The Oberg-Manske-Tonkin (OMT) Classification of Congenital Upper Extremities: Update for 2020

IFSSH Scientific Committee on Congenital Hand Conditions

The Oberg, Manske and Tonkin (OMT) Classification of Congenital Hand and Upper Limb Anomalies was adopted as the official IFSSH classification in 2014 with recommendations for 3-yearly reviews and updates. This report examined the evidence and feedback from the scientific community to see whether changes to the 2020 OMT should be made. The Committee concluded that no current changes are required, but highlighted a number of areas where further research and discussions are needed. These areas include the conditions of symbrachydactyly vs transverse arrest, the ongoing challenge with classifying syndactyly, and the nomenclature of arthrogrypotic conditions. The OMT Classification continues to enjoy high inter- and intra-rater reliability, thus establishing its central place as a robust classification system in various registries around the world.

Epidemiology of Congenital Upper-Limb Anomalies in Southern Taiwan Based on the Updated Oberg, Manske, and Tonkin Classification: A Series of 1,335 Anomalies in 1,188 Patients

PURPOSE

This study aimed to investigate the relative frequency of congenital upper-limb anomalies (CULAs) in southern Taiwan using the 2020-updated the Oberg, Manske, and Tonkin (OMT) classification system and evaluate the practicality of the new classification system.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed patients with CULAs from 1987 to 2021 at a referral center in southern Taiwan. All patients were analyzed based on medical records, photographs, and radiographs, and the anomalies were classified according to the 2020 OMT classification system.

RESULTS

A total of 1,188 patients with 1,335 CULAs were retrospectively reviewed. The results demonstrated that the most common type of CULA was malformations (1,092 cases), followed by dysplasias (144 cases), syndromes (51 cases), and deformations (48 cases). Among the malformations, radial polydactyly was the most common anomaly (732 cases), followed by simple syndactyly (66 cases). Among the dysplasias, camptodactyly was the most common anomaly (52 cases), followed by thumb-in-palm deformity (45 cases) and vascular tumors (17 cases). In the deformations, constriction ring sequence accounted for all cases. Poland syndrome (21 cases) occurred most often in the category of syndromes.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study show that radial polydactyly (732 cases, 55%) is the most common CULA in southern Taiwan, followed by simple syndactyly (66 cases, 5%) and then camptodactyly (52 cases, 4%).

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The OMT classification system is reasonably practical for precise classification of CULAs and enables easy comparison of studies over different time periods. However, continually updating the OMT classification system is required to better categorize the highly variable presentations of CULAs.

Advances and Challenges in Prenatal Detection and Genetic Diagnosis of Upper Limb Anomalies: Analysis of a South London and Kent Cohort

OBJECTIVE

Prenatal detection and genetic diagnosis of congenital upper limb anomalies is particularly challenging due to both anatomical and technological factors. Hereby, we present a cross-sectional description of clinical and genetic findings in a 188-patient cohort.

METHOD

In this retrospective study, we present 188 cases with prenatally or postnatally detected upper limb anomalies, either isolated, associated with other anomalies, or syndromic. Patients were examined in four tertiary care centers in South London and Kent from 2012 to 2023.

RESULTS

Anomalies were prenatally detected in 158/188 patients (84%), with positional defects (37), polydactyly (34) and transverse defects (25) as the most frequent. 63/188 patients (58%) received a genetic diagnosis of aneuploidy (36), Copy Number Variant (9), or monogenic disorder (18). In 39 out of 103 prenatally tested patients (38%), this diagnosis was given prenatally, contributing to termination of the pregnancy in 23 cases.

CONCLUSION

Through a cross-sectional description of 188 cases with congenital upper limb anomalies, we discuss prenatal ultrasound detection (in terms of numbers and accuracy) and genetic diagnosis.

Phenotype-to-Genotype Description of Prenatal Suspected and Postnatal Discovered Upper Limb Anomalies: A Retrospective Cohort Study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate phenotype and genotype characteristics of fetuses and children with upper limb anomalies.

METHOD

Retrospective cohort study of a prenatal and postnatal cohort with upper limb anomalies from January 2007 to December 2021 in a Fetal Medicine Unit. Prenatally on ultrasound suspected upper limb anomalies, such as transverse and longitudinal reduction defects, polydactyly, and syndactyly, and postnatally identified children referred to the Congenital Hand Team were evaluated separately.

RESULTS

The prenatal group included 199 pregnancies: 64 transverse and 19 longitudinal reduction defects, 103 polydactylies, and 13 cases with syndactyly. The majority of cases with longitudinal reduction defects (n = 10, 52.6%), polydactyly (n = 62, 60.2%), and syndactyly (n = 10, 76.9%) were non-isolated, as opposed to transverse reduction defects, which were generally isolated (n = 41, 64.1%). The postnatal cohort included 362 children with upper limb anomalies with 49 transverse and 22 longitudinal reduction defects, 226 polydactylies, and 65 syndactylies. Chromosomal or monogenic abnormalities were identified in 76/199 (38.2%) cases of the prenatal cohort and in 31/362 (8.6%) cases of the postnatal cohort.

CONCLUSION

Prenatal identification of minor defects of the digits is a challenge, with more postnatal than prenatal cases. The majority of cases with isolated anomalies in both groups had no underlying chromosomal or monogenic cause, nor were they associated with a syndrome, as compared to the non-isolated cases. Conducting structural anomaly scans and genetic counseling are crucial to assess the risk of genetic abnormalities.

Prevalence, infant outcomes and gestational risk factors for transverse reduction deficiencies at or above the wrist: a population-based study

We identified individuals born in Norway between 1970 and 2019 with transverse reduction deficiency at or above the wrist (TRDAW) from the Medical Birth Registry of Norway and from the CULA (congenital upper limb anomaly) North Oslo Registry. Infant outcomes and parental factors were compared for 202 individuals with TRDAW to 2,741,013 living individuals without TRDAW born during the same period. We found an overall TRDAW prevalence of 0.74/10,000. Infants with TRDAW had a higher risk for being small for gestational age, an Apgar score <7 and transfer to neonatal intensive care units after delivery. Nine of the infants with TRDAW had associated anomalies, most commonly in the lower limb, and at a higher proportion than the reference population. Other than twin pregnancies, we are unable to identify with certainty any other risk factors for TRDAW.Level of evidence: I.

Developing a Congenital Upper Limb Difference Registry in Australia

Clinical registries are increasingly common and have value in conditions such as congenital upper limb differences where collection of adequate data for scientific study can be challenging due to small numbers and clinical, surgical and psychosocial heterogeneity. This article discusses the motivation, purpose and development of the Australian Hand Differences Register before examining some of the challenges faced during its implementation and considering limitations of registry-derived data. Level of Evidence: Level V (Diagnostic).

Do Nails and Nubbins Matter? A Comparison of Symbrachydactyly and Transverse Deficiency Phenotypes

PURPOSE

Transverse deficiency (TD) and symbrachydactyly may be difficult to distinguish due to shared phenotypes and a lack of pathognomonic features. The 2020 Oberg-Manske-Tonkin classification update modified these anomalies to include "with ectodermal elements" for symbrachydactyly and "without ectodermal elements" for TD as a defining differentiating characteristic. The purpose of this investigation was to characterize ectodermal elements and the level of deficiency and to examine whether ectodermal elements versus the level of deficiency was a greater determining factor for Congenital Upper Limb Differences (CoULD) surgeons making the diagnosis.

METHODS

This was a retrospective review of 254 extremities from the CoULD registry with a diagnosis of symbrachydactyly or TD by pediatric hand surgeons. Ectodermal elements and the level of deficiency were characterized. A review of the registry radiographs and photographs was used to classify the diagnosis and compare it with the diagnosis given by the pediatric hand surgeons. The presence/absence of nubbins versus the level of deficiency as the determining factor to differentiate the pediatric hand surgeons' diagnosis of symbrachydactyly (with nubbins) versus TD (without nubbins) was analyzed.

RESULTS

Based on radiographs and photographs of the 254 extremities, 66% had nubbins on the distal end of the limb; of the limbs with nubbins, nails were present on 51%. The level of deficiency was amelia/humeral (n = 9), <1/3 transverse forearm (n = 23), 1/3 to 2/3 transverse forearm (n = 27), 2/3 to full forearm TD (n = 38), and metacarpal/phalangeal (n = 103). The presence of nubbins was associated with a four times higher likelihood of a pediatric hand surgeon's diagnosis of symbrachydactyly. However, a distal deficiency is associated with a 20-times higher likelihood of a diagnosis of symbrachydactyly than a proximal deficiency.

CONCLUSIONS

Although both the level of deficiency and ectodermal elements are important, the level of deficiency was a greater determining factor for a diagnosis of symbrachydactyly versus TD. Our results suggest that the level of deficiency and nubbins should both be described to help provide greater clarity in the diagnosis of symbrachydactyly versus TD.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Diagnostic IV.

Radial Longitudinal Deficiency: Description of a Novel Surgical Technique and Clinical Cases

Radial longitudinal deficiency III and IV present as a short upper limb, functional elbow, and wrist with severe radial and palmar angulation, where the carpus articulates with the radial and palmar edge of the ulna, allowing limited mobility in a nonfunctional position. Surgical treatment aims to correct radial angulation and flexed carpal position, often altering carpal positioning over the distal ulna and impacting wrist mobility. In addition, fixation through distal ulnar epiphysis affects its growth. Although these procedures improve appearance, functionality remains suboptimal. This study describes a novel ulnar osteotomy and extensor carpi ulnaris transfer for the correction of wrist deformity in radial longitudinal deficiency with preservation of ulnocarpal motion and epiphyseal growth. The surgical technique, indications, contraindications, and potential complications are described. Three cases with postoperative follow-ups at 36, 12, and 6 months, evaluating deformity and pre/postsurgical wrist mobility ranges, are reported. A correction was achieved in the forearm-hand angle of 71 to 88 degrees of the initial. The total range of movement, between 50 degrees and 80 degrees, was almost the same before and after the operation in the most anatomic position. In one patient, there was a residual deformity at the dorsoradial border, which showed no progression during the last 6 months of follow-up. For patients with radial longitudinal deficiency, functional outcomes with preserved mobility appear to hold greater significance. The technique described in this study enabled deformity correction while maintaining a wide range of motion. The preservation of the physis in a different orientation is an aspect that will need evaluation in long-term follow-up but offers potential treatment options in the future; due to the unknown of the secondary deformity, it is recommended that the long-term results should be awaited before adoption of this technique.

Patient-reported function, quality of life and prosthesis wear in adults born with one hand: a national cohort study

We invited individuals aged above 16 years with a congenital transverse reduction deficiency at and above the wrist born in Norway between 1970 and 2006 to complete the short version of the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand Outcome Measure, the 5-Level EuroQoL-5-Dimension instrument, the RAND 36-Item Short Form Health Survey and a single-item questionnaire on arm function, appearance, pain and prosthesis wear. Of 154 eligible participants, 58 (38%) responded. Their scores were not different from the general population. All had been offered prostheses, and 56 (97%) had been fitted at a median age of 1 year (interquartile range 0-2.8). Of the participants, 37 (64%) were still prosthesis wearers, while 21 (36%) were non-wearers or using gripping devices only. Prosthesis wearers had higher levels of 'vitality' as assessed by the RAND-36 and rated their arm appearance higher, but there were no other score differences, indicating that prosthesis rejection is not associated with worse functional outcomes.Level of evidence: III.

Postaxial polydactyly: A case report highlighting genetic context, epidemiological trends, and management options

This case report examines a newborn with bilateral postaxial polydactyly type B, delivered by a 42-year-old mother with a history of third-degree consanguinity. The mother, having had no prior live births and one abortion, presented at 39 weeks gestation. The absence of prenatal care is noted, with its potential impact on prenatal diagnosis not assessed. The newborn, a healthy girl, weighed 3400 g with an Apgar score of 9/10. Radiographic and physical examination revealed vestigial sixth digits with rudimentary phalanges, influencing the surgical approach. This report underscores the importance of genetic counseling in cases of consanguinity and illustrates the multidisciplinary strategy necessary for managing polydactyly, from surgical considerations to genetic evaluation.

Musculoskeletal complaints and disability in a group of young adults with major congenital upper limb differences in The Netherlands

PURPOSE

To determine prevalence of musculoskeletal complaints (MSCs) in adults with major congenital upper limb differences (CoULD) compared to able-bodied controls, and to examine associations of MSCs and disability with various biopsychosocial factors.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Questionnaire-based cross-sectional study assessing MSCs, disability (using the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand questionnaire (DASH)), general and mental health status, physical work demands, and upper extremity range of motion.

RESULTS

Seventy-one individuals with CoULD (participation rate: 41%) and 71 controls matched on age, gender, and education were included (49% female, mean age 28.9 years). Year prevalence of MSCs was significantly higher in the CoULD group (35%) than in the control group (18%). The CoULD group was less often employed and had lower scores on all measures of upper limb range of motion and hand grip. MSCs were associated with higher DASH scores and higher reported work demands. Disability was associated with female gender, more joints with limited range of motion, unemployment, and lower general and mental health. Factors associated with disability did not differ between groups.

CONCLUSIONS

MSCs are a frequent problem in young adults with major CoULD. To prevent or reduce MSC and disability, clinicians and researchers should be aware of the associated factors. Implications for rehabilitationThe year prevalence of musculoskeletal complaints (MSCs) in those with major congenital upper limb differences (CoULD) was approximately double to that of the control group, implying a potential relationship between CoULD and MSCs.Rehabilitation professionals should develop personalized strategies to manage work demands in those with CoULD, considering the association between MSCs and higher reported work demands.Recognizing the impact of a negatively perceived body image on mental health, clinicians should integrate psychological counseling into rehabilitation treatments to support mental well-being and improve overall quality of life in those with CoULD.Rehabilitation professionals should educate individuals with CoULD about the potential associations between upper limb work demands, MSCs, and disability.

The Intrarater and Interrater Reliability of the OMT Classification Among Physicians With a Different Background

BACKGROUND

The Oberg-Manske-Tonkin (OMT) classification established excellent reliability scores in several validation studies. However, one study published in 2022 found much lower scores in a subanalysis of their sample when very simple anomalies were excluded. Our study assessed the reliability of the OMT among physicians with a different background, all involved in congenital hand anomaly care, and analyzed codes with less agreement. Time required for classification was recorded to give an indication on its usability.

METHODS

One hundred digital cases were classified twice with a minimal 1-month time interval, with the use of the 2020 version of the OMT. Two pediatric hand surgeons, 2 rehabilitation specialists, and 2 plastic surgery residents participated in this reliability analysis. The use of multiple codes was allowed. The intra- and interrater reliability was assessed for all 15 possible rater couples by calculating percentage of agreement. Cohen's kappa was calculated along with a 95% confidence interval. For the analysis of individual codes with less agreement, we calculated positive agreement with the use of a summed agreement table. Time necessary for classification was documented in seconds.

RESULTS

The inter- and intrarater agreement was moderate with a mean Cohen's kappa of 0.45 and 0.60 retrospectively. On average, 39 seconds per case were necessary for the first and 24 seconds for the second rating. Background did not influence the level of agreement. Lowest agreement levels (ie, lowest positive agreement) were observed with all the arthrogryposis multiplex congenita subgroups, the "other" subgroups of isolated congenital contractures, syndromic syndactyly, and synpolydactyly. Codes commonly used interchangeably were symbrachydactyly and transverse deficiency and the distinction between these anomalies of only the hand or the entire upper limb; symbrachydactyly and brachydactyly; and camptodactyly and distal arthrogryposis.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study showed a moderate reliability, emphasizing the complexity of this heterogeneous patient population. Despite its imperfections, the OMT remains the best and most versatile classification tool at hand. Its main purpose may lie in contributing to a universal language for research.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

I.

Patient and Caregiver Impressions of the Impact of Madelung Deformity: A CoULD Registry Analysis

PURPOSE

This study seeks to investigate demographics of patients with Madelung deformity in a large, geographically diverse sample and understand patient and caregiver perceptions of the impact of this condition. We hypothesized that patients with untreated Madelung deformity have greater pain and lower function compared to the normal population but are less affected than the chosen control group, namely, patients with proximal radioulnar synostosis (PRUS).

METHODS

This retrospective study queried the Congenital Upper Limb Differences (CoULD) Registry, a multicenter registry of patients treated in tertiary care pediatric hospitals. We searched patients enrolled as of July 2022 and identified 3,980 total patients and 66 (1.7%) with a diagnosis of Madelung deformity. We reviewed demographics and Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS; peer relations, depressive symptoms, pain interference, and upper extremity function domains) scores at time of enrollment. We used a matched cohort comparison with propensity scoring for 50 patients with Madelung deformity and 50 patients with PRUS (control cohort).

RESULTS

Patients with Madelung deformity presented at an average age of 13.1 years (± 2.1 years). Ninety-eight percent were female, and 82% were White. Seventy-four percent had distal radius-only deformity. Upper extremity PROMIS scores in both the Madelung deformity and the PRUS groups were significantly "worse" than normal, confirming our hypothesis. The Madelung deformity and PRUS cohort scores were not consistently different from one another. PROMIS scores from all other domains, including pain interference, were similar to, or better than normal for both groups, disproving the second part of our hypothesis.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with Madelung deformity averaged 13 years of age and were nearly all female, and the majority had only distal involvement of the radius. Patients with Madelung deformity had lower function based on PROMIS scores, similar to the control cohort, whereas all other PROMIS measures were similar to or better when compared to normal values. Pain interference scores in both cohorts were lower than normal values. Patients with Madelung deformity have decreased function, similar to the comparative cohort of patients with PRUS, but do not present with increased pain.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Symptom Prevalence III.

Macrodactyly

Macrodactyly is a rare congenital limb difference manifesting as an overgrowth of one or more fingers or toes. The pathological process affects all tissues of the ray in the hand or foot. The enlargement can significantly alter the limb's appearance and impair its function. The role of a pediatrician is to distinguish isolated macrodactyly from syndromic conditions (including PIK3CA-Related Overgrowth Spectrum) or mimicking conditions to enable early interdisciplinary consultation and treatment planning. The psychological stigma associated with this often disfiguring condition necessitates support for patients and their family. We present a practical guide for physicians who might be the first to raise suspicion of macrodactyly and initiate further diagnostics to achieve adequate treatment and support for children and caregivers.

Isolated Unilateral Absence of Lunate: A Case Report and Review of Literature

Isolated unilateral absence of lunate is an extremely rare condition with only one such case reported in English literature so far. The rarity of this condition can lead to diagnostic dilemma, especially if patient has an old history of trauma or surgery around the wrist, leading to unnecessary intervention and difficulty in ensuring a good surgical outcome. We present such a case and discuss the clinical pointers to the diagnosis of this condition. Level of Evidence: Level V (Therapeutic).

The Oberg, Manske, and Tonkin Classification of Congenital Upper Limb Anomalies: A Consensus Decision-Making Study for Difficult or Unclassifiable Cases

PURPOSE

An ideal classification system promotes communication and guides treatment for congenital upper limb differences (CULDs). The Oberg, Manske, and Tonkin (OMT) classification utilizes phenotypic presentation and knowledge of developmental biology for the classification of CULDs. In this consensus decision-making study, we hypothesized that CULDs that are difficult to classify would be identically classified by a group of experienced pediatric hand surgeons.

METHODS

An international consortium of 14 pediatric hand surgeons in 3 countries contributed a group of 72 difficult-to-classify CULD cases. These were identified from the clinical practices of the surgeons and from associated registries. Through a Delphi-type process, repeated efforts were made to obtain consensus for the correct OMT classification of each case utilizing clinical images and radiographs.

RESULTS

The first round of discussion yielded a universal consensus for 57 cases. The remaining 15 cases continued to be put through additional rounds of the Delphi-type process. The repeat classification and discussion resulted in a final yield of 93% complete consensus in classification by the OMT. The primary challenge in diagnosis was differentiating cleft hand from ulnar longitudinal deficiency, identified as group A. Five cases were in this group, yet 2 remained without a clear consensus. Another controversial group, group B, was termed "brachy-polydactyly" and consisted of 3 cases where diagnoses varied between sympolydactyly, symbrachydactyly, or complex syndactyly.

CONCLUSIONS

The Delphi-type process was feasible and effective and allowed a 93% consensus in the diagnosis of difficult-to-classify cases by the OMT Classification. There remain limitations and controversies with the OMT system, especially when classifying hands with less than 5 skeletal digits, syndactyly, and those with diagnostic overlap between ulnar longitudinal deficiency and cleft hand and those considered "brachypolydactyly." An improved understanding of the underlying etiology may be needed to determine the final diagnosis in difficult-to-classify conditions.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

A consensus-seeking approach is effective and feasible in addressing difficult-to-classify CULDs.

Clinical evidence of the association between radial longitudinal deficiency and radial polydactyly: a case series

Radial longitudinal deficiency (RLD) is commonly associated with thumb hypoplasia. The association between RLD and radial polydactyly (RP) is uncommon, but case reports or case series have been reported. We report our experience of managing patients with this association. A total of 97 patients with RLD were seen in our department, of which six were children with concomitant RLD and RP. Four children had both RLD and RP in the same limb; of them, three also had RLD in the contralateral limb. The mean age at presentation was 11.6 months. Awareness of this association alerts the clinician to look for RLD in the presence of RP and vice versa. This case series supports recent experimental and clinical evidence that RP and RLD may be part of the same developmental spectrum. Further studies may guide its inclusion as a possible new category in the Oberg-Manske-Tonkin (OMT) classification of congenital upper-limb anomalies.Level of evidence: IV.

Ulnar dimelia - a review of 24 cases

Ulnar dimelia is a very rare unilateral congenital upper limb anomaly (CULA) affecting the whole extremity. Treatment remains difficult because of the complexity and multi-level involvement. Twenty-four cases with duplicated ulna, absent radius and polydactyly from seven European centres were reviewed according to a structured list of parameters. At first consultation, median age 8 months (1-178), the shoulder movement was good in 17 patients or poor in six, and the median passive elbow range of motion was 20° (0°-90°). The resting wrist position was flexed in 22/24 patients. Following stretching and splinting, elbow surgery included resection of the lateral proximal ulna in 11 patients and muscle transfers in six to improve passive movement and increase active elbow motion, respectively. Tendon transfers were performed in eight wrists and a pollicization or pseudo-pollicization in 23 patients. Overall, patients demonstrate acceptable function postoperatively. Guidelines for treatment of this severe CULA are presented.Level of evidence: IV.

State of the art review: The pathogenesis and management of Madelung deformity

Madelung deformity remains a fascinating yet unresolved challenge. There is an increasing awareness for early diagnosis by healthcare providers with improvement in diagnostic modalities, however, the exact mechanisms for the development of the deformity have still to be clarified. While some corrective procedures have been described to effectively address an established deformity, the existing literature lacks clear and evidence-based treatment guidelines on how to proceed in daily practice. This review article aims to summarize the current best evidence on this topic, including particular areas of controversy and areas with need for future research.

Re-examining the nomenclature of congenital failure of formation in the upper limb: a historical perspective

In this study, we studied historical case notes to examine nomenclature of congenital upper limb anomalies and explore the changes in terminologies over time. Original diagnoses were reclassified according to previously published classifications and the most recent Oberg, Manske and Tonkin system. Two hundred and thirty-eight case notes were obtained from the period 1961-1991. Hand plate malformations where the diagnosis was obvious or traumatic defects, were excluded. Eighty-six cases (106 extremities) were finally included where an ambiguous diagnosis, such as 'congenital absence' was initially given. None of the re-classifications matched the original diagnoses except for cleft hand and radial dysplasia (n = 31). Eighteen phocomelia-type limbs were re-classifiable when seen as a continuum of longitudinal deficiency, but not as an intercalary deficit. This study provided further insights into the evolving nature of nomenclature in congenital upper limb anomalies, especially for the condition of phocomelia.Level of evidence: IV.

Correction of symbrachydactyly: a systematic review of surgical options

Symbrachydactyly is a rare congenital malformation of the hand characterized by short or even absent fingers with or without syndactyly, mostly unilaterally present. The hand condition can vary from a small hand to only nubbins on the distal forearm. This study aims to systematically review the surgical management options for symbrachydactyly and compare functional and aesthetic outcomes.The review was performed according to the PRISMA guidelines. Literature was systematically assessed searching the Cochrane Library, PubMed, Embase, and PROSPERO databases up to January 1, 2023. Studies were identified using synonyms for 'symbrachydactyly' and 'treatment'. Inclusion criteria were the report of outcomes after surgical treatment of symbrachydactyly in humans. Studies were excluded if they were written in another language than English, German, or French. Case reports, letters to the editor, studies on animals, cadaveric, in vitro studies, biomechanical reports, surgical technique description, and papers discussing traumatic or oncologic cases were excluded.Twenty-four studies published were included with 539 patients (1037 digit corrections). Only one study included and compared two surgical techniques. The quality of the included studies was assessed using the Modified Coleman Methodology Score and ranged from 25 to 47. The range of motion was the main reported outcome and demonstrated modest results in all surgical techniques. The report on aesthetics of the hand was limited in non-vascularized transfers to 2/8 studies and in vascularized transfers to 5/8 studies, both reporting satisfactory results. On average, there was a foot donor site complication rate of 22% in non-vascularized transfers, compared to 2% in vascularized transfers. The hand-related complication rate of 54% was much higher in the vascularized group than in the non-vascularized transfer with 16%.No uniform strategy to surgically improve symbrachydactyly exists. All discussed techniques show limited functional improvement with considerable complication rates, with the vascularized transfer showing relative high hand-related complications and the non-vascularized transfer showing relative high foot-related complications.There were no high-quality studies, and due to a lack of comparing studies, the data could only be analysed qualitatively. Systematic assessment of studies showed insufficient evidence to determine superiority of any procedure to treat symbrachydactyly due to inadequate study designs and comparative studies. This systematic review was registered at the National Institute for Health Research PROSPERO International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews number: CRD42020153590 and received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.Level of evidenceI.Systematic review registrationPROSPERO CRD42020153590.

Congenital Upper-Limb Differences: A 6-Year Literature Review

➤ The Oberg-Manske-Tonkin (OMT) classification of congenital hand and upper-limb anomalies continues to be refined as our understanding of the genetic and embryonic etiology of limb anomalies improves.➤ We have conducted an evaluation of graft and graftless techniques for syndactyly reconstruction; strengths and drawbacks exist for each technique.➤ Treatment for radial longitudinal deficiency remains controversial; however, radialization has shown promise in early follow-up for severe deformities.➤ Recent emphasis on psychosocial aspects of care has demonstrated that children with congenital upper-limb differences demonstrate good peer relationships and marked adaptability.

Congenital Limb Defects: A Retrospective Cohort Study and Overview of the Literature

PURPOSE

Congenital limb defects are common malformations that are often associated with other organ defects and genetic disorders. Since prenatal detection is challenging and classification is often complex, the aim of this study was to describe a large cohort of fetuses with congenital limb defects and to identify characteristics that are essential for prenatal evaluation, counselling, and management.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this retrospective cohort study, all cases of confirmed fetal limb defects from two centers for prenatal ultrasound between 2001 and 2021 were evaluated. Cases with skeletal dysplasia were excluded from this study. Demographic data, association with genetic disorders, and correlation with maternal parameters were analyzed statistically.

RESULTS

170 fetuses were included in this study. 60% were diagnosed with a reduction anomaly and 40% with a duplication anomaly. The majority of fetuses were male, and in 73.5% of all cases, additional malformations were present. Among the genetic causes, trisomy 13 and 18 were the most common in this cohort.

CONCLUSION

Congenital limb malformations are important markers for complex fetal disorders that warrant referral to specialists in prenatal ultrasound. To improve prenatal detection, care should be taken to visualize all fetal extremities already in early pregnancy.

Age-related changes in patients with upper limb thalidomide embryopathy in the United Kingdom

We report the  long-term upper limb disability, health-related quality of life (HRQoL), functional impairment, self-perception of appearance and prevalence of neuropathic pain in patients with upper limb thalidomide embryopathy in the United Kingdom. One-hundred and twenty-seven patients responded to our electronic questionnaire. Mean Quick Version of the Disabilities of Arm, Shoulder, and Hand score was 54.3 (SD 22.6). Median EuroQoL 5-Dimension 5-Likert index, Work and Social Adjustment Scale, Derriford Appearance Scale 24 and Neuropathic Pain Scale were 0.6 (IQR 0.4 to 0.7), 15.5 (IQR 8.0 to 23.5), 35.5 (IQR 28.0 to 50.5), and -0.8 (IQR -1.4 to 0.8), respectively. Thirty-three patients (26%) reported neuropathic pain. Finger changes associated with radial longitudinal deficiency were an independent predictor of more severe upper limb disability. Eighty-nine patients (70%) reported deteriorating HRQoL with increasing age. Patients with upper limb thalidomide embryopathy experience age-related worsening of symptoms and function, highlighting the need for ongoing specialist care and support.Level of evidence: IV.

Recent Advancements in the Diagnosis and Treatment of Congenital Hand Differences

Congenital hand and upper limb differences include a wide spectrum of structural abnormalities that affect functional, appearance, and psychosocial domains of affected children. Ongoing advances in the understanding and treatment of these differences continue to shape management. Over the past 10 years, new developments have been made in areas of molecular genetics, noninvasive treatments, surgical techniques, and outcome measures in several commonly seen congenital hand differences. Applying these advances in knowledge and management of congenital hand differences will enable surgeons to achieve the best outcomes possible for these children.

The association between trauma and paediatric trigger thumb deformity; experience from a single tertiary referral hospital

Whilst the natural history and management of trigger thumb have been thoroughly investigated, the aetiology of the condition remains poorly understood. There are suggestions that this could be a congenital or acquired condition, but evidence remains limited. A history of trauma has repeatedly been noted in a proportion of patients presenting with trigger thumb. This retrospective study reviewed the presentations of 75 cases of trigger thumb in 65 consecutive children who underwent surgery for trigger thumb. We found that 28% of affected digits presented with a traumatic history to the thumb, of those 90% presented immediately post-injury with a flexion deformity. Those who presented with a traumatic history were typically younger at presentation (median age 27.0 months compared to 37.5 months for traumatic and atraumatic presentations respectively) but also tended to present earlier than the atraumatic group (one day compared to 12.17 months respectively). We conclude that a single traumatic event is unlikely to be the causative factor in the development of trigger thumb in children but it may expediate the development of individuals who are predisposed.

Mirror hand-ulnar dimelia: a single centre experience with 13 patients

Mirror hand-ulnar dimelia (MHUD) is rare congenital disorder with a wide range of clinical and radiographic features. The current nomenclature is confusing and the existing classification systems focus mainly on morphology without providing much guidance for treatment. The goal of this study was to review the clinical and radiological features in 13 children with MHUD that were treated at a single institution. Our findings support the hypothesis that MHUD typically involves the entire upper limb, and the treatment plan should consider the predictors of function at each limb segment. A logical and comprehensive management algorithm is proposed.Level of evidence: IV.

Inter- and intra-rater reliability of the Oberg-Manske-Tonkin classification of congenital upper limb anomalies

On two occasions, five surgeons classified a cohort of 150 consecutive patients with congenital upper limb anomalies according to the Oberg-Manske-Tonkin classification (2020 update). We estimated reliability for the main anomaly code by means of Cohen's kappa (Κ) for ten rater pairs for five common and easily distinguishable anomalies (Group 1), and for all the other anomalies (Group 2). Inter-rater reliability for all patients (n = 150) was substantial, almost perfect for Group 1 (n = 64), but only moderate for Group 2 (n = 86). Intra-rater reliability was higher for all groups. We suggest simplifications to the Oberg-Manske-Tonkin classification and highlight specific requirements for instructions to increase its reliability.Level of evidence: I.

Epidemiology of Congenital Hand Differences at a Tertiary Hospital in Southern India – Establishment of a New Registry and Assessment Using Both the Swanson/IFSSH and the Oberg, Manske and Tonkin Classifications

Background: In resource challenged nations, the true magnitude of the congenital hand differences (CHD) remain unknown due to a lack of nation-wide surveillance system. We created a hospital-based registry system with the aim to determine the prevalence and distribution of CHD and compare the Swanson/IFSSH (SI) and Oberg, Manske and Tonkin (OMT) classifications.

Methods: Data of children aged 0 to 18 years with CHD was entered into the online registry and classified based on the SI and OMT classifications from January 2018 to December 2021. The prevalence and distribution of CHD and risk factors like family history were summarised using descriptive analysis. Syndromic and heredity associations were further analysed using Fischer exact test and odds ratio. Clustered columns were used to compare the two classification systems.

Results: A total of 307 patients with CHD presented during the study with a prevalence of 2.4/1,000 patients. Among them, 164 were unilateral, 21 were born of consanguineous marriages (7.6%) and 10 (3.6%) had a family history of CHD. Although not statistically significant, bilateral involvement was twice as likely to be hereditary compared to unilateral involvement. A total of 10 different syndromes were identified among 27 patients of which Holt–Oram syndrome was most common. The most common CHD was Radial longitudinal defificiency (111). A total of 82 (27%) children had other associated anomalies that could not be grouped as a syndrome. Two patients could not be classified using either SI or OMT classifications.

Conclusions: The online registry established an efficient way to store and analyse data related to CHD. It provides new information on its prevalence in South India, which is similar to the existing literature. Most of the CHD can be grouped in both the SI and OMT classifications. However, there still remains some conditions that are unclassifiable. There is a need for a national registry of CDH for effective management, funding and research.

Level of Evidence: Level IV (Epidemiological)

The Impact of Isolated Versus Multiple Osteochondromas: Analysis of the CoULD Registry

PURPOSE

The burden of upper extremity (UE) osteochondromas on function and self-perception among pediatric patients is unclear. The purpose of our study was to study the impact of osteochondromas in comparison to population norms and to evaluate solitary versus multiple osteochondromas on subjective UE function as measured by patient rated outcomes.

METHODS

We utilized the CoULD (Congenital Upper Limb Differences) Registry to review all pediatric patients presenting with osteochondromas between January 2014 and February 2021. Demographic information was collected and patients were classified as having either single or multiple osteochondromas. Patient-Reported Outcome Measurement Information System (PROMIS) and Pediatric Outcomes Data Collection Instrument (PODCI) tools were utilized for assessment. Scores for PODCI subscales of UE function, Pain/comfort, and Happiness and PROMIS domains of UE Function, Pain, Depression, Anxiety, and Peer Relations were reviewed. Differences between groups were analyzed using the Student t test.

RESULTS

Ninety-nine patients met inclusion criteria for the study with an average age of presentation of 9.3 years and 61 patients (62%) were male. Overall, patients demonstrated worse UE Function as well as greater Anxiety and Depression in comparison to the population normals on PROMIS assessment. Patients also demonstrated worse patient and parent reported PODCI UE, Sports and Physical Functioning, Pain/Comfort and Global Functioning scores compared with population norms but demonstrated better than average happiness scores. Patients with multiple osteochondromas demonstrated greater PROMIS pain interference and more disability in PODCI Sports and Physical Functioning, Pain/Comfort and Global Functioning compared with those with solitary osteochondromas.

CONCLUSION

Patients with UE osteochondromas have worse overall function in comparison to population norms, exceeding established minimally clinically important difference values. In addition, patients with multiple osteochondromas reported more pain and poorer physical function than those with solitary osteochondromas. Physicians should be alert to the physical and psychosocial burden of this disease.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level II-prognostic.

Peripheral Nerve Innervation in Bilateral Cleft Hand Syndrome Elucidated by Ultrasound

Bilateral cleft hand syndrome is a rare congenital malformation with complex anatomy. Previous reports have mainly focused on the description of bone and soft tissue abnormalities, but information about innervation is scarce. Knowledge of the peripheral nerve anatomy is helpful for surgical treatment, optimizing the reconstruction, and preventing iatrogenic damage. Following clinical assessment and conventional radiologic imaging, we used high-resolution ultrasound of both hands and forearms to image the peripheral nerves in a patient with severe bilateral cleft hand syndrome. The patient presented with two ulnar digits, a deformed thumb on the right, and a rudimentary thumb appendage on the left. In keeping with the tissue elements present and absent, we found a severe bilateral nerve size reduction of the median nerves, sparing the anterior interosseous nerve fascicles. The radial nerve and end branches were intact, and a slightly smaller ulnar nerve was found that ended in two digital branches to a single digit. Our study shows that in cleft hand syndrome the peripheral nervous system anatomy exactly reflects the presence and absence of the corresponding muscle and skin innervation areas. This information is helpful for planning a surgical-reconstructive approach and suggests a potential role for nerve ultrasound in the assessment of complex limb malformations.

The importance of embryology for parents of children with congenital hand differences

This study aimed to determine whether embryology knowledge or explaining the possible developmental pathway error was important for parents of affected children, and to secondarily determine if there was a relationship between desired knowledge of embryology and disease severity, maternal age group or maternal level of education. Using a self-administered questionnaire, a significant proportion of responding parents considered knowledge of embryology important (32 out of 43). We found a significant association between the importance of embryology knowledge for parents and the disease severity. However, the importance and level of knowledge desired was not related to maternal age or level of education. This study demonstrated the importance of explaining the associated developmental errors in the congenital hand consultation, particularly in severe anomalies. Surgeons should familiarize themselves with embryology to provide an explanation as to why congenital hand differences happen, which may provide better psychological support for parents of these children.

The Hand in Distal Arthrogryposis

Distal arthrogryposis is the second most common type of arthrogryposis after amyoplasia and is defined as arthrogryposis that affects hands and feet; it is mostly inherited in an autosomal-dominant fashion. This review discusses up-to-date background information, clinical features, and treatment of distal arthrogryposis in hands concentrating on camptodactyly, thumb-in-palm deformity, and windblown hand deformity, which are the most common and functionally limiting deformities. Treating these deformities should be individualized and follow a multidisciplinary approach. Most deformities can be initially treated nonoperatively, and if not responsive, operative treatment may be pursued to improve function. Surgery primarily aims to release soft-tissue contractures, rebalance muscle forces, and may need bony correction based on the deficits of each case. Current literature suggests that early treatment leads to better outcomes. However, reported cases are scarce, and no consensus or gold standard for treatment exists. Therefore, long-term (multicenter) studies are needed to assess outcomes and standardize the treatment of such deformities whenever possible.

Pre-natal and post-natal diagnosis of congenital upper limb differences: The first 3 years of the Australian Hand Difference Register

AIMS

Children with a congenital upper limb difference (CoULD) are a diverse group who often require multidisciplinary care and long-term support for functional and social impacts. The Australian Hand Difference Register (AHDR) provides a national database of children born with a CoULD and aims to facilitate research and improve health care for affected children. Using data from the first 3 years of its operation, we analysed the demographic and clinical features of participating families, including type of CoULDs and the frequency of pre-natal and syndromic diagnoses.

METHODS

Families were recruited from tertiary plastic surgery, orthopaedic and genetics clinics, as well as by self-referral. Hand differences were classified by the consulting physician according to the Oberg-Manske-Tonkin classification system. Primary carers were invited to complete an online questionnaire covering demographic information, pregnancy and newborn outcomes and diagnostic details.

RESULTS

Between August 2017 and September 2020, 822 families consented and 320 questionnaires were reviewed. CoULDs were detected pre-natally in 66 (20.6%) and post-natally in 248 children (77.5%); data for 6 (1.9%) children were missing. The most common CoULDs were radial polydactyly, symbrachydactyly with ectodermal elements and radial longitudinal deficiency, hypoplastic thumb. Twenty-seven children (8.4%) had an associated syndrome, 7 diagnosed pre-natally and 19 post-natally; the most common were VACTERL association, Poland anomaly, Holt-Oram and ectrodactyly-ectodermal dysplasia-clefting syndromes.

CONCLUSIONS

The AHDR is a valuable resource for understanding the relative frequencies of CoULDs. Participation will assist future research into the diagnostic journeys of children with CoULDs, including risk factors, diagnosis and psychosocial impacts.

The impact of socioeconomic deprivation on congenital hand differences: A retrospective cohort study

Socioeconomic deprivation is an established risk factor for a range of adverse perinatal and infant outcomes. The primary aim of this study was to investigate any association between socioeconomic deprivation and the prevalence of Congenital Hand Differences (CHDs). This retrospective cross-sectional study was undertaken at a single tertiary referral center over a five year period (March 2015 to February 2020). The inclusion criterion was all patients referred for a review at a CHD clinic. As a measure of socioeconomic status, patients were assigned to a deprivation quintile using the Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD): quintile 1 indicates the most deprived area and quintile 5 indicates the least deprived area. CHDs were classified according to the Oberg-Manske-Tonkin (OMT) Classification. During the study period 259 patients were identified. The overall prevalence of CHD was 15 per 100,000 per year, mean referral age was 2.6 years (Standard Deviation: 4 years) and 135 patients (52%) were female. Areas of greater social deprivation had a significantly higher prevalence of CHD (22 per 100,000 per year in quintile 1 vs. 13 per 100,000 per year in quintile 5; p < 0.001), surgery (75% of patients in quintile 1 vs 43% of patients in quintile 5; p = 0.003), and younger referral age (1.5 years in quintile 1 vs 4.4 years in quintile 5; p = 0.003). This study has shown a greater CHD prevalence rate amongst patients from more socially deprived areas. In the most deprived group, the patient referral age was also significantly younger and surgical intervention rate was higher.

Caring for Children With Congenital Upper Extremity Differences

The purpose of this article is to provide information about the changing landscapes in research, treatment, civil rights' protection, disability awareness, and accepted terminology in the care of children with congenital upper limb differences. This knowledge can guide clinical and nonclinical conversations between patients and their families.

#MadelungDeformity: Insights Into a Rare Congenital Difference Using Social Media

BACKGROUND

Madelung deformity is a rare congenital hand difference with little known regarding the patient perspective. In this cross-sectional survey study, we harnessed the global reach of social media to understand the clinical spectrum of Madelung deformity and its impact on physical, mental, and social health.

METHODS

A survey was developed based on a previously published protocol and multiple Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS) short forms. The survey was distributed on several Madelung deformity communities on Facebook and Instagram. T-scores were calculated, interpreted, and compared between patients who underwent surgery and those who did not. Correlations between scores were calculated using the Spearman rank correlation coefficient.

RESULTS

Mean PROMIS scores for adults were as follows: pain intensity, 4.9 ± 2.8; pain interference, 57.6 ± 10.0; upper extremity, 35.2 ± 8.1; depression, 53.8 ± 11.1; anxiety, 55.4 ± 11.4; and ability to participate in social roles and activities, 42.5 ± 7.7. Mean scores for children were as follows: pain intensity, 5.0 ± 2.8; pain interference, 55.7 ± 11.3; upper extremity function, 24.6 ± 10.4; depressive symptoms, 57.7 ± 11.3; anxiety, 57.3 ± 11.9; and peer relationships, 42.2 ± 10.3.

CONCLUSIONS

Madelung deformity has significant effects on patients' physical, mental, and social well-being, even after surgical treatment. Using social media, we were able to compensate for Madelung deformity's rarity by engaging an international audience, demonstrating the feasibility to conduct research through it, and providing a global perspective of the disease entity.

Incidental Bilateral Scaphotrapezial Coalition in a High-Level Throwing Athlete: A Case Report

CASE

Scaphotrapezial coalition is a rare carpal coalition and historically associated with congenital syndromes because it spans 2 carpal rows. We present the case of an 18-year-old collegiate baseball pitcher who was incidentally found to have bilateral scaphotrapezial coalition. He had no history of wrist pain and no functional limitations on physical examination. He had no family history of this condition and no personal history of congenital abnormalities.

CONCLUSIONS

Bilateral scaphotrapezial coalition can be an incidental and asymptomatic finding that is present even in high-level throwing athletes.

Combined clinic and home-based therapeutic approach for the treatment of bilateral radial deficiency for a young child with Holt-Oram syndrome: A case report

BACKGROUND

Holt-Oram syndrome (HOS) is a rare, genetic condition characterized by the combination of congenital heart defect and hypoplasia in one or both upper extremities. Children with HOS commonly present with varied joint and limb involvement including radial longitudinal deficiency impacting hand function. Evidence-based guidelines regarding orthotic wear and therapeutic techniques are lacking.

PURPOSE

The aim of this case report was to present the results of a long-term occupational therapy program for a patient with HOS pre and postpollicization.

STUDY DESIGN

Case report.

METHODS

A 4-month-old patient with bilateral radial longitudinal deficiencies began outpatient occupational therapy for custom orthosis fabrication and treatment which included long term clinic and home-based intervention. Techniques included passive range of motion, orthosis wear, therapeutic taping, and modified constraint induced movement therapy. Longitudinal assessment of musculoskeletal alignment and functional hand use was performed using goniometry for passive and active range of motion, the Assisting Hand Assessment (AHA), and The Thumb Grasp and Pinch Assessment (T-GAP).

RESULTS

Improvement in passive and active range of motion was achieved as well as improved activity level function as measured by the AHA and T-GAP postpollicization and intervention.

CONCLUSIONS

A combined clinic and home-based therapeutic approach can be effective for children with HOS to improve alignment and function pre and postpollicization to further enhance hand function. Comprehensive, long-term assessment is necessary to fully evaluate and communicate improvement.

Revisiting the management of Manske Type 3B and 4 thumb hypoplasia

The traditional management of Manske 3B and 4 thumbs is index finger pollicization. Recently, the transfer of composite tissues from the foot to reconstruct the thumb or the carpometacarpal joint has allowed the preservation of a five-digit hand. Concerns remained about the donor site and also the limited functional and cosmetic outcomes that could be achieved. This article challenges the existing dogma in the management of hypoplastic thumbs, that pollicization should always be the reference standard. We describe the evolution of techniques with free vascularized metatarsal transfer, our refinements and our proposal for a new classification system that accommodates these modifications. With increased experience, acceptable outcomes that are comparable with pollicization can be achieved.