Multidrug-resistant Myobacterium tuberculosis caused by the Beijing genotype and a specific T1 genotype clone (SIT No. 266) is widely transmitted in Minsk

A multifaceted interplay between virulence, drug resistance, and the phylogeographic landscape of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Latin-American Mediterranean (LAM) family is one of the most significant and global genotypes of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Here, we used the murine model to study the virulence and lethality of the genetically and epidemiologically distinct LAM strains. The pathobiological characteristics of the four LAM strains (three drug resistant and one drug susceptible) and the susceptible reference strain H37Rv were studied in the C57BL/6 mouse model. The whole-genome sequencing was performed using the HiSeq Illumina platform, followed by bioinformatics and phylogenetic analysis. The susceptible strain H37Rv showed the highest virulence. Drug-susceptible LAM strain (spoligotype SIT264) was more virulent than three multidrug-resistant (MDR) strains (SIT252, SIT254, and SIT266). All three MDR isolates were low lethal, while the susceptible isolate and H37Rv were moderately/highly lethal. Putting the genomic, phenotypic, and virulence features of the LAM strains/spoligotypes in the context of their dynamic phylogeography over 20 years reveals three types of relationships between virulence, resistance, and transmission. First, the most virulent and more lethal drug-susceptible SIT264 increased its circulation in parts of Russia. Second, moderately virulent and pre-XDR SIT266 was prevalent in Belarus and continues to be visible in North-West Russia. Third, the low virulent and MDR strain SIT252 previously considered as emerging has disappeared from the population. These findings suggest that strain virulence impacts the transmission, irrespective of drug resistance properties. The increasing circulation of susceptible but more virulent and lethal strains implies that personalized TB treatment should consider not only resistance but also the virulence of the infecting M. tuberculosis strains. IMPORTANCE The study is multidisciplinary and investigates the epidemically/clinically important and global lineage of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, named Latin-American-Mediterranean (LAM), yet insufficiently studied with regard to its pathobiology. We studied different LAM strains (epidemic vs endemic and resistant vs susceptible) in the murine model and using whole-genome analysis. We also collected long-term, 20-year data on their prevalence in Eurasia. The findings are both expected and unexpected. (i) We observe that a drug-susceptible but highly virulent strain increased its prevalence. (ii) By contrast, the multidrug-resistant (MDR) but low-virulent, low-lethal strain (that we considered as emerging 15 years ago) has almost disappeared. (iii) Finally, an intermediate case is the MDR strain with moderate virulence that continues to circulate. We conclude that (i) the former and latter strains are the most hazardous and require close epidemiological monitoring, and (ii) personalized TB treatment should consider not only drug resistance but also the virulence of the infecting strains and development of anti-virulence drugs is warranted.

Phylogenetic relationships of Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates in Poland: The emergence of Beijing genotype among multidrug-resistant cases

Introduction

The epidemiological situation of tuberculosis (TB) in Poland urges for its continuous and scrupulous monitoring. The objective of this study was to explore the genetic diversity of multidrug-resistant (MDR) and drug-susceptible (DS) Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates from Poland with a combination of spoligotyping and high-resolution mycobacterial interspersed repetitive unit-variable number tandem repeat (MIRU-VNTR) analysis. The results were placed in the Northern and Eastern Europe context.

Methods

The study included 89 (39 MDR and 50 DS) M. tuberculosis isolates collected from as many patients between 2018 and 2021 in Poland. The analysis was done using spoligotyping, and MIRU-VNTR typing at 24 standard loci. The data were compared to those available on Poland and neighbors and global M. tuberculosis datasets.

Results

The main identified families were Beijing (28.1%) and Haarlem (16.8%) while 34.8% of isolates were in the heterogeneous L4-unclassified group. Although the Beijing family was the most prevalent (61.5%) among MDR-TB cases, it accounted for only 2% of DS isolates. Among foreign-born patients, a higher ratio of MDR isolates were observed when compared with those who Poland-born (64.3% vs. 40%). Furthermore, all patients from the Former Soviet Union (FSU) countries were infected with MDR-TB.

Discussion

Whereas DS M. tuberculosis population in Poland is dominated by L4 isolates, MDR isolates are mostly of the Beijing genotype. The rise in the prevalence of the Beijing isolates in Poland, coupled with high proportion of the Beijing genotype among foreign-born TB patients may reflect an ongoing transmission of this family, imported to Poland mainly from FSU countries.

Diagnostic utility of GenoType MTBDRsl assay for the detection of moxifloxacin-resistant mycobacterium tuberculosis, as compared to phenotypic method and whole-genome sequencing

Background

Recently, moxifloxacin (MFX)-resistant results of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) obtained by GenoType MTBDRsl (second-line line probe assay [SL-LPA]) have been stratified to determine their resistance level; however, its accuracy has not been well studied. Therefore, the study aimed to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of SL-LPA, with phenotypic drug susceptibility testing (pDST) and whole-genome sequencing (WGS) for the detection of MFX-resistant Mtb and their resistance level.

Methods

A total of 111 sputum samples were subjected to SL-LPA according to the diagnostic algorithm of the National Tuberculosis Elimination Program. Results were compared with pDST of MFX (at critical concentration [CC, 0.25 μg/ml] and clinical breakpoint [CB, 1.0 μg/ml] using BACTEC mycobacterial growth indicator tube-960), and WGS.

Results

At CC, SL-LPA and pDST yielded concordant results of MFX for 104 of 111 (94%). However, at CB, 23 of 30 (77%) isolates carrying gyrA mutation known to confer low-level resistance to MFX were scored as susceptible by pDST. Among 46 Mtb isolates carrying gyrA mutations known to confer high-level resistance to MFX, 36 (78%) isolates yielded concordant results, while 10 (22%) isolates were scored as susceptible at CB by pDST. WGS identified gyrA mutations in all isolates suggested by SL-LPA.

Conclusion

It is concluded that the stratification of MFX-resistant results by SL-LPA/genotypic method is not very well correlated with pDST (at CB), and hence, pDST may not be completely replaced by SL-LPA. gyrA D94G and gyrAA90V are the most prevalent mutations in MFX-resistant Mtb.

Spatiotemporal dynamics of drug-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis: Contrasting trends and implications for tuberculosis control in EU high-priority country

Different and contrasting trends related to human migration and the implementation of health control programmes influence the spread of drug-resistant tuberculosis (TB). We analysed the Mycobacterium tuberculosis population structure in Estonia, a high-priority EU country for TB control, to detect the dynamic changes and underlying factors. The study collection included 278 M. tuberculosis isolates recovered in 1999 and 2014-2015. The isolates were subjected to drug susceptibility testing, genotyping and analysis of sublineage/cluster-specific markers and drug resistance mutations. The Beijing genotype was the most prevalent, and its rate increased from 28.6% in 1999 to 38.5% in 2015 (p = .09). The non-Beijing strains represented Euro-American lineage (Latin American Mediterranean [LAM], Ural, Haarlem, T, X genotypes) and Indo-Oceanic lineage (one EAI-IND isolate). The proportion of isolates resistant to two or more drugs increased from 22.4% to 29.1% (p = .1). The pre-XDR/XDR isolates were identified only within the Beijing genotype. In contrast, the drug resistance rate decreased in the LAM genotype from 42.1% to 11.8% (p = .05). The Beijing B0/W148-cluster ('successful Russian strain') included only MDR, pre-XDR or XDR isolates. All B0/W148-cluster isolates were resistant to two or more drugs compared to 28% of the Beijing 94-32-cluster (p = .0002). The Beijing genotype was not identified in the isolates from patients born in Estonia before 1940 compared to its 35.2% rate among other patients. In summary, the circulation of the highly drug-resistant isolates of the Beijing B0/W148 subtype, the increased prevalence of the Beijing genotype among HIV-coinfected patients and the increased number of patients with alcohol abuse (47.5%) present major challenges of the current TB control in Estonia. The Beijing genotype was likely brought to Estonia after 1945 due to the massive human influx from the Soviet Union. In contrast, the main genotypes of the Euro-American lineage were likely endemic in Estonia during all 20th century.

Analysis of Mycobacterium tuberculosis genetic lineages circulating in Riga and Riga region, Latvia, isolated between 2008 and 2012

Although the number of new tuberculosis (TB) cases registered per year has decreased by 3-fold between 2001 and 2017 in Latvia, the TB incidence and rates of multidrug resistant TB in this Baltic country remain substantially higher than in most other European countries. Molecular typing methods of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) play an important role both in clinical studies of the disease and the epidemiological investigations, allowing to describe and characterize the pathogen's population structure and spread of particular genotypes. Aim of this study was to examine the prevalence of MTB lineages in Riga and Riga region of Latvia within a five-year period (2008-2012), and to evaluate the discriminatory power (DP) of spoligotyping, standard 24-locus MIRU-VNTR and IS6110-RFLP methods in this setting. The results showed that the main MTB spoligotype families were Beijing (25.3%) and LAM (24.3%), followed by T (22.1%), Ural (11.2%), Haarlem (6.6%) and X superfamily (3.4%). This distribution remained stable over the five consecutive years. 67.6% of MTB isolates were pan-susceptible, and 32.4% were resistant to any drug; multi-drug resistance was found in 5.8% of MTB strains, and 7.6% of MTB isolates were extensively drug-resistant. Drug resistance was associated with SIT1, SIT283 and SIT42 genotypes, while SIT1 and SIT42 were overrepresented among multi drug-resistant MTB strains. Overall, DP of spoligotyping method alone was 0.8953, while DP of both 24-locus MIRU-VNTR analysis and IS6110 RFLP was higher (DP = 0.9846 and 0.9927, respectively), mainly due to the improvement of the resolution for the Beijing strains. In conclusion, this work represents the first comprehensive molecular epidemiological description of TB in Latvia, highlighting the high genetic diversity of MTB strains circulating in Riga and Riga region. In combination with detailed epidemiological data this approach was helpful for the in-depth understanding of epidemiological processes in settings where the Next-Gen sequencing is not available as a routine method.

On sunspots, click science and molecular iconography

CRISPR-spoligotyping and MIRU-VNTR typing, SITVIT_WEB and MIRU-VNTRplus are the methods and online resources most widely used for Mycobacterium tuberculosis genotype family assignment and clustering analysis. They have been proven invaluable for molecular epidemiological studies of this important human pathogen in setting up the terminology and classification framework. However, they are inherently limited by insufficient knowledge of evolution of the targeted genome loci (especially, CRISPR). The situation is aggravated by the dogmatic, iconographic perception of these increasingly user-friendly online tools. Here, I present a critical essay on hot practical aspects related to the use of SITVIT_WEB and MIRU-VNTRplus, in particular, partly inadequate (sub)clade assignment due to imperfect decision rules, partly outdated methodological options offered to the users that permit to build scientifically unsound phylogenies from spoligotyping data. A confusing terminology, misclassification and false clustering are not abstract issues but make a scientific discussion meaningless, and I propose some courses for improvement.

Whole-Genome Sequencing of Mycobacterium tuberculosis Provides Insight into the Evolution and Genetic Composition of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis in Belarus

The emergence and spread of drug-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis (DR-TB) are critical global health issues. Eastern Europe has some of the highest incidences of DR-TB, particularly multidrug-resistant (MDR) and extensively drug-resistant (XDR) TB. To better understand the genetic composition and evolution of MDR- and XDR-TB in the region, we sequenced and analyzed the genomes of 138 M. tuberculosis isolates from 97 patients sampled between 2010 and 2013 in Minsk, Belarus. MDR and XDR-TB isolates were significantly more likely to belong to the Beijing lineage than to the Euro-American lineage, and known resistance-conferring loci accounted for the majority of phenotypic resistance to first- and second-line drugs in MDR and XDR-TB. Using a phylogenomic approach, we estimated that the majority of MDR-TB was due to the recent transmission of already-resistant M. tuberculosis strains rather than repeated de novo evolution of resistance within patients, while XDR-TB was acquired through both routes. Longitudinal sampling of M. tuberculosis from 34 patients with treatment failure showed that most strains persisted genetically unchanged during treatment or acquired resistance to fluoroquinolones. HIV+ patients were significantly more likely to have multiple infections over time than HIV− patients, highlighting a specific need for careful infection control in these patients. These data provide a better understanding of the genomic composition, transmission, and evolution of MDR- and XDR-TB in Belarus and will enable improved diagnostics, treatment protocols, and prognostic decision-making.

Trends in molecular epidemiology of drug-resistant tuberculosis in Republic of Karelia, Russian Federation

Background

Russian Republic of Karelia is located at the Russian-Finnish border. It contains most of the historical Karelia land inhabited with autochthonous Karels and more recently migrated Russians. Although tuberculosis (TB) incidence in Karelia is decreasing, it remains high (45.8/100 000 in 2014) with the rate of multi-drug resistance (MDR) among newly diagnosed TB patients reaching 46.5 %. The study aimed to genetically characterize Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates obtained at different time points from TB patients from Karelia to gain insight into the phylogeographic specificity of the circulating genotypes and to assess trends in evolution of drug resistant subpopulations.

Methods

The sample included 150 M. tuberculosis isolates: 78 isolated in 2013–2014 (“new” collection) and 72 isolated in 2006 (“old” collection). Drug susceptibility testing was done by the method of absolute concentrations. Spoligotyping was used to test genotype-specific markers of a Latin-American-Mediterranean (LAM) family and its sublineages as well as a Beijing B0/W148-cluster.

Results

The largest spoligotypes were SIT1 (Beijing family, n = 42) and SIT40 (T family, n = 5). Beijing family was the largest (n = 43) followed by T (n = 11), Ural (n = 10) and LAM (n = 8). Successful Russian clone, Beijing В0/W148, was identified in 15 (34.9 %) of 43 Beijing isolates; all В0/W148 isolates were drug-resistant. Seven of 8 LAM isolates belonged to the RD115/LAM-RUS branch, 1 - to the LAM RD174/RD-Rio sublineage. MDR was found in Beijing (32/43), Ural (3/10), and LAM (3/8). In contrast, all T isolates were pansusceptible. Comparison of drug resistant subgroups of the new and old collections showed an increasing prevalence of the B0/W148 clonal cluster, from 18.0 % (mainly polyresistant) in 2006 to 32.6 % in 2014 (mainly MDR and pre-XDR). The West–east increasing gradient is observed for the Ural genotype that may be defined a ‘Russian’ strain. In contrast, the spoligotype SIT40 of the T family appears to be a historical Karelian strain.

Conclusions

Circulation of the MDR M. tuberculosis isolates of the Beijing genotype and its B0/W148 cluster continues to critically influence the current situation with the MDR-TB control in northwestern Russia including the Republic of Karelia. Revealed phylogeographic patterns of some genotypes reflect a complex demographic history of Karelia within the course of the 20^th century.

Drug-resistant tuberculosis in Eastern Europe: challenges and ways forward

Encouragingly, global rates of new tuberculosis (TB) cases have been falling since 2005, in line with the Millennium Development Goal targets; however, cases of multidrug-resistant (MDR-) and extensively drug-resistant TB (XDR-TB) have been increasing. Fifteen of the world's 27 high MDR- and XDR-TB burden countries are in the World Health Organization (WHO) European Region, of which 10 are in Eastern Europe (including Baltic and Caucasus countries). To address the MDR- and XDR-TB situation in the WHO European Region, a Consolidated Action Plan to Prevent and Combat M/XDR-TB (2011-2015) was developed for all 53 Member States and implemented in 2011. Since the implementation of the Action Plan, the proportion of MDR-TB appears largely to have levelled off among bacteriologically confirmed TB cases in high-burden countries with universal or near universal (>95%) first-line drug susceptibility testing (DST). The treatment success rate, however, continues to decrease. A contributing factor is the substantial proportion of MDR-TB cases that are additionally resistant to either a fluoroquinolone, a second-line injectable agent or both (XDR-TB); high-burden country proportions range from 12.6% to 80.4%. Proportions of XDR-TB range from 5% to 24.8%. Despite much progress in Eastern Europe, critical challenges remain as regards access to appropriate treatment regimens; patient hospitalisation; scale-up of laboratory capacity, including the use of rapid diagnostics and second-line DST; vulnerable populations; human resources; and financing. Solutions to these challenges are aligned with the Post-2015 Global TB strategy. As a first step, the global strategy should be adapted at regional and country levels to serve as a framework for immediate actions as well as longer-term ways forward.