Differential reactivity of individual zinc ions in clusters from bacterial metallothioneins

Differentiated Zn(II) binding affinities in animal, plant, and bacterial metallothioneins define their zinc buffering capacity at physiological pZn

Metallothioneins (MTs) are small, Cys-rich proteins present in various but not all organisms, from bacteria to humans. They participate in zinc and copper metabolism, toxic metals detoxification, and protection against reactive species. Structurally, they contain one or multiple domains, capable of binding a variable number of metal ions. For experimental convenience, biochemical characterization of MTs is mainly performed on Cd(II)-loaded proteins, frequently omitting or limiting Zn(II) binding features and related functions. Here, by choosing 10 MTs with relatively well-characterized structures from animals, plants, and bacteria, we focused on poorly investigated Zn(II)-to-protein affinities, stability-structure relations, and the speciation of individual complexes. For that purpose, MTs were characterized in terms of stoichiometry, pH-dependent Zn(II) binding, and competition with chromogenic and fluorescent probes. To shed more light on protein folding and its relation with Zn(II) affinity, reactivity of variously Zn(II)-loaded MTs was studied by (5,5'-dithiobis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) oxidation in the presence of mild chelators. The results show that animal and plant MTs, despite their architectural differences, demonstrate the same affinities to Zn(II), varying from nano- to low picomolar range. Bacterial MTs bind Zn(II) more tightly but, importantly, with different affinities from low picomolar to low femtomolar range. The presence of weak, moderate, and tight zinc sites is related to the folding mechanisms and internal electrostatic interactions. Differentiated affinities of all MTs define their zinc buffering capacity required for Zn(II) donation and acceptance at various free Zn(II) concentrations (pZn levels). The data demonstrate critical roles of individual Zn(II)-depleted MT species in zinc buffering processes.

The Response of the Soil Microbiome to Contamination with Cadmium, Cobalt and Nickel in Soil Sown with Brassica napus

Soil fertility is determined by biological diversity at all levels of life, from genes to entire biocenoses. The aim of this study was to evaluate bacterial diversity in soil contaminated with Cd2+, Co2+ and Ni2+ and sown with Brassica napus. This is an important consideration because soil-dwelling microorganisms support phytoremediation and minimize the adverse effects of heavy metals on the environment. Microbial counts, the influence (IFHM) of Cd2+, Co2+ and Ni2+ on microorganisms, the colony development (CD) index, the ecophysiological diversity (EP) index and genetic diversity of bacteria were determined under controlled conditions. Soil contamination with Cd2+, Co2+ and Ni2+ significantly influenced microbial diversity and increased the values of CD and EP indices. The tested heavy metals decreased the genetic diversity of bacteria, in particular in the phyla Actinobacteria and Proteobacteria. Bacteria of the genera Arthrobacter, Devosia, Kaistobacter, Paenibacillus, Phycicoccus, Rhodoplanes and Thermomonas were identified in both contaminated and non-contaminated soil. These bacteria are highly resistant to soil contamination with Cd2+, Co2+ and Ni2+.

Characterization analysis and heavy metal-binding properties of CsMTL3 in Escherichia coli

Members of the metallothionein (MT) superfamily are involved in coordinating transition metal ions. In plants, MT family members are characterized by their arrangement of Cys residues. In this study, one member of the MT superfamily, CsMTL3, was characterized from a complementary DNA (cDNA) library from young cucumber fruit; CsMTL3 is predicted to encode a 64 amino acid protein with a predicted molecular mass of 6.751 kDa. Phylogenetic analysis identified it as a type 3 family member as the arrangement of N-terminal Cys residues was different from that of MT-like 2. Heterologous expression of CsMTL3 in Escherichia coli improved their heavy metal tolerance, particularly to Cd2+ and Cu2+, and led to increased uptake of Cd2+ and Cu2+; increased uptake was also observed for cells expressing Arabidopsis thaliana metallothionein 3 (AtMT3) and phytochelatin-like (PCL), with greatest uptake in PCL-expressing cells. These findings demonstrate that CsMTL3 can improve metal tolerance, especially for Cd2+ ions, when heterologously expressed in E. coli, and suggest that the composition and arrangement of N-terminal Cys residues are associated with binding capacity and preference for different metal ions.

Differential reactivity of closely related zinc(II)-binding metallothioneins from the plant Arabidopsis thaliana

The dynamics of metal binding to and transfer from metalloproteins involved in metal homeostasis are important for understanding cellular distribution of metal ions. The dicotyledonous plant Arabidopsis thaliana has two type 4 seed-specific metallothionein homologues, MT4a and MT4b, with likely roles in zinc(II) homeostasis. These two metallothioneins are 84% identical, with full conservation of all metal-binding cysteine and histidine residues. Yet, differences in their spatial and temporal expression patterns suggested divergence in their biological roles. To investigate whether biological functions are reflected in molecular properties, we compare aspects of zinc(II)-binding dynamics of full-length MT4a and MT4b, namely the pH dependence of zinc(II) binding and protein folding, and zinc(II) transfer to the chelator EDTA. UV-Vis and NMR spectroscopies as well as native electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry consistently showed that transfer from Zn6MT4a is considerably faster than from Zn6MT4b, with pseudo-first-order rate constants for the fastest observed step of k obs = 2.8 × 10-4 s-1 (MT4b) and k obs = 7.5 × 10-4 s-1 (MT4a) (5 µM protein, 500 µM EDTA, 25 mM Tris buffer, pH 7.33, 298 K). 2D heteronuclear NMR experiments allowed locating the most labile zinc(II) ions in domain II for both proteins. 3D homology models suggest that reactivity of this domain is governed by the local environment around the mononuclear Cys2His2 site that is unique to type 4 MTs. Non-conservative amino acid substitutions in this region affect local electrostatics as well as whole-domain dynamics, with both effects rendering zinc(II) ions bound to MT4a more reactive in metal transfer reactions. Therefore, domain II of MT4a is well suited to rapidly release its bound zinc(II) ions, in broad agreement with a previously suggested role of MT4a in zinc(II) transport and delivery to other proteins.

Advances in the molecular understanding of biological zinc transport

Recognition of the importance of zinc homeostasis for health has driven a surge in structural data on major zinc-transporting proteins.

Challenging conventional wisdom: single domain metallothioneins

Metallation studies of human metallothioneins support the role of single metal-binding-domains as commonplace with the typical two-domain-cluster structure as exceptional.

Single-domain metallothioneins: evidence of the onset of clustered metal binding domains in Zn-rhMT 1a

Mammalian metallothioneins bind up to seven Zn(2+) ions in two distinct domains: an N-terminal β-domain that binds three Zn(2+) ions and a C-terminal α-domain that binds four Zn(2+) ions. Domain specificity has been invoked in the metalation mechanism with cluster formation and bridging of the 20 Cys residues taking place prior to saturation with seven Zn(2+) ions. We report a novel experiment that examines Zn(2+) metalation by exploiting the expected decrease in K(F) at the onset of clustering using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). During the titration with Zn(2+), the ESI-MS data show that several metalated species coexist until the fully saturated proteins are formed. The relative Zn binding affinities of the seven total sites in the α- and β-fragments were determined through direct competition for added Zn(2+). The K(F) values for each Zn(2+) are expected to decrease as a function of the remaining available sites and the onset of clustering. Analysis shows that Zn(2+) binds to β-rhMT with a greater affinity than α-rhMT. The incremental distribution of Zn(2+) between the competing fragments and apo-βα-rhMT (essentially three and four sites competing with seven sites) identifies the exact point at which clustering begins in the full protein. Analysis of the speciation data shows that Zn(5)-MT forms before clustering begins. This means that all 20 Cys residues of apo-βα-rhMT are bound terminally to Zn(2+) as [Zn(Cys)(4)](2-) units before clustering begins; there is no domain preference in this first metalation stage. Preferential binding of Zn(2+) to β- and α-rhMT at the point where βα-rhMT must form clusters is caused by a significant decrease in the affinity of βα-rhMT for further Zn(2+). The single-domain Zn(5)-rhMT, in which there are no exposed cysteine sulfurs, is a key component of the metalation pathway because the lower affinities of the two clustered Zn(2+) ions allow donation to apoenzymes.

Lessons on the critical interplay between zinc binding and protein structure and dynamics

Zinc is one of the most important micronutrients for virtually all living organisms, and hence, it is important to understand the molecular mechanisms for its homeostasis. Besides proteins involved in transmembrane transport, both extra- and intracellular zinc-binding proteins play important roles in the respective metabolic networks. Important examples for extracellular zinc transporters are mammalian serum albumins, and for intracellular zinc handling, certain metallothioneins are of relevance. The availability of protein structures including relevant metal binding sites is a fundamental prerequisite to decipher the mechanisms that govern zinc binding dynamics in these proteins, but their determination can prove to be surprisingly challenging. Due to the spectroscopic silence of Zn(2+), combinations of biophysical techniques including electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) and multinuclear NMR, isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy, coupled with site-directed mutagenesis and molecular modelling have proven to be valuable approaches to understand not only the zinc-binding properties of metallothioneins and albumins, but also the influence of other physiologically relevant competing agents. These studies have demonstrated why the bacterial metallothionein SmtA contains a site inert towards exchange with Cd(2+), why the plant metallothionein EC from wheat is partially unfolded in the presence of Cd(2+), and how fatty acids impact on the zinc-binding ability of mammalian serum albumins.

The "magic numbers" of metallothionein

Metallothioneins (MT) are a family of small cysteine rich proteins, which since their discovery in 1957, have been implicated in a range of roles including toxic metal detoxification, protection against oxidative stress, and as a metallochaperone involved in the homeostasis of both zinc and copper. The most well studied member of the family is the mammalian metallothionein, which consists of two domains: a β-domain with 9 cysteine residues, which sequesters 3 Cd(2+) or Zn(2+) or 6 Cu(+) ions, and an α-domain with 11 cysteine residues and, which sequesters 4 Cd(2+) or Zn(2+) or 6 Cu(+) ions. Despite over half a century of research, the exact functions of MT are still unknown. Much of current research aims to elucidate the mechanism of metal binding, as well as to isolate intermediates in metal exchange reactions; reactions necessary to maintain homeostatic equilibrium. These studies further our understanding of the role(s) of this remarkable and ubiquitous protein. Recently, supermetallated forms of the protein, where supermetallation describes metallation in excess of traditional levels, have been reported. These species may potentially be the metal exchange intermediates necessary to maintain homeostatic equilibrium. This review focuses on recent advances in the understanding of the mechanistic properties of metal binding, the implications for the metal induced protein folding reactions proposed for metallothionein metallation, the value of "magic numbers", which we informally define as the commonly determined metal-to-protein stoichiometric ratios and the significance of the new supermetallated states of the protein and the possible interpretation of the structural properties of this new metallation status. Together we provide a commentary on current experimental and theoretical advances and frame our consideration in terms of the possible functions of MT.

The isolated Cys2His2 site in EC metallothionein mediates metal-specific protein folding

The selectivity of proteins involved in metal ion homeostasis is an important part of the puzzle to understand how cells allocate the correct metal ions to the correct proteins. Due to their similar ligand-binding properties, and their frequent co-existence in soils, essential zinc and toxic cadmium are a particularly challenging couple. Thus, minimisation of competition of Cd(2+) for Zn(2+) sites is of crucial importance for organisms that are in direct contact with soil. Amongst these, plants have an especially critical role, due to their importance for nutrition and energy. We have studied an embryo-specific, zinc-binding metallothionein (E(C)) from wheat by nuclear magnetic resonance, electrospray mass spectrometry, site-directed mutagenesis, and molecular modelling. Wheat E(C) exploits differences in affinities of Cys(4) and Cys(2)His(2) sites for Cd(2+) and Zn(2+) to achieve metal-selective protein folding. We propose that this may constitute a novel mechanism to discriminate between essential Zn(2+) and toxic Cd(2+).

Metallothioneins: unparalleled diversity in structures and functions for metal ion homeostasis and more

Metallothioneins have been the subject of intense study for five decades, and have greatly inspired the development of bio-analytical methodologies including multi-dimensional and multi-nuclear NMR.With further advancements in molecular biology, protein science, and instrumental techniques, recent years have seen a renaissance of research into metallothioneins. The current report focuses on in vitro studies of so-called class II metallothioneins from a variety of phyla, highlighting the diversity of metallothioneins in terms of structure, biological functions, and molecular functions such as metal ion specificity, thermodynamic stabilities, and kinetic reactivity. We are still far from being able to predict any of these properties, and further efforts will be required to generate the knowledge that will enable a better understanding of what governs the biological and chemical properties of these unusual and intriguing small proteins.

Zinc-handling in cyanobacteria: an update

Zinc is a constituent of all six classes of enzymes, plays important roles in gene regulation, and is thought to be essential for most organisms. Despite initial discoveries of cyanobacterial metallothioneins, zinc efflux pumps and uptake systems, and zinc sensors, our knowledge of the zinc requirements, uptake, and detoxification mechanisms of cyanobacteria is still limited. Although cyanobacteria occupy extremely diverse habitats, most available data pertains to freshwater species, and almost no studies of zinc-handling mechanisms have been conducted in marine species. The current report highlights what is known about zinc homeostasis in cyanobacteria, and presents an analysis of the 40 sequenced cyanobacterial genomes.

Metallothioneins with unusual residues: histidines as modulators of zinc affinity and reactivity

For many years, paradigms regarding metallothioneins comprised the exclusive metal coordination by thiolates from cysteine residues and the absence of aromatic residues. As more sequence and in vitro data on metallothioneins, in particular from non-vertebrate organisms, has become available, both the occurrence of and metal coordination by histidine residues in metallothioneins is emerging as a more frequent feature than expected. We discuss the general implications of histidines versus cysteines in zinc binding sites, and review some recent results from literature and our own lab. We conclude that histidines can stabilise metallothionein clusters by reducing the overall charge, offering the ability to help with structural organisation by supplying H-bond donor and acceptor properties, reducing the likelihood for disulfide bond formation, whilst maintaining a high affinity towards metal ions, in particular the borderline zinc ion.

Histidine ligands in bacterial metallothionein enhance cluster stability

The cyanobacterial metallothionein (MT) SmtA is the prototype for bacterial MTs and protects against elevated levels of zinc. In contrast to mammalian MTs, bacterial MTs coordinate to metal ions not only via cysteine sulfurs, but unusually for MTs, also via histidine nitrogens. To investigate whether histidine coordination in these metal-sulfur clusters provides advantages over S-coordination only, we mutated the two metal-binding histidine residues in the cyanobacterial MT SmtA from Synechococcus PCC7942 to cysteines. We show that the mutant proteins are still capable of binding up to four zinc ions as is the wild-type protein. However, the mutations perturb protein folding and metal-binding dynamics. Interestingly, several homologues of SmtA also show variations in these two residues. We conclude that histidine residues in Synechococcus PCC7942 SmtA have a stabilising effect due to electrostatic interactions that impact on protein folding and metal cluster charge, and are involved in fine-tuning the reactivity of the bound metal ions.