Prognostic factor analysis of stage 4S neuroblastoma in infant patients: A single center study

Revisiting the role of radiotherapy in the treatment of neuroblastoma 4S: 30 years of institutional experience and systematic review

Background and purpose

Neuroblastoma 4S is a rare subtype of metastatic neuroblastoma found in children younger than 12 months, characterized by liver, skin, or bone marrow metastases. While the prognosis for patients is generally favorable, rapid progression of liver metastases can lead to life-threatening organ insufficiency. In such cases, immediate treatment with chemotherapy or radiotherapy is necessary. Given the recent decline in radiotherapy utilization, this study aims to reassess its role, evaluating its effectiveness and toxicity.

Materials and methods

We conducted a systematic review and an institutional retrospective analysis to assess the use of radiotherapy for hepatomegaly in patients with neuroblastoma 4S. The study included data from 164 patients from the literature and 16 patients from our institutional cohort. We extracted and analyzed data on short- and long-term outcomes, as well as reports of radiotherapy-induced toxicity.

Results

Our institutional data showed that 81 % of patients responded to low-dose radiotherapy administered at a median dose of 450 cGy in three fractions, resulting in liver shrinkage and symptom resolution. Based on the systematic review, 1-year survival rate was 80 %, while 5-year survival rate was 75 %. No serious toxicity was observed with the current low-dose radiotherapy; however, one case of induced secondary malignancy was reported.

Conclusion

Radiation therapy is an effective treatment modality for hepatomegaly in patients with neuroblastoma 4S, with a success rate of about 80 %. Despite being administered to infants, a low dose of 450-600 cGy does not result in toxicity related to the kidneys, liver, or posture defects.

The role of surgery in the treatment of neuroblastoma metastases at rare sites

PURPOSE

Treatment of neuroblastoma metastases usually consists of chemotherapy and irradiation. However, in selected cases, surgical treatment is also indicated. In this study, we present three cases of patients with neuroblastoma metastases at rare sites that underwent surgery.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed data of patients who underwent surgery for neuroblastoma at our department of Pediatric Surgery and Pediatric Urology at the University Children's Hospital in Tuebingen and selected those patients who had surgery explicitly for a metastasis.

RESULTS

Between 2002 and 2020, 277 children underwent surgical treatment for neuroblastoma. Three cases with metastases at exceptional sites are presented here after therapy according to protocols. One patient had a penile metastasis and received surgery including a plastic reconstruction. The patient showed no signs of erectile or urinary dysfunction at follow-up. Another patient had a metastasis in the proximal ulna, which remained vital even after exhausted treatment after two relapses. Afterward there was no restriction of movement of the extremity. The third patient had, amongst others, metastases to the pancreatic body and to the liver. Both were surgically removed during primary tumor resection. This patient died after local tumor relapse. The other two patients showed no evidence of tumor relapse after a follow-up of 18 and 17 months, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Although children with neuroblastoma often present with metastases, there is no recommendation for surgical treatment other than diagnostic biopsies. In case of persistence of metastasis or after exhaustion of high-risk therapy, surgical resection must be considered.

Management and Outcomes of Children with Stage 4S (MS) Neuroblastoma: A Single-Center Experience from a Resource-Challenged Nation

OBJECTIVES

To demonstrate the clinical profile, management options, and outcomes of children with stage 4S neuroblastoma (NB 4S) diagnosed at a tertiary care center in a resource-challenged nation. The authors also intend to highlight the factors associated with an unfavorable prognosis in this series of patients.

METHODS

The archives for children with NB 4S, diagnosed over a 24-y period (January 1996-December 2019), were retrospectively retrieved. Data on patient characteristics, management protocols, oncologic outcomes, and overall survival (OS) were reviewed. Multivariate logistic- regression analysis was performed to identify the factors independently predicting unfavorable outcomes.

RESULTS

A total of 22 children (59% males) were included. Adrenal was the most common (82%) primary site. Liver involvement (100%), bone marrow infiltration (23%), and subcutaneous nodules (9%) were observed upon evaluation. Management involved supportive treatment (22%), chemotherapy only (41%), chemotherapy and tumor excision (28%). Ventral hernia was created in two children (9%) due to abdominal compartment syndrome (ACS). Four children died (4/22; 18%) due to ACS (n = 2) and refractory coagulopathy (n = 2). There were no recurrences and all survivors were disease-free. The 5-y OS was 81.8% with a median follow-up duration of 31 mo (range 9 mo-22 y). Age < 2 mo (p = 0.002), respiratory distress at presentation (p < 0.001), and chemotherapy nonresponsiveness (p < 0.001) were significantly associated with mortality. All three factors were independent predictors of mortality.

CONCLUSION

Children with NB 4S have a favorable outcome with 5-y OS of 81.8%. Age < 2 mo, respiratory distress at presentation, and chemotherapy nonresponsiveness are independent predictors of a poor outcome.

Stage 4S Neuroblastoma: What Are the Outcomes? A Systematic Review of Published Studies

INTRODUCTION

 The prognosis of stage 4S/MS neuroblastoma has traditionally been reported as excellent, yet conflicting treatment protocols exist for this enigmatic disease. To critically address this question, we have undertaken a systematic review of published studies to accurately determine outcomes for infants with stage 4S/MS neuroblastoma.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

 Studies were identified using MEDLINE, Embase, and Cochrane databases using the relevant search terms. Literature reviews, case reports, and adult studies were excluded. Data were extracted independently following article selection by three authors and reviewed by the senior author.

RESULTS

 The original search retrieved 2,325 articles. Following application of exclusion criteria and removing duplicate data, 37 studies (1,105 patients) were included for final review. Overall patient survival was 84%. Twelve studies (544 patients) recorded MYCN status. Mortality in MYCN amplified tumors was 56%. Chromosome 1p/11q status was reported in four studies and 1p/11q deletion carried a 40% fatality rate. Management included observation only (201 patients, 8.5% mortality), surgical resection of primary tumor only (153 patients, 6.5% mortality), chemotherapy only (186 patients, 21% mortality), radiotherapy (5 deaths, 33% mortality), chemotherapy with surgery (160 patients, 10% mortality), surgery with radiotherapy (21 patients, 19% mortality), radiotherapy with chemotherapy (42 patients, 29% mortality), and surgery with chemotherapy and radiotherapy (27 patients, 33% mortality).

CONCLUSION

 There is a significant mortality observed in stage 4S/MS neuroblastoma infants with a dismal outcome observed in those patients with MYCN amplification and 1p/11q deletion. Those patients suitably amenable for conservative management or surgery to excise the primary tumor carry the best prognosis.