Clinical and laboratory parameters predicting a requirement for the reevaluation of growth hormone status during growth hormone treatment: Retesting early in the course of GH treatment

The Growth Hormone Deficiency (GHD) Reversal Trial: effect on final height of discontinuation versus continuation of growth hormone treatment in pubertal children with isolated GHD-a non-inferiority Randomised Controlled Trial (RCT)

BACKGROUND

Growth hormone deficiency (GHD) is the commonest endocrine cause of short stature and may occur in isolation (I-GHD) or combined with other pituitary hormone deficiencies. Around 500 children are diagnosed with GHD every year in the UK, of whom 75% have I-GHD. Growth hormone (GH) therapy improves growth in children with GHD, with the goal of achieving a normal final height (FH). GH therapy is given as daily injections until adult FH is reached. However, in many children with I-GHD their condition reverses, with a normal peak GH detected in 64-82% when re-tested at FH. Therefore, at some point between diagnosis and FH, I-GHD must have reversed, possibly due to increase in sex hormones during puberty. Despite increasing evidence for frequent I-GHD reversal, daily GH injections are traditionally continued until FH is achieved.

METHODS/DESIGN

Evidence suggests that I-GHD children who re-test normal in early puberty reach a FH comparable to that of children without GHD. The GHD Reversal study will include 138 children from routine endocrine clinics in twelve UK and five Austrian centres with I-GHD (original peak GH < 6.7 mcg/L) whose deficiency has reversed on early re-testing. Children will be randomised to either continue or discontinue GH therapy. This phase III, international, multicentre, open-label, randomised controlled, non-inferiority trial (including an internal pilot study) will assess whether children with early I-GHD reversal who stop GH therapy achieve non-inferior near FH SDS (primary outcome; inferiority margin 0.55 SD), target height (TH) minus near FH, HRQoL, bone health index and lipid profiles (secondary outcomes) than those continuing GH. In addition, the study will assess cost-effectiveness of GH discontinuation in the early retesting scenario.

DISCUSSION

If this study shows that a significant proportion of children with presumed I-GHD reversal generate enough GH naturally in puberty to achieve a near FH within the target range, then this new care pathway would rapidly improve national/international practice. An assumed 50% reversal rate would provide potential UK health service cost savings of £1.8-4.6 million (€2.05-5.24 million)/year in drug costs alone. This new care pathway would also prevent children from having unnecessary daily GH injections and consequent exposure to potential adverse effects.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

EudraCT number: 2020-001006-39.

Clinical Features of Transient Growth Hormone Deficiency

Background: Most patients with idiopathic growth hormone deficiency (iGHD) in childhood have normal GH stimulation test results in adulthood. The present study aimed to investigate the characteristics and possible etiology of transient iGHD. Methods: Patients with childhood-onset iGHD who completed their GH treatment between March 2010 and March 2021 were retrospectively studied. Patients with a clear history of child abuse or constitutional delay of growth and puberty were excluded. Ten patients with a diagnosis of iGHD based on a decreased growth rate and growth hormone stimulation test findings at the time of onset were included. Retesting demonstrated that these patients had a normal GH level. Results: Five patients had insufficient weight gain (BMI SD score < −1.0 at the start of treatment or a decrease in BMI SD score > 1.0 from one year before treatment to the start of treatment). The other five patients had no remarkable clinical features. One patient had decreased height velocity at the same time as their sibling. Conclusion: Insufficient pre-treatment weight gain or a familial cluster of cases may be related to low GH peaks of GHST, leading to a diagnosis of transient GHD.

The landscape of retesting in childhood-onset idiopathic growth hormone deficiency and its reversibility: a systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

Children diagnosed with idiopathic isolated growth hormone deficiency (IGHD) are frequently observed to no longer be GH-deficient at a later stage of growth as a result of 'GHD reversal'. Reevaluation of GH status by stimulation test is currently incorporated into management guidelines at attainment of final height (FH). Over the past three decades, numerous studies have evaluated reversal rates using different methodologies including crucial parameters like GHD aetiology, GH cut-off and retesting time point, with heterogeneous results. We aimed to systematically analyse the reversibility of childhood-onset IGHD dependent on retesting GH cut-offs and retesting time points.

METHODS

PubMed, Cochrane Library, TRIP database and NHS Evidence were searched for publications investigating the reversibility of IGHD from database initiation to 30 June 2020 following PRISMA recommendations. Study cohorts were pooled according to retesting GH cut-off and time point. Reversal rates were calculated using random-effects models.

RESULTS

Of the 29 studies initially identified, 25 provided sufficient detail for IGHD analysis, resulting in 2030 IGHD patient data. Reversal rates decreased significantly as the retesting GH cut-off increased (P = 0.0013). Pooled (95% CI) reversal rates were 80% (59-92%, n = 227), 73% (62-81%, n = 516) and 55% (41-68%, n = 1287) for cohorts using retesting GH cut-offs of 3-4 ng/mL, 5-6 ng/mL and 7.7-10 ng/mL, respectively. Individuals retested at FH (n = 674) showed a pooled reversal rate of 74% (64-82%) compared to 48% (25-71%) when retested before FH (n = 653).

CONCLUSION

Provided evidence supports reevaluation of current IGHD management guidelines. The high reversal rates should instigate consideration of early retesting.

Gender-specific soluble α-klotho levels as marker of GH deficiency in children: a case-control study

PURPOSE

To evaluate circulating soluble α-klotho (sαKL) levels in GHD children before and after 12 months of GH treatment (GHT).

METHODS

Auxological and basal metabolic parameters, oral glucose tolerance test for glucose and insulin levels, insulin sensitivity indices and klotho levels were evaluated before and after 12 months of follow-up in 58 GHD children and 56 healthy controls.

RESULTS

At baseline, GHD children showed significantly lower growth velocity standard deviation score (SDS) (p < 0.001), bone/chronological age ratio (p < 0.001), GH peak and area under the curve (AUC) after arginine test (ARG) (both p < 0.001) and glucagon stimulation test (GST) (p < 0.001 and 0.048, respectively), IGF-1 (p < 0.001), with higher BMI (SDS) (p < 0.001), WC (SDS) (p = 0.003) and sαKL (p < 0.001) than controls. After 12 months of GHT, GHD children showed a significant increase in height (SDS) (p < 0.001), growth velocity (SDS) (p < 0.001), bone/chronological age ratio (p < 0.001) IGF-1 (p < 0.001), fasting insulin (p < 0.001), Homa-IR (p < 0.001) and sαKL (p < 0.001) with a concomitant decrease in BMI (SDS) (p = 0.002) and WC (SDS) (p = 0.038) than baseline. At ROC curve analysis, we identified a sαKL cut-off to discriminate controls and GHD children of 1764.4 pg/mL in females and 1339.4 pg/mL in males. At multivariate analysis, the independent variables significantly associated with sαKL levels after 12 months of GHT were the oral disposition index (p = 0.004, β = 0.327) and IGF-1 (p = 0.019, β = 0.313).

CONCLUSIONS

Gender-related sαKL may be used as a marker of GHD combined to GH and IGF-1. Insulin and IGF-1 are independently associated with sαKL values after 12 months of GHT.

Pediatric KT in children up to 15 kg: A single-center experience

BACKGROUND

KT is the preferred treatment for ESRD in pediatrics. However, it may be challenging in those weighing ≤15 kg with potential complications that impact on morbidity and graft loss.

METHODS

This retrospective review reports our experience in KT in children, weighing ≤15 kg, and the strategies to reduce morbidity and mortality.

RESULTS

All patients were on RRT prior to KT. Patients reached ESRD mainly due to urologic malformations (54.54%). LD was performed in 82% of patients. The recipient's median age was 2.83 years, and median weight 12.280 kg. Male sex was predominant (73%). All patients required transfusions of PRBCs. There was a high requirement for ventilated support in patients post-KT with no relation to weight, amount of resuscitation used intra-operatively or ml/kg of PRBCs. One patient presented with stenosis of the native renal artery. No patients presented DGF, graft thrombosis, or surgical complications. No association was found between cold ischemia and eGFR at 1 year (p = .12). In univariate analysis, eGFR at 1 year is related to AR. eGFR at 3 years is related to the number of UTI. Median follow-up was 1363 days. Patient and graft survival were 100%.

CONCLUSIONS

KT in children ≤15 kg can be challenging and requires a meticulous perioperative management and surgical expertise. Patient and graft survival are excellent with low rate of complications.

Clinical benefits of sex steroids given as a priming prior to GH provocative test or as a growth-promoting therapy in peripubertal growth delays: Results of a retrospective study among ENDO-ERN centres

OBJECTIVES

Sex steroids, administered as a priming before GH stimulation tests (GHST) to differentiate between growth hormone deficiency (GHD) and constitutional delay of growth and puberty (CDGP) or as growth-promoting therapy using low-dose sex steroids (LDSS) in CDGP, are much debated. We aimed to compare auxological outcomes of CDGP or GHD children undergoing primed or unprimed GHST and to evaluate LDSS treatment in CDGP.

DESIGN

Retrospective study among three paediatric University Hospitals in Italy and UK.

METHODS

184 children (72 females) aged 12.4 ± 2.08 years underwent primed (/P⁺ ) or unprimed (/P^- ) GHST and were followed up until final height (FH). CDGP patients were untreated (CDG P^- ) or received LDSS (CDGP⁺ ). The cohort included 34 CDG P^- /P⁺ , 12 CDGP⁺ /P⁺ , 51 GHD/P⁺ , 29 CDG P^- /P^- , 2 CDGP⁺ /P^- and 56 GHD/P^- . FH standard deviation score (SDS), Δ SDS FH-target height (TH) and degree of success (-1 ≤ Δ SDS FH-SDS TH ≤ +1) were outcomes of interest.

RESULTS

GHD/P⁺ had better FH-SDS (-0.87 vs -1.49; P = .023) and ΔSDS FH-TH (-0.35 vs -0.77; P = .002) than CDGP^- /P⁺ . Overall, GHD/P⁺ showed the highest degree of success (90%, P = .006). Regardless of priming, both rhGH and LDSS improved degree of success compared to no treatment (89% and 86% vs 63%, P = .0009). GHD/P⁺ showed a trend towards a higher proportion of permanent GHD compared to GHD/P^- (30.43% vs 15.09%; P = .067).

CONCLUSION

In peripubertal children, priming before GHST improves diagnostic accuracy of GHST for idiopathic GHD. LDSS treatment improves auxological outcomes in CDGP.

Differential diagnosis between constitutional delay of growth and puberty, idiopathic growth hormone deficiency and congenital hypogonadotropic hypogonadism: a clinical challenge for the pediatric endocrinologist

INTRODUCTION

Differential diagnosis between constitutional delay of growth and puberty (CDGP), partial growth hormone deficiency (pGHD) and congenital hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (cHH) may be difficult. All these conditions usually present with poor growth in pre- or peri-pubertal age and they may recur within one familial setting, constituting a highly variable, but somehow common, spectrum of pubertal delay.

EVIDENCE ACQUISITION

Narrative review of the most relevant English papers published between 1981 and march 2020 using the following search terms "constitutional delay of growth and puberty," "central hypogonadism," "priming," "growth hormone deficiency," "pituitary," "pituitary magnetic resonance imaging," with a special regard to the latest scientific acquisitions.

EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS

CDGP is by far the most prevalent entity in boys and recurs within families. pGHD is a rare, often idiopathic and transient condition, where hypostaturism presents more severely. Specificity of pGHD diagnosis is increased by priming children before growth hormone stimulation test (GHST); pituitary MRI and genetic analysis are recommended to personalize future follow-up. Diagnosing cHH may be obvious when anosmia and eunuchoid proportions concomitate. However, cHH can either overlap with pGHD in forms of multiple pituitary hormone deficiencies (MPHD) or syndromic conditions either with CDGP in family pedigrees, so endocrine workup and genetic investigations are necessary. The use of growth charts, bone age, predictors of adult height, primed GHST and low dose sex steroids (LDSS) treatment are recommended.

CONCLUSIONS

Only a step-by-step diagnostic process based on appropriate endocrine and genetic markers together with LDSS treatment can help achieving the correct diagnosis and optimizing outcomes.

Growth Hormone (GH) Therapy During the Transition Period: Should We Think About Early Retesting in Patients with Idiopathic and Isolated GH Deficiency?

To investigate growth hormone (GH) secretion at the transition age, retesting of all subjects who have undergone GH replacement therapy is recommended when linear growth and pubertal development are complete to distinguish between transitional and persistent GH deficiency (GHD). Early retesting of children with idiopathic and isolated GHD (i.e., before the achievement of final height and/or the adult pubertal stage) can avoid possible over-treatment. Here, we report data from our population with idiopathic and isolated GHD to encourage changes in the management and timing of retesting. We recruited 31 patients (19 males) with idiopathic GHD who received recombinant GH (rGH) for at least 2 years. All of the patients were retested at the transition age at least 3 months after rGH discontinuation. Permanent GHD was defined as a GH peak of <19 ng/mL after administration of growth hormone–releasing hormone (GHRH) + arginine as a provocative test. Permanent GHD was confirmed in only five of 31 patients (16.13%). None of these patients presented low serum insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-1 levels (<−2 standard deviation score (SDS)). Only one male patient with an IGF-1 serum level lower than −2 SDS showed a normal GH stimulation response, with a GH peak of 44.99 ng/mL. Few patients with idiopathic and isolated GHD demonstrated persistence of the deficit when retested at the transition age, suggesting that the timing of retesting should be anticipated to avoid overtreatment.

Pre-treatment growth and IGF-I deficiency as main predictors of response to growth hormone therapy in neural models

Mathematical models have been applied in prediction of growth hormone treatment effectiveness in children since the end of 1990s. Usually they were multiple linear regression models; however, there are also examples derived by empirical non-linear methods. Proposed solution consists in application of machine learning technique - artificial neural networks - to analyse this problem. This new methodology, contrary to previous ones, allows detection of both linear and non-linear dependencies without assuming their character a priori The aims of this work included: development of models predicting separately growth during 1st year of treatment and final height as well as identification of important predictors and in-depth analysis of their influence on treatment's effectiveness. The models were derived on the basis of clinical data of 272 patients treated for at least 1 year, 133 of whom have already attained final height. Starting from models containing 17 and 20 potential predictors, respectively for 1st year and final height model, we were able to reduce their number to 9 and 10. Basing on the final models, IGF-I concentration and earlier growth were indicated as belonging to most important predictors of response to GH therapy, while results of GH secretion tests were automatically excluded as insignificant. Moreover, majority of the dependencies were observed to be non-linear, thus using neural networks seems to be reasonable approach despite it being more complex than previously applied methods.