Pregnancy complications in women with heart disease conceiving with fertility therapy

Best practice recommendations for medically assisted reproduction in patients with known cardiovascular disease or at high risk of cardiovascular disease

Increasing numbers of people are seeking assisted conception. In people with known cardiac disease or risk factors for cardiac disease, assisted conception may carry increased risks during treatment and any subsequent pregnancy. These risks should be assessed, considered and minimized prior to treatment.

Progressive calcification of bioprosthetic mitral valve observed during pregnancy resulting from in vitro fertilization: a case report

BACKGROUND

Women with pre-existing cardiac conditions who undergo assisted reproductive technologies (ART) are believed to be at a heightened risk of cardiovascular events during both the treatment and pregnancy phases. An unresolved question within this context pertains to whether the ART procedure itself constitutes a risk factor for individuals with bioprosthetic heart valves (BHV). Additionally, there is ongoing controversy regarding whether pregnancies expedite the process of structural valve degeneration (SVD) in BHV. The purpose of this study is to present the developmental process of BHV calcification, which is considered the primary cause of SVD, during a pregnancy resulting from in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer (IVF-ET), an ART modality, and to elucidate the underlying mechanisms.

CASE PRESENTATION

At 7 + 3 weeks of gestation in a twin pregnancy resulting from IVF-ET, a 27-year-old woman with a bioprosthetic mitral valve manifesting severe mitral stenosis and moderate pulmonary arterial hypertension, was suspected of SVD. Despite undergoing fetal reduction, she experienced progressive calcification of the bioprosthetic valve, increasing pulmonary arterial pressure and ultimately deteriorated into heart failure. An elective cesarean section and redo valve replacement was subsequently administered to improve her cardiovascular condition. As a result, a healthy young boy was delivered and the dysfunctional BHV was replaced with a mechanical valve. She did not report any discomfort during the 3-month follow-up.

CONCLUSION

The progressive calcification of the BHV was observed during IVF pregnancy, indicating a potential connection between fertility therapy, pregnancy and calcification of BHV. Pregnant women with pre-implanted BHV should be treated with caution, as any medical interventions during ART and pregnancy can have a significant impact on both maternal and fetal outcomes. Thus, involving a multidisciplinary team in decision-making early on, starting from the treatment of the original heart disease, throughout the entire process of ART and pregnancy, is crucial.

Pregnancy Considerations in Tetralogy of Fallot

The majority of women with repaired tetralogy of Fallot are able to tolerate pregnancy with a low risk of cardiovascular events. However, proactive contraceptive advice, prepregnancy counselling, and care by a pregnancy heart team with expertise in congenital heart disease are key to ensuring a good outcome for mother and baby. Maternal and fetal risks are increased in the presence of severe valvular stenosis, poorly tolerated arrhythmia, significant ventricular dysfunction, and cyanosis. It is unusual to see cyanotic adults with tetralogy of Fallot, whether unoperated or shunt palliated; pregnancy risks are greatly reduced by completing their repair before pregnancy is undertaken. The multidisciplinary pregnancy heart team should make a risk-stratified pregnancy care plan using a combination of published scoring systems and an individualized assessment of the patient's comorbidities. Low-risk patients may have the majority of their care and give birth in local units, whereas those at high risk should be managed and give birth in a tertiary centre with high-level expertise and intensive care facilities. Age-appropriate conversations about future childbearing and safe and reliable contraception should be part of routine follow-up from teenage years, so that women with tetralogy of Fallot can control their own fertility and make informed decisions about having children.

Assisted Reproductive Technology Outcomes in Women With Heart Disease

Background

Women with infertility and heart disease (HD) are increasingly seeking assisted reproductive technology (ART). There is only one other study that examines the safety profile of ART in this population. This study aims to evaluate the cardiac, reproductive, and obstetric outcomes of ART in women with HD.

Methods

We conducted a retrospective case-control study of women with underlying congenital or acquired HD who underwent ART at a single University fertility center from 1/2010-3/2019. Women undergoing in-vitro fertilization (IVF), oocyte cryopreservation (OC) or embryo banking (EB) with HD were included. Cases were matched 3:1 with age-, cycle type- and cycle start date- matched controls without HD. Outcomes included cardiovascular (CV), reproductive, and obstetric complications during or following ART.

Results

Twenty women with HD were included. 15 (75%) had congenital HD, 1 (5%) had valvular disease, 1 (5%) had acquired cardiomyopathy, and 3 (15%) had arrhythmias. 90% were New York Heart Association class I. 55% of HD cases were modified WHO (mWHO) risk classification 1-2, 40% were mWHO 2-3 or 3, 5% were mWHO 4. Cases underwent 25 IVF, 5 OC, and 5 EB cycles and were compared with 79 controls who underwent 174 cycles. No CV complications or deaths occurred amongst cases following ART or pregnancy. There was no difference in risk of ART or obstetric outcomes amongst cases versus controls.

Conclusion

For women with HD in this small, low -risk cohort, ART posed few risks that were similar in frequency to healthy controls.

Infertility, Infertility Treatment and Cardiovascular Disease: An Overview

The prevalence of maternal cardiovascular disease (CVD) has risen throughout the developed world, reflecting an increase in acquired cardiovascular risk factors, such as hypertension and diabetes, and the improved life expectancy of those living with congenital CVD due to advances in care. Because many cardiovascular risk factors or cardiovascular conditions are associated with infertility, reproductive-aged women with CVD may increasingly seek reproductive assistance. The worldwide use of assisted reproductive technologies (ART), such as in-vitro fertilization (IVF) with or without intracytoplasmic sperm injection, or intrauterine insemination following pharmacological ovulation induction have increased steadily over the last several decades. It is incumbent among providers who care for reproductive-aged women with pre-existing CVD or CVD risk factors to understand and appreciate the types of treatments offered and inherent risks related to infertility treatments, in order to guide their patients to making safe reproductive choices in line with their values and preferences. While infertility treatments increase the risk of complicated pregnancy, whether these risks are compounded among individuals with pre-existing CVD is less well known. In this review, we summarize current available evidence regarding short-term and long-term cardiovascular implications of ART among individuals with and without CVD, as well as treatment considerations for these women. Existing knowledge gaps and priority areas for further study are presented.

Congenital Heart Disease and Women's Health Across the Life Span: Focus on Reproductive Issues

From adolescence to older age, women with congenital heart disease (CHD) face unique challenges. In this review we explore the ways in which CHD affects women's sexual and reproductive health and, in turn, how their sexual and reproductive history affects the course of their CHD. In adolescence, special attention must be paid to menstrual irregularities and concerns of developing sexuality and self-image. Discussions about sexuality and reproduction are an important part of transition planning and must be done with an awareness of the adolescent's developing understanding and maturity. Pregnancy imposes a hemodynamic load on the heart which may lead to cardiac, obstetric, and fetal/neonatal complications in women with CHD. Prepregnancy counselling must include an assessment of maternal and fetal risk according to several well developed models. Counselling should also include discussions about fertility and alternatives to pregnancy when appropriate. Recommendations for contraception must be made according to the patient's cardiac lesion. In caring for women with CHD during pregnancy, a multidisciplinary cardio-obstetrics team is recommended to optimize care. More research is needed into the long-term impact of pregnancy on the prognosis of patients with CHD. As women with CHD increasingly survive into old age, more attention will need to be directed toward the treatment of menopause and acquired heart disease in this population.

Family Planning and Pregnancy Management in Adults with Congenital Heart Disease

With advances in congenital heart disease management, there are an increasing number of women reaching reproductive age. Pregnancy results in a surge of hormones and increased demands on both the cardiovascular (CV) and respiratory systems. Depending on the heart defect and the treatments the mother has undergone, these hemodynamic changes can result in an increased risk of maternal CV events and an increased risk of fetal morbidity and mortality. Thus, it is important to have a comprehensive approach to adult congenital heart disease patients involving pre-pregnancy planning in addition to diligent peri- and post-partum care.

Adult Congenital Heart Disease with Pregnancy

The number of women with congenital heart disease (CHD) at risk of pregnancy is growing because over 90% of them are grown-up into adulthood. The outcome of pregnancy and delivery is favorable in most of them provided that functional class and systemic ventricular function are good. Women with CHD such as pulmonary hypertension (Eisenmenger syndrome), severe left ventricular outflow stenosis, cyanotic CHD, aortopathy, Fontan procedure and systemic right ventricle (complete transposition of the great arteries [TGA] after atrial switch, congenitally corrected TGA) carry a high-risk. Most frequent complications during pregnancy and delivery are heart failure, arrhythmias, bleeding or thrombosis, and rarely maternal death. Complications of fetus are prematurity, low birth weight, abortion, and stillbirth. Risk stratification of pregnancy and delivery relates to functional status of the patient and is lesion specific. Medication during pregnancy and post-delivery (breast feeding) is a big concern. Especially prescribing medication with teratogenicity should be avoidable. Adequate care during pregnancy, delivery, and the postpartum period requires a multidisciplinary team approach with cardiologists, obstetricians, anesthesiologists, neonatologists, nurses and other related disciplines. Caring for a baby is an important issue due to temporarily pregnancy-induced cardiac dysfunction, and therefore familial support is mandatory especially during peripartum and after delivery. Timely pre-pregnancy counseling should be offered to all women with CHD to prevent avoidable pregnancy-related risks. Successful pregnancy is feasible for most women with CHD at relatively low risk when appropriate counseling and optimal care are provided.

Managing subfertility in patients with heart disease: What are the choices?

More women with heart disease are reaching reproductive age and will want to embark upon pregnancy. Furthermore, many of these women are delaying pregnancy until later in life when they may be exposed to a greater number of complications from their heart disease. A relatively high proportion of these women will pursue fertility treatment to achieve a pregnancy; consequently, the management of subfertile couples where the woman (or man) has heart disease is of growing importance. In this review, we discuss how fertility investigations and treatment can impact a women with heart disease and how some of the potential complications can be minimized or avoided. We also consider surrogacy, which is an important option when pregnancy is contraindicated.

Failure of fertility therapy and subsequent adverse cardiovascular events

BACKGROUND

Infertility may indicate an underlying predisposition toward premature cardiovascular disease, yet little is known about potential long-term cardiovascular events following fertility therapy. We investigated whether failure of fertility therapy is associated with subsequent adverse cardiovascular events.

METHODS

We performed a population-based cohort analysis of women who received gonadotropin-based fertility therapy between Apr. 1, 1993, and Mar. 31, 2011, distinguishing those who subsequently gave birth and those who did not. Using multivariable Poisson regression models, we estimated the relative rate ratio of adverse cardiovascular events associated with fertility therapy failure, accounting for age, year, baseline risk factors, health care history and number of fertility cycles. The primary outcome was subsequent treatment for nonfatal coronary ischemia, stroke, transient ischemic attack, heart failure or thromboembolism.

RESULTS

Of 28 442 women who received fertility therapy, 9349 (32.9%) subsequently gave birth and 19 093 (67.1%) did not. The median number of fertility treatments was 3 (interquartile range 1-5). We identified 2686 cardiovascular events over a median 8.4 years of follow-up. The annual rate of cardiovascular events was 19% higher among women who did not give birth after fertility therapy than among those who did (1.08 v. 0.91 per 100 patient-years, p < 0.001), equivalent to a 21% relative increase in the annual rate (95% confidence interval 13%-30%). We observed no association between event rates and number of treatment cycles.

INTERPRETATION

Fertility therapy failure was associated with an increased risk of long-term adverse cardiovascular events. These women merit surveillance for subsequent cardiovascular events.

Pregnancy in women with congenital heart disease

Due to advances in paediatric congenital heart surgery, there are a growing number of women with congenital heart disease (CHD) reaching childbearing age. Pregnancy, however, is associated with haemodynamic stresses which can result in cardiac decompensation in women with CHD. Many women with CHD are aware of their cardiac condition prior to pregnancy, and preconception counselling is an important aspect of their care. Preconception counselling allows women to make informed pregnancy decisions, provides an opportunity for modifications of teratogenic medications and, when necessary, repair of cardiac lesions prior to pregnancy. Less commonly, the haemodynamic changes of pregnancy unmask a previously unrecognised heart lesion. In general, pregnancy outcomes are favourable for women with CHD, but there are some cardiac lesions that carry high risk for both the mother and the baby, and this group of women require care by an experienced multidisciplinary team. This review discusses preconception counselling including contraception, an approach to risk stratification and management recommendations in women with some common CHDs.