Goal-determined metrics to assess outcomes of exotropia surgery

Correlation of Strabismus Surgical Outcomes Graded by Goal-Determined Metric With Patient Satisfaction Survey

PURPOSE

Although strabismus surgery outcomes can be objectively measured, patient perception of results may differ. We present surgical outcomes graded by a prospective, "goal-determined metric" and compare these outcomes to results of a patient satisfaction survey.

DESIGN

Validity analysis comparing a clinical "goal-determined metric" to patient satisfaction.

METHODS

Goal-determined metric outcomes (2018-2021) for 2 surgeons treating esotropia or exotropia for diplopia control or reconstructive goals were collected. Inclusion required completion of postoperative examination 2-6 months after surgery and a satisfaction survey.

RESULTS

Record review identified 275 patients; 228 (median age 41 years [interquartile range 13-59]) met inclusion criteria. For the entire cohort, 87% were graded as "excellent" outcomes, and 78% of patients were overall "very satisfied." Agreement between patients' and surgeons' grading was 75% to 79% for all reconstructive surgery and for treatment of diplopia from esotropia. Agreement was lower, although not statistically different, for treatment of diplopia from exotropia (64%, 95% CI 43%-80%; P = .184). Preoperative risk factors, concurrent vertical or oblique surgery, and sex did not affect outcomes or satisfaction. Performance of activities requiring distance viewing improved more than performance of activities at near after esotropia-diplopia surgery (odds ratio 3.0, 95% CI 1.5-6.4; P = .004). For reconstructive cases achieving "much better" eye alignment, 62% and 72% (previously esotropic and exotropic) reported enhanced self-confidence.

CONCLUSIONS

Outcomes graded by goal-determined metric correlated well with many aspects of patient satisfaction. Patient-perceived improvement in appearance was important regardless of goal. Greater improvement in performance of activities requiring distance rather than near viewing characterized treatment of diplopia from esotropia.

Nasal Transposition of the Split Lateral Rectus Muscle for Strabismus Associated with Bilateral 3rd-Nerve Palsy

PURPOSE

To determine success rate and complications associated with nasal transposition of the split lateral rectus muscle (NTSLR) for treating bilateral 3^rd-nerve palsy.

DESIGN

Retrospective, interventional case series METHODS: : Setting: International, multicenter registry Study population: All patients with bilateral 3^rd-nerve palsy treated with NTSLR.

OBSERVATION

Sensorimotor evaluations before and 6-months after unilateral or bilateral NTSLR.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Post-operative horizontal alignment ≤ 15 prism diopters (PD), intraoperative technical difficulties, and vision-threatening complications. The association of patient demographics and surgical technique with each outcome was analyzed using multivariable logistic regression.

RESULTS

Thirty-four patients were included with a median age of 46 years (Interquartile range [IQR], 25-54 years) at surgery. The most common etiologies were ischemic (29%), neoplastic (15%), and congenital (12%). NTSLR performed unilaterally with alternative surgery on the opposite eye (65%) resulted in a median post-operative exotropia of 18 PD (IQR, 7-35 PD), and when performed bilaterally (35%) resulted in post-operative exotropia of 14 PD (IQR, 5-35 PD). Success was achieved in 50% of cases, intra-operative technical difficulties reported in 18%, and vision-threatening complications occurred in 21%. Attachment of the lateral rectus muscle ≥ 10 mm posterior to the medial rectus insertion was associated with increased vision-threatening complications (OR, 9.0; 95% CI, 1.3-99).

CONCLUSIONS

NTSLR can address the large-angle exotropia associated with bilateral 3rd-nerve palsy. Surgeons should be aware that posterior placement of the lateral rectus muscle can increase the risk of vision-threatening complications, particularly serous choroidal effusion.

Characteristics of Patients Who Are Not Responsive to Alternate Patching for Overcorrected Intermittent Exotropia

Purpose

To compare the characteristics of patients with surgically overcorrected intermittent exotropia treated with alternate patching.

Methods

The medical records of 51 patients who underwent bilateral lateral rectus muscle recession for intermittent exotropia and required alternate patching to correct postoperative overcorrection were retrospectively reviewed. Patients with postoperative esodeviation ≥18 prism diopters (PD) were started on alternate patching on postoperative day 1, whereas those with postoperative esodeviation of 10 to 17 PD were started after 2 weeks. Postoperative esodeviation <10 PD was considered as slight intentional overcorrection after exotropia surgery. Patients not responsive to alternate patching treatment were defined as those with postoperative esodeviation ≥10 PD after 3 months of treatment. Sex, family history, age, refractive error, amblyopia, stereopsis, suppression, type of exotropia, surgical method, preoperative and postoperative angle of deviation, and start time of alternate patching were compared.

Results

Among 51 patients, 29 patients responded to alternate patching and 22 patients did not respond. Female sex (p = 0.04), larger preoperative exodeviation at distance (p = 0.04), late onset of postoperative maximal esodeviation (p < 0.01), larger postoperative maximal esodeviation at near (p = 0.02), and late initiation of alternate patching (p = 0.01) were associated with patients in the non-responsive group. Although postoperative angle of deviation was similar for 2 weeks, the angle of postoperative esodeviation was significantly larger in the non-responsive group than in the responsive group, beginning at 1 month postoperatively.

Conclusions

Female sex, large preoperative exodeviation, late initiation of alternate patching, and large esodeviation 1-month postoperative predisposed patients to be resistant to alternate patching for postoperative overcorrection.

Patient Characteristics and Surgical Approach Impacting Simultaneous to Alternate Prism Cover Test Disparity After Exotropia Surgery: A Quantitative Look at the Difference in Motor Outcomes

PURPOSE

To investigate the relationship between simultaneous prism and cover test (SPCT) and alternate prism and cover test (APCT) outcomes after exotropia surgery, and to identify characteristics associated with significant disparity between them.

METHODS

Review of sensorimotor outcomes 2 to 6 months after exotropia surgery identified patients with alignment documented by both SPCT and APCT at the same examination. Two hundred seventy-four and 319 patients had both measurements recorded at distance and near, respectively. Correlation between the SPCT and APCT and range of APCT when the SPCT measurement was zero were determined. Patient characteristics studied for association with a difference between the SPCT and APCT exceeding known APCT test-retest variability included age, visual acuity, fusion, intermittency, pattern, preoperative and postoperative angle, and treatment with or without medial rectus resection.

RESULTS

SPCT and APCT outcomes were strongly correlated (P < .001), significantly different (P < .001), and linearly related. The percentage of patients who were orthotropic (SPCT = 0) was 76% at distance and 80% at near. Misalignment of 10 prism diopters (PD) or less by the APCT was present in 92% of orthotropic patients at distance and 84% at near. Surgery without medial rectus resection (P = .015), larger preoperative angle (P = .003), intermittent exotropia (P = .028), and postoperative exotropia rather than esotropia (P < .001) were associated with a significant SPCT-APCT difference.

CONCLUSIONS

Although a greater postoperative SPCT-APCT disparity was confirmed for patients with intermittent exotropia, it also independently associated with a larger preoperative deviation and surgery without medial rectus resection. Performing medial rectus resection, a surgeon's prerogative, provides more apparently consistent postoperative alignment characterized by less SPCT-APCT disparity. [J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus. 2017;54(4):222-230.].