The effects of knee pain on knee contact force and external knee adduction moment in patients with knee osteoarthritis

Relationship of the weaknesses of knee- and hip-spanning muscles with knee compression forces during stair ascent and descent

BACKGROUND

The musculoskeletal models have been improved to estimate accurate knee compression force (KCF) and have been used to reveal the causal relationship between KCF and muscle weakness. Previous studies have explored how muscle weakness influences the KCF during gait; however, the influence of muscle weakness is possibly larger during activities that require deeper knee flexion (e.g., stair ambulation) than other activities (e.g., gait) because of the small knee contact area of articular surfaces.

RESEARCH QUESTION

To explore how muscle weakness influences the KCF during stair ambulation.

METHODS

Ten young adults performed stair ascent and descent tasks at a comfortable speed. Based on a previous study, we created muscle weakness models of rectus femoris (RF), vastus muscles (VAS), gluteus medius (Gmed), and gluteus maximus (Gmax), and the medial and lateral KCF (KCFmed and KCFlat) during stair ambulation were calculated.

RESULTS

Similar to the gait, the Gmed weakness increased KCFmed and decreased KCFlat during stair ascent and descent. Whereas, unlike the gait, the Gmax weakness increased KCFmed during stair ascent and the VAS weakness decreased KCFmed and KCFlat during stair ascent and descent. Moreover, the percentage changes in KCF were similar (or large) during stair ambulation compared with those during gait.

SIGNIFICANCE

Considering the KCF alterations caused by each muscle weakness, the weaknesses in Gmax and Gmed might lead to cartilage loss and pain in the knee, and the VAS weakness might lead to low stability of the knee. The symptom during stair ambulation might help precisely identify the muscle requiring rehabilitation.

Characteristics of Acute Cartilage Response After Mechanical Loading in Patients with Early-Mild Knee Osteoarthritis

This study determined whether the acute cartilage response, assessed by cartilage thickness and echo intensity, differs between patients with early-mild knee osteoarthritis (OA) and healthy controls. We recruited 56 women aged ≥ 50 years with Kellgren-Lawrence (KL) grade ≤ 2 (age, 70.6 ± 7.4 years; height, 153.7 ± 5.2 cm; weight, 51.9 ± 8.2 kg). Based on KL grades and knee symptoms, the participants were classified into control (KL ≤ 1, asymptomatic, n = 27) and early-mild knee OA groups (KL 1 and symptomatic, KL 2, n = 29). Medial femoral cartilage thickness and echo intensity were assessed using ultrasonographic B-mode images before and after treadmill walking (15 min, 3.3 km/h). To investigate the acute cartilage response, repeated-measures analysis of covariance (groups × time) with adjusted age, external knee moment impulse, steps during treadmill walking, and cartilage thickness at pre-walking was performed. A significant interaction was found at the tibiofemoral joint; after walking, the cartilage thickness was significantly decreased in the early-mild knee OA group compared to the control group (p = 0.002). At the patellofemoral joint, a significant main effect of time was observed, but no interaction was detected (p = 0.802). No changes in cartilage echo intensity at either the tibiofemoral or patellofemoral joints, and no interactions were noted (p = 0.295 and p = 0.063). As acute cartilage response after walking, the thickness of the medial tibiofemoral joint in the early-mild knee OA was significantly reduced than that in the control group. Thus, greater acute deformation after walking might be a feature found in patients with early-mild knee OA.

Understanding muscle coordination during gait based on muscle synergy and its association with symptoms in patients with knee osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to investigate the muscle coordination differences between a control group and patients with mild and severe knee osteoarthritis (KOA) using muscle synergy analysis and determine whether muscle coordination was associated with symptoms of KOA.

METHOD

Fifty-three women with medial KOA and 19 control patients participated in the study. The gait analyses and muscle activity measurements of seven lower limb muscles were assessed using a motion capture system and electromyography. Gait speed and knee adduction moment impulse were calculated. The spatiotemporal components of muscle synergy were extracted using non-negative matrix factorization, and the dynamic motor control index during walking (walk-DMC) was computed. The number of muscle synergy and their spatiotemporal components were compared among the mild KOA, severe KOA, and control groups. Moreover, the association between KOA symptoms with walk-DMC and other gait parameters was evaluated using multi-linear regression analysis.

RESULTS

The number of muscle synergies was lower in mild and severe KOA compared with those in the control group. In synergy 1, the weightings of biceps femoris and gluteus medius in severe KOA were higher than that in the control group. In synergy 3, the weightings of higher tibial anterior and lower gastrocnemius lateralis were confirmed in the mild KOA group. Regression analysis showed that the walk-DMC was independently associated with knee-related symptoms of KOA after adjusting for the covariates.

CONCLUSIONS

Muscle coordination was altered in patients with KOA. The correlation between muscle coordination and KOA may be attributed to the knee-related symptoms. Key points • Patients with knee osteoarthritis (OA) experienced a deterioration in muscle coordination when walking. • Loss of muscle coordination was associated with severe knee-related symptoms in knee OA. • Considering muscle coordination as a knee OA symptom-related factor may provide improved treatment.

Delivering Load-Modifying Gait Retraining Interventions via Telehealth in People With Medial Knee Osteoarthritis: A Pilot Randomized Placebo-Controlled Clinical Trial

We aimed to investigate the effects of delivering 3 gait retraining interventions (toe-in, toe-out, and placebo gait) on proxy measures of medial knee load (early- and late-stance peak knee adduction moment [KAM], KAM impulse, and varus thrust) in people with knee osteoarthritis, using a hybrid model of face-to-face and telehealth-delivered sessions over 5 months. This was an originally planned 3-arm randomized placebo-controlled clinical trial. However, during the 2021 COVID-19 outbreak and lockdown in Sydney, Australia, the study became a pilot randomized controlled trial with the remainder of interventions delivered via telehealth. Nine individuals with symptomatic medial knee osteoarthritis were allocated to receive either a toe-in, toe-out, or posture re-education (placebo) gait retraining intervention. Primary outcomes of early- and late-stance peak KAM, KAM impulse, and varus thrust were assessed at baseline and follow-up. Eight participants returned for their follow-up gait assessment. Participants in both active intervention groups (toe-in and toe-out) achieved foot progression angle changes at follow-up. Overall, knee biomechanics in the placebo group did not change at follow-up. It is possible to achieve biomechanical changes in individuals with medial knee osteoarthritis when delivering gait retraining interventions via a hybrid model of face-to-face and telehealth.

The effectiveness of a 6-week biofeedback gait retraining programme in people with knee osteoarthritis: protocol for a randomised controlled trial

BACKGROUND

Gait retraining is a common therapeutic intervention that can alter gait characteristics to reduce knee loading in knee osteoarthritis populations. It can be enhanced when combined with biofeedback that provides real-time information about the users' gait, either directly (i.e. knee moment feedback) or indirectly (i.e. gait pattern feedback). However, it is unknown which types of biofeedback are more effective at reducing knee loading, and also how the changes in gait affect pain during different activities of daily living. Therefore, this study aims to evaluate the acute (6 weeks of training) and chronic (1 month post training) effects of biofeedback based on personalised gait patterns to reduce knee loading and pain in people with knee osteoarthritis, as well as examine if more than one session of knee moment feedback is needed to optimise the gait patterns.

METHODS

This is a parallel group, randomised controlled trial in a symptomatic knee osteoarthritis population in which participants will be randomised into either a knee moment biofeedback group (n = 20), a gait pattern biofeedback group (n = 20) or a control group (n = 10). Supervised training sessions will be carried out weekly for six continuous weeks, with real-time biofeedback provided using marker-based motion capture and an instrumented treadmill. Baseline, post-intervention and 1-month follow-up assessments will be performed to measure knee loading parameters, gait pattern parameters, muscle activation, knee pain and functional ability.

DISCUSSION

This study will identify the optimal gait patterns for participants' gait retraining and compare the effectiveness of gait pattern biofeedback to a control group in reducing knee loading and index knee pain. Additionally, this study will explore how many sessions are needed to identify the optimal gait pattern with knee moment feedback. Results will be disseminated in future peer-reviewed journal articles, conference presentations and internet media to a wide audience of clinicians, physiotherapists, researchers and individuals with knee osteoarthritis.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

This study was retrospectively registered under the International Standard Randomised Controlled Trial Number registry on 7th March 2023 (ISRCTN28045513).

Medial and lateral knee contact forces during walking, stair ascent and stair descent are more affected by contact locations than tibiofemoral alignment in knee osteoarthritis patients with varus malalignment

Introduction: Knee OA progression is related to medial knee contact forces, which can be altered by anatomical parameters of tibiofemoral alignment and contact point locations. There is limited and controversial literature on medial-lateral force distribution and the effect of anatomical parameters, especially in motor activities different from walking. We analyzed the effect of tibiofemoral alignment and contact point locations on knee contact forces, and the medial-lateral force distribution in knee OA subjects with varus malalignment during walking, stair ascending and stair descending. Methods: Fifty-one knee OA subjects with varus malalignment underwent weight-bearing radiographs and motion capture during walking, stair ascending and stair descending. We created a set of four musculoskeletal models per subject with increasing level of personalization, and calculated medial and lateral knee contact forces. To analyze the effect of the anatomical parameters, statistically-significant differences in knee contact forces among models were evaluated. Then, to analyze the force distribution, the medial-to-total contact force ratios were calculated from the fully-informed models. In addition, a multiple regression analysis was performed to evaluate correlations between forces and anatomical parameters. Results: The anatomical parameters significantly affected the knee contact forces. However, the contact points decreased medial forces and increased lateral forces and led to more marked variations compared to tibiofemoral alignment, which produced an opposite effect. The forces were less medially-distributed during stair negotiation, with medial-to-total ratios below 50% at force peaks. The anatomical parameters explained 30%-67% of the variability in the knee forces, where the medial contact points were the best predictors of medial contact forces. Discussion: Including personalized locations of contact points is crucial when analyzing knee contact forces in subjects with varus malalignment, and especially the medial contact points have a major effect on the forces rather than tibiofemoral alignment. Remarkably, the medial-lateral force distribution depends on the motor activity, where stair ascending and descending show increased lateral forces that lead to less medially-distributed loads compared to walking.

Ultrasonographic echo intensity in the medial femoral cartilage is enhanced prior to cartilage thinning in women with early mild knee osteoarthritis

PURPOSE

We aimed to determine whether altered cartilage echo intensity is associated with knee osteoarthritis (OA) severity and whether the alteration occurs before thinning of the femoral cartilage in knee OA.

METHODS

The medial femoral cartilage thickness and echo intensity of 118 women aged ≥ 50 years were assessed using an ultrasound imaging device. Based on the Kellgren-Lawrence (KL) grade and knee symptoms, participants were classified into five groups: control (asymptomatic grades 0-1), early OA (symptomatic grade 1), grade 2, grade 3, and grade 4. Analysis of covariance, with adjusted age and height, and the Sidak post hoc test were used to assess the differences in cartilage thickness and echo intensity in knees with varying OA severity.

RESULTS

The echo intensity on longitudinal images, equivalent to the tibiofemoral weight-bearing surface, was significantly higher in the grade 2 group than that in the control group (p = 0.049). However, no significant difference was noted in cartilage thickness (n.s.). In the grades 3 and 4 groups, cartilage thickness became thinner as OA progressed (p < 0.001 and p < 0.001, respectively). However, the cartilage echo intensity was not significantly enhanced compared with that of the grade 2 group (n.s.). There were no significant differences in the cartilage thickness and echo intensity between the early OA and control groups on the longitudinal images (n.s.).

CONCLUSIONS

The echo intensity of the medial femoral cartilage was high in patients with KL grade 2, without decreased thickness. Our findings suggested that higher echo intensity is a feature of early cartilage degeneration in mild knee OA. Further studies are needed to establish this feature as a useful screening parameter of early cartilage degeneration in knee OA.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

High tibial osteotomy effectively redistributes compressive knee loads during walking

The objectives of this study were to estimate pre- and postoperative lower limb kinematics and kinetics and knee intra-articular forces during gait using musculoskeletal modeling in a cohort of patients with knee osteoarthritis (OA) undergoing high tibial osteotomy (HTO), compare these to controls, and determine correlations between changes in these parameters and Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) subscores after HTO. Sixteen patients with isolated, symptomatic medial compartment knee OA completed pre- and postoperative gait analysis (mean follow-up time: 8.6 months). Sixteen age- and sex-matched asymptomatic volunteers participated as controls. Musculoskeletal modeling was used to evaluate lower limb joint moments and knee contact forces during gait. While HTO had limited influence on sagittal plane kinematics and moments, significant changes in the load distribution at the knee after HTO were observed with a lower postoperative compressive load on the medial compartment during midstance and a higher compressive load on the lateral compartment during early and late stance. Moreover, the lateral shear force in midstance was significantly lower after HTO. Changes in the external knee adduction moment (KAM) did not always coincide with reductions in the knee compressive force in the medial compartment. Biomechanical changes did not correlate with improvements in KOOS subscores. Hence, HTO effectively unloaded the medial compartment by redistributing part of the overall compressive force to the lateral compartment during gait with limited influence on gait function. The KAM may not adequately describe compartmental load magnitude or changes induced by interventions at the compartment level. Clinical trial registration: ClinicalTrials. gov Identifier-NCT02622204. Clinical significance: This study provides important evidence for changes in joint level loads after corrective osteotomy as joint preserving surgery and emphasizes the need for additional biomechanical outcomes of such interventions.

Determining the optimal gait modification strategy for patients with knee osteoarthritis: Trunk lean or medial thrust?

BACKGROUND

The gait modification strategies Trunk Lean and Medial Thrust have been shown to reduce the external knee adduction moment (EKAM) in patients with knee osteoarthritis which could contribute to reduced progression of the disease. Which strategy is most optimal differs between individuals, but the underlying mechanism that causes this remains unknown.

RESEARCH QUESTION

Which gait parameters determine the optimal gait modification strategy for individual patients with knee osteoarthritis?

METHODS

Forty-seven participants with symptomatic medial knee osteoarthritis underwent 3-dimensional motion analysis during comfortable gait and with two gait modification strategies: Medial Thrust and Trunk Lean. Kinematic and kinetic variables were calculated. Participants were then categorized into one of the two subgroups, based on the modification strategy that reduced the EKAM the most for them. Multiple logistic regression analysis with backward elimination was used to investigate the predictive nature of dynamic parameters obtained during comfortable walking on the optimal modification gait strategy.

RESULTS

For 68.1 % of the participants, Trunk Lean was the optimal strategy in reducing the EKAM. Baseline characteristics, kinematics and kinetics did not differ significantly between subgroups during comfortable walking. Changes to frontal trunk and tibia angles correlated significantly with EKAM reduction during the Trunk Lean and Medial Thrust strategies, respectively. Regression analysis showed that MT is likely optimal when the frontal tibia angle range of motion and peak knee flexion angle in early stance during comfortable walking are high (R²_Nagelkerke = 0.12).

SIGNIFICANCE

Our regression model based solely on kinematic parameters from comfortable walking contained characteristics of the frontal tibia angle and knee flexion angle. As the model explains only 12.3 % of variance, clinical application does not seem feasible. Direct assessment of kinetics seems to be the most optimal strategy for selecting the most optimal gait modification strategy for individual patients with knee osteoarthritis.

Early Changes in Postural Balance Following Inverted V-Shaped High Tibial Osteotomy in Patients With Knee Osteoarthritis

Patients with knee osteoarthritis and varus knee deformity have impaired postural balance, resulting in decreased walking performance and an increased risk of falls. This study aimed to investigate the early changes in the postural balance following inverted V-shaped high tibial osteotomy (HTO). Fifteen patients with medial knee osteoarthritis were recruited. Postural balance was assessed using the center-of-pressure (COP) data during single-leg standing before and 6 weeks after inverted V-shaped HTO. The maximum range, mean velocity, and area of COP movements in the anteroposterior and mediolateral directions were analyzed. Preoperative and postoperative visual analog scale for knee pain was assessed. The maximum range of COP in the mediolateral direction decreased (P = .017), whereas the mean velocity of COP in the anteroposterior direction increased 6 weeks postoperatively (P = .011). The visual analog scale score for knee pain significantly improved at 6 weeks postoperatively (P = .006). Valgus correction with inverted V-shaped HTO resulted in improved postural balance in the mediolateral direction and good short-term clinical outcomes early following surgery. Early rehabilitation after inverted V-shaped HTO should focus on postural balance in the anteroposterior direction.

Relationship Between Knee Biomechanics and Pain in People With Knee Osteoarthritis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

Our primary aim was to determine the cross-sectional relationship between knee biomechanics during gait and pain in people with medial knee osteoarthritis. Our secondary aim was to evaluate differences in knee biomechanics between symptomatic and asymptomatic participants with medial knee osteoarthritis.

METHODS

Four online databases were searched from inception to July 2021. Eligible studies included people with medial/nonspecific knee osteoarthritis and a reported relationship between knee biomechanics during gait and pain or biomechanics of symptomatic and asymptomatic participants. Two reviewers independently extracted data and evaluated risk of bias. Random-effects meta-analyses were performed when three or more studies reported the same biomechanical variable for pooling (knee adduction moment [KAM], KAM impulse, varus thrust, and peak knee flexion moment [KFM]).

RESULTS

Forty studies were included. Methodological quality ranged from 4 to 9/10. Forty-seven unique biomechanical variables were reported. For the KAM, there was no correlation with pain for peak values pooled (early stance and overall) (r = 0.00, 95% confidence interval [95% CI]: -0.12, 0.11, k = 16), a small negative correlation for early stance peak alone (r = -0.09, 95% CI -0.18, -0.002, k = 12), and a medium positive correlation for the overall peak during stance (r = 0.30, 95% CI 0.17, 0.42, k = 4). Metaregression identified that body mass index moderated the peak KAM-pain relationship (P < 0.001). KAM impulse had a small positive correlation with pain (r = 0.23, 95% CI 0.04, 0.40, k = 5), and people with varus thrust had 3.84 greater odds of reporting pain compared with people without (95% CI 1.72, 8.53, k = 3). Meta-analyses for the peak KFM and pain correlation and secondary aim were nonsignificant.

CONCLUSION

Some knee gait biomechanics were associated with pain in this cohort. Longitudinal studies are required to determine causality.

Towards Tailored Rehabilitation by Implementation of a Novel Musculoskeletal Finite Element Analysis Pipeline

Tissue-level mechanics (e.g., stress and strain) are important factors governing tissue remodeling and development of knee osteoarthritis (KOA), and hence, the success of physical rehabilitation. To date, no clinically feasible analysis toolbox has been introduced and used to inform clinical decision making with subject-specific in-depth joint mechanics of different activities. Herein, we utilized a rapid state-of-the-art electromyography-assisted musculoskeletal finite element analysis toolbox with fibril-reinforced poro(visco)elastic cartilages and menisci to investigate knee mechanics in different activities. Tissue mechanical responses, believed to govern collagen damage, cell death, and fixed charge density loss of proteoglycans, were characterized within 15 patients with KOA while various daily activities and rehabilitation exercises were performed. Results showed more inter-participant variation in joint mechanics during rehabilitation exercises compared to daily activities. Accordingly, the devised workflow may be used for designing subject-specific rehabilitation protocols. Further, results showed the potential to tailor rehabilitation exercises, or assess capacity for daily activity modifications, to optimally load knee tissue, especially when mechanically-induced cartilage degeneration and adaptation are of interest.

An EMG-assisted muscle-force driven finite element analysis pipeline to investigate joint- and tissue-level mechanical responses in functional activities: towards a rapid assessment toolbox

Joint tissue mechanics (e.g., stress and strain) are believed to have a major involvement in the onset and progression of musculoskeletal disorders, e.g., knee osteoarthritis (KOA). Accordingly, considerable efforts have been made to develop musculoskeletal finite element (MS-FE) models to estimate highly detailed tissue mechanics that predict cartilage degeneration. However, creating such models is time-consuming and requires advanced expertise. This limits these complex, yet promising MS-FE models to research applications with few participants and makes the models impractical for clinical assessments. Also, these previously developed MS-FE models have not been used to assess activities other than gait. This study introduces and verifies a semi-automated rapid state-of-the-art MS-FE modeling and simulation toolbox incorporating an electromyography- (EMG) assisted MS model and a muscle-force driven FE model of the knee with fibril-reinforced poro(visco)elastic cartilages and menisci. To showcase the usability of the pipeline, we estimated joint- and tissue-level knee mechanics in 15 KOA individuals performing different daily activities. The pipeline was verified by comparing the estimated muscle activations and joint mechanics to existing experimental data. To determine the importance of EMG-assisted MS approach, results were compared to those from the same FE models but driven by static-optimization-based MS models. The EMG-assisted MS-FE pipeline bore a closer resemblance to experiments compared to the static-optimization-based MS-FE pipeline. Importantly, the developed pipeline showed great potential as a rapid MS-FE analysis toolbox to investigate multiscale knee mechanics during different activities of individuals with KOA. The template FE model of the study is freely available here.