Planarity does not always mean higher aromaticity - Intriguing metalloaromaticity of three Al13+ isomers

Electric field-driven up-and-down motion of the flexible tail of Al13+ cluster system-a nano-scale flipper

CONTEXT

Dynamic metal nanoclusters have become a hot area of research in the field of nanoscience and nanotechnology due to their potential applications in micro devices. One such dynamic cluster is a quasi-planar ground state (GS) Al13+ cluster which exhibits an electric field driven up and down flipping motion of the flexible tail which oscillates with respect to the mean plane. A Car-Parrinello molecular dynamics (CPMD) simulation has been carried out to understand the nature of dynamics of the cluster. CPMD simulation study reveals that the flexible tail region of the Al13+ isomeric system (two ground states M1, M2 and a transition state TS connecting them) can be engaged in a systematic up down flipping motion by the application of a transverse electric field. A saw tooth electric field of amplitude 5.19 V/nm is sufficient to induce the up-and-down flipping oscillation of the cluster, which has an average oscillation frequency of around 20 THz. AIM, NICS and AdNDP analyses also have been carried out to understand the fluxional nature of the cluster from the electronic structural perspective. Electronic structural analysis of selected optimized intermediate states in the presence of transverse electric field has also been analyzed to correlate the electronic structure with the dynamic nature of the cluster.

METHODS

Single-point energies of all intermediate states between two minima of Al13+ clusters connected through a transition state cluster. Optimized geometries of Al13+ clusters in the presence of electric field of different strengths have been carried out by using the Gaussian 03 package. 6-311 + G(d) basis set and B3LYP hybrid density functional have been utilized for these studies. To establish the flipping motion, Car-Parrinello molecular dynamics (CPMD) has been performed using the cp.x module of the Quantum ESPRESSO 6.3.0 program package using the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) functional, plane-wave basis set and ultrasoft pseudopotentials. ORTEP-3 and POV ray-3.7 software packages have been used for visualization and graphics generation. Atoms in molecule (AIM), Adaptive Natural Density Partitioning (AdNDP) analysis have been carried out using Multiwfn 3.7 program package.

Carbon-[n]Triangulenes and Sila-[n]Triangulenes: Which Are Planar?

Using our recently suggested concept of a quasi-molecule ("tile") and, in the case of the planarity here at stake, its generalization to larger than tetratomics, we explain why carbon [n]triangulenes tend to be planar, while hybrids, where just a few or even all a- or b-type carbon atoms are silicon-substituted (sila-[n]triangulenes), tend to be planar/nonplanar when compared with the unsubstituted carbon-[n]triangulenes. Because other spin states of the parent carbon- and sila-[n]triangulenes tend to correlate with the same tiles, it is conjectured that no structural changes are expected to depend on their spin state. Other polycyclic and sila-compounds are also discussed.

Effect of alkali atom doping on the electronic structure and aromatic character of planar and quasi-planar Al13+ clusters

A set of three Al₁₃⁺ clusters, one perfectly planar, and two quasi-planar structures, have been recently reported by our group (Guin et al. Journal of Molecular Graphics and Modeling, 2020, 97, 107544). All three clusters possess bilateral symmetry with identical structural features-a set of ten aluminum atoms encircle a triangular core. The symmetry axis passes through one of the Al atoms of the central triangular core and two Al atoms located on the periphery at two opposite ends of the cluster. This set of three aluminum clusters is an example of a rare metallo-aromatic system where highly anti-aromatic islands are embedded within an aromatic sea. In the present study, we have explored the effect of doping alkali atoms (Li, Na, and K) at the positions of the Al atoms that lie on the symmetry axis of the cluster intending to understand the structural stability and the effect on the aromatic character as compared to the undoped parent clusters. Besides the electronic structural analysis, NICS and ELF studies have also been carried out to characterize the aromatic nature of the doped clusters. Interestingly, it has been found that even with the incorporation of the alkali atoms, the bilateral symmetry of the clusters remains intact, but the alkali atoms are pushed out of the original location toward the edge of the cluster, whereas the aluminum atoms remain grouped. The dipole moment of the clusters systematically increases, and the overall aromaticity of the cluster systematically decreases with the increase in the atomic number of the doped alkali atoms. Effect of alkali atom doping to Al₁₃⁺ cluster.