Characterization of the nanoscale structure of milk fat

Multiscale analysis of triglycerides using X-ray scattering: implementing a shape-dependent model for CNP characterization

In the last decade, research has focused on examining the fundamental interactions occurring in triglycerides, aiming to comprehend the self-assembly of crystalline nanoplatelets (CNPs) and their role in forming larger hierarchical structures essential for fat functionality. Microscopy research on CNPs frequently requires disruptive preparatory techniques, such as deoiling and sonication, to achieve quantitative outcomes. Conversely, X-ray scattering has proven to be an advantageous method for studying triglycerides, as little sample is needed to quantify the system's hierarchical structures. Specifically, ultra-small-angle X-ray scattering (USAXS) has emerged as a fitting technique for studying CNPs, owing to its length scale range falling between 25 nm and 3.49 μm. In this study, we characterized four different 30% fat dilutions of stearic acid-based fats in triolein, with various purities and preparation protocols. Samples were characterized by combining diverse microscopy techniques (cryo-SEM, TEM, polarized light and phase contrast microscopy) with synchrotron-radiation X-ray scattering (WAXS, SAXS, and USAXS). A shape-dependent model for the interpretation of USAXS data is proposed, overcoming some of the drawbacks linked to previously utilized models. CNPs are modeled as polydisperse parallelepipeds, and the aggregates are characterized by fractal dimensionality. This model offers novel insights into CNP cross-section, as well as aggregation. In the long run, we hope that the model will increase our understanding of CNP conformation and interactions, helping us design new fat systems on the mesoscale.

Crystal networks, partial coalescence, and rheological properties of milk fat fraction model systems

This study aimed to investigate the crystal network of bulk milk fat fractions and the partial coalescence, and the rheological properties of their oil-in-water (O/W) emulsions. Different milk fat fraction model systems were compared for their physicochemical properties, crystallization kinetics, and fat crystal networks across a range of temperatures. The extent of partial coalescence and rheological properties of the O/W emulsion prepared by different milk fat fractions were further analyzed. The results demonstrated that the ratio between saturated fatty acids (SFA) and unsaturated fatty acids and triacylglycerides (TAG) influenced the melting thermal behaviors, solid fat contents (SFC), and crystal networks of various milk fat fractions, which in turn influenced the partial coalescence and rheological characteristics of their O/W emulsions. Moreover, an excellent fit of the trend line confirmed that hardness increased exponentially with SFC. Trisaturated TAG in fractions with high melting points (HMF) such as milk fat fraction MF45, whose clarification temperature was 45°C, enriched long-chain SFA (saturated:unsaturated fatty acid = 2.2:1). We found that MF45 achieved higher SFC and hardness in the range of 0 to 40°C and, ultimately, formed a well-defined microstructural network with thick, rod-like crystals. Further, TAG in fractions with low melting points (LMF) such as MF10, whose clarification temperature was 10°C, were enriched with short-chain and unsaturated fatty acids (saturated:unsaturated fatty acid = 1.5:1), and a disordered crystal network in MF10, composed of randomly arranged, translucent platelets, was detected. Although fat globules of HMF and LMF were stabilized against coalescence, this could be attributed to a variety of mechanisms involving SFC, liquid fat, protective film around the fat globule, and minor lipids. According to the rheological profiles, all O/W emulsions exhibited weak viscoelastic "gel-like" structures [storage modulus (G') > loss modulus (G")] over most of the measured range. The G' values and apparent viscosity of HMF were greater than those of other fractions, indicating that the large and rigid crystals strengthen the networks more effectively.

Application of small angle scattering (SAS) in structural characterisation of casein and casein-based products during digestion

In recent years, small and ultra-small angle scattering techniques, collectively known as small angle scattering (SAS) have been used to study various food structures during the digestion process. These techniques play an important role in structural characterisation due to the non-destructive nature (especially when using neutrons), various in situ capabilities and a large length scale (of 1 nm to ∼20 μm) they cover. The application of these techniques in the structural characterisation of dairy products has expanded significantly in recent years. Casein, a major dairy protein, forms the basis of a wide range of gel structures at different length scales. These gel structures have been extensively researched utilising scattering techniques to obtain structural information at the nano and micron scale that complements electron and confocal microscopy. Especially, neutrons have provided opportunity to study these gels in their natural environment by using various in situ options. One such example is understanding changes in casein gel structures during digestion in the gastrointestinal tract, which is essential for designing personalised food structures for a wide range of food-related diseases and improve health outcomes. In this review, we present an overview of casein gels investigated using small angle and ultra-small angle scattering techniques. We also reviewed their digestion using newly built setups recently employed in various research. To gain a greater understanding of micro and nano-scale structural changes during digestion, such as the effect of digestive juices and mechanical breakdown on structure, new setups for semi-solid food materials are needed to be optimised.

Network Structure and Nanoplatelet Characterization of the Edible Fat Crystallization in Low-Fat W/O Emulsions

Fat crystals provided the strength of the colloidal network in W/O emulsions and stabilized water droplets. To understand the stabilizing effect of fat-regulated emulsions, W/O emulsions with different edible fats were fabricated. The result indicated that more stable W/O emulsions were produced by palm oil (PO) and palm stearin (PS), whose proportions of fatty acids were similar. Meanwhile, water droplets inhibited the crystallization of emulsified fats but participated in the formation of the colloidal network with fat crystals in emulsions, and the Avrami equation showed a slower crystallization rate of emulsified fats than the corresponding fat blends. However, water droplets participated in the formation of a colloidal network of fat crystals in emulsions, and the adjacent fat crystals were connected through a bridge constructed by water droplets. Fats in the emulsion containing palm stearin crystallized faster and more easily formed the β-polymorph. The small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) data were interpreted by the unified fit model to determine the average size of crystalline nanoplatelets (CNPs). The larger CNPs (>100 nm) with a rough surface of emulsified fats and a uniform distribution of their aggregates was confirmed.

Multiple phase transitions and microstructural rearrangements shape milk fat crystal networks

HYPOTHESIS

The rheology of milk fat, which is strongly related to its functionality, reflects multiscale structural transitions in the colloidal network formed by crystallizing triacylglycerols.

EXPERIMENTS

To relate rheology to structure, early stages of milk fat crystallization at 15-22 °C were studied combining different techniques; XRD and microscopy to study structural changes, NMR to quantify the different structures, and rheology to evaluate their effect on macroscopic properties.

FINDINGS

Network strength increased with the synchronized formation of micro- and nanostructures. A rheological response was only obtained when these structures became visibly connected on a microscale, and internal transitional changes could be detected with rheology. On the nanoscale, transitions were linked to the formation of specific crystal polymorphs. We quantified the formation of polymorphs commonly found in milk fat (α-2 and β₁^'-2) and of two less commonly obtained polymorphs: β-2 and β₂^'-2. For the first time, the formation of these polymorphs was quantified and related to the composition of fat. Besides providing insights into the complex phase behavior of milk fat, this study shows that the structural transitions involved can be characterized and quantified by combining XRD with NMR and be detected at an early stage using rheology and microscopy.

Isothermal crystallization of anhydrous milk fat in presence of free fatty acids and their esters: From nanostructure to textural properties

We performed a multiscale study to understand the impact of pure exogenous compounds at low concentration on the crystallization of triacylglycerols (TAGs) in anhydrous milk fat (AMF). We selected butyric acid, an inhibitor of crystallization, and palmitic acid, a promotor, to investigate the influence of the chain length. Tripalmitin was also used as a promotor to assess the impact of fatty acid esterification. Melted blends containing the additives (1 wt%) were quenched at 25 °C. X-ray scattering data showed that AMF TAGs crystallized directly in the β'-2L form. The presence of additives did not modify the nanostructure of TAG crystals. However, they significantly altered the microstructure of AMF, as revealed by polarized light microscopy and rheology. This study emphasizes the interest of a multiscale approach to gain knowledge about the behavior of complex fat blends and of the use of modulators at low concentration to monitor their textural properties.

Structural characterization of nanoemulsions stabilized with sodium caseinate and of the hydrogels prepared from them by acid-induced gelation

Hydrogels obtained by acidification with glucono-δ-lactone (GDL), starting from nanoemulsions formulated with different concentrations of sodium caseinate (1-4 wt%) or 4 wt% sodium caseinate and sucrose (2-8 wt%), were prepared with the aim of quantifying structural parameters of both, initial nanoemulsions and hydrogels after 2.5 h of GDL addition, using the Guinier-Porod (GP) or the generalized GP models. Gelation process was followed by performing in situ temperature-controlled X-ray small angle scattering experiments (SAXS) using synchrotron radiation. In nanoemulsions, the calculated radius of gyration for oil nanodroplets (Rg _oil ) decreased with increasing protein concentration and for the 4 wt% protein nanoemulsion, with increasing sucrose content. Calculated values of Rg _oil were validated correlating them with experimental Z-average values as measured by dynamic light scattering (DLS). For hydrogels, radii of gyration for the sphere equivalent to the hydrogel scattering object (R _gsph ) were close to 3 nm while correlation distances among building blocks (R _g2 ) were dependent on formulation. They increased with increasing contents of sodium caseinate and sucrose. R _g2 parameter linearly correlated with hydrogel strength (G' _∞ ): a more connected nanostructure led to a stronger hydrogel.

Milk fat crystal network as a strategy for delivering vegetable oils high in omega-9, -6, and -3 fatty acids

As an alternative to the strategies currently used to deliver unsaturated fatty acids, especially, the essentials omega-6 and 3- fatty acids, the aim of this work was to investigate the effect of the incorporation of 25 e 50% (w/w) of olive, corn and linseed oil into the crystal structure of anhydrous milk fat (AMF). Fatty acid composition, atherogenicity (AI), and thrombogenicity (TI) index, crystallization kinetics, polymorphism by Rietveld method (RM), microstructure, thermal behavior, solid fat content, and lipid compatibility was evaluated. The addition of vegetable oils reduced the saturated fatty acids, and the AI and TI indices of AMF, and increased the concentration of unsaturated, specifically omega-6 and -3 fatty acids. Although vegetable oils caused changes in nucleation and crystallization kinetics, the spherulitic and crystalline morphology and the β' polymorphism of AMF were maintained. The study demonstrated the possibility of using the crystal structure of AMF as a vehicle for unsaturated fatty acids in food formulations, as an alternative to nutritional supplementation. In addition, studies on the use of RM in blends made with AMF and vegetable oil have not been found in literature, thus demonstrating the relevance of the present study.

Fractionation and characterisation of hard milk fat crystals using atomic force microscopy

The hard milk fat (HMF) fraction of milk fat was isolated via dry, thermal fractionation, followed by a solvent washing process. The resulting HMF crystals were visibly free of entrapped liquid fat, and subsequently characterised by thermal analysis, X-ray diffraction, and electron microscopy. The HMF crystals were found to be mostly β' and β'₂ crystalline structures, with a lamellar thickness of 42.7-44.1 Å. Additionally, crystal size was determined to be ≥1 μm in length and 0.4-1 μm in width. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) was used to further characterise the HMF crystals. AFM enabled 3D mapping and visualisation of crystal layering, as well as simple determination of layer thickness (∼4.2 ± 0.8 nm); a value in close agreement with the results obtained via X-ray analysis. The AFM characterisation approach provides a simple method of characterising HMF crystals, without suffering the limitations of other widely used techniques.

Development of combined microstructure and structure characterization facility for in situ and operando studies at the Advanced Photon Source

Following many years of evolutionary development, first at the National Synchrotron Light Source, Brookhaven National Laboratory, and then at the Advanced Photon Source (APS), Argonne National Laboratory, the APS ultrasmall-angle X-ray scattering (USAXS) facility has been transformed by several new developments. These comprise a conversion to higher-order crystal optics and higher X-ray energies as the standard operating mode, rapid fly scan measurements also as a standard operational mode, automated contiguous pinhole small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) measurements at intermediate scattering vectors, and associated rapid wide-angle X-ray scattering (WAXS) measurements for X-ray diffraction without disturbing the sample geometry. With each mode using the USAXS incident beam optics upstream of the sample, USAXS/SAXS/WAXS measurements can now be made within 5 min, allowing in situ and operando measurement capabilities with great flexibility under a wide range of sample conditions. These developments are described, together with examples of their application to investigate materials phenomena of technological importance. Developments of two novel USAXS applications, USAXSbased X-ray photon correlation spectroscopy and USAXS imaging, are also briefly reviewed.

Networks of micronized fat crystals grown under static conditions

Dispersions of micronized fat crystals (MFCs) in oil form a weak-interaction network organized by crystal aggregates in a continuous net of crystalline nanoplatelets.

Insights into the mechanism of the formation of the most stable crystal polymorph of milk fat in model protein matrices

The effect of incorporation and presence of various ingredients in a model sodium caseinate-based imitation cheese matrix on the polymorphism of milk fat was comprehensively described using powder x-ray diffraction, differential scanning calorimetry, and microscopy. With anhydrous milk fat (AMF) in bulk used as control, the embedding of AMF as droplets in a protein matrix was found to result in a greater extent of formation of the β polymorph than AMF alone and AMF homogenized with water and salts solution. The use of other protein matrices such as soy and whey protein isolate gels revealed that the nature of the protein and other factors associated with it (i.e., hydrophobicity and molecular structure) do not seem to play a role in the formation of the β polymorph. These results indicated that the most important factor in the formation of the β polymorph is the physical constraints imposed by a solid protein matrix, which forces the triacylglycerols in milk fat to arrange themselves in the most stable crystal polymorph. Characterization of the crystal structure of milk fat or fats in general within a food matrix could provide insights into the complex thermal and rheological behavior of foods with added fats.

Characterization of zein assemblies by ultra-small-angle X-ray scattering

Zein, a major corn protein, has an amphiphilic molecule capable of self-assembling into distinctly different structures, i.e., rods, sheets, and spheres. In this work, ultra-small-angle X-ray scattering (USAXS) was applied to investigate the formation of self-assembled zein structures in binary solvent systems of ethanol and water. The study included observing structural changes due to aging. Three distinctive regions, each corresponding to different co-existing structures having a hierarchical organization, were observed in zein-solvent systems. Rod shaped (R_g = 1.5-2.5 nm, P = 1) primary structural units were identified, believed to be molecular zein. Two-dimensional sheet-like structures (R_g = 80-200 nm, 2 < P < 3) were observed, believed to be formed by primary units first assembled into one-dimensional fibers and then into 2D sheet structures. Also, large three-dimensional spherical aggregates were observed (R_g > 1000 nm, P = 4), believed to have assembled from two-dimensional sheet structures. Aging did not change the size or the shape of the primary units, but USAXS detected changes in R_g and P values of the intermediate structures, pointing to a further level of self-assembly where proteins develop a more regular and organized structure. The viscoelastic moduli (G' and G''), the consistency index (K) and the flow behavior index (n), were also measured to investigate the effect of zein structural development by self-assembly on rheological behavior. Samples became more solid-like with aging. Raman spectra suggested that zein underwent secondary structure transformations from α-helix to β-sheets, which influenced the size and morphology of molecular assemblies and ultimately the rheological properties of zein solutions.