Influence of Pt particle size and reaction phase on the photocatalytic performances of ultradispersed Pt/TiO2 catalysts for hydrogen evolution

Stable and Highly Active Single Atom Configurations for Photocatalytic H2 Generation

The employment of single atoms (SAs), especially Pt SAs, as co-catalysts in photocatalytic H2 generation has gained significant attention due to their exceptional efficiency. However, a major challenge in their application is the light-induced agglomeration of these SAs into less active nanosized particles under photocatalytic conditions. This study addresses the stability and reactivity of Pt SAs on TiO2 surfaces by investigating various post-deposition annealing treatments in air, Ar, and Ar-H2 environments at different temperatures. It is described that annealing in an Ar-H2 atmosphere optimally stabilizes SA configurations, forming stable 2D rafts of assembled SAs ≈0.5-1 nm in diameter. These rafts not only resist light-induced agglomeration but also exhibit significantly enhanced H2 production efficiency. The findings reveal a promising approach to maintaining the high reactivity of Pt SAs while overcoming the critical challenge of their stability under photocatalytic conditions.

Facet-engineered TiO2 drives photocatalytic activity and stability of supported noble metal clusters during H2 evolution

Metal clusters supported on TiO2 are widely used in many photocatalytic applications, including pollution control and production of solar fuels. Besides high photoactivity, stability during the photoreaction is another essential quality of high-performance photocatalysts, however systematic studies on this attribute are absent for metal clusters supported on TiO2. Here we have studied, both experimentally and with first-principles simulation methods, the stability of Pt, Pd and Au clusters prepared by ball milling on nanoshaped anatase nanoparticles preferentially exposing {001} (plates) and {101} (bipyramids) facets during the photogeneration of hydrogen. It is found that Pt/TiO2 exhibits superior stability than Pd/TiO2 and Au/TiO2, and that {001} facet-based photocatalysts always are more stable than their {101} analogous regardless of the considered metal species. The loss of stability associated with cluster sintering, which is facilitated by the transfer of photoexcited carriers from the metal species to the neighbouring Ti and O atoms, most significantly and detrimentally affects the H2-evolution photoactivity.

A step-by-step strategy to design active and stable quaternary intermetallic compounds for the hydrogen evolution reaction

Multinary intermetallic compounds with rich chemical compositions enable one to achieve a logical design for desired materials based on the required function. In this work, we have demonstrated a step-by-step strategy to design a quaternary intermetallic compound that exhibits highly active and stable performance for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). With binary intermetallic TaCo2 as the starting point, the minor inclusion of a ductile Cu element in TaCo2 to form ternary TaCu0.25Co1.75 can substantially lower the degradation rate from ca. 20% to 5% after sintering treatment (i.e., enhance connectivity between particles). However, the overpotential at a current density of 10 mA cm-2 (η10) increases by ca. 20 mV from TaCo2 to TaCu0.25Co1.75. Further incorporation of a HER active Ru element to cast quaternary TaCu0.125Ru0.125Co1.75 can decrease ca. 70 mV of η10 while maintaining long-term stability. This proves that one can design functional intermetallic compounds intentionally, which may be extended to different fields of application.

Reactive Deposition Versus Strong Electrostatic Adsorption (SEA): A Key to Highly Active Single Atom Co-Catalysts in Photocatalytic H2 Generation

In recent years, the use of single atoms (SAs) has become of a rapidly increasing significance in photocatalytic H2 generation; here SA noble metals (mainly Pt SAs) can act as highly effective co-catalysts. The classic strategy to decorate oxide semiconductor surfaces with maximally dispersed SAs relies on "strong electrostatic adsorption" (SEA) of suitable noble metal complexes. In the case of TiO2 - the classic benchmark photocatalyst - SEA calls for adsorption of cationic Pt complexes such as [(NH3 )4 Pt]2+ which then are thermally reacted to surface-bound SAs. While SEA is widely used in literature, in the present work it is shown by a direct comparison that reactive attachment based on the reductive anchoring of SAs, e.g., from hexachloroplatinic(IV) acid (H2 PtCl6 ) leads directly to SAs in a configuration with a significantly higher specific activity than SAs deposited with SEA - and this at a significantly lower Pt loading and without any thermal post-deposition treatments. Overall, the work demonstrates that the reactive deposition strategy is superior to the classic SEA concept as it provides a direct electronically well-connected SA-anchoring and thus leads to highly active single-atom sites in photocatalysis.

Fermi-level shift, electron separation, and plasmon resonance change in Ag nanoparticle-decorated TiO2 under UV light illumination

Noble metal nanoparticles are widely used as co-catalysts for storing and separating electrons in semiconductor photocatalysis. Thus, evaluating this ability is important and meaningful to understand the photocatalytic mechanism. Employing Ag nanoparticles, the present study combined in situ photoconductance and theoretical analysis to evaluate the Fermi-level (E_F) shift in a UV-illuminated Ag/TiO₂ system under gaseous conditions. Based on this, the role of the Ag nanoparticles in storing and separating electrons was discussed. It was found that the E_F of Ag/TiO₂ is located deeper in the gap and a variation in temperature has less effect on the E_F of Ag/TiO₂ compared to the undecorated TiO₂. The analysis showed that ∼46 electrons can be stored in 10 nm Ag nanoparticles under our experimental conditions, which does not change with temperature. The electron traps in TiO₂ can affect the electron distribution in the TiO₂ and Ag nanoparticles. It was observed that the localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) of the Ag nanoparticles exhibited a blue-shift under UV light illumination, which is generally ascribed to the electron storage in the Ag nanoparticles. However, we showed that the blue-shift is not related to the electron storage in the Ag nanoparticles, and thus it cannot be used as an indicator for evaluating their electron-storage ability. The in situ XPS analysis also does not support that the LSPR blue shift is associated with the reduction in the Ag₂O layer and TiO₂.

Light-Induced Agglomeration of Single-Atom Platinum in Photocatalysis

With recent advances in the field of single-atoms (SAs) used in photocatalysis, an unprecedented performance of atomically dispersed co-catalysts has been achieved. However, the stability and agglomeration of SA co-catalysts on the semiconductor surface may represent a critical issue in potential applications. Here, the photoinduced destabilization of Pt SAs on the benchmark photocatalyst, TiO₂ , is described. In aqueous solutions within illumination timescales ranging from few minutes to several hours, light-induced agglomeration of Pt SAs to ensembles (dimers, multimers) and finally nanoparticles takes place. The kinetics critically depends on the presence of sacrificial hole scavengers and the used light intensity. Density-functional theory calculations attribute the light induced destabilization of the SA Pt species to binding of surface-coordinated Pt with solution-hydrogen (adsorbed H atoms), which consequently weakens the Pt SA bonding to the TiO₂ surface. Despite the gradual aggregation of Pt SAs into surface clusters and their overall reduction to metallic state, which involves >90% of Pt SAs, the overall photocatalytic H₂ evolution remains virtually unaffected.

Aldehyde Hydrogenation by Pt/TiO2 Catalyst in Aqueous Phase: Synergistic Effect of Oxygen Vacancy and Solvent Water

The aldehyde hydrogenation for stabilizing and upgrading biomass is typically performed in aqueous phase with supported metal catalysts. By combining density functional theory calculations and ab initio molecular dynamics simulations, the model reaction of formaldehyde hydrogenation with a Pt/TiO₂ catalyst is investigated with explicit solvent water molecules. In aqueous phase, both the O vacancy (Ov) on support and solvent molecules could donate charges to a Pt cluster, where the Ov could dominantly reduce the Pt cluster from positive to negative. During the formaldehyde hydrogenation, the water molecules could spontaneously protonate the O in the aldehyde group by acid/base exchange, generating the OH* at the metal-support interface by long-range proton transfer. By comparing the stoichiometric and reduced TiO₂ support, it is found that the further hydrogenation of OH* is hard on the positively charged Pt cluster over stoichiometric TiO₂. However, with the presence of Ov on reduced support, the OH* hydrogenation could become not only exergonic but also kinetically more facile, which prohibits the catalyst from poisoning. This mechanism suggests that both the proton transfer from solvent water molecules and the easier OH* hydrogenation from Ov could synergistically promote aldehyde hydrogenation. That means, even for such simple hydrogenation in water, the catalytic mechanism could explicitly relate to all of the metal cluster, oxide support, and solvent waters. Considering the ubiquitous Ov defects in reducible oxide supports and the common aqueous environment, this synergistic effect may not be exclusive to Pt/TiO₂, which can be crucial for supported metal catalysts in biomass conversion.

Property-governed performance of platinum-modified titania photocatalysts

Titania is probably the most widely investigated semiconductor photocatalyst because of various advantages, such as high activity, thermal and chemical stability, low price, abundance, and negligible toxicity. However, pristine titania is also characterized by charge carriers’ recombination, and thus lower quantum yields of photocatalytic reactions than theoretical 100%. Moreover, its wide bandgap, despite being recommended for excellent redox properties, means also inactivity under visible part of solar radiation. Accordingly, titania has been surface modified, doped and coupled with various elements/compounds. For example, platinum deposited on the surface of titania has shown to improve both UV activity and the performance under vis. Although the studies on titania modification with platinum started almost half a century ago, and huge number of papers have been published up to now, it is unclear which properties are the most crucial and recommended to obtain highly efficient photocatalyst. In the literature, the opposite findings could be found on the property-governed activities that could result from huge differences in the reaction systems, and also examined photocatalysts. Considering the platinum properties, its content, the size of nanoparticles and the oxidation state, must be examined. Obviously, the characteristics of titania also influence the resultant properties of deposited platinum, and thus the overall photocatalytic performance. Although so many reports on Pt/TiO₂ have been published, it is hardly possible to give indispensable advice on the recommended properties. However, it might be concluded that usually fine platinum NPs uniformly deposited on the titania surface result in high photocatalytic activity, and thus in the low optimal content of necessary platinum. Moreover, the aggregation of titania particles might also help in the lowering the necessary platinum amount (even to 0.2 wt%) due to the interparticle electron transfer mechanism between titania particles in one aggregate. In respect of platinum state, it is thought that it is highly substrate-specific case, and thus either positively charged or zero valent platinum is the most recommended. It might be concluded that despite huge number of papers published on platinum-modified titania, there is still a lack of comprehensive study showing the direct correlation between only one property and the resultant photocatalytic activity.

Synergistic effects of Tin sulfide Nitrogen-doped titania Nanobelt-Modified graphitic carbon nitride nanosheets with outstanding photocatalytic activity

Designing efficient ternary nanostructures is a feasible approach for energy production under simulated solar irradiation. In this study, excellent photoexcited charge carrier separation and enhanced visible-light response were achieved with nitrogen-doped titania nanobelts (N-TNBs), whose 1D geometry facilitated the fabrication of a heterostructure with SnS₂ on the surface of graphitic carbon nitride (g-C₃N₄). We established the design of SnS₂@N-TNB and SnS₂@N-TNB/g-C₃N₄ heterostructures by in situ hydrothermal and ultrasonication processes, and achieved commendable simulated solar light driven photocatalytic H₂ generation. UV-vis diffuse reflectance spectroscopy analysis revealed a red shift in the absorption spectra of the SnS₂@N-TNB and SnS₂@N-TNB/g-C₃N₄ samples. The H₂ produced via SnS₂@N-TNB-10/g-C₃N₄ (6730.8 µmol/g/h) was 2.6 times higher than that produced by SnS₂@N-TNB (2515.1 µmol/g/h), and 299 times higher than that produced by N-TNB (22.5 µmol/g/h). The improved photocatalytic H₂ production was attributed to the maximum interface contact between SnS₂@N-TNB and g-C₃N₄, and to the improved visible-light absorption and effective charge-carrier separation. Therefore, the present study provides novel insights for combining the advantages of ternary materials to improve the conversion of solar energy to H₂ fuel.

Optimized Pt Single Atom Harvesting on TiO2 Nanotubes-Towards a Most Efficient Photocatalyst

In the present work the authors show that anodic TiO₂ nanotubes (NT) show excellent harvesting properties for Pt single atoms (Pt SAs) from highly dilute Pt solutions. The tube walls of anodic nanotubes, after adequate annealing to anatase, provide ample of suitable trapping sites-that is, surface Ti³⁺ -O_v (O_v : oxygen vacancy) defects that are highly effective to extract and accumulate Pt in the form of SAs. A saturated (maximized) SA density can be achieved by an overnight immersion of a TiO₂ NT layer to a H₂ PtCl₆ solution with a concentration that is as low as 0.01 mm Pt. Such TiO₂ NTs with surface trapped Pt SAs provide a maximized high activity for photocatalytic H₂ generation (reaching a turnover frequency (TOF) of 1.24 × 10⁶ h^-1 at a density of 1.4 × 10⁵ Pt atoms µm^-2 )-a higher loading with Pt nanoparticles does not further increase the photocatalytic activity. Overall, these findings show that anodic TiO₂ nanotubes provide a remarkable substrate for Pt extraction and recovery from very dilute solutions that directly results in a highly efficient photocatalyst, fabricated by a simple immersion technique.

Two Tungstates Containing Platinum Nanoparticles Prepared by Air-Calcining Keggin-Type Polyoxotungstate-Coordinated Diplatinum(II) Complexes: Effect on Sintering-Resistance and Photocatalysis

Two tungstates containing platinum nanoparticles (Pt Npts) were obtained by air-calcining α-Keggin-type diplatinum(II)-coordinated polyoxotungstates, Cs3[α-PW11O39{cis-Pt(NH3)2}2]⋅8H2O (Cs-P-Pt) and Cs4[α-SiW11O39{cis-Pt(NH3)2}2]⋅11H2O (Cs-Si-Pt), at 700–900 °C for 5 h. The polyoxotungstate Cs-P-Pt was transformed to a mixture of Pt Npts and Cs3PW12O40 upon calcination, while the Cs-Si-Pt structures were transformed to Pt Npts and Cs4W11O35. The Pt Npts generated by air-calcining Cs-P-Pt at 700 °C for 5 h were uniform with an average particle size of 3.6 ± 1.1 nm, which was much smaller than that of the Pt Npts obtained by calcining Cs-Si-Pt (19.9 ± 9.9 nm) under identical conditions. This demonstrated the significant inhibitory effect of Cs-P-Pt on aggregation during high-temperature air-calcination at a high platinum content (10.6 wt.%) and in the absence of a support. During calcination at 700–900 °C, Cs-P-Pt exhibited higher activities than Cs-Si-Pt with respect to hydrogen evolution from aqueous triethanolamine solutions under visible light irradiation in the presence of Eosin Y, α-Keggin-type mono-aluminum-substituted polyoxotungstate, and titanium dioxide. When Cs-P-Pt was calcined at 800 °C for 100 h, no decrease in activity was observed in comparison with that upon calcination for 5 h.

Graphical Abstract

Structural transformations of solid electrocatalysts and photocatalysts

Heterogeneous catalysts often undergo structural transformations when they operate under thermal reaction conditions. These transformations are reflected in their evolving catalytic activity, and a fundamental understanding of the changing nature of active sites is vital for the rational design of solid materials for applications. Beyond thermal catalysis, both photocatalysis and electrocatalysis are topical because they can harness renewable energy to drive uphill reactions that afford commodity chemicals and fuels. Although structural transformations of photocatalysts and electrocatalysts have been observed in operando, the resulting implications for catalytic behaviour are not fully understood. In this Review, we summarize and compare the structural evolution of solid thermal catalysts, electrocatalysts and photocatalysts. We suggest that well-established knowledge of thermal catalysis offers a good basis to understand emerging photocatalysis and electrocatalysis research.

Pt–BiVO4/TiO2 composites as Z-scheme photocatalysts for hydrogen production from ethanol: the effect of BiVO4 and Pt on the photocatalytic efficiency

The photodeposition of platinum particles on the BiVO₄/TiO₂ composite surface promotes the H₂ production by reducing H⁺ species.

Photoinduced Deposition of Platinum from (Bu4N)2[Pt(NO3)6] for a Low Pt-Loading Pt/TiO2 Hydrogen Photogeneration Catalyst

An efficient method for the deposition of ionic platinum species PtO_x onto a TiO₂ surface was developed on the basis of light-induced activation of the [Pt(NO₃)₆]^2- anion. The deposited PtO_x species with an effective Pt oxidation state between +4 and +2 have an oxygen-made environment and include single ion centers {PtO_n} and polyatomic ensembles {Pt_nO_m} connected to a TiO₂ surface with Pt-O-Ti bonds. The resulting PtO_x/TiO₂ materials were tested as photocatalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) from a water ethanol mixture and have shown uniquely high activity with the rate of H₂ evolution achieving 11 mol h^-1 per gram of Pt, which is the highest result for such materials reported to date. A combination of spectral methods shows that, under HER conditions, reduction of the supported PtO_x species leads to the formation of well-dispersed nanoparticles of metallic platinum attached on the surface of TiO₂ by Ti-O-Pt bonds. The high activity of the PtO_x/TiO₂ materials is believed to result from a combination of uniform distribution of small platinum nanoparticles over the titania surface and their close interaction with TiO₂.

A perspective on oxide-supported single-atom catalysts

Single-atom catalysts (SACs) can not only maximize the metal atom utilization efficiency, but also show drastically improved catalytic performance for various important catalytic processes. Insights into the working principles of SACs provide rational guidance to design and prepare advanced catalysts. Many factors have been claimed to affect the performance of SACs, which makes it very challenging to clarify the correlation between the catalytic performance and physicochemical characteristics of SACs. Oxide-supported SACs are one of the most extensively explored systems. In this minireview, some latest developments on the determining factors of the stability, activity and selectivity of SACs on oxide supports are overviewed. Discussed also are the reaction mechanisms for different systems and methods that are employed to correlate the properties with the catalyst structures at the atomic level. In particular, a recently proposed surface free energy approach is introduced to fabricate well-defined modelled SACs that may help address some key issues in the development of SACs in the future.

Crystallization time in ZnO: the role of surface OH groups in its photoactivity

The crystallization time and surface modifications concerning the hydroxyl groups on the ZnO catalyst were studied and the results suggest that there is a balance between the surface groups and morphology playing a critical role in its photoactivity.

TiO2-supported Pt single atoms by surface organometallic chemistry for photocatalytic hydrogen evolution

Platinum single atoms are grafted by SOMC on morphology-controlled TiO₂. Their structure is characterized by EXAFS and other techniques, and their activity and stability in HER and backwards reaction are studied and compared to Pt nanoparticles.