Devastating recurrent brain ischemic infarctions and retinal disease in pediatric patients with CD59 deficiency

Complement-membrane regulatory proteins are absent from the nodes of Ranvier in the peripheral nervous system

BACKGROUND

Homozygous CD59-deficient patients manifest with recurrent peripheral neuropathy resembling Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS), hemolytic anemia and recurrent strokes. Variable mutations in CD59 leading to loss of function have been described and, overall, 17/18 of patients with any mutation presented with recurrent GBS. Here we determine the localization and possible role of membrane-bound complement regulators, including CD59, in the peripheral nervous systems (PNS) of mice and humans.

METHODS

We examined the localization of membrane-bound complement regulators in the peripheral nerves of healthy humans and a CD59-deficient patient, as well as in wild-type (WT) and CD59a-deficient mice. Cross sections of teased sciatic nerves and myelinating dorsal root ganglia (DRG) neuron/Schwann cell cultures were examined by confocal and electron microscopy.

RESULTS

We demonstrate that CD59a-deficient mice display normal peripheral nerve morphology but develop myelin abnormalities in older age. They normally express myelin protein zero (P0), ankyrin G (AnkG), Caspr, dystroglycan, and neurofascin. Immunolabeling of WT nerves using antibodies to CD59 and myelin basic protein (MBP), P0, and AnkG revealed that CD59 was localized along the internode but was absent from the nodes of Ranvier. CD59 was also detected in blood vessels within the nerve. Finally, we show that the nodes of Ranvier lack other complement-membrane regulatory proteins, including CD46, CD55, CD35, and CR1-related gene-y (Crry), rendering this area highly exposed to complement attack.

CONCLUSION

The Nodes of Ranvier lack CD59 and are hence not protected from complement terminal attack. The myelin unit in human PNS is protected by CD59 and CD55, but not by CD46 or CD35. This renders the nodes and myelin in the PNS vulnerable to complement attack and demyelination in autoinflammatory Guillain-Barré syndrome, as seen in CD59 deficiency.

A Splice Site Mutation Associated with Congenital CD59 Deficiency

Congenital CD59 deficiency is a recently described rare autosomal recessive disease associated with CD59 gene mutations that lead to deficient or dysfunctional CD59 protein on the cell surface. The disease is characterized by the early onset of chronic hemolysis, relapsing peripheral demyelinating neuropathy, and recurrent ischemic strokes. To date, there are 14 patients with 4 exon mutations reported globally. A young boy with early onset peripheral neuropathy and atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome is presented. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) identified a homozygous splice site variant in intron 1 of the CD59 gene (c.67 + 1G > T). This variant alters a consensus donor splicing site. Quantitative reverse transcription PCR showed that CD59 mRNA expression in the patient is significantly reduced to 0.017-fold compared to the controls. Flow cytometry showed the lack of CD59 protein on the surface of the patient’s red blood cells. This variant is the first splice site mutation reported to be associated with congenital CD59 deficiency.

Complement and the prothrombotic state

In 2007 and 2009 the regulatory approval of the first-in-class complement inhibitor Eculizumab has revolutionized the clinical management of two rare, life-threatening clinical conditions: paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) and atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS). While being completely distinct diseases affecting blood cells and the glomerulus, PNH and aHUS remarkably share several features in their etiology and clinical presentation. An imbalance between complement activation and regulation at host surfaces underlies both diseases precipitating in severe thrombotic events that are largely resistant to anti-coagulant and/or anti-platelet therapies. Inhibition of the common terminal complement pathway by Eculizumab prevents the frequently occurring thrombotic events responsible for the high mortality and morbidity observed in patients not treated with anti-complement therapy. While many in vitro and ex vivo studies elaborate numerous different molecular interactions between complement activation products and hemostasis, this review focuses on the clinical evidence that links these two fields in humans. Several non-infectious conditions with known complement involvement are scrutinized for common patterns concerning a prothrombotic statues and the occurrence of certain complement activation levels. Next to PNH and aHUS, germline encoded CD59 or CD55 deficiency (the latter causing the disease Complement Hyperactivation, Angiopathic thrombosis, and Protein-Losing Enteropathy; CHAPLE), autoimmune hemolytic anemia (AIHA), (catastrophic) anti-phospholipid syndrome (APS, CAPS) and C3 glomerulopathy are considered. Parallels and distinct features among these conditions are discussed against the background of thrombosis, complement activation, and potential complement diagnostic and therapeutic avenues.

Therapeutic Targeting of the Complement System: From Rare Diseases to Pandemics

The complement system was discovered at the end of the 19th century as a heat-labile plasma component that "complemented" the antibodies in killing microbes, hence the name "complement." Complement is also part of the innate immune system, protecting the host by recognition of pathogen-associated molecular patterns. However, complement is multifunctional far beyond infectious defense. It contributes to organ development, such as sculpting neuron synapses, promoting tissue regeneration and repair, and rapidly engaging and synergizing with a number of processes, including hemostasis leading to thromboinflammation. Complement is a double-edged sword. Although it usually protects the host, it may cause tissue damage when dysregulated or overactivated, such as in the systemic inflammatory reaction seen in trauma and sepsis and severe coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). Damage-associated molecular patterns generated during ischemia-reperfusion injuries (myocardial infarction, stroke, and transplant dysfunction) and in chronic neurologic and rheumatic disease activate complement, thereby increasing damaging inflammation. Despite the long list of diseases with potential for ameliorating complement modulation, only a few rare diseases are approved for clinical treatment targeting complement. Those currently being efficiently treated include paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria, atypical hemolytic-uremic syndrome, myasthenia gravis, and neuromyelitis optica spectrum disorders. Rare diseases, unfortunately, preclude robust clinical trials. The increasing evidence for complement as a pathogenetic driver in many more common diseases suggests an opportunity for future complement therapy, which, however, requires robust clinical trials; one ongoing example is COVID-19 disease. The current review aims to discuss complement in disease pathogenesis and discuss future pharmacological strategies to treat these diseases with complement-targeted therapies. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: The complement system is the host's defense friend by protecting it from invading pathogens, promoting tissue repair, and maintaining homeostasis. Complement is a double-edged sword, since when dysregulated or overactivated it becomes the host's enemy, leading to tissue damage, organ failure, and, in worst case, death. A number of acute and chronic diseases are candidates for pharmacological treatment to avoid complement-dependent damage, ranging from the well established treatment for rare diseases to possible future treatment of large patient groups like the pandemic coronavirus disease 2019.

Molecular pathogenesis of human CD59 deficiency

Objective

To characterize all 4 mutations described for CD59 congenital deficiency.

Methods

The 4 mutations, p.Cys64Tyr, p.Asp24Val, p.Asp24Valfs*, and p.Ala16Alafs*, were described in 13 individuals with CD59 malfunction. All 13 presented with recurrent Guillain-Barré syndrome or chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy, recurrent strokes, and chronic hemolysis. Here, we track the molecular consequences of the 4 mutations and their effects on CD59 expression, localization, glycosylation, degradation, secretion, and function. Mutants were cloned and inserted into plasmids to analyze their expression, localization, and functionality.

Results

Immunolabeling of myc-tagged wild-type (WT) and mutant CD59 proteins revealed cell surface expression of p.Cys64Tyr and p.Asp24Val detected with the myc antibody, but no labeling by anti-CD59 antibodies. In contrast, frameshift mutants p.Asp24Valfs* and p.Ala16Alafs* were detected only intracellularly and did not reach the cell surface. Western blot analysis showed normal glycosylation but mutant-specific secretion patterns. All mutants significantly increased MAC-dependent cell lysis compared with WT. In contrast to CD59 knockout mice previously used to characterize phenotypic effects of CD59 perturbation, all 4 hCD59 mutations generate CD59 proteins that are expressed and may function intracellularly (4) or on the cell membrane (2). None of the 4 CD59 mutants are detected by known anti-CD59 antibodies, including the 2 variants present on the cell membrane. None of the 4 inhibits membrane attack complex (MAC) formation.

Conclusions

All 4 mutants generate nonfunctional CD59, 2 are expressed as cell surface proteins that may function in non-MAC-related interactions and 2 are expressed only intracellularly. Distinct secretion of soluble CD59 may have also a role in disease pathogenesis.

CD59 deficiency presenting as polyneuropathy and Moyamoya syndrome with endothelial abnormalities of small brain vessels

CD59 is involved in lymphocyte signal transduction and regulates complement-mediated cell lysis by inhibiting the membrane attack complex. In the cases reported so far, congenital isolated CD59 deficiency was associated with recurrent episodes of hemolytic anemia, peripheral neuropathy, and strokes. Here, we report on a patient from a consanguineous Turkish family, who had a first episode of hemolytic anemia at one month of age and presented at 14 months with acute Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS). The child suffered repeated infection-triggered relapses leading to the diagnosis of chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy (CIDP). Although partly steroid-responsive, the polyneuropathy failed to be stabilized by a number of immunosuppressive agents. At the age of 6 years, he developed acute hemiparesis and showed progressive stenosis of proximal cerebral arteries, evolving into Moyamoya syndrome (MMS) with recurrent infarctions leading to death at 8 years of age. Post-mortem genetic analysis revealed a pathogenic p.(Asp49Valfs*31) mutation in CD59. Re-analysis of brain biopsy specimens showed absent CD59 expression and severe endothelial damage. Whereas strokes are a known feature of CD59 deficiency, MMS has not previously been described in this condition. Therefore, we conclude that in MMS combined with hemolysis or neuropathy CD59 deficiency should be considered. Establishing the diagnosis and targeted therapy with eculizumab might have prevented the lethal course in our patient.

Prothrombotic mechanisms in patients with congenital p.Cys89Tyr mutation in CD59

BACKGROUND

Thrombosis is the prognostic factor with the greatest effect on survival in patients with paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH), who lack dozens of membrane surface proteins. We recently described a primary homozygous Cys89Tyr congenital nonfunctioning CD59 in humans with clinical manifestation in infancy, associated with chronic hemolysis, recurrent strokes, and relapsing peripheral demyelinating neuropathy. Here we investigated hypercoagulability mechanisms characterizing the syndrome.

METHODS

Membrane attack complex (MAC) deposition (anti-SC5b-9) and free hemoglobin (colorimetric assay) were assessed. Platelet activation was identified (anti-CD61, anti-CD62P), and microparticles (MPs) of 0.5-0.9 μm, were characterized (Annexin V, anti-human GlyA, anti-CD15, anti-CD14, anti-CD61). Platelet-monocyte aggregation was assessed with FlowSight.

FINDINGS

2/7 patients (29%) with homozygosity for Cys89Tyr and 6/12 (50%) with any of four described CD59 mutations had recurrent strokes. In plasma samples from four patients carrying identical mutations, MAC deposition was increased on RBCs (p < 0.0003), neutrophils (p < 0.009), and platelets (p < 0.0003). Free-plasma hemoglobin levels were abnormally high, up to 100 mg/dl. Patients with CD59 mutation had RBC-derived MP levels 9-fold higher than those in healthy controls (p < 0.01), and 2-2.5 fold higher than PNH patients (p < 0.09). Leukocyte-activated platelet aggregation was increased (p < 0.0062). Loss of CD59 was shown in the endothelium of these patients.

INTERPRETATION

Nonfunctioning CD59 is a major risk factor for stroke and hypercoagulability. Uncontrolled hemolysis causes massive MP release and endothelial heme damage. MAC attack on unprotected endothelium and platelet activation and aggregation with leukocytes mediate additional mechanisms leading to vascular occlusion. It is suggested that CD59 loss represents a major arterial prothrombotic factor in PNH and additional diseases.

Demyelination, strokes, and eculizumab: Lessons from the congenital CD59 gene mutations

Neurological symptoms of patients with p.Cys89Tyr mutation in the CD59 gene include recurrent peripheral neuropathy resembling Guillain-Barré syndrome, characterized by sensory-motor demyelinating neuropathy with secondary axonal damage and moderate enhancement of the nerve roots on spine MRI, together with recurrent strokes and retinal involvement. Three additional mutations in CD59, leading to loss of function, have been described, and overall, 12/12 (100%) of patients with any mutation presented with neurological symptoms; 11/12 (92%) patients presented with recurrent peripheral neuropathy, 6/12 (50%) with recurrent strokes, and 1/12 (8%) with retinal involvement. We review the possible thrombophilic profile associated with the mutations. In these patients, excessive intravascular hemolysis saturates scavenger mechanisms resulting in free hemoglobin in plasma that irreversibly reacts with nitric oxide to form nitrate and methemoglobin, leading to arterial thrombosis. CD59 loss of function is also one of the major thrombophilic mechanisms in patients with paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. We then describe the relationship with demyelination. The lack of CD59 allows uncontrolled complement amplification following low-level spontaneous-, viral-, or post viral-induced complement activation, resulting in severe demyelination in the peripheral nervous system. It is interesting, and certainly encouraging, that after 3 years, following 4 patients with Cys89Tyr mutations who are treated with eculizumab, no strokes occurred and non-permanent neurological insults underwent resolution without any new neurological exacerbations.