Inconclusive diagnosis after a positive newborn bloodspot screening result for cystic fibrosis; clarification of the harmonised international definition

What is cystic fibrosis screen positive inconclusive diagnosis? And what is it not?

Since screening for cystic fibrosis (CF) was incorporated into the newborn screening program, the number of recognised variants in the CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene has significantly increased. This has led to the discovery of combinations of gene variants with an uncertain prognosis. One outcome is the designation of 'cystic fibrosis screen positive inconclusive diagnosis' (CFSPID). While the majority of these children are expected to be unaffected by their CFTR variants, a small proportion have been seen to develop symptoms or increasing sweat chloride levels over time, which may reflect dysfunction of the CFTR protein.As the number of children with CFSPID increases, paediatricians and those working in primary care are more likely to encounter them in their practice. It is important that professionals have an understanding of CFSPID: what it is and, importantly, what it is not (ie, they do not have CF). In this article, we hope to explore this using some example cases, illustrating the ways in which these children may present symptomatically and how to manage them.

Diagnostic Transitions of Cystic Fibrosis and Related Metabolic Syndrome Compared After 12 Years of Newborn Screening in California

OBJECTIVE

To compare the long-term diagnostic transitions for cystic fibrosis (CF) and CF-Related Metabolic Syndrome (CRMS) side-by-side during follow-up since the onset of newborn screening in California.

STUDY DESIGN

Using real-world data, we conducted a retrospective cohort study to compare long-term observations of CRMS and CF in California and the diagnostic transitions from one to the other using clinical and diagnostic metrics. The California Genetic Disease Screening Program (GDSP) newborn screening for CF employs an immunoreactive trypsinogen tier-1 laboratory test, followed by molecular testing. This approach captures CF and CRMS, a diagnosis of "watchful waiting" among infants at risk for CF but with signs and symptoms that may emerge outside the screening window. Waiting entails periodic diagnostic reviews that can continue for many years; GDSP routinely conducts five years of follow-up for each child identified with a disorder. We utilized categorial logistic regression to compare the transitions with CRMS.

RESULTS

After screening 5,944,700 newborns between July 2007 and July 2019, 694 CF cases and 1,258 CRMS cases were identified. Of the 1,258 CRMS cases, 66 (5.2%, 95% CI=3.9%,6.4%) transitioned from CRMS to CF (CRMS2CF) at a mean age of 3.3 years (median=2.9 years). CRMS2CF cases had longer follow-up periods and were more likely later to develop positive sweat chloride and fecal elastase test results after 6 months of life than other CRMS cases.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that children who have a CRMS2CF transition are more likely to develop positive biochemical markers than other CRMS patients and have few clinical indications during the first five years of follow-up.

Literary evidence of the impact of nonbiological risk factors on CRMS/CFSPID: A scoping review

Newborn screening for cystic fibrosis (CF) occasionally results in an inconclusive diagnosis of this disease, and these individuals are designated as CFTR-related metabolic syndrome (CRMS) in the United States, and CF Screen Positive Inconclusive Diagnosis (CFSPID) in other countries. Some of these asymptomatic individuals will progress to symptomatic disease, but risk factors associated with disease progression are not well understood. This scoping review was conducted to comprehensively map nonbiological risk factors in the CRMS/CFSPID literature and to identify understudied topics. Six electronic databases were systematically searched, resulting in 2951 studies. Forty nine eligible works were identified as including information on nonbiological risk factors related to CRMS/CFPSID. Eligible studies were published from 2002 to 2024, most prevalently in the United States (36.7%), and as quantitative data (81.6%). Of the 49 eligible works, 23 articles contributed only intellectual conjecture, while 26 articles contained original data, which underwent full-text qualitative content analysis. Key themes identified in descending order of content coverage included Psychological Impact, Management Care, Newborn Screening and Diagnostics, Communicating Diagnosis, and Lifestyle and External Exposures. This scoping review identified that while nonbiological risk factors are being studied in the CRMS/CFSPID literature, there was nearly equal distribution of works gathering original data to those citing previously published information. These findings indicate a critical need for original data collection on these risk factors, particularly on understudied topics identified herein.

Cystic fibrosis

Cystic fibrosis is a rare genetic disease caused by mutations in CFTR, the gene encoding cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR). The discovery of CFTR in 1989 has enabled the unravelling of disease mechanisms and, more recently, the development of CFTR-directed therapeutics that target the underlying molecular defect. The CFTR protein functions as an ion channel that is crucial for correct ion and fluid transport across epithelial cells lining the airways and other organs. Consequently, CFTR dysfunction causes a complex multi-organ disease but, to date, most of the morbidity and mortality in people with cystic fibrosis is due to muco-obstructive lung disease. Cystic fibrosis care has long been limited to treating symptoms using nutritional support, airway clearance techniques and antibiotics to suppress airway infection. The widespread implementation of newborn screening for cystic fibrosis and the introduction of a highly effective triple combination CFTR modulator therapy that has unprecedented clinical benefits in up to 90% of genetically eligible people with cystic fibrosis has fundamentally changed the therapeutic landscape and improved prognosis. However, people with cystic fibrosis who are not eligible based on their CFTR genotype or who live in countries where they do not have access to this breakthrough therapy remain with a high unmet medical need.

International Perspectives of Extended Genetic Sequencing When Used as Part of Newborn Screening to Identify Cystic Fibrosis

There is increasing interest in using extended genetic sequencing (EGS) in newborn screening (NBS) for cystic fibrosis (CF). How this is implemented will change the number of children being given an uncertain outcome of CRMS/CFSPID (cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR)-related metabolic syndrome/CF Screen Positive Inconclusive Diagnosis), probable carrier results, and the number of missed CF diagnoses. An international survey of CF health professionals was used to gather views on two approaches to EGS-specific (may reduce detection of CRMS/CFSID but miss some CF cases) versus sensitive (may increase detection of CRMS/CFSPID but avoid missing more CF cases). Health professionals acknowledged the anxiety caused to parents (and health professionals) from the uncertainty surrounding the prognosis and management of CRMS/CFSPID. However, most preferred the sensitive approach, as overall, identifying more cases of CRMS/CFSPID was viewed as less physically and psychologically damaging than a missed case of CF. The importance of early diagnosis and treatment for CF to ensure better health outcomes and reducing diagnostic odysseys for parents were highlighted. A potential benefit to identifying more children with CRMS/CFSPID included increasing knowledge to obtain a better understanding of how these children should best be managed in the future.

Diagnostic challenges in CFTR-related metabolic syndrome: Where the guidelines fall short

Newborn screening (NBS) for cystic fibrosis (CF) has enabled earlier diagnosis and has improved nutritional and growth-related outcomes in children with CF. For those with a positive NBS for CF that do not meet the diagnostic criteria for CF, the clinical entity called CFTR-Related Metabolic Syndrome (CRMS) or CF Screen- Positive, Inconclusive Diagnosis (CFSPID) is used. Although most children with CRMS remain relatively asymptomatic, studies have shown that between 11% and 48% of these patients may eventually progress to a diagnosis of CF over time. Although the CF Foundation guidelines for CRMS management and European CF Society guidelines for CFSPID have some similarities, there are also some differences. Here, we review challenging case scenarios that highlight remaining gaps in CRMS guidelines, thus supporting the need to update and unify existing guidelines.

Benchmarking AlphaMissense pathogenicity predictions against cystic fibrosis variants

Variants in the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator gene (CFTR) result in cystic fibrosis-a lethal autosomal recessive disorder. Missense variants that alter a single amino acid in the CFTR protein are among the most common cystic fibrosis variants, yet tools for accurately predicting molecular consequences of missense variants have been limited to date. AlphaMissense (AM) is a new technology that predicts the pathogenicity of missense variants based on dual learned protein structure and evolutionary features. Here, we evaluated the ability of AM to predict the pathogenicity of CFTR missense variants. AM predicted a high pathogenicity for CFTR residues overall, resulting in a high false positive rate and fair classification performance on CF variants from the CFTR2.org database. AM pathogenicity score correlated modestly with pathogenicity metrics from persons with CF including sweat chloride level, pancreatic insufficiency rate, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection rate. Correlation was also modest with CFTR trafficking and folding competency in vitro. By contrast, the AM score correlated well with CFTR channel function in vitro-demonstrating the dual structure and evolutionary training approach learns important functional information despite lacking such data during training. Different performance across metrics indicated AM may determine if polymorphisms in CFTR are recessive CF variants yet cannot differentiate mechanistic effects or the nature of pathophysiology. Finally, AM predictions offered limited utility to inform on the pharmacological response of CF variants i.e., theratype. Development of new approaches to differentiate the biochemical and pharmacological properties of CFTR variants is therefore still needed to refine the targeting of emerging precision CF therapeutics.

Optimization of performance of Dutch newborn screening for cystic fibrosis

BACKGROUND

Dutch newborn screening (NBS) for Cystic Fibrosis (CF) introduced in 2011 showed a sensitivity of 90% and a positive predictive value (PPV) of 63%. We describe a study including an optimization phase and evaluation of the modified protocol.

METHODS

Dutch protocol consists of four steps: determination of immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT) and pancreatitis-associated protein (PAP), DNA analysis by INNO-LiPA and extended gene analysis (EGA). For the optimization phase we used results of 556,952 newborns screened between April 2011 and June 2014 to calculate effects of 13 alternative protocols on sensitivity, specificity, PPV, ratios of CF to other diagnoses, and costs. One alternative protocol was selected based on calculated sensitivity, PPV and costs and was implemented on 1st July 2016. In this modified protocol DNA analysis is performed in samples with a combination of IRT ≥60 µg/l and PAP ≥3.0 µg/l, IRT ≥100 µg/l and PAP ≥1.2 µg/l or IRT ≥124 µg/l and PAP not relevant. Results of 599,137 newborns screened between 1st July 2016 and 31st December 2019 were similarly evaluated as in the optimization phase.

RESULTS

The modified protocol showed a sensitivity of 95%, PPV of 76%, CF to CF transmembrane conductance regulator-related metabolic syndrome/CF screen positive, inconclusive diagnoses (CRMS/CFSPID) ratio 12/1, CF/CF carrier ratio 4/1. Costs per screened newborn were slightly higher. Eleven children, of whom five with classic CF, would not have been referred with the previous protocol.

CONCLUSIONS

The modified protocol results in acceptable sensitivity (95%) and good PPV of 76% with minimal increase in costs.

[Cystic fibrosis: Epidemiology, clinical manifestations, diagnosis and treatment]

Cystic fibrosis is a genetic and multisystemic disease. The main comorbidity in adulthood is respiratory involvement, with the presence of bronchiectasis, chronic bronchial infection and airflow obstruction. Until a decade ago, treatments were aimed at favoring secretion drainage, reducing respiratory exacerbations, controlling chronic bronchial infection and slowing functional deterioration, but with the advent of cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) modulators, the cystic fibrosis paradigm has changed. This novel treatment goes a step further in the management of this disease, it is able to improve the production of defective CFTR protein and increase its expression on the cell surface, thus achieving a better functioning of ion exchange, fluidizing respiratory secretions and reducing airflow obstruction. In addition, there are currently different lines of research aimed at correcting the genetic defect that causes cystic fibrosis.

Standards for the care of people with cystic fibrosis (CF): A timely and accurate diagnosis

There is considerable activity with respect to diagnosis in the field of cystic fibrosis (CF). This relates primarily to developments in newborn bloodspot screening (NBS), more extensive gene analysis and improved characterisation of CFTR-related disorder (CFTR-RD). This is particularly pertinent with respect to accessibility to variant-specific therapy (VST), a transformational intervention for people with CF with eligible CFTR gene variants. This advance reinforces the need for a timely and accurate diagnosis. In the future, there is potential for trials to assess effectiveness of variant-specific therapy for CFTR-RD. The guidance in this paper reaffirms previous standards, clarifies a number of issues, and integrates emerging evidence. Timely and accurate diagnosis has never been more important for people with CF.

Cystic Fibrosis screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID) to Cystic Fibrosis: Detecting disease with serial assessments

We present the case of a child given a CFSPID designation in early life who was later reclassified as having CF based on a combination of recurrent respiratory symptoms and CFTR functional testing, despite normal sweat chloride levels. Here we demonstrate the importance of monitoring these children, each time reviewing the diagnosis based on updated understanding of individual CFTR mutation phenotypes or clinical findings inconsistent with the designation. This case identifies situations in which the CFSPID designation should be challenged, and gives an approach for this when CF is suspected.

Gradual increase in sweat chloride concentration is associated with a higher risk of CRMS/CFSPID to CF reclassification

OBJECTIVES

Universal implementation of cystic fibrosis (CF) newborn screening (NBS) has led to the diagnostic dilemma of infants with CF screen-positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID), with limited guidance regarding prognosis and standardized care. Rates of reclassification from CFSPID to CF vary and risk factors for reclassification are not well established. We investigated whether clinical characteristics are associated with the risk of reclassification from CFSPID to a CF diagnosis.

METHODS

Children with a positive CF NBS were recruited from two sites in California. Retrospective, longitudinal, and cross-sectional data were collected. A subset of subjects had nasal epithelial cells collected for CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) functional assessment. Multivariate logistic regression was used to assess the risk of reclassification.

RESULTS

A total of 112 children completed the study (CF = 53, CFSPID = 59). Phenotypic characteristics between groups showed differences in pancreatic insufficiency prevalence, immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT) levels, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PSA) colonization. Spirometry measures were not different between groups. Nasal epithelial cells from 10 subjects showed 7%-30% of wild-type (WT)-CFTR (wtCFTR) function in those who reclassified and 27%-67% of wtCFTR function in those who retained the CFSPID designation. Modeling revealed that increasing sweat chloride concentration (sw[Cl^- ]) and PSA colonization were independent risk factors for reclassification to CF.

CONCLUSION

Increasing sw[Cl^- ] and a history of PSA colonization are associated with the risk of reclassification from CFSPID to CF in a population with high IRT and two CFTR variants. A close follow-up to monitor phenotypic changes remains critical in this population. The role of CFTR functional assays in this population requires further exploration.

Cystic Fibrosis Screen Positive, Inconclusive Diagnosis Genotypes in People with Cystic Fibrosis from the U.S. Patient Registry

Rationale: Variants within the cystic fibrosis (CF) transmembrane conductance regulator gene, CFTR, that are of unknown significance or are categorized as non-CF causing may be observed in persons with CF. These variants are frequently detected in children with inconclusive newborn screen results and, in some cases, may be associated with a benign presentation in early childhood that progresses to a CF phenotype later in life. Objectives: To analyze data from individuals enrolled in the U.S. Cystic Fibrosis Foundation Patient Registry who have received a diagnosis of CF and who have variants found in a population of children with a CF screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID). Methods: This retrospective review analyzed registry data from individuals with a diagnosis of CF who also harbor one or more variants of interest because of their frequency within a CFSPID population and/or their interpretation as non-CF causing. Three groups were defined by the number of CF-causing variants identified (CF-Cx2, CF-Cx1, and CF-Cx0), which were reported in addition to the variant(s) of interest. Multivariate quantile regression modeling of the outcome for forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV1) generated a disease severity score for each person determined by six selected variables. Median scores were calculated for the three groups. Results: Patients carrying one CF-causing variant and at least one variant of interest (CF-Cx1) had higher median disease severity scores compared with those carrying CF-Cx2, suggesting a milder phenotype (P < 0.05). However, there was no statistically significant difference in scores between CF-Cx2 and the two other groups combined (CF-Cx1 and CF-Cx0; P = 0.33). Analysis revealed that the CF-Cx1 and CF-Cx0 groups, when compared with the CF-Cx2 group, had later median diagnoses (8 years vs. newborn; P < 0.0001), lower median sweat chloride (48 mmol/L vs. 94.5 mmol/L; P < 0.0001), lower prevalence of pancreatic insufficiency (29% vs. 78%; P < 0.0001), and higher median FEV1% predicted (95% vs. 87%; P = 0.0002). Conclusions: Individuals with CF who have specific variants frequently identified in children with CFSPID have a similar range of disease severity scores compared with those who have two CF-causing variants, but a milder phenotype overall. Variants that should be given careful scrutiny because of their high prevalence are G576A+R668C, T854T, R75Q, F1052V, R1070W, R31C, and L967S.

Psychological and Ethical Challenges of Introducing Whole Genome Sequencing into Routine Newborn Screening: Lessons Learned from Existing Newborn Screening

As a psychologist and an ethicist, we have explored empirically newborn screening consent and communication processes. In this paper we consider the impact on families if newborn screening uses whole genome sequencing. We frame this within the World Health Organization's definition of health and contend that proposals to use whole genome sequencing in newborn screening take into account the ethical, practical and psychological impact of such screening. We argue that the important psychological processes occurring in the neonatal phase necessitate a clear justification that providing risk information at this stage provides a health benefit. We illustrate how research on current newborn screening can inform whole genome sequencing debates, whilst highlighting important gaps. Obtaining explicit, voluntary, and sufficiently informed consent for newborn screening is challenging, however we stress that such consent is ethically and legally appropriate and psychologically and practically important. We conclude by outling how this might be done.

Immunoreactive trypsinogen in healthy newborns and infants with cystic fibrosis

OBJECTIVE

Newborn screening (NBS) for cystic fibrosis (CF) was introduced in Switzerland in 2011 based on an immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT)-DNA-IRT protocol. CF diagnosis was confirmed by sweat test and/or genetics but remained inconclusive for some newborns (cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator related metabolic syndrome (CRMS)/CF screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID)). We aimed to (1) Describe IRT levels in healthy newborns in the first year of life and by gestational age (GA), and (2) Compare IRT at two time points between healthy newborns and newborns with CF and CRMS/CFSPID.

DESIGN

Retrospective study.

SETTING

National NBS database.

PATIENTS

All children with an IRT measurement by heel prick test from 2011 to 2019.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

IRT values were extracted from the National NBS Laboratory, and clinical characteristics of positively screened children from the CF-NBS database. Second IRT assessment in positively screened children was usually performed after 18-24 days. We calculated internal IRT Z-Scores and multiples of the median to compare our results across different laboratory tools.

RESULTS

Among 815 899 children; 232 were diagnosed with CF, of whom 36 had meconium ileus (MI); 27 had CRMS/CFSPID. Among all samples analysed, mean IRT Z-Scores were higher for newborns with GA <33 weeks and ≥43 weeks (all Z-Scores >0.11) compared with term babies (all Z-Scores ≤0.06). Repeated IRT Z-Scores after a median (IQR) of 19 (17-22) days remained high for infants with CF with or without MI but decreased for infants with CRMS/CFSPID.

CONCLUSIONS

Measurement of a second IRT value can help distinguish between children with CRMS/CFSPID and CF, early in life.

Outcomes of children with cystic fibrosis screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis/CFTR related metabolic syndrome

Background

Some infants undergoing newborn screening (NBS) tests have inconclusive sweat chloride test (SCT) results that lead to the designation of Cystic Fibrosis Screen Positive, Inconclusive Diagnosis/CFTR-related metabolic syndrome (CFSPID/CRMS). Some proportion of them transition to a CF diagnosis, but no predictive markers can stratify which are at risk for this transition. We report single-center outcomes of children with CRMS.

Methods

We retrospectively identified all infants born in Alabama from 2008 through 2020 referred to our CF Center with an elevated immunoreactive trypsinogen level (IRT) associated with a cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) mutation (IRT+/DNA+) who had at least one SCT result documented. Infants were classified per established guidelines as Carrier, CRMS, or CF based on the IRT+/DNA+ and SCT results. The electronic health record was reviewed for follow-up visits until the children received a definitive diagnosis (to carrier or CF) according to current diagnostic guidelines for CF, or through the end of the 2020 year.

Results

Of the 1,346 infants with IRT+ and at least 1 CFTR mutation identified (IRT+/DNA+), 63 (4.7%) were designated as CRMS. Of these infants, 12 (19.1%) transitioned to Carrier status (CRMS-Carrier), 40 (63.5%) of them remained CRMS status (CRMS-Persistent) and 11 (17.5%) of them transitioned to a diagnosis of CF (CRMS-CF). Of the 11 children in the CRMS-CF group, 4 (36%) had an initial SCT 30-39 mmol/L, 4 (36%) had an initial SCT 40-49 mmol/L and 3 (27%) had an initial SCT 50-59 mmol/L. These children also had higher initial sweat tests and greater yearly increases in sweat chloride values than others with CRMS. We found that in comparison to children in the CRMS-P group, a greater proportion of children in the CRMS-CF group cultured bacteria like methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, Stenotrophomonas maltophilia, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, had smaller weight-for-height percentiles and remained smaller over time despite slightly greater growth.

Conclusion

Infants with an inconclusive diagnosis of CF should continue to receive annual care and management given their potential risk of transition to CF. Further research is needed to assess whether certain phenotypic patterns, clinical symptoms, diagnostic tests or biomarkers could better stratify these children.

Revisiting a diagnosis of cystic fibrosis - Uncertainties and considerations

There is now increased knowledge and experience of newborn screening around the world. There is also a better understanding of CF gene analysis, informed by international databases. This has resulted in a small number of children and adults having their diagnosis of CF reversed. This article illustrates this issue with three cases. It considers how best to tell children and adults with their families, and the reactions that may be encountered. It also discusses practical issues of removing the diagnosis.

Cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator-related metabolic syndrome/cystic fibrosis screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CRMS/CFSPID)

Newborn bloodspot screening (NBS) for cystic fibrosis (CF) is an effective strategy for the early recognition of infants with a CF diagnosis. Some infants with a positive NBS result for CF have an inconclusive diagnosis and evidence suggests the number of these infants is increasing, as more extensive gene analysis is integrated into screening protocols. There is an internationally agreed, but complex, designation for infants with an unclear diagnosis after a positive screening result: cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR)-related metabolic syndrome/cystic fibrosis screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CRMS/CFSPID). Infants with a CRMS/CFSPID designation have no clinical evidence of disease and do not meet the criteria for a CF diagnosis, but the NBS result indicates some risk of developing CF or a CFTR-related disorder. In this review, we describe the accurate designation of these and reflect on emerging management pathways, with particular attention given to clear and consistent communication.

Educational aims

To clarify the definition of the global harmonised designation: cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator-related metabolic syndrome (CRMS)/cystic fibrosis screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID).To understand what impact a CRMS/CFSPID result has for the patient and their family.

Outcomes of Cystic Fibrosis Screening-Positive Infants With Inconclusive Diagnosis at School Age

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Cystic fibrosis (CF) screen-positive infants with an inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID) are infants in whom sweat testing and genetic analysis does not resolve a CF diagnosis. Lack of knowledge about the health outcome of these children who require clinical follow-up challenges effective consultation. Early predictive biomarkers to delineate the CF risk would allow a more targeted approach to these children.

METHODS

Prospective, longitudinal, multicenter, Canada-wide cohort study of CF positive-screened newborns with 1 to 2 cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator gene variants, of which at least 1 is not known to be CF-causing and/or a sweat chloride between 30 and 59 mmol/L. These were monitored for conversion to a CF diagnosis, pulmonary, and nutritional outcomes.

RESULTS

The mean observation period was 7.7 (95% confidence interval 7.1 to 8.4) years. A CF diagnosis was established for 24 of the 115 children with CFSPID (21%) either because of reinterpretation of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator genotype or because of increase in sweat chloride concentration ≥60 mmol/L. An initial sweat chloride of ≥40 mmol/l predicted conversion to CF on the basis of sweat testing. The 91 remaining children with CFSPID were pancreatic sufficient and showed normal growth until school age. Pulmonary function as well as lung clearance index in a subgroup of children with CFSPID were similar to that of healthy controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Children with CFSPID have good nutritional and pulmonary outcomes at school age, but rates of reclassifying the diagnosis are high. The initial sweat chloride test can be used as a biomarker to predict the risk for CF in CFSPID.

When CFSPID becomes CF

There has been a growing number of infants identified as CRMS/CFSPID in countries applying genetic testing as part of cystic fibrosis (CF) newborn screening. Currently there are neither standardized protocols for follow up beyond infancy, nor established predictors to stratify this population as high or low risk of reclassification to CF or CFTR-related disorder. We report a series of 10 children who reclassified, including eight carrying CFTR variants of varying clinical consequence and seven with initial sweat chloride measurements <30 mmol/L. The overall increase in sweat chloride concentration was 5.8 mmol/L/year. Pseudomonas aeruginosa was isolated from respiratory cultures in five subjects, and reclassification was aided by human nasal epithelial cultures in two cases. In this center's experience, 6% of all CRMS/CFSPID referrals reclassified to CF over a 12-year period. The rate of sweat chloride increase, genotype, and CFTR functional assay can potentially be used as prognostic tools in the CRMS/CFSPID population.

Two Years of Newborn Screening for Cystic Fibrosis in North Macedonia: First Experience

There is a widely accepted consensus on the benefits of newborn screening (NBS) for cystic fibrosis (CF) in terms of reduced disease severity, improved quality of life, lower treatment burden, and reduced costs. More and more countries in the world are introducing NBS for CF as a national preventive health program. Newborn screening for CF was introduced in the Republic of North Macedonia (RNM) in April, 2019, after a pilot study of 6 months in 2018. A two-step immunoreactive trysinogen (IRT-IRT) algorithm is performed, and then a sweat test for confirmation/exclusion of the CF diagnosis when the IRT values were both over the cutoff (70.0 and 45.0 ng/mL, respectively). In cases with confirmed diagnosis of CF (a sweat chloride concentration >60.0 mmol/L) or with intermediate sweat test results (a sweat chloride concentration of between 30.0 and 59.0 mmol/L), CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) mutation analysis is performed. By the end of 2020, over a period of 27 months, including the pilot study period, a total number of 43,139 newborns were screened for CF. Seventeen (0.039%) newborns were diagnosed with CF. In all newly discovered CF cases by screening, the diagnosis was confirmed by determination of the CFTR mutations. The most common CFTR mutation, F508del, was found with an overall incidence of 70.6%. Other more frequent mutations were G542X (11.8%) and N1303K (5.9%). Four mutations were found in one CFTR allele each: G1349D, G126D, 457TAT>G and CFTRdupexon22, with the last one being newly discovered with unknown consequences. An incredibly large difference was found in the incidence of the disease between the Macedonian and Albanian neonatal population, with almost four time higher prevalence among Albanians (1:4530 vs. 1:1284).

Neonatal cystic fibrosis screening: Analysis and differences in immunoreactive trypsin levels in newborns with a positive screen

INTRODUCTION

Neonatal cystic fibrosis (CF) screening has enabled the disease to be diagnosed early, and is a determining factor in the increase in survival of these patients. Its main disadvantage is its low specificity and elevated number of false positives. The aim of this study is to analyse the differences in immunoreactive trypsin (IRT) between the different groups of newborns (NB) with a positive neonatal screen depending on whether they were healthy, healthy carriers, affected by CF, or CFSPID (Cystic Fibrosis Screen Positive, Inconclusive Diagnosis).

MATERIAL

Retrospective analytical study of the concentrations of IRT in NB with a positive neonatal screen for CF born in a tertiary hospital during an 8-year period.

RESULTS

A total of 790 NB with a positive neonatal screen for CF were analysed. Of these 86.3% were term, 53% girls, and 11.8% were admitted. The mean IRT value was 79.16 ng/mL (range 60-367). Significantly higher concentrations of IRT were found in those affected by CF compared to the other groups (P < .001). There were higher levels in large prematures (P = .007) and admitted patients (P = .002). There were no differences as regards gender or season. There was a direct correlation of 64% (P = .001) between IRT and sweat test in those affected by CF and CFSPID. A cut-off value of IRT for the diagnosis of CF was calculated from the ROC curve (76.2 ng/mL (S = 95.7%, Sp = 64.5%).

CONCLUSIONS

NB with CF have significantly higher levels of IRT than healthy ones, or carriers and CFSPID. Prematurity and hospital admission may also have an influence. A higher IRT value is associated with a higher level in the sweat test.

Cystic fibrosis

Cystic fibrosis is a monogenic disease considered to affect at least 100 000 people worldwide. Mutations in CFTR, the gene encoding the epithelial ion channel that normally transports chloride and bicarbonate, lead to impaired mucus hydration and clearance. Classical cystic fibrosis is thus characterised by chronic pulmonary infection and inflammation, pancreatic exocrine insufficiency, male infertility, and might include several comorbidities such as cystic fibrosis-related diabetes or cystic fibrosis liver disease. This autosomal recessive disease is diagnosed in many regions following newborn screening, whereas in other regions, diagnosis is based on a group of recognised multiorgan clinical manifestations, raised sweat chloride concentrations, or CFTR mutations. Disease that is less easily diagnosed, and in some cases affecting only one organ, can be seen in the context of gene variants leading to residual protein function. Management strategies, including augmenting mucociliary clearance and aggressively treating infections, have gradually improved life expectancy for people with cystic fibrosis. However, restoration of CFTR function via new small molecule modulator drugs is transforming the disease for many patients. Clinical trial pipelines are actively exploring many other approaches, which will be increasingly needed as survival improves and as the population of adults with cystic fibrosis increases. Here, we present the current understanding of CFTR mutations, protein function, and disease pathophysiology, consider strengths and limitations of current management strategies, and look to the future of multidisciplinary care for those with cystic fibrosis.

Outcomes of repeat sweat testing in cystic fibrosis newborn screen positive infants

BACKGROUND

Infants with a positive cystic fibrosis (CF) newborn screen, only one identified CFTR mutation (NBS+/1 mut), and an initial intermediate sweat chloride (30-59 mmol/L) should have repeat sweat chloride testing (SCT). However, the outcome of repeat SCT and the relationship between initial sweat Cl and subsequent CF diagnosis have not been reported.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to analyze the outcomes of repeat SCT and subsequent CF diagnosis in NBS+/1 mut infants based on their initial sweat chloride concentration.

METHODS

We retrospectively identified all infants born in Indiana from 2007 to 2017 with NBS+/1 mut and initial SCT in the intermediate range. For each infant, we recorded the initial and repeat SCT results and/or a final CF diagnosis.

RESULTS

From 2007 through 2017 there were 2822 NBS+/1 mut infants of which 2613 (82%) had at least one SCT result. No infants with an initial SCT of 30-39 mmol/L were subsequently diagnosed with CF. Of the 31 infants with an initial SCT of 40-49 mmol/L, only 1 was subsequently diagnosed with CF. In contrast, 61% of those with SCTs of 50-59 mmol/L were later diagnosed with CF.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that infants with a positive NBS for CF and one CFTR mutationwhose initial sweat chloride concentration is 50-59 mmol/L need to be monitored more closely forCF with strong consideration for earlier repeat SCTs and immediate genotyping.

[Newborn screening for cystic fibrosis in France]

Neonatal screening for cystic fibrosis has optimised the prognosis for patients allowing very early multidisciplinary care. Over the past 20 years, screening programmes have undergone major international expansion. The performances of the French neonatal cystic fibrosis screening programme, established in 2002, has met European guideline standards, with positive predictive value of 0.31 (against a minimum of 0.30) and sensitivity value of 0.95 (against a minimum of 0.95). It is also important to highlight the very high percentage of sweat tests performed (95.5%), of mutations identified (96.6%), the 9:1 ratio of cystic fibrosis cases to cases of inconclusive diagnosis achieved and the effectiveness of the strategy implemented for the detection of false negative cases. A new organisation for cystic fibrosis neonatal screening has now been established in France. It is vital that effectiveness is maintained throughout the process, from newborn maternity care to diagnosis in cystic fibrosis care centres, and that further knowledge is gained through exhaustive data collection and validation.

CRMS/CFSPID Subjects Carrying D1152H CFTR Variant: Can the Second Variant Be a Predictor of Disease Development?

Background: There are no predictive factors of evolution of cystic fibrosis (CF) screen positive inconclusive diagnosis subjects (CFSPIDs). Aim: to define the role of the second CFTR variant as a predictive factor of disease evolution in CFSPIDs carrying the D1152H variant. Methods: We retrospectively evaluated clinical characteristics and outcome of CFSPIDs carrying the D1152H variant followed at five Italian CF centers. CFSPIDs were divided in two groups: Group A: compound heterozygous for D1152H and a CF-causing variant; Group B: compound heterozygous for D1152H and a: (i) non CF-causing variant, (ii) variant with varying clinical consequences, or (iii) variant with unknown significance. The variants were classified according to CFTR2 mutation database. Results: We enrolled 43 CFSPIDs with at least one D1152H variant: 28 (65.1%) were classified in the group A, and 15 (34.9%) in the Group B. CFSPIDs of group A had the first IRT significantly higher compared to those of group B (p < 0.05) and had a more severe clinical outcome during the follow-up. At the end of the study period, after a mean follow-up of 40.6 months (range 6–91.6), 4 (9.3%) out of 43 CFSPIDs progressed to CFTR-RD or CF. All these subjects were in the group A. Conclusions: The genetic profile could help predict the risk of disease evolution in CFSPIDs carrying D1152H, revealing the subjects that need a more frequent follow-up.

Constructing a Bioethical Framework to Evaluate and Optimise Newborn Bloodspot Screening for Cystic Fibrosis

Newborn bloodspot screening for cystic fibrosis is a valid public health strategy for populations with a high incidence of this inherited condition. There are a wide variety of approaches to screening and in this paper, we propose that a bioethical framework is required to determine the most appropriate screening protocol for a population. This framework depends on the detailed evaluation of the ethical consequences of all screening outcomes and placing these in the context of the genetic profile of the population screened, the geography of the region and the healthcare resources available.

Processing Newborn Bloodspot Screening Results for CF

Every newborn bloodspot screening (NBS) result for cystic fibrosis (CF) consists of two parts: a screening part in the laboratory and a clinical part in a CF centre. When introducing an NBS programme, more attention is usually paid to the laboratory part, especially which algorithm is most suitable for the region or the country. However, the clinical part, how a positive screening result is processed, is often underestimated and can have great consequences for the affected child and their parents. A clear algorithm for the diagnostic part in CF centres is also important and influences the performance of a CF NBS programme. The processing of a positive screening result includes the initial information given to the parents, the invitation to the sweat test, what to do if a sweat test fails, information about the results of the sweat test, the inconclusive diagnosis and the carrier status, which is handled differently from country to country. The time until the definitive diagnosis and adequate information is given, is considered by the parents and the CF team as the most important factor. The communication of a positive NBS result is crucial. It is not a singular event but rather a process that includes ensuring the appropriate clinicians are aware of the result and that families are informed in the most efficient and effective manner to facilitate consistent and timely follow-up.

Inconclusive Diagnosis after Newborn Screening for Cystic Fibrosis

An unintended consequence of newborn screening for cystic fibrosis (CF) is the identification of infants with a positive screening test but an inconclusive diagnostic testing. These infants are designated as CF transmembrane conductance regulator-related metabolic syndrome (CRMS) in the US and CF screen-positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID) in Europe. Recently, experts agreed on a unified international definition of CRMS/CFSPID which will improve our knowledge on the epidemiology and outcomes of these infants and optimize comparisons between cohorts. Many of these children will remain free of symptoms, but a number may develop clinical features suggestive of CFTR-related disorder (CFTR-RD) or CF later in life. Clinicians should to be prepared to identify these infants and communicate with parents about this challenging and stressful situation for both healthcare professionals and families. In this review, we present the recent publications on infants designated as CRMS/CFSPID, including the definition, the incidence across Europe, the assessment of the CFTR protein function, the outcomes with the rates of conversion to a final diagnosis of CF and their management.

The Role of Extended CFTR Gene Sequencing in Newborn Screening for Cystic Fibrosis

There has been considerable progress in the implementation of newborn screening (NBS) programs for cystic fibrosis (CF), with DNA analysis being part of an increasing number of strategies. Thanks to advances in genomic sequencing technologies, CFTR-extended genetic analysis (EGA) by sequencing its coding regions has become affordable and has already been included as part of a limited number of core NBS programs, to the benefit of admixed populations. Based on results analysis of existing programs, the values and challenges of EGA are reviewed in the perspective of its implementation on a larger scale. Sensitivity would be increased at best by using EGA as a second tier, but this could be at the expense of positive predictive value, which improves, however, if EGA is applied after testing a variant panel. The increased detection of babies with an inconclusive diagnosis has proved to be a major drawback in programs using EGA. The lack of knowledge on pathogenicity and penetrance associated with numerous variants hinders the introduction of EGA as a second tier, but EGA with filtering for all known CF variants with full penetrance could be a solution. The issue of incomplete knowledge is a real challenge in terms of the implemention of NBS extended to many genetic diseases.

Initial Evaluation of Prospective and Parallel Assessments of Cystic Fibrosis Newborn Screening Protocols in Eastern Andalusia: IRT/IRT versus IRT/PAP/IRT

Identifying newborns at risk for cystic fibrosis (CF) by newborn screening (NBS) using dried blood spot (DBS) specimens provides an opportunity for presymptomatic detection. All NBS strategies for CF begin with measuring immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT). Pancreatitis-associated protein (PAP) has been suggested as second-tier testing. The main objective of this study was to evaluate the analytical performance of an IRT/PAP/IRT strategy versus the current IRT/IRT strategy over a two-year pilot study including 68,502 newborns. The design of the study, carried out in a prospective and parallel manner, allowed us to compare four different CF-NBS protocols after performing a post hoc analysis. The best PAP cutoff point and the potential sources of PAP false positive results in our non-CF newborn population were also studied. 14 CF newborns were detected, resulting in an overall CF prevalence of 1/4, 893 newborns. The IRT/IRT algorithm detected all CF cases, but the IRT/PAP/IRT algorithm failed to detect one case of CF. The IRT/PAP/IRT with an IRT-dependent safety net protocol was a good alternative to improve sensitivity to 100%. The IRT × PAP/IRT strategy clearly performed better, with a sensitivity of 100% and a positive predictive value (PPV) of 39%. Our calculated optimal cutoffs were 2.31 µg/L for PAP and 167.4 µg2/L2 for IRT × PAP. PAP levels were higher in females and newborns with low birth weight. PAP false positive results were found mainly in newborns with conditions such as prematurity, sepsis, and hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy.

Psychological Impact on Parents of an Inconclusive Diagnosis Following Newborn Bloodspot Screening for Cystic Fibrosis: A Qualitative Study

Genetic results of uncertain clinical significance are being returned to parents following newborn screening, representing a paradigm change in how society considers health and illness. 'Cystic Fibrosis screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis' (CFSPID) is a designation given to newborns with a positive screening result for, but not a definitive diagnosis of, cystic fibrosis. We explored the psychological impact of receiving a CFSPID result on parents. Five semi-structured interviews were conducted with eight parents whose children have CFSPID. Interpretative phenomenological analysis identified these themes: "The way we were told": 'diagnosis as a traumatic event' focused on how parents were distressed and dissatisfied by the initial screening result communication, 'Facing and challenging traditional ideas about health and illness' explored the emerging problem of how CFSPID does not fit the commonly accepted medical model, and 'Making certainty out of uncertainty' explored the varying strategies parents developed to adapt to the uncertainty regarding their child's prognosis. Findings suggest that CFSPID results caused parents' distress, initiated with the first communication of the result and persisting thereafter. Our data suggests approaches to the delivery of CFSPID results that may reduce the impact. Work is needed to close the gap between healthcare advances and societies commonly held medical model.