Consensus of the Italian Primary Immunodeficiency Network on transition management from pediatric to adult care in patients affected with childhood-onset inborn errors of immunity

Transitions of Care in Patients With Inborn Errors of Immunity

Inborn errors of immunity (IEI) are a group of inherited conditions caused by damaged monogenic variants that result in impairment and/or dysregulation within the immune system. IEI are typically diagnosed in infancy or early childhood, with clinical presentations that include increased susceptibility to infections, immune dysregulation, autoinflammation, bone marrow failure, and/or malignancy. Historically, transitions of care experienced by patients with IEI have not been well described in the literature. However, with treatment advances extending the long-term survival of patients, this has become a primary area of research. It is crucial to establish guidelines and recommendations specific to the transition of patients with IEI. Transitions may include patients who naturally progress from pediatric to adult care, from inpatient to outpatient settings, or from their established health care team to a new team (ie, moving from one geographic area to another). This narrative review summarizes the current data on transitions of care and describes the health care challenges and patient-related barriers impacting transitions of care. Frameworks with practical guidance on how health care practitioners can better manage care transitions faced by patients with IEI are presented.

Health-related quality of life in patients with inborn errors of immunity: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Inborn Errors of Immunity (IEI) significantly affect patients' health-related quality of life (HRQOL), presenting greater challenges than those faced by the healthy population and other chronic disease sufferers. Current research lacks comprehensive integration of this critical issue.

OBJECTIVE

This study explores HRQOL in IEI patients, identifies impacting factors, and advocates for increased research focus on their quality of life.

METHODS

Following systematic review and meta-analysis guidelines, a search of Scopus and PubMed until November 15, 2023, yielded 1633 publications. We evaluated the literature, assessed study quality, and compared the HRQOL of IEI patients to that of healthy individuals and other chronic disease patients.

RESULTS

Of 90 articles and 10,971 IEI patients analyzed, study quality varied (nine good, 63 moderate, and 18 poor). The Short Form-36 (SF-36) and Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory generic core scales (PedsQL) were the primary generic instruments used among adults and children, respectively, with 12 studies each using the disease-specific instruments. Meta-analysis showed IEI patients have significantly lower scores in general health, physical and mental health, and social and emotional roles compared to healthy populations. We noted significant differences between self and proxy reports, indicating caregiver anxiety and perception disparities.

CONCLUSION

Despite limitations like small sample sizes and reliance on generic instruments, this research underscores the substantially lower HRQOL among IEI patients, emphasizing the need for a patient-centered, multidisciplinary approach to improve their life quality and calling for more focused attention on IEI patients and their caregivers' HRQOL.

Infectious complications in the paediatric immunocompromised host: a narrative review

BACKGROUND

Infections are a major cause of morbidity in children with primary or secondary immunodeficiency, and have a negative impact on overall outcome.

OBJECTIVES

This narrative review presents select paediatric-specific aspects regarding the clinical impact, diagnosis, management, and follow-up of infectious complications in patients with primary and secondary immunodeficiencies.

SOURCES

PubMed until January 2024 and searched references in identified articles including the search terms: infection, immunodeficiency or cancer, diagnostics, antimicrobial agents, bacteria or fungus or virus, and follow-up.

CONTENT

Major advances have been made in the early detection and management of patients with primary immunodeficiency, and multiple analyses report in children with cancer on risk groups and periods of risk for infectious complications. Although many diagnostic tools are comparable between children and adults, specific considerations have to be applied, such as minimizing the use of radiation. Antimicrobial drug development remains a major challenge in the paediatric setting, which includes the establishment of appropriate dosing and paediatric approval. Last, long-term follow-up and the impact of late effects are extremely important to be considered in the management of immunocompromised paediatric patients.

IMPLICATIONS

Although infectious disease supportive care of immunocompromised children and adolescents has considerably improved over the last three decades, close international collaboration is needed to target the specific challenges in this special population.

Experience of pediatric to adult transition in immunology services: patient experience questionnaire and micro-costing analysis

The effective transition from pediatric to adult care for individuals with chronic medical conditions should address the medical, psychosocial and educational needs of the cohort. The views and experiences of service users and their families are an integral component of service development. This study sought to evaluate the current provision of transition services from pediatric immunology services to adult immunology services for patients with a diagnosis of an inborn error of immunity at St. James's Hospital, Dublin. We gathered patient perspectives on the experience of the transition process using a structured survey. In addition, we adopted a micro-costing technique to estimate the cost of implementing the current standard of care for these patients. Results of a micro-costing analysis suggest that the most significant component of cost in assessing these patients is on laboratory investigation, an area where there is likely significant duplication between pediatric and adult care. Perspectives from patients suggested that the transition period went well for the majority of the cohort and that they felt ready to move to adult services, but the transition was not without complications in areas such as self-advocacy and medication management. The transition process may benefit from enhanced communication and collaboration between pediatric and adult services.

Transition of care in inborn errors of immunity

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This review outlines the principles of transition, summarizes current information about transition practices in inborn errors of immunity (IEI) and highlights general and specific considerations for transition of patients with these conditions.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent surveys demonstrate the variability in access to and transition practices in IEI. Key challenges of transition in IEI from the perspective of healthcare professionals include lack of adult subspecialists, lack of access to holistic care and fragmentation of adult services. Limited research focused on IEI patient and carer perspectives highlight information gaps, poor coordination and difficulty adapting to adult healthcare structures as important challenges for smooth transition.

SUMMARY

Local policies and practices for transition in IEI are highly variable with limited assessment of outcomes or patient experience. There is a need for IEI-focused transition research and for development of national and international consensus statements to guide improved transition in IEI.

Navigating the transition of care in patients with inborn errors of immunity: a single-center's descriptive experience

The transition from pediatric to adult care is a critical milestone in managing children, especially in those with complex chronic conditions. It involves ensuring the patient and family adapt correctly to the new phase, maintaining continuity of ongoing treatments, and establishing an appropriate follow-up plan with specialists. Patients with Inborn error of immunity (IEI), formerly known as Primary Immune Disorders (PID) are part of a group of disorders characterized by alterations in the proper functioning of the immune system; as the diagnostic and treatment tools for these entities progress, life expectancy increases, and new needs emerge. These children have special needs during the transition. Particularly important in the group of children with PID and syndromic features, who often present multiple chronic medical conditions. In these cases, transition planning is a significant challenge, involving not only the patients and their families but also a wide range of specialists. To achieve this, a multidisciplinary transition team should be established between the pediatric specialists and the adult consultants, designing a circuit in which communication is essential. As few transition care guidelines in the field of PID are available, and to our knowledge, there is no specific information available regarding patients with PID associated with syndromic features, we share our experience in this issue as a Primary Immunodeficiencies Unit that is a National Reference Center for PID, and propose a guide to achieve an adequate and successful transition to adulthood in these patients, especially in those with associated syndromic features.

Transitioning from pediatric to adult healthcare with an inborn error of immunity: a qualitative study of the lived experience of youths and their families

Introduction

Transition from pediatric to adult healthcare is a multifaceted and consequential process with important health implications for youth. Although research on transition has grown significantly, research on transition for patients living with an inborn error of immunity (IEI) is scarce. We undertook a qualitative study to better understand the perspectives of youths and parents in an outpatient immunology clinic.

Methdos

Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 9 youths, 6 parents and 5 clinicians, all recruited from the same clinic. All youths recently transferred to adult care with or without an established diagnosis of IEI. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and thematic analysis was conducted. Two sets of themes were generated. The first set captured the positive and negative aspects experienced during transition, as well as recommendations to facilitate the process. The second set focused on key topics discussed in the interviews that were merged into overarching themes.

Results

Perspectives of participants were clustered into 6 overarching themes: (1) lack of knowledge about IEIs; (2) scattered transitions; (3) changing healthcare teams; (4) approaching an unknown environment; (5) transitioning to adulthood; (6) assuming responsibility for the management of the condition. Overall, the challenges encountered with respect to these themes had profound clinical and humanistic implications for patients such as generating significant distress.

Discussion

We discuss the unique challenges of the youths in our study in comparison to common problems reported by youths with chronic illness in the broader transition literature (for example: the change of healthcare team, the lack of information about the transition process and navigating the adult care system, growth towards self-management and the co-occurring developmental transition to adulthood). There is an urgency to attend to the specific problems created by the rarity of IEIs and related lack of knowledge about them as well as the need for multidisciplinary cross-clinic care during transition and beyond.

Transition practice for primary immunodeficiency diseases in Southeast Asia: a regional survey

Introduction

With increased diagnostic capabilities and treatment modalities in the field of primary immunodeficiencies (PID), many pediatric patients survive beyond childhood and experience a change of care to the adult-oriented healthcare system. Unfortunately, the transition pathways for PID are less clearly defined, resulting in deterioration of quality of care in adulthood. Hence, this is the first regional study to address PID clinicians' opinions on practices and challenges of transition care in 7 Southeast Asia (SEA) countries.

Methods

We adopted a cross-sectional study design through an online survey platform to enquire opinions of transition practices from expert representatives in 7 SEA countries.

Results

Regionally, 3 out 7 countries reported having no practice of transition care. Among cited challenges were reluctant adaptation by patients and caregivers to unfamiliarized adult healthcare systems, inadequate ratio of adult immunologists to patients and lack of facilities for transfer.

Discussion and conclusion

Our study provides evidence to advocate policy makers on the importance of standardized integration of transition practice towards betterment of transiting PID patients into adulthood.

Knowledge, Attitudes, and Practices of Allergists/Immunologists Regarding Transition of Care for Primary Immunodeficiency Patients

PURPOSE

Only some allergists/immunologists provide care throughout the lifespan despite their training. Although transition of care (TOC) guidelines exist, research on provider perspectives on TOC for pediatric primary immunodeficiency (PID) patients is lacking. We aimed to characterize knowledge, attitudes, and practices and establish clinician needs using a needs assessment survey.

METHODS

The 15-min online survey was adapted from an existing rheumatology TOC survey and was emailed to the American Academy of Allergy Asthma and Immunology (AAAAI) and Clinical Immunology Society (CIS) members. Our primary hypothesis was that both AAAAI and CIS providers report being underprepared for TOC and would express interest in TOC resources and consensus.

RESULTS

Forty-nine of 1250 eligible AAAAI and 67 of 698 eligible CIS participants completed the survey (4.8% vs 11.3% participation rate). Many (53.1% vs 59.7%) respondents transition their own patients but also retain adult patients (59.2% vs 52.2%). Many accepted transition patients (85.7% vs 92.5%). In total, 24.1% of respondents did not have a TOC policy while 18.9% have an informal policy. Only 25.0% were satisfied with their current practices while 43.9% agreed that a consensus statement would be useful.

CONCLUSION

Despite a small sample size and high rate of unanswered questions, our findings show that TOC remains overlooked in our specialty and that providers want and need additional training and resources. There is a clear need to develop and evaluate the effectiveness of evidence-based TOC guidelines, resources, and best practices for PID patients.

Current Transition Practice for Primary Immunodeficiencies and Autoinflammatory Diseases in Europe: a RITA-ERN Survey

BACKGROUND

Due to the absence of curative treatments for inborn errors of immunity (IEI), children born with IEI require long-term follow-up for disease manifestations and related complications that occur over the lifespan. Effective transition from pediatric to adult services is known to significantly improve adherence to treatment and long-term outcomes. It is currently not known what transition services are available for young people with IEI in Europe.

OBJECTIVE

To understand the prevalence and practice of transition services in Europe for young people with IEI, encompassing both primary immunodeficiencies (PID) and systemic autoinflammatory disorders (AID).

METHODS

A survey was generated by the European Reference Network on immunodeficiency, autoinflammatory, and autoimmune diseases Transition Working Group and electronically circulated, through professional networks, to pediatric centers across Europe looking after children with IEI.

RESULTS

Seventy-six responses were received from 52 centers, in 45 cities across 17 different countries. All services transitioned patients to adult services, mainly to specialist PID or AID centers, typically transferring up to ten patients to adult care each year. The transition process started at a median age of 16-18 years with transfer to the adult center occurring at a median age of 18-20 years. 75% of PID and 68% of AID centers held at least one joint appointment with pediatric and adult services prior to the transfer of care. Approximately 75% of PID and AID services reported having a defined transition process, but few centers reported national disease-specific transition guidelines to refer to.

CONCLUSIONS

Transition services for children with IEI in Europe are available in many countries but lack standardized guidelines to promote best practice.

The management of transitional care of patients affected by phenylketonuria in Italy: Review and expert opinion

Phenylketonuria (PKU) is a metabolic inherited disorder in which transition from infancy to adult care is particularly difficult and not sufficiently regulated. According to the scientific literature, only few medical centers offer healthcare assistance for adult patients with PKU that are therefore still treated in pediatric settings. This generates psychological, emotional, and organizational discomfort among patients, leading them to discontinue the follow-up. European guidelines and national consensus documents underline this unmet need and the lack of practical recommendations for a structured transitional pathway in PKU. The aim of this review and expert opinion is to propose good practices for managing the transition period of PKU patients, based on the literature and the experience of a panel of Italian experts in PKU. The consensus of the experts was obtained through the administration of three rounds of surveys and one structured interview. The result is the first proposal of a pathway for an efficient transition of PKU patients. Key steps of the proposed pathway are the "a priori" planning involving the pediatric and adult teams, the acceptance of the patient and his/her family to the process, the preliminary definition of appropriate spaces in the structure, the organization of meetings with the joint team, and the appointment of a transition coordinator. For the first time, the involvement of decision makers and patient associations is proposed.