Commentary on Landry et al.: "Propentofylline, a CNS glial modulator, does not decrease pain in post-herpetic neuralgia patients: in vitro evidence for differential responses in human and rodent microglia and macrophages"

Neuro-immune signatures in chronic low back pain subtypes

We recently showed that patients with different chronic pain conditions (such as chronic low back pain, fibromyalgia, migraine, and Gulf War Illness) demonstrated elevated brain and/or spinal cord levels of the glial marker 18 kDa translocator protein, which suggests that neuroinflammation might be a pervasive phenomenon observable across multiple etiologically heterogeneous pain disorders. Interestingly, the spatial distribution of this neuroinflammatory signal appears to exhibit a degree of disease specificity (e.g. with respect to the involvement of the primary somatosensory cortex), suggesting that different pain conditions may exhibit distinct "neuroinflammatory signatures". To further explore this hypothesis, we tested whether neuroinflammatory signal can characterize putative etiological subtypes of chronic low back pain patients based on clinical presentation. Specifically, we explored neuroinflammation in patients whose chronic low back pain either did or did not radiate to the leg (i.e. "radicular" vs. "axial" back pain). Fifty-four chronic low back pain patients, twenty-six with axial back pain (43.7 ± 16.6 y.o. [mean±SD]) and twenty-eight with radicular back pain (48.3 ± 13.2 y.o.), underwent PET/MRI with [11C]PBR28, a second-generation radioligand for the 18 kDa translocator protein. [11C]PBR28 signal was quantified using standardized uptake values ratio (validated against volume of distribution ratio; n = 23). Functional MRI data were collected simultaneously to the [11C]PBR28 data 1) to functionally localize the primary somatosensory cortex back and leg subregions and 2) to perform functional connectivity analyses (in order to investigate possible neurophysiological correlations of the neuroinflammatory signal). PET and functional MRI measures were compared across groups, cross-correlated with one another and with the severity of "fibromyalgianess" (i.e. the degree of pain centralization, or "nociplastic pain"). Furthermore, statistical mediation models were employed to explore possible causal relationships between these three variables. For the primary somatosensory cortex representation of back/leg, [11C]PBR28 PET signal and functional connectivity to the thalamus were: 1) higher in radicular compared to axial back pain patients, 2) positively correlated with each other and 3) positively correlated with fibromyalgianess scores, across groups. Finally, 4) fibromyalgianess mediated the association between [11C]PBR28 PET signal and primary somatosensory cortex-thalamus connectivity across groups. Our findings support the existence of "neuroinflammatory signatures" that are accompanied by neurophysiological changes, and correlate with clinical presentation (in particular, with the degree of nociplastic pain) in chronic pain patients. These signatures may contribute to the subtyping of distinct pain syndromes and also provide information about inter-individual variability in neuro-immune brain signals, within diagnostic groups, that could eventually serve as targets for mechanism-based precision medicine approaches.

Microglial Modulation as a Target for Chronic Pain: From the Bench to the Bedside and Back

With a widespread opioid epidemic and profound biopsychosocial implications, chronic pain is a multifaceted public health issue requiring urgent attention. The treatment of chronic pain is particularly important to anesthesiologists given our unique role as perioperative physicians and pain medicine specialists. The present review details the recent shift from a neuronal theory of chronic pain to one that includes complex neuron-glia interactions. In particular, we highlight microglia, the myeloid-lineage cells of the central nervous system, as initiators of a postinjury neuroimmune response that contributes to the acute to chronic pain transition. We discuss ever-advancing preclinical studies, wherein significant success has been made through pharmacologic and genetic modulation of microglia, and we emphasize where these approaches have made the transition to the clinical realm. Furthermore, we highlight the most current, novel efforts to visualize glial activation in vivo using positron emission tomography and improve the diagnosis of chronic pain through radiotracer binding of specific targets, like the 18 kDa translocator protein in microglia and myeloid-lineage cells. Our rapidly advancing knowledge about microglia and their involvement in pain suggests that the era of glial-targeted therapeutics is just beginning so long as we refocus our attention on optimizing preclinical studies using a clinically informed approach, before translation.

Astrocyte contributes to pain development via MMP2-JNK1/2 signaling in a mouse model of complex regional pain syndrome

BACKGROUND

The activation of spinal glial cells (astrocyte and microglia) is reported in patient with complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS). However, the roles of spinal glial activities in the pathophysiology of CRPS are unclear. Here, we explored the roles of spinal astrocyte and microglia and the molecular mechanisms underlying CRPS using a mouse model of chronic post-ischemia pain (CPIP).

RESULTS

CPIP injury increased the level of glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP, reactive astrocyte biomarker), but had no significant impact on ionized calcium binding adaptor molecule 1 (IBA1, reactive microglia biomarker), in the ipsilateral dorsal horn on post-injury day (PID) 3 when the pain threshold started to reduce significantly. Astrocytic inhibition with fluorocitrate but not microglial inhibition with minocycline attenuated the development of allodynia in CPIP-injured mice, which was concomitant with increased spinal levels of phosphorylated c-jun N-terminal kinase 1/2 (pJNK1/2) on PID 3. Furthermore, the intrathecal administration of SP600125 (JNK inhibitor) prevented the development of allodynia in CPIP-injured mice. Double immunofluorescence staining showed that pJNK1/2 was mainly co-localized with GFAP. Subsequently, increased levels of pJNK1/2 were reversed by intrathecal fluorocitrate. Furthermore, the level of spinal matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP2) was increased and mainly expressed in NeuN (neuron biomarker) on PID 3 in the CPIP-injured mice, while intrathecal APR 100 (MMP2 inhibitor) delayed the development of allodynia and decreased spinal levels of GFAP and pJNK1/2 on PID 3.

CONCLUSION

This study shows that activation of astrocyte MMP2/JNK1/2 signaling pathway contributes to the pathogenesis of pain hypersensitivity in the CPIP model.

Activity-triggered tetrapartite neuron-glial interactions following peripheral injury

Recent studies continue to support the proposition that non-neuronal components of the nervous system, mainly glial cells and associated chemical mediators, contribute to the development of neuronal hyperexcitability that underlies persistent pain conditions. In the event of peripheral injury, enhanced or abnormal nerve input is likely the most efficient way to activate simultaneously central neurons and glia. Injury induces phenotypic changes in glia and triggers signaling cascades that engage reciprocal interactions between presynaptic terminals, postsynaptic neurons, microglia and astrocytes. While some responses to peripheral injury may help the nervous system to adapt positively to counter the disastrous effect of injury, the net effect often leads to long-lasting sensitization of pain transmission pathways and chronic pain.

The search for novel analgesics: targets and mechanisms

The management of the pain state is of great therapeutic relevance to virtually every medical specialty. Failure to manage its expression has deleterious consequence to the well-being of the organism. An understanding of the complex biology of the mechanisms underlying the processing of nociceptive information provides an important pathway towards development of novel and robust therapeutics. Importantly, preclinical models have been of considerable use in determining the linkage between mechanism and the associated behaviorally defined pain state. This review seeks to provide an overview of current thinking targeting pain biology, the use of preclinical models and the development of novel pain therapeutics. Issues pertinent to the strengths and weaknesses of current development strategies for analgesics are considered.

Opioid-induced central immune signaling: implications for opioid analgesia

Despite being the mainstay of pain management, opioids are limited in their clinical utility by adverse effects, such as tolerance and paradoxical hyperalgesia. Research of the past 15 years has extended beyond neurons, to implicate central nervous system immune signaling in these adverse effects. This article will provide an overview of these central immune mechanisms in opioid tolerance and paradoxical hyperalgesia, including those mediated by Toll-like receptor 4, purinergic, ceramide, and chemokine signaling. Challenges for the future, as well as new lines of investigation will be highlighted.

Evidence for brain glial activation in chronic pain patients

Although substantial evidence has established that microglia and astrocytes play a key role in the establishment and maintenance of persistent pain in animal models, the role of glial cells in human pain disorders remains unknown. Here, using the novel technology of integrated positron emission tomography-magnetic resonance imaging and the recently developed radioligand (11)C-PBR28, we show increased brain levels of the translocator protein (TSPO), a marker of glial activation, in patients with chronic low back pain. As the Ala147Thr polymorphism in the TSPO gene affects binding affinity for (11)C-PBR28, nine patient-control pairs were identified from a larger sample of subjects screened and genotyped, and compared in a matched-pairs design, in which each patient was matched to a TSPO polymorphism-, age- and sex-matched control subject (seven Ala/Ala and two Ala/Thr, five males and four females in each group; median age difference: 1 year; age range: 29-63 for patients and 28-65 for controls). Standardized uptake values normalized to whole brain were significantly higher in patients than controls in multiple brain regions, including thalamus and the putative somatosensory representations of the lumbar spine and leg. The thalamic levels of TSPO were negatively correlated with clinical pain and circulating levels of the proinflammatory citokine interleukin-6, suggesting that TSPO expression exerts pain-protective/anti-inflammatory effects in humans, as predicted by animal studies. Given the putative role of activated glia in the establishment and or maintenance of persistent pain, the present findings offer clinical implications that may serve to guide future studies of the pathophysiology and management of a variety of persistent pain conditions.

Pathological pain and the neuroimmune interface

Reciprocal signalling between immunocompetent cells in the central nervous system (CNS) has emerged as a key phenomenon underpinning pathological and chronic pain mechanisms. Neuronal excitability can be powerfully enhanced both by classical neurotransmitters derived from neurons, and by immune mediators released from CNS-resident microglia and astrocytes, and from infiltrating cells such as T cells. In this Review, we discuss the current understanding of the contribution of central immune mechanisms to pathological pain, and how the heterogeneous immune functions of different cells in the CNS could be harnessed to develop new therapeutics for pain control. Given the prevalence of chronic pain and the incomplete efficacy of current drugs--which focus on suppressing aberrant neuronal activity--new strategies to manipulate neuroimmune pain transmission hold considerable promise.

Systemic administration of propentofylline, ibudilast, and (+)-naltrexone each reverses mechanical allodynia in a novel rat model of central neuropathic pain

Central neuropathic pain (CNP) is a debilitating consequence of central nervous system damage for which current treatments are ineffective. To explore mechanisms underlying CNP, we developed a rat model involving T13/L1 dorsal root avulsion. The resultant dorsal horn damage creates bilateral below-level (L4-L6) mechanical allodynia. This allodynia, termed spinal neuropathic avulsion pain, occurs in the absence of confounding paralysis. To characterize this model, we undertook a series of studies aimed at defining whether spinal neuropathic avulsion pain could be reversed by any of 3 putative glial activation inhibitors, each with distinct mechanisms of action. Indeed, the phosphodiesterase inhibitor propentofylline, the macrophage migration inhibitory factor inhibitor ibudilast, and the toll-like receptor 4 antagonist (+)-naltrexone each reversed below-level allodynia bilaterally. Strikingly, none of these impacted spinal neuropathic avulsion pain upon first administration but required 1 to 2 weeks of daily administration before pain reversal was obtained. Given reversal of CNP by each of these glial modulatory agents, these results suggest that glia contribute to the maintenance of such pain and enduring release of macrophage migration inhibitory factor and endogenous agonists of toll-like receptor 4 is important for sustaining CNP. The markedly delayed efficacy of all 3 glial modulatory drugs may prove instructive for interpretation of apparent drug failures after shorter dosing regimens.

PERSPECTIVE

CNP that develops after trauma is often described by patients as severe and intolerable. Unfortunately, current treatments are not effective. This work suggests that using pharmacologic treatments that target glial cells could be an effective clinical treatment for CNP.

Low-dose endotoxin potentiates capsaicin-induced pain in man: evidence for a pain neuroimmune connection

Despite the wealth of evidence in animals that immune activation has a key role in the development and maintenance of chronic pain, evidence to support this in humans is scant. We have sought such evidence by examining the effect of a subtle immunological stimulus, low dose intravenous endotoxin, on the allodynia, hyperalgesia, flare and pain produced by intradermal capsaicin in healthy volunteers. Here we provide evidence of immune priming of this neuropathic-like pain response in humans. Specifically, in 12 healthy volunteers, activation of Toll-Like Receptor 4 by endotoxin (0.4ng/kg IV) caused significant 5.1-fold increase in the 90-min integral of areas of capsaicin-induced allodynia (95% CI 1.3-9.1), 2.2-fold increase in flare (95% CI 1.9-2.6) and 1.8-fold increase in hyperalgesia (95% CI 1.1-2.5) following 50μg intradermal capsaicin injected into the forearm 3.5h after endotoxin. These data demonstrate clinically a significant role for the neuroimmune pain connection in modifying pain, thus providing evidence that immune priming may produce pain enhancement in humans and hence offer a novel range of pharmacological targets for anti-allodynics and/or analgesics. Additionally, the simplicity of the model makes it suitable as a test-bed for novel immune-targeted pain therapeutics.

Astrocytes--multitaskers in chronic pain

Treatment of chronic pain remains a clinical challenge and sufficient pharmacological management is difficult to achieve without concurrent adverse drug effects. Recently the concept of chronic pain as a solely neuron-mediated phenomenon has evolved and it is now appreciated that also glial cells are of critical importance in pain generation and modulation. Astrocytes are macroglial cells that have close structural relationships with neurons; they contact neuronal somata and dendrites and enwrap synapses, where small astrocytic processes have been shown to be highly motile. This organization allows astrocytes to directly influence and coordinate neurons located within their structural domains. Moreover, astrocytes form astroglial networks and calcium wave propagations can spread through neighbouring astrocytes. ATP, which is released from astrocytes in response to elevated intracellular calcium concentrations, can contribute to the central mechanisms in chronic pain via purinergic receptors. In this review we highlight the structural organization and the functionalities of astrocytes that allow them to undertake critical roles in pain processing and we stress the possibility that astrocytes contribute to chronic pain not via a single pathway, but by undertaking various roles depending on the pain condition.

The role of the immune system in the generation of neuropathic pain

Persistent pain is a sequela of several neurological conditions with a primary immune basis, such as Guillain-Barré syndrome and multiple sclerosis. Additionally, diverse forms of injury to the peripheral or the central nervous systems--whether traumatic, metabolic, or toxic--result in substantial recruitment and activation of immune cells. This response involves the innate immune system, but evidence also exists of T-lymphocyte recruitment, and in some patient cohorts antibodies to neuronal antigens have been reported. Mediators released by immune cells, such as cytokines, sensitise nociceptive signalling in the peripheral and central nervous systems. Preclinical data suggest an immune pathogenesis of neuropathic pain, but clinical evidence of a central role of the immune system is less clear. An important challenge for the future is to establish to what extent this immune response initiates or maintains neuropathic pain in patients and thus whether it is amenable to therapy.

P2X4R+ microglia drive neuropathic pain

Neuropathic pain, the most debilitating of all clinical pain syndromes, may be a consequence of trauma, infection or pathology from diseases that affect peripheral nerves. Here we provide a framework for understanding the spinal mechanisms of neuropathic pain as distinct from those of acute pain or inflammatory pain. Recent work suggests that a specific microglia response phenotype characterized by de novo expression of the purinergic receptor P2X4 is critical for the pathogenesis of pain hypersensitivity caused by injury to peripheral nerves. Stimulating P2X4 receptors initiates a core pain signaling pathway mediated by release of brain-derived neurotrophic factor, which produces a disinhibitory increase in intracellular chloride in nociceptive (pain-transmitting) neurons in the spinal dorsal horn. The changes caused by signaling from P2X4R(+) microglia to nociceptive transmission neurons may account for the main symptoms of neuropathic pain in humans, and they point to specific interventions to alleviate this debilitating condition.