Reverse phenotyping facilitates disease allele calling in exome sequencing of patients with CAKUT

Practical Approach to Congenital Anomalies of the Kidneys: Focus on Anomalies With Insufficient or Abnormal Nephron Development: Renal Dysplasia, Renal Hypoplasia, and Renal Tubular Dysgenesis

Congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract (CAKUT) accounts for up to 30% of antenatal congenital anomalies and is the main cause of kidney failure in children worldwide. This review focuses on practical approaches to CAKUT, particularly those with insufficient or abnormal nephron development, such as renal dysplasia, renal hypoplasia, and renal tubular dysgenesis. The review provides insights into the histological features, pathogenesis, mechanisms, etiologies, antenatal and postnatal presentation, management, and prognosis of these anomalies. Differential diagnoses are discussed as several syndromes may include CAKUT as a phenotypic component and renal dysplasia may occur in some ciliopathies, tumor predisposition syndromes, and inborn errors of metabolism. Diagnosis and genetic counseling for CAKUT are challenging, due to the extensive variability in presentation, genetic and phenotypic heterogeneity, and difficulties to assess postnatal lung and renal function on prenatal imaging. The review highlights the importance of perinatal autopsy and pathological findings in surgical specimens to establish the diagnosis and prognosis of CAKUT. The indications and the type of genetic testing are discussed. The aim is to provide essential insights into the practical approaches, diagnostic processes, and genetic considerations offering valuable guidance for pediatric and perinatal pathologists.

Genetic Contributions to Lower Urinary Tract Dysfunction

Lower urinary tract dysfunction (LUTD) can manifest as a spectrum of voiding symptoms in childhood, including urinary urgency, frequency, hesitancy, and incontinence. In severe cases, it can lead to frequent urinary tract infections, hydronephrosis, kidney scarring, and chronic kidney disease. Non-neurogenic neurogenic bladder (NNNB) is a diagnosis of exclusion in which children develop discoordination between the detrusor smooth muscle and external urethral sphincter in the absence of neurological or obstructive lesions, resulting in severe LUTD. Historically, such disorders of voiding were thought to result from behavioral maladaptation. However, it is now increasingly recognized that some individuals may have an underlying genetic etiology for their symptoms. Here, we performed exome sequencing for five probands with NNNB or other forms of severe LUTD, and we identified two individuals with monogenic etiologies for their symptoms. One individual had a homozygous exon 9 deletion in HPSE2 and another had a homozygous single amino acid deletion (p.Gly167del) in ARL6. We performed PCR experiments to identify the breakpoints of the HPSE2 exon 9 deletion and implicate microhomology-mediated end joining as a potential mechanism by which the deletion arose. These findings suggest that genetic testing should be considered for children with severe LUTD.

The expanded spectrum of human disease associated with GREB1L likely includes complex congenital heart disease

OBJECTIVE

GREB1L has been linked prenatally to Potter's sequence, as well as less severe anomalies of the kidney, uterus, inner ear, and heart. The full phenotypic spectrum is unknown. The purpose of this study was to characterize known and novel pre- and postnatal phenotypes associated with GREB1L.

METHODS

We solicited cases from the Fetal Sequencing Consortium, screened a population-based genomic database, and conducted a comprehensive literature search to identify disease cases associated with GREB1L. We present a detailed phenotypic spectrum and molecular changes.

RESULTS

One hundred twenty-seven individuals with 51 unique pathogenic or likely pathogenic GREB1L variants were identified. 24 (47%) variants were associated with isolated kidney anomalies, 19 (37%) with anomalies of multiple systems, including one case of hypoplastic left heart syndrome, five (10%) with isolated sensorineural hearing loss, two (4%) with isolated uterine agenesis; and one (2%) with isolated tetralogy of Fallot.

CONCLUSION

GREB1L may cause complex congenital heart disease (CHD) in humans. Clinicians should consider GREB1L testing in the setting of CHD, and cardiac screening in the setting of GREB1L variants.

Genetic and environmental factors driving congenital solitary functioning kidney

BACKGROUND

Congenital solitary functioning kidney (CSFK) is an anomaly predisposing to hypertension, albuminuria and chronic kidney disease. Its aetiology is complex and includes genetic and environmental factors. The role of gene-environment interactions (G×E), although relevant for other congenital anomalies, has not yet been investigated. Therefore, we performed a genome-wide G×E analysis with six preselected environmental factors to explore the role of these interactions in the aetiology of CSFK.

METHODS

In the AGORA (Aetiologic research into Genetic and Occupational/environmental Risk factors for Anomalies in children) data- and biobank, genome-wide single-nucleotide variant (SNV) data and questionnaire data on prenatal exposure to environmental risk factors were available for 381 CSFK patients and 598 healthy controls. Using a two-step strategy, we first selected independent significant SNVs associated with one of the six environmental risk factors. These SNVs were subsequently tested in G×E analyses using logistic regression models, with Bonferroni-corrected P-value thresholds based on the number of SNVs selected in step one.

RESULTS

In step one, 7-40 SNVs were selected per environmental factor, of which only rs3098698 reached statistical significance (P = .0016, Bonferroni-corrected threshold 0.0045) for interaction in step two. The interaction between maternal overweight and this SNV, which results in lower expression of the Arylsulfatase B (ARSB) gene, could be explained by lower insulin receptor activity in children heterozygous for rs3098698. Eight other G×E interactions had a P-value <.05, of which two were biologically plausible and warrant further study.

CONCLUSIONS

Interactions between genetic and environmental factors may contribute to the aetiology of CSFK. To better determine their role, large studies combining data on genetic and environmental risk factors are warranted.

The genetics and pathogenesis of CAKUT

Congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract (CAKUT) comprise a large variety of malformations that arise from defective kidney or urinary tract development and frequently lead to kidney failure. The clinical spectrum ranges from severe malformations, such as renal agenesis, to potentially milder manifestations, such as vesicoureteral reflux. Almost 50% of cases of chronic kidney disease that manifest within the first three decades of life are caused by CAKUT. Evidence suggests that a large number of CAKUT are genetic in origin. To date, mutations in ~54 genes have been identified as monogenic causes of CAKUT, contributing to 12-20% of the aetiology of the disease. Pathogenic copy number variants have also been shown to cause CAKUT and can be detected in 4-11% of patients. Furthermore, environmental and epigenetic factors can increase the risk of CAKUT. The discovery of novel CAKUT-causing genes is challenging owing to variable expressivity, incomplete penetrance and variable genotype-phenotype correlation. However, such a discovery could ultimately lead to improvements in the accurate molecular genetic diagnosis, assessment of prognosis and multidisciplinary clinical management of patients with CAKUT, potentially including personalized therapeutic approaches.

Recessive CHRM5 variant as a potential cause of neurogenic bladder

Neurogenic bladder is caused by disruption of neuronal pathways regulating bladder relaxation and contraction. In severe cases, neurogenic bladder can lead to vesicoureteral reflux, hydroureter, and chronic kidney disease. These complications overlap with manifestations of congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract (CAKUT). To identify novel monogenic causes of neurogenic bladder, we applied exome sequencing (ES) to our cohort of families with CAKUT. By ES, we have identified a homozygous missense variant (p.Gln184Arg) in CHRM5 (cholinergic receptor, muscarinic, 5) in a patient with neurogenic bladder and secondary complications of CAKUT. CHRM5 codes for a seven transmembrane-spanning G-protein-coupled muscarinic acetylcholine receptor. CHRM5 is shown to be expressed in murine and human bladder walls and is reported to cause bladder overactivity in Chrm5 knockout mice. We investigated CHRM5 as a potential novel candidate gene for neurogenic bladder with secondary complications of CAKUT. CHRM5 is similar to the cholinergic bladder neuron receptor CHRNA3, which Mann et al. published as the first monogenic cause of neurogenic bladder. However, functional in vitro studies did not reveal evidence to strengthen the status as a candidate gene. Discovering additional families with CHRM5 variants could help to further assess the genes' candidate status.

Prioritization of Monogenic Congenital Anomalies of the Kidney and Urinary Tract Candidate Genes with Existing Single-Cell Transcriptomics Data of the Human Fetal Kidney

INTRODUCTION

Congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract (CAKUT) are the most common cause of chronic kidney disease in the first 3 decades of life. Over 40 genes have been identified as causative for isolated human CAKUT. However, many genes remain unknown, and the prioritization of potential CAKUT candidate genes is challenging. To develop an independent approach to prioritize CAKUT candidate genes, we hypothesized that monogenic CAKUT genes are most likely co-expressed along a temporal axis during kidney development and that genes with coinciding high expression may represent strong novel CAKUT candidate genes.

METHODS

We analyzed single-cell mRNA (sc-mRNA) transcriptomics data of human fetal kidney for temporal sc-mRNA co-expression of 40 known CAKUT genes. A maximum of high expression in consecutive timepoints of kidney development was found for four of the 40 genes (EYA1, SIX1, SIX2, and ITGA8) in nephron progenitor cells a, b, c, d (NPCa-d). We concluded that NPCa-d are relevant for CAKUT pathogenesis and intersected two lists of CAKUT candidate genes resulting from unbiased whole-exome sequencing (WES) with the 100 highest expressed genes in NPCa-d.

RESULTS

Intersection of the 100 highest expressed genes in NPCa-d with WES-derived CAKUT candidate genes identified an overlap with the candidate genes KIF19, TRIM36, USP35, CHTF18, in each of which a biallelic variant was detected in different families with CAKUT.

CONCLUSION

Sc-mRNA expression data of human fetal kidney can be utilized to prioritize WES-derived CAKUT candidate genes. KIF19, TRIM36, USP35, and CHTF18 may represent strong novel candidate genes for CAKUT.

A Clinical Workflow for Cost-Saving High-Rate Diagnosis of Genetic Kidney Diseases

SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT

To optimize the diagnosis of genetic kidney disorders in a cost-effective manner, we developed a workflow based on referral criteria for in-person evaluation at a tertiary center, whole-exome sequencing, reverse phenotyping, and multidisciplinary board analysis. This workflow reached a diagnostic rate of 67%, with 48% confirming and 19% modifying the suspected clinical diagnosis. We obtained a genetic diagnosis in 64% of children and 70% of adults. A modeled cost analysis demonstrated that early genetic testing saves 20% of costs per patient. Real cost analysis on a representative sample of 66 patients demonstrated an actual cost reduction of 41%. This workflow demonstrates feasibility, performance, and economic effect for the diagnosis of genetic kidney diseases in a real-world setting.

BACKGROUND

Whole-exome sequencing (WES) increases the diagnostic rate of genetic kidney disorders, but accessibility, interpretation of results, and costs limit use in daily practice.

METHODS

Univariable analysis of a historical cohort of 392 patients who underwent WES for kidney diseases showed that resistance to treatments, familial history of kidney disease, extrarenal involvement, congenital abnormalities of the kidney and urinary tract and CKD stage ≥G2, two or more cysts per kidney on ultrasound, persistent hyperechoic kidneys or nephrocalcinosis on ultrasound, and persistent metabolic abnormalities were most predictive for genetic diagnosis. We prospectively applied these criteria to select patients in a network of nephrology centers, followed by centralized genetic diagnosis by WES, reverse phenotyping, and multidisciplinary board discussion.

RESULTS

We applied this multistep workflow to 476 patients with eight clinical categories (podocytopathies, collagenopathies, CKD of unknown origin, tubulopathies, ciliopathies, congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract, syndromic CKD, metabolic kidney disorders), obtaining genetic diagnosis for 319 of 476 patients (67.0%) (95% in 21 patients with disease onset during the fetal period or at birth, 64% in 298 pediatric patients, and 70% in 156 adult patients). The suspected clinical diagnosis was confirmed in 48% of the 476 patients and modified in 19%. A modeled cost analysis showed that application of this workflow saved 20% of costs per patient when performed at the beginning of the diagnostic process. Real cost analysis of 66 patients randomly selected from all categories showed actual cost reduction of 41%.

CONCLUSIONS

A diagnostic workflow for genetic kidney diseases that includes WES is cost-saving, especially if implemented early, and is feasible in a real-world setting.

A homozygous truncating ETV4 variant in a Nigerian family with congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract

Congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract (CAKUT) are the most prevalent cause of chronic kidney disease that manifests in children. To date ~23 different monogenic causes have been implicated in isolated forms of human CAKUT, but the vast majority remains elusive. In a previous study, we identified a homozygous missense variant in E26 transformation-specific (ETS) Variant Transcription Factor 4 (ETV4) causing CAKUT via dysregulation of the transcriptional function of ETV4, and a resulting abrogation of GDNF/RET/ETV4 signaling pathway. This CAKUT family remains the only family with an ETV4 variant reported so far. Here, we describe one additional CAKUT family with a homozygous truncating variant in ETV4 (p.(Lys6*)) that was identified by exome sequencing. The variant was found in an individual with isolated CAKUT displaying posterior urethral valves and renal dysplasia. The newly identified stop variant conceptually truncates the ETS_PEA3_N and ETS domains that regulate DNA-binding transcription factor activity. The variant has never been reported homozygously in the gnomAD database. To our knowledge, we here report the first CAKUT family with a truncating variant in ETV4, potentially causing the isolated CAKUT phenotype observed in the affected individual.

Genetic spectrum of CAKUT and risk factors for kidney failure: a pediatric multicenter cohort study

BACKGROUND

Congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tracts (CAKUT) are the leading cause of kidney failure in children with phenotypic and genotypic heterogeneity. Our objective was to describe the genetic spectrum and identify the risk factors for kidney failure in children with CAKUT.

METHODS

Clinical and genetic data were derived from a multicenter network (Chinese Children Genetic Kidney Disease Database, CCGKDD) and the Chigene database. A total of 925 children with CAKUT who underwent genetic testing from 2014 to 2020 across China were studied. Data for a total of 584 children wereobtained from the CCGKDD, including longitudinal data regarding kidney function. The risk factors for kidney failure were determined by the Kaplan-Meier method and Cox proportional hazards models.

RESULTS

A genetic diagnosis was established in 96 out of 925 (10.3%) children, including 72 (8%) with monogenic variants, 20 (2%) with copy number variants (CNVs), and 4 (0.4%)with major chromosomal anomalies. Patients with skeletal abnormalities were more likely to have large CNVs or abnormal karyotypes than monogenic variants. Eighty-two patients from the CCGKDD progressed to kidney failure at a median age of 13.0 (95% confidence interval, 12.4-13.6) years, and twenty-four were genetically diagnosed with variants of PAX2, TNXB, EYA1, HNF1B and GATA3 or the 48, XXYY karyotype. The multivariate analysis indicated that solitary kidney, posterior urethral valves, bilateral hypodysplasia, the presence of certain variants and premature birth were independent prognostic factors.

CONCLUSIONS

The genetic spectrum of CAKUT varies among different subphenotypes. The identified factors indicate areas that require special attention.

A Genome-Wide Association Study into the Aetiology of Congenital Solitary Functioning Kidney

Congenital solitary functioning kidney (CSFK) is a birth defect that occurs in 1:1500 children and predisposes them to kidney injury. Its aetiology is likely multifactorial. In addition to known monogenic causes and environmental risk factors, common genetic variation may contribute to susceptibility to CSFK. We performed a genome-wide association study among 452 patients with CSFK and two control groups of 669 healthy children and 5363 unaffected adults. Variants in two loci reached the genome-wide significance threshold of 5 × 10-8, and variants in 30 loci reached the suggestive significance threshold of 1 × 10-5. Of these, an identified locus with lead single nucleotide variant (SNV) rs140804918 (odds ratio 3.1, p-value = 1.4 × 10-8) on chromosome 7 was most promising due to its close proximity to HGF, a gene known to be involved in kidney development. Based on their known molecular functions, both KCTD20 and STK38 could explain the suggestive significant association with lead SNV rs148413365 on chromosome 6. Our findings need replication in an independent cohort of CSFK patients before they can be established definitively. However, our analysis suggests that common variants play a role in CSFK aetiology. Future research could enhance our understanding of the molecular mechanisms involved.

Disease mechanisms of monogenic congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract American Journal of Medical Genetics Part C

Congenital Anomalies of the Kidney and Urinary Tract (CAKUT) is a developmental disorder of the kidney and/or genito-urinary tract that results in end stage kidney disease (ESKD) in up to 50% of children. Despite the congenital nature of the disease, CAKUT accounts for almost 10% of adult onset ESKD. Multiple lines of evidence suggest that CAKUT is a Mendelian disorder, including the observation of familial clustering of CAKUT. Pathogenesis in CAKUT is embryonic in origin, with disturbances of kidney and urinary tract development resulting in a heterogeneous range of disease phenotypes. Despite polygenic and environmental factors being implicated, a significant proportion of CAKUT is monogenic in origin, with studies demonstrating single gene defects in 10%-20% of patients with CAKUT. Here, we review monogenic disease causation with emphasis on the etiological role of gene developmental pathways in CAKUT.

Clinical and Genetic Characterization of Patients with Bartter and Gitelman Syndrome

Bartter (BS) and Gitelman (GS) syndrome are autosomal recessive inherited tubulopathies, whose clinical diagnosis can be challenging, due to rarity and phenotypic overlap. Genotype-phenotype correlations have important implications in defining kidney and global outcomes. The aim of our study was to assess the diagnostic rate of whole-exome sequencing (WES) coupled with a bioinformatic analysis of copy number variations in a population of 63 patients with BS and GS from a single institution, and to explore genotype-phenotype correlations. We obtained a diagnostic yield of 86% (54/63 patients), allowing disease reclassification in about 14% of patients. Although some clinical and laboratory features were more commonly reported in patients with BS or GS, a significant overlap does exist, and age at onset, preterm birth, gestational age and nephro-calcinosis are frequently misleading. Finally, chronic kidney disease (CKD) occurs in about 30% of patients with BS or GS, suggesting that the long-term prognosis can be unfavorable. In our cohort the features associated with CKD were lower gestational age at birth and a molecular diagnosis of BS, especially BS type 1. The results of our study demonstrate that WES is useful in dealing with the phenotypic heterogeneity of these disorders, improving differential diagnosis and genotype-phenotype correlation.