Mapping of FVIII inhibitor epitopes using cellulose-bound synthetic peptide arrays

Computer-predicted peptides that mimic discontinuous epitopes on the A2 domain of factor VIII

Development of antibodies (Abs) against factor VIII (FVIII) is a severe complication of haemophilia A treatment. Recent publications suggest that domain specificity of anti-FVIII antibodies, particularly during immune tolerance induction (ITI), might be related to the outcome of the treatment. Obtaining suitable tools for a fine mapping of discontinuous epitopes could thus be helpful. The aim of this study was to map discontinuous epitopes on FVIII A2 domain using a new epitope prediction functionality of the PEPOP bioinformatics tool and a peptide inhibition assay based on the Luminex technology. We predicted, selected and synthesized 40 peptides mimicking discontinuous epitopes on the A2 domain of FVIII. A new inhibition assays using Luminex technology was performed to identify peptides able to inhibit the binding of anti-A2 Abs to A2 domain. We identified two peptides (IFKKLYHVWTKEVG and LYSRRLPKGVKHFD) able to block the binding of anti-A2 allo-antibodies to this domain. The three-dimensional representation of these two peptides on the A2 domain revealed that they are localized on a limited region of A2. We also confirmed that residues 484-508 of the A2 domain define an antigenic site. We suggest that dissection of the antibody response during ITI using synthetic peptide epitopes could provide important information for the management of patients with inhibitors.

Phenotypes of allo- and autoimmune antibody responses to FVIII characterized by surface plasmon resonance

Evidence of antibody isotype/subtype switching may provide prognostic value regarding the state of immune responses to therapeutic proteins, e.g. anti-factor VIII (FVIII) antibodies that develop in many hemophilia A patients, clinically termed “inhibitors”. A sensitive, high- information-content surface plasmon resonance (SPR) assay has been developed to quantify IgG subtype distributions and the domain specificity of anti-drug antibodies. Plasma samples from 22 subjects with an allo- or auto-immune reaction to FVIII were analyzed. Pre-analytical treatment protocols were developed to minimize non-specific binding and specific matrix interference due to von Willebrand factor-FVIII interactions. The dynamic range for IgG quantification was 0.2–5 µg/ml (∼1–33 nM), allowing characterization of inhibitor-positive samples. Subtype-specific monoclonal antibodies were used to quantify the IgG subtype distribution of FVIII-specific antibodies. Most samples obtained from multiply-infused inhibitor subjects contained IgG4 antibodies. Several distinct phenotypes were assigned based on the IgG subtype distribution: IgG₁, IgG₄, IgG₁ & IgG₄, and IgG₁, IgG₂ & IgG₄. An IgG₁-only response was found in mild/moderate HA subjects during early FVIII infusions, and analysis of serial samples followed antibody class switching as several subjects’ immune responses developed. Competition studies utilizing a recombinant FVIII-C2 domain indicated 40–80% of FVIII-specific antibodies in most samples were directed against this domain.

Designed ankyrin repeat proteins: a new approach to mimic complex antigens for diagnostic purposes?

Inhibitory antibodies directed against coagulation factor VIII (FVIII) can be found in patients with acquired and congenital hemophilia A. Such FVIII-inhibiting antibodies are routinely detected by the functional Bethesda Assay. However, this assay has a low sensitivity and shows a high inter-laboratory variability. Another method to detect antibodies recognizing FVIII is ELISA, but this test does not allow the distinction between inhibitory and non-inhibitory antibodies. Therefore, we aimed at replacing the intricate antigen FVIII by Designed Ankyrin Repeat Proteins (DARPins) mimicking the epitopes of FVIII inhibitors. As a model we used the well-described inhibitory human monoclonal anti-FVIII antibody, Bo2C11, for the selection on DARPin libraries. Two DARPins were selected binding to the antigen-binding site of Bo2C11, which mimic thus a functional epitope on FVIII. These DARPins inhibited the binding of the antibody to its antigen and restored FVIII activity as determined in the Bethesda assay. Furthermore, the specific DARPins were able to recognize the target antibody in human plasma and could therefore be used to test for the presence of Bo2C11-like antibodies in a large set of hemophilia A patients. These data suggest, that our approach might be used to isolate epitopes from different sets of anti-FVIII antibodies in order to develop an ELISA-based screening assay allowing the distinction of inhibitory and non-inhibitory anti-FVIII antibodies according to their antibody signatures.

The IgG autoimmune response in postpartum acquired hemophilia A targets mainly the A1a1 domain of FVIII

BACKGROUND

Acquired hemophilia A (AHA) is a severe life-threatening autoimmune disease due to the development of autoantibodies that neutralize the procoagulant activity of factor VIII (FVIII). In rare cases, AHA occurs in the postpartum period as a serious complication of an otherwise normal pregnancy and delivery. Due to its rarity, little is known about the features of the antibody response to FVIII in AHA.

OBJECTIVES

Our study wanted to (i) determine the epitope specificity and the immunoglobulin (Ig) subclasses of anti-FVIII autoantibodies in plasma samples from a large cohort of AHA patients, and (ii) compare the epitope specificity of anti-FVIII autoantibodies in plasma samples from postpartum AHA and other AHA patients.

PATIENTS/METHODS

Seventy-three plasma samples from patients with postpartum AHA (n = 10) or associated with malignancies (n = 16) or autoimmune diseases (n = 11) or without underlying disease (n = 36) were analyzed with three multiplexed assays.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Our results showed a stronger response against the A1a1-A2a2-B fragments of FVIII and more specifically against the A1a1 domain in patients with postpartum AHA than in the other AHA groups (P < 0.01). Moreover, although IgG4 was the predominant IgG subclass in all groups, anti-A1a1-A2a2-B and anti-A1a1 domain autoantibodies of the IgG(1) and IgG3 subclasses were more frequently detected in postpartum AHA than in the other AHA groups. These findings support the involvement of the Th1-driven response in the generation of autoantibodies in women with postpartum AHA compared with the other groups of AHA patients in whom production of Th2-driven IgG4 was predominant.

Discontinuous epitopes on the C2 domain of coagulation Factor VIII mapped by computer-designed synthetic peptides

The occurrence of alloantibodies against Factor VIII (FVIII) is the main iatrogenic complication in haemophilia A (HA). Anti-FVIII autoantibodies may also spontaneously appear in non-HA patients, leading to acquired haemophilia A. In both contexts, the antibody response against FVIII is complex and difficult to analyse due to the lack of suitable tools. Our purpose was to comprehensively map, at the amino acid level, discontinuous epitopes of the C2 domain of FVIII targeted by patients' antibodies. We synthesized 33 synthetic peptides, which were predicted by the bioinformatic algorithm PEPOP to mimic C2 domain discontinuous epitopes. Using an inhibition assay based on the x-MAP technology, we evaluated their ability to block the binding to the C2 domain of anti-C2 domain antibodies from pooled plasma samples. Nine peptides were thus selected and tested again in individual plasma samples. Our results support the view that C2 domain epitopes are organized as an epitopic mosaic distributed around the molecule, showed that each patient displayed a specific anti-C2 epitopic profile, and confirmed the complexity and variability of the immune response against the C2 domain of FVIII. This ability to finely map epitopes could be further used to follow the antibody specificity modifications over time.

Use of affinity-directed liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry to map the epitopes of a factor VIII inhibitor antibody fraction

BACKGROUND

Neutralizing factor (F) VIII antibodies develop in approximately 30% of individuals with hemophilia A and show specificity to multiple sites in the FVIII protein.

METHODS

Reactive epitopes to an immobilized IgG fraction prepared from a high-titer, FVIII inhibitor plasma were determined after immuno-precipitation (IP) of tryptic and chymotryptic peptides derived from digests of the A1 and A2 subunits of FVIIIa and FVIII light chain. Peptides were detected and identified using highly sensitive liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS).

RESULTS

Coverage maps of the A1 subunit, A2 subunit and light chain represented 79%, 69% and 90%, respectively, of the protein sequences. Dot blots indicated that the inhibitor IgG reacted with epitopes contained within each subunit of FVIIIa. IP coupled with LC-MS identified 19 peptides representing epitopes from all FVIII A and C domains. The majority of peptides (10) were derived from the A2 domain. Three peptides mapped to the C2 domain, while two mapped to the A1 and A3 domains, and single peptides mapped to the a1 segment and C1 domain. Epitopes were typically defined by peptide sequences of < 12 residues.

CONCLUSIONS

IP coupled with LC-MS identified extensive antibody reactivity at high resolution over the entire functional FVIII molecule and yielded sequence lengths of < 15 residues. A number of the peptides identified mapped to known sequences involved in functionally important protein-protein and protein-membrane interactions.

Characteristics, mechanisms of action, and epitope mapping of anti-factor VIII antibodies

The development of anti-factor VIII (FVIII) antibodies (Abs), also called inhibitors, is currently one of the most serious complications arising during the treatment of hemophilia A patients. Improved prevention and eradication of these Abs remain a challenge both for clinicians and scientists. Numerous studies in the literature have reported on their epitope specificity, on their mechanism of FVIII inactivation, as well as on the methods used for their detection. In this review, we summarize the current knowledge on the nature (isotypes, kinetic properties), epitope properties, and mechanisms of action of anti-FVIII Abs. Furthermore, we present methods for detection and epitope characterization of anti-FVIII Abs with emphasis on the Luminex technique susceptible to facilitate the monitoring of changes in the epitope specificity of these Abs.

Immune response to FVIII in hemophilia A: an overview of risk factors

Development of inhibitors is perhaps the most serious complication of factor VIII (FVIII) replacement therapy, which can practically preclude efficient clinical management of patients with hemophilia A. Much effort therefore has been focused both in improving our understanding of the reasons for the formation of FVIII antibodies and to find alternative methods of treatment. Several patient-related factors have been related to the risk of inhibitor development such as ethnicity, FVIII gene mutation type, family history of inhibitors, HLA haplotype, polymorphisms in the promoter regions of IL 10 gene, single nucleotide polymorphisms of tumor necrosis factor alpha gene, and so on. In addition to the genetic determinants, there are several nongenetic factors which mainly include treatment characteristics like the type and purity of coagulation factor concentrates used for treatment, age at the time of initial treatment, initial doses of concentrate, mode of infusion, surgery, frequency of dosing prior to inhibitor development, and intensity of treatment or regular prophylaxis. Inflammatory processes in early childhood are under discussion as being an environmental factor that may modify the immune response to a foreign antigen. The genetic risks cannot be changed, while environmental factors may increase or decrease the inhibitor risk in an individual patient. In addition, there are other causes of inhibitor development against FVIII like stress, age, malignancy, infection, pregnancy, antibiotics, etc. Development of inhibitors in such cases happens in individuals who are not hemophilic and have normal plasma FVIII levels. Acquired inhibitors to FVIII in nonhemophiliacs (autoantibodies) pose a further challenge to treatment, as this is often associated with significant morbidity and mortality. Prognosis in case of autoantibodies is related to the underlying disease process and is associated with high mortality. Improved understanding of these complex interactions may lead to the development of preventive measures to minimize FVIII inhibitor formation. The modifiable risk factors for inhibitor formation may provide the key to predict and perhaps prevent the formation of inhibitors in hemophilia patients.

Kinetic parameters of monoclonal antibodies ESH2, ESH4, ESH5, and ESH8 on coagulation factor VIII and their influence on factor VIII activity

The murine monoclonal antibodies ESH2, ESH4, ESH5, and ESH8 specifically bind and inhibit the procoagulant activity of human coagulation factor VIII (FVIII). They are frequently used as a model of inhibitors which are raised against injected FVIII in about 25% of hemophiliacs as a serious side effect of substitution therapy. However, binding kinetics of the interaction of these antibodies with FVIII and their influence on FVIII activity (inhibition) have not yet been examined systematically. For this, we examined association and dissociation of protein:antibody interaction using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and determined their ability to inhibit the FVIII activity in a one-stage and a two-stage assay. SPR-analysis revealed that the equilibrium dissociation constants (K(D)) of ESH8 and ESH4 are low and in a similar range (ESH8: K(D(ESH8)) = 0.542 nM; ESH4: K(D(ESH4)) = 0.761 nM). A 5.7 times higher K(D) than for ESH4 was observed for ESH2 (4.33 nM), whereas ESH5 showed the highest K(D) of 28.8 nM. In accordance with the lowest K(D), ESH8, and ESH4 reduced FVIII activity of normal human plasma almost completely in a one-stage clot inhibition assay (ESH8: 91.9%; ESH4: 90.1%). However, ESH8 inhibited FVIII activity more efficiently as only 1.0 microg/ml ESH8 was sufficient to obtain maximum inhibition compared to up to 600 microg/ml of ESH4. Despite its attenuated K(D), ESH2 inhibits FVIII:C still efficiently, reducing 61.3% of FVIII activity at a concentration of 9 microg/ml in the one-stage clotting assay. However, a discrepancy of inhibitory efficiency was found depending on the method used to measure FVIII activity. These effects seem to be mainly caused by differences of activation time of FVIII during both FVIII activity assays. The systematic assessment of these results should support FVIII interaction studies, and can provide data to rationally test peptides/mimotopes to remove or neutralize inhibitors of FVIII activity.

A murine model for induction of long-term immunologic tolerance to factor VIII does not require persistent detectable levels of plasma factor VIII and involves contributions from Foxp3+ T regulatory cells

Under certain instances, factor VIII (FVIII) stimulates an immune response, and the resulting neutralizing antibodies present a significant clinical challenge. Immunotherapies to re-establish or induce long-term tolerance would be beneficial, and an in-depth knowledge of mechanisms involved in tolerance induction is essential to develop immune-modulating strategies. We have developed a murine model system for studying mechanisms involved in induction of immunologic tolerance to FVIII in hemophilia A mice. We used lentiviral vectors to deliver the canine FVIII transgene to neonatal hemophilic mice and demonstrated that induction of long-term FVIII tolerance could be achieved. Hemophilia A mice are capable of mounting a robust immune response to FVIII after neonatal gene transfer, and tolerance induction is dependent on the route of delivery and type of promoter used. High-level expression of FVIII was not required for tolerance induction and, indeed, tolerance developed in some animals without evidence of detectable plasma FVIII. Tolerance to FVIII could be adoptively transferred to naive hemophilia recipient mice, and FVIII-stimulated splenocytes isolated from tolerized mice expressed increased levels of interleukin-10 and decreased levels of interleukin-6 and interferon-gamma. Finally, induction of FVIII tolerance mediated by this protocol is associated with a FVIII-expandable population of CD4(+)CD25(+)Foxp3(+) regulatory T cells.

Reduction of the immune response to factor VIII mediated through tolerogenic factor VIII presentation by immature dendritic cells

BACKGROUND

The development of neutralizing antibodies to factor FVIII (FVIII) represents the most serious complication in the treatment of hemophilia A.

OBJECTIVE

We have explored the potential of using immature dendritic cells (iDCs) to present FVIII in a tolerogenic manner to T cells.

METHODS

The iDCs were isolated from hemophilic murine bone marrow and pulsed with canine cFVIII (cFVIII-iDCs) in the presence or absence of the NFkappaB pathway blocking compound Andrographolide (Andro-cFVIII-iDCs). Three weekly intravenous infusions of one million cFVIII pulsed-iDCs were administered to a group of five hemophilic Balb/c mice. Anti-FVIII antibody levels were monitored by functional Bethesda assay after four weekly intravenous challenges with 2 IU of cFVIII.

RESULTS

We have shown that cFVIII in the presence or absence of Andro is efficiently taken up by iDCs and that this process does not result in the maturation of DCs or the activation of co-cultured T cells. Following repeated infusion of the cFVIII-iDCs and Andro-cFVIII-iDCs into hemophilic mice, which were subsequently challenged with cFVIII, long-term reductions of FVIII inhibitors of 25% and 40%, respectively, were documented. Studies of cytokine release and T-cell phenotypes indicate that the mechanisms responsible for reducing immunologic responsiveness to cFVIII appear to involve an expansion of Foxp3 T regulatory cells in the case of cFVIII-iDC infusion and the elaboration of the immunosuppressive cytokines IL-10 and TGF-beta following andrographolide-treated cFVIII-iDCs.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that tolerogenic presentation of cFVIII to the immune system can significantly reduce immunogenicity of the protein.

Covalent inactivation of factor VIII antibodies from hemophilia A patients by an electrophilic FVIII Analog

The antigen-binding sites of antibodies (Abs) can express enzyme-like nucleophiles that react covalently with electrophilic compounds. We examined the irreversible and specific inactivation of antibodies (Abs) to Factor VIII (FVIII) responsible for failure of FVIII replacement therapy in hemophilia A (HA) patients. Electrophilic analogs of FVIII (E-FVIII) and its C2 domain (E-C2) were prepared by placing the strongly electrophilic phosphonate groups at surface-exposed Lys side chains of diverse antigenic epitopes. IgG Abs to FVIII from HA patients formed stable immune complexes with E-FVIII and E-C2 that were refractory to dissociation by SDS treatment and boiling, procedures that dissociate noncovalent Ab-antigen complexes. The rate-limiting step in the reaction was formation of the initial noncovalent complexes. Conversion of the initial complexes to the irreversible state occurred rapidly. The antigenic epitopes of E-FVIII were largely intact, and most of the Abs were consumed covalently. E-FVIII expressed poor FVIII cofactor activity in clotting factor assays. Nonspecific interference by E-FVIII in clotting factor function was not evident. Treatment with E-FVIII, and to a lesser extent E-C2, irreversibly relieved the FVIII inhibitory effect of HA IgG in clotting factor assays. Small FVIII peptides did not display useful reactivity, highlighting the diverse epitope specificities of the Abs and the conformational character of FVIII epitopes. E-FVIII is a prototype reagent able to attain irreversible and specific inactivation of pathogenic Abs.

Reactivity profile of anti-factor VIII antibodies with designed synthetic peptides mimicking epitopes of the C2 and a1 domains

Antibodies (Abs) that block factor VIII (FVIII) activity occur in hemophilia A patients treated with FVIII replacement therapy and severely impair treatment. In this work, we designed and synthesized ten peptides whose sequences are found in putative epitopes at the surface of a1 and C2 domains of the FVIII molecule. These peptides were screened for their ability to inhibit the binding of anti-FVIII Abs from plasmas of hemophilia A patients to FVIII. All peptides were efficient in inhibiting anti-FVIII Abs in plasma from patients with inhibitors, with however different efficiencies. It was found that each tested patient's plasma had a different profile of reactivity with peptides, consistent with an individual anti-FVIII Ab specificity. The profile of recognized peptides was also changing during the treatment of the patients. Three peptides were used in an affinity chromatography assay to attempt to remove anti-FVIII Abs from patients' plasma. Anti-FVIII IgGs were significantly captured by the peptide-Sepharose affinity matrixes as assessed by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. However, due to the low level of Abs in the plasma samples, other methods (Chromogenic and Bethesda assays) were not sensitive enough to properly detect the reduction of inhibitors.

Assessment of in vitro cytokine response in hemophilia A patients with or without factor VIII inhibitory antibody

Factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitor antibodies are produced in a proportion of hemophilia A patients. Development of anti-FVIII inhibitor antibodies is a T cell-dependent response, mediated by FVIII specific CD4(+) T cells. This study was performed to investigate the contribution of T helper (Th) cell-mediated cytokine response in inhibitor production. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were obtained from hemophilia A patients with (n = 14) or without inhibitor (n = 14) and from normal individuals (n = 14). Following stimulation of PBMCs with rFVIII and phytohemagglutinin (PHA) mitogen, the secreted cytokines, interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), interleukin-10 (IL-10), and transforming growth factor-beta1 (TGF-beta1), in culture supernatant and the proliferative response were assessed using sandwich ELISA and (3)H-thymidine incorporation, respectively. No significant proliferative response to FVIII was observed, whereas PHA induced a strong response in all groups. No cytokine secretion was observed in response to FVIII stimulation. Although PHA induced IL-10, TGF-beta1 and IFN-gamma secretion in all groups, the level of IFN-gamma was significantly lower in hemophilia A patients than in normal individuals (p < 0.0001). The levels of TGF-beta1 and IL-10 were similarly higher in patients compared with normal subjects, but the difference was not statistically significant. Lack of FVIII-induced proliferative response and cytokine production together with reduced secretion of PHA-induced IFN-gamma in both groups of patients suggest involvement of nonspecific immunosuppression possibly due to hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection observed in the majority of patients.