Inflammatory and non-inflammatory thyroid eye disease: comparison of disease signs, symptoms and quality of life in US patients

Effect of intravenous methylprednisolone on serum antibody levels in thyroid eye disease

BACKGROUND/AIMS

We evaluated longitudinal autoantibody changes after intravenous methylprednisolone (IVMP), compared them with those in untreated patients and identified prognostic factors for treatment response.

METHODS

In this single-centre, retrospective, observational study, a total of 163 individuals diagnosed with moderate-to-severe thyroid eye disease were enrolled and followed for 12 months. Depending on whether IVMP was administered, we divided the patients into treatment and control groups. Based on the effect of IVMP on TSH receptor (TSH Rc) antibody level, we divided the patients into Ab declined and Ab not declined groups.We evaluated the time, group and interaction associations with the longitudinal autoantibody titres over 12 months using generalised estimating equations. Using multivariable logistic regression, we investigated the prognostic factors for a poor response to IVMP.

RESULTS

In the IVMP group, the TSH Rc antibody (Ab) titre decreased rapidly for 6 months and then decreased slowly until 12 months, becoming similar to the control group at 12 months. This suggests a difference in the decreasing pattern over time between the IVMP and control groups (group and time interaction p=0.029). Total cholesterol (OR 1.0217 (95% CI 1.0068 to 1.0370), p=0.0043) was a significant prognostic factor for the steroid response. The threshold total cholesterol value to distinguish between Ab declined and Ab not declined was 186 mg/dL.

CONCLUSION

IVMP significantly decreased the TSH Rc Ab level for the 3 months after treatment, compared with the no-treatment group, but the groups did not differ significantly after 12 months. Patients with high total cholesterol levels generally showed a poor response to IVMP.

The Rate of Re-treatment in Patients Treated with Teprotumumab: A Multicenter Study of 119 Patients with 1 Year of Follow-up

PURPOSE

To determine the rate of re-treatment in patients who receive a full course of teprotumumab therapy for thyroid eye disease (TED) and drivers of re-treatment.

DESIGN

Multicenter retrospective study.

PARTICIPANTS

All patients who received a full course of treatment and had available data at 1 year after initial treatment were included.

METHODS

Charts were reviewed for the following information: age, sex, months since diagnosis of TED, smoking status, and prior treatments. Further, the clinical activity score (CAS), proptosis, and the Gorman diplopia score were reviewed at baseline, at the end of the first course, and at baseline for the second course in those who received it. A logistic regression model was created to review the drivers of re-treatment.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Rate of re-treatment and the drivers of re-treatment.

RESULTS

One hundred nineteen patients were included from 3 centers across the United States. The overall re-treatment rate was 24% (29/119). No difference was found among the 3 sites (P = 0.6). In univariable analyses, at baseline, no difference was found in proptosis (P = 0.07), diplopia score (P = 0.4), or duration of TED (P = 0.4) between patients who were re-treated and those not re-treated. From the re-treated group, 82% showed a significant proptosis response (≥ 2-mm reduction from baseline) after the initial course, whereas 68% of patients who were not re-treated showed a clinically significant proptosis response (P = 0.16). The mean ± standard deviation difference between the end of the first treatment and at baseline before the second treatment (in those who received it) was 2 ± 2 for CAS, 2 ± 4 mm for proptosis, and 1 ± 1 for diplopia score. Age was the only significant driver of re-treatment (P < 0.05). Re-treated patients were 7 years older than patients who were not re-treated (60 years vs. 53 years; P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

In patients receiving a full course of teprotumumab therapy, the rate of re-treatment was 24%. Age was the only driver of re-treatment.

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S)

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found in the Footnotes and Disclosures at the end of this article.

Immune-related visual dysfunction in thyroid eye disease: a combined orbital and brain neuroimaging study

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the pathological interplay between immunity and the visual processing system (VPS) in thyroid eye disease (TED).

METHODS

A total of 24 active patients (AP), 26 inactive patients (IP) of TED, and 27 healthy controls (HCs) were enrolled. Orbital magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and resting-state functional MRI (rs-fMRI) were conducted for each participant. Multiple MRI parameters of the intraorbital optic nerve (ON) were assessed. The amplitude of low-frequency fluctuations (ALFF) and regional homogeneity (ReHo) were calculated. Correlation analyses were carried out on the above parameters and clinical characteristics.

RESULTS

Visual functioning scores differentiated between the AP and IP groups. The ON subarachnoid space and ON sheath diameter were significantly higher in AP than in IP. Six vision-related brain regions were identified in TED patients compared with HCs, including right calcarine (CAL.R), right cuneus (CUN.R), left postcentral gyrus (PoCG.L), right middle temporal gyrus (MTG.R), left superior frontal gyrus (SFG.L), and left caudate (CAU.L). The brain activity of MTG.R, SFG.L, and CAU.L differentiated between the AP and IP groups. The correlation analysis revealed a close association among the vision-related brain regions, MRI parameters of ON, and clinical characteristics in AP and IP, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Combined orbital and brain neuroimaging revealed abnormalities of the VPS in TED, which had a close correlation with immune statuses. Vision-related brain regions in TED might be possibly altered by peripheral immunity via a direct or indirect approach.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT

The discovery of this study explained the disparity of visual dysfunction in TED patients with different immune statuses. With the uncovered neuroimaging markers, early detection and intervention of visual dysfunction could be achieved and potentially benefit TED patients.

KEY POINTS

• Patients with different immune statuses of thyroid eye disease varied in the presentation of visual dysfunction. • The combined orbital and brain neuroimaging study identified six altered vision-related brain regions, which had a significant correlation with the MRI parameters of the intraorbital optic nerve and immunological characteristics. • Peripheral immunity might possibly give rise to alterations in the central nervous system part of the visual processing system via a direct or indirect approach.

Long-Term Efficacy of Teprotumumab in Thyroid Eye Disease: Follow-Up Outcomes in Three Clinical Trials

Introduction: Thyroid eye disease (TED) is an autoimmune process characterized by extraocular muscle and orbital fat remodeling/expansion resulting in swelling, pain, redness, proptosis, and diplopia. Teprotumumab, an insulin-like growth factor-I receptor inhibitor, demonstrated improvements in TED signs and symptoms in three adequately powered clinical trials of 24 weeks duration. Here we analyze the long-term maintenance of responses with teprotumumab from these trials. Methods: A total of 112 patients who received 7 or 8 infusions of teprotumumab in the Phase 2, Phase 3 (OPTIC study), and OPTIC Extension (OPTIC-X) studies were included in this analysis. Responses, including clinical activity score (CAS ≥2-point improvement), the European Group of Graves' Orbitopathy ophthalmic composite outcome, diplopia (≥1 Gorman grade improvement), proptosis (≥2 mm improvement), Overall (improvement in proptosis + CAS), and disease inactivation (CAS ≤1), were assessed and pooled from study baseline to week 24 (formal study) and up to week 72 (formal follow-up). Graves' Ophthalmopathy quality-of-life (GO-QoL) scores were also assessed. Outcomes included the percentages of observed patient responses from the study baseline. Additional alternative treatments for TED were assessed as a surrogate of persistent benefit from week 24 through week 120 (extended follow-up). Studies differed in the timing of follow-up visits, and data from some visits were unavailable. Results: At week 72, 52/57 (91.2%), 51/57 (89.5%), 35/48 (72.9%), 38/56 (67.9%), and 37/56 (66.1%) of patients were responders for CAS, composite outcome, diplopia, proptosis, and Overall response, respectively. The mean reduction in proptosis was 2.68 mm (SD 1.92, n = 56), mean GO-QoL improvement was 15.22 (SE 2.82, n = 56), and disease inactivation (CAS ≤1) was detected in 40/57 (70.2%). Over 99 weeks following teprotumumab therapy, 19/106 (17.9%) patients reported additional TED therapy during formal and extended follow-up. Conclusion: The long-term response to teprotumumab as observed 51 weeks after therapy was similar to week 24 results in the controlled clinical trials. Inflammatory and ophthalmic composite outcome improvements were seen in 90% of patients with nearly 70% reporting improvement in diplopia and proptosis. Further, 82% of patients in this analysis did not report additional TED treatment (including surgery) over 99 weeks following the final teprotumumab dose.

Bridging and Validation of the Specific Graves Ophthalmopathy Quality of Life Questionnaire With Health State Utility Values

OBJECTIVE

In thyroid eye disease (TED), inflammation and expansion of orbital muscle and periorbital fat result in diplopia and proptosis, severely impacting patient quality of life (QOL). The reported health state utility (HSU) scores, which are QOL measures, allow quantification of TED impact and improvement with therapies; however, no current QOL instrument has been validated with HSU scores for TED. Here, we used the disease-specific Graves Ophthalmopathy Quality of Life (GO-QOL) questionnaire and HSU scores to validate QOL impact.

METHODS

The GO-QOL scores from patients in 2 randomized, masked, placebo-controlled teprotumumab trials (N=171) were compared with 6 HSU values based on severity of proptosis/diplopia in those studies. Patient GO-QOL and HSU scores were compared at baseline and after 6-month treatment via regression analyses. GO-QOL and HSU scores were correlated for validation and quantification of QOL impact by severity state and to estimate quality-adjusted life year improvement.

RESULTS

GO-QOL scores were correlated with TED severity, indicating that worse severity was associated with lower (worse) GO-QOL scores. Less severe health states were represented by higher (better) GO-QOL scores. Importantly, GO-QOL scores were positively correlated with utility scores of the 6 health states, allowing for conversion of the GO-QOL scores to utility scores. A positive (improved) 0.013 utility change was found for each 1-point (positive) improvement in GO-QOL score produced by teprotumumab versus placebo.

CONCLUSION

Patients with moderate-to-severe active TED health states demonstrate increasing TED severity associated with declining utility values and worsening GO-QOL scores. These results indicate that the GO-QOL scores can be used to bridge to the HSU scores for benefit quantification.

Interrater reliability of photographic assessment of thyroid eye disease using the VISA classification

PURPOSE

To determine the interrater reliability (IRR) of thyroid eye disease (TED) photographic assessment using the VISA classification. To assess whether a VISA grading atlas improves ophthalmology trainees' performance in photographic assessment of TED.

METHODS

A prospective, partially randomized, international study conducted from September 2021 to May 2022. Online study invitation was emailed to a volunteer sample group of 68 ophthalmology college accredited consultants and trainees, and 6 were excluded from the study. Participants were asked to score 10 patient photographs of TED using only the inflammation and motility restriction components of the VISA classification. IRR was compared between groups of practitioners by their level of experience. A clinical activity grading atlas was randomized to 50% of the ophthalmology trainees.

RESULTS

Overall rater ICC was 0.96 for inflammation and 0.99 for motility restriction. No statistically significant difference in IRR between rater groups was identified. Trainees with a grading atlas had the highest IRR for inflammation (ICC = 0.95). Each subcomponent of the inflammation and motility restriction components of VISA classification had an ICC considered good to excellent. The mean overall rater score was 4.6/9 for inflammation and 3.5/12 for motility restriction. For motility restriction there was a reduced mean score variance among all raters when scoring photographs with more severe motility restriction.

CONCLUSION

IRR using the inflammation and motility restriction components of the VISA classification was excellent. A VISA grading atlas improved trainee performance in grading inflammation.

Efficacy and Safety of Teprotumumab in Patients With Thyroid Eye Disease of Long Duration and Low Disease Activity

CONTEXT

Early inflammatory thyroid eye disease (TED) can lead to symptomatic chronic disease, including disabling proptosis. Teprotumumab, an insulin-like growth factor-1 receptor (IGF-1R) inhibitor, previously demonstrated efficacy in acute, high-inflammation TED trials.

OBJECTIVE

We present data from the first placebo-controlled trial with teprotumumab in chronic/low disease activity TED.

METHODS

This randomized double-masked, placebo-controlled trial, conducted at 11 US centers, enrolled adult participants with TED duration of 2 to 10 years, Clinical Activity Score (CAS) ≤ 1 or no additional inflammation or progression in proptosis/diplopia for ≥1 year, proptosis ≥3 mm from before TED and/or from normal, euthyroid/mildly hypo/hyperthyroid, no prior teprotumumab, and no steroids within 3 weeks of baseline. Patients received (2:1) intravenous teprotumumab or placebo once every 3 weeks (total 8 infusions). The primary endpoint was proptosis (mm) improvement at Week 24. Adverse events (AEs) were assessed.

RESULTS

A total of 62 (42 teprotumumab and 20 placebo) patients were randomized. At Week 24, least squares mean (SE) proptosis improvement was greater with teprotumumab (-2.41 [0.228]) than with placebo (-0.92 [0.323]), difference -1.48 (95% CI -2.28, -0.69; P = .0004). Proportions of patients with AEs were similar between groups. Hyperglycemia was reported in 6 (15%) vs 2 (10%) and hearing impairment in 9 (22%) vs 2 (10%) with teprotumumab and placebo, respectively. AEs led to discontinuation in 1 teprotumumab (left ear conductive hearing loss with congenital anomaly) and 1 placebo patient (infusion-related). There were no deaths.

CONCLUSION

Teprotumumab significantly improved proptosis vs placebo in longstanding/low inflammation TED, demonstrating efficacy regardless of disease duration/activity. The safety profile was comparable to that previously reported.

Rundle's Curve: A Useful Construct That Does Not Fit All

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to analyze Rundle's original data and subsequent articles on Graves orbitopathy (GO) natural history.

METHODS

Rundle's texts were analyzed qualitatively and quantitatively. Serial measurements were plotted and fitted with different functions. Subsequent articles in the English literature on the natural history of GO were also analyzed.

RESULTS

Different functions such as simple linear regressions, parabolic, saturating exponential growth, and exponential decay functions were well fitted for Rundle's data on measurements of proptosis and supraduction along time. The few quantitative data of the same variables post-Rundle were also well-fitted with various functions.

CONCLUSION

Rundle described in his articles, from 1945 to 1957, 2 phases of ocular changes in GO: dynamic and static. However, he did not mention the pathophysiology of these phases nor used the terms inflammatory and cicatricial. Actually, most of his observations and the subsequent data in the literature on proptosis and supraduction did not obey the biphasic pattern of the so-called Rundle's curve.

How patients experience thyroid eye disease

Objective

To determine the impact of thyroid eye disease (TED) on patients in various stages of the disease.

Background

TED is a debilitating and potentially sight-threatening inflammatory autoimmune disease that is frequently misdiagnosed. Challenging quality-of-life (QoL) issues can persist long after the active phase of disease has subsided.

Methods

A 62-question survey was designed as a hypothesis-generating instrument to identify key issues confronting patients ≥18 years old with physician-diagnosed TED. Questions focused primarily on physical and emotional status, and QoL experiences in the 2 months prior to the survey. Data for individual questions are presented as summary statistics. Correlations between questions were determined using χ2 analyses.

Results

The 443 respondents were 18 to >80 years old; >90% female, and >80% from the United States. Time since TED diagnosis ranged from <1 year to >10 years. Participants provided >500 free-form responses describing experiences of living with TED. Physical signs/symptoms were experienced by 307/443 (69%) patients. Of those responding to the QoL questions (N = 394), 53 (13%) reported symptoms improving, 73 (19%) reported symptoms worsening, and 255 (65%) reported no change in the 2 months prior to the survey. The most bothersome signs/symptoms were dry/gritty eyes, light sensitivity, bulging eyes, and pressure or pain behind the eyes. Respondents <60 years were significantly (p < 0.0001) more likely to report symptomatic TED than older patients. Of 394 respondents, 179 (45%) reported feeling depressed and/or anxious, 174 (44%) reported concern about their appearance, and 73 (19%) avoided public situations; 192 (49%) reported declines in confidence or feelings of general well-being, and 78 (20%) reported an inability to achieve goals. Activities limited by TED included reading, driving, and socializing. The proportion of respondents experiencing these negative QoL measures was higher when patients reported experiencing >5 symptoms, had been diagnosed within the last 5 years, or were <60 years of age.

Conclusions

Physical manifestations of TED impact QoL for patients through all phases of the disease. It is essential that physicians and healthcare professionals become more familiar with patient experiences such as those described here to better help patients manage their disease.

Teprotumumab for the treatment of thyroid eye disease

INTRODUCTION

Thyroid eye disease (TED) is an autoimmune disease characterized by inflammation of orbital and extraocular muscles. It induces proptosis and diplopia, leading to a worsening of quality of life (QoL) because of its impact on physical appearance, and visual function. The natural history involves an 'active TED,' which is an autoimmune inflammatory response targeting orbital soft tissues, and 'inactive TED,' where there is tissue expansion remodeling. To date, glucocorticoids represent the main medical therapy, even if often ineffective and associated with side effects.

AREAS COVERED

In TED, the autoimmune process leads to production of TSH-R and IGF-1 R autoantibodies. This induces inflammatory changes in the orbital tissue, and activation of fibroblasts with accumulation of glycosaminoglycans, leading to consequent proptosis, and diplopia. In two previous randomized, double-masked, placebo-controlled, parallel-group, multicenter trials, teprotumumab has been shown to be effective in improving proptosis, inflammation, diplopia, and QoL. More recently, it has been shown that teprotumumab is also effective in chronic-inactive TED. Teprotumumab was approved by the FDA on 21 January 2020 for the treatment of TED.

EXPERT OPINION

For the above-mentioned reasons teprotumumab represents a potential first line therapy for TED that could replace the use of steroids in the next future.

Utility Assessment of Moderate to Severe Thyroid Eye Disease Health States

Importance

Thyroid eye disease (TED) results in varying degrees of proptosis and diplopia negatively affecting quality of life (QoL), producing possibly substantial visual changes, disfigurement, and disability.

Objective

To determine the association of varying TED severities with QoL in a non-TED population by assessing health state utility scores.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This qualitative study, conducted from April 20, 2020, to April 29, 2021, assessed health states for active, moderate-severe TED, and values were elicited using time trade-off methods. Six health states of varying severity were determined from 2 placebo-controlled clinical trials (171 patients with TED and clinical activity score ≥4, ±diplopia/proptosis) and refined using interviews with US patients with TED (n = 6). Each health state description was validated by interviews with additional TED patient advocates (n = 3) and physician experts (n = 3). Health state descriptions and a QOL questionnaire were piloted and administered to a general population. Visual analog scales (VASs) were also administered to detect concurrence of the findings.

Main Outcomes and Measures

TED health state utility scores and whether they differ from one another were assessed using Shapiro-Wilk, Kruskal-Wallis, pairwise Wilcoxon rank sum, and paired t tests.

Results

A total of 111 participants completed time trade-off interviews. The mean (SD) utility value was 0.44 (0.34). The lowest (worse) mean utility value was observed in the most severe disease state (constant diplopia/large proptosis) with 0.30 (95% CI, 0.24-0.36), followed by constant diplopia/small proptosis (0.34; 95% CI, 0.29-0.40), intermittent or inconstant diplopia/large proptosis (0.43; 95% CI, 0.36-0.49), no diplopia/large proptosis (0.46; 95% CI, 0.40-0.52), and intermittent or inconstant diplopia/small proptosis (0.52; 95% CI, 0.45-0.58). The highest (best) mean value, 0.60 (95% CI, 0.54-0.67), was observed for the least severe disease state (no diplopia/small proptosis).

Conclusions and Relevance

These findings suggest that patients with active, moderate-severe TED may have substantial disutility, with increasing severity of proptosis/diplopia more likely to have detrimental associations with QoL. These health state scores may provide a baseline for determining QoL improvement in these TED health states (utility gains) treated with new therapies.