Donor-derived cell-free DNA as a composite marker of acute lung allograft dysfunction in clinical care

Macrophage and CD8 T cell discordance are associated with acute lung allograft dysfunction progression

BACKGROUND

Acute lung allograft dysfunction (ALAD) is an imprecise syndrome denoting concern for the onset of chronic lung allograft dysfunction (CLAD). Mechanistic biomarkers are needed that stratify risk of ALAD progression to CLAD. We hypothesized that single cell investigation of bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) cells at the time of ALAD would identify immune cells linked to progressive graft dysfunction.

METHODS

We prospectively collected BAL from consenting lung transplant recipients for single cell RNA sequencing. ALAD was defined by a ≥10% decrease in FEV1 not caused by infection or acute rejection and samples were matched to BAL from recipients with stable lung function. We examined cell compositional and transcriptional differences across control, ALAD with decline, and ALAD with recovery groups. We also assessed cell-cell communication.

RESULTS

BAL was assessed for 17 ALAD cases with subsequent decline (ALAD declined), 13 ALAD cases that resolved (ALAD recovered), and 15 cases with stable lung function. We observed broad differences in frequencies of the 26 unique cell populations across groups (p = 0.02). A CD8 T cell (p = 0.04) and a macrophage cluster (p = 0.01) best identified ALAD declined from the ALAD recovered and stable groups. This macrophage cluster was distinguished by an anti-inflammatory signature and the CD8 T cell cluster resembled a Tissue Resident Memory subset. Anti-inflammatory macrophages signaled to activated CD8 T cells via class I HLA, fibronectin, and galectin pathways (p < 0.05 for each). Recipients with discordance between these cells had a nearly 5-fold increased risk of severe graft dysfunction or death (HR 4.6, 95% CI 1.1-19.2, adjusted p = 0.03). We validated these key findings in 2 public lung transplant genomic datasets.

CONCLUSIONS

BAL anti-inflammatory macrophages may protect against CLAD by suppressing CD8 T cells. These populations merit functional and longitudinal assessment in additional cohorts.

Nuances in the interpretation and utility of donor-derived cell-free DNA in lung transplantation following allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation - Case report

Respiratory complications following allogeneic HSCT can lead to severe morbidity and mortality. Lung transplantation (LT) is a potential treatment for select patients with late-onset non-infectious pulmonary complications post-HSCT. Donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) is a noninvasive biomarker for monitoring the health of allografts following LT. However, its utility in a multi-genome setting of LT after HSCT has not yet been clinically validated. Here we describe a case of a 75-year-old, male patient who underwent single-lung transplantation for BOS related to chronic GVHD and presented with persistently elevated dd-cfDNA levels. In a surveillance biopsy, the patient was diagnosed with mild acute cellular rejection at three months. The patient's lung function remained stable, and the reported dd-cfDNA levels decreased after the rejection episode but remained elevated above levels that would be considered quiescent for LT alone. In this unique setting, as 3 different genomes contributed to the dd-cfDNA% reported value, valuable insight was obtained by performing further analysis to separate the specific SNPs to identify the contribution of recipient, lung-donor, and HSCT-donor cfDNA. This study highlights the potential utility of dd-cfDNA in the multi-genome setting of lung transplant post-HSCT, nuances that need to be considered while interpreting the results, and its value in monitoring lung rejection.

Extreme elevations of donor-derived cell-free DNA increases the risk of chronic lung allograft dysfunction and death, even without clinical manifestations of disease

BACKGROUND

Lung transplant recipients are traditionally monitored with pulmonary function testing (PFT) and lung biopsy to detect post-transplant complications and guide treatment. Plasma donor-derived cell free DNA (dd-cfDNA) is a novel molecular approach of assessing allograft injury, including subclinical allograft dysfunction. The aim of this study was to determine if episodes of extreme molecular injury (EMI) in lung transplant recipients increases the risk of chronic lung allograft dysfunction (CLAD) or death.

METHODS

This multicenter prospective cohort study included 238 lung transplant recipients. Serial plasma samples were collected for dd-cfDNA measurement by shotgun sequencing. EMI was defined as a dd-cfDNA above the third quartile of levels observed for acute rejection (dd-cfDNA level of ≥5% occurring after 45 days post-transplant). EMI was categorized as Secondary if associated with co-existing acute rejection, infection or PFT decline; or Primary if not associated with these conditions.

RESULTS

EMI developed in 16% of patients at a median 343.5 (IQR: 177.3-535.5) days post-transplant. Over 50% of EMI episodes were classified as Primary. EMI was associated with an increased risk of severe CLAD or death (HR: 2.78, 95% CI: 1.26-6.22, p = 0.012). The risk remained consistent for the Primary EMI subgroup (HR: 2.34, 95% CI 1.18-4.85, p = 0.015). Time to first EMI episode was a significant predictor of the likelihood of developing CLAD or death (AUC=0.856, 95% CI=0.805-0.908, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Episodes of EMI in lung transplant recipients are often isolated and may not be detectable with traditional clinical monitoring approaches. EMI is associated with an increased risk of severe CLAD or death, independent of concomitant transplant complications.

The 2022 Banff Meeting Lung Report

The Lung Session of the 2022 16th Banff Foundation for Allograft Pathology Conference-held in Banff, Alberta-focused on non-rejection lung allograft pathology and novel technologies for the detection of allograft injury. A multidisciplinary panel reviewed the state-of-the-art of current histopathologic entities, serologic studies, and molecular practices, as well as novel applications of digital pathology with artificial intelligence, gene expression analysis, and quantitative image analysis of chest computerized tomography. Current states of need as well as prospective integration of the aforementioned tools and technologies for complete assessment of allograft injury and its impact on lung transplant outcomes were discussed. Key conclusions from the discussion were: (1) recognition of limitations in current standard of care assessment of lung allograft dysfunction; (2) agreement on the need for a consensus regarding the standardized approach to the collection and assessment of pathologic data, inclusive of all lesions associated with graft outcome (eg, non-rejection pathology); and (3) optimism regarding promising novel diagnostic modalities, especially minimally invasive, which should be integrated into large, prospective multicenter studies to further evaluate their utility in clinical practice for directing personalized therapies to improve graft outcomes.

Hypobaric hypoxia modulated structural characteristics of circulating cell-free DNA in high-altitude pulmonary edema

The utility of cell-free (cf) DNA has extended as a surrogate or clinical biomarker for various diseases. However, a more profound and expanded understanding of the diverse cfDNA population and its correlation with physiological phenotypes and environmental factors is imperative for using its full potential. The high-altitude (HA; altitude > 2,500 m above sea level) environment characterized by hypobaric hypoxia offers an observational case-control design to study the differential cfDNA profile in patients with high-altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE) (number of subjects, n = 112) and healthy HA sojourners (n = 111). The present study investigated cfDNA characteristics such as concentration, fragment length size, degree of integrity, and subfractions reflecting mitochondrial-cfDNA copies in the two groups. The total cfDNA level was significantly higher in patients with HAPE, and the level increased with increasing HAPE severity (P = 0.0036). A lower degree of cfDNA integrity of 0.346 in patients with HAPE (P = 0.001) indicated the prevalence of shorter cfDNA fragments in circulation in patients compared with the healthy HA sojourners. A significant correlation of cfDNA characteristics with the peripheral oxygen saturation levels in the patient group demonstrated the translational relevance of cfDNA molecules. The correlation was further supported by multivariate logistic regression and receiver operating characteristic curve. To our knowledge, our study is the first to highlight the association of higher cfDNA concentration, a lower degree of cfDNA integrity, and increased mitochondrial-derived cfDNA population with HAPE disease severity. Further deep profiling of cfDNA fragments, which preserves cell-type specific genetic and epigenetic features, can provide dynamic physiological responses to hypoxia.NEW & NOTEWORTHY This study observed altered cell-free (cf) DNA fragment patterns in patients with high-altitude pulmonary edema and the significant correlation of these patterns with peripheral oxygen saturation levels. This suggests deep profiling of cfDNA fragments in the future may identify genetic and epigenetic mechanisms underlying physiological and pathophysiological responses to hypoxia.

Organizing pneumonia is associated with molecular allograft injury and the development of antibody-mediated rejection

BACKGROUND

The association between organizing pneumonia (OP) after lung transplantation with the development of acute rejection (AR) remains undefined. In addition, molecular allograft injury, as measured by donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA), during episodes of OP and its relationship to episodes of AR, chronic lung allograft dysfunction (CLAD), or death is unknown.

METHODS

This multicenter, prospective cohort study collected serial plasma samples from 188 lung transplant recipients for dd-cfDNA at the time of bronchoscopy with biopsy. Multivariable Cox regression was used to analyze the association between OP with the development of AR (antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) and acute cellular rejection (ACR)), CLAD, and death. Multivariable models were performed to test the association of dd-cfDNA at OP with the risk of AR, CLAD, or death.

RESULTS

In multivariable analysis, OP was associated with increased risk of AMR (hazard ratio (HR) = 2.26, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.04-4.92, p = 0.040) but not ACR (HR = 1.29, 95% CI: 0.66-2.5, p = 0.45) or the composite outcome of CLAD or death (HR = 0.88, 95% CI, 0.47-1.65, p = 0.69). Median levels of dd-cfDNA were higher in OP compared to stable controls (1.33% vs 0.43%, p = 0.0006). Multivariable analysis demonstrated that levels of dd-cfDNA at diagnosis of OP were associated with increased risk of both AMR (HR = 1.29, 95% CI 1.03-1.62, p = 0.030) and death (HR = 1.16, 95% CI, 1.02-1.31, p = 0.026).

CONCLUSIONS

OP is independently associated with an increased risk of AMR but not CLAD or death. The degree of molecular allograft injury at the diagnosis of OP may further predict the risk of AMR and death.

Pulmonary and esophageal function in lung transplantation: Fundamental principles and clinical application

The lungs and esophagus have a close anatomical and physiological relationship. Over the years, reflux-induced pulmonary injury has gained wider recognition, but the full effects of pulmonary disease on esophageal function are still unknown. Intrathoracic pressure dynamics potentially affect esophageal function, especially in patients with end-stage lung disease, both obstructive and restrictive. Lung transplantation is the only viable option for patients with end-stage pulmonary disease and has provided us with a unique opportunity to study these effects as transplantation restores the intrathoracic environment. Esophageal and foregut functional testing before and after transplantation provide insights into the pathophysiology of the foregut-pulmonary axis, such as how underlying pulmonary disease and intrathoracic pressure changes affect esophageal physiology. This review summarizes the available literature and shares the research experience of a lung transplant center, covering topics such as pre- and posttransplant foregut function, esophageal motility in lung transplant recipients, immune-mediated mechanisms of graft rejection associated with gastroesophageal reflux, and the role of antireflux surgery in this population.

Molecular monitoring of lung allograft health: is it ready for routine clinical use?

Maintenance of long-term lung allograft health in lung transplant recipients (LTRs) requires a fine balancing act between providing sufficient immunosuppression to reduce the risk of rejection whilst at the same time not over-immunosuppressing individuals and exposing them to the myriad of immunosuppressant drug side-effects that can cause morbidity and mortality. At present, lung transplant physicians only have limited and rather blunt tools available to assist them with this task. Although therapeutic drug monitoring provides clinically useful information about single time point and longitudinal exposure of LTRs to immunosuppressants, it lacks precision in determining the functional level of immunosuppression that an individual is experiencing. There is a significant gap in our ability to monitor lung allograft health and therefore tailor optimal personalised immunosuppression regimens. Molecular diagnostics performed on blood, bronchoalveolar lavage or lung tissue that can detect early signs of subclinical allograft injury, differentiate rejection from infection or distinguish cellular from humoral rejection could offer clinicians powerful tools in protecting lung allograft health. In this review, we look at the current evidence behind molecular monitoring in lung transplantation and ask if it is ready for routine clinical use. Although donor-derived cell-free DNA and tissue transcriptomics appear to be the techniques with the most immediate clinical potential, more robust data are required on their performance and additional clinical value beyond standard of care.

Circulating donor-derived cell-free DNA as a marker for rejection after lung transplantation

Objective

Recently, circulating donor-derive cell free DNA (dd-cfDNA) has gained growing attention in the field of solid organ transplantation. The aim of the study was to analyze circulating dd-cfDNA levels in graft rejection, ACR and AMR separately for each rejection type compared with non-rejection, and assessed the diagnostic potential of dd-cfDNA levels in predicting graft rejection after lung transplantation.

Methods

A systematic search for relevant articles was conducted on Medline, Web of Science, China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), and Wanfang databases without restriction of languages. The search date ended on June 1, 2023. STATA software was used to analyze the difference between graft rejection, ACR, AMR and stable controls, and evaluate the diagnostic performance of circulating dd-cfDNA in detecting graft rejection.

Results

The results indicated that circulating dd-cfDNA levels in graft rejection, ACR, and AMR were significantly higher than non-rejection (graft rejection: SMD=1.78, 95% CI: 1.31-2.25, I2 = 88.6%, P< 0.001; ACR: SMD=1.03, 95% CI: 0.47-1.59, I2 = 89.0%, P < 0.001; AMR: SMD= 1.78, 95% CI: 1.20-2.35, I2 = 89.8%, P < 0.001). Circulating dd-cfDNA levels distinguished graft rejection from non-rejection with a pooled sensitivity of 0.87 (95% CI: 0.80-0.92) and a pooled specificity of 0.82 (95% CI: 0.76-0.86). The corresponding SROC yield an AUROC of 0.90 (95% CI: 0.87-0.93).

Conclusion

Circulating dd-cfDNA could be used as a non-invasive biomarker to distinguish the patients with graft rejection from normal stable controls.

Systematic Review Registration

https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/, identifier CRD42023440467.

Relative Change in Donor-Derived Cell-free DNA is Superior to Absolute Values for Diagnosis of Acute Lung Allograft Dysfunction

Donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA%) is a biomarker of early acute lung allograft dysfunction (ALAD), with a value of ≥1.0% indicating injury. Whether dd-cfDNA% is a useful biomarker in patients >2 y posttransplant is unknown. Our group previously demonstrated that median dd-cfDNA% in lung recipients ≥2 y posttransplant without ALAD was 0.45%. In that cohort, biologic variability of dd-cfDNA% was estimated by a reference change value (RCV) of 73%, suggesting that change exceeding 73% may be pathologic. In this study, we aimed to determine whether dd-cfDNA% variability or absolute thresholds are optimal for detecting ALAD.

Methods

We prospectively measured plasma dd-cfDNA% every 3 to 4 mo in patients ≥2 y post-lung transplant. ALAD was defined as infection, acute cellular rejection, possible antibody-mediated rejection, or change in forced expiratory volume in 1 s >10%, and was adjudicated retrospectively. We analyzed area under the curve for RCV and absolute dd-cfDNA% and reported performance of RCV ≥73% versus absolute value >1% for discriminating ALAD.

Results

Seventy-one patients had ≥2 baseline measurements of dd-cfDNA%; 30 developed ALAD. RCV of dd-cfDNA% at ALAD had a greater area under the receiver operator characteristic curve than absolute dd-cfDNA% values (0.87 versus 0.69, P = 0.018). Test characteristics of RCV >73% for ALAD diagnosis were sensitivity 87%, specificity 78%, positive predictive value 74%, and negative predictive value 89%. In contrast, dd-cfDNA% ≥1% had sensitivity 50%, specificity 78%, positive predictive value 63%, and negative predictive value 68%.

Conclusions

Relative change in dd-cfDNA% has improved test characteristics for diagnosing ALAD compared with absolute values.

Pig heart and lung xenotransplantation: Present status

The recent pig heart transplant in a patient at the University of Maryland Medical Center has stimulated renewed interest in the xenotransplantation of organs from genetically engineered pigs. The barriers to the use of pigs as sources of organs have largely been overcome by 2 approaches - (1) the deletion of expression of the three known pig carbohydrate xenoantigens against which humans have preformed antibodies, and (2) the transgenic introduction of human 'protective' proteins, such as complement-regulatory proteins. These gene modifications, coupled with immunosuppressive therapy based on blockade of the CD40/CD154 costimulation pathway, have resulted in survival of baboons with life-supporting pig heart grafts for almost 9 months. The initial clinical success at the University of Maryland reinforces encouraging preclinical results. It suggests that pig hearts are likely to provide an effective bridge to an allotransplant, but their utility for destination therapy remains uncertain. Because of additional complex immunobiological problems, the same approach has been less successful in preclinical lung xenograft transplantation, where survival is still measured in days or weeks. The first formal clinical trials of pig heart transplantation may include patients who do not have access to an allotransplant, those with contraindications for mechanical circulatory support, those in need of retransplantation or with a high level of panel-reactive antibodies. Infants with complex congenital heart disease, should also be considered.

Why Cell-Free DNA Can Be a “Game Changer” for Lung Allograft Monitoring for Rejection and Infection

Purpose of Review

Although there has been improvement in short-term clinical outcomes for patients following lung transplant (LT), advances have not translated into longer-term allograft survival. Furthermore, invasive biopsies are still standard of practice for monitoring LT recipients for allograft injury. We review the relevant literature supporting the role of using plasma donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) as a non-invasive biomarker for LT allograft injury surveillance and discuss future research directions.

Recent Findings

Accumulating data has demonstrated that dd-cfDNA is associated with molecular and cellular injury due to acute (cellular and antibody-mediated) rejection, chronic lung allograft dysfunction, and relevant infectious pathogens. Strong performance in distinguishing rejection and allograft injury from stable patients has set the stage for clinical trials to assess dd-cfDNA utility for surveillance of LT patients. Research investigating the potential role of dd-cfDNA methylation signatures to map injured tissue and cell-free DNA in detecting allograft injury-related pathogens is ongoing.

Summary

There is an amassed breadth of clinical data to support a role for dd-cfDNA in monitoring rejection and other forms of allograft injury. Rigorously designed, robust clinical trials that encompass the diversity in patient demographics are paramount to furthering our understanding and adoption of plasma dd-cfDNA for surveillance of lung allograft health.

Lymphocytic Airway Inflammation in Lung Allografts

Lung transplant remains a key therapeutic option for patients with end stage lung disease but short- and long-term survival lag other solid organ transplants. Early ischemia-reperfusion injury in the form of primary graft dysfunction (PGD) and acute cellular rejection are risk factors for chronic lung allograft dysfunction (CLAD), a syndrome of airway and parenchymal fibrosis that is the major barrier to long term survival. An increasing body of research suggests lymphocytic airway inflammation plays a significant role in these important clinical syndromes. Cytotoxic T cells are observed in airway rejection, and transcriptional analysis of airways reveal common cytotoxic gene patterns across solid organ transplant rejection. Natural killer (NK) cells have also been implicated in the early allograft damage response to PGD, acute rejection, cytomegalovirus, and CLAD. This review will examine the roles of lymphocytic airway inflammation across the lifespan of the allograft, including: 1) The contribution of innate lymphocytes to PGD and the impact of PGD on the adaptive immune response. 2) Acute cellular rejection pathologies and the limitations in identifying airway inflammation by transbronchial biopsy. 3) Potentiators of airway inflammation and heterologous immunity, such as respiratory infections, aspiration, and the airway microbiome. 4) Airway contributions to CLAD pathogenesis, including epithelial to mesenchymal transition (EMT), club cell loss, and the evolution from constrictive bronchiolitis to parenchymal fibrosis. 5) Protective mechanisms of fibrosis involving regulatory T cells. In summary, this review will examine our current understanding of the complex interplay between the transplanted airway epithelium, lymphocytic airway infiltration, and rejection pathologies.

Cell-free DNA in lung transplantation: research tool or clinical workhorse?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Recent evidence indicates that plasma donor-derived cell-free DNA (dd-cfDNA) is a sensitive biomarker for the detection of underlying allograft injury, including rejection and infection. In this review, we will cover the latest evidence revolving around dd-cfDNA in lung transplantation and its role in both advancing mechanistic insight into disease states in lung transplant recipients as well as its potential clinical utility.

RECENT FINDINGS

Plasma dd-cfDNA increases in the setting of allograft injury, including in primary graft dysfunction, acute cellular rejection, antibody-mediated rejection and infection. Dd-cfDNA has demonstrated good performance characteristics for the detection of various allograft injury states, most notably with a high negative-predictive value for detection of acute rejection. Elevated levels of dd-cfDNA in the early posttransplant period, reflecting molecular evidence of lung allograft injury, are associated with increased risk of chronic lung allograft dysfunction and death.

SUMMARY

As a quantitative, molecular biomarker of lung allograft injury, dd-cfDNA holds great promise in clinical and research settings for advancing methods of posttransplant surveillance monitoring, diagnosis of allograft injury states, monitoring adequacy of immunosuppression, risk stratification and unlocking pathophysiological mechanisms of various disease.