Common SVOCs in house dust from urban dwellings with schoolchildren in six typical cities of China and associated non-dietary exposure and health risk assessment

A multi-environmental source approach to explore associations between metals exposure and olfactory identification among school-age children residing in northern Italy

BACKGROUND

Metal exposures can adversely impact olfactory function. Few studies have examined this association in children. Further, metal exposure occurs as a mixture, yet previous studies of metal-associated olfactory dysfunction only examined individual metals. Preventing olfactory dysfunctions can improve quality of life and prevent neurodegenerative diseases with long-term health implications.

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to test the association between exposure to a mixture of 12 metals measured in environmental sources and olfactory function among children and adolescents residing in the industrialized province of Brescia, Italy.

METHODS

We enrolled 130 children between 6 and 13 years old (51.5% females) and used the "Sniffin' Sticks" test to measure olfactory performance in identifying smells. We used a portable X-ray fluorescence instrument to determine concentrations of metals (arsenic (As), calcium, cadmium (Cd), chromium, copper, iron, manganese, lead (Pb), antimony, titanium, vanadium and zinc) in outdoor and indoor deposited dust and soil samples collected from participants' households. We used an extension of weighted quantile sum (WQS) regression to test the association between exposure to metal mixtures in multiple environmental media and olfactory function adjusting for age, sex, socio-economic status, intelligence quotient and parents' smoking status.

RESULTS

A higher multi-source mixture was significantly associated with a reduced Sniffin' Sticks identification score (β = -0.228; 95% CI -0.433, -0.020). Indoor dust concentrations of Pb, Cd and As provided the strongest contributions to this association (13.8%, 13.3% and 10.1%, respectively). The metal mixture in indoor dust contributed more (for 8 metals out of 12) to the association between metals and olfactory function compared to soil or outdoor dust.

IMPACT STATEMENT

Among a mixture of 12 metals measured in three different environmental sources (soil, outdoor and indoor dust), we identified Pb, Cd and As measured in indoor dust as the main contributors to reduced olfactory function in children and adolescents residing in an industrialized area. Exposure to indoor pollution can be effectively reduced through individual and public health interventions allowing to prevent the deterioration of olfactory functions. Moreover, the identification of the factors that can deteriorate olfactory functions can be a helpful instrument to improve quality of life and prevent neurodegenerative diseases as long-term health implications.

Comprehensive assessment of phthalates in indoor dust across China between 2007 and 2019: Benefits from regulatory restrictions

China is the largest producer and consumer of phthalates in the world. However, it remains unclear whether China's phthalate restrictions have alleviated indoor phthalate pollution. We extracted the concentrations of dimethyl phthalate (DMP), diethyl phthalate (DEP), dibutyl phthalate (DBP), diisobutyl phthalate (DIBP), benzyl butyl phthalate (BBP), and bis(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP) in indoor dust at 2762 sites throughout China between 2007 and 2019 from the published literature. Based on these data, we investigated the effects of phthalate restrictions and environmental factors on the temporal-spatial distribution and sources of phthalates and estimated human exposure and risk of phthalates. The results revealed that the mean concentrations of phthalates in indoor dust throughout China decreased in the following order: DEHP > DBP > DIBP > DMP > DEP > BBP. The concentrations of six phthalates were generally higher in northern and central-western China than in southern regions. BBP and DEHP concentrations decreased by 73.5% and 17.9%, respectively, from 2007 to 2019. Sunshine was a critical environmental factor in reducing phthalate levels in indoor dust. Polyvinyl chloride materials, personal care products, building materials, and furniture were the primary sources of phthalates in indoor dust. The phthalates in indoor dust posed the most significant threat to children and older adults. This study provides a picture of phthalate pollution, thus supporting timely and effective policies and legislation.

Assessment of the internal and external exposure risks to methylsiloxanes in communities near a petroleum refinery

Methylsiloxanes (MSs) are widely used in industrial production and have attracted much attention due to their potential health risks to humans. MSs are present in emissions from petroleum refining, and it is therefore important to assess the health risks to residents living near refineries. In this study, we evaluated the pollution characteristics and human exposure risks of three cyclic MS (CMS) oligomers (D4-D6) in areas upwind and downwind of a petroleum refinery. The concentrations of total CMSs were 4-33 times higher in the downwind than upwind areas. At the same sampling site, the concentrations of CMSs were higher indoors than outdoors. The maximum concentration of CMSs was found in the indoor environment 200 m downwind of the petroleum refinery (75 μg/m3 in air and 2.3 μg/g in dust). The concentrations and detection rates of CMSs in plasma samples were higher in the downwind than upwind residents. Although residents living downwind of the petroleum refinery were a non-occupationally exposed population, they should be considered a highly CMS-exposed population because of their extremely high internal exposure doses. Inhalation exposure was the main source of CMSs in the plasma of these residents. When different exposure pathways were investigated, inhalation exposure was the major contributor to the average daily dose in residents of locations near the petroleum refinery, whereas the dermal absorption of personal care products was the major contributor at other sites. Although the overall risks of exposure to total CMSs were below the chronic reference dose for all exposure pathways, the combined joint toxic effects of various CMSs remain unclear. Further studies are therefore required to determine the exposure risks and subsequent health effects of CMSs for the residents of these areas.

Ellie A, Dong H, Ahmad UM. Health Effects of Exposure to Indoor Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds in Chinese Building Environment: A Systematic Review

People spend a considerable portion of their lives indoors; thus, the quality of the indoor environment is crucial. Semi-volatile organic compounds (SVOCs) are among the primary indoor pollutants responsible for various health risks. This paper systematically reviews the impact of SVOC exposure on human health in Chinese built environments. Based on a set of criteria, we judged 12 publications as providing sufficient information on both SVOC exposure and health effects to inform the relationship. Out of six studies on polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), three observed a positive association between PAH exposure and lung cancer. Out of six studies of phthalate exposure, two studies reported a significant positive association between DEP and DiBP and asthma, between DEP and DEHP and dry cough among children, and between DBP and rhinitis among younger adults. The results of this review suggest that there might be a link between phthalate exposure and asthma and allergies, as well as a link between PAH exposure and lung cancer. However, due to the limited number of studies conducted, more evidence is necessary to definitively guide the establishment of standards for SVOC control in China.

Fractional diffusion model for emission and adsorption prediction of TXIB from wallpaper

Mercury injection test shows that wallpaper is a porous building material with a complex fractal mass transfer channel. Therefore, fractional Fick's law is employed to investigate sub-diffusion of 2,2,4 trimethy1-1,3-pentanediol diisobutyrate (TXIB) from wallpaper. In view of the fact that a small amount of TXIB has been released from the wallpaper before the environmental chamber experiment, the non-uniform initial concentration is introduced. Based on fractional Fick's law, both fractional convective mass transfer equation and fractional mass balance equation have been firstly proposed. Combining the finite difference method and L1 algorithm, the fractional diffusion model is solved numerically. Numerical simulation results show that the present model matches well with the experimental data. Compared with the previous model based on Fick's law, the present model is in better agreement with experimental data of di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP) released from polyvinyl chloride (PVC) flooring. The influence of key parameters on the concentration of TXIB is analyzed graphically. In addition, the absorption amount and absorption rate of TXIB on the environmental bulkhead are numerically simulated for the first time.

Identification of Phthalates from Artificial Products in Chinese Kindergarten Classrooms and the Implications for Preschool Children's Exposure Assessments

Phthalates are typical chemical pollutants in kindergarten classrooms since numerous artificial products (e.g., polyvinyl chloride (PVC) floorings, soft polymers and plastic toys) that might contain phthalates are widely distributed in kindergarten classrooms. Although Chinese preschool children spend a considerable amount of their waking hours (>8 h/day) in kindergartens, phthalate exposure in such indoor environment has not been given much attention. In this study, the mass fractions of six phthalates in twenty-six artificial products (fifteen flat decoration materials and eleven plastic toys) commonly found in Chinese kindergarten classrooms were measured. Di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP) was the most predominant compound in all materials. The emission characteristics of the DEHP from these materials were further investigated. The measured emission characteristics were used for predicting multi-phase DEHP concentrations in kindergarten classrooms by applying a mass transfer model. The modeled concentrations were comparable with those measured in the real environment, indicating that these products might be the major sources of DEHP in Chinese kindergarten classrooms. Preschool children’s exposure to DEHP was found to be 0.42 μg/kg/day in kindergartens under baseline conditions, accounting for 18% of the total exposure to DEHP in Chinese indoor environments.

Assessment of internal exposure to methylsiloxanes in children and associated non-dietary exposure risk

Methylsiloxanes (MSs) are a significant source of indoor environmental pollution due to their high production level and widespread application, and pose a potential health risk. Given the special vulnerability of children to environmental contaminants, assessment of indoor MSs exposure in children is quite essential. In this study, we assessed internal exposure doses and external exposure levels of MSs in children from industrial and residential areas in southwestern China. Indoor air, indoor dust, and personal care product (PCP) samples were collected to evaluate indoor non-dietary MSs exposure in children through various pathways. The concentrations of MSs in indoor environments of industrial areas were approximately one to four orders of magnitude higher than those of residential areas. Sun protection products contained the highest concentrations of MSs. Relatively high levels of cyclic methylsiloxanes (CMSs) were found in plasma of children from industrial areas, which were one to two orders of magnitude higher than those in children from residential areas. The highest MSs levels in plasma were detected in infants (0-1 year), with values of 1.4 × 10² ng/mL and 1.3 × 10² ng/mL for CMSs (D4-D6) and linear methylsiloxanes (LMSs) (L5-L16), respectively. The internal exposure dose of infants in residential areas is driven by major unknown sources of MSs. The average daily doses via inhalation and dust ingestion in children from industrial areas were one to three orders of magnitude higher than in those from residential areas, indicating that these children should be considered a highly exposed population. Inhalation and dust ingestion were both major exposure pathways to MSs for children of all age groups in industrial areas, whereas dermal absorption from PCPs was the predominant exposure pathway for children of all age groups in residential areas (except for infants). Although the exposure risk to D4 and D5 was at an acceptable level for all children studied, the total daily exposure doses of these two cyclic compounds via inhalation for infants in the industrial areas was near the chronic reference dose. Meanwhile, MSs may accumulate in infant plasma within a short period of time (<6 months). Therefore, infants should be the focus of greater attention in future research. As indoor environments may pose high risks for infants in industrial areas, they should be the focus of future research.

Characteristics of dust-phase phthalates in dormitory, classroom, and home and non-dietary exposure in Beijing, China

The phthalate concentrations in dust from undergraduate dormitories, classrooms, and homes in Beijing, China, were measured in April 2017. We analyzed the characteristics of phthalates in dust from three environments. In addition, we estimated the daily intake of phthalates via three pathways using Monte Carlo simulations. The detection frequency of eight phthalates in dust ranges from 74.5 to 100%. Di (2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP), di-n-butyl phthalate (DnBP), and di-isobutyl phthalate (DiBP) are the most abundant phthalates. The median proportion of DEHP in dust is the highest, ranging from 67.1 to 72.9%. The PMF results indicated that two, four, and three types of phthalate sources exist in home, dormitory, and classroom, respectively. The differences in the phthalate concentrations between sunny and shaded rooms and urban and suburban classrooms are insignificant, whereas that between male and female dormitories is significant. The total daily intake of DEHP, DnBP, and DiBP ranges from 97.3 to 336 ng/ (kg·day). The oral intake for DEHP in classrooms and the dermal intake of DnBP and DiBP in homes are the highest. The carcinogenic risk of DEHP to university students is the highest in classrooms and the total carcinogenic risk of the three environments is 4.70 × 10^-6.

Spatial-temporal characteristics, source-specific variation and uncertainty analysis of health risks associated with heavy metals in road dust in Beijing, China

Based on the concentrations of ten heavy metals (As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni, Pb, Zn, Fe) in 144 road dust samples collected from 36 sites across 4 seasons from 2016 to 2017 in Beijing, this study systematically analyzed the levels and main sources of health risks in terms of their temporal and spatial variations. A combination of receptor models (positive matrix factorization and multilinear engine-2), human health risk assessment models, and Monte Carlo simulations were used to apportion the seasonal variation of the health risks associated with these heavy metals. While non-carcinogenic risks were generally acceptable, Cr and Ni induced cautionary carcinogenic risks (CR) to children (confidence levels was approximately 80% and 95%, respectively).. Additionally, fuel combustion posed cautionary CR to children in all seasons, while the level of CR from other sources varied, depending on the seasons. Heavy metal concentrations were the most influential variables for uncertainties, followed by ingestion rate and skin adherence factor. The values and spatial patterns of health risks were influenced by the spatial pattern of risks from each source.

Dietary exposure and risk assessment of perchlorate in diverse food from Wuhan, China

The perchlorate levels in 330 foods belonging to 5 varieties obtained from Wuhan were monitored. An ultra-high performance liquid chromatography coupled with triple quadrupoles mass spectrometry in combination with Cl¹⁸O₄^- internal standard method was performed to determine the level of perchlorate in various foods. Hereafter, dietary exposure and risk assessment of perchlorate was evaluated. The results revealed that the average level of perchlorate was 15.04 µg/kg with a detection of 95% among the whole food groups. The level of perchlorate in vegetables was the highest among the 5 varieties of food with an average content of 27.39 µg/kg, which in meat was the lowest with an average of 3.65 µg/kg. Estimated dietary intake results illustrated that males showed exposure in the range 0.004-0.18 µg/kg bw/day, which for females was 0.01-0.21 µg/kg bw/day. The results indicated that exposure to perchlorate via the food consumption for Wuhan people was evaluated as safe.

Catalytic oxidation of dimethyl phthalate over titania-supported noble metal catalysts

Semi-volatile organic compounds (SVOCs) are organic compounds with the boiling point ranging between 240/260 ℃ and 380/400 ℃. Detailed knowledge regarding catalytic removal of SVOCs from indoor environment is very limited as it remains challenge to explore such reaction due to the viscosity nature of target contaminants. Here, we established a facile methodology to explore the heterogeneous catalytic oxidation reaction of dimethyl phthalate (DMP), a model SVOC, over the surface of supported catalyst. DMP was found to be gradually oxidized over the surface of titania supported catalysts including palladium (Pd), platinum and ruthenium with increasing temperature. The cleavage of side chain of DMP occurs at 75 ℃ over the surface of Pd/TiO₂, which is significantly lower than that of the other two catalysts. Carbon dioxide was observed as the main product of the catalytic oxidation reaction. However, aromatic products and small molecule products were still observed as side-product in different temperature range. Density functional theory calculations further show that DMP can react with reactive oxygen species to form phthalic acid. While the cleavage of the DMP side chain occurs to form products such as methyl benzoate. This work thus provides basic knowledge about indoor SVOCs catalytic oxidation removal.

Methylsiloxanes in plasma from potentially exposed populations and an assessment of the associated inhalation exposure risk

Methylsiloxanes (MSs) are ubiquitous in indoor air and pose an important health risk. Thus, assessments of indoor inhalation exposure by measuring MSs levels in plasma are needed. In this study, we measured plasma MSs concentrations and evaluated daily indoor inhalation exposure in potentially exposed populations, including residents of industrial areas, university campus, and residential areas, all located in southwestern China. The concentrations of MSs in indoor air (gas-phase and PM_2.5) collected from factory housing and from girls' dormitories on university campus were approximately one to three orders of magnitude higher than in parallel samples from other areas. The consequences of MSs exposure were investigated by measuring MSs levels in the plasma samples of the exposed populations. Relatively high levels of cyclic MSs (CMSs: D4-D6) were found in the plasma of the co-resident family members of factory workers and in female college students living in campus dormitories. The highest levels of CMSs (D4-D6) and linear MSs (L5-L16), 2.3 × 10² and 2.0 × 10² ng/mL, respectively, were detected in the very young (0-3 years old) co-resident children of factory workers. The average daily dose via inhalation (ADD_inh) in different groups showed that the ADD_inh values of all MSs (D4-D6, L5-L16) were one to two orders of magnitude higher in the co-resident family members of factory workers and in female college students than in other groups, indicating that both populations should be considered as potentially highly exposed to MSs. A further assessment showed that inhalation exposure is the main source of CMSs (D4-D6) in plasma for people exposed to high indoor air levels of these compounds. Although the health risk assessment showed that the health risk from inhalation exposure to D4 and D5 was acceptable for all of the studied groups based on the current chronic reference dose (cRfD), the maximum ADD_inh,CMSs value in 0- to 3-year-old children was only 7.9-fold below the cRfD. Because the toxicity of other MSs is unknown, the potential health risk of MSs to very young children via inhalation exposure should be further analysed.

Concentration of phthalate esters in indoor and outdoor dust in Kocaeli, Turkey: implications for human exposure and risk

The interest in phthalate esters (PAEs) has increased in recent years because elevated phthalate levels have been detected in environmental matrices and they have certain adverse effects on human health. Indoor dust from 90 homes and outdoor (street) dust from outside these homes were collected in Kocaeli province between February and April 2016 and analyzed for eight PAEs. The total indoor dust concentrations of eight PAEs (Σ₈PAEs) ranged from 21.33 μg g^-1 to 1802 μg g^-1 (median, 387.67 μg g^-1), significantly higher than outdoor dust concentrations (0.16-36.85 μg g^-1 with median 4.84 μg g^-1). Di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP) was the most dominant pollutant in both indoor and outdoor environments with a median value of 316.02 μg g^-1 and 3.89 μg g^-1, respectively, followed by di-n-butyl phthalate and butylbenzyl phthalate (BBP). DEHP was measured within the range of 198.54-816.92 μg g^-1 and BBP within the range of 15.52-495.33 μg g^-1 in homes with PVC coating, significantly higher than the levels in homes with parquet and tiled floor (p<0.05). Monte Carlo simulation was applied to probabilistically estimate exposure to PAEs and associated carcinogenic risk. The Σ₅PAE median values of non-dietary ingestion and dermal absorption exposure were estimated as 1.57 μg kg day^-1 and 0.007 μg kg day^-1 for children and 0.09 μg kg day^-1 and 0.04 μg kg day^-1 for adults while inhalation route exposure to PAE in dust was at a negligible level for both groups. Children were more exposed to PAEs through ingestion route (92.74% to 99.54% of the total exposure) while adult exposure through ingestion routes (62-68.4%) and dermal absorption (29.74% and 31.87% of the total exposure) were comparable. The mean cancer risk level via non-dietary ingestion of DEHP for children was 2.33×10^-6, about eight times higher than the levels for adults. The risk levels of about 16% of adults and 95% of children are greater than the threshold value of 10^-6 when the population is exposed to DEHP in indoor dust. Looking from the viewpoint of child health, the most effective method to reduce exposure among the measured PAEs is to keep the release of DEHP under control, especially in indoor environment, and to take precautions to reduce exposure.

Indoor phthalate concentrations in residences in Shihezi, China: implications for preschool children's exposure and risk assessment

Despite the risks associated with phthalate exposure, there are few studies emphasizing preschool children's exposure to phthalates in residences in Northwest China. In this study, seven phthalates from indoor dust samples were measured in 50 residences in Shihezi, China. Preschool children's exposure doses via non-dietary intake were calculated by Monte Carlo simulation. Risk assessment was conducted by comparing the simulated exposure dose with benchmarks for reproductive toxicity and cancer specified in Proposition 65 of California. The detection frequencies for all selected phthalates were more than 75%, with the exception of benzyl butyl phthalate (BBP) and di-n-octyl phthalate (DNOP). Bis(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP) was the most principal compound in the dust samples (median = 455 μg/g and 462 μg/g in the bedroom and living room, respectively). The simulation displayed that the median DBP daily intake was 1.5-1.9 μg/day/kg for preschool children in Shihezi, which was considered a high level compared with similar studies around the world. The risk assessment indicated that almost all preschool children face potential reproductive risk due to dibutyl phthalate (DBP) exposure, with medians of hazard index (HI) from 9.6 to 12.4 for all age groups. Therefore, from a children's health perspective, attention should be paid to reducing indoor phthalate pollution and exposure in this area.

Dermal bioaccessibility of plasticizers in indoor dust and clothing

Several studies indicate that human exposure to plasticizers via dermal pathway is not negligible, but the dermal bioaccessibility of phthalates and alternative plasticizers from the important environmental matrix including indoor dust and clothing and the importance weight of dermal exposure to those pollutants have been poorly studied. An in vitro physiologically based extraction test was employed to investigate the dermal bioaccessibility of target phthalates and alternative plasticizers from indoor dust and clothing. Temperature, incubation time, sweat/sebum ratio and solid/liquid ratio were selected to study their effects on the bioaccessibility. The bioaccessibility of Diethyl phthalates (DEP), dibutyl phthalate (DBP), bis-2-ethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP), Acetyl tributyl citrate (ATBC), bis-2-ethylhexyladipate (DEHA) and bis-2-ethylhexyl terephthalate (DEHT) in indoor dust were 66.20 ± 1.93%, 94.27 ± 1.31%, 80.37 ± 8.09%, 75.02 ± 2.12%, 94.50 ± 3.42% and 74.09 ± 3.79%, respectively, under the condition of 1:1 sweat/sebum ratio, 1/100 solid/liquid ratio (indoor dust), 1:1 area/area ratio (1:1, clothing) and 90 min incubation time at 36.3 °C which are chosen based on the experimental results and human physical conditions. DBP showed the highest bioaccessibility in all samples. The time course of the plasticizer release was fitted to a first-order one-compartment model. DBP showed the highest release rate (k₁) calculated from the model, which was consistent with the bioaccessibility result. Risk assessment indicated that dermal exposure of DBP was an important exposure route, accounting for about 21.58% of total intake, and indoor dust was an important exposure media when considering the dermal bioaccessibility.