Optimizing pea protein fractionation to yield protein fractions with a high foaming and emulsifying capacity

Impact of pH on the structure, interfacial and foaming properties of pea protein isolate: Investigation of the structure - Function relationship

This study explored the relationship between pea protein foaming properties and their structure and physicochemical properties under neutral and acidic pH. Results showed that pH modified the zeta potential, particle size and surface tension due to electrostatic changes. FT-MIR and fluorescence spectra revealed pH-induced conformational changes, exposing hydrophobic groups and increasing sulfhydryl content, promoting protein aggregation. At pH 3, the highest foaming capacity (1.273) and lowest foam expansion (6.967) were observed, associated with increased surface hydrophobicity and net charges, ideal for creating light foams with high liquid incorporation for acidic beverages or fruit-based mousses. Pea protein isolate generated stable foams with foam volume stability between 86.662 % and 94.255 %. Although neutral pH conditions showed the highest foam volume stability, their air bubbles increased in size and transitioned from spherical to polyhedral shape, suitable for visual-centric applications, like cappuccino foam and beer-head retention. Foams at pH 5 exhibited the smallest bubbles and maintained their spherical shape, enhancing drainage resistance, beneficial for whipped toppings. Strong correlations (Pearson correlation coefficient higher than 0.600) were noted between the structure, surface and foaming properties, providing crucial insights into optimizing pea protein functionality across various pH conditions, enabling the development of plant-based foamed products with tailored properties.

A time-resolved investigation at multiple-length scales of the structure of liquid foam stabilized by albumins from pea

HYPOTHESIS

The structural details of foams made with pea albumins are affected by the pH of the initial solution and followed heat treatment.

EXPERIMENTS

An in situ, time-resolved investigation of foams prepared with pea albumins was conducted using small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) in combination with imaging and conductance measurements. Solutions were tested at pH three pH values (3, 4.5, and 8) before and after heating (90 °C for 1 and 5 min).

FINDINGS

The characteristic structures present in the foam from the nano to the meso-scale differed during drainage depending on solution pH. Foams obtained at pH 3, had the largest bubble radius and thinnest plateau border, as well as the highest extent of liquid drainage. At pH 4.5, close to the isoelectric point of the proteins, foams displayed similar bubbles' behavior to those at pH 8, but with the largest film thickness. In this case, the proteins were extensively aggregated. Heating of the solutions prior to foaming did not significantly affect the foam aging regardless of pH. The quantification of specific surface areas and film thickness over time without sample disruption shows to be a powerful approach to designing foam structures.

Understanding Stabilization of Oil-in-Water Emulsions with Pea Protein─Studies of Structure and Properties

This study investigates the stability and structure of oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by pea protein. Of the wide range of emulsion compositions explored, a region of stability at a minimum of 5% w/v pea protein and 30-50% v/v oil was determined. This pea protein concentration is more than what is needed to form a layer covering the interface. X-ray scattering revealed a thick, dense protein layer at the interface as well as hydrated protein dispersed in the continuous phase. Shear-thinning behavior was observed, and the high viscosity in combination with the thick protein layer at the interface creates a good stability against creaming and coalescence. Emulsions in a pH range from acidic to neutral were studied, and the overall stability was observed to be broadly similar independently of pH. Size measurements revealed polydisperse protein particles. The emulsion droplets are also very polydisperse. Apart from understanding pea protein-stabilized emulsions in particular, insights are gained about protein stabilization in general. Knowledge of the location and the role of the different components in the pea protein material suggests that properties such as viscosity and stability can be tailored for various applications, including food and nutraceutical products.

Effects of molecular structure and charge state on the foaming and emulsifying properties of Spirulina protein isolates

Microalgae protein holds great potential for various applications in the food industry. However, the current knowledge regarding microalgae protein remains limited, with little information available on its functional properties. Furthermore, the relationship between its molecular structure and functional properties is not well defined, which limits its application in food processing. This study aims to addresses these gaps though an analysis of the emulsibility and foamability of various soluble protein isolates from two species of Spirulina (Arthospira platensis and Spirulina platensis), and the functional properties of Spirulina protein isolates in relation to its molecular structure and charge state. Results revealed that the degree of cross-linking and aggregation or folding and curling of protein tertiary structures was higher in the highly soluble Spirulina protein isolates (AP50% and SP50%) than in the low-solubility isolates (AP30% and SP30%). The foaming capacity (FC) of AP50% and SP50% was found to be lower than that of AP30% and SP30%. Spirulina protein isolates can stably adsorb at the air-water interface for at least 20 min and possessed good interfacial activity. A high pH value was found to promote cross-linking of protein particles at the oil-water interface, thereby reinforcing the internal network structure of emulsions and increasing viscosity. These findings provide preliminary insights for potential applications of Spirulina protein isolates in food production, especially towards quality improvement.

Structural evolution of pea-derived albumins during pH and heat treatment studied with light and X-ray scattering

Pea albumins are found in the side stream during the isolation of pea proteins. They are soluble at acidic pH and have functional properties which differ from their globulin counterparts. In this study, we have investigated the aggregation and structural changes occurring to pea albumins under different environmental conditions, using a combination of size-exclusion chromatography coupled with multi-angle laser light scattering (SEC-MALS) and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). Albumins were extracted from a dry fractionated pea protein concentrate by precipitating the globulin fraction at acidic pH. The albumins were then studied at different pH (3, 4, 4.5, 7, 7.5, and 8) values. The effect of heating at 90 °C for 1, 3, and 5 min on their structural changes was investigated using SAXS. In addition, size exclusion of the albumins showed 4 distinct populations, depending on pH and heating conditions, with two large aggregates peaks (∼250 kDa): a dimer peak (∼24 kDa) containing predominantly pea albumin 2 (PA2), and a monomer peak of a molar mass of about 12 kDa (PA1). X-ray scattering intensities as a function of q were modeled as polydisperse spheres, and their aggregation was followed as a function of heating time. Albumins was most stable at pH 3, showing no aggregation during heat treatment. While albumins at pH 7.5 and 8 showed aggregation after heating, solutions at pH 4, 4.5, and 7 already contained aggregates even before heating. This work provides new knowledge on the overall structural development of albumins under different environmental conditions, improving our ability to employ these as future ingredients in foods.

Oil-water interface and emulsion stabilising properties of rapeseed proteins napin and cruciferin studied by nonlinear surface rheology

HYPOTHESIS

Two major protein families are present in rapeseed, namely cruciferins and napins. The structural differences between the two protein families indicate that they might behave differently when their mixture stabilises oil-water interfaces. Therefore, this work focuses on elucidating the role of both proteins in interface and emulsion stabilisation.

EXPERIMENTS

Protein molecular properties were evaluated, using SEC, DSC, CD, and hydrophobicity analysis. The oil-water interface mechanical properties were studied using LAOS and LAOD. General stress decomposition (GSD) was used as a novel method to characterise the nonlinear response. Additionally, to evaluate the emulsifying properties of the rapeseed proteins, emulsions were prepared using pure napins or cruciferin and also their mixtures at 1:3, 1:1 and 3:1 (w:w) ratios.

FINDINGS

Cruciferins formed stiff viscoelastic solid-like interfacial layers (Gs' = 0.046 mN/m; Ed' = 30.1 mN/m), while napin formed weaker and more stretchable layers at the oil-water interface (Gs' = 0.010 mN/m; Ed' = 26.4 mN/m). As a result, cruciferin-formed oil droplets with much higher stability against coalescence (coalescence index, CI up to 10%) than napin-stabilised ones (CI up to 146%) during two months of storage. Both proteins have a different role in emulsions produced with napin-cruciferin mixtures, where cruciferin provides high coalescence stability, while napin induces flocculation. Our work showed the role of each rapeseed protein in liquid-liquid multiphase systems.

Pea protein [Pisum sativum] as stabilizer for oil/water emulsions

A map of stability for various water/oil/pea protein compositions has been plotted from the numerous reported results. Two clear regions of stability were identified. High internal oil phase emulsions with 70-80%, v/v oil content stabilized by total pea protein concentration <2.5%, w/v showed stability. Low oil content of 10-30%, v/v for a range of total pea protein concentrations >0.5%, w/v have also been identified as stable. Intermediate oil content and pea protein concentrations >4% w/v are unexplored regions and are likely to be areas of fruitful future research. The wide range of stability suggests that different stabilization mechanisms could be important for different compositions and careful consideration has to be taken to avoid oversimplification. Both stabilization with particles, i.e. Pickering emulsions, and protein unfolding have been suggested as mechanisms. The diverse way of describing stability makes it difficult to intercompare results in different studies. A summary of different oil types used have been presented and several properties such as dynamic viscosity, density, the dielectric constant and interfacial tension have been summarized for common vegetable oils. The type of vegetable oil and emulsion preparation techniques were seen to have rather little effect on emulsion stability. However, the different extraction methods and processing of the pea material had more effect, which could be attributed to changing composition of different proteins and to the states of aggregation and denaturing. Careful consideration has to be taken in the choice of extraction method and an increased understanding of what contributes to the stability is desirable for further progress in research and eventual product formulation.

Perilla seed oil high internal phase emulsion improve the gel properties of myofibrillar protein

The effects of perilla seed oil high internal phase emulsions stabilized by pea protein (PP-PSO HIPEs) on the gel properties and conformation of myofibrillar protein (MP) gels were investigated. The results showed that the PP-PSO HIPEs with 4.0 % (w/v) PP formed stable HIPEs with low droplet size and good viscoelasticity. The addition of PP-PSO HIPEs (5.0 % - 15.0 %) could significantly improve the MP gel properties (P < 0.05), while the addition of 10.0 % PP-PSO HIPEs showed the highest gel strength and water holding capacity. Otherwise, the MP gels with 10.0 % PP-PSO HIPEs showed higher proportions of immobile water (PT22) and lower proportion of free water (PT23), and the Raman spectra suggested that the content of α-helix decreased, while the content of β-sheet increased (P < 0.05), thus facilitating the formation of better gel properties. Therefore, the addition of PP-PSO HIPEs is a potential alternative for developing fat-reduced meat products.

An overview of edible foams in food and modern cuisine: Destabilization and stabilization mechanisms and applications

Foam, as a structured multi-scale colloidal system, is becoming increasingly popular in food because it gives a series of unique textures, structures, and appearances to foods while maintaining clean labels. Recently, developing green and healthy food-grade foaming agents, improving the stability of edible foams, and exploring the application of foam structures and new foaming agents have been the focus of foam systems. This review comprehensively introduces the destabilization mechanisms of foam and summarizes the main mechanisms controlling the foam stability and progress of different food-grade materials (small-molecular surfactants, biopolymers, and edible Pickering particles). Furthermore, the classic foam systems in food and modern cuisine, their applications, developments, and challenges are also underlined. Natural small-molecular surfactants, novel plant/microalgae proteins, and edible colloidal particles are the research hotspots of high-efficiency food-grade foam stabilizers. They have apparent differences in foam stability mechanisms, and each exerts its advantages. However, the development of foam stabilizers remains to be enriched compared with emulsions. Food foams are diverse and widely used, bringing unique enjoyment and benefit to consumers regarding sense, innovation, and health attributes. In addition to industrial inflatable foods, the foam foods in molecular gastronomy are also worthy of exploration. Moreover, edible foams may have greater potential in structured food design, 3D/4D printing, and controlled flavor release in the future. This review will provide a reference for the efficient development of functional inflatable foods and the advancement of foam technologies in modern cuisine.

Colloidal gas aphrons for biotechnology applications: a mini review

Colloidal gas aphrons (CGAs) are highly stable, spherical, micrometer-sized bubbles encapsulated by surfactant multilayers. They have several intriguing properties, including: high stability, large interfacial area, and the ability to maintain the same charge as their parent molecules. The physical properties of CGAs make them ideal for biotechnological applications such as the recovery of a variety of: biomolecules, particularly proteins, yeast, enzymes, and microalgae. In this review, the bio-application of CGAs for the recovery of natural components is presented, as well as: experimental results, technical challenges, and critical research directions for the future. Experimental results from the literature showed that the recovery of biomolecules was mainly determined by electrostatic or hydrophobic interactions between polyphenols and proteins (lysozyme, β-casein, β-lactoglobulin, etc.), yeast, biological molecules (gallic acid and norbixin), and microalgae with CGAs. Knowledge transfer is essential for commercializing CGA-based bio-product recovery, which will be recognized as a viable technology in the future.

Protein composition and nutritional aspects of pea protein fractions obtained by a modified isoelectric precipitation method using fermentation

Pea albumins are promising for their nutritional, biological, and techno-functional properties. However, this fraction is usually discarded in the industry due to its low protein content compared to globulin fraction and the presence of some anti-nutritional compounds. In the present study, we used an alternative method of pea protein extraction based on alkaline solubilization/isoelectric precipitation in which the reduction of pH was achieved by lactic acid fermentation using specific starters instead of mineral acids. Hence, the main objective of this study was to examine the protein profile and the content of anti-nutritional and nutritional active compounds in pea albumin-rich fractions obtained by the isoelectric extraction method without (control) or with fermentation with different lactic acid bacteria (Streptococcus thermophilus, Lactiplantibacillus plantarum, and their co-culture). Different pea cultivars (Cartouche, Ascension, and Assas) were used here for their differences in protein profile. The results revealed a higher total nitrogen content in albumin-rich fraction for fermented samples and, in particular, for co-culture. The majority of total nitrogen was determined as non-protein (~50%), suggesting the degradation of proteins by LAB to small peptides and amino acids, which were solubilized in the soluble fraction (albumin) as confirmed by size exclusion chromatography (SEC-HPLC) analysis. Moreover, the higher antioxidant activity of fermented albumin samples was attributed to the production of small peptides during extraction. Lactic acid fermentation also resulted in a significant reduction of trypsin inhibitor activity, α-galactoside, and phytic acid content of this fraction compared to control.

Yellow Field Pea Protein (Pisum sativum L.): Extraction Technologies, Functionalities, and Applications

Yellow field peas (Pisum sativum L.) hold significant value for producers, researchers, and ingredient manufacturers due to their wealthy composition of protein, starch, and micronutrients. The protein quality in peas is influenced by both intrinsic factors like amino acid composition and spatial conformations and extrinsic factors including growth and processing conditions. The existing literature substantiates that the structural modulation and optimization of functional, organoleptic, and nutritional attributes of pea proteins can be obtained through a combination of chemical, physical, and enzymatic approaches, resulting in superior protein ingredients. This review underscores recent methodologies in pea protein extraction aimed at enhancing yield and functionality for diverse food systems and also delineates existing research gaps related to mitigating off-flavor issues in pea proteins. A comprehensive examination of conventional dry and wet methods is provided, in conjunction with environmentally friendly approaches like ultrafiltration and enzyme-assisted techniques. Additionally, the innovative application of hydrodynamic cavitation technology in protein extraction is explored, focusing on its prospective role in flavor amelioration. This overview offers a nuanced understanding of the advancements in pea protein extraction methods, catering to the interests of varied stakeholders in the field.

Quantifying the effects of pre-roasting on structural and functional properties of yellow pea proteins

Roasting could modify the protein structure/conformation, contributing to changes in functional properties. Here we investigated the effects of pre-roasting on the extraction efficiency, structural and functional properties of pea protein concentrates and isolates (PPC and PPI) produced from yellow split peas. The shorter roasting times (150 °C, 10 and 20 min) had little effect on protein yields and could increase the solubility of PPC or PPI by ∼ 12% at pH 7 and enhance the solubility of PPI by ∼ 12% (10-min roasting) and ∼ 24% (20-min roasting) at pH 3. However, a longer duration of pre-roasting (150 °C, 30 min) significantly reduced the extraction efficiency of PPC and PPI by ∼ 30% and ∼ 61%, respectively. Meanwhile, pre-roasting had minor effects on SDS-PAGE profiles and the secondary structures of pea proteins but significantly altered tertiary structures by reducing free sulfhydryl groups, increasing disulfide bonds and surface hydrophobicity. As for the emulsifying properties, pre-roasting improved the emulsion ability index (EAI) of PPC and PPI but decreased the emulsion stability index (ESI) of PPC and had no significant effect on PPI. Moreover, PPC and PPI with shorter pre-roasting duration (10 and 20 min) had endothermic peaks and showed a slight decrease in the denaturation temperature (Td) and the onset temperature (To), respectively. Overall, the study demonstrated that controlled pre-roasting at 150 °C for 10 min and 20 min altered protein structures (mainly tertiary structures), improving the solubility and EAI of pea proteins at pH 7, while retaining their thermal properties in comparison to unroasted samples.

Surface stress decomposition in large amplitude oscillatory interfacial dilatation of complex interfaces

HYPOTHESIS

Multiphase materials are often subjected to large deformations during processing, but the rheological responses of complex interfaces (e.g. stabilized by proteins) in this nonlinear deformation regime are still poorly understood. We expect nonlinearities in the response to be introduce by changes of the interfacial network and surface density of the emulsifier.

EXPERIMENTS

Large amplitude oscillatory dilatation (LAOD) experiments were performed on WPI-, pea albumin-, pea globulin- and rapeseed lecithin-stabilized interfaces and analyzed with a general stress decomposition (GSD). With GSD, the stress response was decomposed into the four stress terms (τ₁-τ₄). Here, τ₁ and τ₂ represent, the elastic and viscous contribution of the odd Fourier harmonics, and τ₃ and τ₄ represent the dissipative and recoverable contribution of the even harmonics.

FINDINGS

Analysis of WPI-, pea albumin-, pea globulin- and rapeseed lecithin-stabilized interfaces revealed that higher odd harmonics (k≥3) describe in-plane network responses and that even harmonics describe surface density changes. Analysis of these complex interfaces showed that GSD is a valuable tool for (quantitative) description of interfacial responses in LAOD, providing new insights into the origin of asymmetric nonlinear stress responses.

A Plant-Based Animal Fat Analog Produced by an Emulsion Gel of Alginate and Pea Protein

As the market for plant-based meat analogs grows, the development of plant-based animal fat analogs has become increasingly important. In this study, we propose an approach by developing a gelled emulsion based on sodium alginate, soybean oil (SO), and pea protein isolate. Formulations containing 15% to 70% (w/w) SO were successfully produced without phase inversion. The addition of more SO resulted in pre-gelled emulsions with a more elastic behavior. After the emulsion was gelled in the presence of calcium, the color of the gelled emulsion changed to light yellow, and the formulation containing 70% SO exhibited a color most similar to actual beef fat trimming. The lightness and yellowness values were greatly influenced by the concentrations of both SO and pea protein. Microscopic images revealed that pea protein formed an interfacial film around the oil droplets, and the oil was more tightly packed at higher oil concentrations. Differential scanning calorimetry showed that lipid crystallization of the gelled SO was influenced by the confinement of the alginate gelation, but the melting behavior was like that of free SO. FTIR spectrum analysis indicated a potential interaction between alginate and pea protein, but the functional groups of SO were unchanged. Under mild heating conditions, gelled SO exhibited an oil loss similar to that observed in actual beef trims. The developed product has the potential to mimic the appearance and slow-rendering melting attribute of real animal fat.

Structural properties of pea proteins (Pisum sativum) for sustainable food matrices

Pea proteins are widely used as a food ingredient, especially in sustainable food formulations. The seed itself consists of many proteins with different structures and properties that determine their structure-forming properties in food matrices, such as emulsions, foams, and gels. This review discusses the current insights into the structuring properties of pea protein mixtures (concentrates, isolates) and the resulting individual fractions (globulins, albumins). The structural molecular features of the proteins found in pea seeds are discussed and based on this information, different structural length scales relevant to foods are reviewed. The main finding of this article is that the different pea proteins are able to form and stabilize structural components found in foods such as air-water and oil-water interfaces, gels, and anisotropic structures. Current research reveals that each individual protein fraction has unique structure-forming properties and that tailored breeding and fractionation processes will be required to optimize these properties. Especially the use of albumins, globulins, and mixed albumin-globulins proved to be useful in specific food structures such as foams, emulsions, and self-coacervation, respectively. These new research findings will transform how pea proteins are processed and being used in novel sustainable food formulations in the future.

Mild Fractionation for More Sustainable Food Ingredients

With the rising problems of food shortages, energy costs, and raw materials, the food industry must reduce its environmental impact. We present an overview of more resource-efficient processes to produce food ingredients, describing their environmental impact and the functional properties obtained. Extensive wet processing yields high purities but also has the highest environmental impact, mainly due to heating for protein precipitation and dehydration. Milder wet alternatives exclude, for example, low pH-driven separation and are based on salt precipitation or water only. Drying steps are omitted during dry fractionation using air classification or electrostatic separation. Benefits of milder methods are enhanced functional properties. Therefore, fractionation and formulation should be focused on the desired functionality instead of purity. Environmental impact is also strongly reduced by milder refining. Antinutritional factors and off-flavors remain challenges in more mildly produced ingredients. The benefits of less refining motivate the increasing trend toward mildly refined ingredients.

Study on the Structure, Function, and Interface Characteristics of Soybean Protein Isolate by Industrial Phosphorylation

The impacts of industrial phosphorylation on the structural changes, microstructure, functional, and rheological features of soybean protein isolate (SPI) were spotlighted. The findings implied that the spatial structure and functional features of the SPI changed significantly after treatment with the two phosphates. Sodium hexametaphosphate (SHMP) promoted aggregation of SPI with a larger particle size; sodium tripolyphosphate (STP) modified SPI with smaller particle size. SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) results showed insignificant alterations in the structure of SPI subunits. Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) and endogenous fluorescence noted a decline in α-helix quantity, an amplification in β-fold quantity, and an increase in protein stretching and disorder, indicating that phosphorylation treatment fluctuated the spatial structure of the SPI. Functional characterization studies showed that the solubility and emulsion properties of the SPI increased to varying degrees after phosphorylation, with a maximum solubility of 94.64% for SHMP-SPI and 97.09% for STP-SPI. Emulsifying activity index (EAI) and emulsifying steadiness index (ESI) results for STP-SPI were better than those for SHMP-SPI. Rheological results showed that the modulus of G' and G″ increased and the emulsion exhibited significant elastic behavior. This affords a theoretical core for expanding the industrial production applications of soybean isolates in the food and various industries.

Recovery and Utilization of Pea Albumins as Acidic Emulsion Stabilizer by Complexation with Dextran Sulfate

In this work, pea albumins (PAs) were efficiently recovered by complexation with dextran sulfate (DS), and the emulsifying ability and stability of PA/DS complexes were studied. The largest amounts of PAs (81.25%) were recovered at r = 5:1 and pH_max (pH 3.41) by forming insoluble complexes; and only soluble complexes were formed at r = 2:1 and over the whole pH range (2.0-7.0). The emulsions stabilized by PA/DS soluble complexes remained stable under acidic conditions due to the highly negatively charge (from -45.10 ± 0.40 to -57.23 ± 0.66 mV) and small particle size (0.168 ± 0.010-0.448 ± 0.004 μm), while emulsions stabilized by PAs alone generated a strong creaming and serum separation at pH 5 and 6. In terms of emulsifying stability, all PA emulsions and unheated PA/DS emulsions became unstable with different creaming index after 14 days storage. SDS-PAGE results showed that the interface adsorption proteins of unheated emulsions mainly consisted of PA1a, which was unfavorable to the stability of the interface. On the contrary, heat treatment (95 °C, 30 min) and complexation (PA/DS = 2:1) enhanced the adsorption of PA2 and lectin at the interface, inhibiting the aggregation of PA2 and lectin. This resulted in long-term stability of the PA/DS emulsions under acidic conditions.

A comprehensive review on pulse protein fractionation and extraction: processes, functionality, and food applications

The increasing world population requires the production of nutrient-rich foods. Protein is an essential macronutrient for healthy individuals. Interest in using plant proteins in foods has increased in recent years due to their sustainability and nutritional benefits. Dry and wet protein fractionation methods have been developed to increase protein yield, purity, and functional and nutritional qualities. This review explores the recent developments in pretreatments and fractionation processes used for producing pulse protein concentrates and isolates. Functionality differences between pulse proteins obtained from different fractionation methods and the use of fractionated pulse proteins in different food applications are also critically reviewed. Pretreatment methods improve the de-hulling efficiency of seeds prior to fractionation. Research on wet fractionation methods focuses on improving sustainability and functionality of proteins while studies on dry methods focus on increasing protein yield and purity. Hybrid methods produced fractionated proteins with higher yield and purity while also improving protein functionality and process sustainability. Dry and hybrid fractionated proteins have comparable or superior functionalities relative to wet fractionated proteins. Pulse protein ingredients are successfully incorporated into various food formulations with notable changes in their sensory properties. Future studies could focus on optimizing the fractionation process, improving protein concentrate palatability, and optimizing formulations using pulse proteins.