Peripheral blood natural killer cells activation status determined by CD69 upregulation predicts implantation outcome in IVF

The function of decidua natural killer cells in physiology and pathology of pregnancy

The role of decidual natural killer (dNK) cells in maintaining immune tolerance at the maternal-fetal interface during pregnancy is a significant topic in reproductive health. Immune tolerance is essential for a successful pregnancy and involves a complex immune response involving various immune cells and molecules. DNK cells comprise the largest population of lymphocyte subsets found in the decidua and play important roles in maintaining immune tolerance. These cells exert multiple functions to maintain homeostasis of the decidual microenvironment, including modulation of trophoblast invasion, promotion of fetal development, regulation of endometrial decidualization and spiral artery remodeling. DNK cells can also be divided into different subsets based on their functions as NKtolerant , NKcytotoxic , and NKregulatory cells. However, the relationship between dNK cells function and pregnancy outcomes is complex and poorly understood. In this review, we will focus on the physiological role of dNK cells during pregnancy and highlight the potential role in pathological pregnancies and therapeutic approaches.

Co-administration of tacrolimus and low molecular weight heparin in patients with a history of implantation failure and elevated peripheral blood natural killer cell proportion

AIM

To investigate the therapeutic effect of co-administration of tacrolimus (TAC) and low-molecular-weight heparin (LMWH) or LMWH only on pregnancy outcomes in the female with a history of implantation failure and elevated peripheral blood natural killer (pNK) cell proportion in frozen-thawed embryo transfer cycles.

METHODS

To evaluate the pregnancy parameters for 249 patients with ≥2 implantation failures and pNK cell proportion ≥12% by analyzing a retrospective observational cohort study. Sixty patients had received the co-administration TAC and LMWH (TAC & LMWH group), 85 others had only taken LMWH (LWMH group), and the rest did not take any particular drugs (control group).

RESULTS

The experimental finding indicated that the TAC & LMWH group and the LMWH group showed higher clinical pregnancy rates than the control group (p < 0.05), and TAC & LMWH group had a much higher live birth rate. According to the binary logistic regression analysis, the combination of TAC and LMWH was conducive to clinical pregnancy and live birth rate and reduced the possibility of miscarriage. It would not affect the result of spontaneous abortion and live birth, although the LMWH was only beneficial to clinical pregnancy. In addition, these findings were similar for these three groups' obstetrical and neonatal outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

The combination of TAC and LMWH can improve clinical pregnancy and live birth rates and reduce the risk of spontaneous miscarriage in patients with a history of implantation failure and elevated pNK ratio. LMWH is also beneficial to clinical pregnancy.

A blinded multicenter investigation: Accentuated NK lymphocyte CD335 (NKp46) expression predicts reproductive failures after IVF

The peripheral blood NK cell diversity is highly complex. Recent studies have described more than a thousand phenotypes sharing NK cell receptors (NKRs), across the leukocyte lineages. Previously, we have found that accentuated NK p46 phenotype has prognostic value for NK cytotoxicity status, and is characteristic for patients with recurrent implantation failure (RIF). In a blinded investigation we studied blood samples from IVF women before embryo transfer (pre-implantation genetic tested [PGT] embryos n = 116; not tested embryos n = 219). We studied NKp46 expression by flow cytometry and anti-cardiolipin antibody (aCL) levels. aCL results were transmitted to the clinic but NKp46 expression was blinded (for us and for the clinic) and not analyzed before termination of the study (end of last pregnancy). Association of NKp46 phenotype with clinical pregnancy rate (CPR), pregnancy failure (PF) rate and life birth rate (LBR) were analyzed. aCL positive and IvIg treated cases were excluded. IVF success was dependent on p46 NK phenotype in patients with PGT embryos. Elevated p46 expression on NK (>93%) as well as decreased (<66%) significantly reduce CPR (OR 12.7 and 3.8) without affecting pregnancy failure frequency. Both accentuations (taken together) resulted in a significant reduction of LBR (OR 3.9 p = 0.019) compared with non-accentuated phenotypes (p46 levels 66-93%). Elevated NK cell levels (>14.5% weakly) were associated with PF (OR 3.1 p = 0.069), but not significantly with reduced LBR. In contrast, numbers of NKCD335+ lymphocytes (>11.5%) were a significant predictor of PF (OR-4.0 p<0.05) and decreased LBR (OR 2.1 p = 0.06). At the same time, accentuated numbers of NKCD335neg lymphocytes (<0.7 and >4%) were also associated with decreased LBR (OR 2,65 p = 0.05). In patients with NKCD335++ numbers (<5 and >21%), we found a weakly association with IVF failure. We found similar associations in IVF patients without PGT -A but at lower significance levels regardless the higher number of patients. Impact of NKp46 phenotype for IVF success was significant in patients with donor's ET and almost imperceptible in patients > 35y.o. with own embryo transfer. Accentuated increased or decreased CD335 expression on NK was associated with embryo implantation failure. Balanced CD335 levels form a condition favorable for implantation. Elevated numbers of p46+NK (CD3-CD56+CD335+) predicts pregnancy failures at higher significance levels than elevated NK cell numbers. Elevated numbers of p46negNK (CD3-CD56+CD335-) indicate reduced LBR. Accentuation of p46 expression on NK cells is associated with reproductive failures. In combination with PGD it provides a powerful prediction algorithm and treatment option.

Management of recurrent implantation failure: British Fertility Society policy and practice guideline

Recurrent implantation failure (RIF) is defined as the absence of a positive pregnancy test after three consecutive transfers of good quality embryos. There remains significant variation in clinical practice in the management of RIF. This British Fertility Society (BFS) Policy and Practice guideline analyses the evidence for investigations and therapies that are employed in RIF and provides recommendations for clinical practice and for further research. Evidence for investigations of sperm and egg quality, uterine and adnexal factors, immunological factors and thrombophilia, endocrine conditions and genetic factors and for associated therapies have been evaluated. This guideline has been devised to assist reproductive medicine specialists and patients in making shared decisions concerning management of RIF. Finally, suggestions for research towards improving understanding and management of RIF have also been provided.

Prednisolone and enoxaparin (clexane) therapy ('the Bondi protocol') for repeated IVF failure

PROBLEM

What is the impact of an empirical immune therapy protocol of prednisolone and enoxaparin (clexane) (the 'Bondi protocol') on women with repeated in vitro fertilization (IVF) failure?

METHOD OF STUDY

This was a retrospective review of live birth outcomes conducted on all transfer cycles performed by a single clinician (GS) at IVFAustralia between February 2016 and April 2020. This study consisted of 1786 transfer cycles, including 460 cycles treated with the Bondi protocol and 1326 without. Women with repeated IVF failure were given the Bondi protocol based on blood NK cell activity. Primary outcome was live birth and statistical analysis was performed with GraphPad Prism software with significance for P-values < .05.

RESULTS

Overall 'Bondi' and 'normal' protocol cycles had similar rates of IVF/ICSI, fresh/frozen transfers and use of preimplantation genetic testing (PGT). Women given the Bondi protocol were older, had more previous cycles and had higher blood NK cell activity. There was no significant difference in live birth rates (Bondi 26%, normal 28%). Bondi protocol live birth rates per transfer cycle were as high as 40% in patients under 38 years old. The Bondi protocol was more effective as NK activity increased from 'normal' to 'borderline' to 'high'. For high NK cell activity levels, live birth rates were over four times higher for women on the Bondi protocol (28%) than those on normal protocols (6%, P = .0007).

CONCLUSION

This study describes a simple and relatively safe immune therapy protocol that may improve IVF success rates in women with evidence of immune dysfunction.

Accentuated Peripheral Blood NK Cytotoxicity Forms an Unfavorable Background for Embryo Implantation and Gestation

Problem Many studies have demonstrated the negative impact of high rates of NK cytotoxicity (NKc) on reproductive processes, but there is no agreement as to the appropriateness and feasibility of using the NKc for routine diagnostic in IVF patients. This study conducted a retrospective analysis of embryo transfer (ET) success rates and live birth rates (LBR) in patients with different NKc values. Method of study 1854 cycles of ET were selected and divided into three groups according to NKc levels, and randomized by anamnesis and age: normal (nNKc, n = 871), elevated (eNKc, n = 759), and reduced NKc (rNKc, n = 123). ET with donors’ embryos (n = 101) were analyzed separately. NKc-to-K562 was measured in PBMC (peripheral blood mononuclear cells) by flow cytometry before ET. The patients did not obtain any additional treatments. Results Patients with eNKc, in addition to having reduced clinical pregnancy rates (OR1.59, p < 0.0001), had increased levels of subsequent pregnancy failures (OR2.545, p < 0.0001) when compared to nNKc patients. As a result, patients with eNKc had almost half the LBR than patients with nNKc (OR2.2, p < 0.0001). In patients with rNKc, LBR was also lowered. eNKc was equally unfavorable for implantation and delivery in cryo- or fresh cycles. Markedly, eNKc was much more unfavorable for reproduction than slightly elevated NKc. The donor’s embryos were implanted irrespective of the recipient’s NKc levels, but the later stages of pregnancy were worse in patients with eNKc. Conclusions Our findings highlighted the negative impact of high levels of NK cytotoxicity on pregnancy outcomes.

Can Lactobacillus spp. Be a Factor Reducing the Risk of Miscarriage?

Pregnancy loss is a common obstetric problem. Significant causes of miscarriage include genetic and epigenetic disorders of the embryo, immunological and endocrine factors, uterine malformations, improper embryo selection, and lifestyle. Perhaps a hitherto underappreciated cause of miscarriage may be an abnormal microbiota composition of the female reproductive system. Lactobacillus spp. is the most common bacteria within the reproductive tract. However, the protective role of Lactobacilli in the vagina has been well described in the literature, while it is still unknown what function Lactobacilli may have in the uterus. Moreover, new research shows that Lactobacillus spp. can have a role in miscarriage. However, both molecular and immunological mechanisms of host-Lactobacillus spp. interactions are not fully understood. Understanding these relationships will help address the importance and extent of the protective role of Lactobacillus spp. in miscarriage.

Uterine natural killer cells and recurrent spontaneous abortion

Recurrent spontaneous abortion (RSA), termed as two or more consecutive pregnancy loss is a great problem for some women of childbearing age. A large number of evidence confirm that there may be an immune background of RSA. As a member of the innate immune system, uterine natural killer (uNK) cells account for about 70% of total lymphocytes during pregnancy and play a critical role in the establishment and maintenance of pregnancy. This review mainly introduces the phenotype, origin, receptor, and function of uNK cells to illuminate its relationship with RSA.

Natural killer frequency determines natural killer cytotoxicity directly in accentuated zones and indirectly in "moderate-to-normal frequency" segment

Natural killer (NK) frequency and NK cytotoxicity (NKc) are key determining factors of a clinical outcome. In our previous study, we showed the prognostic clinical significance of immune parameters when they are beyond the optimal range (accentuated). In this study, we attempted to explain the disparity of accentuated but physiologically and immunologically normal NK parameters that might serve as negative clinical prognostics indications of failed pregnancies. We have analyzed NK%, NKc levels, and their reciprocal correlation in 2,804 patients with reproductive failures. In the entire clinical population, NK% correlates with NKc. Interestingly, we found this relationship to be strongly dependent on NK level's status. NK%-NKc correlation was the strongest (r = 0.2021, p < 0.0001) in a patient group with high NK% (> 17.5%). Patients with NK% between 15-17.5% manifested lower but still significant correlation NK%-NKc (r = 0.1213, p = 0.0155). Additionally, significant correlation (r = 0.2689, p < < 0.0001) between NK% and NKc was observed in a group of patients with NK levels < 7% (1.7-7%). While patients' groups with NK% (7-15%) did not reveal NK%-NKc association. This led us to hypothesize that the qualitative-quantitative status of NK population is responsible for their cytotoxic activity. Consistent with our hypothesis, the "balanced zone" NK% is tightly controlled, and thus does not correlate directly with NKc. In contrast, the "accentuated zones" of NK% escape this control and directly affecting NKc. Demonstrated phenomena supports our idea about the clinical significance of immune accentuation and explains its novel physiological role.

Expression of natural cytotoxicity receptor NKp46 on peripheral blood natural killer cells in women with a history of recurrent implantation failures

AIM

The peripheral blood natural killer (NK) cells diversity is highly complex; recent studies described more than a thousand phenotypes sharing NK cell receptors, across the leukocyte lineages. In this study, we investigated the expression of NKp46 in peripheral blood NK cells in women with a history of recurrent implantation failures (RIF) with euploid embryos with pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) and control group (donors of oocytes and surrogate mothers).

METHODS

The expression of NKp46 in peripheral blood lymphocytes and NK cells from women with RIF (n = 57) and control group (n = 50) was analyzed with three-color flow cytometry.

RESULTS

The percentage of NKp46⁺ NK cells was significantly higher in women with RIF compare with the control group and high amount of NKp46⁺ NK cells (>13% of total lymphocytes) was a poor prognostic factor for embryo implantation. Also, women with RIF had a low amount of NKp46^neg NK cells, which was a negative prognostic factor for embryo implantation. The analysis of NK subpopulations, on the basis of NKp46 expression, also revealed that NKp46^neg NK in low amounts (<20% of NK cells) and NKp46^dim in high amounts (>50% of NK cells) are also negative prognostic factors for embryo implantation.

CONCLUSION

Our results support the clinical significance of the NKp46 expression on NK cells in women with RIF. We suggest that the low level of NKp46^neg subset in women with RIF may be a result of an imbalance in the differential development of ILC subsets toward cytotoxic ILC (NK cells), which in turn is a negative condition for successful embryo implantation.

Novel predictive and therapeutic options for better pregnancy outcome in frozen embryo transfer cycles

Since 1978, in the first decades of in vitro fertilization (IVF), the use of ovarian hyperstimulation allowed for the development and transfer of multiple embryos. As IVF technology improved, the number of multiple pregnancies increased, which led to gradual reduction in the number of embryos that were transferred. Embryo freezing (vitrification) was recommended to allow subsequent transfer if the fresh cycle was unsuccessful. However, experimentation has continued to improve pregnancy outcomes. We discuss here the significance of frozen embryo transfer cycle and the impact of uterine and peripheral immunity dominated by NK cells and regulatory T cells and human chorionic gonadotropin on pregnancy outcome in this innovative mode of IVF therapy.

Intrauterine administration of autologous hCG- activated peripheral blood mononuclear cells improves pregnancy outcomes in patients with recurrent implantation failure; A double-blind, randomized control trial study

We aimed to investigate the effect of intrauterine administration of autologous hCG-activated PBMCs in RIF women with low Th-17/Treg cell ratio. 248 women with a history of implantation failure volunteered to receive PBMC-therapy. After immunologic consultation and doing flow cytometry analysis, 100 women with at least three IVF/ET failure who had low Th-17/Treg ratio in comparison with healthy control were enrolled in this study. These 100 patients were randomly divided into two groups as PBMC receiving (n = 50) and controls (n = 50). Then PBMCs were obtained from patients and treated with hCG for 48 h. Afterward, PBMCs were administered into the uterine cavity of the patient in the study group, two days before ET. The concentration of inflammatory cytokines was examined in the supernatant of cultured PBMCs after 2, 24, and 48 h of incubation using the ELISA method. The frequency of Th-17, Treg, and the Th-17/Treg ratio was significantly lower in RIF women than the healthy controls (P < 0.0001). The secretion of inflammatory cytokines was significantly higher after 48 h compared to 2 and 24 h (P < 0.0001). The pregnancy and live birth rate were significantly increased in women undergoing the PBMC-therapy compared to control (PBS-injecting) group (P = 0.032 and P = 0.047, respectively). The miscarriage rate was considerably lower in PBMC-therapy group (P = 0.029). Our findings suggest that intrauterine administration of autologous in vitro hCG-activated PBMCs improves pregnancy outcomes in patients with at least three IVF/ET failures.

Comparison of T and NK lymphocyte subsets between human endometrial tissue and peripheral blood

Immune profiles in endometrium may be changed in patients with IVF failure and its possible correlations with immune parameters in peripheral blood are important for the diagnostic approach. Such correlations in healthy women are unknown and have been studied in the present research. The expression of CD56, CD158a, HLA DR, CD69 in T lymphocytes, CD4 T lymphocytes, CD8+ T lymphocytes and NK cells were studied by flow-cytometry in endometrium and peripheral blood in healthy 24 donors of oocytes aged 25-32 years. Levels of T lymphocyte and T helper cells were lower in endometrium and no differences in CD8 T lymphocytes were registered between endometrium and peripheral blood. The expression of HLA DR and especially CD69 was higher in CD3, CD4, CD8 T cells in endometrium in comparison with peripheral blood. The endometrium lymphocyte population was enriched by NK cells that were generally CD56++ with a higher expression of HLA DR and almost in total were CD69 positive. Strong positive correlations of CD8 expression in NK cells (r = 0.6478, p < 0.001) and HLA DR expression in CD8 T cells (r = 0.6107, p < 0.01) between peripheral blood and endometrium were registered in fertile women. The endometrial CD56 expression in CD8+ T cells negatively correlated with endometrial CD8 expression in NK cells (r = -0.5252, p < 0.01) which possibly reflected a suppressive and regulating mechanism in the endometrium. CD8+ NK cells and HLA DR+ CD8 T cells in endometrium were related to the same subsets in peripheral blood.

Enumeration of peripheral blood NKp46 positive NK lymphocytes reflects NK cytotoxic activity in vitro

Natural killer (NK) cells are the predominant innate lymphocyte subsets that mediate anti-tumor and anti-viral responses. The monitoring of NK cells function is important in various physiological and pathological conditions. Different approaches have been used to directly or indirectly evaluate NK cells activities. The purpose of this study was to investigate the correlation between the number of NK cells and cytotoxic activity of NK cells and to determine whether NKp46⁺NK cells reflect NK cytotoxicity status. In our study, we retrospectively analyzed laboratory data on NK cytotoxicity and NK lymphocyte levels of 4896 infertile women which underwent routine immunology investigation after IVF failures. In healthy women, NKp46 expression was assessed on NK cells (n = 214) and cytotoxicity activity was evaluated with regard to NKp46 expression. We found that despite a significant correlation coefficient (n = 4689, r = 0.447), the correlation with cytotoxicity is maintained only within the zones with a low or high NK cells frequency. NK cells frequency has no significant prognostic value for their cytotoxicity - within the medium NK frequency zone the samples may have any cytotoxicity, both reduced and elevated. However, our data demonstrate that NKp46⁺NK cells frequency correlates with cytotoxicity activity even more significantly than the NK cells frequency (n = 214, r = 0.67 and r = 0.62, respectively) and has significant prognostic value for the abnormal NK cytotoxicity status indications, both low and increased. Our results further support an important role of NKp46 in NK cells killing and afford grounds for using the measurement of the NKp46⁺NK cells frequency as an alternative method for abnormal NK cytotoxicity status indication, which is responsive, simple and reliable.

Transcriptome profiles in peripheral white blood cells at the time of artificial insemination discriminate beef heifers with different fertility potential

Background

Infertility is a longstanding limitation in livestock production with important economic impact for the cattle industry. Female reproductive traits are polygenic and lowly heritable in nature, thus selection for fertility is challenging. Beef cattle operations leverage estrous synchronization in combination with artificial insemination (AI) to breed heifers and benefit from an early and uniform calving season. A couple of weeks following AI, heifers are exposed to bulls for an opportunity to become pregnant by natural breeding (NB), but they may also not become pregnant during this time period. Focusing on beef heifers, in their first breeding season, we hypothesized that: a- at the time of AI, the transcriptome of peripheral white blood cells (PWBC) differs between heifers that become pregnant to AI and heifers that become pregnant late in the breeding season by NB or do not become pregnant during the breeding season; and b- the ratio of transcript abundance between genes in PWBC classifies heifers according to pregnancy by AI, NB, or failure to become pregnant.

Results

We generated RNA-sequencing data from 23 heifers from two locations (A: six AI-pregnant and five NB-pregnant; and B: six AI-pregnant and six non-pregnant). After filtering out lowly expressed genes, we quantified transcript abundance for 12,538 genes. The comparison of gene expression levels between AI-pregnant and NB-pregnant heifers yielded 18 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) (ADAM20, ALDH5A1, ANG, BOLA-DQB, DMBT1, FCER1A, GSTM3, KIR3DL1, LOC107131247, LOC618633, LYZ, MNS1, P2RY12, PPP1R1B, SIGLEC14, TPPP, TTLL1, UGT8, eFDR≤0.02). The comparison of gene expression levels between AI-pregnant and non-pregnant heifers yielded six DEGs (ALAS2, CNKSR3, LOC522763, SAXO2, TAC3, TFF2, eFDR≤0.05). We calculated the ratio of expression levels between all gene pairs and assessed their potential to classify samples according to experimental groups. Considering all samples, relative expression from two gene pairs correctly classified 10 out of 12 AI-pregnant heifers (P = 0.0028) separately from the other 11 heifers (NB-pregnant, or non-pregnant).

Conclusion

The transcriptome profile in PWBC, at the time of AI, is associated with the fertility potential of beef heifers. Transcript levels of specific genes may be further explored as potential classifiers, and thus selection tools, of heifer fertility.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12864-018-4505-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Intrauterine insemination of cultured peripheral blood mononuclear cells prior to embryo transfer improves clinical outcome for patients with repeated implantation failures

Implantation failure is a major limiting factor in assisted reproduction improvement. Dysfunction of embryo–maternal immuno-tolerance pathways may be responsible for repeated implantation failures. This fact is supported by immunotropic theory stipulating that maternal immune cells, essentially uterine CD56+ natural killer cells, are determinants of implantation success. In order to test this hypothesis, we applied endometrium immuno-modulation prior to fresh embryo transfer for patients with repeated implantation failures. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were isolated from repeated implantation failure patients undergoing assisted reproductive technology cycles. On the day of ovulation induction, cells were isolated and then cultured for 3 days and transferred into the endometrium cavity prior to fresh embryo transfer. This immunotherapy was performed on 27 patients with repeated implantation failures and compared with another 27 patients who served as controls. Implantation and clinical pregnancy were increased significantly in the peripheral blood mononuclear cell test versus control (21.54, 44.44 vs. 8.62, 14.81%). This finding suggests a clear role for endometrium immuno-modulation and the inflammation process in implantation success. Our study showed the feasibility of intrauterine administration of autologous peripheral blood mononuclear cells as an effective therapy to improve clinical outcomes for patients with repeated implantation failures and who are undergoing in vitro fertilization cycles.