Cobalt(II) and zinc(II) binding to a ferredoxin maquette

De Novo Construction of Redox Active Proteins

Relatively simple principles can be used to plan and construct de novo proteins that bind redox cofactors and participate in a range of electron-transfer reactions analogous to those seen in natural oxidoreductase proteins. These designed redox proteins are called maquettes. Hydrophobic/hydrophilic binary patterning of heptad repeats of amino acids linked together in a single-chain self-assemble into 4-alpha-helix bundles. These bundles form a robust and adaptable frame for uncovering the default properties of protein embedded cofactors independent of the complexities introduced by generations of natural selection and allow us to better understand what factors can be exploited by man or nature to manipulate the physical chemical properties of these cofactors. Anchoring of redox cofactors such as hemes, light active tetrapyrroles, FeS clusters, and flavins by His and Cys residues allow cofactors to be placed at positions in which electron-tunneling rates between cofactors within or between proteins can be predicted in advance. The modularity of heptad repeat designs facilitates the construction of electron-transfer chains and novel combinations of redox cofactors and new redox cofactor assisted functions. Developing de novo designs that can support cofactor incorporation upon expression in a cell is needed to support a synthetic biology advance that integrates with natural bioenergetic pathways.

Empirical and computational design of iron-sulfur cluster proteins

Here, we compare two approaches of protein design. A computational approach was used in the design of the coiled-coil iron-sulfur protein, CCIS, as a four helix bundle binding an iron-sulfur cluster within its hydrophobic core. An empirical approach was used for designing the redox-chain maquette, RCM as a four-helix bundle assembling iron-sulfur clusters within loops and one heme in the middle of its hydrophobic core. We demonstrate that both ways of design yielded the desired proteins in terms of secondary structure and cofactors assembly. Both approaches, however, still have much to improve in predicting conformational changes in the presence of bound cofactors, controlling oligomerization tendency and stabilizing the bound iron-sulfur clusters in the reduced state. Lessons from both ways of design and future directions of development are discussed. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Photosynthesis Research for Sustainability: from Natural to Artificial.

Controlling and fine tuning the physical properties of two identical metal coordination sites in de novo designed three stranded coiled coil peptides

Herein we report how de novo designed peptides can be used to investigate whether the position of a metal site along a linear sequence that folds into a three-stranded α-helical coiled coil defines the physical properties of Cd(II) ions in either CdS(3) or CdS(3)O (O-being an exogenous water molecule) coordination environments. Peptides are presented that bind Cd(II) into two identical coordination sites that are located at different topological positions at the interior of these constructs. The peptide GRANDL16PenL19IL23PenL26I binds two Cd(II) as trigonal planar 3-coordinate CdS(3) structures whereas GRANDL12AL16CL26AL30C sequesters two Cd(II) as pseudotetrahedral 4-coordinate CdS(3)O structures. We demonstrate how for the first peptide, having a more rigid structure, the location of the identical binding sites along the linear sequence does not affect the physical properties of the two bound Cd(II). However, the sites are not completely independent as Cd(II) bound to one of the sites ((113)Cd NMR chemical shift of 681 ppm) is perturbed by the metalation state (apo or [Cd(pep)(Hpep)(2)](+) or [Cd(pep)(3)](-)) of the second center ((113)Cd NMR chemical shift of 686 ppm). GRANDL12AL16CL26AL30C shows a completely different behavior. The physical properties of the two bound Cd(II) ions indeed depend on the position of the metal center, having pK(a2) values for the equilibrium [Cd(pep)(Hpep)(2)](+) → [Cd(pep)(3)](-) + 2H(+) (corresponding to deprotonation and coordination of cysteine thiols) that range from 9.9 to 13.9. In addition, the L26AL30C site shows dynamic behavior, which is not observed for the L12AL16C site. These results indicate that for these systems one cannot simply assign a "4-coordinate structure" and assume certain physical properties for that site since important factors such as packing of the adjacent Leu, size of the intended cavity (endo vs exo) and location of the metal site play crucial roles in determining the final properties of the bound Cd(II).

Design of thiolate rich metal binding sites within a peptidic framework

A de novo protein design strategy provides a powerful tool to elucidate how heavy metals interact with proteins.Cysteine derivatives of the TRI peptide family (Ac-G(LKALEEK)4G-NH2) have been shown to bind heavy metals in an unusual trigonal geometry. Our present objective was to design binding sites in R-helical scaffolds that are able to form higher coordination number complexes with Cd(II) and Hg(II). Herein, we evaluate the binding of Cd(II) and Hg(II) to double cysteine substituted TRI peptides lacking intervening leucines between sulfurs in the heptads. We compare a -Cysd-X-X-X-Cysa- binding motif found in TRIL12CL16C to the more common -Cysa-X-X-Cysd- sequence of native proteins found in TRIL9CL12C. Compared to TRI, these substitutions destabilize the helical aggregates,leading to mixtures of two- and three-stranded bundles. The three-stranded coiled coils are stabilized by the addition of metals. TRIL9CL12C forms distorted tetrahedral complexes with both Cd(II) and Hg(II), as supported by UV-vis,CD, 113Cd NMR, 199Hg NMR and 111mCd PAC spectroscopy. Additionally, these signatures are very similar to those found for heavy metal substituted rubredoxin. These results suggest that in terms of Hg(II) binding, TRIL9CL12Ccan be considered as a good mimic of the metallochaperone HAH1, that has previously been shown to form protein dimers. TRIL12CL16C has limited ability to generate homoleptic tetrahedral complexes (Cd(SR)42-). These type of complexes were identified only for Hg(II). However, the spectroscopic signatures suggest a different geometry around the metal ion, demonstrating that effective metal sequestration into the hydrophobic interior of the bundle requires more than simply adding two sulfur residues in adjacent layers of the peptide core. Thus, proper design of metal binding sites must also consider the orientation of cysteine sidechains in a vs d positions of the heptads.

Role of Protons in the Thermodynamic Contribution of a Zn(II)-Cys4 Site toward Metalloprotein Stability

The current limited understanding of the free energy contributions of metal-protein interactions toward metalloprotein stability is largely due to an inability to separate the energetics of the metal-ligand and protein-protein interactions. In order to elucidate the thermodynamic contribution of a Zn(II)-(S.Cys)4 site toward metalloprotein stability relevant to classic structural Zn(II) sites, the reaction of {Zn(II)(H2O)6}2+ with a minimal, unstructured, tetracysteine 16-mer peptide, GGG, is described. Isothermal titration fluorimetry over the pH range of 4.5 to 9.0 is used to measure the free energy of Zn(II) binding to the model peptide GGG. The data show that, in the absence of proton competition, Zn(II) binds to the Cys4 coordination sphere with a Kd of 60 aM, indicating that the Zn(II)-(S.Cys)4 interaction can provide up to 22.1 kcal mol-1 in driving force for protein stabilization, folding, and/or assembly. Isothermal titration calorimetry shows that Zn(II)-GGG formation is entropy driven because of water release from both the metal and the peptide scaffold. At pH 7.0, where the Zn(II)-GGG Kd value is 8.0 pM, the reaction releases 3.8 protons, is endothermic with DeltaHrxn of +6.4 kcal mol-1, and entropy driven with DeltaSrxn of +72 cal K-1 mol-1. At pH 8.0, where the peptide is partially deprotonated prior to Zn(II) binding, the 1.0 fM Zn(II)-GGG Kd value reflects a Zn(II) complexation reaction involving the release of 2.5 protons, which is slightly exothermic, with DeltaHrxn of -2.0 kcal mol-1, and largely entropy driven, with DeltaSrxn of +61 cal K-1 mol-1. At pH 5.5, where proton competition weakens the Kd to 4.0 microM, only 3.2 protons are released upon Zn(II) binding, the reaction is endothermic, with DeltaHrxn of +7.7 kcal mol-1, and entropy driven, with DeltaSrxn of +51 cal K-1 mol-1. Likely an intrinsic property of Zn(II)-(S.Cys)4 sites, the entropy driven binding of Zn(II) reflects the proton dependent chemical speciation of the Zn(II)-(S.Cys)4 peptide complex and its effects on modulating the dehydration of both the peptide and metal. Furthermore, the Zn(II) binding thermodynamics of a variety of Zn(II) proteins at pH 7.0 reveals the presence of enthalpy-entropy compensation (EEC) phenomena in nature.

Femtomolar Zn(II) affinity in a peptide-based ligand designed to model thiolate-rich metalloprotein active sites

Metal-ligand interactions are critical components of metalloprotein assembly, folding, stability, electrochemistry, and catalytic function. Research over the past 3 decades on the interaction of metals with peptide and protein ligands has progressed from the characterization of amino acid-metal and polypeptide-metal complexes to the design of folded protein scaffolds containing multiple metal cofactors. De novo metalloprotein design has emerged as a valuable tool both for the modular synthesis of these complex metalloproteins and for revealing the fundamental tenets of metalloprotein structure-function relationships. Our research has focused on using the coordination chemistry of de novo designed metalloproteins to probe the interactions of metal cofactors with protein ligands relevant to biological phenomena. Herein, we present a detailed thermodynamic analysis of Fe(II), Co(II), Zn(II), and[4Fe-4S]2(+/+) binding to IGA, a 16 amino acid peptide ligand containing four cysteine residues, H2N-KLCEGG-CIGCGAC-GGW-CONH2. These studies were conducted to delineate the inherent metal-ion preferences of this unfolded tetrathiolate peptide ligand as well as to evaluate the role of the solution pH on metal-peptide complex speciation. The [4Fe-4S]2(+/+)-IGA complex is both an excellent peptide-based synthetic analogue for natural ferredoxins and is flexible enough to accommodate mononuclear metal-ion binding. Incorporation of a single ferrous ion provides the FeII-IGA complex, a spectroscopic model of a reduced rubredoxin active site that possesses limited stability in aqueous buffers. As expected based on the Irving-Williams series and hard-soft acid-base theory, the Co(II) and Zn(II) complexes of IGA are significantly more stable than the Fe(II) complex. Direct proton competition experiments, coupled with determinations of the conditional dissociation constants over a range of pH values, fully define the thermodynamic stabilities and speciation of each MII-IGA complex. The data demonstrate that FeII-IGA and CoII-IGA have formation constant values of 5.0 x 10(8) and 4.2 x 10(11) M-1, which are highly attenuated at physiological pH values. The data also evince that the formation constant for ZnII-IGA is 8.0 x 10(15) M-1, a value that exceeds the tightest natural protein Zn(II)-binding affinities. The formation constant demonstrates that the metal-ligand binding energy of a ZnII(S-Cys)4 site can stabilize a metalloprotein by -21.6 kcal/mol. Rigorous thermodynamic analyses such as those demonstrated here are critical to current research efforts in metalloprotein design, metal-induced protein folding, and metal-ion trafficking.

Apolipoprotein A-I-mimetic peptides with antioxidant actions

To augment antioxidant action of apolipoprotein A-I (Apo A-I)-mimetic peptide, the peptide F3,6,14,18 18A (DWFKAFYDKVAEKFKEAF) was modified by incorporating antioxidant amino acid residues. Introduction of His residue at position 2 or 3 at N-terminal of the peptide remarkably enhanced antioxidant action against Cu2+ oxidation of LDL and the capability of sequestering Cu2+. Likewise, the substitution of Ala for Cys residue at position 12 increased antioxidant action against Cu2+ oxidation of LDL. Additionally, the Cys substitution contributed to enhanced capabilities in the removal of hypochlorous acid (HOCl) and 13-hydroperoxyoctadecadienoic acid. Furthermore, the combined incorporation of His and Cys residues enhanced antioxidant actions in preventing Cu2+ oxidation and reducing HOCl and hydroperoxide levels. Separately, in solubilizing phosphatidylcholine, either peptides with His residue at N-terminal position 2 or 3, or those containing Cys residue at position 11 or 12 were equipotent to peptide F3,6,14,18 18A. Further, the lipid-solubilizing ability of those containing both His and Cys residues was comparable to that of peptide F3,6,14,18 18A. In support of this, a similar structural importance was observed with Trp fluorescence study illustrating the penetration of peptides in phosphatidylcholine liposome. Besides, the modified peptides were also comparable to peptide F3,6,14,18 18A in restoring phosphatidylserine-induced loss of PON1 activity. These results indicate that the insertion of His or Cys residue into peptide F3,6,14,18 18A at appropriate positions could lead to enhanced antioxidant action with no significant change of lipid-solubilizing action.

Probing metal-protein interactions using a de novo design approach

De novo design of metalloproteins provides a valuable tool for understanding the structural constraints and functional attributes of natural biological systems using first principles. This review focuses on recent research aimed primarily at probing the subtle interactions between metals and proteins in designed systems. Considerable attention has focussed on redefining novel design methods used in mimicking natural hemeproteins, mononuclear and dinuclear metallopeptides and functional biological electron-transfer proteins. The present results indicate that the field of metalloprotein design is contributing significantly to the understanding of metals in biology.

Comparison of cysteine and penicillamine ligands in a Co(II) maquette

l-Penicillamine (Pen) has been investigated as a ligand for metalloprotein design by examining the binding of Co(II) to the sequence NH(2)-KL(Pen)EGG.(Pen)IG(Pen)GA(Pen).GGW-CONH(2). For comparison, we have studied Co(II) binding to the analogous sequence with Cys ligands, the ferredoxin maquette ligand IGA that was originally designed to bind a [4Fe-4S] cluster. The Co(II) affinity and UV-vis spectroscopic properties of IGA indicate formation of a pseudotetrahedral tetrathiolate ligated Co(II). In contrast, IGA-Pen showed formation of a pseudotetrahedral complex with Co(II) bound by three Pen ligands and an exogenous H(2)O. EXAFS data on both Co(II) complexes confirms not only the proposed primary coordination spheres but also shows six Co(II)-C(beta) methyl group distances in Co(II)-IGA-Pen. These results demonstrate that ligand sterics in simple peptides can be designed to provide asymmetric coordination spheres such as those commonly observed in natural metalloproteins.