Family Experiences Deciding For and Against Pediatric Home Ventilation

Bilateral renal agenesis: fetal intervention and outcomes

Bilateral renal agenesis (BRA) is a fetal anomaly which leads to anhydramnios and resultant pulmonary hypoplasia. Historically, this anomaly was universally fatal early in the neonatal period due to the severity of the associated lung disease. Over the last 30 years, innovations in fetal therapies-specifically, serial amnioinfusions-have led to instances of infant pulmonary survival and initiation of postnatal dialysis, raising the possibility that early neonatal death may not be inevitable. Amnioinfusions are not without risk, and maternal complications can include prelabor rupture of membranes, preterm labor, infection, and bleeding. The data detailing neonatal outcomes are still limited and actively being collected. Two case series and one non-randomized clinical trial have supplied most of the known outcome data for infants with BRA after prenatal amnioinfusion. Although there are survivors reported in the literature, mortality remains high, with many deaths in infancy due to dialysis-associated sepsis. In addition, previously unknown morbidities have been documented in these infants, including neurologic injury. These challenges, in addition to the mechanical difficulties of providing dialysis to extremely small infants, can result in significant burdens for patients and their caregivers and moral distress for the health care team. The present review aims to explain the pathophysiology of BRA, detail the historical context and rationale for serial amnioinfusions to treat the pulmonary insufficiency associated with BRA, describe the available data regarding outcomes of infants born following prenatal amnioinfusions, discuss ethical issues surrounding this fetal intervention, and describe critical aspects of prenatal counseling for patients considering the intervention.

Tracheostomy and long-term invasive ventilation decision-making in children: A scoping review

An increasing number of children are surviving critical illnesses requiring tracheostomy/long-term ventilation (LTV). This scoping review seeks to collate the available evidence on decision-making for tracheostomy/LTV in children. Systematic searches of electronic databases and websites were conducted for articles and reports. Inclusion criteria included: (1) children 0-18 years old; (2) described use of tracheostomy or tracheostomy/LTV; and (3) information on recommendations for tracheostomy decision-making or decision-making experiences of family-caregivers or health care providers. Articles not written in English were excluded. Of the 4463 records identified through database search and other methods, a total of 84 articles, 2 dissertations, 1 book chapter, 3 consensus statement/society guidelines, and 8 pieces of grey literature were included. Main thematic domains identified were: (1) legal and moral standards for decision-making; (2) decision-making models, roles of decision-makers, and decisional aids towards a shared decision-making model; (3) experiences and perspectives of decision-makers; (4) health system and society considerations; and (5) conflict resolution and legal considerations. A high degree of uncertainty and complexity is involved in tracheostomy/LTV decision-making. There is a need for a standardized decision-support process that is consistent with a child's best interests and shared decision-making. Strategies for optimizing communication and mechanism for managing disputes are needed.

Parents' experiences of their children's medical journeys with tracheostomies: A Focus Group Study

Objectives

Children living with a tracheostomy have among the most complex medical care needs in Canada. The focus of this study was to gain a contemporary understanding of key aspects of these children's medical journeys.

Methods

We conducted a qualitative constructivist grounded theory study using semi-structured focus groups with parents whose children are living in the community with a tracheostomy. Parents were recruited from the Stollery Children's Hospital Tracheostomy Clinic, which serves a geographically wide and diverse population.

Results

Three focus groups were completed, including a total of 12 participants. Key themes leading up to tracheostomy related to contextual understanding, experiences of inclusion, and perceptions of proportionality. Parents discussed the preparedness for how a tracheostomy would affect their child, their own involvement in recovery, and the education needed for their child's medical care. Navigating hospital units related to inconsistencies in care, accommodations of families' needs, and confidence in care received. Finally, living in the community was the focus of much of the participants' discussions including coping with system-related issues, limited homecare and medical support, cost of care, and connections with the broader community of parents of children with complex medical needs. All themes encircled the family's deeply felt responsibility to care for their child.

Conclusions

From both patient- and family-centered care perspectives, there exist individual and systemic issues related to the care delivery for children with a tracheostomy. It is in particular in the community where there is a severe deficiency of support afforded to these children and their families.

Establishing Goals of Care in Serious and Complex Pediatric Illness

An increasing number of children are living for months and years with serious/complex illness characterized by long-term prognostic uncertainty, intensive interactions with medical systems, functional limitations, and often home medical technologies that shape the child's and family's quality of life. These families face many medical decision points that require intentional and iterative discussions about goals of care. Threats to cohesive goals of care include prognostic uncertainty, diffusion of medical responsibility, individual family context, and blended goals of care. This article offers strategies for addressing each of these challenges.

Home values and experiences navigation track (HomeVENT): Supporting decisions about pediatric home ventilation

Objective

To pilot feasibility and acceptability of HomeVENT, a systematic approach to family-clinician decision-making about pediatric home ventilation.

Methods

Parents and clinicians of children facing home ventilation decisions were enrolled at 3 centers using a pre/post cohort design. Family interventions included: 1) a website describing the experiences of families who previously chose for and against home ventilation 2) a Question Prompt List (QPL); 3) in-depth interviews exploring home life and values. Clinician HomeVENT intervention included a structured team meeting reviewing treatment options in light of the family's home life and values. All participants were interviewed one month after the decision.

Results

We enrolled 30 families and 34 clinicians. Most Usual Care (14/15) but fewer Intervention (10/15) families elected for home ventilation. Families reported the website helped them consider different treatment options, the QPL promoted discussion within the family and with the team, and the interview helped them realize how home ventilation might change their daily life. Clinicians reported the team meeting helped clarify prognosis and prioritize treatment options.

Conclusions

The HomeVENT pilot was feasible and acceptable.

Innovation

This systematic approach to pediatric home ventilation decisions prioritizes family values and is a novel method to increase the rigor of shared decision-making in a rushed clinical environment.

Parent Perspectives on the Child Experience of Pediatric Home Ventilation via Tracheostomy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Parents facing the decision of whether to initiate pediatric mechanical ventilation via tracheostomy ("home ventilation") report wanting information about what to expect for life at home for their child. The study objective is to explore parent descriptions of the child experience of home ventilation to increase awareness for clinicians in the inpatient setting caring for these children.

METHODS

Semistructured interviews were conducted using purposive sampling of parents with children who initiated home ventilation within the previous 5 years from 3 geographically diverse academic medical centers.

RESULTS

We interviewed 21 families from 3 geographic regions in the United States. About 75% of children had respiratory failure in the first year of life, 80% had medical complexity, and half had severe neurologic impairment. Five domains emerged regarding parent perceptions of their child's experience of home ventilation: (1) health and well-being; (2) development; (3) adaptation; (4) mobility and travel; and (5) relationships. Within each domain, several themes were identified. For each theme, there was a positive and negative subtheme to illustrate how the child's experience was modified by home ventilation. Parent descriptions were generally positive, however, in all domains and to varying degrees, parents expressed negative aspects of home ventilation.

CONCLUSIONS

By providing information about the realistic experiences of children using home ventilation, clinicians can support families in the inpatient setting as they face this complex decision. Balanced information about home ventilation is critical to enhancing clinician counseling so that families may benefit from the perspectives of experienced parents.

Caring for children with new medical technology at home: parental perspectives

OBJECTIVES

This qualitative descriptive study explores the experiences of family caregivers (FCs) of children with medical complexity who are initiated on new medical technology in the hospital and transition to new daily life at home. The study aims to investigate FCs' response and readiness for medical technology use, the value of education and transition support and the challenges associated with managing new medical technology in the home.

STUDY DESIGN

A qualitative descriptive approach was used to conduct and analyse 14 semistructured interviews with a group of FCs composed of 11 mothers and 3 fathers. Content analysis was used to analyse transcripts of the caregiver interviews. The study was conducted at a tertiary paediatric hospital in Toronto, Canada.

RESULTS

Our study revealed three main themes: FC's response and readiness for medical technology use, the value of education and transition support for initiation of new medical technology and the challenges associated with managing new medical technology in the home. FCs expressed emotional distress related to coping with the realisation that their child required medical technology. Although the theoretical and hands-on practice training instilled confidence in families, FCs reported feeling overwhelmed when they transitioned home with new medical technology. Finally, FCs reported significant psychological, emotional and financial challenges while caring for their technology-dependent child.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study reveals the unique challenges faced by FCs who care for technology-dependent children. These findings highlight the need to implement a comprehensive education and transition programme that provides longitudinal support for all aspects of care.

Shared decision-making experiences in child long-term ventilation: a systematic review

INTRODUCTION

Recent decades have seen an increase in children receiving long-term ventilation. To ensure that long-term ventilation decisions incorporate the perspectives of stakeholders, it is vital that empirical evidence is gathered to substantiate frameworks and guidance on shared decision-making for long-term ventilation. This systematic review and qualitative evidence synthesis aimed to clarify what shared decision-making constitutes in relation to long-term ventilation initiation for children and young people (<21 years).

METHODS

A systematic review of qualitative research was undertaken. Searches were conducted in MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, PsycINFO and Web of Science.

RESULTS

Findings from 13 studies were included representative of 363 caregivers and 143 healthcare professional experiences. Components that support shared decision-making included acknowledging the unique positionality of caregivers and ensuring caregivers were informed about the implications of long-term ventilation. Beneficial qualities of engagement between stakeholders included honest, clear and timely dialogue using lay, tactful and sensitive language.

CONCLUSION

Our findings clarify components and approaches supportive of shared decision-making in discussions about long-term ventilation. This review therefore provides a valuable resource to implement shared decision-making practices in the context of long-term ventilation decisions for children and young people.

Palliative care for NICU survivors with chronic critical illness

The sickest of NICU survivors develop chronic critical illness (CCI). Most infants with CCI will leave the NICU using chronic medical technology and will experience repeated rehospitalizations. The unique issues for these NICU graduates- escalating chronic medical technologies, fractured post-NICU healthcare, gaps in home health services, and family strain-are common and predictable. This means that raising family and NICU team awareness of these issues, and putting plans in place to address them, should occur for every NICU infant with CCI. Pediatric palliative care is one resource that can be engaged within the NICU to support the child and family through NICU discharge and beyond. This review examines what is known about the unique needs of infants who leave the NICU with CCI and the role that NICU-initiated palliative care involvement can play for these patients, families, clinicians, and the health care system.

Family-Reflections.com: Creating a parent-to-parent web-based tool regarding pediatric home ventilation

BACKGROUND

The decision to initiate pediatric mechanical ventilation via tracheostomy ("home ventilation") is complex and parents often desire information from other parents who have faced this decision. However, parent-to-parent communication is challenging as it is difficult to connect new families to experienced families in ways that optimize informed, balanced decision-making.

OBJECTIVE

Create a parent-to-parent web-based tool to support decision-making about pediatric home ventilation.

PATIENT INVOLVEMENT

The tool was created based on interviews and feedback from parents.

METHODS

We interviewed parents who previously chose for, or against, home ventilation for their child. Interview themes and family comments guided website development. Viewer feedback was solicited via an embedded survey in the tool.

RESULTS

We created 6 composite character families to communicate 6 themes about home ventilation: 1) Considering treatment options, 2) Talking with medical team, 3) Impact on life at home, 4) Impact on relationships, 5) Experience for the child, and 6) If the child's life is short. Nine families who reviewed the draft tool felt it would have helped with their decision about home ventilation. Specifically, it supported families in thinking through what was "most important about their child's breathing problems" (7 of 9 parents) and feeling "more at peace with the decision" (8 of 9 parents). Between 6/1/20-12/31/22, nearly 5500 viewers have accessed the tool and 56 viewers completed the survey (including 13 families and 39 clinicians). Feedback from experienced families and clinicians reported the tool taught them something new.

DISCUSSION

This novel parent-to-parent tool shows promise for expanding access to balanced, family-centered information about pediatric home ventilation.

PRACTICAL VALUE

The diverse stories and decisions let parents access multiple family perspectives. The tool's focus is on family-centric information that parents reported was usually missing from clinician counseling.

FUNDING

This work was supported by the National Palliative Care Research Center.

Predictors for invasive home mechanical ventilation duration in bronchopulmonary dysplasia

BACKGROUND

Children with bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD) who require invasive home mechanical ventilation (IHMV) are medically vulnerable and experience high caregiving and healthcare costs. Predictors for duration of IHMV in children with BPD remain unclear, which can make prognostication and decision-making challenging.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study of children with BPD requiring IHMV was conducted from independent children's hospital records (2005-2021). The primary outcome was IHMV duration, defined as time from initial discharge home on IHMV until cessation of positive pressure ventilation (day and night). Two new variables were included: discharge age corrected for tracheostomy (DACT) (chronological age at discharge minus age at tracheostomy) and level of ventilator support at discharge (minute ventilation per kg per day). Univariable Cox regression was performed with variables of interest compared to IHMV duration. Significant nonlinear factors (p < 0.05) were included in the multivariable analysis.

RESULTS

One-hundred-and-nineteen patients used IHMV primarily for BPD. Patient median index hospitalization lasted 12 months (interquartile range [IQR] 8.0,14.4). Once home, half of the patients were weaned off IHMV by 36.0 months and 90% by 52.2 months. Being Hispanic/Latinx ethnicity (hazard ratio [HR] 0.14 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.04, 0.53), p < 0.01) and having a higher DACT were associated with increased IHMV duration (HR 0.66 (CI 0.43, 0.98), p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Disparity in IHMV duration exists among patients using IHMV after prematurity. Prospective multisite studies that further investigate new analytic variables, such as DACT and level of ventilator support, and address standardization of IHMV care are needed to create more equitable IHMV management strategies.

"What Would Give Her the Best Life?": Understanding Why Families Decline Pediatric Home Ventilation

Background: Families who must decide about pediatric home ventilation rely on the clinicians who counsel them for guidance. Most studies about pediatric home ventilation decisions focus on families who opt for this intervention, leaving much unknown about the families who decline. Objective: To describe the rationales of families who decline home ventilation. Design: Semi-structured interview study. Setting/Subjects: We interviewed 16 families in hospitals across 3 U.S. states, identified by their clinicians as previously deciding to not pursue home ventilation via tracheostomy within the past five years. Measurements: Targeted content and narrative analyses were used to understand family intentions and reasons for declining. Results: The clinical and social context varied among the 16 families in this study. Families' intentions in saying "no" fell into two categories: (1) definitive "No": Families who stood firm on in their decision and (2) contingent "No": Families who may consider this in the future. Families described four reasons why their child did not receive home ventilation: (1) concern about medical impacts, (2) concern about physical and/or communication restrictions, (3) concern that there would be no clear health benefit, and (4) concern about no clear meaningful life. Most families mentioned all four reasons, but concern about no clear meaningful life predominated. Conclusions: Though these families did not see home ventilation as an appropriate option, each reported a complex interplay of intentions behind and reasons for declining. Clinicians who counsel families about home ventilation could share the reasons that families commonly decline this intervention to facilitate a balanced discussion.

Outcomes for Children With Pulmonary Hypertension Undergoing Tracheostomy Placement: A Multi-Institutional Analysis

OBJECTIVES

To describe epidemiology, interventions, outcomes, and the health services experience for a cohort of children with pulmonary hypertension (PH) who underwent tracheostomy placement and to identify risk factors for inhospital mortality and 30-day readmissions.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study of the Pediatric Health Information System database.

SETTING

Thirty-seven freestanding U.S. children's hospitals.

PATIENTS

Patients 31 days to 21 years old who were discharged from the hospital between January 1, 2009, and December 31, 2017, with a diagnosis of primary or secondary PH, and who underwent tracheostomy placement. Outcomes were examined over a 2-year period from the time of discharge from the index encounter.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

There were 793 patients with PH who underwent tracheostomy placement. The overall inhospital mortality rate was 23.7%. Secondary PH due to congenital heart disease (CHD) was significantly associated with overall inhospital mortality (adjusted odds ratio [OR], 2.36; 95% CI, 1.38-4.04). The rate of 30-day readmissions for patients over the 2-year follow-up period was 33.3%. Tracheostomy during the index encounter and the diagnosis of secondary PH due to CHD were significantly associated with lower rates of 30-day readmissions (adjusted OR, 0.34; 95% CI, 0.19-0.61; and adjusted OR, 0.43; 95% CI, 0.24-0.77, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

In the context of expanding utilization of tracheostomy and long-term ventilation, children with PH are among the highest risk cohorts for extended and repeated hospitalization and death. Tracheostomy placement during the index encounter was associated with fewer 30-day readmissions over the 2-year follow-up period. Further understanding of which subgroups may benefit from earlier intervention and which subgroups are at highest risk may offer important clinical insight when considering optimal timing of tracheostomy and may enhance informed decision-making for all stakeholders.

Home mechanical ventilation for children with severe neurological impairment: Parents' perspectives on clinician counselling

AIM

To retrospectively explore the perspectives of parents of children with severe neurological impairment (SNI), such as those with severe cerebral palsy, epilepsy syndromes, and structural brain differences, on clinician counseling regarding home mechanical ventilation (HMV).

METHOD

Inductive thematic analysis was performed on data from telephone interviews with parents who chose for and against HMV for their child with SNI at three academic children's hospitals across the USA.

RESULTS

Twenty-six parents/legal guardians of 24 children were interviewed. Fourteen children had static encephalopathy, 11 received HMV, and 20 were alive at the time of parent interviews. Themes included how HMV related to the child's prognosis, risk of death, and integration with goals of care. Although clinicians voiced uncertainty about how HMV would impact their child, parents felt this was coupled with prescriptive/intimidating examples about the child's end of life and judgments about the child's quality of life.

INTERPRETATION

While prognositc uncertainty exists, this study suggests that parents of children with SNI seek clinician counseling about HMV that considers their goals of care and views on their child's quality of life.

Parental Decision-Making for Children With Medical Complexity: An Integrated Literature Review

CONTEXT

Children with medical complexity (CMC) have multiple significant chronic health conditions that result in functional limitations and high health care utilization. The population of CMC is increasing and parent decision-making for this population is nuanced.

OBJECTIVES

To review the literature specifically related to the parent experience of medical decision-making for CMC from the parent perspective.

METHODS

A comprehensive, systematic approach was undertaken with the goal of identifying emergent themes in the existing literature as well as implications for clinical practice and future research. PubMed and PsycInfo databases were searched for English-language articles published between 1995-2020 that focused on parent experiences/perspectives using the search terms: children with medical complexity, children with serious illness, parent decision-making, parent experience, goals of care, parental priorities, advance care planning, and shared decision-making.

RESULTS

The search yielded 300 unique manuscripts; including 32 empirical articles incorporated in this review. The synthesized findings were broken down into three main sections: 1. types of decisions that parents of CMC face, 2. key factors that influence parental decision-making for CMC, and 3. reasons that the decision-making process for parents of CMC is unique. The findings suggest that parents should be considered experts in their child's care and should be incorporated in shared decision-making in a culturally appropriate manner. CMC should have their personhood valued and providers require specialized training in communication.

CONCLUSIONS

Parents of CMC have unique needs in their decision-making process and benefit from shared decision-making, continuity of care, collaborative communication and tailored, individualized care.

Top Ten Tips Palliative Care Clinicians Should Know About Their Work's Intersection with Clinical Ethics

Palliative care (PC) subspecialists and clinical ethics consultants often engage in parallel work, as both function primarily as interprofessional consultancy services called upon in complex clinical scenarios and challenging circumstances. Both practices utilize active listening, goals-based communication, conflict mediation or mitigation, and values explorations as care modalities. In this set of tips created by an interprofessional team of ethicists, intensivists, a surgeon, an attorney, and pediatric and adult PC nurses and physicians, we aim to describe some paradigmatic clinical challenges for which partnership may improve collaborative, comprehensive care.

Life with pediatric home ventilation: Expectations versus experience

OBJECTIVES

To explore the family experience of home ventilation through a comparison of anticipated home life changes with subsequent experiences.

STUDY DESIGN

Guided interviews with parents across three states who chose home ventilation for their child within the last 5 years.

PATIENT-SUBJECT SELECTION

Purposive sampling of parents who chose home ventilation for their child within the last 5 years.

METHODS

Interviews were transcribed for qualitative analysis and analyzed for thematic saturation and prevalence of codes.

RESULTS

Twenty families were interviewed. Families generally reported not considering potential home life changes when facing the decision about home ventilation; instead, they worried most about medical management. These concerns reversed in importance later. Families learned medical management quickly but felt largely unprepared for the extensive changes to their home life, including isolation, altered relationships with extended family and community, effects on siblings, financial strain, and need for physical changes to their house. Families had not anticipated how much they would be affected by home healthcare as a new part of their life.

CONCLUSIONS

The priorities that families consider during decisions about pediatric home ventilation may not be aligned with the actual home experience of this technology. Given that the success of home ventilation largely rests with the family's care, family expectations for home life adaptations must be augmented, as should postdischarge supports for families with complex home care experiences.

The Long Shadow: Collateral Impact and Finding Resilience Amidst a Global Pandemic Pediatric Palliative Care Social Work During COVID-19

This manuscript illuminates the nuanced ways in which the COVID-19 pandemic has impacted the pediatric palliative care social work role and clinical care in caring for children with life-limiting illnesses and their families throughout the country. The authors discuss memorable moments, logistical impacts, telehealth usage, decision-making experiences, end of life care, bereavement practices, specialized interventions, and self-care. The paper concludes with lessons learned and practical recommendations for the future.