Optimal management of phenylketonuria: a centralized expert team is more successful than a decentralized model of care

The management of phenylketonuria in adult patients in Italy: a survey of six specialist metabolic centers

INTRODUCTION

Phenylketonuria (PKU) is a rare autosomal recessive disorder caused by a deficiency of phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH). Its prevalence is estimated to be 1:10,000 in Europe. PKU is the commonest congenital inborn error of metabolism. The aim of our study was to investigate the characteristics of clinical practice in relation to PKU in Italy, in order to raise awareness about the current management and therapeutic approaches adopted.

METHODS

Six Italian experts conducted a systematic literature review as well as an internal survey to investigate the relevant clinical aspects. Collectively, the expert panel managed a total of 678 PKU patients treated in the early stages of the condition over a 16-year period across six centers.

RESULTS

The management of PKU varied markedly between centers, with differences in the composition of the multidisciplinary team, dietary treatments, compliance and adherence to management, tetrahydrobiopterin use, and patient follow-up. Patients were mostly managed by a pediatric reference center from the initial PKU diagnosis during newborn screening until adulthood, without transition to a specialized adult clinician. Fogginess, concentration reduction, low attention, anxiety, irritability, memory deficit, headache, and unstable mood were common features in patients with uncontrolled blood phenylalanine levels (generally above 600 µmol/L).

CONCLUSION

A homogeneous and shared approach to the management of PKU patients is important. Our survey demonstrates the current management of PKU in Italy, with the aim of promoting the implementation of therapeutic strategies and follow-up, increased patient compliance and adherence, and the achievement of the phenylalanine level targets recommended by European Union guidelines. Emerging therapies are likely to become a standard treatment for patients unable to comply with diet therapy and maintain their phenylalanine levels below the threshold values.

Supplemental data for this article is available online at https://doi.org/10.1080/03007995.2020.1847717.

Patient's thoughts and expectations about centres of expertise for PKU

BACKGROUND

In the Netherlands (NL) the government assigned 2 hospitals as centres of expertise (CE) for Phenylketonuria (PKU), while in the United Kingdom (UK) and Germany no centres are assigned specifically as PKU CE's.

METHODS

To identify expectations of patients/caregivers with PKU of CEs, a web-based survey was distributed through the national Phenylketonuria societies of Germany, NL and UK.

RESULTS

In total, 105 responded (43 patients, 56 parents, 4 grandparents, 2 other) of whom 59 were from NL, 33 from UK and 13 from Germany. All participants (n = 105) agreed that patients and/or practitioners would benefit from CEs. The frequency patients would want to visit a CE, when not treated in a CE (n = 83) varied: every hospital visit (24%, n = 20), annual or bi-annual (45%, n = 37), at defined patient ages (6%, n = 5), one visit only (22%, n = 18), or never (4%, n = 3). Distance was reported as a major barrier (42%, n = 35). 78% (n = 65) expected CE physicians and dieticians to have a higher level of knowledge than in non-CE centres. For participants already treated in a CE (n = 68), 66% requested a more extensive annual or bi-annual review. In general, psychology review and neuropsychologist assessment were identified as necessary by approximately half of the 105 participants. In addition, 66% (n = 68) expected a strong collaboration with patient associations.

CONCLUSION

In this small study, most participants expected that assigning CEs will change the structure of and delivery of Phenylketonuria care.

Nutritional management of phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH) deficiency in pediatric patients in Canada: a survey of dietitians' current practices

Background

Phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH) deficiency is one of 31 targeted inherited metabolic diseases (IMD) for the Canadian Inherited Metabolic Diseases Research Network (CIMDRN). Early diagnosis and initiation of treatment through newborn screening has gradually shifted treatment goals from the prevention of disabling complications to the optimization of long term outcomes. However, clinical evidence demonstrates that subtle suboptimal neurocognitive outcomes are present in the early and continuously diet-treated population with PAH deficiency. This may be attributed to variation in blood phenylalanine levels to outside treatment range and this, in turn, is possibly due to a combination of factors; disease severity, dietary noncompliance and differences in practice related to the management of PAH deficiency. One of CIMDRN’s goals is to understand current practices in the diagnosis and management of PAH deficiency in the pediatric population, from the perspective of both health care providers and patients/families.

Objectives

We investigated Canadian metabolic dietitians’ perspectives on the nutritional management of children with PAH deficiency, awareness of recently published North American treatment and nutritional guidelines in relation to PAH deficiency, and nutritional care practices within and outside these guidelines.

Methods

We invited 33 dietitians to participate in a survey, to ascertain their use of recently published guidelines and their practices in relation to the nutritional care of pediatric patients with PAH deficiency.

Results

We received 19 responses (59% response rate). All participants reported awareness of published guidelines for managing PAH deficiency. To classify disease severity, 89% of dietitians reported using pre-treatment blood phenylalanine (Phe) levels, alone or in combination with other factors. 74% of dietitians reported using blood Phe levels ≥360 μmol/L (6 mg/dL) as the criterion for initiating a Phe-restricted diet. All respondents considered 120-360 μmol/L (2–6 mg/dL) as the optimal treatment range for blood Phe in children 0–9 years old, but there was less agreement on blood Phe targets for older children. Most dietitians reported similar approaches to diet assessment and counseling: monitoring growth trends, use of 3 day diet records for intake analysis, individualization of diet goals, counseling patients to count grams of dietary natural protein or milligrams of dietary Phe, and monitoring blood Phe, tyrosine and ferritin.

Conclusion

While Canadian dietitians’ practices in managing pediatric PAH deficiency are generally aligned with those of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG), and with the associated treatment and nutritional guidelines from Genetic Metabolic Dietitians International (GMDI), variation in many aspects of care reflects ongoing uncertainty and a need for robust evidence.

Impact of geographic access to care on compliance and metabolic control in phenylketonuria

OBJECTIVE

To study the impact of geographic access to care on metabolic control and compliance in phenylketonuria (PKU).

STUDY DESIGN

Phenylalanine (Phe) levels and number of samples obtained were abstracted from a data base of 76 patients age <21 years and compared for age, sex, and distance to clinic. Levels and number of samples were compared to the clinic guidelines for age.

RESULTS

There was a strong positive correlation between age and Phe levels in adolescents and young adults while age and number of samples submitted were negatively correlated. There was not a significant correlation between Phe levels and distance to clinic, nor was there a significant difference in the Phe levels by distant categories (Denver metro, Front Range, distant area). However, there was a decrease in number of samples sent compared to clinic guidelines by distance, with patients residing in distant areas (>100 miles) sending significantly less samples.

CONCLUSION

Geographic access to care does not impact control of Phe levels, but it does affect the number of monitoring samples sent to the clinic. Age groups of adolescents and young adults have a strong impact on both control of Phe levels and number of monitoring samples compared to clinic guidelines.

Causes of delay in referral of patients with phenylketonuria to a specialized reference centre in Mexico

Objective

To expose causes leading to the delayed arrival of phenylketonuria (PKU) patients at a governmental reference centre (RC), and to describe their clinical characteristics.

Material and methods

PKU files registered during the past 18 years at the National Institute of Pediatrics in Mexico City were evaluated. Patients were classified into two groups according to their age at arrival: Group I (early reference), patients arriving during the first month of life; and Group II (late reference), those who arrived after thirty days of age. Time and causes of delay were documented.

Results

Of 57 recorded files, 10 were classified in Group I and 47 in Group II. Causes leading to the late arrival of Group II patients were absence of routine newborn screening (NBS), PKU not included in the routine NBS, sampling after the recommended age, false negative result, results without interpretation and/or instructions to follow, delayed notification of results, poor medical criteria of attending physician, difficulties in obtaining confirmatory tests, and administrative failures.

Conclusion

The main cause of late referral of PKU patients was the absence of PKU testing. As a developing country, Mexico still faces challenges in the proper functioning and expansion of the NBS programme. Most PKU patients arrived at the RC late, presenting with varying degrees of the clinical spectrum. Incorporating PKU testing into the already established Mexican NBS system and adding quality indicators to guarantee proper operation in all NBS phases is necessary to achieve the goal of identifying, referring, diagnosing, and treating patients promptly.

Outcomes of phenylketonuria with relevance to follow-up

Currently, there is no international consensus on how patients with phenylketonuria (PKU) (or milder forms of hyperphenylalaninaemia) should be followed in clinical practice. Guidelines concerning the frequency and type of assessments that should be made according to age usually focus on blood phenylalanine concentrations. A need exists for improved guidelines on how to do the follow-up of individuals with PKU/milder forms of hyperphenylalaninaemia. An interdisciplinary approach for monitoring patients is required, involving relevant clinical investigations and regular contact with a clinician and dietician/nutritionist as well as contact with social health worker, psychologist and neurologist, at least at request. This chapter presents a scheme for follow-up. However, by no means this scheme aims to present the one for all time follow-up programme. The scheme for follow-up may rather serve as a start for further discussion in larger groups of professionals in collaboration with patients and their parents. A number of questions remain unanswered, and further research is still needed to fine-tune the management of PKU at different ages.

Follow up of phenylketonuria patients

In recent years our understanding of the follow up policies for PKU has increased substantially. In particular, we now understand the importance of maintaining control of blood phenylalanine (phe) concentrations life-long to achieve the best long-term neuropsychological outcomes. The concordance with the follow up strategy remains a key challenge for the future, especially with respect to adolescents and young adults. The recent therapies could ease the burden of the dietary phe restriction for PKU patients and their families. The time may be right for revisiting the guidelines for follow up of PKU in order to address a number of important issues related to PKU management: promotion of breastfeeding to complementary feeding up to 2 years of age for prevention of early growth retardation and later overweight development, treatment advancements for metabolic control, blood phe and tyr variability, routine screening measures for nutritional biomarkers, neurocognitive and psychological assessments, bone pathology, understanding the challenges of compliance and transitioning into adulthood as an individual with PKU and addressing unmet needs in this population.

Nutritional Management of Phenylketonuria

Phenylketonuria (PKU) is caused by deficient activity of the enzyme phenylalanine hydroxylase, needed to convert the essential amino acid (AA) phenylalanine (phe) to tyrosine. In order to prevent neurological damage, lifelong adherence to a low-phe diet that is restricted in natural foods and requires ingestion of a phe-free AA formula to meet protein needs is required. The goal of nutritional management for those with PKU is to maintain plasma phe concentrations that support optimal growth, development, and mental functioning while providing a nutritionally complete diet. This paper reviews developing a lifelong dietary prescription for those with PKU, outcomes of nutritional management, compliance with the low-phe diet across the life cycle, and new options for nutritional management. An individualized dietary prescription is needed to meet nutrient requirements, and the adequacy of phe intake is monitored with assessment of blood phe levels. Elevated phe concentrations may occur due to illness, excessive or inadequate phe intake, or inadequate intake of AA formula. Although normal growth and development occurs with adherence to the low-phe diet, it is important to monitor vitamin, mineral and essential fatty acid status, especially in those who do not consume sufficient AA formula. Given the growing population of adults with PKU, further research is needed to understand the risks for developing osteoporosis and cardiovascular disease. There are promising new options to liberalize the diet and improve metabolic control such as tetrahydrobiopterin therapy or supplementation with large neutral AAs. Moreover, foods made with glycomacropeptide, an intact protein that contains minimal phe, improves the PKU diet by offering a palatable alternative to AA formula. In summary, continued efforts are needed to overcome the biggest challenge to living with PKU - lifelong adherence to the low-phe diet.

PKU-what is daily practice in various centres in Europe? Data from a questionnaire by the scientific advisory committee of the European Society of Phenylketonuria and Allied Disorders

BACKGROUND

Since the start of the European Society of Phenylketonuria and Allied Disorders Treated as Phenylketonuria (ESPKU) in 1987, an increasing number of parental organizations of member countries have joined. Treatment varies widely within Europe. A survey among professionals was done to determine goals and practice.

METHOD

In 2005, a questionnaire was sent to professionals of member countries, addressing diagnostic and treatment procedures, numbers of patients necessary for a PKU centre, guidelines followed, numbers of patients treated and professionals involved in care, target phenylalanine concentrations, amount of protein prescribed, frequency of monitoring and clinical visits, need for follow-up of various clinical and biochemical data, the importance of various abnormalities, and definition of (non)compliance.

RESULTS

Seventeen centres of 12 countries answered. Professionals of 13 countries could not be reached or did not respond. Differences in care were observed in many issues of care including target phenylalanine concentrations. Only few issues had general consensus.

CONCLUSION

Not all countries were really active at ESPKU level. In the active countries, a professional could not always be contacted. Responses show that PKU care varies largely between European countries. Notwithstanding the large diversity on many issues of day-to-day care and therapeutic targets, results showed increasing consensus on some issues. The most important outcome of this questionnaire might be that the Scientific Advisory Committee of the ESPKU initiated meetings for professionals of different backgrounds taking care of PKU patients besides the already existing programme for parents, patients and delegates. Discussion among these professionals may improve quality of care.

Organising health care services for persons with an intellectual disability

BACKGROUND

When compared to the general population, persons with an intellectual disability have lower life expectancy, higher morbidity, higher rates of unmet health needs, and more difficulty finding and getting health care. Organisational interventions are used to reconfigure the structure or delivery of health care services and may prove useful to decrease the noted disparities.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the effects of organisational interventions for the mental and physical health problems of persons with an intellectual disability.

SEARCH STRATEGY

We searched the Cochrane Effective Practice and Organisation of Care Group specialised register (no year restriction), MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, other databases from January 1990 to April 2006 reference lists of included studies, and we consulted experts in the field.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Randomised controlled trials, controlled clinical trials, controlled before and after studies and interrupted time series of organisational interventions aimed at improving care of mental and physical health problems of adult persons with an intellectual disability.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Two review authors independently extracted data and assessed study quality. Missing data were requested from authors of included studies.

MAIN RESULTS

Eight studies met the selection criteria: six were randomised controlled trials, one was a controlled before and after study, and one was an interrupted time series. In general the studies were of acceptable methodological quality. The included studies investigated interventions dealing with the mental health problems of persons with an intellectual disability, none focused on physical health problems. Three of the studies identified effective organisational interventions and five showed no evidence of effect. Only two studies were similar enough to analyse using a meta-analysis. In the pooled analyses 25 participants received assertive community treatment and 25 received standard community treatment. Results from measures of function, caregiver burden and quality of life were non-significant.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

There are currently no well designed studies focusing on organising the health services of persons with an intellectual disability and concurrent physical problems. There are very few studies of organisational interventions targeting mental health needs and the results of those that were found need corroboration. There is an urgent need for high quality health services research to identify optimal health services for persons with an intellectual disability and concurrent physical problem.