A Systematic Review of Renal Pathology in Chronic Kidney Disease of Uncertain Etiology

Burden of Chronic Kidney Disease of Undetermined Aetiology (CKDu) in a Tertiary Care Public Hospital in North India

INTRODUCTION

Chronic kidney disease of undetermined aetiology (CKDu) is an important public health problem. Indian data are mostly based on studies from rural regions in south and east India. We examined the burden and profile of CKDu in patients attending a tertiary care hospital in north India.

METHODS

We assessed records of consecutive new CKD patients registered in a nephrology clinic from January 2015 to June 2022. Patients were classified as having CKDu based on predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria. Clinical and laboratory parameters at presentation and kidney biopsy when done were noted.

RESULTS

Records of 32,369 patients with CKD were screened, and 29,663 were included (2,706 excluded due to inadequate data). A total of 370 (1.2%) patients were categorized as CKDu. Mean age was 41 ± 14.7 years, 58.1% being male. Of them, 158 (42.7%) patients were in CKD stage 3, 89 (24.1%) in stage 4, 84 (22.7%) in stage 5, and 39 (10.5%) were dialysis dependent at presentation; 232 (62.7%) patients had proteinuria <0.5 gm/day and 138 (37.3%) between 0.5 and 1 gm/day. Renal histology was available for 65 CKDu patients: 62 had chronic tubulointerstitial nephritis (CTIN) and 3 had non-specific changes.

CONCLUSION

When defined using strict criteria with intensive diagnostic workup, burden of CKDu is low in our hospital-based cohort of CKD patients. CTIN is the predominant histopathological finding in kidney biopsy.

Systematic Review of Kidney Injury Biomarkers for the Evaluation of CKD of Uncertain Etiology

Introduction

Chronic kidney disease of uncertain etiology (CKDu) is an incompletely defined phenotype of chronic kidney disease (CKD) affecting young individuals mostly in agricultural communities in Central America and South Asia. CKDu is a diagnosis of exclusion made in individuals from endemic regions.

Methods

We conducted a systematic review of the primary literature on urinary and plasma kidney injury biomarkers measured in the setting of CKDu (through February 2023). The literature was identified via a Web of Science search and hand search of the references of previously identified literature. Search terms included "CKDu," "Mesoamerican Nephropathy," "CKD of unknown etiology," "Chronic Interstitial Nephritis in Agricultural Communities," "biomarker," "urin∗," and/or "plasma."

Results

A total of 25 papers were included. The 2 most frequently measured biomarkers were urinary kidney injury molecule-1 (KIM-1) and urinary neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin (NGAL). There was substantial variability in study design, laboratory assay methods, and statistical methodology, which prohibited meta-analysis.

Conclusion

Biomarkers that identify tubulointerstitial disease early and accurately may substantially accelerate progress in the study of CKDu and facilitate public health approaches that eventually lead to its prevention and elimination. To date, the literature is limited by relatively small sample sizes and methodological limitations which should be addressed in future studies.

X-Ray-Based 3D Histopathology of the Kidney Using Cryogenic Contrast-Enhanced MicroCT

The kidney's microstructure, which comprises a highly convoluted tubular and vascular network, can only be partially revealed using classical 2D histology. Considering that the kidney's microstructure is closely related to its function and is often affected by pathologies, there is a need for powerful and high-resolution 3D imaging techniques to visualize the microstructure. Here, we present how cryogenic contrast-enhanced microCT (cryo-CECT) allowed 3D visualization of glomeruli, tubuli, and vasculature. By comparing different contrast-enhancing staining agents and freezing protocols, we found that the preferred sample preparation protocol was the combination of staining with 1:2 hafnium(IV)-substituted Wells-Dawson polyoxometalate and freezing by submersion in isopentane at -78°C. This optimized protocol showed to be highly sensitive, allowing to detect small pathology-induced microstructural changes in a mouse model of mild trauma-related acute kidney injury after thorax trauma and hemorrhagic shock. In summary, we demonstrated that cryo-CECT is an effective 3D histopathological tool that allows to enhance our understanding of kidney tissue microstructure and their related function.

Chronic Interstitial Nephritis in Agricultural Communities: Observational and Mechanistic Evidence Supporting the Role of Nephrotoxic Agrochemicals

Chronic interstitial nephritis in agricultural communities (CINAC) is an epidemic of kidney disease affecting specific tropical and subtropical regions worldwide and is characterized by progressive CKD in the absence of traditional risk factors, such as hypertension and diabetes. CINAC prevalence is higher among young, male agricultural workers, but it also affects women, children, and nonagricultural workers in affected areas. Biopsies from patients with CINAC across regions commonly demonstrate tubular injury with lysosomal aggregates, tubulointerstitial inflammation, and fibrosis and variable glomerular changes. Each endemic area holds environmental risk factors and patient/genetic milieus, resulting in uncertainty about the cause(s) of the disease. Currently, there is no specific treatment available for CINAC. We highlight survey findings of Houston-based migrant workers with CINAC and draw similarities between kidney injury phenotype of patients with CINAC and mice treated chronically with paraquat, an herbicide used worldwide. We propose potential pathways and mechanisms for kidney injury in patients with CINAC, which may offer clues for potential therapies.

Failing kidneys: Hotspots, blind spots and biopolitics of indifference

Chronic kidney disease of non-traditional cause (CKDnt) is commonly associated with monocropping agriculture, heat stress and impoverished working conditions, referred to as CKDnt "hotspots." The condition is also emerging in various sites of environmental contamination, raising questions as to whether multiple variants of the condition exist as a result of different ecologies and different human-environment interactions. This paper examines the emergence of CKDnt around Lake Chapala in Mexico, where we document local efforts to gain recognition and reparation for CKDnt. We follow the ways patients, families and activists have mobilized specific and interlocking infrastructural failures to enact complaint and confront state inaction and neglect of their bodies, communities, and environments. Though their labors have formally achieved little, we discuss how they make visible a biopolitics of indifference, one bound to the production of structural "blindspots."

The AKI-to-CKD Transition: The Role of Uremic Toxins

After acute kidney injury (AKI), renal function continues to deteriorate in some patients. In a pro-inflammatory and profibrotic environment, the proximal tubules are subject to maladaptive repair. In the AKI-to-CKD transition, impaired recovery from AKI reduces tubular and glomerular filtration and leads to chronic kidney disease (CKD). Reduced kidney secretion capacity is characterized by the plasma accumulation of biologically active molecules, referred to as uremic toxins (UTs). These toxins have a role in the development of neurological, cardiovascular, bone, and renal complications of CKD. However, UTs might also cause CKD as well as be the consequence. Recent studies have shown that these molecules accumulate early in AKI and contribute to the establishment of this pro-inflammatory and profibrotic environment in the kidney. The objective of the present work was to review the mechanisms of UT toxicity that potentially contribute to the AKI-to-CKD transition in each renal compartment.

The impact of heat exposures on biomarkers of AKI and plasma metabolome among agricultural and non-agricultural workers

BACKGROUND

Agricultural workers are consistently exposed to elevated heat exposures and vulnerable to acute kidney injury. The underlying pathophysiology and detailed molecular mechanisms of AKI among agricultural workers, and the disproportionate burden of HRI and heat stress exposure are not well understood, especially at the level of cellular metabolism.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to examine the impact of heat exposures on renal biomarkers and on the human metabolome via untargeted high-resolution metabolomics among agricultural and non-agricultural workers.

METHODS

Blood and urine samples were collected pre- and post-work shift from 63 agricultural workers and 27 non- agricultural workers. We evaluated pre- and post-work shift renal biomarkers and completed untargeted metabolomics using high-resolution mass spectrometry with liquid chromatography. Metabolome-wide association studies (MWAS) models identified the metabolic features differentially expressed between agricultural workers and non-agricultural workers.

RESULTS

Median values of pre-shift creatinine and osteopontin (p < 0.05) were higher for agricultural workers than non-agricultural workers. Metabolic pathway enrichment analyses revealed 27 diverse pathways differed between agricultural workers and non-agricultural workers (p < 0.05) including TCA cycle and urea cycle, carbohydrate metabolism, histidine metabolism and evidence for altered microbiome shikimate pathway.

CONCLUSION

This is the first investigation on the metabolic pathways that are affected among agricultural workers who are exposed to heat compared to non-heat exposed workers. This study shows extensive responses of central metabolic systems to heat exposures that impact human health.

Chronic kidney disease with unknown cause across the global spectrum

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

In the 1990s, a type of chronic kidney disease with unknown cause (CKDu) was identified in Central America and Sri Lanka. Patients lacked hypertension, diabetes, glomerulonephritis, or other usual causes of kidney failure. Affected patients are predominantly male agricultural workers aged 20-60 years, living in economically disadvantaged areas with poor access to medical care. Patients typically present late and progress to end-stage kidney disease within 5 years, resulting in social and economic hardship for families, regions, and countries. This review covers the current state of knowledge for this disease.

RECENT FINDINGS

The prevalence of CKDu is increasing in known endemic regions and across the globe, reaching epidemic proportions. There is primary tubulointerstitial injury with secondary glomerular and vascular sclerosis. No definitive etiologic factors have been identified, and these may vary or overlap in different geographic locations. The leading hypotheses include exposure to agrochemicals, heavy metals and trace elements, and kidney injury from dehydration/heat stress. Infections and lifestyle factors may play a role, but are likely not key. Genetic and epigenetic factors are beginning to be explored.

SUMMARY

CKDu is a leading cause of premature death in young-to-middle-aged adults in endemic regions and has become a public health crisis. Studies are underway to investigate clinical, exposome, and omics factors, and hopefully will provide insights into pathogenetic mechanisms resulting in biomarker discovery, preventive measures, and therapeutics.

Early Ultrastructural Changes in Biopsies From Patients With Symptomatic CKD of Uncertain Etiology

Introduction

Although the investigation of chronic kidney disease of uncertain etiology (CKDu) has identified many possible influencing factors in recent years, the exact pathomechanism of this disease remains unclear.

Methods

In this study, we collected 13 renal biopsies from patients with symptomatic CKDu (Sym-CKDu) from Sri Lanka with well-documented clinical and socioeconomic factors. We performed light microscopy and electron microscopic evaluation for ultrastructural analysis, which was compared with 100 biopsies from German patients with 20 different kidney diseases.

Results

Of the 13 Sri Lankan patients, 12 were men (92.3%), frequently employed in agriculture (50%), and experienced symptoms such as feeling feverish (83.3%), dysuria (83.3%), and arthralgia (66.6%). Light microscopic evaluation using activity and chronicity score revealed that cases represented early stages of CKDu except for 2 biopsies, which showed additional signs of diabetes. Most glomeruli showed only mild changes, such as podocyte foot process effacement on electron microscopy. We found a spectrum of early tubulointerstitial changes including partial loss of brush border in proximal tubules, detachment of tubular cells, enlarged vacuoles, and mitochondrial swelling associated with loss of cristae and dysmorphic lysosomes with electron-dense aggregates. None of these changes occurred exclusively in Sym-CKDu; however, they were significantly more frequent in these cases than in the control cohort.

Conclusion

In conclusion, our findings confirm the predominant and early alterations of tubular structure in CKDu that can occur without significant glomerular changes. The ultrastructural changes do not provide concrete evidence of the cause of CKDu but were significantly more frequent in Sym-CKDu than in the controls.

Factors Associated with Chronic Kidney Disease of Unknown Etiology (CKDu): A Systematic Review

(1) Background: Despite ample research, the factors, specific causes, and pathways associated with chronic kidney disease of unknown etiology (CKDu) remain elusive. Therefore, we performed a systematic review to explore the potential etiologies for the development of CKDu globally. (2) Methods: A systematic literature review was conducted using databases CINAHL, Cochrane Library, Embase, Google Scholar, MEDLINE, and PsycINFO on the specific causes and pathophysiology related to CKDu from inception until April 2021. Study selection, data extraction of included articles, and quality appraisal were assessed. The narrative approach was used to summarize and comprehend the findings. (3) Results: Our study included 25 studies, considering 38,351 participants. Twelve studies were case-control, ten were cross-sectional, and three were cohort designs. All articles were from low-and middle-income countries (LMICs). The findings suggest 12 factors are associated with CKDu. Most studies (n = 8) identified farming and water sources as the factors related to CKDu, with heavy metal toxicity coming in second (n = 7). (4) Conclusion: The systematic review reported various factors associated with CKDu, from which most studies reported farming, water sources, and heavy metal poisoning. Considering the findings, the study recommends future strategies and public health initiatives to prevent the epidemiological/environmental factors contributing to CKDu.

Metals and Metallothionein Expression in Relation to Progression of Chronic Kidney Disease of Unknown Etiology (CKDu) in Sri Lanka

Chronic kidney disease of unknown etiology was investigated for metal relations in an endemic area by a cross-sectional study with CKD stages G1, G2, G3a, G3b, G4, G5 (ESRD), and endemic and nonendemic controls (EC and NEC) as groups. Subjects with the medical diagnosis were classified into groups by eGFR (SCr, CKD-EPI) and UACR of the study. It determined 24 metals/metalloids in plasma (ICPMS) and metallothionein (MT) mRNA in blood (RT-PCR). MT1A at G3b and MT2A throughout G2−G5 showed increased transcription compared to NEC (ANOVA, p < 0.01). Both MT1A and MT2A remained metal-responsive as associations emerged between MT2A and human MT inducer Cr (in EC: r = 0.54, p < 0.05, n = 14), and between MT1A and MT2A (in EC pooled with G1−G5: r = 0.58, p < 0.001, n = 110). Human MT (hMT)-inducers, namely Zn, Cu, As, Pb, and Ni; Σ hMT-inducers; 14 more non-inducer metals; and Σ MT-binding metals remained higher (p < 0.05) in EC as compared to NEC. Declining eGFR or CKD progression increased the burden of Be, Mg, Al, V, Co, Ni, Rb, Cs, Ba, Mn, Zn, Sr, Σ hMT-inducers, and Σ MT-binding metals in plasma, suggesting an MT role in the disease. MT1A/2A mRNA followed UACR (PCA, Dendrogram: similarity, 57.7%). The study provides evidence that proteinuric chronic renal failure may increase plasma metal levels where blood MT2A could be a marker.

Multi-pronged research on endemic chronic kidney disease of unknown etiology in Sri Lanka: a systematic review

Increasing prevalence of endemic chronic kidney disease of unknown etiology (CKDu) in Sri Lanka is a major health problem since the 1990s. Despite numerous studies on CKDu, research groups have been unable to develop a comprehensive approach to mitigate the disorder, and thereby to identify research gaps. We conducted a systematic literature review of 119 publications on CKDu in Sri Lanka from Pubmed, Google Scholar, and Scopus, published until end September 2020. A higher CKDu prevalence in the working population of the North Central Province was reported with recent studies indicating patients from non-endemic regions as well. A majority were etiological studies that recorded conflicting and inconclusive evidence on CKDu etiology. Studies on clinico-pathological, diagnostic, biochemical, and molecular biological aspects of CKDu, studies analyzing CKDu symptom burden, anthropological, and behavioral impacts of CKDu, were reviewed as well. A dearth of research exists on nutritional, demographical, immunological, and microbial aspects of CKDu. The overview of the reviewed literature indicated the absence of a comprehensive plan of action to mitigate this situation. Hence, we propose the "One Health" approach with a systems dynamics model as a potential way forward to alleviate the CKDu epidemic in Sri Lanka. This enables the representation of multiple causative agents (and interactions thereof) among environmental, animal, and human systems, in concert with the "exposome" that provides the totality of exposure the individual has undergone since birth.