Colorectal dysplasia in chronic inflammatory bowel disease: a contemporary consensus classification and interobserver study

Clinicopathologic and Molecular Characterization of Inflammatory Bowel Disease-Associated Neuroendocrine Carcinomas and Mixed Neuroendocrine-Non-Neuroendocrine Neoplasms

The pathogenesis of neuroendocrine carcinoma (NEC) and mixed neuroendocrine-non-neuroendocrine neoplasms (MiNEN) in the gastrointestinal tract remains poorly understood. This study seeks to characterize the clinicopathologic and molecular features of NEC/MiNEN in patients with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). Eighteen surgically resected IBD-associated intestinal carcinomas with a minimum of 30% neuroendocrine component were collected from 6 academic centers and compared to a control group of 12 IBD-associated carcinomas lacking neuroendocrine differentiation. Both groups exhibited a male predominance and similar age distribution. The NEC/MiNEN group was more likely to have a higher percentage of Crohn's disease (9/18 vs. 1/12, P=0.024), occur in the rectum (9/18 vs. 3/12) and small intestine (4/18 vs. 0/12) (P<0.01), be diagnosed on resection without a preceding biopsy (6/18 vs. 0/12, P=0.057), and have unidentifiable precursor lesions (10/18 vs. 1/12, P=0.018) than the control group. Synchronous carcinoma, advanced tumor stage (pT3 and pT4), and lymph node metastasis occurred at similar rates; however, the NEC/MiNEN group had a higher incidence of angiovascular invasion (14/18 vs. 4/12, P=0.024), distant metastasis (8/18 vs. 1/12, P=0.049), mortality (8/18 vs. 2/12, P=0.058), and worse survival (Kaplan-Meier, P=0.023) than the control group. All tested cases were mismatch repair proficient. A Ki-67 proliferation index ranged from 25% to 100%. Next-generation sequencing in 11 NEC/MiNEN cases revealed low tumor mutational burdens but complex genetic abnormalities commonly involving TP53 (9/11, 82%), FBXW7 (4/11, 36%), and APC (3/11, 27%), with the other genetic alterations randomly occurring in one or two cases. The neuroendocrine component, which shared similar molecular alterations as the non-neuroendocrine component, was subcategorized into intermediate (G3a)- and high-grade (G3b); the higher-grade correlated with more genetic alterations. In conclusion, IBD-associated NEC/MiNEN shows diverse histologic features, variable precursor lesions, intricate genetic abnormalities, and aggressive biologic behavior. The classification and grading of GI-NEC/MiNEN may be refined for better clinical management.

Dysplasia Detected in Patients With Serrated Epithelial Change Is Frequently Associated With an Invisible or Flat Endoscopic Appearance, Nonconventional Dysplastic Features, and Advanced Neoplasia

The significance of serrated epithelial change (SEC), defined as endoscopically invisible hyperplastic polyp (HP)-like mucosal change identified in patients with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), remains unclear. Although some studies reported an increased risk of synchronous and/or metachronous colorectal neoplasia in patients with SEC, including advanced neoplasia (high-grade dysplasia or colorectal cancer), the development of SEC is not significantly associated with increased colonic inflammation. This contrasts with the reported positive correlation between increased colonic inflammation and the risk of colorectal neoplasia in ulcerative colitis, arguing against the notion that SEC may represent a form of dysplasia. As such, this study aimed to characterize the features of synchronous and metachronous dysplasia detected in patients with SEC to identify factors contributing to the increased risk of colorectal neoplasia, including advanced neoplasia, observed in a subset of these patients. Clinicopathologic features of 46 IBD patients with SEC (n=109) and synchronous and/or metachronous dysplasia (n=153) were analyzed. All dysplastic lesions were subtyped as either conventional or nonconventional dysplasia. As controls, 45 IBD patients with endoscopically visible or polypoid HP (n=75) and synchronous and/or metachronous dysplasia (n=87) were analyzed. The SEC group included 28 (61%) men and 18 (39%) women with a mean age of 58 years and a long history of IBD (mean duration: 23 years). The majority of patients (n=34; 74%) had ulcerative colitis, and 12 (26%) had Crohn's disease. Thirty-nine (85%) patients had a history of pancolitis, and 2 (4%) had concomitant primary sclerosing cholangitis. Twenty-seven (59%) patients had multifocal SEC. SEC was predominantly found in the left colon (n=52; 48%) and rectum (n=34; 31%). Dysplasia in the SEC group was often endoscopically invisible or flat (n=42; 27%) and demonstrated nonconventional dysplastic features (n=49; 32%). Six nonconventional subtypes were identified in the SEC group, including 17 (11%) dysplasia with increased Paneth cell differentiation, 12 (8%) hypermucinous dysplasia, 8 (5%) crypt cell dysplasia, 7 (5%) goblet cell deficient dysplasia, 3 (2%) sessile serrated lesion-like dysplasia, and 2 (1%) traditional serrated adenoma-like dysplasia. Advanced neoplasia was detected in 11 (24%) patients. The SEC group was more likely to have nonconventional dysplasia (32%, P<0.001), invisible/flat dysplasia (27%, P<0.001), and advanced neoplasia (24%, P<0.001) than the control group (7%, 2%, and 0%, respectively). High-risk nonconventional subtypes (ie, hypermucinous, crypt cell, and goblet cell deficient dysplasias) accounted for 18% of all dysplastic lesions in the SEC group, which were not seen in the control group (P<0.001). The SEC group (n=35; 76%) also had a higher rate of concordance between the location of SEC and the area of synchronous/metachronous dysplasia than the control group (n=22; 49%) (P=0.007). In conclusion, dysplasia detected in patients with SEC is often endoscopically invisible/flat (27%), nonconventional (32%, including the high-risk subtypes), and found in the same colonic segment as SEC (76%), which may in part explain why some patients with SEC are associated with an increased risk of colorectal neoplasia, including advanced neoplasia. The finding of SEC may warrant a careful follow-up colonoscopy with increased random biopsy sampling, especially in the segment of colon with SEC.

Molecular profiling of visible polypoid and invisible conventional intestinal-type low-grade dysplasia in patients with idiopathic inflammatory bowel disease

AIMS

Little is known about the molecular features of visible polyps with low-grade intestinal-type dysplasia in patients with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). To better understand their origins and biological potential, we sought to genomically profile these lesions and compare them with invisible low-grade dysplasia and sporadic adenomas from non-IBD patients.

METHODS

22 polyps within areas of colitis, 13 polyps outside areas of colitis, 10 foci of invisible dysplasia from patients with IBD and 6 sporadic tubular adenomas from non-IBD patients were analysed using the OncoPanel assay.

RESULTS

Polyps arising in areas of colitis showed a greater spectrum of mutations, including APC, KRAS, FBXW7, TP53, ARID1A and TCF7L2. Polyps outside colitis and non-IBD sporadic adenomas showed a limited mutational profile, with APC and CTNNB1 mutations. Invisible dysplasia was characterised by TP53, CTNNB1 and KRAS alterations. Compared with dysplastic polyps, none of the invisible dysplastic foci showed APC alterations (73%-within colitis; p=0.0001, 92%-outside colitis; p<0.0001, 83%-sporadic adenomas; p=0.001). TP53 mutations were significantly higher in invisible dysplasia (50%) compared with polyps within colitis (9%; p=0.02) and outside colitis (8%; p=0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Molecular alterations in visible low-grade dysplastic polyps with conventional intestinal-type dysplasia from patients with IBD and sporadic adenomas from non-IBD patients overlap significantly. APC alterations appear to play a major role in the development of visible low-grade dysplastic lesions in patients with IBD, regardless of background colitis. As with IBD-associated colorectal cancers, TP53 mutations are an early event in the development of invisible, low-grade conventional intestinal-type dysplasia in patients with IBD.

Nonconventional Dysplasia is Frequently Associated With Goblet Cell Deficient and Serrated Variants of Colonic Adenocarcinoma in Inflammatory Bowel Disease

Various subtypes of nonconventional dysplasia have been recently described in inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). We hypothesized that goblet cell deficient dysplasia and serrated dysplasia may be the primary precursor lesions for goblet cell deficient (GCDAC) and serrated (SAC) variants of colonic adenocarcinoma, respectively. Clinicopathologic features of 23 GCDAC and 10 SAC colectomy cases were analyzed. All dysplastic lesions found adjacent to the colorectal cancers (n = 22 for GCDACs and n = 10 for SACs) were subtyped as conventional, nonconventional, or mixed-type dysplasia. As controls, 12 IBD colectomy cases with well to moderately differentiated adenocarcinoma that lacked any mucinous, signet ring cell, low-grade tubuloglandular, or serrated features while retaining goblet cells throughout the tumor (at least 50% of the tumor) were evaluated. The cohort consisted of 19 (58%) men and 14 (42%) women, with a mean age of 53 years and a long history of IBD (mean duration: 18 y). Twenty-seven (82%) patients had ulcerative colitis. GCDACs (57%) were more often flat or invisible than SACs (10%) and controls (25%; P = 0.023). The GCDAC and SAC groups were more likely to show lymphovascular invasion (GCDAC group: 52%, SAC group: 50%, control group: 0%, P = 0.001) and lymph node metastasis (GCDAC group: 39%, SAC group: 50%, control group: 0%, P = 0.009) than the control group. Notably, GCDACs and SACs were more frequently associated with nonconventional dysplasia than controls (GCDAC group: 77%, SAC group: 40%, control group: 0%, P < 0.001). Goblet cell deficient dysplasia (73%) was the most prevalent dysplastic subtype associated with GCDACs ( P = 0.049), whereas dysplasias featuring a serrated component (60%) were most often associated with SACs ( P = 0.001). The GCDAC group (75%) had a higher rate of macroscopically flat or invisible synchronous dysplasia compared with the SAC (20%) and control (33%) groups ( P = 0.045). Synchronous dysplasia demonstrated nonconventional dysplastic features more frequently in the GCDAC (69%) and SAC (40%) groups compared with the control group (0%; P = 0.016). In conclusion, goblet cell deficient dysplasia and dysplasias featuring a serrated component could potentially serve as high-risk markers for GCDACs and SACs, respectively.

Increased Active Inflammation in the Colon is Not a Reliable Predictor of an Elevated Risk of Dysplasia in Patients With Primary Sclerosing Cholangitis and Ulcerative Colitis

Although the increased risk of colorectal neoplasia in patients with both primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC) and ulcerative colitis (UC; termed PSC-UC) is well documented, the mechanism through which concomitant PSC increases the risk of colorectal neoplasia remains unclear. Given that the risk of colorectal neoplasia in UC is positively correlated with increased histologic inflammation, this study sought to investigate whether increased histologic inflammation could be used to stratify the risk of dysplasia development in patients with PSC-UC. Twenty patients with PSC-UC and dysplasia were compared with 30 control patients with PSC-UC who had no history of neoplasia. For each patient, all surveillance biopsies were scored using a 4-point scoring system: (1) no epithelial neutrophils = 0, (2) cryptitis only = 1, (3) cryptitis plus crypt abscess in <50% of crypts = 2, and (4) crypt abscess in ≥50% of crypts, erosion, neutrophilic exudate, and/or ulceration = 3. A score was designated for each biopsy, and both mean and maximum inflammation scores were calculated from all biopsies taken during each colonoscopy. The inflammation burden score was calculated for each surveillance interval by multiplying the average maximum score between each pair of surveillance episodes by the length of the surveillance interval in years. The average scores derived from all colonoscopies for each patient were used to determine the patient's overall mean, maximum, and inflammation burden scores. In both the dysplasia and control groups, the 3 summative inflammation scores were calculated independently for the entire colon, right colon, and left colon. The dysplasia group consisted of 14 (70%) men and 6 (30%) women, with a mean age of 27 years at UC diagnosis and a long history of pancolitis (mean duration: 17 y). A total of 49 dysplastic lesions were detected in the dysplasia group, and 8 (40%) of the 20 patients had multifocal dysplasia. The majority of dysplastic lesions belonged to nonconventional subtypes (n = 28; 57%) and were located in the right colon (n = 37; 76%). Irrespective of the colon segment, there was no significant difference in the 3 summative inflammation scores between the dysplasia and control groups (P > 0.05). However, in each group, the 3 summative inflammation scores were significantly higher in the right colon than in the left colon (P< 0.05). In conclusion, patients with PSC-UC exhibit increased histologic inflammation in the right colon compared with the left colon, regardless of the presence of dysplasia. Although this may provide an explanation for the predominance of right-sided colorectal neoplasia in patients with PSC-UC, increased histologic inflammation does not reliably predict an elevated risk of dysplasia in patients with PSC-UC. These findings reinforce the current recommendation for annual endoscopic surveillance for all patients with PSC-UC, irrespective of the extent and severity of inflammation.

Pathology and Clinical Significance of Inflammatory Bowel Disease-Associated Colorectal Dysplastic Lesions

Timely diagnosis and effective management of colorectal dysplasia play a vital role in preventing mortality from colorectal cancer in patients with chronic inflammatory bowel disease. This review provides a contemporary overview of the pathologic and endoscopic classification of dysplasia in inflammatory bowel disease, their roles in determining surveillance and management algorithms, and emerging diagnostic and therapeutic approaches that might further enhance patient management.

Recently described types of dysplasia associated with IBD: tips and clues for the practising pathologist

Longstanding inflammatory bowel disease (especially in patients with severely active disease or primary sclerosing cholangitis) is associated with an increased risk of developing dysplasia and adenocarcinoma. This review covers critical clinical aspects, such as risk factors and screening endoscopy basics, emphasising the SCENIC (Surveillance for Colorectal Endoscopic Neoplasia Detection in Inflammatory Bowel Disease International Consensus) guidelines. The histopathological and molecular features of both conventional (adenomatous) dysplasia and the non-conventional subtypes (hypermucinous dysplasia, goblet cell-deficient dysplasia, crypt cell dysplasia, serrated dysplasias) are discussed with an emphasis on challenging diagnostic areas and helpful tips to allow correct categorisation by the practising pathologist.