpont's syndrome (PS) which exhibits numerous features including global developmental delay (GDD), intellectual disability (ID), varying neurobehavioral and psychiatric manifestations with/without autism spectrum disorder (ASD), abnormal fat distribution in the distal extremities, short stature (SS), head circumference abnormalities, hearing loss (HL), and facial dysmorphisms. Eight PS patients, having a de novo mutation resulting in p.Tyr446Cys, showed no manifestations of ASD. The three other PS patients, having mutations resulting in p.Tyr446His, p.Cys325Tyr and p.Gly237Asp, respectively, and without the p.Tyr446Cys alteration, were in addition associated with neurobehavioral abnormalities, including ASD, hyperactivity, and self-mutilation tendencies. Here, via trio whole exome sequencing, we describe a 12th PS patient, the first from the Indian subcontinent, reflecting a novel TBL1XR1 p.His348Arg alteration. The proband is a 4.5-year-old male having GDD, speech delay, facial dysmorphisms, abnormal digital fat pads, hypotonia, microcephaly, patent ductus arteriosus, and ASD features. Our report strengthens the hypothesis that TBL1XR1 variants coding for the TBL1XR1 protein other than p.Tyr446Cys might be more commonly associated with a neurobehavioral phenotype and autistic tendencies.

Pierpont syndrome-Report of a new patient

We report on a 6-year-old girl with Pierpont Syndrome who was diagnosed using the whole-exome sequencing technique. In addition to commonly recognized traits, our patient had scoliosis, a feature reported only in one other occasion.

TBL1XR1 associated intellectual disability, a new missense variant with dysmorphic features plus autism: Expanding the phenotypic spectrum

Missense and frameshift pathogenic variants and microdeletions involving TBL1XR1 gene have been described in patients with intellectual disability, autism, Rett-like features and schizophrenia, some of them with the clinical diagnosis of Pierpont syndrome, a rare pattern of multiple congenital anomalies, but others without dysmorphic findings or with non-specific ones, and also patients with only some of the features associated with Pierpont syndrome. We here present a case with a de novo novel missense variant in TBL1XR1 gene with overlapping features with Pierpont syndrome and autism, a neurobehavioral manifestation not previously reported in Pierpont syndrome. This patient expands the phenotypic spectrum of TBL1XR1 gene pathogenic variants.

Nuclear receptor corepressors in intellectual disability and autism

Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is characterized by neurocognitive dysfunctions, such as impaired social interaction and language learning. Gene-environment interactions have a pivotal role in ASD pathogenesis. Nuclear receptor corepressors (NCORs) are transcription co-regulators physically associated with histone deacetylases (HDACs) and many known players in ASD etiology such as transducin β-like 1 X-linked receptor 1 and methyl-CpG binding protein 2. The epigenome-modifying NCOR complex is sensitive to many ASD risk factors, including HDAC inhibitor valproic acid and a variety of endocrine factors, xenobiotic chemicals, or metabolites that can directly bind to multiple nuclear receptors. Here, we review recent studies of NCORs in neurocognition using animal models and human genetics approaches. We discuss functional interplays between NCORs and other known players in ASD etiology. It is conceivable that the NCOR complex may bridge the in utero environmental risk factors of ASD with epigenetic remodeling and can serve as a converging point for many gene-environment interactions in the pathogenesis of ASD and intellectual disability.

Nuclear Receptor Coactivators (NCOAs) and Corepressors (NCORs) in the Brain

Nuclear receptor coactivators (NCOAs) and corepressors (NCORs) bind to nuclear hormone receptors in a ligand-dependent manner and mediate the transcriptional activation or repression of the downstream target genes in response to hormones, metabolites, xenobiotics, and drugs. NCOAs and NCORs are widely expressed in the mammalian brain. Studies using genetic animal models started to reveal pivotal roles of NCOAs/NCORs in the brain in regulating hormonal signaling, sexual behaviors, consummatory behaviors, exploratory and locomotor behaviors, moods, learning, and memory. Genetic variants of NCOAs or NCORs have begun to emerge from human patients with obesity, hormonal disruption, intellectual disability, or autism spectrum disorders. Here we review recent studies that shed light on the function of NCOAs and NCORs in the central nervous system.

On the verge of diagnosis: Detection, reporting, and investigation of de novo variants in novel genes identified by clinical sequencing

The variable evidence supporting gene-disease associations contributes to the difficulty of accurate variant reporting in a clinical setting. An evidence-based scoring system for evaluating the clinical validity of gene-disease associations, proposed by ClinGen, considers experimental as well as genetic evidence. De novo variants are heavily weighted, given the overall rarity in the genome and their contribution to human disease, however they are reported as "genes of unknown significance" in our center when there is insufficient evidence for the gene-disease assertion. We report a collection of 21 de novo variants in genes of unknown clinical significance ascertained via clinical testing, of which eight of 21 (38%) are predicted to cause loss of function. These genes were subjected to ClinGen scoring to assess the strength of gene-disease relationships. Using a cutoff for moderate high or strong, 10 of 21 genes now have sufficient evidence to qualify as likely pathogenic or pathogenic variants. Sharing such cases with phenotypic data is imperative to strengthen available genetic evidence to ultimately upgrade clinical validity classifications and facilitate accurate molecular diagnosis.

Central Hypothyroidism and Novel Clinical Phenotypes in Hemizygous Truncation of TBL1X

Transducin β-like 1 X-linked (TBL1X) gene encodes a subunit of the nuclear corepressor-silencing mediator for retinoid and thyroid hormone receptor complex (NCoR-SMRT) involved in repression of thyroid hormone action in the pituitary and hypothalamus. TBL1X defects were recently associated with central hypothyroidism and hearing loss. The current study aims to describe the clinical and genetic characterization of a male diagnosed with central hypothyroidism through thyroid hormone profiling, TRH test, brain MRI, audiometry, and psychological evaluation. Next-generation sequencing of known genes involved in thyroid disorders was implemented. The 6-year-old boy was diagnosed with central hypothyroidism [free T4: 10.42 pmol/L (normal: 12 to 22 pmol/L); TSH: 1.57 mIU/L (normal: 0.7 to 5.7 mIU/L)], with a mildly reduced TSH response to TRH. He was further diagnosed with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) at 7 years, alternating episodes of encopresis and constipation, and frequent headaches. MRI showed a normal pituitary but detected a Chiari malformation type I (CMI). At 10 years, audiometry identified poor hearing threshold at high frequencies. Sequencing revealed a nonsense hemizygous mutation in TBL1X [c.1015C>T; p.(Arg339Ter)] largely truncating its WD-40 repeat domain involved in nuclear protein-protein interactions. In conclusion, to our knowledge, we identified the first severely truncating TBL1X mutation in a patient with central hypothyroidism, hypoacusia, and novel clinical features like ADHD, gastrointestinal dysmotility, and CMI. Given the relevance of TBL1X and NCoR-SMRT for the regulation of transcriptional programs at different tissues (pituitary, cochlea, brain, fossa posterior, and cerebellum), severe mutations in TBL1X may lead to a distinct syndrome with a phenotypic spectrum wider than previously reported.

TBL1XR1 mutations in Pierpont syndrome are not restricted to the recurrent p.Tyr446Cys mutation

Pierpont syndrome is a rare and sporadic syndrome, including developmental delay, facial characteristics, and abnormal extremities. Recently, a recurrent de novo TBL1XR1 variant (c.1337A > G; p.Tyr446Cys) has been identified in eight patients by whole-exome sequencing. A dominant-negative effect of this mutation is strongly suspected, since patients with TBL1XR1 deletion and other variants predicting loss of function do not share the same phenotype. We report two patients with typical Pierpont-like syndrome features. Exome sequencing allowed identifying a de novo heterozygous missense TBL1XR1 variant in both patients, different from those already reported: p.Cys325Tyr and p.Tyr446His. The localization of these mutations and clinical features of Pierpont-like syndrome suggest that their functional consequences are comparable with the recurrent mutation previously described, and provided additional data to understand molecular mechanisms of TBL1XR1 anomalies.