Modification of the heme active site to increase the peroxidase activity of thermophilic cytochrome P450: A rational approach

Enhancing the thermostability of lignin peroxidase: Heme as a keystone cofactor driving stability changes in heme enzymes

Heme-containing enzymes, critical across life's domains and promising for industrial use, face stability challenges. Despite the demand for robust industrial biocatalysts, the mechanisms underlying the thermal stability of heme enzymes remain poorly understood. Addressing this, our research utilizes a 'keystone cofactor heme-interaction approach' to enhance ligand binding and improve the stability of lignin peroxidase (LiP). We engineered mutants of the white-rot fungus PcLiP (Phanerochaete chrysosporium) to increase thermal stability by 8.66 °C and extend half-life by 29 times without losing catalytic efficiency at 60 °C, where typically, wild-type enzymes degrade. Molecular dynamics simulations reveal that an interlocked cofactor moiety contributes to enhanced structural stability in LiP variants. Additionally, a stability index developed from these simulations accurately predicts stabilizing mutations in other PcLiP isozymes. Using milled wood lignin, these mutants achieved triple the conversion yields at 40 °C compared to the wild type, offering insights for more sustainable white biotechnology through improved enzyme stability.

Iron mobilization from intact ferritin: effect of differential redox activity of quinone derivatives with NADH/O2 and in situ-generated ROS

Ferritins are multimeric nanocage proteins that sequester/concentrate excess of free iron and catalytically synthesize a hydrated ferric oxyhydroxide bio-mineral. Besides functioning as the primary intracellular iron storehouses, these supramolecular assemblies also oversee the controlled release of iron to meet physiologic demands. By virtue of the reducing nature of the cytosol, reductive dissolution of ferritin-iron bio-mineral by physiologic reducing agents might be a probable pathway operating in vivo. Herein, to explore this reductive iron-release pathway, a series of quinone analogs differing in size, position/nature of substituents and redox potentials were employed to relay electrons from physiologic reducing agent, NADH, to the ferritin core. Quinones are well known natural electron/proton mediators capable of facilitating both 1/2 electron transfer processes and have been implicated in iron/nutrient acquisition in plants and energy transduction. Our findings on the structure-reactivity of quinone mediators highlight that iron release from ferritin is dictated by electron-relay capability (dependent on E1/2 values) of quinones, their molecular structure (i.e., the presence of iron-chelation sites and the propensity for H-bonding) and the type/amount of reactive oxygen species (ROS) they generate in situ. Juglone/Plumbagin released maximum iron due to their intermediate E1/2 values, presence of iron chelation sites, the ability to inhibit in situ generation of H2O2 and form intramolecular H-bonding (possibly promotes semiquinone formation). This study may strengthen our understanding of the ferritin-iron-release process and their significance in bioenergetics/O2-based cellular metabolism/toxicity while providing insights on microbial/plant iron acquisition and the dynamic host-pathogen interactions.

Designing cytochrome P450 enzymes for use in cancer gene therapy

Cancer is a significant global socioeconomic burden, as millions of new cases and deaths occur annually. In 2020, almost 10 million cancer deaths were recorded worldwide. Advancements in cancer gene therapy have revolutionized the landscape of cancer treatment. An approach with promising potential for cancer gene therapy is introducing genes to cancer cells that encode for chemotherapy prodrug metabolizing enzymes, such as Cytochrome P450 (CYP) enzymes, which can contribute to the effective elimination of cancer cells. This can be achieved through gene-directed enzyme prodrug therapy (GDEPT). CYP enzymes can be genetically engineered to improve anticancer prodrug conversion to its active metabolites and to minimize chemotherapy side effects by reducing the prodrug dosage. Rational design, directed evolution, and phylogenetic methods are some approaches to developing tailored CYP enzymes for cancer therapy. Here, we provide a compilation of genetic modifications performed on CYP enzymes aiming to build highly efficient therapeutic genes capable of bio-activating different chemotherapeutic prodrugs. Additionally, this review summarizes promising preclinical and clinical trials highlighting engineered CYP enzymes' potential in GDEPT. Finally, the challenges, limitations, and future directions of using CYP enzymes for GDEPT in cancer gene therapy are discussed.

Emerging Strategies for Modifying Cytochrome P450 Monooxygenases into Peroxizymes

ConspectusCytochrome P450 monooxygenase is a versatile oxidizing enzyme with great potential in synthetic chemistry and biology. However, the dependence of its catalytic function on the nicotinamide cofactor NAD(P)H and redox partner proteins limits the practical catalytic application of P450 in vitro. An alternative to expensive cofactors is low-cost H2O2, which can be used directly to exploit the catalytic potential of P450s. However, the peroxide shunt pathway is generally inefficient at driving P450 catalysis compared to normal NAD(P)H-dependent activity. Over the last few decades, the scientific community has made continuous efforts to use directed evolution or site-directed mutagenesis to modify P450 monooxygenases into their peroxizyme modes─peroxygenase and peroxidase. Despite significant progress, obtaining efficient P450 peroxizymes remains a huge challenge. Here, we summarize our efforts to modulate peroxizyme activity in P450 monooxygenases and exploit their catalytic applications in challenging selective C-H oxidation, oxygenation, and oxyfunctionalization over the past seven years. We first developed a dual-functional small molecule (DFSM) strategy for transforming P450BM3 monooxygenase into peroxygenase. In this strategy, the typical DFSM, such as N-(ω-imidazolyl)-hexanoyl-l-phenylalanine (Im-C6-Phe), binds to the P450BM3 protein with an anchoring group at one end and plays a general acid-base catalytic role in the activation of H2O2 with an imidazolyl group at the other end. Compared with the O-O homolysis mechanism in the absence of DFSM, the addition of DFSM efficiently enables the heterolytic O-O cleavage of the adduct Fe-O-OH, thus being favored for the formation of active species compound I, which has been demonstrated by combining crystallographic and theoretical calculations. Furthermore, protein engineering showed the unique catalytic performance of DFSM-facilitated P450 peroxygenase for the highly difficult selective oxidation of C-H bonds. This catalytic performance was demonstrated during the chemoselective hydroxylation of gaseous alkanes, regioselective O-demethylation of aryl ethers, highly (R)-enantioselective epoxidation of styrene, and regio- and enantiomerically diverse hydroxylation of alkylbenzenes. Second, we demonstrated that DFSM-facilitated P450BM3 peroxygenase could be effectively switched to an efficient peroxidase mode through mechanism-guided protein engineering of redox-sensitive residues. Utilizing the peroxidase function of P450 enabled the direct nitration of unsaturated hydrocarbons including phenols, aromatic amines, and styrene derivatives, which was not only the P450-catalyzed direct nitration of phenols and aromatic amines for the first time but also the first example of the direct biological nitration of olefins. Finally, we report an H2O2 tunnel engineering strategy to enable peroxygenase activity in several different P450 monooxygenases for the first time, providing a general approach for accessing engineered P450 peroxygenases. In this Account, we highlight the emerging strategies we have developed for producing practical P450 peroxizyme biocatalysts. Although the DFSM strategy is primarily applied to P450BM3 to date, both strategies of redox-sensitive residue engineering and H2O2 tunnel engineering show great potential to extend to other P450s. These strategies have expanded the scope of applications of P450 chemistry and catalysis. Additionally, they provide a unique solution to the challenging selective oxidation of inert C-H bonds in synthetic chemistry.

Engineering Cytochrome P450BM3 Enzymes for Direct Nitration of Unsaturated Hydrocarbons

Applications of the peroxidase activity of cytochrome P450 enzymes in synthetic chemistry remain largely unexplored. We present herein a protein engineering strategy to increase cytochrome P450BM3 peroxidase activity for the direct nitration of aromatic compounds and terminal aryl-substituted olefins in the presence of a dual-functional small molecule (DFSM). Site-directed mutations of key active-site residues allowed the efficient regulation of steric effects to limit substrate access and, thus, a significant decrease in monooxygenation activity and increase in peroxidase activity. Nitration of several phenol and aniline compounds also yielded ortho- and para-nitration products with moderate-to-high total turnover numbers. Besides direct aromatic nitration by P450 variants using nitrite as a nitrating agent, we also demonstrated the use of the DFSM-facilitated P450 peroxidase system for the nitration of the vinyl group of styrene and its derivatives.

Enabling Peroxygenase Activity in Cytochrome P450 Monooxygenases by Engineering Hydrogen Peroxide Tunnels

Given prominent physicochemical similarities between H₂O₂ and water, we report a new strategy for promoting the peroxygenase activity of P450 enzymes by engineering their water tunnels to facilitate H₂O₂ access to the heme center buried therein. Specifically, the H₂O₂-driven activities of two native NADH-dependent P450 enzymes (CYP199A4 and CYP153A_M.aq) increase significantly (by >183-fold and >15-fold, respectively). Additionally, the amount of H₂O₂ required for an artificial P450 peroxygenase facilitated by a dual-functional small molecule to obtain the desired product is reduced by 95%-97.5% (with ∼95% coupling efficiency). Structural analysis suggests that mutating the residue at the bottleneck of the water tunnel may open a second pathway for H₂O₂ to flow to the heme center (in addition to the natural substrate tunnel). This study highlights a promising, generalizable strategy whereby P450 monooxygenases can be modified to adopt peroxygenase activity through H₂O₂ tunnel engineering, thus broadening the application scope of P450s in synthetic chemistry and synthetic biology.

Enhanced Substrate Specificity of Thermostable Cytochrome P450 CYP175A1 by Site Saturation Mutation on Tyrosine 68

Thermostable cytochrome P450 (CYP175A1) cloned from Thermus thermophilus shows mid-point unfolding temperature (Tm) of 88 °C (361 K) along with high thermodynamic stability making it a potential industrially viable biocatalyst. Molecular docking analyses, and structural superposition with steroidogenic and fatty acid metabolizing cytochrome P450 s suggested that the tyrosine 68 may have important role in binding as well as metabolism of substrates by the enzyme. Site-saturation mutation of the tyrosine 68 residue was carried out and several unique mutations were obtained that were properly folded and showed high thermostability. We investigated the effects of variation of the single residue, Tyr68 at the substrate binding pocket of the enzyme on the substrate specificity of CYP175A1. Screening of the mutant colonies of CYP175A1 obtained after saturation mutagenesis of Tyr68 using saturated fatty acid, myristic acid and poly unsaturated fatty acids showed that the Y68K had notable binding and catalytic activity for mono-oxygenation of the saturated fatty acid (myristic acid), which had no major detectable binding affinity towards the WT enzyme. The Y68R mutant of CYP175A1, on the other hand was found to selectively bind and catalyse reaction of cholesterol. The wild type as well as both the mutants of the enzyme however bind poly unsaturated fatty acids. The results thus show that saturation mutation of a single amino acid at the substrate binding pocket of the thermostable cytochrome P450 could induce sufficient changes in the substrate binding pocket of the enzyme that can efficiently change substrate specificity of the enzyme.

A Unique P450 Peroxygenase System Facilitated by a Dual-Functional Small Molecule: Concept, Application, and Perspective

Cytochrome P450 monooxygenases (P450s) are promising versatile oxidative biocatalysts. However, the practical use of P450s in vitro is limited by their dependence on the co-enzyme NAD(P)H and the complex electron transport system. Using H₂O₂ simplifies the catalytic cycle of P450s; however, most P450s are inactive in the presence of H₂O₂. By mimicking the molecular structure and catalytic mechanism of natural peroxygenases and peroxidases, an artificial P450 peroxygenase system has been designed with the assistance of a dual-functional small molecule (DFSM). DFSMs, such as N-(ω-imidazolyl fatty acyl)-l-amino acids, use an acyl amino acid as an anchoring group to bind the enzyme, and the imidazolyl group at the other end functions as a general acid-base catalyst in the activation of H₂O₂. In combination with protein engineering, the DFSM-facilitated P450 peroxygenase system has been used in various oxidation reactions of non-native substrates, such as alkene epoxidation, thioanisole sulfoxidation, and alkanes and aromatic hydroxylation, which showed unique activities and selectivity. Moreover, the DFSM-facilitated P450 peroxygenase system can switch to the peroxidase mode by mechanism-guided protein engineering. In this short review, the design, mechanism, evolution, application, and perspective of these novel non-natural P450 peroxygenases for the oxidation of non-native substrates are discussed.

Alteration of Coaxial Heme Ligands Reveals the Role of Heme in Bacterioferritin from Mycobacterium tuberculosis

The uptake and utilization of iron remains critical for the survival/virulence of the host/pathogens in spite of the limitations (low bioavailability/high toxicity) associated with this nutrient. Both the host and pathogens manage to overcome these problems by utilizing the iron repository protein nanocages, ferritins, which not only sequester and detoxify the free Fe(II) ions but also decrease the iron solubility gap by synthesizing/encapsulating the Fe(III)-oxyhydroxide biomineral in its central hollow nanocavity. Bacterial pathogens including Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), the causative agent of tuberculosis, encode a distinct subclass of ferritins called bacterioferritin (BfrA), which binds heme, the versatile redox cofactor, via coaxial, conserved methionine (M52) residues at its subunit-dimer interfaces. However, the exact role of heme in Mtb BfrA remains yet to be established. Therefore, its coaxial ligands were altered via site-directed mutagenesis, which resulted in both heme-bound (M52C; ∼1 heme per cage) and heme-free (M52H and M52L) variants, indicating the importance of M52 residues as preferential heme binding axial ligands in Mtb BfrA. All these variants formed intact nanocages of similar size and iron-loading ability as that of wild-type (WT) Mtb BfrA. However, the as-isolated heme-bound variants (WT and M52C) exhibited enhanced protein stability and reductive iron mobilization as compared to their heme-free analogues (M52H and M52L). Further, increasing the heme content in BfrA variants by reconstitution not only enhanced the cage stability but also facilitated the iron mobilization, suggesting the role of heme. In contrary, heme altered the ferroxidase activity to a lesser extent despite facilitating the accumulation of the reactive intermediates formed during the course of the reaction. The current study suggests that heme in Mtb BfrA enhances the overall stability of the protein and possibly acts as an intrinsic electron relay station to influence the iron mineral dissolution and thus may be associated with Mtb's pathogenicity.

Functional characterization of a novel CYP119 variant to explore its biocatalytic potential

Biocatalysts are increasingly applied in the pharmaceutical and chemical industry. Cytochrome P450 enzymes (P450s) are valuable biocatalysts due to their ability to hydroxylate unactivated carbon atoms using molecular oxygen. P450s catalyze reactions using nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NAD(P)H) cofactor and electron transfer proteins. Alternatively, P450s can utilize hydrogen peroxide (H₂ O₂ ) as an oxidant, but this pathway is inefficient. P450s that show higher efficiency with peroxides are sought after in industrial applications. P450s from thermophilic organisms have more potential applications as they are stable toward high temperature, high and low pH, and organic solvents. CYP119 is an acidothermophilic P450 from Sulfolobus acidocaldarius. In our previous study, a novel T213R/T214I (double mutant [DM]) variant of CYP119 was obtained by screening a mutant library for higher peroxidation activity utilizing H₂ O₂ . Here, we characterized the substrate scope; stability toward peroxides; and temperature and organic solvent tolerance of DM CYP119 to identify its potential as an industrial biocatalyst. DM CYP119 displayed higher stability than wild-type (WT) CYP119 toward organic peroxides. It shows higher peroxidation activity for non-natural substrates and higher affinity for progesterone and other bioactive potential substrates compared to WT CYP119. DM CYP119 emerges as a new biocatalyst with a wide range of potential applications in the pharmaceutical and chemical industry.

Strategies for Substrate-Regulated P450 Catalysis: From Substrate Engineering to Co-catalysis

Cytochrome P450 enzymes (P450s) catalyze the monooxygenation of various organic substrates. These enzymes are fascinating and promising biocatalysts for synthetic applications. Despite the impressive abilities of P450s in the oxidation of C-H bonds, their practical applications are restricted by intrinsic drawbacks, such as poor stability, low turnover rates, the need for expensive cofactors (e.g., NAD(P)H), and the narrow scope of useful non-native substrates. These issues may be overcome through the general strategy of protein engineering, which focuses on the improvement of the catalysts themselves. Alternatively, several emerging strategies have been developed that regulate the P450 catalytic process from the viewpoint of the substrate. These strategies include substrate engineering, decoy molecule, and dual-functional small-molecule co-catalysis. Substrate engineering focuses on improving the substrate acceptance and reaction selectivity by means of an anchoring group. The latter two strategies utilize co-substrate-like small molecules that either are proposed to reform the active site, thereby switching the substrate specificity, or directly participate in the catalytic process, thereby creating new catalytic peroxygenation capabilities towards non-native substrates. For at least 10 years, these approaches have played unique roles in solving the problems highlighted above, either alone or in conjunction with protein engineering. Herein, we review three strategies for substrate regulation in the P450-catalyzed oxidation of non-native substrates. Furthermore, we address remaining challenges and potential solutions associated with these approaches.

Phenothiazines and phenoxazines: as electron transfer mediators for ferritin iron release

Redox active phenothiazine and phenoxazine dyes facilitate ferritin iron release by acting as electron transfer (ET) mediators following Marcus theory.

Effects of Alternative Redox Partners and Oxidizing Agents on CYP154C8 Catalytic Activity and Product Distribution

CYP154C8 catalyzes the hydroxylation of diverse steroids, as has previously been demonstrated, by using an NADH-dependent system including putidaredoxin and putidaredoxin reductase as redox partner proteins carrying electrons from NADH. In other reactions, CYP154C8 reconstituted with spinach ferredoxin and NADPH-dependent ferredoxin reductase displayed catalytic activity different from that of the NADH-dependent system. The NADPH-dependent system showed multistep oxidation of progesterone and other substrates including androstenedione, testosterone, and nandrolone. (Diacetoxyiodo)benzene was employed to generate compound I (FeO³⁺ ), actively supporting the redox reactions catalyzed by CYP154C8. In addition to 16α-hydroxylation, progesterone and 11-oxoprogesterone also underwent hydroxylation at the 6β-position in reactions supported by (diacetoxyiodo)benzene. CYP154C8 was active in the presence of high concentrations (>10 mm) of H₂ O₂ , with optimum conversion surprisingly being achieved at ≈75 mm H₂ O₂ . More importantly, H₂ O₂ tolerance by CYP154C8 was evident in the very low heme oxidation rate constant (K) even at high concentrations of H₂ O₂ . Our results demonstrate that alternative redox partners and oxidizing agents influence the catalytic efficiency and product distribution of a cytochrome P450 enzyme. More importantly, these choices affected the type and selectivity of reaction catalyzed by the P450 enzyme.

Selective hydroxylation of naphthalene using the H2O2-dependent engineered P450BM3 driven by dual-functional small molecules

We herein report the H2O2-dependent selective hydroxylation of naphthalene catalyzed by engineered P450BM3 with the assistance of dual-functional small molecules (DFSMs). The mutation at position 268 significantly improved the hydroxylation activity of P450BM3, which is quite different from those engineered P450BM3 peroxygenases and NADPH-dependent P450BM3 mutants previously reported, implicating the unique role of the residue at position 268. This study provides a potential approach to develop the practical hydroxylation biocatalyst of P450s for aromatic hydrocarbons using the DFSM-facilitated P450BM3-H2O2 system.

Dual-Functional Small Molecules for Generating an Efficient Cytochrome P450BM3 Peroxygenase

We report a unique strategy for the development of a H₂ O₂ -dependent cytochrome P450BM3 system, which catalyzes the monooxygenation of non-native substrates with the assistance of dual-functional small molecules (DFSMs), such as N-(ω-imidazolyl fatty acyl)-l-amino acids. The acyl amino acid group of DFSM is responsible for bounding to enzyme as an anchoring group, while the imidazolyl group plays the role of general acid-base catalyst in the activation of H₂ O₂ . This system affords the best peroxygenase activity for the epoxidation of styrene, sulfoxidation of thioanisole, and hydroxylation of ethylbenzene among those P450-H₂ O₂ system previously reported. This work provides the first example of the activation of the normally H₂ O₂ -inert P450s through the introduction of an exogenous small molecule. This approach improves the potential use of P450s in organic synthesis as it avoids the expensive consumption of the reduced nicotinamide cofactor NAD(P)H and its dependent electron transport system. This introduces a promising approach for exploiting enzyme activity and function based on direct chemical intervention in the catalytic process.

Determinants of thermostability in the cytochrome P450 fold

Cytochromes P450 are found throughout the biosphere in a wide range of environments, serving a multitude of physiological functions. The ubiquity of the P450 fold suggests that it has been co-opted by evolution many times, and likely presents a useful compromise between structural stability and conformational flexibility. The diversity of substrates metabolized and reactions catalyzed by P450s makes them attractive starting materials for use as biocatalysts of commercially useful reactions. However, process conditions impose different requirements on enzymes to those in which they have evolved naturally. Most natural environments are relatively mild, and therefore most P450s have not been selected in Nature for the ability to withstand temperatures above ~40°C, yet industrial processes frequently require extended incubations at much higher temperatures. Thus, there has been considerable interest and effort invested in finding or engineering thermostable P450 systems. Numerous P450s have now been identified in thermophilic organisms and analysis of their structures provides information as to mechanisms by which the P450 fold can be stabilized. In addition, protein engineering, particularly by directed or artificial evolution, has revealed mutations that serve to stabilize particular mesophilic enzymes of interest. Here we review the current understanding of thermostability as it applies to the P450 fold, gleaned from the analysis of P450s characterized from thermophilic organisms and the parallel engineering of mesophilic forms for greater thermostability. We then present a perspective on how this information might be used to design stable P450 enzymes for industrial application. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Cytochrome P450 biodiversity and biotechnology, edited by Erika Plettner, Gianfranco Gilardi, Luet Wong, Vlada Urlacher, Jared Goldstone.

Determination of hemin-binding characteristics of proteins by a combinatorial peptide library approach

Studies of the binding of heme/hemin to proteins or peptides have recently intensified as it became evident that heme serves not only as a prosthetic group, but also as a regulator and effector molecule interacting with transmembrane and cytoplasmic proteins. The iron-ion-containing heme group can associate with these proteins in different ways, with the amino acids Cys, His, and Tyr allowing individual modes of binding. Strong coordinate-covalent binding, such as in cytochrome c, is known, and reversible attachment is also discussed. Ligands for both types of binding have been reported independently, though sometimes with different affinities for similar sequences. We applied a combinatorial approach using the library (X)(4) (C/H/Y)(X)(4) to characterize peptide ligands with considerable hemin binding capacities. Some of the library-selected peptides were comparable in terms of hemin association independently of whether or not a cysteine residue was present in the sequence. Indeed, a preference for His-based (≈39 %) and Tyr-based (≈40 %) sequences over Cys-based ones (≈21 %) was detected. The binding affinities for the library-selected peptides, as determined by UV/Vis spectroscopy, were in the nanomolar range. Moreover, selected representatives efficiently competed for hemin binding with the human BK channel hSlo1, which is known to be regulated by heme through binding to its heme-binding domain.

Conjugation of cytochrome c with hydrogen titanate nanotubes: novel conformational state with implications for apoptosis

We show that hydrogen titanate (H(2)Ti(3)O(7)) nanotubes form strongly associated reversible nano-bio-conjugates with the vital respiratory protein, cytochrome c. Resonance Raman spectroscopy along with direct electrochemical studies indicate that in this nano-bio-conjugate, cytochrome c exists in an equilibrium of two conformational states with distinctly different formal redox potentials and coordination geometries of the heme center. The nanotube-conjugated cytochrome c also showed enhanced peroxidase activity similar to the membrane-bound protein that is believed to be an apoptosis initiator. This suggests that such a nanotube-cytochrome c conjugate may be a good candidate for cancer therapy applications.