Comparison of Nylon Suture Versus 2 Fibrin Glue Products for Delayed Nerve Coaptation in an Animal Model

Nerve Coaptation in 2023: Adjuncts to Nerve Repair Beyond Suture

Effective nerve coaptation entails tensionless repair of healthy fascicles with intact fascicular architecture and a well-vascularized environment, supportive of the regenerative cellular behaviors of neurons, immune cells, and Schwann cells. Suture coaptations have historically been used to ensure that these criteria are met for end-to-end repair, nerve transfers, and allograft or autograft reconstructions; however, unfortunately, overall restoration of function remains poor. As optimal coaptation is required for return of sensorimotor function, adjunct biomaterials are increasingly being enlisted attempting to optimize these suture-based coaptations. The purpose of this review was to discuss the biological, preclinical, and clinical data for the use of fibrin glue and nerve wraps made of type 1 collagen, porcine small intestine submucosa, chitosan, and human amniotic membrane. This study provides available data on each material's ability to optimize the regenerative potential of nerve repair as well as available outcomes data. Although each biomaterial discussed has benefits to nerve regeneration, at large, data remain heterogeneous, and continued investigation is required to fully understand the specific mechanisms involved and the long-term potential clinical impacts each can provide for improvement of sensorimotor outcomes.

Biomechanical Evaluation of an Atraumatic Polymer-assisted Peripheral Nerve Repair System Compared with Conventional Neurorrhaphy Techniques

Background

Microsuturing, the gold standard for peripheral nerve repair, can create tension and damage at the repair site, potentially impacting regeneration and causing neuroma formation. A sutureless and atraumatic polymer-assisted system was developed to address this challenge and support peripheral nerve repair. The system is based on a biocompatible and biodegradable biosynthetic polymer and consists of a coaptation chamber and a light-activated polymer for securing to the nerve. In this study, we compare the system's biomechanical performance and mechanism of action to microsutures and fibrin repairs.

Methods

The system's fixation force was compared with microsutures and fibrin glue, and evaluated across various nerve diameters through tensile testing. Tension and tissue morphology at the repair site were assessed using finite element modeling and scanning electron microscopy.

Results

The fixation force of the polymer-assisted repair was equivalent to microsutures and superior to fibrin glue. This force increased linearly with nerve diameter, highlighting the correlation between polymer surface contact area and performance. Finite element modeling analysis showed stress concentration at the repair site for microsuture repairs, whereas the polymer-assisted repair dissipated stress along the nerve, away from the repair site. Morphological analysis revealed nerve alignment with no tissue trauma for the polymer-assisted repair, unlike microsutures.

Conclusions

The mechanical performance of the polymer-assisted coaptation system is suitable for peripheral nerve repair. The achieved fixation forces are equivalent to those of microsutures and superior to fibrin glue, minimizing stress concentration at the repair site and avoiding trauma to the severed nerve ends.

Comparison of nylon, vicryl, and fibrin glue for nerve grafting in rats

OBJECTIVES

For nerve injuries, not amendable to tensionless epineural coaptation of the nerve, autografts are the preferred treatment. Although absorbable sutures are not recommended for nerve repair, there is no evidence that non-absorbable sutures are superior to absorbable sutures. This study aims to assess the effectiveness of non-absorbable monofilament nylon sutures, absorbable monofilament vicryl sutures, and fibrin glue when used for nerve grafting.

METHODS

Lewis rats (N = 32) were subjected to a sciatic nerve transection and randomly assigned to a group: graft with Nylon, graft with Vicryl, graft with Fibrin Glue, or no graft. Motor function, sensory function, and thermal pain were assessed during a 12-week recovery period, and immunohistochemistry was used to assess macrophage response.

RESULTS

At 12 weeks, the Vicryl and Nylon groups had significantly larger ankle angles at to lift off, which is a measure of motor function, compared to injured controls (p < 0.05). Grafted rats displayed no difference in thermal response but hypersensitivity to mechanical stimuli compared to the uninjured hindlimb. The Nylon, Vicryl, and Fibrin Glue groups all had significantly less atrophy of the gastrocnemius muscle compared to injured controls (p < 0.0001). In the Fibrin Glue group, 3/9 grafts did not incorporate. The Nylon group had significantly less (p = 0.0004) axon growth surrounding the suture holes compared to the Vicryl group. There were no differences in the axon counts, motor neurons, or sensory neurons between all grafted rats.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate that vicryl sutures work just as well as nylon for nerve recovery after injury and grafting.

Visualization analysis of research frontiers and trends in the treatment of sciatic nerve injury

Objective

To visualize and analyze the literature related to sciatic nerve injury treatment from January 2019 to December 2023, and summarize the current status, hotspots, and development trends of research in this field.

Methods

Using CiteSpace and VOSviewer software, we searched the Web of Science database for literature related to the treatment of sciatic nerve injury. Then we analyzed and plotted visualization maps to show the number of publications, countries, institutions, authors, keywords, references, and journals.

Results

A total of 2,653 articles were included in the English database. The annual number of publications exceeded 230, and the citation frequency increased yearly. The United States and China were identified as high-influence nations in this field. Nantong University was the leading institution in terms of close cooperation among institutions. The authors Wang Yu had the highest number of publications and were highly influential in this field. Keyword analysis and reference Burst revealed a research focus on nerve regeneration and neuropathic pain, which involve regenerative medicine and neural tissue engineering. Chronic pain resulting from sciatic nerve injury often manifests alongside anxiety, depression, cognitive-behavioral disorders, and other issues. Interventions such as stem cells, electrical stimulation, electroacupuncture, total joint replacement, pharmacological interventions, gene therapy, nerve conduits, chitosan scaffolds, and exercise promote nerve repair and alleviate pain. Schwann cells have been the focus of much attention in nerve repair and regeneration. Improving the outcome of sciatic nerve injury is a current research challenge and focus in this field. Based on keyword Burst, nerve conduits and grafts may become a potential research hotspot in the treatment of sciatic nerve injury.

Conclusion

This visual analysis summarizes research trends and developments of sciatic nerve injury treatment and predicts potential research frontiers and hot directions.

Tensile strength of adhesives in peripheral nerve anastomoses: an in vitro biomechanical evaluation of four different neurorrhaphies

BACKGROUND

The fundamental prerequisite for prognostically favorable postoperative results of peripheral nerve repair is stable neurorrhaphy without interruption and gap formation.

METHODS

This study evaluates 60 neurorrhaphies on femoral chicken nerves in terms of the procedure and the biomechanical properties. Sutured neurorrhaphies (n = 15) served as control and three sutureless adhesive-based nerve repair techniques: Fibrin glue (n = 15), Histoacryl glue (n = 15), and the novel polyurethane adhesive VIVO (n = 15). Tensile and elongation tests of neurorrhaphies were performed on a tensile testing machine at a displacement rate of 20 mm/min until failure. The maximum tensile force and elongation were recorded.

RESULTS

All adhesive-based neurorrhaphies were significant faster in preparation compared to sutured anastomoses (p < 0.001). Neurorrhaphies by sutured (102.8 [cN]; p < 0.001), Histoacryl (91.5 [cN]; p < 0.001) and VIVO (45.47 [cN]; p < 0.05) withstood significant higher longitudinal tensile forces compared to fibrin glue (10.55 [cN]). VIVO, with △L/L0 of 6.96 [%], showed significantly higher elongation (p < 0.001) compared to neurorrhaphy using fibrin glue.

CONCLUSION

Within the limitations of an in vitro study the adhesive-based neurorrhaphy technique with VIVO and Histoacryl have the biomechanical potential to offer alternatives to sutured neuroanastomosis because of their stability, and faster handling. Further in vivo studies are required to evaluate functional outcomes and confirm safety.

Nerve Regeneration after a Nerve Graft in a Rat Model: The Effectiveness of Fibrin Glue

BACKGROUND

Simulating the post-traumatic continuity defect of small human peripheral nerves, we compared the effectiveness of fibrin glue with neurorrhaphy for nerve gap restoration.

METHODS

In twenty-four male Wistar rats, a fifteen mm defect in one sciatic nerve only was made and immediately repaired with an inverted polarity autograft. According to the used technique, rats were divided into Group A (Control), using traditional neurorrhaphy, and Group B (Study), using fibrine glue sealing; in total, 50% of rats were sacrificed at 16 weeks and 50% at 21 weeks. Before sacrifice, an assessment of motor function was done through Walking Track Analysis and an electroneurophysiological evaluation. After sacrifice, selected muscle mass indexes and the histology of the regenerated nerves were assessed. All data were evaluated by Student's t test for unpaired data.

RESULTS

No significant differences were found between the two groups, with only the exception of a relative improvement in the tibialis anterior muscle's number of motor units in the study group.

CONCLUSION

Despite the fact that the use of fibrin glue as a nerve sealant is not superior in terms of functional recovery, its effectiveness is comparable to that of microsurgical repair. Hence, the faster and technically easier glueing technique could deserve broader clinical application.

A favorable suture method for size-mismatched nerve transfer: comparison with standard perineural suture in an experimental rat study

BACKGROUND

In nerve transfer for peripheral nerve injury, it is sometimes necessary to suture size-mismatched nerves. In 1993, a favorable suture method called the Ochiai suture method for size-mismatched nerve transfer was reported. However, there is currently a lack of substantial evidence beyond the original report. Therefore, this study aimed to verify the advantages of using the Ochiai suture method for size-mismatched nerve transfer.

METHODS

A total of 18 rats were evaluated in this study and randomly divided into two groups. All rats underwent femoral to sciatic nerve transfer. Specifically, group A (n = 10) underwent the Ochiai suture method, while group B (n = 8) underwent the perineural suture method. After 12 weeks postoperatively, we conducted the sciatic functional index (SFI) test, measured muscle wet-weight, and performed histological evaluations. All data were compared between the two groups, with Welch's t test for normally distributed data and Mann-Whitney's U test for non-normally distributed data. Statistical significance was set at p < 0.05.

RESULTS

The mean number of axons was significantly greater in group A than in group B at 5 mm distal to the stump (p = 0.04). Additionally, the average axonal diameter was significantly greater in group A than in group B at 5 mm and 10 mm distal to the stump (p < 0.01 and p < 0.01, respectively). However, the SFI test and measured muscle wet-weight values showed no significant differences between the two groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study revealed that the Ochiai suture method for size-mismatched nerve transfer in rats increases the regenerative axon numbers and diameters. These findings suggest that the Ochiai suture method could be a valuable approach for achieving effective motor function restoration in cases of size-mismatched nerve transfer.

Functional recovery and muscle atrophy in pre-clinical models of peripheral nerve transection and gap-grafting in mice: effects of 4-aminopyridine

We recently demonstrated a repurposing beneficial effect of 4-aminopyridine (4-AP), a potassium channel blocker, on functional recovery and muscle atrophy after sciatic nerve crush injury in rodents. However, this effect of 4-AP is unknown in nerve transection, gap, and grafting models. To evaluate and compare the functional recovery, nerve morphology, and muscle atrophy, we used a novel stepwise nerve transection with gluing (STG), as well as 7-mm irreparable nerve gap (G-7/0) and 7-mm isografting in 5-mm gap (G-5/7) models in the absence and presence of 4-AP treatment. Following surgery, sciatic functional index was determined weekly to evaluate the direct in vivo global motor functional recovery. After 12 weeks, nerves were processed for whole-mount immunofluorescence imaging, and tibialis anterior muscles were harvested for wet weight and quantitative histomorphological analyses for muscle fiber cross-sectional area and minimal Feret’s diameter. Average post-injury sciatic functional index values in STG and G-5/7 models were significantly greater than those in the G-7/0 model. 4-AP did not affect the sciatic functional index recovery in any model. Compared to STG, nerve imaging revealed more misdirected axons and distorted nerve architecture with isografting. While muscle weight, cross-sectional area, and minimal Feret’s diameter were significantly smaller in G-7/0 model compared with STG and G-5/7, 4-AP treatment significantly increased right TA muscle mass, cross-sectional area, and minimal Feret’s diameter in G-7/0 model. These findings demonstrate that functional recovery and muscle atrophy after peripheral nerve injury are directly related to the intervening nerve gap, and 4-AP exerts differential effects on functional recovery and muscle atrophy.