Sinks in patient rooms in ICUs are associated with higher rates of hospital-acquired infection: a retrospective analysis of 552 ICUs

Sustainability and novel technologies to improve environmental cleaning in healthcare - Implications and considerations

Along with emerging technologies electrolysed water (EW) systems have been proposed for cleaning and/or disinfection in clinical areas. There is evidence for the use of EW in food-handling and the dairy industry however there is lack of evidence for EW as an effective cleaning and disinfecting agent in a clinical setting. Existing publications mostly are either laboratory based or from non-clinical settings. This is in direct contrast to other approaches used in healthcare cleaning. The aim of this paper is to provide infection prevention and control professionals with a risk assessment checklist using an evaluation of electrolysed water as an example of the analysis and consideration required prior to the introduction of any new technology and, in particular, the inclusion of sustainability.

Polymicrobial outbreak of carbapenemase producing Enterobacterales managed using universal admission and discharge screening and water-safe built environment

BACKGROUND

Carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales (CPE) are antimicrobial resistant (AMR) bacteria which are increasing in incidence globally. Hospitals act as powerhouses for transmission of such bacteria with some regions experiencing prolonged outbreaks and high prevalence for several years. Current screening strategies are based on admission and risk-based screening only. Growing evidence supports hospital wastewater as playing a key role in transmission. We describe how changes to the CPE screening policy at Wexham Park Hospital (WPH) identified a hospital-based outbreak which, in turn, led to identification and mitigation of risks from the hospital wastewater system.

METHODS

Enhanced CPE patient screening (using a molecular methodology) was introduced to include admission and discharge screening of all patients admitted to the hospital over a 34-week period. The wastewater drainage infrastructure was surveyed, and likely interventions identified.

FINDINGS

The screening strategy detected a polymicrobial hospital-wide CPE outbreak involving different enzymes, predominantly New Delhi metallo-β-lactamase (NDM) and OXA-48 with the hospital wastewater system acting as the reservoir. During the 34-week period of enhanced screening, 1.2% of patients screened CPE positive, of which 14% of patients developed infection. Of the 65 CPE-positive patients detected, healthcare acquisition at WPH was likely in 47 (73%) patients. Mitigations to the risk from the hospital wastewater system combined with universal admission and discharge screening produced a long-standing reduction in transmission.

CONCLUSION

Universal admission and discharge screening along with introduction of water-safe concepts are effective in improving detection of CPE outbreaks and followed by a reduction of acquisition in healthcare settings where prevalence of such bacteria is increasing.

Nosocomial transmission of NDM-1-containing Klebsiella pneumoniae ST147 in a Dutch pediatric oncology center associated with patients from Ukraine

We studied nosocomial transmission of multidrug-resistant blaNDM-1-containing Klebsiella pneumoniae ST147 in a Dutch pediatric oncology center. Whole-genome multilocus sequence typing revealed two genetic clusters consisting of 2 and 5 K. pneumoniae isolates, both from Ukrainian medical evacuees and Dutch patients. Ukrainian patients were colonized at admission, and two Dutch patients developed bacteremia. Temporal and spatial transmission links were assessed and sampling of sinks revealed environmental contamination of blaNDM-1-containing K. pneumoniae with genetic relatedness to cluster isolates. Phylogenetic analysis of 163 K. pneumoniae ST147 isolates from the Dutch national surveillance revealed that transmission-related isolates formed a unique phylogenetic branch.In conclusion, we demonstrate nosocomial transmission of unique blaNDM-1-containing K. pneumoniae ST147 strains introduced by Ukrainian patients. Sink drains colonized by genetically similar blaNDM-1-containing strains in rooms designated as spatial links within the cluster were considered the potential source of transmission. Healthcare professionals should be aware of these risks, particularly in settings with susceptible patients exposed to antibiotic pressure.

Persistence of OXA-48-producing ST-22 Citrobacter freundii in patients and the hospital environment, Paris, France, 2016 to 2022

In 2016-2019, hospital A's haematology ward experienced an outbreak of OXA-48-producing ST-22 Citrobacter freundii strains, with toilets identified as source of transmission. Between 2020 and 2022, 28 strains of OXA-48-producing ST-22 C. freundii were isolated on other wards. This study aimed to determine whether all OXA-48-producing ST-22 C. freundii strains belonged to the same clone and to investigate the persistence of this clone using whole genome sequencing. OXA-48-producing ST-22 C. freundii strains collected from patients (n = 33) and from the hospital environment (n = 20) of seven wards were sequenced using Illumina technology and clonal relationships were determined using single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP). Phylogenetic analyses were performed on 53 strains from hospital A and on 240 epidemiologically unrelated carbapenem-resistant ST-22 C. freundii isolated from elsewhere in France. SNP analysis suggested long-lasting persistence of the same clone for more than 6 years. Phylogenetic analysis showed that 52 of 53 strains isolated in hospital A belonged to the same cluster and were different from the 240 epidemiologically unrelated C. freundii ST-22. Our data suggest that this clone can persist in hospital environments for years, representing a risk for hospital-acquired infections and outbreaks. Reservoir management is essential to prevent further transmission.

A multicentric survey and single-centre observational study of usage behaviour of sinks in intensive care: training is needed to minimize risk

INTRODUCTION

Sinks have been introduced near patients to improve hand hygiene as part of infection prevention and control measures. However, sinks are a known reservoir for gram-negative bacterial pathogens in particular and their removal to prevent bacterial infections in intensive care patients is currently recommended by several international guidelines.

METHODS

Healthcare workers (HCWs) in 15 intensive care units (ICUs) in Germany were given the opportunity to complete an anonymous survey on the use of sinks between August 2022 and January 2023. Observations were then made in three participating ICUs to determine the frequency and reason for contact with the sink.

RESULTS

258 questionnaires were returned (nurses 87%). 90% found it useful to very useful to have a sink in the patient room, and 56% reported using it daily for hand hygiene. We observed 33 contacts between nurses and sinks over 17 h. In 20/33 (60%) cases, the sink was used for waste disposal. In 3/33 (10%) it was used for hand washing.

DISCUSSION

Sinks are still used for daily care in intensive care units. Educational Interventions in existing buildings to minimise risk through "sink hygiene" (i.e. separation of sinks for water disposal and uptake) can make an important contribution to infection prevention.

Too much ado about data: continuous remote monitoring of water temperatures, circulation and throughput can assist in the reduction of hospital-associated waterborne infections

BACKGROUND

National and international guidance provides advice on maintenance and management of water systems in healthcare buildings; however, healthcare-associated waterborne infections (HAWIs) are increasing.

AIM

To identify parameters critical to water quality in healthcare buildings and to assess whether remote sensor monitoring can deliver safe water systems, thus reducing HAWIs.

METHODS

A narrative review was performed using the following search terms: (1) consistent water temperature AND waterborne pathogen control OR nosocomial infection; (2) water throughput AND waterborne pathogen control OR nosocomial infection; (3) remote monitoring of in-premises water systems AND continuous surveillance for temperature OR throughput OR flow OR use. Databases employed were PubMed, CDSR (Clinical Study Data Request) and DARE (Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects) from January 2013 to March 2024.

FINDINGS

Single ensuite-patient rooms, expansion of handwash basins, widespread glove use, alcohol gel and wipes have increased water system stagnancy resulting in amplification of waterborne pathogens and transmission risk of legionella, pseudomonas, and non-tuberculous mycobacteria. Manual monitoring does not represent temperatures across large complex water systems. This review deems that multiple-point continuous remote sensor monitoring is effective at identifying redundant and low use outlets, hydraulic imbalance and inconsistent temperature delivery across in-premises water systems.

CONCLUSION

As remote monitoring becomes more common there will be greater recognition of failures in temperature control, hydraulics, and balancing in water systems, and there remains much to learn as we adopt this developing technology within our hospitals.

Water-free patient care: a narrative review of the literature and discussion of the pressing need for a way forward

BACKGROUND

Florence Nightingale was the first person to recognize the link between the built environment and patient ill-health. More than 160 years later, the threat of the end of the antibiotic era looms large. The antimicrobial resistance action plan focuses on antimicrobial stewardship and developing new therapeutic agents. The risk from the built environment has been ignored, with wastewater systems identified as major sources of antimicrobial resistance within healthcare facilities. England is undertaking the largest healthcare construction programme globally. These facilities will be operating when antimicrobial resistance is predicted to be at its fiercest. Water-free patient care is a strategy for limiting dispersal of antimicrobial resistance, and preventing patient infections that need further evaluation in new hospitals.

METHODS

A narrative review was undertaken using the terms: waterless/water-free units; waterless/water-free care; sink reduction; sink removal; and washing without water. PubMed, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, and Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects were searched from January 2000 to February 2024 for reviews and original articles. Unit type, geographical location, reasons for a waterless/water-free approach, and outcomes were recorded.

FINDINGS

Seven papers were identified. Four involved adult intensive care units (ICUs), one involved a care of the elderly setting, and two involved neonatal ICUs. In five papers, the aim of intervention was to reduce Gram-negative infections/colonizations. One paper was a systematic review of 'washing without water' which reviewed cost-effectiveness and patient experience. All of the five papers focusing on Gram-negative bacilli reported a reduction in infections or colonizations post intervention.

CONCLUSION

More studies are highlighting the risks from water and wastewater to patient safety, and the value of water-free strategies in reducing infection rates.

Comparison of methods for sampling and detection of carbapenemase-producing organisms in clinical handwash basin drains in health care

There are currently no standardized methods for the sampling and testing of clinical handwash basin (HWB) samples for the detection of carbapenemase-producing organisms (CPOs). Methods used for sampling (drain aspirate vs swab from top of drain) and detection of CPOs in clinical HWB drains in two different healthcare settings, one which was dealing with a hospital-wide CPO outbreak (Hospital A) and another with no reported outbreaks (Hospital B), were compared. Drain aspirates and swabs from HWB drains were tested using multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) together with culture-based methods. No significant difference in detection of CPOs was found between drain aspirate or swab methods of sampling. Direct PCR on samples detected significantly more carbapenemase genes than culture on CARBA agar (P<0.0001 and 0.0045, respectively). A higher percentage of HWB drains were positive in Hospital A both by culture and by direct PCR, and a significantly higher number of carbapenemase genes were detected in HWB drain aspirates at Hospital A, both by PCR and by culture (P=0.014 and 0.0071, respectively). There was high correlation between drain swab positivity by PCR and culture in Hospital A (91%) compared with Hospital B (33%). No difference in drain contamination rates was found when HWBs with a rear drain were compared with HWBs with the drain directly below the tap. Colonization of HWBs at the top of the drain may be related to risk of cross-transmission of CPOs from the healthcare environment to patients.

The impact of sink removal and other water-free interventions in intensive care units on water-borne healthcare-associated infections: a systematic review

With increasing awareness of water sinks as potential sources of outbreaks and transmission of multi-drug resistant (MDR) bacteria in intensive care units (ICUs), there is growing interest in water-free patient care systems. This systematic review reviewed and synthesized available evidence on the effectiveness of sink removal with or without water-free activities in the ICU environment to reduce water-borne healthcare-associated infections. We searched five databases (PubMed, MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science and Embase) for studies published from 1st January 1980 to 2nd April 2024 that examined water-less or water-free activities in the ICU to reduce healthcare-associated infections and patient colonization. Of 2075 articles, seven quasi-experimental studies (total: 332 patient beds) met the study selection criteria. Six of these seven studies (85.7%) were based in adult ICUs; one (14%) was in a neonatal ICU. Five of seven sites (71.4%) implemented water-less interventions after an outbreak. Water-free alternatives used included water-less bath products (six of seven; 85.7%), bottled water for consumption (three of seven; 42.9%), oral care (three of seven; 42.9%) and dissolving of oral medication (four of seven; 57.1%), designated 'contaminated' sink outside of patient and medication preparation areas for disposal of wastewater (four of seven; 57.1%). Implicated pathogens studied included MDR Gram-negative bacteria (four of seven; 57.1%), MDR Pseudomonas aeruginosa only (two of seven; 28.6%), and pulmonary non-tuberculous mycobacterium (NTB) (one of seven; 14.3%). Five of seven (71.4%) studies reported outbreak cessation. Preliminary evidence, from a limited number of studies of which the majority were conducted in an outbreak setting, suggest that sink removal and other water-free interventions in the ICU helped terminate outbreaks involving taps and decrease hospital-onset respiratory isolation of pulmonary NTB.

Biofilms, mobile genetic elements and the persistence of pathogens on environmental surfaces in healthcare and food processing environments

Biofilms are the natural state for bacterial and fungal species. To achieve surface hygiene in commercial facilities, the presence of biofilms must be adequately considered. However, standard disinfectant and sanitizer efficacy tests required by the US-EPA and the European Committee for Standardization (CEN) do not currently consider the role of environmental biofilms. This selective review will discuss what biofilms are and why they are important. We will also cover where they are commonly found in healthcare and food processing facilities and explore how current antimicrobial test methods required for product registration do not test for the presence of biofilms. Additionally, we will explore how a lack of efficacy against biofilms may play a role in the development of antimicrobial resistance in healthcare facilities due to the exchange of mobile genetic elements that occur readily in a biofilm matrix.

Sink interventions in the ICU to reduce risk of infection or colonization with Gram-negative pathogens: a systematic review of the literature

BACKGROUND

Healthcare-associated infections (HAIs) are a major problem in intensive care units (ICUs). The hospital water environment is a potential reservoir for Gram-negative bacteria (GNB), and it has been shown that contaminated sinks contribute to the spread of GNB in outbreak and non-outbreak settings. This study aimed to investigate which sink interventions may reduce GNB infection and colonization rates in the ICU.

METHODS

A database search (MEDLINE via PubMed, EMBASE via Ovid and ClinicalTrials.gov) was undertaken without restrictions on language or date of publication. Studies of any design were included if they described an intervention on the water fixtures in patient rooms, and presented data about HAI or colonization rates in non-outbreak settings. Acquisition (infection and/or colonization) rates of GNB and Pseudomonas aeruginosa were analysed as outcomes.

RESULTS

In total, 4404 records were identified. Eleven articles were included in the final analysis. No randomized controlled trials were included in the analysis, and all studies were reported to have moderate to serious risk of bias. Removing sinks and applying filters on taps had a significant impact on GNB acquisition, but there was high heterogeneity among reported outcomes and sample size among the studies.

CONCLUSION

Few studies have investigated the association of sinks in patient rooms with healthcare-associated acquisition of GNB in non-outbreak settings. Heterogeneity in study design made it impossible to generalize the results. Prospective trials are needed to further investigate whether removing sinks from patient rooms can reduce the endemic rate of HAIs in the ICU.

Long-term ICU outbreak of carbapenamase-producing organisms associated with contaminated sink drains

BACKGROUND

Between 2018 and 2022, a Belgian tertiary care hospital faced a growing issue with acquiring carbapenemase-producing organisms (CPO), mainly VIM-producing P. aeruginosa (PA-VIM) and NDM-producing Enterobacterales (CPE-NDM) among hospitalized patients in the adult intensive care unit (ICU). We report the investigation of this ICU long-term CPO outbreak involving multiple species and a persistent environmental reservoir.

METHODS

Active case finding, environmental sampling, whole genome sequencing (WGS) analysis of patient and environmental strains and implemented control strategies were described in this study.

FINDINGS

From 2018 to 2022, 37 patients became colonised or infected with PA-VIM and/ or CPE-NDM during their ICU stay. WGS confirmed the epidemiological link between clinical and environmental strains collected from the sink drains with clonal strains dissemination and horizontal gene transfer mediated by plasmid conjugation and/or transposon jumps. Environmental disinfection by quaternary ammonium-based disinfectant and replacement of contaminated equipment failed to eradicate environmental sources. Interestingly, efflux pumps genes conferring resistance to quaternary ammonium compounds were widespread in the isolates. As removing sinks was not feasible, a combination of a foaming product degrading the biofilm and foaming disinfectant based on peracetic acid and hydrogen peroxide has been evaluated and has so far prevented re-colonisation of the proximal sink drain by CPO.

CONCLUSION

The persistence in the hospital environment of antibiotic-and-disinfectant resistant bacteria with the ability to transfer mobile genetic elements poses a serious threat on ICU patients with a risk of shifting towards an endemicity scenario. Innovative strategies are needed to address persistent environmental reservoirs and prevent CPO transmission.