How a decreased fibrillar interconnectivity influences stiffness and swelling properties during early cartilage degeneration

Towards a load bearing hydrogel: A proof of principle in the use of osmotic pressure for biomimetic cartilage constructs

Cartilage defects occur frequently and can lead to osteoarthritis. Hydrogels are a promising regenerative strategy for treating such defects, using their ability of mimicking the native extracellular matrix. However, commonly used hydrogels for tissue regeneration are too soft to resist load-bearing in the joint. To overcome this, an implant is being developed in which the mechanical loadbearing function originates from the osmotic pressure generated by the swelling potential of a charged hydrogel, which is restricted from swelling by a textile spacer fabric. This study aims to quantify the relationship between the swelling potential of the hydrogel and the compressive stiffness of the implant.

The role of bone mineral density and cartilage volume to predict knee cartilage degeneration

Knee Osteoarthritis (OA) is a highly prevalent condition affecting knee joint that causes loss of physical function and pain. Clinical treatments are mainly focused on pain relief and limitation of disabilities; therefore, it is crucial to find new paradigms assessing cartilage conditions for detecting and monitoring the progression of OA. The goal of this paper is to highlight the predictive power of several features, such as cartilage density, volume and surface. These features were extracted from the 3D reconstruction of knee joint of forty-seven different patients, subdivided into two categories: degenerative and non-degenerative. The most influent parameters for the degeneration of the knee cartilage were determined using two machine learning classification algorithms (logistic regression and support vector machine); later, box plots, which depicted differences between the classes by gender, were presented to analyze several of the key features’ trend. This work is part of a strategy that aims to find a new solution to assess cartilage condition based on new-investigated features.

Direct Ink Write Printing of Chitin-Based Gel Fibers with Customizable Fibril Alignment, Porosity, and Mechanical Properties for Biomedical Applications

A fine control over different dimensional scales is a challenging target for material science since it could grant control over many properties of the final material. In this study, we developed a multivariable additive manufacturing process, direct ink write printing, to control different architectural features from the nano- to the millimeter scale during extrusion. Chitin-based gel fibers with a water content of around 1500% were obtained extruding a polymeric solution of chitin into a counter solvent, water, inducing instant solidification of the material. A certain degree of fibrillar alignment was achieved basing on the shear stress induced by the nozzle. In this study we took into account a single variable, the nozzle's internal diameter (NID). In fact, a positive correlation between NID, fibril alignment, and mechanical resistance was observed. A negative correlation with NID was observed with porosity, exposed surface, and lightly with water content. No correlation was observed with maximum elongation (~50%), and the scaffold's excellent biocompatibility, which appeared unaltered. Overall, a single variable allowed a customization of different material features, which could be further tuned, adding control over other aspects of the synthetic process. Moreover, this manufacturing could be potentially applied to any polymer.

Subchondral bone plate thickness is associated with micromechanical and microstructural changes in the bovine patella osteochondral junction with different levels of cartilage degeneration

The influence of joint degeneration on the biomechanical properties of calcified cartilage and subchondral bone plate at the osteochondral junction is relatively unknown. Common experimental difficulties include accessibility to and visualization of the osteochondral junction, application of mechanical testing at the appropriate length scale, and availability of tissue that provides a consistent range of degenerative changes. This study addresses these challenges. A well-established bovine patella model of early joint degeneration was employed, in which micromechanical testing of fully hydrated osteochondral sections was carried out in conjunction with high-resolution imaging using differential interference contrast (DIC) optical light microscopy. A total of forty-two bovine patellae with different grades of tissue health ranging from healthy to mild, moderate, and severe cartilage degeneration, were selected. From the distal-lateral region of each patella, two adjacent osteochondral sections were obtained for the mechanical testing and the DIC imaging, respectively. Mechanical testing was carried out using a robotic micro-force acquisition system, applying compression tests over an array (area: 200 μm × 1000 μm, step size: 50 μm) across the osteochondral junction to obtain a stiffness map. Morphometric analysis was performed for the DIC images of fully hydrated cryo-sections. The levels of cartilage degeneration, DIC images, and the stiffness maps were used to associate the mechanical properties onto the specific tissue regions of cartilage, calcified cartilage, and subchondral bone plate. The results showed that there were up to 20% and 24% decreases (p < 0.05) in the stiffness of calcified cartilage and subchondral bone plate, respectively, in the severely degenerated group compared to the healthy group. Furthermore, there were increases (p < 0.05) in the number of tidemarks, bone spicules at the cement line, and the mean thickness of the subchondral bone plate with increasing levels of degeneration. The decreasing stiffness in the subchondral bone plate coupled with the presence of bone spicules may be indicative of a subchondral remodeling process involving new bone formation. Moreover, the mean thickness of the subchondral bone plate was found to be the strongest indicator of mechanical and associated structural changes in the osteochondral joint tissues.

CT- and MRI-Based 3D Reconstruction of Knee Joint to Assess Cartilage and Bone

For the observation of human joint cartilage, X-ray, computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) are the main diagnostic tools to evaluate pathologies or traumas. The current work introduces a set of novel measurements and 3D features based on MRI and CT data of the knee joint, used to reconstruct bone and cartilages and to assess cartilage condition from a new perspective. Forty-seven subjects presenting a degenerative disease, a traumatic injury or no symptoms or trauma were recruited in this study and scanned using CT and MRI. Using medical imaging software, the bone and cartilage of the knee joint were segmented and 3D reconstructed. Several features such as cartilage density, volume and surface were extracted. Moreover, an investigation was carried out on the distribution of cartilage thickness and curvature analysis to identify new markers of cartilage condition. All the extracted features were used with advanced statistics tools and machine learning to test the ability of our model to predict cartilage conditions. This work is a first step towards the development of a new gold standard of cartilage assessment based on 3D measurements.

The ultrastructure of cartilage tissue and its swelling response in relation to matrix health

This multi-length scale anatomical study explores the influence of mild cartilage structural degeneration on the tissue swelling response. While the swelling response of cartilage has been studied extensively, this is the first study to reveal and correlate tissue microstructure and ultrastructure, with the swelling induced cartilage tissue strains. Cartilage sample strips (n = 30) were obtained from the distal-lateral quadrant of thirty mildly degenerate bovine patellae and, following excision from the bone, the cartilage strips were allowed to swell freely for 2 h in solutions of physiological saline and distilled water successively. The swelling response of this group of samples were compared with that of healthy cartilage, with (n = 20) and without the surface layer (n = 20). The subsequent curling response of cartilage showed that in healthy tissue it was highly variable, and with the surface removed some samples curved in the opposite direction, while in the mildly degenerate tissue group, virtually all tissue strips curved in a consistent upward manner. A significant difference in strain was observed between healthy samples with surface layer removed and mildly degenerate samples, illustrating how excision of the surface zone from pristine cartilage is insufficient to model the swelling response of tissue which has undergone natural degenerative changes. On average, total tissue thickness increased from 940 µm (healthy) to 1079 µm (mildly degenerate), however, looking at the zonal strata, surface and transition zone thicknesses both decreased while deep zone thickness increased from healthy to mildly degenerate tissue. Morphologically, changes to the surface zone integrity were correlated with a diminished surface layer which, at the ultrastructural scale, correlated with a decreased fibrillar density. Similarly, fibrosity of the general matrix visible at the microscale was associated with a loss of later interconnectivity resulting in large, aggregated fibril bundles. The microstructural and ultrastructural investigation revealed that the key differences influencing the tissue swelling strain response was (1) the thickness and extent of disruption to the surface layer and (2) the amount of fibrillar network destructuring, highlighting the importance of the collagen and tissue matrix structure in restraining cartilage swelling.

An ex vivo human osteochondral culture model

To reduce animal experimentation and to overcome translational issues in cartilage tissue engineering, there is a need to develop an ex vivo human tissue-based approach. This study aims to demonstrate that a human osteochondral explant at different stages of osteoarthritis (OA) can be kept in long-term culture while preserving its viability and composition. Osteochondral explants with either a smooth or fibrillated cartilage surface, representing different OA stages, were harvested from fresh human tibial plateaus. Explants were cultured for 2 or 4 weeks in a double-chamber culture platform. The biochemical content of the cartilage of cultured explants did not significantly change over a period of 4 weeks and these findings were supported by histology. Chondrocytes mostly preserved their metabolic activity during culture and active bone and marrow were found in the periphery of the explants, while metabolic activity was decreased in the bone core in cultured explants compared to fresh explants. In fibrillated explants, chondrocyte viability decreased in the periphery of the sample in cultured groups compared to fresh explants (fresh, 94 ± 6%; cultured, 64% ± 17%, 2 weeks, and 69% ± 17%, 4 weeks; P < .05). Although biochemical and histological results did not show changes within the cartilage tissue, the viability of the explants should be carefully controlled for each specific use. This system provides an alternative to explore drug treatment and implant performance under more controlled experimental conditions than possible in vivo, in combination with clinically relevant human osteochondral tissue.

Perlecan in Pericellular Mechanosensory Cell-Matrix Communication, Extracellular Matrix Stabilisation and Mechanoregulation of Load-Bearing Connective Tissues

In this study, we review mechanoregulatory roles for perlecan in load-bearing connective tissues. Perlecan facilitates the co-acervation of tropoelastin and assembly of elastic microfibrils in translamellar cross-bridges which, together with fibrillin and elastin stabilise the extracellular matrix of the intervertebral disc annulus fibrosus. Pericellular perlecan interacts with collagen VI and XI to define and stabilize this matrix compartment which has a strategic position facilitating two-way cell-matrix communication between the cell and its wider extracellular matrix. Cues from the extracellular matrix are fed through this pericellular matrix back to the chondrocyte, allowing it to perceive and respond to subtle microenvironmental changes to regulate tissue homeostasis. Thus perlecan plays a key regulatory role in chondrocyte metabolism, and in chondrocyte differentiation. Perlecan acts as a transport proteoglycan carrying poorly soluble, lipid-modified proteins such as the Wnt or Hedgehog families facilitating the establishment of morphogen gradients that drive tissue morphogenesis. Cell surface perlecan on endothelial cells or osteocytes acts as a flow sensor in blood and the lacunar canalicular fluid providing feedback cues to smooth muscle cells regulating vascular tone and blood pressure, and the regulation of bone metabolism by osteocytes highlighting perlecan's multifaceted roles in load-bearing connective tissues.

The mechanical significance of the zonally differentiated collagen network of articular cartilage in relation to tissue swelling

BACKGROUND

We hypothesise that the Benninghoff arcade fibril structure motif of cartilage is able to predict the swelling response of cartilage.

METHODS

A total of ten healthy adult bovine patellae were used for this study, yielding 20 paired full depth cartilage samples (half with surface layer intact and half with surface layer removed). Following excision from the bone, samples were allowed to equilibrate first in physiological saline for 2 h, and then in distilled water for another 2 h to maximise the swelling response. Images were captured using a stereomicroscope to measure strain and the fully-swollen samples were fixed in 10% formalin to retain shape for microscopic and ultrastructural imaging.

FINDINGS

We expected all swelling samples with an intact 'strain-limiting' surface layer to curl upwards, instead only 70% of them did. For samples without a surface layer, we expected the swelling to be evenly distributed and to remain relatively uncurled; but in 40% of the samples there was a downward curvature (i.e. opposite to that of the previous group). Micro-to-ultrastructural imaging, to determine fibrillar structure and organisation, revealed the deep zone cartilage was an additional counter layer limiting swelling strain, and was the likely cause of the unexpected swelling responses.

INTERPRETATION

Our expectations that the surface layer alone will influence the swelling response, was based on the assumptions of the Benninghoff arcade model. This study highlights the additional importance of sub-micron scale fibrillar interconnectivity and the role of the deep zone.

The performance of resurfacing implants for focal cartilage defects depends on the degenerative condition of the opposing cartilage

BACKGROUND

Non-degradable resurfacing implants are being developed for treatment of focal cartilage defects. Performance of these implants has been investigated opposing intact cartilage. This study investigates whether implants would perform equally well when the opposing cartilage is fibrillated.

METHODS

Human osteochondral strips (~2x1x1 cm) with a smooth (n = 9) or fibrillated (n = 17) cartilage surface were obtained from human tibial plateaus excised during total knee arthroscopy. A custom-made pin-on-plate sliding indenter was used to apply simultaneous compression (0.75-3 MPa) and movement (4 mm/s over 6 mm). Either metal implants, polycarbonate-urethane or healthy porcine osteochondral plugs with a diameter of 6 mm were used as indenter.

FINDINGS

Cartilage roughness of the osteochondral strips was significantly higher for the fibrillated than the smooth group prior to sliding-indentation. Roughness of the indenters was not significantly altered by sliding indentation using either smooth or fibrillated cartilage. For all but one sample, sliding of smooth cartilage against any of the indenter surfaces did not cause damage. However, samples with fibrillated cartilage showed varied responses from seemingly unaffected to severe tissue wear as quantified by analysis of Indian ink staining and histology.

INTERPRETATION

This study demonstrates that the opposing cartilage quality is relevant for the clinical success of implanting an artificial implant in a focal cartilage defect. Therefore it is essential to test the efficacy of newly developed implants against arthritic joint surfaces, and care should be taken when interpreting in vivo studies in which implants are inserted in healthy joints.

Macroscopically healthy articular cartilage with fibrillar-scale early tissue degeneration subject to impact loading results in greater extent of cell-death

From previous investigations it has been shown that there exists healthy-appearing articular cartilage that contains collagen fibril network destructuring. It is hypothesised that such sub-micron scale destructuring not only presents an increased vulnerability to tissue scale damage following impact loading, but an increase in cell death as well. Cartilage-on-bone blocks from 12 patellae, six healthy (G0) and the other six with sub-micron fibrillar destructuring (G1), were obtained and subject to 2.3 J impact loading. Two sets of sub-samples were obtained for each block tested. One set was used to examine for the live/dead cell response using calcein-AM and propidium iodide staining, imaged with confocal microscopy. The tissue microstructural matrix was imaged from the other matched set, unstained and in its fully hydrated state, using differential interference contrast optical light microscopy. High speed imaging of the impact was used to calculate the velocity changes or coefficient of restitution (COR) and used as a proxy of energy that the tissue absorbed. A previously defined tissue matrix damage score was used to quantify the extent of fracturing and cracking in the matrix. The cell death (PCD) was counted and presented as a percentage against all cells live plus dead. The energy absorbed was 36.5% higher in G1 than in G0 (p = 0.034). However, the damage score and PCD of samples in the G1 group was much larger than the G0 group, ~300% and 161% respectively. Microscopy showed that cell death is associated to both matrix compaction and further fibrillar destructuring from the ECM to the territorial matrix regions of the chondron. Following impact loading, cartilage tissue that appears normal but contains sub-micron fibrillar matrix destructuring responds with significantly increased cell death.

Assessment and prevention of cartilage degeneration surrounding a focal chondral defect in the porcine model

Focal defects in articular cartilage are unable to self-repair and, if left untreated, are a leading risk factor for osteoarthritis. This study examined cartilage degeneration surrounding a defect and then assessed whether infilling the defect prevents degeneration. We created a focal chondral defect in porcine osteochondral explants and cultured them ex vivo with and without dynamic compressive loading to decouple the role of loading. When compared to a defect in a porcine knee four weeks post-injury, this model captured loss in sulfated glycosaminoglycans (sGAGs) along the defect's edge that was observed in vivo, but this loss was not load dependent. Loading, however, reduced the indentation modulus of the surrounding cartilage. After infilling with in situ polymerized hydrogels that were soft (100 kPa) or stiff (1 MPa) and which produced swelling pressures of 13 and 310 kPa, respectively, sGAG loss was reduced. This reduction correlated with increased hydrogel stiffness and swelling pressure, but was not affected by loading. This ex vivo model recapitulates sGAG loss surrounding a defect and, when infilled with a mechanically supportive hydrogel, degeneration is minimized.

Matrix degradation in osteoarthritis primes the superficial region of cartilage for mechanical damage

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a degenerative disease that affects 25% of the world's population over fifty years of age. It is a chronic disease of the synovial joints, primarily the hip and knee. The main pathologies are degradation of the articular cartilage and changes to the subchondral bone, as a result of both mechanical wear and a locally elevated inflammatory state. This study compares the viscoelastic properties of cartilage that represents the biochemical changes in OA and age-matched healthy tissue. Further, the mechanical damage induced by this compressive loading cycle was characterised and the mechanism for it was investigated. The storage modulus of OA cartilage was shown to be significantly lower than that of healthy cartilage whilst having a higher capacity to hold water. Following mechanical testing, there was a significant increase in the surface roughness of OA cartilage. This change in surface structure occurred following a reduction in sulphated glycosaminoglycan content of the superficial region in OA, as seen by alcian blue staining and quantified by micro X-ray fluorescence. These findings are important in understanding how the chemical changes to cartilage matrix in OA influence its dynamic mechanical properties and structural integrity.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

Cartilage has a very specialised tissue structure which acts to resist compressive loading. In osteoarthritis (OA), there is both mechanically- and chemically-induced damage to cartilage, resulting in severe degradation of the tissue. In this study we have undertaken a detailed mechanical and chemical analysis of macroscopically undamaged OA and healthy cartilage tissue. We have demonstrated, for the first time in human tissue, that the mechanical degradation of the tissue is attributed to a chemical change across the structure. In macroscopically undamaged OA tissue, there is a reduction in the elastic response of cartilage tissue and an associated destabilisation of the matrix that leaves it susceptible to damage. Understanding this allows us to better understand the progression of OA to design better therapeutic interventions.

Composition, structure and tensile biomechanical properties of equine articular cartilage during growth and maturation

Articular cartilage undergoes structural and biochemical changes during maturation, but the knowledge on how these changes relate to articular cartilage function at different stages of maturation is lacking. Equine articular cartilage samples of four different maturation levels (newborn, 5-month-old, 11-month-old and adult) were collected (N = 25). Biomechanical tensile testing, Fourier transform infrared microspectroscopy (FTIR-MS) and polarized light microscopy were used to study the tensile, biochemical and structural properties of articular cartilage, respectively. The tensile modulus was highest and the breaking energy lowest in the newborn group. The collagen and the proteoglycan contents increased with age. The collagen orientation developed with age into an arcade-like orientation. The collagen content, proteoglycan content, and collagen orientation were important predictors of the tensile modulus (p < 0.05 in multivariable regression) and correlated significantly also with the breaking energy (p < 0.05 in multivariable regression). Partial least squares regression analysis of FTIR-MS data provided accurate predictions for the tensile modulus (r = 0.79) and the breaking energy (r = 0.65). To conclude, the composition and structure of equine articular cartilage undergoes changes with depth that alter functional properties during maturation, with the typical properties of mature tissue reached at the age of 5-11 months.

How changes in interconnectivity affect the bulk properties of articular cartilage: a fibre network study

The remarkable compressive strength of articular cartilage arises from the mechanical interactions between the tension-resisting collagen fibrils and swelling proteoglycan proteins within the tissue. These interactions are facilitated by a significant level of interconnectivity between neighbouring collagen fibrils within the extracellular matrix. A reduction in interconnectivity is suspected to occur during the early stages of osteoarthritic degeneration. However, the relative contribution of these interconnections towards the bulk mechanical properties of articular cartilage has remained an open question. In this study, we present a simple 2D fibre network model which explicitly represents the microstructure of articular cartilage as collection of discrete nodes and linear springs. The transverse stiffness and swelling properties of this fibre network are studied, and a semi-analytic relationship which relates these two macroscopic properties via microscopic interconnectivity is derived. By comparing this derived expression to previously published experimental data, we show that although a reduction in network interconnectivity accounts for some of the observed changes in the mechanical properties of articular cartilage as degeneration occurs, a decrease in matrix interconnectivity alone do not provide a full account of this process.