Effects of temperature on the emission of particulate matter, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and polybrominated diphenyl ethers from the thermal treatment of printed wiring boards

Quantifying the removal of polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) in physical, chemical, and biological sludge treatment systems

Polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDE) are priority contaminants historically used as flame retardants. PBDEs are known to occur in wastewater biosolids posing potential concerns with the beneficial land application of the biosolids. This study evaluated the removal of 21 congeners in nine full-scale sludge treatment systems including pelletization (P), alkaline stabilization (AS), and aerobic (AE) and anaerobic (AN) digestion. It is the first study to conduct a mass balance analysis of a broad spectrum of PBDEs during physical, chemical, and biological sludge treatment. The PBDE congener pattern in raw sludge and biosolids samples was consistent with commercial formulations. The fully brominated congener BDE-209 dominated biosolids from all sites with an average concentration of 620 ng/g dry weight (dw), followed by BDE-99 (173 ng/g dw) and BDE-47 (162 ng/g dw). Mass balance analysis on the P and AS processes showed no change in PBDE mass flows with treatment. However, aerobic and anaerobic digestion processes reported significant levels of removal and formation of individual congeners, though the results were not consistent between facilities. One aerobic digestion process (AE2) reported an overall average removal of 48%, whereas the other (AE1) reported very high levels of accumulation of tri- and tetraBDE congeners. Similarly, there were significant variations in PBDE behavior across the five anaerobic digestion plants studied. The plant with the longest solids retention time (SRT) (AN1) reported a moderate removal (50%) of overall PBDE loading and lower congeners, whereas other plants (AN2-AN5) showed significant low (-19%) to high (-166%) levels of formation of lower congeners. The results suggest that reduced SRTs result in formation of lower congeners while extended SRTs can lead to moderate removal of some PBDEs. Conventional sludge treatment result in low to moderate PBDE removal and advanced thermal conversion technologies may be needed to improve the contaminant removal during sludge treatment.

Emission characteristics of (halogenated) polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons during printed circuit board combustion and estimated emission intensity of a typical e-waste dismantling site in South China

The pollution of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and halogenated PAHs (Cl/Br-PAHs) caused by electronic waste dismantling activities have attracted considerable attention. The present study investigated the emissions and formation of PAHs and Cl/Br-PAHs based on the combustion of printed circuit boards simulating electronic waste dismantling process. The emission factor of ΣPAHs was 648 ± 56 ng/g, which was much lower than that of ΣCl/Br-PAHs (8.80 × 104 ± 9.14 × 103 ng/g). From 25 to 600 °C, the emission rate of ΣPAHs reached a sub-peak of 7.39 ± 1.85 ng/(g•min) at 350 °C, then increased gradually with the fastest rate of 19.9 ± 21.8 ng/(g•min) at 600 °C, whereas that of ΣCl/Br-PAHs was the fastest at 350 °C with a rate of 597 ± 106 ng/(g•min), then decreased gradually. The present study suggested that the formation pathways of PAHs and Cl/Br-PAHs are by de novo synthesis. Low molecular weight PAHs were readily partitioned into gas and particle phases, whereas high molecular weight fused PAHs were only detected in oil phase. However, the proportion of Cl/Br-PAHs in particle and oil phases were different from that of gas phase, whereas similar to that of the total emission. In addition, PAH and Cl/Br-PAH emission factors were used to estimate the emission intensity of pyrometallurgy project in Guiyu Circular Economy Industrial Park, and it was shown that approximately 1.30 kg PAHs and 176 kg Cl/Br-PAHs would be emitted annually. This study revealed that Cl/Br-PAHs would be formed by de novo synthesis, and for the first time provided the emission factors of Cl/Br-PAHs during the heat treatment process of printed circuit board, as well as estimated the contribution of pyrometallurgy, a new electronic waste recovery technology, to environmental Cl/Br-PAH pollution, which provides potential scientific information for governmental decision-making on the control of Cl/Br-PAHs.

Mixed bromine/chlorine transformation products of tetrabromobisphenol A formed in the combustion of printed circuit boards: Emission characteristics and transformation pathways

Recently, mixed bromine/chlorine transformation products of tetrabromobisphenol A (Cl_yBr_xBPAs) were found to be possibly related to the thermal treatment processes of electronic wastes. To explore their emission characteristics and formation mechanism, printed circuit board scraps were combusted in a tube furnace, under the temperature from 25 °C to 600 °C. The emission factor of the debromination products of tetrabromobisphenol A (Br_xBPAs) was the highest, whereas that of Cl_yBr_xBPAs was the lowest. Among three phases, most of the target compounds were partitioned into the oil and particle phases, and only negligible gaseous 2-BrBPA and bisphenol A were detected. The emission rates of most compounds were fastest at 300 °C, although 2-BrBPA, 2,6-Br₂BPA, and 2-Cl-6-BrBPA peaked at 350 °C. Among the chemicals in total emission, 2-BrBPA was the dominant congener in Br_xBPAs, whereas 2-Cl-2',6,6'-Br₃BPA, 2-Cl-2',6^#-Br₂BPA, and Σ₂Cl₁Br₁BPAs shared similar proportions in Cl_yBr_xBPAs. Meanwhile, the composition profiles at 300 °C showed that 2,2',6-Br₃BPA and 2-Cl-2',6,6'-Br₃BPA occupied the largest proportions in Br_xBPAs and Cl_yBr_xBPAs, respectively. To reveal the possible transformation pathways, the Gibbs free energy was calculated based on a radical substitution reaction. After "•Br" removal from tetrabromobisphenol A or other Br_xBPAs, the intermediate was more easily combined with "•H" than with "•Cl." In addition, the Cl_yBr_xBPA formation via "-•H + •Cl" by Br_xBPAs is nonspontaneous, thus limiting the further generation of Cl_yBr_xBPAs. This study not only provides ideas for the study of other mixed halogenated products, but also provides constructive suggestions for environmental source analysis by combining previous research on the occurrence of Cl_yBr_xBPAs in various environmental matrices.

Effects of Polybrominated Diphenyl Ethers on Hormonal and Reproductive Health in E-Waste-Exposed Population: A Systematic Review

Electronic waste management is a global rising concern that is primarily being handled by informal recycling practices. These release a mix of potentially hazardous chemicals, which is an important public health concern. These chemicals include polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs), used as flame retardants in electronic parts, which are persistent in nature and show bioaccumulative characteristics. Although PBDEs are suspected endocrine disruptors, particularly targeting thyroid and reproductive hormone functions, the relationship of PBDEs with these health effects are not well established. We used the Navigation Guide methodology to conduct a systematic review of studies in populations exposed to e-waste to better understand the relationships of these persistent flame retardants with hormonal and reproductive health. We assessed nineteen studies that fit our pre-determined inclusion criteria for risk of bias, indirectness, inconsistency, imprecision, and other criteria that helped rate the overall evidence for its quality and strength of evidence. The studies suggest PBDEs may have an adverse effect on thyroid hormones, reproductive hormones, semen quality, and neonatal health. However, more research is required to establish a relationship of these effects in the e-waste-exposed population. We identified the limitations of the data available and made recommendations for future scientific work.

Occurrence and fate of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons from electronic waste dismantling activities: A critical review from environmental pollution to human health

Electronic waste (e-waste) is one of the fastest-growing solid wastes and has become an urgent issue due to the potential adverse consequences of exposure to emitted toxic pollutants, especially for these occupational exposed workers and local residents. In this review, the environmental occurrences, emission characteristics, sources, and possible adverse effects of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) emitted from primitive e-waste dismantling activities are summarized. In general, the atmospheric levels of PAHs at typical e-waste sites, e.g., in Guiyu, China, have substantially decreased by more than an order of magnitude compared with levels a decade ago. The PAH concentrations in soil from old e-waste sites in China are also generally lower than those at newly emerged e-waste sites in India, Pakistan and Ghana. However, elevated concentrations of PAHs have been reported in human milk, hair and urine from the populations near these e-waste sites. Source apportionment both from bench-scale studies to field observations has demonstrated that the pyrolysis and combustion processing of electronic circuit board are mainly responsible for the emissions of various PAHs. In addition, some specific PAHs and their derivatives, such as triphenylbenzene, halogenated and oxygenated PAHs, have frequently been identified and could be considered as indicators in routine analysis in addition to the 16 U.S. EPA priority PAHs currently used.

Thermal treatment of decabrominated diphenyl ether in its highly contaminated soil in Taiwan

Polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) were commonly used flame retardants in the world, while some of PBDEs have been listed as persistent organic pollutants (POPs). Decabrominated diphenyl ether (BDE-209) was the most commercially used PBDEs. A farm near the factory located in Northern Taiwan was highly contaminated with BDE-209. Since PBDEs in the contaminated soils can be uptake by crops shown in our previous studies and could be potentially consumed by humans, it is very important to establish a feasible treatment method for PBDE remediation in this contaminated farm. Thermal treatment of PBDEs in soil was studied. The initial concentration of BDE-209 in contaminated soil was 1.472 mg/kg. A series of thermal experiments under different operating conditions including various temperature (105, 150, 200, 250, 300, 350, 400 and 450 °C), holding time (10, 20 and 30 min), heating rate (5, 10, 20 and 40 °C/min), and soil amount (10, 100, 1000 and 2000 g) were investigated. The optimal heating conditions for thermal treatment of contaminated soil were heating at 450 °C for 30 min with a heating rate of 10 °C/min. Under this condition, the removal of BDE-209 in the different weights of contaminated soil was tested. The soils in the contaminated farm were tested to further evaluate the feasibility of remediating the on-site PBDE contaminated soil through thermal treatment, suggesting that the holding time was extended to 2 h for the field-scale contaminated soil. The results showed that BDE-209 had been removed to below the detection limit in on-site soil. This investigation is the first study using thermal treatment to remediate soils really contaminated with PBDEs.

Polybrominated diphenyl ethers in indoor air from two typical E-waste recycling workshops in Southern China: Emission, size-distribution, gas-particle partitioning, and exposure assessment

The emission characteristics of respirable particulate matter (PM₁₀), and polybrominated diphenyl ether (PBDE) size distribution, gas-particle partitioning and occupational exposure in two e-waste recycling workshops (manual and thermal dismantling workshop: ManuDW and TherDW) were investigated. The PM₁₀ mass concentration was higher but the number concentration was lower in the ManuDW than in the TherDW. The gaseous phase PBDE concentration (40.5 ng/m³) was higher in the ManuDW than in the TherDW (10.6 ng/m³) while the particulate phase PBDE concentration was just reverse (57.7 vs 156 ng/m³). The size distribution of particle was similar for two workshops but the size distribution of particle-bound PBDE exhibited remarkable differences. BDE-209 was the dominant congener in particle-bound PBDE in the TherDW, while Tri-, Tetra-, and Deca-BDE were the three most abundant homologues in the ManuDW. The size distribution of particle-bound PBDE homologue profile in the ManuDW was also distinct from that in the TherDW. The PBDE exposure doses were 13.9 and 15.3 ng/kg/day in the ManuDW and the TherDW, far lower than reference doses. Gaseous and particle phase have same contribution to the total doses in the ManuDW but the exposure doses in the TherDW mainly come from the particle phase.

Microplastics generated under simulated fire scenarios: Characteristics, antimony leaching, and toxicity

Intentional or incidental thermal changes inevitably occur during the lifecycle of plastics. High temperatures accelerate the aging of plastics and promote their fragmentation to microplastics (MPs). However, there is little information available on the release of MPs after fires. In this study, an atomic force microscope combined with nanoscale infrared analysis was used to demonstrate the physicochemical properties of polypropylene (PP) plastics under simulated fire scenarios. Results showed that the chemical composition and relative stiffness of heat-treated plastic surfaces changed, significantly enhancing the generation of MPs under external forces; over (2.1 ± 0.2) × 10⁵ items/kg abundance of MPs released from PP which were burned at 250 °C in air and trampled by a person. The leaching of antimony (Sb) from MPs in different solutions first increased and then decreased with increasing temperature, reaching a maximum at 250 °C. Higher concentrations of humic acid (10 vs 1 mg/L) caused a greater release of Sb. Furthermore, the tap water leachates of PP burned at 250 °C had the greatest effect on the growth and photosynthetic activity of Microcystis aeruginosa. Our results suggest fires as a potential source of MPs and calls for increased focus on burning plastics in future research.