Automatic bone and plaque removal using dual energy CT for head and neck angiography: Feasibility and initial performance evaluation

Reliability and accuracy of 3-mm and 2-mm maximum intensity projection CT angiography to detect intracranial large vessel occlusion in patients with acute anterior cerebral circulation stroke

PURPOSE

To evaluate the reliability and accuracy of thick maximum intensity projection (MIP) CTA images to detect large-vessel occlusion (LVO) in the anterior circulation in patients with acute stroke.

METHODS

A total of 140 acute stroke patients (41 with and 99 without LVO) were evaluated by two neuroradiologists for LVO using axial 3-mm and 2-mm MIPs.

RESULTS

Interobserver agreement was substantial using 3-mm MIPs (ĸ = 0.67) and almost perfect using 2-mm MIPs (ĸ = 0.82). Using 3-mm MIPs, sensitivities were 80.5% and 68.3%, with specificities of 98.0% and 96.0%. Using 2-mm MIPs, sensitivities were 82.9% and 73.2%, with specificities of 98.0% and 99.0%. Sensitivity and specificity of 3 mm and 2 mm MIPs were not statistically significantly different (P ≥ 0.375). The majority of LVOs in the distal intracranial carotid artery, and/or M1-segment were correctly identified: 96.0% (observer 1, 3-mm MIPs), 88.0% (observer 2, 3-mm MIPs), 96.0% (observer 1, 2-mm MIPs), and 96.0% (observer 2, 2 mm MIPs). Using 3-mm MIP images, observers 1 and 2 missed 7/15 (46.7%) and 9/15 (60.0%) of isolated M2-segment occlusions, respectively. Using 2-mm MIP images, observers 1 and 2 missed 5/15 (33.3%) and 6/15 (40.0%) of isolated M2-segment occlusions, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Thick (2-3 mm) axial MIPs are not useful to detect proximal LVO in the anterior circulation.

Photon-counting CT with tungsten as contrast medium: Experimental evidence of vessel lumen and plaque visualization

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

We aimed to investigate the potential of a preclinical photon-counting detector CT (PCT) scanner with an experimental tungsten-based contrast medium for carotid artery imaging.

METHODS

A carotid artery specimen was imaged on a PCT system using the multi-energy bin option (pixel size 0.5 × 0.5 mm²; tube voltage 140 kVp, contrast media-dependent energy thresholds: iodine 20, 75 keV; tungsten 20, 68 keV) at two radiation doses (CTDI_vol of 100 mGy and 10 mGy) with iodine and tungsten as contrast media at equal mass-concentrations. Standard CT, virtual non-calcium (VNCa) and calcium-only images were reconstructed. Subjective image quality (4-point Likert scale) was rated using histology as reference. Noise and attenuation measurements were performed. Simulations were conducted to assess the material-decomposition efficiency for different object diameters.

RESULTS

Image quality on VNCa images was significantly higher for tungsten at lower dose (reader 1/reader 2: 2, [2,2]/2, [2,2] vs 1.5, [2,1]/1, [1,1.75], p < 0.05). Noise was significantly lower at both dose levels for tungsten VNCa images as compared to iodine images (higher dose: tungsten 24 vs iodine 31; lower dose: tungsten 60 vs iodine 82; both p < 0.01). Simulations indicated improved material-decomposition efficiency for tungsten than for iodine pronounced at smaller object diameters.

CONCLUSIONS

PCT employing the multi-energy bin option in combination with tungsten as contrast media enables improved carotid artery imaging with respect to lumen and plaque visualization and image noise.

K-edge subtraction imaging for iodine and calcium separation at a compact synchrotron x-ray source

Purpose: About one third of all deaths worldwide can be traced to some form of cardiovascular disease. The gold standard for the diagnosis and interventional treatment of blood vessels is digital subtraction angiography (DSA). An alternative to DSA is K-edge subtraction (KES) imaging, which has been shown to be advantageous for moving organs and for eliminating image artifacts caused by patient movement. As highly brilliant, monochromatic x-rays are required for this method, it has been limited to synchrotron facilities so far, restraining the applicability in the clinical routine. Over the past decades, compact synchrotron x-ray sources based on inverse Compton scattering have been evolving; these provide x-rays with sufficient brilliance and meet spatial and financial requirements for laboratory settings or university hospitals. Approach: We demonstrate a proof-of-principle KES imaging experiment using the Munich Compact Light Source (MuCLS), the first user-dedicated installation of a compact synchrotron x-ray source worldwide. A series of experiments were performed both on a phantom and an excised human carotid to demonstrate the ability of the proposed KES technique to separate the iodine contrast agent and calcifications. Results: It is shown that the proposed filter-based KES method allows for the iodine-contrast agent and calcium to be clearly separated, thereby providing x-ray images only showing one of the two materials. Conclusions: The results show that the quasimonochromatic spectrum of the MuCLS enables filter-based KES imaging and can become an important tool in preclinical research and possible future clinical diagnostics.

Objective image characterization of a spectral CT scanner with dual-layer detector

This work evaluated the performance of a detector-based spectral CT system by obtaining objective reference data, evaluating attenuation response of iodine and accuracy of iodine quantification, and comparing conventional CT and virtual monoenergetic images in three common phantoms. Scanning was performed using the hospital's clinical adult body protocol. Modulation transfer function (MTF) was calculated for a tungsten wire and visual line pair targets were evaluated. Image noise power spectrum (NPS) and pixel standard deviation were calculated. MTF for monoenergetic images agreed with conventional images within 0.05 lp cm^-1. NPS curves indicated that noise texture of 70 keV monoenergetic images is similar to conventional images. Standard deviation measurements showed monoenergetic images have lower noise except at 40 keV. Mean CT number and CNR agreed with conventional images at 75 keV. Measured iodine concentration agreed with true concentration within 6% for inserts at the center of the phantom. Performance of monoenergetic images at detector based spectral CT is the same as, or better than, that of conventional images. Spectral acquisition and reconstruction with a detector based platform represents the physical behaviour of iodine as expected and accurately quantifies the material concentration.

Dual-energy computed tomography angiography: virtual calcified plaque subtraction in a vascular phantom

BACKGROUND

Material decomposition of dual-energy computed tomography (DECT) enables subtraction of calcified plaque.

PURPOSE

To evaluate the accuracy of lumen area measurement in calcified plaque by subtraction of DECT and to determine the effect of contrast material concentration, lumen diameter, density, and thickness of calcified plaque for the measurement.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Vessel phantoms were made with six lumen diameters (5.7, 4.9, 3.9, 3.0, 1.9, and 1.3 mm) and six types of calcified plaques with three densities and two thicknesses were attached. CT scans were performed with three contrast material concentrations (62, 111, and 170 mg iodine/mL). Lumen area discrepancy (AD) was calculated by subtracting the measured lumen area from a reference value. The lumen area underestimation percentage (AU), defined as (AD/reference value) × 100, was calculated. General linear model analysis was used to test the effect of variables for log-transformed AU (ln_AU).

RESULTS

The AD and AU was calculated to be 6.1 ± 4.8 mm² and 69.8 ± 29.4%, respectively. Ln_AU was significantly affected by contrast material concentration (P < 0.001), calcium density (P = 0.001), plaque thickness (P = 0.010), and lumen diameter (P < 0.001). Ln_AU was significantly higher in 62 mg iodine/mL than in 111 or 170 mg iodine/mL (P < 0.001 for both). Ln_AU was significantly lower at a lumen diameter of 5.7 mm than 3.9 mm (P = 0.001) or 3.0 (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Calcified plaque subtraction in DECT substantially underestimates measurements of lumen area. Higher enhancement in larger vessels ensures more accurate subtraction of calcified plaque.

Optimizing spectral CT parameters for material classification tasks

In this work, we propose a framework for optimizing spectral CT imaging parameters and hardware design with regard to material classification tasks. Compared with conventional CT, many more parameters must be considered when designing spectral CT systems and protocols. These choices will impact material classification performance in a non-obvious, task-dependent way with direct implications for radiation dose reduction. In light of this, we adapt Hotelling Observer formalisms typically applied to signal detection tasks to the spectral CT, material-classification problem. The result is a rapidly computable metric that makes it possible to sweep out many system configurations, generating parameter optimization curves (POC's) that can be used to select optimal settings. The proposed model avoids restrictive assumptions about the basis-material decomposition (e.g. linearity) and incorporates signal uncertainty with a stochastic object model. This technique is demonstrated on dual-kVp and photon-counting systems for two different, clinically motivated material classification tasks (kidney stone classification and plaque removal). We show that the POC's predicted with the proposed analytic model agree well with those derived from computationally intensive numerical simulation studies.

Polychromatic Iterative Statistical Material Image Reconstruction for Photon-Counting Computed Tomography

This work proposes a dedicated statistical algorithm to perform a direct reconstruction of material-decomposed images from data acquired with photon-counting detectors (PCDs) in computed tomography. It is based on local approximations (surrogates) of the negative logarithmic Poisson probability function. Exploiting the convexity of this function allows for parallel updates of all image pixels. Parallel updates can compensate for the rather slow convergence that is intrinsic to statistical algorithms. We investigate the accuracy of the algorithm for ideal photon-counting detectors. Complementarily, we apply the algorithm to simulation data of a realistic PCD with its spectral resolution limited by K-escape, charge sharing, and pulse-pileup. For data from both an ideal and realistic PCD, the proposed algorithm is able to correct beam-hardening artifacts and quantitatively determine the material fractions of the chosen basis materials. Via regularization we were able to achieve a reduction of image noise for the realistic PCD that is up to 90% lower compared to material images form a linear, image-based material decomposition using FBP images. Additionally, we find a dependence of the algorithms convergence speed on the threshold selection within the PCD.

Dual energy CT: how well can pseudo-monochromatic imaging reduce metal artifacts?

PURPOSE

Dual Energy CT (DECT) provides so-called monoenergetic images based on a linear combination of the original polychromatic images. At certain patient-specific energy levels, corresponding to certain patient- and slice-dependent linear combination weights, e.g., E = 160 keV corresponds to α = 1.57, a significant reduction of metal artifacts may be observed. The authors aimed at analyzing the method for its artifact reduction capabilities to identify its limitations. The results are compared with raw data-based processing.

METHODS

Clinical DECT uses a simplified version of monochromatic imaging by linearly combining the low and the high kV images and by assigning an energy to that linear combination. Those pseudo-monochromatic images can be used by radiologists to obtain images with reduced metal artifacts. The authors analyzed the underlying physics and carried out a series expansion of the polychromatic attenuation equations. The resulting nonlinear terms are responsible for the artifacts, but they are not linearly related between the low and the high kV scan: A linear combination of both images cannot eliminate the nonlinearities, it can only reduce their impact. Scattered radiation yields additional noncanceling nonlinearities. This method is compared to raw data-based artifact correction methods. To quantify the artifact reduction potential of pseudo-monochromatic images, they simulated the FORBILD abdomen phantom with metal implants, and they assessed patient data sets of a clinical dual source CT system (100, 140 kV Sn) containing artifacts induced by a highly concentrated contrast agent bolus and by metal. In each case, they manually selected an optimal α and compared it to a raw data-based material decomposition in case of simulation, to raw data-based material decomposition of inconsistent rays in case of the patient data set containing contrast agent, and to the frequency split normalized metal artifact reduction in case of the metal implant. For each case, the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) was assessed.

RESULTS

In the simulation, the pseudo-monochromatic images yielded acceptable artifact reduction results. However, the CNR in the artifact-reduced images was more than 60% lower than in the original polychromatic images. In contrast, the raw data-based material decomposition did not significantly reduce the CNR in the virtual monochromatic images. Regarding the patient data with beam hardening artifacts and with metal artifacts from small implants the pseudo-monochromatic method was able to reduce the artifacts, again with the downside of a significant CNR reduction. More intense metal artifacts, e.g., as those caused by an artificial hip joint, could not be suppressed.

CONCLUSIONS

Pseudo-monochromatic imaging is able to reduce beam hardening, scatter, and metal artifacts in some cases but it cannot remove them. In all cases, the CNR is significantly reduced, thereby rendering the method questionable, unless special post processing algorithms are implemented to restore the high CNR from the original images (e.g., by using a frequency split technique). Raw data-based dual energy decomposition methods should be preferred, in particular, because the CNR penalty is almost negligible.

Dual-Source Dual-Energy CT Angiography of the Supra-Aortic Arteries with Tin Filter: Impact of Tube Voltage Selection

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

Automatic bone and plaque subtraction (BPS) in computed tomographic angiographic (CTA) examinations using dual-energy CT (DECT) remains challenging because of beam-hardening artifacts in the shoulder region and close proximity of the internal carotid artery to the base of the skull. The selection of the tube voltage combination in dual-source CT influences the spectral separation and the susceptibility for artifacts. The purpose of this study was to assess which tube voltage combination leads to an optimal image quality of head and neck DECT angiograms after bone subtraction.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifty-one patients received tin-filter-enhanced DECT angiograms of the supra-aortic arteries using two voltage protocols: 24 patients were studied using 80/Sn140 kV and 27 using a 100/Sn140 kV protocol, both protocols with an additional tin filter. A commercially available DE-CTA BPS algorithm was used. Artificial vessel erosions in BPS maximum intensity projections (four-level Likert scale with CTA source data as reference) and vessel signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) were assessed in the level of the shoulders and the base of the skull in each patient and compared.

RESULTS

At the level of the shoulder, 100/Sn140 kV achieved higher SNR (23.4 ± 6.4 at 80/Sn140 kV vs. 35.1 ± 11.8 at 100/Sn140 kV; P < .0001) with less erosions (erosion score 3.9 ± 0.4 in 80/Sn140 kV vs. 2.1 ± 1.3 in 100/Sn140 kV; P < .0001) than 80/Sn140 kV. At the level of the skull base, erosion scores and objective image quality of arterial segments were comparable with both protocols (P = .14).

CONCLUSIONS

The 100/Sn140 kV protocol achieved more favorable results for BPS of the supra-aortic arteries than the 80/Sn140 kV protocol.

Clinical applications of dual-energy CT in head and neck imaging

Dual-energy CT provides insights into the material properties of the tissues and can differentiate between tissues that have similar attenuation on conventional, single energy CT imaging. It has several useful and promising applications in head and neck imaging that an otolaryngologist could use to deliver improved clinical care. These applications include metal artifact reduction, atherosclerotic plaque and tumor characterization, detection of parathyroid lesions, and delineation of paranasal sinus ventilation. Dual-energy CT can potentially improve image quality, reduce radiation dose, and provide specific diagnostic information for certain head and neck lesions. This article reviews some current and potential otolaryngology applications of dual-energy CT.

Efficacy of 'fine' focal spot imaging in CT abdominal angiography

OBJECTIVES

To assess the efficacy of fine focal spot imaging in calcification beam-hardening artefact reduction and vessel clarity on CT abdominal angiography (CTAA).

METHODS

Adult patients of any age and gender who presented for CTAA were included. Thirty-nine patients were examined with a standard focal spot size (SFSS) of 1 × 1 mm in the first 3 months while 31 consecutive patients were examined with a fine focal spot size (FFSS) of 1 × 0.5 mm in the following 3 months. Vessel clarity and calcification beam-hardening artefacts of the abdominal aorta, celiac axis, superior mesenteric artery, inferior mesenteric artery, renal arteries, and iliac arteries were assessed using a 5-point grading scale by two blinded radiologists randomly.

RESULTS

Cohen's Kappa test indicated that on average, there was substantial agreement among reviewers for vessel wall clarity and calcification artefact grading. Mann-Whitney test showed that there was a significant difference between the two groups, with FFSS performing significantly better for vessel clarity (U, 6481.50; p < 0.001; r, 0.73) and calcification artefact reduction (U, 1916; p < 0.001; r, 0.77).

CONCLUSION

Fine focus CT angiography produces images with better vessel wall clarity and less vessel calcification beam-hardening artefact.

KEY POINTS

Focal spot size affects the spatial resolution of a CT system. Fine focus CTAA produces images with improved vessel wall clarity. Fine focus CTAA is associated with fewer calcification beam-hardening artefacts. Fine focus CTAA may improve accuracy in assessment of luminal stenosis.

128-slice acceletated-pitch dual energy CT angiography of the head and neck: comparison of different low contrast medium volumes

BACKGROUND

Our study aims to evaluate the image quality and feasibility of 128-slice dual-energy CTA (DE-CTA) for supra-aortic arteries using reduced amounts of contrast medium (CM).

METHODS

A prospective study was performed in 54 patients receiving CTA of the head and neck with a 128-slice dual-source CT system. Patients were randomized into two groups with a volume of either 40 mL of CM (Group I) or 50 mL of CM (Group II). Arterial and venous enhancements were recorded for quantitative assessment. Qualitative assessments for images without bone removal (BR) were based on a) the visualization of the circle of Willis and b) streak artifacts due to residual CM in the subclavian or internal jugular veins ipsilateral to injection of CM. Qualitative assessment of dual-energy images using BR was based on the presence of bone remnants and vessel integrity. Quantitative data was compared using the Student t test. The χ(2) test was used for the qualitative measurements of streak artifacts in veins while the Mann-Whitney U test was used for the qualitative measurements of images with BR.

RESULTS

Arterial and venous attenuation was significantly higher in Group II (P=0.000). Image quality regarding the circle of Willis was excellent in both groups (3.90±0.30 for Group I and 4.00±0 for Group II) . Imaging of the internal jugular veins was scored higher in Group I (1.87±0.72) compared with Group II (1.48±0.51) (P=0.021). Within Group I using BR, mean scores for bone remnants did not differ significantly (P>0.05) but mean scores of vessel integrity (P<0.05) did.

CONCLUSIONS

Contrast-enhanced head and neck CTA is feasible using a scan protocol with low amounts of contrast medium (40 mL) on a 128-slice dual-energy CTA. The 40-mL protocol provides satisfactory image quality before and after dual-energy bone-removal post-processing.

Automatic bone removal technique in whole-body dual-energy CT angiography: performance and image quality

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the efficiency of automatic bone removal in dual-energy CT angiography (CTA) of the trunk.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Nineteen patients underwent dual-energy CTA of the trunk (tube A, 140 kV; tube B, 100 kV). In addition to the dual-energy dataset, an image equivalent to that of a standard 120-kV single-energy examination was generated with both tubes. Automated bone segmentation was performed on both datasets, and the results were analyzed. The time required for and subjective image quality of the maximum intensity projections (MIPs) generated were evaluated.

RESULTS

Errors in bone segmentation were found for 1.5% of bones on dual-energy images and 12.4% of bones on single-energy images (p < 0.01). The most important differences were found in the rib cage, sternum, and pelvis. The times required for postprocessing of MIPs were similar for the dual-energy (113.5 seconds) and single-energy (106.8 seconds) techniques. The subjective image quality of the arteries was considered better for dual-energy CTA (4.5 points) than for single-energy CTA (4.1 points) owing to false cutoff of vessels during the bone removal process on the single-energy images (p = 0.026).

CONCLUSION

For CTA of the trunk, the dual-energy postprocessing capabilities for 3D visualization are superior to the threshold-based bone removal of single-energy CT. Dual-energy CTA can generate boneless MIP images of substantial quality.

Dual-energy CT: vascular applications

OBJECTIVE

Dual-energy CT permits a variety of image reconstructions for the depiction and characterization of vascular disease. Techniques include visualization of low- and high-peak-kilovoltage spectra image datasets and also material-specific reconstructions combining both low- and high-peak-kilovoltage data.

CONCLUSION

This article focuses on four main vascular areas: the aorta, the major visceral, lower limb, and cervical arteries. For each territory, the current status, potential advantages, and limitations of these techniques are described.

Evaluation of computer-assisted quantification of carotid artery stenosis

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the influence of advanced software assistance on the assessment of carotid artery stenosis; particularly, the inter-observer variability of readers with different level of experience is to be investigated. Forty patients with suspected carotid artery stenosis received head and neck dual-energy CT angiography as part of their pre-interventional workup. Four blinded readers with different levels of experience performed standard imaging interpretation. At least 1 day later, they performed quantification using an advanced vessel analysis software including automatic dual-energy bone and hard plaque removal, automatic and semiautomatic vessel segmentation, as well as creation of curved planar reformation. Results were evaluated for the reproducibility of stenosis quantification of different readers by calculating the kappa and correlation values. Consensus reading of the two most experienced readers was used as the standard of reference. For standard imaging interpretation, experienced readers reached very good (k = 0.85) and good (k = 0.78) inter-observer variability. Inexperienced readers achieved moderate (k = 0.6) and fair (k = 0.24) results. Sensitivity values 80%, 91%, 83%, 77% and specificity values 100%, 84%, 82%, 53% were achieved for significant area stenosis >70%. For grading using advanced vessel analysis software, all readers achieved good inter-observer variability (k = 0.77, 0.72, 0.71, and 0.77). Specificity values of 97%, 95%, 95%, 93% and sensitivity values of 84%, 78%, 86%, 92% were achieved. In conclusion, when supported by advanced vessel analysis software, experienced readers are able to achieve good reproducibility. Even inexperienced readers are able to achieve good results in the assessment of carotid artery stenosis when using advanced vessel analysis software.

Different imaging techniques in the head and neck: Assets and drawbacks

In this review, the gold standard imaging techniques for the head and neck and the latest upcoming techniques are presented, by comparing computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance imaging and positron emission tomography-CT, as well as ultrasound, depending on the examined area. The advantages and disadvantages of each examination protocol are presented. This article illustrates the connection between the imaging technique and the examined area. Therefore, the head and neck area is divided into different sections such as bony structures, nervous system, mucous membranes and squamous epithelium, glandular tissue, and lymphatic tissue and vessels. Finally, the latest techniques in the field of head and neck imaging such as multidetector CT, dual-energy CT, flash CT, magnetic resonance angiography, spectroscopy, and diffusion tensor tractography using 3 tesla magnetic resonance are discussed.

Automatic lumen segmentation in calcified plaques: dual-energy CT versus standard reconstructions in comparison with digital subtraction angiography

OBJECTIVE

Dual-energy CT has the potential to automatically remove calcified plaques from angiographic data sets. The objective of this study is to compare the accuracy of visual grading of stenoses after plaque removal with visual grading in standard reconstructions. Digital subtraction angiography (DSA) was used as a reference standard.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Twenty-five patients underwent dual-energy CT (140 kV and 80 mAs; 80 kV and 234 mAs) angiography and DSA. Plaque and bone removal was performed. Twenty-nine calcified stenoses were quantified using standard reconstructions, plaque and bone removal maximum intensity projections after plaque and bone removal, and DSA images, according to the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial criteria. The accuracy of the detection of relevant stenoses (> 70%) and occlusions was assessed. Correlation coefficients of the grades of stenoses with DSA were calculated. The influence of vessel enhancement on the accuracy of plaque removal was analyzed.

RESULTS

The average postprocessing time was 45 seconds. After plaque removal, all 25 relevant and four nonrelevant stenoses were correctly detected. Six relevant stenoses were overestimated as complete occlusions. With the standard reconstructions, two nonrelevant stenoses were overestimated as relevant. Correlation coefficients (r(2)) for the grading of stenoses after plaque removal and with standard reconstructions versus DSA were 0.7694 and 0.4329, respectively. Vessel contrast enhancement correlated weakly (r(2) = 0.2072) with the accuracy of plaque removal.

CONCLUSION

Dual-energy CT with plaque removal automatically delivers CT luminograms with a high sensitivity for the detection of relevant stenoses and a higher correlation to DSA than standard reconstructions but frequently leads to an overestimation of high-grade stenoses as occlusions. Thus, dual-energy CT plaque and bone removal should be used complementary to standard reconstructions, and not exclusively.