Predicting the outcome of transcatheter mitral valve implantation using image-based computational models

Standardization and validation of neoLVOT assessment using three-dimensional trans-esophageal echocardiography before trans-catheter mitral valve replacement

BACKGROUND

Trans-catheter mitral valve replacement (TMVR) procedures had emerged as an alternative solution for patients who are at high risk for mitral valve surgery. Although cardiac computed tomography (CT) remains the standard method for procedural planning, there is no full agreement on the best systolic phase for quantitation of the neoLVOT. Furthermore, a new three-dimensional trans-esophageal echocardiography (3DTEE) based software was developed to serve as filter and or an alternative for patients who cannot have CT due to any contraindication.

AIM

To determine the systolic phase of the cardiac cycle that shows the narrowest NeoLVOT area in order to standardize the way of using these software and then to validate the 3DTEE-based software against the CT-based one as a gold standard, in mitral valve annulus (MA) and NeoLVOT assessment.

METHODS

A single center, observational, retrospective study. Initially, a sample of 20 patients (age 62 ± 4 years, 70% men) had CT-based analysis at mid-diastole (80%), early-systole (10%), mid-systole (20%), late-systole (30%-40%), in order to detect the best systolic phase at which the neoLVOT area is the narrowest after TMVR. Then, the end systolic phase was standardized for the analysis of 49 patients (age 57 ± 6 years, 60% men), using both the commercially available CT-based software and the newly available 3DTEE-based software (3mensio Structural Heart, Pie Medical Imaging, The Netherlands). The 3DTEE derived parameters were compared with the gold standard CT-based measurements.

RESULTS

The neoLVOT area was significantly narrower at end-systole (224 ± 62 mm2), compared to early-systole (299 ± 70 mm2) and mid-systole (261 ± 75 mm2), (p = .005). Excellent correlation was found between 3DTEE and CT measurements for MA AP diameter (r = .96), IC diameter (r = .92), MA area (r = .96), MA perimeter (r = .94) and NeoLVOT area (r = .96), (all p-values < .0001). Virtual valve sizing was based on annulus measurement and was identical between CT and 3DTEE. Interobserver and intraobserver agreements were excellent for all the measurements with ICCs > .80.

CONCLUSIONS

End-systole is the phase that shows the narrowest neoLVOT and hence should be the standard phase used during the analysis. The 3DTEE based analysis using this new software is reliable compared to the CT-based analysis and can be serve as an alternative analysis tool in patients who cannot have CT for any clinical contraindication or as a screening test and/or filter for all patients before proceeding to a detailed CT scan.

Patient-specific fluid simulation of transcatheter mitral valve replacement in mitral annulus calcification

Introduction

Transcatheter mitral valve replacement is a promising alternative to open-heart surgery in elderly patients. Patients with severe mitral annulus calcification (MAC) are a particularly high-risk population, where postprocedural complications can have catastrophic effects. Amongst these, obstruction of the left ventricular outflow tract can lead to ventricular hypertrophic remodeling and subsequent heart failure, while subclinical valve thrombosis can result in early bioprosthetic valve failure.

Methods

To elucidate the mechanisms of left ventricular outflow tract obstruction and valve thrombosis following valve-in-MAC procedures, we used image processing and Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) software to generate patient- and device-specific models based on preprocedural CT data. Personalized computer simulations were performed to predict the left ventricular haemodynamics after implantation in three patients with severe MAC.

Results

The simulations have successfully captured the increased pressure gradient in the left ventricular outflow tract as a result of the partial obstruction due to the implanted valve. Regions of wall shear stress above the threshold value for platelet activation were also observed on the bioprosthetic frame as a result of the reduced outflow tract area, which led to increases in flow resistance and blood residence time inside the ventricle. Consistent with these findings, areas of slow recirculating flow and blood stasis formed near the valve frame, creating potential pro-thrombotic conditions.

Discussion

This study provides insight into the relationship between size and shape of the outflow tract post-implantation, pressure gradients and pro-thrombotic flow metrics such as wall shear stress and blood residence time. Results show the potential of CFD modeling to bring key functional metrics into preprocedural assessment for a comprehensive evaluation of post-procedural risks beyond anatomical factors. Following further validation and extension to the atrial chamber, this approach can provide an in-depth analysis of the likelihood of valvular thrombosis.

Role of computed tomography in transcatheter replacement of 'other valves': a comprehensive review of preprocedural imaging

Transcatheter procedures for heart valve repair or replacement represent a valid alternative for treating patients who are inoperable or at a high risk for open-heart surgery. The transcatheter approach has become predominant over surgical intervention for aortic valve disease, but it is also increasingly utilized for diseases of the 'other valves', that is the mitral and, to a lesser extent, tricuspid and pulmonary valve. Preprocedural imaging is essential for planning the transcatheter intervention and computed tomography has become the main imaging modality by providing information that can guide the type of treatment and choice of device as well as predict outcome and prevent complications. In particular, preprocedural computed tomography is useful for providing anatomic details and simulating the effects of device implantation using 3D models. Transcatheter mitral valve replacement is indicated for the treatment of mitral regurgitation, either primary or secondary, and computed tomography is crucial for the success of the procedure. It allows evaluating the mitral valve apparatus, the surrounding structures and the left heart chambers, identifying the best access route and the landing zone and myocardial shelf, and predicting obstruction of the left ventricular outflow tract, which is the most frequent postprocedural complication. Tricuspid valve regurgitation with or without stenosis and pulmonary valve stenosis and regurgitation can also be treated using a transcatheter approach. Computer tomography provides information on the tricuspid and pulmonary valve apparatus, the structures that are spatially related to it and may be affected by the procedure, the right heart chambers and the right ventricular outflow tract.

Fluid structure computational model of simulating mitral valve motion in a contracting left ventricle

BACKGROUND

Fluid structure interaction simulations h hold promise in studying normal and abnormal cardiac function, including the effect of fluid dynamics on mitral valve (MV) leaflet motion. The goal of this study was to develop a 3D fluid structure interaction computational model to simulate bileaflet MV when interacting with blood motion in left ventricle (LV).

METHODS

The model consists of ideal geometric-shaped MV leaflets and the LV, with MV dimensions based on human anatomical measurements. An experimentally-based hyperelastic isotropic material was used to model the mechanical behaviour of the MV leaflets, with chordae tendineae and papillary muscle tips also incorporated. LV myocardial tissue was prescribed using a transverse isotropic hyperelastic formulation. Incompressible Navier-Stokes fluid formulations were used to govern the blood motion, and the Arbitrary Lagrangian Eulerian (ALE) method was employed to determine the mesh deformation of the fluid and solid domains due to trans-valvular pressure on MV boundaries and the resulting leaflet movement.

RESULTS

The LV-MV generic model was able to reproduce physiological MV leaflet opening and closing profiles resulting from the time-varying atrial and ventricular pressures, as well as simulating normal and prolapsed MV states. Additionally, the model was able to simulate blood flow patterns after insertion of a prosthetic MV with and without left ventricular outflow tract flow obstruction. In the MV-LV normal model, the regurgitant blood flow fraction was 10.1 %, with no abnormality in cardiac function according to the mitral regurgitation severity grades reported by the American Society of Echocardiography.

CONCLUSION

Our simulation approach provides insights into intraventricular fluid dynamics in a contracting LV with normal and prolapsed MV function, as well as aiding in the understanding of possible complications after transcatheter MV implantation prior to clinical trials.

Assessing the Hemodynamic Impact of Anterior Leaflet Laceration in Transcatheter Mitral Valve Replacement: An in silico Study

Background

A clinical study comparing the hemodynamic outcomes of transcatheter mitral valve replacement (TMVR) with vs. without Laceration of the Anterior Mitral leaflet to Prevent Outflow Obstruction (LAMPOON) has never been designed nor conducted.

Aims

To quantify the hemodynamic impact of LAMPOON in TMVR using patient-specific computational (in silico) models.

Materials

Eight subjects from the LAMPOON investigational device exemption trial were included who had acceptable computed tomography (CT) data for analysis. All subjects were anticipated to be at prohibitive risk of left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) obstruction from TMVR, and underwent successful LAMPOON immediately followed by TMVR. Using post-procedure CT scans, two 3D anatomical models were created for each subject: (1) TMVR with LAMPOON (performed procedure), and (2) TMVR without LAMPOON (virtual control). A validated computational fluid dynamics (CFD) paradigm was then used to simulate the hemodynamic outcomes for each condition.

Results

LAMPOON exposed on average 2 ± 0.6 transcatheter valve cells (70 ± 20 mm² total increase in outflow area) which provided an additional pathway for flow into the LVOT. As compared to TMVR without LAMPOON, TMVR with LAMPOON resulted in lower peak LVOT velocity, lower peak LVOT gradient, and higher peak LVOT effective orifice area by 0.4 ± 0.3 m/s (14 ± 7% improvement, p = 0.006), 7.6 ± 10.9 mmHg (31 ± 17% improvement, p = 0.01), and 0.2 ± 0.1 cm² (17 ± 9% improvement, p = 0.002), respectively.

Conclusion

This was the first study to permit a quantitative, patient-specific comparison of LVOT hemodynamics following TMVR with and without LAMPOON. The LAMPOON procedure achieved a critical increment in outflow area which was effective for improving LVOT hemodynamics, particularly for subjects with a small neo-left ventricular outflow tract (neo-LVOT).

Clinical Impact of Computational Heart Valve Models

This paper provides a review of engineering applications and computational methods used to analyze the dynamics of heart valve closures in healthy and diseased states. Computational methods are a cost-effective tool that can be used to evaluate the flow parameters of heart valves. Valve repair and replacement have long-term stability and biocompatibility issues, highlighting the need for a more robust method for resolving valvular disease. For example, while fluid-structure interaction analyses are still scarcely utilized to study aortic valves, computational fluid dynamics is used to assess the effect of different aortic valve morphologies on velocity profiles, flow patterns, helicity, wall shear stress, and oscillatory shear index in the thoracic aorta. It has been analyzed that computational flow dynamic analyses can be integrated with other methods to create a superior, more compatible method of understanding risk and compatibility.

Characterization of Flow Dynamics in the Pulmonary Bifurcation of Patients With Repaired Tetralogy of Fallot: A Computational Approach

The hemodynamic environment of the pulmonary bifurcation is of great importance for adult patients with repaired tetralogy of Fallot (rTOF) due to possible complications in the pulmonary valve and narrowing of the left pulmonary artery (LPA). The aim of this study was to computationally investigate the effect of geometrical variability and flow split on blood flow characteristics in the pulmonary trunk of patient-specific models. Data from a cohort of seven patients was used retrospectively and the pulmonary hemodynamics was investigated using averaged and MRI-derived patient-specific boundary conditions on the individualized models, as well as a statistical mean geometry. Geometrical analysis showed that curvature and tortuosity are higher in the LPA branch, compared to the right pulmonary artery (RPA), resulting in complex flow patterns in the LPA. The computational analysis also demonstrated high time-averaged wall shear stress (TAWSS) at the outer wall of the LPA and the wall of the RPA proximal to the junction. Similar TAWSS patterns were observed for averaged boundary conditions, except for a significantly modified flow split assigned at the outlets. Overall, this study enhances our understanding about the flow development in the pulmonary bifurcation of rTOF patients and associates some morphological characteristics with hemodynamic parameters, highlighting the importance of patient-specificity in the models. To confirm these findings, further studies are required with a bigger cohort of patients.

Transcatheter Repair and Replacement Technologies for Mitral Regurgitation: a European Perspective

Purpose of Review

We aimed to picture the contemporary landscape of available catheter-based repair and replacement solutions for mitral regurgitation (MR) in Europe.

Recent Findings

Edge-to-edge repair remains the dominant technique for transcatheter mitral valve repair especially in the context of secondary mitral regurgitation. Two recent randomized trials reported seemingly contradicting clinical results with transcatheter edge-to-edge repair for patients with heart failure and severe secondary MR. A proportionality framework related to secondary MR was proposed to help explain inconsistencies but requires further research. (In)Direct annuloplasty primarily aims to correct secondary MR; however, the scientific basis seems less robust. One dedicated transcatheter heart valve has the CE mark for mitral valve replacement but requires transapical access. Balloon-expandable transcatheter aortic valve platforms are emerging for transvenous transseptal mitral replacement in the context of mitral annular calcification, a failing surgical mitral bioprosthesis, or annuloplasty. Advanced computed tomography imaging techniques improved pre-procedural planning and introduced the option for modeling and simulation.

Summary

Development of a toolbox of catheter-based technologies, complementary imaging modalities, and refined patient selection offer novel perspectives to high-risk patients with primary or secondary MR. Clinical trials are required to help formulate evidence-based guidelines for the management of mitral valve disease.

Transcatheter Mitral Valve Replacement: Current Evidence and Concepts

Over the past decade, several transcatheter devices have been developed to address the treatment of severe mitral regurgitation (MR) in patients at high surgical risk, mainly aimed at repairing the native mitral valve (MV). MV repair devices have recently been shown to have high efficacy and safety. However, to replicate promising trial results, specific anatomical and pathophysiological criteria have to be met and operators need a high level of experience. As yet, the longer-term durability of transcatheter MV repair remains unknown. Transcatheter MV replacement (TMVR) might be a treatment option able to target various anatomies, reliably abolish MR, and foster ease of use with a standardised implantation protocol. This review presents upcoming TMVR devices and available data and discusses how TMVR might further advance the field of transcatheter treatment of MR.

Numerical Biomechanics Models of the Interaction Between a Novel Transcatheter Mitral Valve Device and the Subvalvular Apparatus

Objective

Mitral valve regurgitation (MR) is a common valvular heart disease where improper closing causes leakage. Currently, no transcatheter mitral valve device is commercially available. Raanani (co-author) and colleagues have previously proposed a unique rotational implantation, ensuring anchoring by metallic arms that pull the chordae tendineae. This technique is now being implemented in a novel device design. The aim of this study is to quantify the rotational implantation effect on the mitral annulus kinematics and on the stresses in the chordae and papillary muscles.

Methods

Finite element analysis of the rotational step of the implantation in a whole heart model is employed to compare 5 arm designs with varying diameters (25.9 mm to 32.4 mm) and rotation angles (up to 140°). The arm rotation that grabs the chordae was modeled when the valve was in systolic configuration.

Results

An increase in the rotation angle results in reduced mitral annulus perimeters. Larger rotation angles led to higher chordae stresses with the 29.8 mm experiencing the maximum stresses. The calculated chordae stresses suggest that arm diameter should be <27.8 mm and the rotation angle <120°.

Conclusions

The upper limit of this diameter range is preferred in order to reduce the stresses in the papillary muscles while grabbing more chords. The findings of this study can help improving the design and performance of this unique device and procedural technique.

Current and Future Application of Transcatheter Mitral Valve Replacement

Mitral valve anatomy is complex, and one size does not fit all. More recently, percutaneous mitral valve interventions have revolutionized the management of primary and secondary mitral regurgitation (MR). However, edge-to-edge leaflet repair is not suitable for a large proportion of individuals including those with a failing bioprosthetic mitral valve/annuloplasty ring, and patients with significant mitral annular calcification resulting in mixed mitral valve disease/mitral stenosis. For this high risk cohort, transcatheter mitral valve replacement seems to be an attractive alternative.

A Simplified In Silico Model of Left Ventricular Outflow in Patients After Transcatheter Mitral Valve Replacement with Anterior Leaflet Laceration

In silico modeling has been proposed as a tool to simulate left ventricular (LV) outflow tract (LVOT) obstruction in patients undergoing transcatheter mitral valve replacement (TMVR). This study validated a simplified approach to simulate LV outflow hemodynamics in the setting of TMVR with anterior leaflet laceration, a clinical technique used to mitigate the risk of LVOT obstruction. Personalized, 3-dimensional computational fluid dynamics models were developed from computed tomography images of six patients who underwent TMVR with anterior leaflet laceration. LV outflow hemodynamics were simulated using the patient-specific anatomy and the peak systolic flow rate as boundary conditions. The peak outflow velocity, a clinically relevant hemodynamic metric, was extracted from each simulation (v_sim-peak) and compared with the clinical measurement from Doppler echocardiography (v_clin-peak) for validation. In silico models were successfully developed and implemented for all patients. The pre-processing time was 2 h per model and the simulation could be completed within 3 h. In three patients, the lacerated anterior leaflet exposed open cells of the transcatheter valve to flow. Good agreement was obtained between v_sim-peak and v_clin-peak (r = 0.97, p < 0.01) with average discrepancies of 5 ± 2% and 14 ± 1% for patients with exposed and unexposed cells of the transcatheter valve, respectively. The proposed in silico modeling paradigm therefore simulated LV outflow hemodynamics in a time-efficient manner and demonstrated good agreement with clinical measurements. Future studies should investigate the ability of this paradigm to support clinical applications.

Neo-LVOT and Transcatheter Mitral Valve Replacement: Expert Recommendations

With the advent of transcatheter mitral valve replacement (TMVR), the concept of the neo-left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) was introduced and remains an essential component of treatment planning. This paper describes the LVOT anatomy and provides a step-by-step computed tomography methodology to segment and measure the neo-LVOT while discussing the current evidence and outstanding challenges. It also discusses the technical and hemodynamic factors that play a major role in assessing the neo-LVOT. A summary of expert-based recommendations about the overall risk of LVOT obstruction in different scenarios is presented along with the currently available methods to reduce the risk of LVOT obstruction and other post-procedural complications.

Multidisciplinary preoperative simulations to optimize surgical outcomes in a challenging case of the complete double aortic arch in the adult

BACKGROUND

Challenging surgical cases are becoming more and more frequent, making the optimization of decision making process and an accurate preoperative planning mandatory in order to improve postoperative outcomes.

AIMS

Here we present an original multidisciplinary approach aimed at optimizing decision making in a peculiar case of double aortic arch (DAA) presenting in an adult patient.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Following the diagnosis of DAA, based on conventional exams, a three steps engineering simulation was adopted including: a) three-dimensional (3D) rapid prototype simulation; b) computational fluid-dynamic analysis; c) 3D virtual simulation of surgical exposure.

RESULTS

Based on careful evaluation of such simulations we were able to identify optimal anatomical and functional surgical options, along with the optimal surgical approach.

DISCUSSION

In peculiar clinical case, a significant step forward to optimize preoperative surgical planning could be obtained applying current available engineering techniques.

CONCLUSION

We do believe that a multidisciplinary approach could become mandatory, in challenging cases, to optimize preoperative planning and outcomes.