Stabilization of herring (Clupea harengus) by-products against lipid oxidation by rinsing and incubation with antioxidant solutions

Lipid Peroxidation in Muscle Foods: Impact on Quality, Safety and Human Health

The issue of lipid changes in muscle foods under the action of atmospheric oxygen has captured the attention of researchers for over a century. Lipid oxidative processes initiate during the slaughtering of animals and persist throughout subsequent technological processing and storage of the finished product. The oxidation of lipids in muscle foods is a phenomenon extensively deliberated in the scientific community, acknowledged as one of the pivotal factors affecting their quality, safety, and human health. This review delves into the nature of lipid oxidation in muscle foods, highlighting mechanisms of free radical initiation and the propagation of oxidative processes. Special attention is given to the natural antioxidant protective system and dietary factors influencing the stability of muscle lipids. The review traces mechanisms inhibiting oxidative processes, exploring how changes in lipid oxidative substrates, prooxidant activity, and the antioxidant protective system play a role. A critical review of the oxidative stability and safety of meat products is provided. The impact of oxidative processes on the quality of muscle foods, including flavour, aroma, taste, colour, and texture, is scrutinised. Additionally, the review monitors the effect of oxidised muscle foods on human health, particularly in relation to the autooxidation of cholesterol. Associations with coronary cardiovascular disease, brain stroke, and carcinogenesis linked to oxidative stress, and various infections are discussed. Further studies are also needed to formulate appropriate technological solutions to reduce the risk of chemical hazards caused by the initiation and development of lipid peroxidation processes in muscle foods.

Protein Hydrolysates from Fishery Processing By-Products: Production, Characteristics, Food Applications, and Challenges

Fish processing by-products such as frames, trimmings, and viscera of commercial fish species are rich in proteins. Thus, they could potentially be an economical source of proteins that may be used to obtain bioactive peptides and functional protein hydrolysates for the food and nutraceutical industries. The structure, composition, and biological activities of peptides and hydrolysates depend on the freshness and the actual composition of the material. Peptides isolated from fishery by-products showed antioxidant activity. Changes in hydrolysis parameters changed the sequence and properties of the peptides and determined their physiological functions. The optimization of the value of such peptides and the production costs must be considered for each particular source of marine by-products and for their specific food applications. This review will discuss the functional properties of fishery by-products prepared using hydrolysis and their potential food applications. It also reviews the structure-activity relationships of the antioxidant activity of peptides as well as challenges to the use of fishery by-products for protein hydrolysate production.

Oxidative Stability of Side-Streams from Cod Filleting-Effect of Antioxidant Dipping and Low-Temperature Storage

Currently, side-streams (e.g., head, backbone, tail, and intestines) generated in the fish processing industry often end up as low-value products for feed applications or even as waste. In order to upcycle such side-streams, they need to be preserved to avoid oxidative degradation of the lipids between the generation point and the valorization plant. In the cod filleting industry, three main solid side-streams: viscera, heads, and backbones, are obtained. Hence, this study aimed to identify the most efficient antioxidant for preserving the cod side-streams using a dipping-based strategy prior to pre-valorization storage at low temperatures (ice and frozen storage). The dipping solutions evaluated contained: (i) a lipophilic rosemary extract (0.05% and 0.2% in 0.9% NaCl), (ii) Duralox MANC (a mixture of rosemary extract, ascorbic acid, tocopherols, and citric acid; 2% in 0.9% NaCl), and (iii) NaCl (0.9%) w/w solution. One group was not dipped. No dipping and dipping in NaCl were included as controls. The results showed a positive effect of dipping with solutions containing antioxidants as measured by peroxide value (PV), TBA-reactive substances (TBARS), and sensory profiling, e.g., rancid odor. Moreover, the oxidative stability increased with decreased storage temperature. The cod side-streams were in general most efficiently preserved by Duralox MANC, followed by the lipophilic rosemary extract (0.2%), compared to no dipping and dipping in NaCl solution and the lower concentration of the lipophilic rosemary extract (0.05%). The efficiency of the antioxidant treatments was independent of the side-stream fraction and storage temperature. Thus, using antioxidant dipping combined with low temperature storage is an efficient preservation method for maintaining the quality of the lipids in cod solid side-streams during their pre-valorization storage.

Pilot-Scale Antioxidant Dipping of Herring (Clupea harengus) Co-products to Allow Their Upgrading to a High-Quality Mince for Food Production

To enable production of high-quality mince from herring backbones, a scalable antioxidant strategy is needed due to the high susceptibility of herring muscle to lipid oxidation. We here measured the stabilizing effect of lab-/pilot-scale predipping of herring backbones (30-500 kg) in antioxidant solutions prior to production of mechanically separated mince (MSM). The antioxidants were (i) Duralox MANC, a mixture of rosemary extract, ascorbic acid, α-tocopherol, and citric acid, and (ii) rosemary extract with or without isoascorbic acid. Delivery of the key rosemary-derived antioxidant components carnosol and carnosic acid was monitored during the dipping process and ice/frozen storage. Predipping in 2% Duralox MANC gave MSM with 26.7-31.7 mg/kg carnosol + carnosic acid and extended the oxidation lag phase from <1 to 12 days during ice storage and from <1 to 6 months during frozen storage compared to control. Dipping in 0.2% rosemary extract with or without 0.5% isoascorbic acid solution gave MSM with 20.6-28.2 mg/kg carnosol + carnosic acid and extended the lag phase to 6 days and 9 months during ice and frozen storage, respectively. Our results confirmed, in pilot scale, that predipping herring coproducts in antioxidant solutions is a promising strategy to utilize these raw materials for, e.g., mince and burger production rather than for low value products as fish meal.

Inhibitory mechanisms of polyphenols on heme protein-mediated lipid oxidation in muscle food: New insights and advances

Lipid oxidation is a major cause of quality deterioration that decreases the shelf-life of muscle-based foods (red meat, poultry, and fish), in which heme proteins, particularly hemoglobin and myoglobin, are the primary pro-oxidants. Due to increasing consumer concerns over synthetic chemicals, extensive research has been carried out on natural antioxidants, especially plant polyphenols. The conventional opinion suggests that polyphenols inhibit lipid oxidation of muscle foods primarily owing to their strong hydrogen-donating and transition metal-chelating activities. Recent developments in analytical techniques (e.g., protein crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, fluorescence anisotropy, and molecular docking simulation) allow deeper understanding of the molecular interaction of polyphenols with heme proteins, phospholipid membrane, reactive oxygen species, and reactive carbonyl species; hence, novel hypotheses regarding their antioxidant mechanisms have been formulated. In this review, we summarize five direct and three indirect pathways by which polyphenols inhibit heme protein-mediated lipid oxidation in muscle foods. We also discuss the relation between chemical structures and functions of polyphenols as antioxidants.

Five cuts from herring (Clupea harengus): Comparison of nutritional and chemical composition between co-product fractions and fillets

Weight distribution, proximate composition, fatty acids, amino acids, minerals and vitamins were investigated in five sorted cuts (head, backbone, viscera + belly flap, tail, fillet) emerging during filleting of spring and fall herring (Clupea harengus). The herring co-product cuts constituted ∼ 60 % of the whole herring weight, with backbone and head dominating. Substantial amounts of lipids (5.8-17.6 % wet weight, ww) and proteins (12.8-19.2 % ww) were identified in the co-products, the former being higher in fall than in spring samples. Co-product cuts contained up to 43.1 % long-chain n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (LC n-3 PUFA) of total FA, absolute levels peaking in viscera + belly flap. All cuts contained high levels of essential amino acids (up to 43.3 %), nutritional minerals (e.g., iodine, selenium, calcium, and iron/heme-iron), and vitamins E, D, and B12. Co-products were, in many cases, more nutrient-rich than the fillet and could be excellent sources for both (functional) food and nutraceuticals.

Model systems for studying lipid oxidation associated with muscle foods: Methods, challenges, and prospects

Lipid oxidation is a complex process in muscle-based foods (red meat, poultry and fish) causing severe quality deterioration, e.g., off-odors, discoloration, texture defects and nutritional loss. The complexity of muscle tissue -both composition and structure- poses as a formidable challenge in directly clarifying the mechanisms of lipid oxidation in muscle-based foods. Therefore, different in vitro model systems simulating different aspects of muscle have been used to study the pathways of lipid oxidation. In this review, we discuss the principle, preparation, implementation as well as advantages and disadvantages of seven commonly-studied model systems that mimic either compositional or structural aspects of actual meat: emulsions, fatty acid micelles, liposomes, microsomes, erythrocytes, washed muscle mince, and muscle homogenates. Furthermore, we evaluate the prospects of stem cells, tissue cultures and three-dimensional printing for future model system development. Based on this reviewing of oxidation models, tailoring correct model to different study aims could be facilitated, and readers are becoming acquainted with advantages and shortcomings. In addition, insight into recent technology developments, e.g., stem cell- and tissue-cultures as well as three-dimensional printing could provide new opportunities to overcome the current bottlenecks of lipid oxidation studies in muscle.

Quercetin as an inhibitor of hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation: Mechanisms of action and use of molecular docking

The antioxidant effect of quercetin on hemoglobin(Hb)-mediated lipid oxidation and the mechanisms involved were investigated. Quercetin strongly inhibited Hb-mediated lipid oxidation in washed muscle. Quercetin showed effective hydroxyl radical scavenging ability similar to butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT). Quercetin reduced metHb resulting in formation of oxyHb. Bound quercetin decreased heme dissociation from metHb. Conversion to oxyHb and decreased heme dissociation represent routes to limit Hb-mediated lipid oxidation. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) indicated one molecule of quercetin was covalently bound to Hb α-chain. Quercetin quinone docked 3.3 Å from the thiol of αCys(H15) but not near any other Cys residues of turkey Hb. At the docking site, hydrogen bonding between quercetin quinone and amino acids of α- and β-chain was demonstrated. This represents a path by which quercetin became covalently bound to α-chain. Molecular docking of heme proteins to polyphenols provides a template to better understand antioxidant interactions in muscle foods.

Lipid oxidation in sorted herring (Clupea harengus) filleting co-products from two seasons and its relationship to composition

Lipid oxidation in ice-stored sorted herring fractions (head, backbone, viscera + belly flap, tail, fillet) from spring and fall, and its association with endogenous prooxidants, antioxidants and lipid substrates were investigated. Peroxide value (PV) and thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) had increased significantly in all fractions after 1 day, but for both seasons, the most rapid PV and TBARS development occurred in head, which also had highest hemoglobin (Hb) levels and lipoxygenases (LOX) activity. Viscera + belly flap was overall the most stable part, and also had the highest α-tocopherol content. Pearson correlation analyses across all five fractions confirmed a significant impact of Hb, LOX and α-tocopherol on the lipid oxidation susceptibility, while content of total iron, copper, lipids or polyunsaturated fatty acids provided no significant correlation. Overall, the study showed which pro-oxidants that should be inhibited or removed to succeed with value adding of herring filleting co-products and the fillet itself.

Effect of antioxidants on lipid oxidation in herring (Clupea harengus) co-product silage during its production, heat-treatment and storage

Provided high product quality, ensilaging can be used to valorize fish filleting co-products into a silage suitable for food applications. However, a documented challenge for products from hemoglobin-rich fish raw materials is the high susceptibility to lipid oxidation, calling for stabilization by antioxidants. In a comparison among different rosemary-containing antioxidants and isoascorbic acid, we here found that the commercial mixture Duralox MANC-213 (MANC) provided the best protection against peroxide value and 2-thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) development during ensilaging of herring filleting co-products (0–7 days, 22 °C), and also during subsequent heat-treatment (30 min, 85 °C). Increasing MANC concentration from 0.25 and 0.75 to 1.25% lowered TBARS values from 43.53 and 25.12 to 18.04 µmole TBARS/Kg silage, respectively, after 7 days of ensilaging. During storage at 4 °C/22 °C in presence of MANC, 1.25% provided the highest protection with 87–90% and 66–73% lower TBARS, at 4 °C and 22 °C, respectively, at 6 months compared to the controls. At this time point, heat-treated silages had lower protein degree of hydrolysis and free amino acids values than the non-heat-treated one. Regardless of antioxidant addition, total volatile basic nitrogen (TVB-N) formation still increased during the storage, but, overall, TVB-N values in silages were below the acceptable limit of 30 mg TVB-N/100 g fish for human consumption. Together with lipid oxidation data, this suggest that herring silage produced in presence of antioxidants can be used both for high quality feed and food applications.

Cross-processing herring and salmon co-products with agricultural and marine side-streams or seaweeds produces protein isolates more stable towards lipid oxidation

Herring and salmon filleting co-products were pH-shift processed together with seven antioxidant-containing raw materials ("helpers") including lingonberry-, apple-, oat-, barley- and shrimp-co-products, and two seaweeds (Saccharina latissima, Ulva fenestrata) to produce protein isolates stable towards lipid oxidation. Malondialdehyde (MDA) and 4-hydroxy-(E)-2-hexenal (HHE) levels revealed that all helpers, except shrimp shells, to different extents retarded lipid oxidation both during pH-shift-processing and ice storage. The three helpers performing best were: lingonberry press-cake > apple pomace ∼ Ulva. Color of protein isolates was affected by helper-derived pigments (e.g., anthocyanins, carotenoids, chlorophyll) and lipid oxidation-induced changes (e.g., metHb-formation, pigment-bleaching). In conclusion, combining fish co-products with other food side-streams or seaweeds during pH-shift processing appears a promising new tool to minimize lipid oxidation of protein isolates, both during their production and subsequent storage. Lingonberry press-cake was the most efficient helper but provided dark color which may narrow product development possibilities, something which requires further attention.

Lipid oxidation and antioxidant delivery systems in muscle food

Lipid oxidation accelerates quality deterioration in muscle-based foods (fish, red meat, and poultry), resulting in off-odors/flavors, color problems, texture defects, and safety concerns. Adding antioxidants is one approach to control lipid oxidation, and several delivery strategies have been applied, such as supplementing antioxidants to the feed, direct mixing into minces, or, for whole muscle pieces; spraying, glazing, and injection. However, some issues linked to these technologies hinder their wide utilization, such as low effectiveness, noncompatibility with clean label, and off-flavor. These shortcomings have promoted the development of new antioxidant delivery technologies. In this review, the main focus is on the principles, characteristics, and implementation of five novel antioxidant delivery methods in different types of muscle food products. Their advantages and drawbacks are also summarized, plus comments about future trends in this area. Among novel routes to deliver antioxidants to muscle foods are, for whole tissues, recyclable dipping solutions; for minces, encapsulation; and, for both minces and whole tissues, cross-processing with nonmuscle antioxidant-containing raw materials as well as applications of edible films/coatings and active packaging. Advantages of these technologies comprise, for example, low price, the possibility to control the antioxidant release rate, overcoming strong aromas from natural antioxidants, and allowing antioxidant-containing raw materials from the food industry to be valorized, providing an opportunity for more circular food production.

A Recyclable Dipping Strategy to Stabilize Herring (Clupea harengus) Co-products During Ice Storage

Applying value-adding techniques to fish filleting co-products is rendered difficult due to their high susceptibility to lipid oxidation, microbial spoilage, and amine formation. In this study, a recyclable dipping strategy was developed and investigated for its ability to stabilize herring (Clupea harengus) co-products (head, backbone, caudal fin, intestines, belly flap, skin, and in some cases roe) against oxidation and microbial spoilage. From initial screening of seven antioxidative components/formulas in minced herring co-products during ice storage, an oil-soluble rosemary extract (RE-B) and isoascorbic acid (IAA) were identified as most promising candidates. These compounds were then formulated to a recyclable solution to be used for dipping of the herring co-products. The commercial Duralox MANC antioxidant mixture was used as a positive control. Dipping in 0.2% RE-B solution ± 0.5% IAA or in 2% Duralox MANC solutions remarkably increased the oxidation lag phase from < 1 day to > 12 days during subsequent storage on ice (0–1 °C) of minced or intact co-products, respectively, even when the antioxidant solutions were re-used up to 10 times. The dipping also reduced microbiological growth and total volatile basic nitrogen, but the effect became weaker with an increased number of re-using cycles. The presented dipping strategies could hereby facilitate more diversified end use of herring co-products from current fish meal to high-quality minces, protein isolates, or oils for the food industry.

Hemoglobin-mediated lipid oxidation of herring filleting co-products during ensilaging and its inhibition by pre-incubation in antioxidant solutions

The aims of this study were to investigate the role of hemoglobin (Hb) in lipid oxidation development during ensilaging of herring filleting co-products, and, to inhibit this reaction by pre-incubating the co-products in water or physiological salt, with/without different antioxidants. Results showed that both peroxide value (PV) and 2-thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) gradually increased during 7 days of ensilaging at 22 °C in absence of antioxidants. The increase in TBARS was proportional to the Hb levels present, while PV was less affected. A Hb-fortified Tris-buffer model system adjusted to pH 3.50 confirmed that Hb changed immediately from its native oxyHb to the metHb state, which facilitated heme group release and thus probably explains the increased PV and TBARS during ensilaging. Pre-incubating the co-products for 30 s in a solution containing 0.5% rosemary extract was the most promising strategy to inhibit lipid oxidation both in the co-products during pre-processing storage and during the actual ensilaging. The solution could be re-used up to ten times without losing its activity, illustrating that this methodology can be a scalable and cost-effective strategy to extend the oxidative stability of herring co-products allowing for further value adding e.g., into a high-quality silage.

Differences in lipid composition of Bigeye tuna (Thunnus obesus) during storage at 0 °C and 4 °C

This study aimed to investigate the lipid oxidation and distribution in Bigeye tuna stored at 0 °C and 4 °C for 6 days. Tuna were evaluated by determining the peroxide value (POV), acid value (AV), anisidine value (AnV), polyene index, fluorescence ratio (FR), phosphatidylcholine (PC), phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), phosphatidylinositol (PI) content, and major glycerophospholipid molecular species. The value of lipid oxidation indexes (POV, AV, AnV, FR, PC, PE and PI) increased as the storage time increased. High-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (HPLC-MS/MS) results indicated that the major types of lipids included diacylglycerol (DAG), monoacylglycerol (MAG), phospholipid (PL), and triacylglycerol (TAG). At least 136 PC and 64 PE molecular species were identified in Bigeye tuna. The results of the confocal laser scanning microscope analysis indicated the distribution of TAG and PL particles. In addition, principal component analysis showed that the contents of PI and TAG were positively correlated with PC, polyene index and lipid content but negatively correlated with PI, POV, FR, AOV, AnV, MAG, and DAG, which might be explained by distinguishing the lipid parameters affecting lipid oxidation. Therefore, this study may provide a novel method to evaluate lipid changes and contribute to the balanced nutritional value of aquatic foods during cold storage.

Effect of recovery technique, antioxidant addition and compositional features on lipid oxidation in protein enriched products from cod- salmon and herring backbones

The influence of recovery technique (pH-shift processing vs mechanical separation), antioxidant addition and endogenous factors on lipid oxidation in protein-enriched products from herring, salmon and cod backbones was investigated. Salmon-derived products were very stable during both ice and -20 °C storage. Contrary, peroxide value and TBA-reactive substances in herring- and cod-derived products increased rapidly during ice storage, with the pH-shift-produced protein isolates (PI) being most susceptible to oxidation in case of cod. Duralox MANC (0.5%) however largely increased the oxidation lag phase in both PI and mechanically separated meat (MSM); from <1 day to >15 days. At -20 °C, mainly the herring products oxidized, and particularly the MSM. Pearson correlation tests showed that endogenous levels of Hb, total Fe, ascorbic acid and α-tocopherol correlated significantly (p < 0.05) with lipid oxidation development. Evaluating the role of pre-processing storage indicated that fish co-products should be processed immediately after the filleting process unless antioxidants are added.

Mechanisms involved in the inhibitory effects of free fatty acids on lipid peroxidation in turkey muscle

The pro-oxidant and anti-oxidant effects of free fatty acids (FFA) in meat remain ambiguous. To clarify the role of FFA in lipid oxidation of muscle food, the FFA was added into two systems (turkey mince and washed turkey muscle (WTM)) and lipid oxidation was investigated. A mixture of FFA inhibited lipid oxidation in both systems. The absorbance spectrum of oxyHb and metHb was determined in the presence of C18:1 and C18:2. Conversion to hemichrome spectra was observed and was particularly rapid when metHb was mixed with C18:2. C18:2 was also reacted with metHb followed by a chromatography step to remove unbound C18:2, and termed 'modified Hb'. Electron spin resonance (ESR) spectra of the modified Hb was indicative of hemichrome formation. The modified Hb did not promote lipid oxidation in washed turkey muscle during storage. This suggested that hemichrome formation due to added FFA diminished the lipid oxidation capacity of Hb.

Improving the Stability of Red Blood Cells in Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and Herring (Clupea harengus): Potential Solutions for Post-mortem Fish Handling to Minimize Lipid Oxidation

This study aimed at limiting hemolysis of fish red blood cells (RBCs) as a strategy to limit hemoglobin (Hb)-induced lipid oxidation during post-mortem handling and processing. Effects of varying temperature, salinity, and mechanical impact were studied using washed resuspended RBCs (wr-RBCs) and whole blood (WB) from rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and herring (Clupea harengus). The wr-RBCs were most stable avoiding mechanical stress, keeping isotonic conditions (0.9–1.3% NaCl) and low temperature 0–6 °C, with predicted minimum at 2.5 °C. When compared at the same salinity, it was found that hemolysis was more pronounced in herring than trout wr-RBCs. Furthermore, WB was more stable than wr-RBCs, showing protecting the effects of blood plasma. Studying individual plasma components, stabilizing effects were found from glucose, proteins, and ascorbic acid. This study indicates that small adjustments in the early handling and processing of fish such as changing salinity of storage and rinsing solutions could minimize Hb contamination of the fish muscle and thereby improve quality.