Foaming properties of mixtures of a non-ionic (C12DMPO) and an ionic surfactant (C12TAB)

Comparative Study on Interfacial Properties, Foam Stability, and Firefighting Performance of C6 Fluorocarbon Surfactants with Different Hydrophilic Groups

Liquid fuel is flammable and hazardous, and a pool fire is one of the most serious disasters. Therefore, it is important to develop high-performance firefighting agents. To synthesize aqueous film-forming foam (AFFF) formulations, two C6 short-chain fluorocarbon surfactants Capstone 1157 (FC1157) and sodium perfluorohexylethyl sulfonate (SF852) with different hydrophilic groups were introduced, and three hydrocarbon surfactants sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), decyl glucoside (APG0810), and coco glucoside (APG0814) were chosen. The AFFF formulations based on the short-chain fluorocarbon-hydrocarbon compounding system were developed, and the firefighting performance of the formulations was assessed according to the standard pool fire extinction test. The results indicated that amphoteric FC1157 was slightly more effective than anionic SF852 in extinguishing small-scale pool fires and could reduce heat flux more effectively than SF852. Fluorocarbon surfactant FC1157 has been shown to suppress large pool fires much better than SF852, possibly due to its higher foam stability, higher foaming property, lower dynamic surface tension, and lower bubble coarsening rate. Both formulations we studied were more effective than commercial AFFF formulations. A concentration of 0.1-0.3% of FC1157 in an AFFF solution was optimal for extinguishing high-boiling-point oil fires.

On the mechanism of enhanced foam stability by combining carboxylated cellulose nanofiber with hydrocarbon and fluorocarbon surfactants

The effect of carboxylated cellulose nanofiber (CCNF) on the firefighting foam stability and stabilization mechanism is investigated. The results show that equilibrium surface tension of CTAB/FC1157 solution decreases when CCNF concentration increases to 0.5 wt%, while CCNF has little effect on that of SDS/FC1157 solution. Besides, when CCNF concentration of SDS/FC1157 solution increases to 1.0 wt%, the foam initial drainage is delayed for about 3 min. Increasing CCNF concentration can slow down foam coarsening process and liquid drainage process of SDS/FC1157 and CTAB/FC1157 solutions, improving the foam stability. The foam stability enhancement of CTAB/FC1157 solution is due to the formation of bulk aggregates and the increase of viscosity. However, the foam stability enhancement of SDS/FC1157 solution may be caused by the increase of viscosity. CCNF significantly reduces the foaming ability of CTAB/FC1157 solution when CCNF concentration is >0.5 wt%. Nevertheless, the foaming ability of SDS/FC1157 solution decreases significantly when CCNF concentration reaches 3.0 wt%, and its foaming ability remains higher than CTAB/FC1157 solution. The foaming ability of SDS/FC1157 solution is mainly dominated by viscosity, while that of CTAB/FC1157 solution is dominated by viscosity and adsorption kinetics. Adding CCNF is expected to enhance the stability of firefighting foam and increase the efficiency of extinguishing fire.

Foam-Based Electrophoretic Separation of Charged Dyes

Electrophoretic separation of a fluorescent dye mixture, containing rhodamine B (RB) and fluorescein, in liquid foams stabilized by anionic, cationic, or non-ionic surfactants in water-glycerol mixtures was studied in a custom-designed foam separation device. The effects of the external electric field applied across the foam and the initial pH of the solution on the effectiveness of separation were also studied. The fluid motion due to electroosmosis and the resulting back pressure within the foam and local pH changes were found to be complex and affected the separation. Fluorescein dye molecules, which have a positive or negative charge depending on the solution pH, aggregated in the vicinity of an electrode, leaving a pure band of neutral dye RB. The effectiveness of the separation was quantified by the percentage width of the pure RB band, which was found to be between 29 and 42%. This study demonstrates the potential of liquid foam as a platform for electrophoretic separation.

Prediction of surface tension of solution in the presence of hydrophilic silica nanoparticle and anionic surfactant by ATR-FTIR spectroscopy and chemometric methods

In the current research, an analytical method was proposed for the quantitative determination of surface tension of anionic surfactant solutions in the presence of hydrophilic silica nanoparticles using attenuated total reflection Fourier-transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy and chemometric methods. The surface tension behavior of anionic surfactant solutions considerably changes by the addition of silica nanoparticles with different particle size. The spectral data of solutions were used for prediction of surface tension using two calibration methods based on support vector machine regression (SVM-R) as a non-linear algorithm and partial least squares regression (PLS-R) as a linear algorithm. For preprocessing of data, baseline correction and standard normal variate (SNV) were also applied. Root mean square error of prediction (RMSEP) in SVM-R and PLS-R methods were 4.203 and 4.507, respectively. Considering the complexity of the samples, the SVM-R model was found to be reliable. The proposed method is fast and easy for measurement of the surface tension of surfactant solutions without any sample preparation step in chemical enhanced oil recovery (C-EOR).

A Review on Bubble Stability in Fresh Concrete: Mechanisms and Main Factors

In order to improve the stability of air bubbles in fresh concrete, it is of great significance to have a better understanding of the mechanisms and main influencing factors of bubble stability. In the present review, the formation and collapse process of air bubbles in fresh concrete are essentially detailed; and the advances of major influencing factors of bubble stability are summarized. The results show that the surface tension of air-liquid interface exerts a huge impact on bubble stability by reducing surface free energy and Plateau drainage, as well as increasing the Gibbs surface elasticity. However, surface tension may not be the only determinant of bubble stability. Both the strength of bubble film and the diffusion rate of air through the membrane may also dominate bubble stability. The application of nano-silica is a current trend and plays a key role in ameliorating bubble stability. The foam stability could be increased by 6 times when the mass fraction of nano-particle reached 1.5%.

Foamability of aqueous solutions: Role of surfactant type and concentration

In this paper we study the main surface characteristics which control the foamability of solutions of various surfactants. Systematic series of experiments with anionic, cationic and nonionic surfactants with different head groups and chain lengths are performed in a wide concentration range, from 0.001 mM to 100 mM. The electrolyte (NaCl) concentration is also varied from 0 up to 100 mM. For all surfactants studied, three regions in the dependence of the foamability, V_A, on the logarithm of surfactant concentration, lgC_S, are observed. In Region 1, V_A is very low and depends weakly on C_S. In Region 2, V_A increases steeply with C_S. In Region 3, V_A reaches a plateau. To analyse these results, the dynamic and equilibrium surface tensions of the foamed solutions are measured. A key new element in our interpretation of the foaming data is that we use the surface tension measurements to determine the dependence of the main surface properties (surfactant adsorption, surface coverage and surface elasticity) on the surface age of the bubbles. In this way we interpret the results from the foaming tests by considering the properties of the dynamic adsorption layers, formed during foaming. The performed analysis reveals a large qualitative difference between the nonionic and ionic surfactants with respect to their foaming profiles. The data for the nonionic and ionic surfactants merge around two master curves when plotted as a function of the surface coverage, the surface mobility factor, or the Gibbs elasticity of the dynamic adsorption layers. This difference between the ionic and nonionic surfactants is explained with the important contribution of the electrostatic repulsion between the foam film surfaces for the ionic surfactants which stabilizes the dynamic foam films even at moderate surface coverage and at relatively high ionic strength (up to 100 mM). In contrast, the films formed from solutions of nonionic surfactants are stabilized via steric repulsion which becomes sufficiently high to prevent bubble coalescence only at rather high surface coverage (> 90%) which corresponds to related high Gibbs elasticity (> 150 mN/m) and low surface mobility of the dynamic adsorption layers. Mechanistic explanations of all observed trends are provided and some important similarities and differences with the process of emulsification are outlined.

How Promoting and Breaking Intersurfactant H-Bonds Impact Foam Stability

On the basis of previous results revealing that intersurfactant H-bonds improve foam stability, we now focus on how foams stabilized by two different N-acyl amino acid surfactants are affected by different salts (NaF, NaCl, NaSCN), which can promote or break intersurfactant H-bonds. The chosen surfactants, namely, sodium N-lauroyl sarcosinate (C₁₂SarcNa) and sodium N-lauroyl glycinate (C₁₂GlyNa), differ only by one methyl group at the nitrogen of the amide bond that blocks intersurfactant H-bonds in the case of C₁₂SarcNa. The salts were chosen because they are kosmotropic (NaF), chaotropic (NaSCN), and in between (NaCl) and thus influence the formation of an H-bond network in different ways. Surface tension measurements showed that the addition of salts decreased the cmcs of both surfactants and increased the packing density, as expected. Moreover, in presence of the salts, the head groups of the H-bond forming surfactant C₁₂GlyNa were more tightly packed at the surface than the C₁₂SarcNa head groups. The effect of the salts on foam stability was studied by analysis of the foam height, the foam liquid fraction, and by image analysis of the foam structure. As expected, the salts had no significant effect on foams stabilized by C₁₂SarcNa, which is unable to form intersurfactant H-bonds. In contrast, the stability of C₁₂GlyNa-containing foams followed the trend NaF > NaCl > NaSCN, which is in agreement with NaF promoting and NaSCN breaking intersurfactant H-bonds. Surface rheology measurements allowed us to correlate foam stability with surface elasticity. This study provides new insights into the importance of H-bond promoters and breakers, which should be used in the future design of tailor-made surfactants.

Effect of Alkyl Tail Length of Alpha Olefin Sulfonates on Foam Properties

The effect of alkyl tail length on the foam properties of alpha olefin sulfonates (AOS) in aqueous solutions at various concentrations was investigated by measurements of the foamability, foam stability and bubble size and numbers, obtained from conductivity and image analyses techniques based on FoamScan foam analyzer. It was found that foamability and foam stability of Cn AOS (n = 14–16, 16–18, 20–24) first increase and then decrease with increase in the carbon chain length, showing an optimum for a length of n = 16–18. The foamability and foam stability of AOS increase with increasing of surfactant concentration. This is due to the fact that the adsorbed quantity of surfactant molecules increases at the air/water interface with the increase of concentration. In addition, it was found that the bubble size produced by C16–18 AOS is smaller than that of C14–16 AOS.

Determining the surface dilational rheology of surfactant and protein films with a droplet waveform generator

Understanding rheological properties of surfactant and protein films plays a crucial role in a variety of industrial and research areas, such as food processing, cosmetics, and pharmacology. To determine the surface dilational modulus using drop shape analysis, one needs to measure the dynamic surface tension in response to a sinusoidal oscillation of the surface area of the droplet. Despite many applications of drop shape analysis in studying interfacial rheology, oscillation of the droplet surface area is usually controlled in an indirect manner. Existing methods are only capable of controlling volume oscillations of the droplet rather than its surface area. We have developed an arbitrary waveform generator (AWG) to directly oscillate the surface area of a millimeter-sized droplet in a predefined sinusoidal waveform. Here, we demonstrated the capacity of this AWG, in conjunction with constrained drop surfactometry (CDS), in studying the surface dilational rheology of adsorbed surfactant and protein films. It is found that the surface dilational modulus determined for a dilute surfactant (C₁₂DMPO) and two protein solutions (bovine serum albumin and β-casein) revealed their adsorption mechanisms. Our methods hold promise in studying the interfacial rheology of various thin-film materials, biomembranes, foams, and emulsions.

Droplet Oscillation as an Arbitrary Waveform Generator

Oscillating droplets and bubbles have been developed into a novel experimental platform for a wide range of analytical and biological applications, such as digital microfluidics, thin film, biophysical simulation, and interfacial rheology. A central effort of developing any droplet-based experimental platform is to increase the effectiveness and accuracy of droplet oscillations. Here, we developed a novel system of droplet-based arbitrary waveform generator (AWG) for feedback-controlling single-droplet oscillations. This AWG was developed through closed-loop axisymmetric drop shape analysis and based on the hardware of constrained drop surfactometry. We have demonstrated the capacity of this AWG in oscillating the volume and surface area of a millimeter-sized droplet to follow four representative waveforms, sine, triangle, square, and sawtooth. The capacity of oscillating the surface area of a droplet across the frequency spectrum makes the AWG an ideal tool for studying interfacial rheology. The AWG was used to determine the surface dilational modulus of a commonly studied nonionic surfactant, dodecyldimethylphosphine oxide. The droplet-based AWG developed in this study is expected to achieve accuracy, versatility, and applicability in a wide range of research areas, such as thin film and interfacial rheology.

On the Influence of Intersurfactant H-Bonds on Foam Stability: A Study with Technical Grade Surfactants

From the literature on the foam stability of various surfactants with C12 alkyl chains but different head groups a clear picture emerges: Foams are more stable when hydrogen bonds can form between the head groups, i. e. when the polar head group has a hydrogen bond donor and a proton acceptor. These observations suggest that hydrogen bonds between neighbouring molecules at the surface enhance foam stability. To support this hypothesis, we carried out a systematic foaming study of two types of technical grade surfactants, one of them being capable of forming H-bonds and the other one not. As was the case for the pure surfactants we found again that more stable foams are formed when the head group is capable of forming intersurfactant H-bonds: These results will certainly affect the future design of surfactants.

Synthesis of phosphine oxide based amphiphilic molecules via ring-opening Wittig olefination of a macrocyclic phosphoranylidene and their property study as non-ionic surfactants

A novel ring-opening Wittig olefination approach was developed for the synthesis of amphiphilic phosphine oxides (PO) as non-ionic surfactants. The approach concurrently introduces the crucial functional groups (lipophilic chain and phosphine oxide moiety) present in the known PO surfactants and additional hydrophilic group (i.e., ethylene glycol units) in one step via Wittig olefination of a macrocyclic phosphoranylidene. A series of novel PO compounds were obtained from a variety of aldehydes and selected compounds were examined for their physiochemical properties (surface tension, critical micelle concentration and interfacial tension) and also for their abilities to form emulsions as non-ionic surfactants.

A novel ring-opening Wittig olefination approach was developed for the synthesis of amphiphilic phosphine oxides (PO) as non-ionic surfactants.

Interfacial tension of reactive, liquid interfaces and its consequences

Dispersions of immiscible liquids, such as emulsions and polymer blends, are at the core of many industrial applications which makes the understanding of their properties (morphology, stability, etc.) of great interest. A wide range of these properties depend on interfacial phenomena, whose understanding is therefore of particular importance. The behaviour of interfacial tension in emulsions and polymer blends is well-understood - both theoretically and experimentally - in the case of non-reactive stabilization processes using pre-made surfactants. However, this description of the interfacial tension behaviour in reactive systems, where the stabilizing agents are created in-situ (and which is more efficient as a stabilization route for many systems), does not yet find a consensus among the community. In this review, we compare the different theories which have been developed for non-reactive and for reactive systems, and we discuss their ability to capture the behaviour found experimentally. Finally, we address the consequences of the reactive stabilization process both on the global emulsions or polymer blend morphologies and at the interfacial scale.

On how hydrogen bonds affect foam stability

Do intermolecular H-bonds between surfactant head groups play a role for foam stability? From the literature on the foam stability of various surfactants with C12 alkyl chains but different head groups a clear picture emerges: stable foams are only generated when hydrogen bonds can form between the head groups, i.e. when the polar head group has a hydrogen bond donor and a proton acceptor. Stable foams can therefore be generated with surfactants having a sugar unit, a glycine, an amine oxide (at pH~5), or a carboxylic acid (at pH~pK_a) as polar head group. On the other hand, aqueous foams stabilized with surfactants having oligo(ethylene oxide), phosphine oxide, quaternary ammonium, sulfate, sarcosine, amine oxide (at pH≠5), or carboxylic acid (at pH≠pK_a) are not very stable. These observations suggest that hydrogen bonds between neighbouring molecules at the surface enhance foam stability. Formation of hydrogen bonds between surfactant head groups gives rise to a short-range attractive interaction that may restrict the surfactant's mobility while providing a more elastic surfactant layer which can counteract deformations. To support our hypothesis we carried out a systematic foaming study of two types of surfactants, one of them being capable of forming H-bonds and the other one not. Generating foams of all surfactants mentioned above with the same foaming conditions we found that stable foams are obtained when the head group is capable of forming intersurfactant H-bonds. The outcome of this study constitutes a new step towards the implementation of H-bonds in the future design of surfactants.

Phosphine oxide surfactants revisited

This review summarizes everything we currently know about the nonionic surfactants alkyl dimethyl (C(n)DMPO) and alkyl diethyl (C(n)DEPO) phosphine oxide (PO surfactants). The review starts with the synthesis and the general properties (Section 2) of these compounds and continues with their interfacial properties (Section 3) such as surface tension, surface rheology, interfacial tension and adsorption at solid surfaces. We discuss studies on thin liquid films and foams stabilized by PO surfactants (Section 4) as well as studies on their self-assembly into lyotropic liquid crystals and microemulsions, respectively (Section 5). We aim at encouraging colleagues from both academia and industry to take on board PO surfactants whenever possible and feasible because of their broad variety of excellent properties.

Plant-derived surfactants as an alternative to synthetic surfactants: surface and antioxidant activities

Biosurfactants have great advantages as an eco-friendly alternative to synthetic surfactants. Surface active properties and antioxidant activity of extracts prepared from

Effects of protonation on foaming properties of dodecyldimethylamine oxide solutions: a pH-study

The critical micelle concentration (cmc), the surface excess (Γ), as well as the micelle aggregation number (m) of the surfactant dodecyldimethylamine oxide (C12DMAO) have been reported to strongly depend on the pH-value of the aqueous surfactant solution. At high ionic strength, the cmc displays a minimum, while both Γ and m have a maximum at a pH-value close to the pKa of the surfactant. These experimental observations have been explained as being due to specific hydrogen bonds between the head groups, which are formed once the surfactant is partly or fully protonated. This investigation addresses the question of whether the pH also affects the foaming properties of C12DMAO solutions. To answer this question we measured the foamability and the foam stability of C12DMAO solutions at a fixed C12DMAO concentration of 5 cmc for five different pH-values, namely pH = 2, 3, 5, 8, and 10. We found that the foamability is hardly affected by the pH-value, while the foam stability strongly depends on the pH. As is the case for the above mentioned properties, the foam stability also displays an extremum in the studied pH-range, namely a maximum at pH = 5. We discuss our results in terms of the hydrogen bond hypothesis and show that this hypothesis indeed is in line with the observed trend for the foam stability. Moreover, we discuss that hydrogen bond formation may rationalize how the molecular structure of a surfactant affects foam stability.

Enhancement of foamability and foam stability induced by interactions between a hyperbranched exopolysaccharide and a zwitterionic surfactant dodecyl sulfobetaine

Weak hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interactions between a zwitterionic surfactant dodecyl sulfobetaine (DSB) and a hyperbranched exopolysaccharide (EPS) enhanced considerably the stability and foamability of EPS/DSB foam.

Enhanced foamability of sodium dodecyl sulfate surfactant mixed with superspreader trisiloxane-(poly)ethoxylate

Gravitational drainage from thin vertical surfactant solution films and gravitational drainage in a settler column are used to study the behavior of foams based on two-surfactant mixtures. Namely, solutions of the anionic sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and nonionic superspreader SILWET L-77, and their mixtures at different mixing ratios, are studied. It is shown, for the first time, that solutions having a longer lifetime in the vertical film drainage process also possess a higher foamability. An additional and unexpected unique result is that when using a mixed surfactant system, the foamability can be much greater than the foamabilities of the individual components.