Vertical rib plating for the treatment of slipping rib syndrome

Healthcare economic burden of unresolved slipping rib syndrome

Objective

To evaluate the healthcare costs associated with unresolved slipping rib syndrome (SRS).

Methods

Data pertaining to patients who underwent operative repair for SRS at our academic institution were analyzed retrospectively. Duration of symptoms, previous management efforts, number of healthcare provider consultations, imaging studies, adjunctive surgical and pain management procedures performed to treat the symptoms, and prior unsuccessful SRS operations were catalogued. US Medicare billing standards were used to average costs for provider visits and overall cost of surgical and interventional pain management procedures. Analgesic medication costs were determined using generic pricing.

Results

Between February 2019 and January 2024, a total of 435 consecutive patients spent a median of 36 months searching for a diagnosis and symptom relief prior to evaluation at our institution. The median number of physicians consulted was 6 (range, 0-75). The total cost of physician visits was $2,990,434 USD. The median number of imaging studies was 5 (range, 0-55), at a total cost of $965,949. Cholecystectomy was performed in 47 patients (11%), at a cost of $716,750. Previous SRS surgery had been attempted 150 times at various institutions and accounted for $4,500,000 (estimated $30,000 per operation in billing). Intercostal nerve block, ablation, and spinal cord stimulator placement had been performed in 30%, 15%, and 5% of the patients, respectively, at a total cost of $963,821. The median number of analgesic medications used per patient was 1 (mean, 1.3; range, 0-5); the total medication cost was $1,111,860. The total preoperative healthcare cost in our series was $12,445,173, for an average of $28,610 per patient.

Conclusions

SRS remains poorly understood. Symptoms can be severe and debilitating, and patients frequently consume significant healthcare resources. With recognition and definitive surgical management, SRS may be addressed successfully. Prompt treatment has the potential for significant healthcare savings.

Costal margin reconstruction for slipping rib syndrome: Outcomes of more than 500 cases and advancements beyond earlier sutured repair technique

Objectives

To evaluate results of sutured repair for slipping rib syndrome (SRS), identify failure points, and discuss technique modifications to improve outcomes through costal margin reconstruction (CMR).

Methods

Patients undergoing repair of SRS between February 2019 and February 2024 at an academic referral institution were retrospectively analyzed. Pain scores, quality of life, pain medication use, and reoperations were evaluated pre- and postoperatively at 1 and 6 months. In patients failing sutured repair we identified specific failure points and devised a new CMR technique to overcome them. Subsequent CMR patients were followed at 1, 6, 12, 18, and 24 months using the same outcome measures.

Results

Four hundred forty-nine patients underwent repair. Two hundred forty-one patients underwent sutured repair with revision required in 66. Median time to revision was 14 months. CMR was developed and performed in 247 patients. In CMR patients, preoperative mean pain score of 7.5 out of 10 dropped postoperatively to 4.0, 2.5, 1.9, 1.3, and 0.9 at 1, 6, 12, 18, and 24 months, respectively (P < .001). Mean quality of life of 38% improved to 73%, 83%, 88%, 93%, and 95% at the same intervals (P < .001). Preoperatively, 29% of patients chronically used opioid medications. Opioid use dropped postoperatively to 11%, 4%, 4%, 0%, and 0% at the same intervals. Use of nonopioid medications followed a similar pattern. One CMR patient required full revision.

Conclusions

SRS is a debilitating, but correctable disorder. Improved pain and quality of life, reduction in chronic opioid use, and freedom from revision surgery suggest that CMR should be considered the standard operation for SRS.

A Review of Slipping Rib Syndrome: Diagnostic and Treatment Updates to a Rare and Challenging Problem

Slipping rib syndrome (SRS) is a disorder that occurs when one or more of the eighth through tenth ribs become abnormally mobile. SRS is a poorly understood condition leading to a significant delay in diagnosis and therapeutic management. History and a physical exam are usually sufficient for a diagnosis of SRS. The utility of dynamic ultrasounds has also been studied as a useful diagnostic tool. Multiple surgical techniques for SRS have been described within the literature. Cartilage rib excision (CRE) has been the most common technique utilized. However, the literature has shown a high rate of recurrence and associated risks with the procedure. More recently, minimally invasive rib fixation and costal cartilage excision with vertical rib plating have been shown as successful and safe alternative techniques. This may be an effective, alternative approach to CRE in adult and pediatric populations with SRS.

Dynamic musculoskeletal ultrasound: slipping rib, muscle hernia, snapping hip, and peroneal tendon pathology

Dynamic musculoskeletal ultrasound is an important diagnostic tool that allows the practitioner to observe soft tissue structures over a range of motion and identify pathology not diagnosed on other modalities. Familiarity with this modality allows health care practitioners to appropriately refer patients for this type of examination. This article will review several indications for dynamic ultrasound imaging, including slipping rib, muscle hernia, snapping hip, and peroneal tendon pathology. The examination technique and expected findings for common pathology in each location are discussed.

Initial outcomes using cryoablation in surgical management of slipping rib syndrome

INTRODUCTION

Minimally invasive repair of pectus excavatum (MIRPE) and cartilaginous rib excision (CRE) for slipping rib syndrome (SRS) are painful procedures. Intercostal nerve cryoablation (Cryo) controls pain and decreases opioid use in MIRPE. Herein, we describe our experience with cryoablation in CRE.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review was performed of all patients undergoing CRE between 2018 and 2022. Data on demographics, clinical characteristics, operative details, and hospital course were collected.

RESULTS

A total of 98 patients underwent CRE: 68 CRE without cryo, 22 CRE + Cryo, and 8 combined MIRPE + CRE + Cryo. Ninety percent of patients underwent bioabsorbable rib plating. Patients were predominantly female (79%, 73%, 50% respectively) with median ages 17.6, 16.9, and 14.2 years respectively. CRE + Cryo patients used significantly less opioids in hospital (0.6 OME/kg [0.1,1.2]) compared to CRE without cryo (1.0 OME/kg [0.6,2.1]), p < 0.05. The median length of stay (LOS) in CRE + Cryo was 1 day [1,2] compared to 2 days in CRE without cryo [1,2], p = 0.09. MIRPE + CRE + Cryo patients used 0.6 OME/kg [0.2,8.0] with a 2 day [1,5.5] LOS. Ninety-one percent of Cryo patients had cryoablation of T9 and/or T10 intercostal nerves, with no documented abdominal wall laxity at median follow-up of 16 days. Cryo was applied extra-thoracically in CRE + cryo without thoracoscopy or lung isolation, while MIRPE + CRE + Cryo used a combination extra-/intra-thoracic cryoablation in with thoracoscopy.

CONCLUSION

Intercostal nerve cryoablation reduces opioid use and LOS in patients undergoing cartilaginous rib excision for slipping rib syndrome. Cryotherapy to as low as T10 did not result in abdominal wall laxity and can be applied extra-thoracically without the need for thoracoscopy. Ongoing prospective studies are required to assess the long-term outcomes.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Síndromes por atrapamiento del nervio intercostal y sus ramas

Musculoskeletal chest pain poses a broad differential diagnosis, among which intercostal nerve involvement stands out. Its entrapment or that of any of its branches can resemble visceral pain and therefore can easily go unnoticed. With a good examination and the use of dynamic ultrasound, the diagnostic approach can be simpler. We present a 40-year-old man evaluated in a rehabilitation department for right lower rib pain, triggered by certain movements and associated with a pectus excavatum type thoracic deformity. Using dynamic ultrasound maneuvers, he was diagnosed with neuralgia of the 7th right intercostal nerve secondary to dynamic entrapment in the context of a thoracic deformity with costal hypermobility. We describe the clinical presentation, ultrasound imaging, treatment, and evolution after treatment. In this case, we describe entrapment syndromes of the intercostal nerve and its branches, their clinical and ultrasound diagnosis, and their therapeutic approach.

Combined Excision of Costal Cartilage and Rib Plating For Slipped Rib Syndrome

Slipped rib syndrome is often underdiagnosed and can be a source of significant discomfort and frustration for patients. Multiple conservative treatment approaches and surgical procedures have been described in the literature without a definitive standard. We present a case report utilizing two surgical techniques. This includes the excision of the affected costal cartilage in conjunction with placement of bioabsorbable rib plates. This technique could reduce the risk of recurrence as well as restore normal chest wall structure and function.