The Impact of Respiratory Function on Voice in Patients with Presbyphonia

Presbyphonia: A Scoping Review for a Comprehensive Assessment of Aging Voice

BACKGROUND

Presbylarynx refers to age-related changes in the larynx that can manifest clinically as presbyphonia. Several underlying mechanisms remain unclear.

OBJECTIVES

Perform a scoping review of the published literature on the mechanisms of presbyphonia in order to provide an adequate, comprehensive assessment of aging voice.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A scoping review on Medline, Cochrane, and Scopus included 188 published articles. Laryngeal aging results in calcifications of the hyaline cartilages, decreased vocal folds lubrication, decreased neuromotor transmission, decreased hyaluronic acid, increased lamina propria stiffness, and changes in the thyroarytenoid muscles. Concomitant aging of the respiratory system, collateral effects of age-related hormonal changes, concomitant presbycusis, and medical comorbidities interact with the presbylarynx to induce clinically detectable voice aging changes (a weak, breathy, or hoarse voice). Based on the results of our study, we proposed a comprehensive assessment of the aging voice, including all the factors involved.

CONCLUSION

This scoping review proposes a comprehensive assessment of presbyphonia based on the available data. We believe that this assessment will allow a more personalized approach to treatment.

Influence of Sensory Monitoring on Speech Breathing Planning Processes: An Exploratory Study in Aging Speakers Reporting Dyspnea

PURPOSE

Previous studies have suggested that inspirations during speech pauses are influenced by the length of adjacent utterances, owing to respiratory motor planning and physiological recovery processes. The goal of this study was to examine how attention to respiratory sensations may influence these processes in aging speakers with dyspnea, by measuring the effect of sensory monitoring on the relationship between utterance length and the occurrence of inspirations, as well as on functional voice and respiratory measures.

METHOD

Seventeen adults aged 50 years and older with complaints of voicing-related dyspnea completed a repeated-measures protocol consisting of a 2-week baseline phase and a 4-week sensory monitoring phase. Audiovisual recordings of semistructured speech and self-report questionnaires were collected at study onset, after the baseline phase, and after the sensory monitoring phase. Repeated-measures logistic regressions were conducted to examine changes in the relationship between utterance length and the occurrence of inspirations in adjacent pauses, and repeated-measures analyses of variance were used to investigate any changes in functional voice and respiratory measures.

RESULTS

Planning and recovery processes appeared to remain constant across the baseline phase. From postbaseline to postsensory monitoring timepoints, a strengthening of the relationship between the presence of an inspiration during a speech pause and the length of the subsequent-but not preceding-utterance was noted. Significant improvements were noted in voice-related handicap from study onset to postsensory monitoring, but no changes were reported in respiratory comfort during speech.

CONCLUSIONS

Results suggest that respiratory planning processes, that is, the ability to plan breath intakes based on the length of upcoming utterances, may be modifiable behaviorally through targeted sensory monitoring. Further studies are warranted to validate the proposed role of respiratory sensation awareness in achieving skilled temporal coordination between voicing and breathing.

Systematic Review: Singing-Based Interventions to Improve Physical Functions Related to Aging Voice in Older Adults

PURPOSE

This systematic review aimed to evaluate the effects of singing as an intervention for aging voice.

METHOD

Quantitative studies of interventions for older adults with any medical condition that involves singing as training were reviewed, measured by respiration, phonation, and posture, which are the physical functions related to the aging voice. English and Chinese studies published until April 2024 were searched using 31 electronic databases, and seven studies were included. The included articles were assessed according to the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluations rubric.

RESULTS

Seven studies were included. These studies reported outcome measures that were related to respiratory functions only. For the intervention effect, statistically significant improvements were observed in five of the included studies, among which three studies had large effect sizes. The overall level of evidence of the included studies was not high, with three studies having moderate levels and the rest having lower levels. The intervention activities included trainings other than singing. These non-singing training items may have caused co-intervention bias in the study results.

CONCLUSIONS

This systematic review suggests that singing as an intervention for older adults with respiratory and cognitive problems could improve respiration and respiratory-phonatory control. However, none of the included studies covers the other two of the physical functions related to aging voice (phonatory and postural functions). The overall level of evidence of the included studies was not high either. There is a need for more research evidence in singing-based intervention specifically for patient with aging voice.

A Systematic Review of Speech-Language Pathology Interventions for Presbyphonia Using the Rehabilitation Treatment Specification System

BACKGROUND

The prevalence of voice disorders for people aged >65 years is four times higher than for the population at large. The most common cause of dysphonia in this group is presbyphonia, the preferred first-line treatment for which is voice therapy with a speech-language pathologist. This systematic review seeks to identify how voice therapy affects multidimensional voice outcomes in people with presbyphonia.

METHODS

A systematic search of CINAHL, Embase, Emcare, MEDLINE, and Google Scholar was conducted in March 2023. Comparative and noncomparative studies of voice therapy in participants aged >50 years with presbyphonia were considered for inclusion. No limitations were placed on date or language of publication. Study quality and risk of bias were assessed with the Cochrane Risk of Bias 2 tool and the Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies. Subgroup analysis was used to compare studies based on participant sex, intervention duration, study design, and intervention content. Interventions were specified using the Rehabilitation Treatment Specification System (RTSS) employing a consensus methodology among reviewers. The results were synthesized utilizing meta-analysis when outcomes were adequately specified and narrative analysis when they were not.

RESULTS

Twenty-three studies were included with 1050 subjects (mean age: 72.5 ± 8.6 years; 51% female). The most reported intervention was vocal function exercises. Per the RTSS, 14 interventions employed a predominantly Organ Functions approach, and the 14 remaining interventions employed a Skills & Habits approach. Meta-analysis confirmed posttherapy improvement in patient-related outcome measures of 0.93 standard mean difference (P < 0.00001, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.70-1.17); studies with predominantly males and with longer treatment periods were associated with larger improvements, while randomized controlled trials reported more modest improvements. Meta-analysis also identified a mean posttherapy increase in maximum phonation time (MPT) of 5.37 seconds (P < 0.00001, 95% CI: 3.52-7.22). Treatments with an Organ Functions focus resulted in greater gains in MPT than those with a Skills & Habits focus (7.52 seconds versus 2.90 seconds). Finally, meta-analysis identified reductions in acoustic perturbation measures (jitter: 0.62%, P < 0.001, 95% CI: 0.26%-0.97%; shimmer 1.05%, P < 0.00001, 95% CI: 0.67%-1.44%). Narrative synthesis further identified improvement in auditory-perceptual voice quality in all active treatment groups as well as improved glottal function in most studies that reported this.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the uncertainty around internal validity introduced by the inclusion of a wide range of study designs, there is convincing evidence that voice therapy for presbyphonia results in significant improvement in patient-reported, aerodynamic, acoustic, and expert-rated voice outcomes. Treatments with an Organ Functions focus may better address the underlying physiological deficits of presbyphonia, although future comparative studies with multidimensional voice assessment are warranted.

The Influence of Presbylarynx Status on Objective Measures of the Aging Voice

OBJECTIVE

The primary objective of this study was to assess objective voice measures in an elderly population representative of those seen in a tertiary laryngology practice, stratified by sex and presbylarynx status, and compare their measures to each other and to a cohort of young adult patients aged 40 years or less. The secondary objectives of this study were to evaluate and compare the strobovideolaryngoscopy findings across all groups and compare the voice complaints and subjective questionnaire results between the presbylarynx and non-presbylarynx groups.

METHODS

Two hundred and eighty-six adult voice patients (147 females/139 males) were included in this study and stratified into one of three groups: (1) young adults aged 40 years or less (n = 122), (2) patients over the age of 60 without presbylarynx (n = 78), and (3) patients over the age of 60 with a diagnosis of presbylarynx (n = 86). The acoustic analysis included fundamental frequency (F₀), voice intensity, standard deviation of the fundamental frequency (SDFF), jitter (Jitt), relative average perturbation (RAP), shimmer (Shim), noise-to-harmonic ratio (NHR), and others. The aerodynamic and pulmonary assessment included maximum phonation time (MPT), S/Z ratio, mean flow rate (MFR), forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV₁), and maximal mid-expiratory flow (FEF_25-75). Coexisting vocal fold conditions and pathologies were also characterized and compared. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS 28.0.0.0 (IBM, Armonk, NY). All tests were performed in two-tailed, and a P value of less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

Assessment of vocal fold features revealed a significantly higher prevalence of benign vocal fold lesions in the young adult group for males and females compared to both elderly groups but significantly lower prevalence of vocal fold edema only in young adult females compared to the elderly female groups. Among males, young adults differed significantly from both elderly groups with regard to SDFF, Shim, FEV₁, and FEF_25-75. However, Jitt and RAP only differed significantly between the young adult and presbylarynx groups. Among females, young adults differed significantly from both elderly groups for F₀, SDFF, Jitt, RAP, NHR, CPP, MFR, FEV₁, and FEF_25-75. However, the non-presbylarynx group had a significantly lower S/Z ratio than the young adult and presbylarynx groups. A comparison of voice complaints between elderly groups revealed breathiness to be significantly more common in the presbylarynx group compared to the non-presbylarynx group, but no other significant differences were found in voice complaints or questionnaire scores.

CONCLUSION

When interpreting objective voice measures, it is critical to consider differences in vocal fold features alongside age-related changes. In addition, sex-related differences in anatomy and the aging process may explain discrepancies in significant findings between young adults and elderly patients stratified by presbylarynx status. However, presbylarynx status alone appears insufficient to generate significant differences in most objective voice measures among the elderly. Yet, presbylarynx status may be sufficient to generate differences in perceptual voice symptoms.

Quantification of Vocal Fold Atrophy in Age‐Related and Parkinson's Disease‐Related Vocal Atrophy

OBJECTIVE

Vocal fold atrophy (VFA) is associated with aging and Parkinson's disease (PD). Clinical diagnosis of VFA depends on several visual-perceptual laryngostroboscopy findings that are inherently subjective. The purpose of this study was to use quantitative measurements to; (1) examine the relationships between VFA and dysphonia severity and (2) evaluate differences in VFA in patients with age-related VFA versus PD.

METHODS

Thirty-six patients >60 years of age with VFA were included in this retrospective cohort study. Demographic information, medical history, Consensus Auditory-Perceptual Evaluation of Voice (CAPE-V), Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI-10), and still images from the stroboscopic exam were obtained. Image J™ was used to measure VFA, including bowing index (BI), normalized glottal gap area, and normalized mucosal wave amplitude. Pearson's correlation was used to evaluate the relationship between VFA, CAPE-V, and VHI-10. t-Tests and multivariate linear regression were used to compare VFA measures by dysphonia severity (CAPE-V <30 vs. >30) and diagnosis (age-related vocal atrophy [ARVA] and PD).

RESULTS

BI was positively correlated with CAPE-V. Patients with CAPE-V >30 had a significantly larger BI compared to those with CAPE-V <30. Patients with PD had significantly larger BI than those with ARVA. Diagnosis of PD also predicted a larger BI after controlling for age and CAPE-V.

CONCLUSION

Quantitative measures supported an association between bowing severity and dysphonia severity in patients with PD and ARVA. A PD diagnosis significantly predicted more severe BI. These findings demonstrate the potential utility of BI. Quantitative VFA measures might also provide insight into the mechanisms of ARVA and dysphonia.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

3 Laryngoscope, 133:1462-1469, 2023.