Isolated epsilon subunit of Bacillus subtilis F1-ATPase binds ATP

ATP binding by an F1Fo ATP synthase ε subunit is pH dependent, suggesting a diversity of ε subunit functional regulation in bacteria

It is a conjecture that the ε subunit regulates ATP hydrolytic function of the F₁F_o ATP synthase in bacteria. This has been proposed by the ε subunit taking an extended conformation, with a terminal helix probing into the central architecture of the hexameric catalytic domain, preventing ATP hydrolysis. The ε subunit takes a contracted conformation when bound to ATP, thus would not interfere with catalysis. A recent crystallographic study has disputed this; the Caldalkalibacillus thermarum TA2.A1 F₁F_o ATP synthase cannot natively hydrolyse ATP, yet studies have demonstrated that the loss of the ε subunit terminal helix results in an ATP synthase capable of ATP hydrolysis, supporting ε subunit function. Analysis of sequence and crystallographic data of the C. thermarum F₁F_o ATP synthase revealed two unique histidine residues. Molecular dynamics simulations suggested that the protonation state of these residues may influence ATP binding site stability. Yet these residues lie outside the ATP/Mg²⁺ binding site of the ε subunit. We then probed the effect of pH on the ATP binding affinity of the ε subunit from the C. thermarum F₁F_o ATP synthase at various physiologically relevant pH values. We show that binding affinity changes 5.9 fold between pH 7.0, where binding is weakest, to pH 8.5 where it is strongest. Since the C. thermarum cytoplasm is pH 8.0 when it grows optimally, this correlates to the ε subunit being down due to ATP/Mg²⁺ affinity, and not being involved in blocking ATP hydrolysis. Here, we have experimentally correlated that the pH of the bacterial cytoplasm is of critical importance for ε subunit ATP affinity regulated by second-shell residues thus the function of the ε subunit changes with growth conditions.

Evolution of the Inhibitory and Non-Inhibitory ε, ζ, and IF1 Subunits of the F1FO-ATPase as Related to the Endosymbiotic Origin of Mitochondria

The F1FO-ATP synthase nanomotor synthesizes >90% of the cellular ATP of almost all living beings by rotating in the “forward” direction, but it can also consume the same ATP pools by rotating in “reverse.” To prevent futile F1FO-ATPase activity, several different inhibitory proteins or domains in bacteria (ε and ζ subunits), mitochondria (IF1), and chloroplasts (ε and γ disulfide) emerged to block the F1FO-ATPase activity selectively. In this study, we analyze how these F1FO-ATPase inhibitory proteins have evolved. The phylogeny of the α-proteobacterial ε showed that it diverged in its C-terminal side, thus losing both the inhibitory function and the ATP-binding/sensor motif that controls this inhibition. The losses of inhibitory function and the ATP-binding site correlate with an evolutionary divergence of non-inhibitory α-proteobacterial ε and mitochondrial δ subunits from inhibitory bacterial and chloroplastidic ε subunits. Here, we confirm the lack of inhibitory function of wild-type and C-terminal truncated ε subunits of P. denitrificans. Taken together, the data show that ζ evolved to replace ε as the primary inhibitor of the F1FO-ATPase of free-living α-proteobacteria. However, the ζ inhibitory function was also partially lost in some symbiotic α-proteobacteria and totally lost in some strictly parasitic α-proteobacteria such as the Rickettsiales order. Finally, we found that ζ and IF1 likely evolved independently via convergent evolution before and after the endosymbiotic origin mitochondria, respectively. This led us to propose the ε and ζ subunits as tracer genes of the pre-endosymbiont that evolved into the actual mitochondria.

Bacterial F-type ATP synthases follow a well-choreographed assembly pathway

F-type ATP synthases are multiprotein complexes composed of two separate coupled motors (F₁ and F_O) generating adenosine triphosphate (ATP) as the universal major energy source in a variety of relevant biological processes in mitochondria, bacteria and chloroplasts. While the structure of many ATPases is solved today, the precise assembly pathway of F₁F_O-ATP synthases is still largely unclear. Here, we probe the assembly of the F₁ complex from Acetobacterium woodii. Using laser induced liquid bead ion desorption (LILBID) mass spectrometry, we study the self-assembly of purified F₁ subunits in different environments under non-denaturing conditions. We report assembly requirements and identify important assembly intermediates in vitro and in cellula. Our data provide evidence that nucleotide binding is crucial for in vitro F₁ assembly, whereas ATP hydrolysis appears to be less critical. We correlate our results with activity measurements and propose a model for the assembly pathway of a functional F₁ complex.

ATPases are the macromolecular machines for cellular energy production. Here the authors investigate factors that govern the assembly of the F₁ complex from a bacterial F-type ATPase and relate differences in activity of complexes assembled in cells and in vitro to structural changes.

A second shell residue modulates a conserved ATP-binding site with radically different affinities for ATP

BACKGROUND

Prediction of ligand binding and design of new function in enzymes is a time-consuming and expensive process. Crystallography gives the impression that proteins adopt a fixed shape, yet enzymes are functionally dynamic. Molecular dynamics offers the possibility of probing protein movement while predicting ligand binding. Accordingly, we choose the bacterial F₁F_o ATP synthase ε subunit to unravel why ATP affinity by ε subunits from Bacillus subtilis and Bacillus PS3 differs ~500-fold, despite sharing identical sequences at the ATP-binding site.

METHODS

We first used the Bacillus PS3 ε subunit structure to model the B. subtilis ε subunit structure and used this to explore the utility of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to predict the influence of residues outside the ATP binding site. To verify the MD predictions, point mutants were made and ATP binding studies were employed.

RESULTS

MD simulations predicted that E102 in the B. subtilis ε subunit, outside of the ATP binding site, influences ATP binding affinity. Engineering E102 to alanine or arginine revealed a ~10 or ~54 fold increase in ATP binding, respectively, confirming the MD prediction that E102 drastically influences ATP binding affinity.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings reveal how MD can predict how changes in the "second shell" residues around substrate binding sites influence affinity in simple protein structures. Our results reveal why seemingly identical ε subunits in different ATP synthases have radically different ATP binding affinities.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

This study may lead to greater utility of molecular dynamics as a tool for protein design and exploration of protein design and function.

The Molecular Basis for Purine Binding Selectivity in the Bacterial ATP Synthase ϵ Subunit

The ϵ subunit of ATP synthases has been proposed to regulate ATP hydrolysis in bacteria. Prevailing evidence supports the notion that when the ATP concentration falls below a certain threshold, the ϵ subunit changes its conformation from a non-inhibitory down-state to an extended up-state that then inhibits enzymatic ATP hydrolysis by binding to the catalytic domain. It has been demonstrated that the ϵ subunit from Bacillus PS3 is selective for ATP over other nucleotides, including GTP. In this study, the purine triphosphate selectivity is rationalized by using results from MD simulations and free energy calculations for the R103A/R115A mutant of the ϵ subunit from Bacillus PS3, which binds ATP more strongly than the wild-type protein. Our results are in good agreement with experimental data, and the elucidated molecular basis for selectivity could help to guide the design of novel GTP sensors.

F-ATP-ase of Escherichia coli membranes: The ubiquitous MgADP-inhibited state and the inhibited state induced by the ε-subunit's C-terminal domain are mutually exclusive

ATP synthases are important energy-coupling, rotary motor enzymes in all kingdoms of life. In all F-type ATP synthases, the central rotor of the catalytic F₁ complex is composed of the γ subunit and the N-terminal domain (NTD) of the ε subunit. In the enzymes of diverse bacteria, the C-terminal domain of ε (εCTD) can undergo a dramatic conformational change to trap the enzyme in a transiently inactive state. This inhibitory mechanism is absent in the mitochondrial enzyme, so the εCTD could provide a means to selectively target ATP synthases of pathogenic bacteria for antibiotic development. For Escherichia coli and other bacterial model systems, it has been difficult to dissect the relationship between ε inhibition and a MgADP-inhibited state that is ubiquitous for F_OF₁ from bacteria and eukaryotes. A prior study with the isolated catalytic complex from E. coli, EcF₁, showed that these two modes of inhibition are mutually exclusive, but it has long been known that interactions of F₁ with the membrane-embedded F_O complex modulate inhibition by the εCTD. Here, we study membranes containing EcF_OF₁ with wild-type ε, ε lacking the full εCTD, or ε with a small deletion at the C-terminus. By using compounds with distinct activating effects on F-ATP-ase activity, we confirm that εCTD inhibition and ubiquitous MgADP inhibition are mutually exclusive for membrane-bound E. coli F-ATP-ase. We determine that most of the enzyme complexes in wild-type membranes are in the ε-inhibited state (>50%) or in the MgADP-inhibited state (30%).

ATP-binding affinity of the ε subunit of thermophilic F1-ATPase under label-free conditions

The ε subunits of several bacterial F₁-ATPases bind ATP. ATP binding to the ε subunit has been shown to be involved in the regulation of F₁-ATPase from thermophilic Bacillus sp. PS3 (TF₁). We previously reported that the dissociation constant for ATP of wild-type ε subunit of TF₁ at 25 °C is 4.3 μM by measuring changes in the fluorescence of the dye attached to the ε subunit (Kato, S. et al. (2007) J. Biol. Chem.282, 37618). However, we have recently noticed that this varies with the dye used. In this report, to determine the affinity for ATP under label-free conditions, we have measured the competitive displacement of 2′(3′)-O-N′-methylaniloyl-aminoadenosine-5′-triphosphate (Mant-ATP), a fluorescent analog of ATP, by ATP. The dissociation constant for ATP of wild-type ε subunit of TF₁ at 25 °C was determined to be 0.29 μM, which is one order of magnitude higher affinity than previously reported values.

•

The ε subunit of F₁-ATPase from Bacillus PS3 specifically binds ATP.

•

Fluorescent labeling of ε subunit for the measurement may affect binding affinity.

•

ATP binding affinity under label-free conditions was determined.

•

Affinity of ε subunit for ATP is revised.

Cryo-EM reveals distinct conformations of E. coli ATP synthase on exposure to ATP

ATP synthase produces the majority of cellular energy in most cells. We have previously reported cryo-EM maps of autoinhibited E. coli ATP synthase imaged without addition of nucleotide (Sobti et al. 2016), indicating that the subunit ε engages the α, β and γ subunits to lock the enzyme and prevent functional rotation. Here we present multiple cryo-EM reconstructions of the enzyme frozen after the addition of MgATP to identify the changes that occur when this ε inhibition is removed. The maps generated show that, after exposure to MgATP, E. coli ATP synthase adopts a different conformation with a catalytic subunit changing conformation substantially and the ε C-terminal domain transitioning via an intermediate 'half-up' state to a condensed 'down' state. This work provides direct evidence for unique conformational states that occur in E. coli ATP synthase when ATP binding prevents the ε C-terminal domain from entering the inhibitory 'up' state.

C-terminal regulatory domain of the ε subunit of Fo F1 ATP synthase enhances the ATP-dependent H+ pumping that is involved in the maintenance of cellular membrane potential in Bacillus subtilis

The ε subunit of F_oF₁‐ATPase/synthase (F_oF₁) plays a crucial role in regulating F_oF₁ activity. To understand the physiological significance of the ε subunit‐mediated regulation of F_oF₁ in Bacillus subtilis, we constructed and characterized a mutant harboring a deletion in the C‐terminal regulatory domain of the ε subunit (ε^∆C). Analyses using inverted membrane vesicles revealed that the ε^∆C mutation decreased ATPase activity and the ATP‐dependent H⁺‐pumping activity of F_oF₁. To enhance the effects of ε^∆C mutation, this mutation was introduced into a ∆rrn8 strain harboring only two of the 10 rrn (rRNA) operons (∆rrn8 ε^∆C mutant strain). Interestingly, growth of the ∆rrn8 ε^∆C mutant stalled at late‐exponential phase. During the stalled growth phase, the membrane potential of the ∆rrn8 ε^∆C mutant cells was significantly reduced, which led to a decrease in the cellular level of 70S ribosomes. The growth stalling was suppressed by adding glucose into the culture medium. Our findings suggest that the C‐terminal region of the ε subunit is important for alleviating the temporal reduction in the membrane potential, by enhancing the ATP‐dependent H⁺‐pumping activity of F_oF₁.

ADP-Inhibition of H+-FOF1-ATP Synthase

H+-F_OF₁-ATP synthase (F-ATPase, F-type ATPase, F_OF₁ complex) catalyzes ATP synthesis from ADP and inorganic phosphate in eubacteria, mitochondria, chloroplasts, and some archaea. ATP synthesis is powered by the transmembrane proton transport driven by the proton motive force (PMF) generated by the respiratory or photosynthetic electron transport chains. When the PMF is decreased or absent, ATP synthase catalyzes the reverse reaction, working as an ATP-dependent proton pump. The ATPase activity of the enzyme is regulated by several mechanisms, of which the most conserved is the non-competitive inhibition by the MgADP complex (ADP-inhibition). When ADP binds to the catalytic site without phosphate, the enzyme may undergo conformational changes that lock bound ADP, resulting in enzyme inactivation. PMF can induce release of inhibitory ADP and reactivate ATP synthase; the threshold PMF value required for enzyme reactivation might exceed the PMF for ATP synthesis. Moreover, membrane energization increases the catalytic site affinity to phosphate, thereby reducing the probability of ADP binding without phosphate and preventing enzyme transition to the ADP-inhibited state. Besides phosphate, oxyanions (e.g., sulfite and bicarbonate), alcohols, lauryldimethylamine oxide, and a number of other detergents can weaken ADP-inhibition and increase ATPase activity of the enzyme. In this paper, we review the data on ADP-inhibition of ATP synthases from different organisms and discuss the in vivo role of this phenomenon and its relationship with other regulatory mechanisms, such as ATPase activity inhibition by subunit ε and nucleotide binding in the noncatalytic sites of the enzyme. It should be noted that in Escherichia coli enzyme, ADP-inhibition is relatively weak and rather enhanced than prevented by phosphate.

Single mutations in the ε subunit from thermophilic Bacillus PS3 generate a high binding affinity site for ATP

The ε subunit from ATP synthases acts as an ATP sensor in the bacterial cell to prevent ATP hydrolysis and thus the waste of ATP under conditions of low ATP concentration. However, the ATP binding affinities from various bacterial organisms differ markedly, over several orders of magnitude. For example, the ATP synthases from thermophilic Bacillus PS3 and Escherichia coli exhibit affinities of 4 µM and 22 mM, respectively. The recently reported R103A/R115A double mutant of Bacillus PS3 ATP synthase demonstrated an increased binding affinity by two orders of magnitude with respect to the wild type. Here, we used atomic-resolution molecular dynamics simulations to determine the role of the R103A and R115A single mutations. These lead us to predict that both single mutations also cause an increased ATP binding affinity. Evolutionary analysis reveals R103 and R115 substitutions in the ε subunit from other bacillic organisms, leading us to predict they likely have a higher ATP binding affinity than previously expected.

The regulatory subunit ε in Escherichia coli FOF1-ATP synthase

F-type ATP synthases are extraordinary multisubunit proteins that operate as nanomotors. The Escherichia coli (E. coli) enzyme uses the proton motive force (pmf) across the bacterial plasma membrane to drive rotation of the central rotor subunits within a stator subunit complex. Through this mechanical rotation, the rotor coordinates three nucleotide binding sites that sequentially catalyze the synthesis of ATP. Moreover, the enzyme can hydrolyze ATP to turn the rotor in the opposite direction and generate pmf. The direction of net catalysis, i.e. synthesis or hydrolysis of ATP, depends on the cell's bioenergetic conditions. Different control mechanisms have been found for ATP synthases in mitochondria, chloroplasts and bacteria. This review discusses the auto-inhibitory behavior of subunit ε found in F_OF₁-ATP synthases of many bacteria. We focus on E. coli F_OF₁-ATP synthase, with insights into the regulatory mechanism of subunit ε arising from structural and biochemical studies complemented by single-molecule microscopy experiments.

Insights into the regulatory function of the ɛ subunit from bacterial F-type ATP synthases: a comparison of structural, biochemical and biophysical data

ATP synthases catalyse the formation of ATP, the most common chemical energy storage unit found in living cells. These enzymes are driven by an electrochemical ion gradient, which allows the catalytic evolution of ATP by a binding change mechanism. Most ATP synthases are capable of catalysing ATP hydrolysis to varying degrees, and to prevent wasteful ATP hydrolysis, bacteria and mitochondria have regulatory mechanisms such as ADP inhibition. Additionally, ɛ subunit inhibition has also been described in three bacterial systems, Escherichia coli, Bacillus PS3 and Caldalkalibacillus thermarum TA2.A1. Previous studies suggest that the ɛ subunit is capable of undergoing an ATP-dependent conformational change from the ATP hydrolytic inhibitory 'extended' conformation to the ATP-induced non-inhibitory 'hairpin' conformation. A recently published crystal structure of the F1 domain of the C. thermarum TA2.A1 F1Fo ATP synthase revealed a mutant ɛ subunit lacking the ability to bind ATP in a hairpin conformation. This is a surprising observation considering it is an organism that performs no ATP hydrolysis in vivo, and appears to challenge the current dogma on the regulatory role of the ɛ subunit. This has prompted a re-examination of present knowledge of the ɛ subunits role in different organisms. Here, we compare published biochemical, biophysical and structural data involving ɛ subunit-mediated ATP hydrolysis regulation in a variety of organisms, concluding that the ɛ subunit from the bacterial F-type ATP synthases is indeed capable of regulating ATP hydrolysis activity in a wide variety of bacteria, making it a potentially valuable drug target, but its exact role is still under debate.

The structural basis of a high affinity ATP binding ε subunit from a bacterial ATP synthase

The ε subunit from bacterial ATP synthases functions as an ATP sensor, preventing ATPase activity when the ATP concentration in bacterial cells crosses a certain threshold. The R103A/R115A double mutant of the ε subunit from thermophilic Bacillus PS3 has been shown to bind ATP two orders of magnitude stronger than the wild type protein. We use molecular dynamics simulations and free energy calculations to derive the structural basis of the high affinity ATP binding to the R103A/R115A double mutant. Our results suggest that the double mutant is stabilized by an enhanced hydrogen-bond network and fewer repulsive contacts in the ligand binding site. The inferred structural basis of the high affinity mutant may help to design novel nucleotide sensors based on the ε subunit from bacterial ATP synthases.

Dynamic mechanisms driving conformational conversions of the β and ε subunits involved in rotational catalysis of F1-ATPase

F-type ATPase is a ubiquitous molecular motor. Investigations on thermophilic F₁-ATPase and its subunits, β and ε, by NMR were reviewed. Using specific isotope labeling, pK_a of the putative catalytic carboxylate in β was estimated. Segmental isotope-labeling enabled us to monitor most residues of β, revealing that the conformational conversion from open to closed form of β on nucleotide binding found in ATPase was an intrinsic property of β and could work as a driving force of the rotational catalysis. A stepwise conformational change was driven by switching of the hydrogen bond networks involving Walker A and B motifs. Segmentally labeled ATPase provided a well resolved NMR spectra, revealing while the open form of β was identical for β monomer and ATPase, its closed form could be different. ATP-binding was also a critical factor in the conformational conversion of ε, an ATP hydrolysis inhibitor. Its structural elucidation was described.

On the ATP binding site of the ε subunit from bacterial F-type ATP synthases

F-type ATP synthases are reversible machinery that not only synthesize adenosine triphosphate (ATP) using an electrochemical gradient across the membrane, but also can hydrolyze ATP to pump ions under certain conditions. To prevent wasteful ATP hydrolysis, subunit ε in bacterial ATP synthases changes its conformation from the non-inhibitory down- to the inhibitory up-state at a low cellular ATP concentration. Recently, a crystal structure of the ε subunit in complex with ATP was solved in a non-biologically relevant dimeric form. Here, to derive the functional ATP binding site motif, we carried out molecular dynamics simulations and free energy calculations. Our results suggest that the ATP binding site markedly differs from the experimental resolved one; we observe a reorientation of several residues, which bind to ATP in the crystal structure. In addition we find that an Mg(2+) ion is coordinated by ATP, replacing interactions of the second chain in the crystal structure. Thus we demonstrate more generally the influence of crystallization effects on ligand binding sites and their respective binding modes. Furthermore, we propose a role for two highly conserved residues to control the ATP binding/unbinding event, which have not been considered before. Additionally our results provide the basis for the rational development of new biosensors based on subunit ε, as shown previously for novel sensors measuring the ATP concentration in cells.

High affinity nucleotide-binding mutant of the ε subunit of thermophilic F1-ATPase

Specific ATP binding to the ε subunit of thermophilic F1-ATPase has been utilized for the biosensors of ATP in vivo. I report here that the ε subunit containing R103A/R115A mutations can bind ATP with a dissociation constant at 52 nM, which is two orders of magnitude higher affinity than the wild type. The mutant retained specificity for ATP; ADP and GTP bound to the mutant with dissociation constants 16 and 53 μM, respectively. Thus, the mutant would be a good platform for various types of nucleotide biosensor with appropriate modifications.

Assembly of F1F0-ATP synthases

F1F0-ATP synthases are multimeric protein complexes and common prerequisites for their correct assembly are (i) provision of subunits in appropriate relative amounts, (ii) coordination of membrane insertion and (iii) avoidance of assembly intermediates that uncouple the proton gradient or wastefully hydrolyse ATP. Accessory factors facilitate these goals and assembly occurs in a modular fashion. Subcomplexes common to bacteria and mitochondria, but in part still elusive in chloroplasts, include a soluble F1 intermediate, a membrane-intrinsic, oligomeric c-ring, and a membrane-embedded subcomplex composed of stator subunits and subunit a. The final assembly step is thought to involve association of the preformed F1-c10-14 with the ab2 module (or the ab8-stator module in mitochondria)--mediated by binding of subunit δ in bacteria or OSCP in mitochondria, respectively. Despite the common evolutionary origin of F1F0-ATP synthases, the set of auxiliary factors required for their assembly in bacteria, mitochondria and chloroplasts shows clear signs of evolutionary divergence. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Chloroplast Biogenesis.

ATP-induced dimerization of the F0F1 ε subunit from Bacillus PS3: a hydrogen exchange-mass spectrometry study

F0F1 ATP synthase harnesses a transmembrane electrochemical gradient for the production of ATP. When operated in reverse, this multiprotein complex catalyzes ATP hydrolysis. In bacteria, the ε subunit is involved in regulating this ATPase activity. Also, ε is essential for coupling ATP hydrolysis (or synthesis) to proton translocation. The ε subunit consists of a β sandwich and two C-terminal helices, α1 and α2. The protein can switch from a compact fold to an alternate conformation where α1 and α2 are separated, resulting in an extended structure. ε from the thermophile Bacillus PS3 (Tε) binds ATP with high affinity such that this protein may function as an intracellular ATP level sensor. ATP binding to isolated Tε triggers a major conformational transition. Earlier data were interpreted in terms of an ATP + Tεextended → ATP·Tεcompact transition that may mimic aspects of the regulatory switching within F0F1 (Yagi et al. (2007) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 104, 11233–11238). In this work, we employ complementary biophysical techniques for examining the ATP-induced conformational switching of isolated Tε. CD spectroscopy confirmed the occurrence of a large-scale conformational transition upon ATP binding, consistent with the formation of stable helical structure. Hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) mass spectrometry revealed that this transition is accompanied by a pronounced stabilization in the vicinity of the ATP-binding pocket. Surprisingly, dramatic stabilization is also seen in the β8−β9 region, which is remote from the site of ATP interaction. Analytical ultracentrifugation uncovered a previously unrecognized feature of Tε: a high propensity to undergo dimerization in the presence of ATP. Comparison with existing crystallography data strongly suggests that the unexpected β8−β9 HDX protection is due to newly formed protein–protein contacts. Hence, ATP binding to isolated Tε proceeds according to 2ATP + 2Tεextended → (ATP·Tεcompact)2. Implications of this dimerization propensity for the possible role of Tε as an antibiotic target are discussed.

ATP synthase in mycobacteria: special features and implications for a function as drug target

ATP synthase is a ubiquitous enzyme that is largely conserved across the kingdoms of life. This conservation is in accordance with its central role in chemiosmotic energy conversion, a pathway utilized by far by most living cells. On the other hand, in particular pathogenic bacteria whilst employing ATP synthase have to deal with energetically unfavorable conditions such as low oxygen tensions in the human host, e.g. Mycobacterium tuberculosis can survive in human macrophages for an extended time. It is well conceivable that such ATP synthases may carry idiosyncratic features that contribute to efficient ATP production. In this review genetic and biochemical data on mycobacterial ATP synthase are discussed in terms of rotary catalysis, stator composition, and regulation of activity. ATP synthase in mycobacteria is of particular interest as this enzyme has been validated as a target for promising new antibacterial drugs. A deeper understanding of the working of mycobacterial ATP synthase and its atypical features can provide insight in adaptations of bacterial energy metabolism. Moreover, pinpointing and understanding critical differences as compared with human ATP synthase may provide input for the design and development of selective ATP synthase inhibitors as antibacterials. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: 18th European Bioenergetic Conference.

The ydaO motif is an ATP-sensing riboswitch in Bacillus subtilis

We report what is to our knowledge the first natural RNA that regulates gene expression in response to intracellular ATP. Using a biochemical screen, we found that several putative riboswitches bind ATP in vitro. The ydaO motif specifically bound ATP and regulated expression of endogenous and reporter genes in response to ATP concentrations in Bacillus subtilis. This discovery demonstrates a role for RNAs in regulating gene expression in response to energy balance in bacteria.

ATP binding to the ϵ subunit of thermophilic ATP synthase is crucial for efficient coupling of ATPase and H+ pump activities

ATP binding to the ϵ subunit of F1-ATPase, a soluble subcomplex of TFoF1 (FoF1-ATPase synthase from the thermophilic Bacillus strain PS3), affects the regulation of F1-ATPase activity by stabilizing the compact, ATPase-active, form of the ϵ subunit [Kato, S., Yoshida, M. and Kato-Yamada, Y. (2007) J. Biol. Chem. 282, 37618-37623]. In the present study, we report how ATP binding to the ϵ subunit affects ATPase and H+ pumping activities in the holoenzyme TFoF1. Wild-type TFoF1 showed significant H+ pumping activity when ATP was used as the substrate. However, GTP, which bound poorly to the ϵ subunit, did not support efficient H+ pumping. Addition of small amounts of ATP to the GTP substrate restored coupling between GTPase and H+ pumping activities. Similar uncoupling was observed when TFoF1 contained an ATP-binding-deficient ϵ subunit, even with ATP as a substrate. Further analysis suggested that the compact conformation of the ϵ subunit induced by ATP binding was required to couple ATPase and H+ pumping activities in TFoF1 unless the ϵ subunit was in its extended-state conformation. The present study reveals a novel role of the ϵ subunit as an ATP-sensitive regulator of the coupling of ATPase and H+ pumping activities of TFoF1.

The regulatory C-terminal domain of subunit ε of F₀F₁ ATP synthase is dispensable for growth and survival of Escherichia coli

The C-terminal domain of subunit ε of the bacterial F₀F₁ ATP synthase is reported to be an intrinsic inhibitor of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis activity in vitro, preventing wasteful hydrolysis of ATP under low-energy conditions. Mutants defective in this regulatory domain exhibited no significant difference in growth rate, molar growth yield, membrane potential, or intracellular ATP concentration under a wide range of growth conditions and stressors compared to wild-type cells, suggesting this inhibitory domain is dispensable for growth and survival of Escherichia coli.

Structural and functional analysis of the intrinsic inhibitor subunit epsilon of F1-ATPase from photosynthetic organisms

The epsilon subunit, a small subunit located in the F1 domain of ATP synthase and comprising two distinct domains, an N-terminal beta-sandwich structure and a C-terminal alpha-helical region, serves as an intrinsic inhibitor of ATP hydrolysis activity. This inhibitory function is especially important in photosynthetic organisms as the enzyme cannot synthesize ATP in the dark, but may catalyse futile ATP hydrolysis reactions. To understand the structure-function relationship of this subunit in F1 from photosynthetic organisms, we solved the NMR structure of the epsilon subunit of ATP synthase obtained from the thermophilic cyanobacterium Thermosynechococcus elongatus BP-1, and examined the flexibility of the C-terminal domains using molecular dynamics simulations. In addition, we revealed the significance of the C-terminal alpha-helical region of the epsilon subunit in determining the binding affinity to the complex based on the assessment of the inhibition of ATPase activity by the cyanobacterial epsilon subunit and the chimaeric subunits composed of the N-terminal domain from the cyanobacterium and the C-terminal domain from spinach. The differences observed in the structural and biochemical properties of chloroplast and bacterial epsilon subunits explains the distinctive characteristics of the epsilon subunits in the ATPase complex of the photosynthetic organism.

Visualization of ATP levels inside single living cells with fluorescence resonance energy transfer-based genetically encoded indicators

Adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) is the major energy currency of cells and is involved in many cellular processes. However, there is no method for real-time monitoring of ATP levels inside individual living cells. To visualize ATP levels, we generated a series of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based indicators for ATP that were composed of the epsilon subunit of the bacterial F(o)F(1)-ATP synthase sandwiched by the cyan- and yellow-fluorescent proteins. The indicators, named ATeams, had apparent dissociation constants for ATP ranging from 7.4 muM to 3.3 mM. By targeting ATeams to different subcellular compartments, we unexpectedly found that ATP levels in the mitochondrial matrix of HeLa cells are significantly lower than those of cytoplasm and nucleus. We also succeeded in measuring changes in the ATP level inside single HeLa cells after treatment with inhibitors of glycolysis and/or oxidative phosphorylation, revealing that glycolysis is the major ATP-generating pathway of the cells grown in glucose-rich medium. This was also confirmed by an experiment using oligomycin A, an inhibitor of F(o)F(1)-ATP synthase. In addition, it was demonstrated that HeLa cells change ATP-generating pathway in response to changes of nutrition in the environment.

Regulation of the F1F0-ATP synthase rotary nanomotor in its monomeric-bacterial and dimeric-mitochondrial forms

The F(1)F(0)-adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthase rotational motor synthesizes most of the ATP required for living from adenosine diphosphate, Pi, and a proton electrochemical gradient across energy-transducing membranes of bacteria, chloroplasts, and mitochondria. However, as a reversible nanomotor, it also hydrolyzes ATP during de-energized conditions in all energy-transducing systems. Thus, different subunits and mechanisms have emerged in nature to control the intrinsic rotation of the enzyme to favor the ATP synthase activity over its opposite and commonly wasteful ATPase turnover. Recent advances in the structural analysis of the bacterial and mitochondrial ATP synthases are summarized to review the distribution and mechanism of the subunits that are part of the central rotor and regulate its gyration. In eubacteria, the epsilon subunit works as a ratchet to favor the rotation of the central stalk in the ATP synthase direction by extending and contracting two alpha-helixes of its C-terminal side and also by binding ATP with low affinity in thermophilic bacteria. On the other hand, in bovine heart mitochondria, the so-called inhibitor protein (IF(1)) interferes with the intrinsic rotational mechanism of the central gamma subunit and with the opening and closing of the catalytic beta-subunits to inhibit its ATPase activity. Besides its inhibitory role, the IF(1) protein also promotes the dimerization of the bovine and rat mitochondrial enzymes, albeit it is not essential for dimerization of the yeast F(1)F(0) mitochondrial complex. High-resolution electron microscopy of the dimeric enzyme in its bovine and yeast forms shows a conical shape that is compatible with the role of the ATP synthase dimer in the formation of tubular the cristae membrane of mitochondria after further oligomerization. Dimerization of the mitochondrial ATP synthase diminishes the rotational drag of the central rotor that would decrease the coupling efficiency between rotation of the central stalk and ATP synthesis taking place at the F(1) portion. In addition, F(1)F(0) dimerization and its further oligomerization also increase the stability of the enzyme to natural or experimentally induced destabilizing conditions.

Regulatory mechanisms of proton-translocating F(O)F (1)-ATP synthase

H(+)-F(O)F(1)-ATP synthase catalyzes synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate using the energy of transmembrane electrochemical potential difference of proton (deltamu(H)(+). The enzyme can also generate this potential difference by working as an ATP-driven proton pump. Several regulatory mechanisms are known to suppress the ATPase activity of F(O)F(1): 1. Non-competitive inhibition by MgADP, a feature shared by F(O)F(1) from bacteria, chloroplasts and mitochondria 2. Inhibition by subunit epsilon in chloroplast and bacterial enzyme 3. Inhibition upon oxidation of two cysteines in subunit gamma in chloroplast F(O)F(1) 4. Inhibition by an additional regulatory protein (IF(1)) in mitochondrial enzyme In this review we summarize the information available on these regulatory mechanisms and discuss possible interplay between them.

Role of the epsilon subunit of thermophilic F1-ATPase as a sensor for ATP

The epsilon subunit of F(1)-ATPase from the thermophilic Bacillus PS3 (TF(1)) has been shown to bind ATP. The precise nature of the regulatory role of ATP binding to the epsilon subunit remains to be determined. To address this question, 11 mutants of the epsilon subunit were prepared, in which one of the basic or acidic residues was substituted with alanine. ATP binding to these mutants was tested by gel-filtration chromatography. Among them, four mutants that showed no ATP binding were selected and reconstituted with the alpha(3)beta(3)gamma complex of TF(1). The ATPase activity of the resulting alpha(3)beta(3)gammaepsilon complexes was measured, and the extent of inhibition by the mutant epsilon subunits was compared in each case. With one exception, weaker binding of ATP correlated with greater inhibition of ATPase activity. These results clearly indicate that ATP binding to the epsilon subunit plays a regulatory role and that ATP binding may stabilize the ATPase-active form of TF(1) by fixing the epsilon subunit into the folded conformation.

Structures of the thermophilic F1-ATPase epsilon subunit suggesting ATP-regulated arm motion of its C-terminal domain in F1

The epsilon subunit of bacterial and chloroplast F(o)F(1)-ATP synthases modulates their ATP hydrolysis activity. Here, we report the crystal structure of the ATP-bound epsilon subunit from a thermophilic Bacillus PS3 at 1.9-A resolution. The C-terminal two alpha-helices were folded into a hairpin, sitting on the beta sandwich structure, as reported for Escherichia coli. A previously undescribed ATP binding motif, I(L)DXXRA, recognizes ATP together with three arginine and one glutamate residues. The E. coli epsilon subunit binds ATP in a similar manner, as judged on NMR. We also determined solution structures of the C-terminal domain of the PS3 epsilon subunit and relaxation parameters of the whole molecule by NMR. The two helices fold into a hairpin in the presence of ATP but extend in the absence of ATP. The latter structure has more helical regions and is much more flexible than the former. These results suggest that the epsilon C-terminal domain can undergo an arm-like motion in response to an ATP concentration change and thereby contribute to regulation of F(o)F(1)-ATP synthase.

Interactions of rotor subunits in the chloroplast ATP synthase modulated by nucleotides and by Mg2+

ATP synthases - rotary nano machines - consist of two major parts, F(O) and F(1), connected by two stalks: the central and the peripheral stalk. In spinach chloroplasts, the central stalk (subunits gamma, epsilon) forms with the cylinder of subunits III the rotor and transmits proton motive force from F(O) to F(1), inducing conformational changes of the catalytic centers in F(1). The epsilon subunit is an important regulator affecting adjacent subunits as well as the activity of the whole protein complex. Using a combination of chemical cross-linking and mass spectrometry, we monitored interactions of subunit epsilon in spinach chloroplast ATP synthase with III and gamma. Onto identification of interacting residues in subunits epsilon and III, one cross-link defined the distance between epsilon-Cys6 and III-Lys48 to be 9.4 A at minimum. epsilon-Cys6 was competitively cross-linked with subunit gamma. Altered cross-linking yields revealed the impact of nucleotides and Mg(2+) on cross-linking of subunit epsilon. The presence of nucleotides apparently induced a displacement of the N-terminus of subunit epsilon, which separated epsilon-Cys6 from both, III-Lys48 and subunit gamma, and thus decreasing the yield of the cross-linked subunits epsilon and gamma as well as epsilon and III. However, increasing concentrations of the cofactor Mg(2+) favoured cross-linking of epsilon-Cys6 with subunit gamma instead of III-Lys48 indicating an approximation of subunits gamma and epsilon and a separation from III-Lys48.

Regulatory interplay between proton motive force, ADP, phosphate, and subunit epsilon in bacterial ATP synthase

ATP synthase couples transmembrane proton transport, driven by the proton motive force (pmf), to the synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate (P(i)). In certain bacteria, the reaction is reversed and the enzyme generates pmf, working as a proton-pumping ATPase. The ATPase activity of bacterial enzymes is prone to inhibition by both ADP and the C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon. We studied the effects of ADP, P(i), pmf, and the C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon on the ATPase activity of thermophilic Bacillus PS3 and Escherichia coli ATP synthases. We found that pmf relieved ADP inhibition during steady-state ATP hydrolysis, but only in the presence of P(i). The C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon in the Bacillus PS3 enzyme enhanced ADP inhibition by counteracting the effects of pmf. It appears that these features allow the enzyme to promptly respond to changes in the ATP:ADP ratio and in pmf levels in order to avoid potentially wasteful ATP hydrolysis in vivo.

The regulator of the F1 motor: inhibition of rotation of cyanobacterial F1-ATPase by the epsilon subunit

The chloroplast-type F(1) ATPase is the key enzyme of energy conversion in chloroplasts, and is regulated by the endogenous inhibitor epsilon, tightly bound ADP, the membrane potential and the redox state of the gamma subunit. In order to understand the molecular mechanism of epsilon inhibition, we constructed an expression system for the alpha(3)beta(3)gamma subcomplex in thermophilic cyanobacteria allowing thorough investigation of epsilon inhibition. epsilon Inhibition was found to be ATP-independent, and different to that observed for bacterial F(1)-ATPase. The role of the additional region on the gamma subunit of chloroplast-type F(1)-ATPase in epsilon inhibition was also determined. By single molecule rotation analysis, we succeeded in assigning the pausing angular position of gamma in epsilon inhibition, which was found to be identical to that observed for ATP hydrolysis, product release and ADP inhibition, but distinctly different from the waiting position for ATP binding. These results suggest that the epsilon subunit of chloroplast-type ATP synthase plays an important regulator for the rotary motor enzyme, thus preventing wasteful ATP hydrolysis.

gammaepsilon Sub-complex of thermophilic ATP synthase has the ability to bind ATP

The isolated epsilon subunit of F(1)-ATPase from thermophilic Bacillus PS3 (TF(1)) binds ATP [Y. Kato-Yamada, M. Yoshida, J. Biol. Chem. 278 (2003) 36013]. The obvious question is whether the ATP binding concern with the regulation of ATP synthase activity or not. If so, the epsilon subunit even in the ATP synthase complex should have the ability to bind ATP. To check if the ATP binding to the epsilon subunit within the ATP synthase complex may occur, the gammaepsilon sub-complex of TF(1) was prepared and ATP binding was examined. The results clearly showed that the gammaepsilon sub-complex can bind ATP.

The role of subunit epsilon in the catalysis and regulation of FOF1-ATP synthase

The regulation of ATP synthase activity is complex and involves several distinct mechanisms. In bacteria and chloroplasts, subunit epsilon plays an important role in this regulation, (i) affecting the efficiency of coupling, (ii) influencing the catalytic pathway, and (iii) selectively inhibiting ATP hydrolysis activity. Several experimental studies indicate that the regulation is achieved through large conformational transitions of the alpha-helical C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon that occur in response to membrane energization, change in ATP/ADP ratio or addition of inhibitors. This review summarizes the experimental data obtained on different organisms that clarify some basic features as well as some molecular details of this regulatory mechanism. Multiple functions of subunit epsilon, its role in the difference between the catalytic pathways of ATP synthesis and hydrolysis and its influence on the inhibition of ATP hydrolysis by ADP are also discussed.