CO2 activation on small Cu-Ni and Cu-Pd bimetallic clusters

A systematic theoretical study of CO2 hydrogenation towards methanol on Cu-based bimetallic catalysts: role of the CHO&CH3OH descriptor in thermodynamic analysis

The application of density functional theory (DFT) has enriched our understanding of methanol synthesis through CO2 hydrogenation on Cu-based catalysts. However, variations in catalytic performance under different metal doping conditions have hindered the development of universal catalytic principles. To address these challenges, we systematically investigated the scaling relationships of adsorption energy among different reaction intermediates on pure Cu, Au-Cu, Ni-Cu, Pt-Cu, Pd-Cu and Zn-Cu models. Additionally, by summing the respective adsorption energies of two separate species, we have developed a dual intermediate descriptor of CHO&CH3OH, capable of achieving computational accuracy on par with DFT results using the multiple linear regression method, all the while enabling the rapid prediction of thermodynamic properties at various stages of methanol synthesis. This method facilitates a better understanding of the coupling mechanisms between energy and linear expressions on copper-based substrates, and the universal linear criterion can be applied to other catalytic systems, with the aim of pursuing potential catalysts having both high efficiency and low cost.

CO2 and H2 Activation on Zinc-Doped Copper Clusters

Here we systematically investigate the CO2 and H2 activation and dissociation on small Cun Zn0/+ (n=3-6) clusters using Density Functional Theory. We show that Cu6 Zn is a superatom, displaying an increased HOMO-LUMO gap and is inert towards CO2 or H2 activation or dissociation. While other neutral clusters weakly activate CO2 , the cationic clusters preferentially bind the CO2 in monodentate nonactivated way. Notably, Cu4 Zn allows for the dissociation of activated CO2 , whereas larger clusters destabilize all activated CO2 binding modes. Conversely, H2 dissociation is favored on all clusters examined, except for Cu6 Zn. Cu3 Zn+ and Cu4 Zn, favor the formation of formate through the H2 dissociation pathway rather than CO2 dissociation. These findings suggest the potential of these clusters as synthetic targets and underscore their significance in the realm of CO2 hydrogenation.

Heterogeneous Catalytic Systems for Carbon Dioxide Hydrogenation to Value-Added Chemicals

Utilizing renewable energy to hydrogenate carbon dioxide into fuels eliminates massive CO2 emissions from the atmosphere and diminishes our need for using fossil fuels. This review presents the most recent developments for designing heterogeneous catalysts for the hydrogenation of CO2 to formate, methanol, and C2+ hydrocarbons. Thermodynamic challenges and mechanistic insights are discussed, providing a strong foundation to propose a suitable catalyst. The main body of this review focuses on nanostructured catalysts for constructing efficient heterogeneous systems. The most important factors affecting catalytic performance are highlighted, including active metals, supports and promoters that can potentially be used. The summary of the results and the outlook are presented in the final section. During the past few decades, heterogeneous CO2 hydrogenation has gained much attention and made tremendous progress. Thus, many highly efficient catalysts have been studied to discover their active sites and provide mechanistic insights. This paper summarizes recent advances in CO2 hydrogenation and its conversion into various hydrocarbons such as formate, methanol, and C2+ products. As for formate production, Au and Ru nanocatalysts show superior activity. However, considering the catalyst cost, Cu-based catalysts have an excellent prospect for methanol production, among other catalysts. Ultra-small nanoparticles and nanoclusters appear promising to provide highly active cost-effective catalysts. A growing number of researchers are investigating the possibility of directly synthesizing C2+ products through CO2 hydrogenation. The major challenge in producing heavy hydrocarbons is breaking the ASF limitations, which have been achieved over bifunctional catalysts using zeolites. Using suitable support and promoter can lead to a superior activity, ascribed to structural, electronic, and chemical promotional effects.

Adsorption, activation, and conversion of carbon dioxide on small copper-tin nanoclusters

Carbon dioxide (CO₂) conversion to value-added chemicals is an attractive solution to reduce globally accelerating CO₂ emissions. Among the non-precious and abundant metals tested so far, copper (Cu) is one of the best electrocatalysts to convert CO₂ into more than thirty different hydrocarbons and alcohols. However, the selectivity for desired products is often too low. We present a computational investigation of the effects of nanostructuring, doping, and support on the activity and selectivity of Cu-Sn catalysts. Density functional theory calculations were conducted to explore the possibility of using small Cu-Sn clusters, Cu_4-nSn_n (n = 0-4), isolated or supported on graphene and γ-Al₂O₃, to activate CO₂ and convert it to carbon monoxide (CO) and formic acid (HCOOH). First, a detailed analysis of the structure, stability, and electronic properties of Cu_4-nSn_n clusters and their ability to absorb and activate CO₂ was considered. Then, the kinetics of the gas phase CO₂ direct dissociation on Cu_4-nSn_n to generate CO was determined. Finally, the mechanism of electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction to CO and HCOOH on Cu_4-nSn_n, Cu_4-nSn_n/graphene and Cu_4-nSn_n/γ-Al₂O₃ was computed. The selectivity towards the competitive electrochemical hydrogen evolution reaction on these catalysts was also considered. The Cu₂Sn₂ cluster suppresses the hydrogen evolution reaction and is highly selective towards CO, if unsupported, or HCOOH if supported on graphene. This study demonstrates that the Cu₂Sn₂ cluster is a potential candidate for the electrocatalytic conversion of the CO₂ molecule. Moreover, it identifies insightful structure-property relationships in Cu-based nanocatalysts, highlighting the influence of composition and catalyst support on CO₂ activation.

Oxidative dehydrogenation of cyclohexene on atomically precise subnanometer Cu4-nPdn (0 ≤ n ≤ 4) tetramer clusters: the effect of cluster composition and support on performance

The pronounced effects of the composition of four-atom monometallic Cu and Pd and bimetallic CuPd clusters and the support on the catalytic activity and selectivity in the oxidative dehydrogenation of cyclohexene are reported. The ultra-nanocrystalline diamond supported clusters are highly active and dominantly produce benzene; some of the mixed clusters also produce cyclohexadiene, which are all clusters with a much suppressed combustion channel. The also highly active TiO₂-supported tetramers solely produce benzene, without any combustion to CO₂. The selectivity of the zirconia-supported mixed CuPd clusters and the monometallic Cu cluster is entirely different; though they are less active in comparison to clusters with other supports, these clusters produce significant fractions of cyclohexadiene, with their selectivity towards cyclohexadiene gradually increasing with the increasing number of copper atoms in the cluster, reaching about 50% for Cu₃Pd₁. The zirconia-supported copper tetramer stands out from among all the other tetramers in this reaction, with a selectivity towards cyclohexadiene of 70%, which far exceeds those of all the other cluster-support combinations. The findings from this study indicate a positive effect of copper on the stability of the mixed tetramers and potential new ways of fine-tuning catalyst performance by controlling the composition of the active site and via cluster-support interactions in complex oxidative reactions under the suppression of the undesired combustion of the feed.

Optimal Icosahedral Copper-Based Bimetallic Clusters for the Selective Electrocatalytic CO2 Conversion to One Carbon Products

Electrochemical CO2 reduction reactions can lead to high value-added chemical and materials production while helping decrease anthropogenic CO2 emissions. Copper metal clusters can reduce CO2 to more than thirty different hydrocarbons and oxygenates yet they lack the required selectivity. We present a computational characterization of the role of nano-structuring and alloying in Cu-based catalysts on the activity and selectivity of CO2 reduction to generate the following one-carbon products: carbon monoxide (CO), formic acid (HCOOH), formaldehyde (H2C=O), methanol (CH3OH) and methane (CH4). The structures and energetics were determined for the adsorption, activation, and conversion of CO2 on monometallic and bimetallic (decorated and core@shell) 55-atom Cu-based clusters. The dopant metals considered were Ag, Cd, Pd, Pt, and Zn, located at different coordination sites. The relative binding strength of the intermediates were used to identify the optimal catalyst for the selective CO2 conversion to one-carbon products. It was discovered that single atom Cd or Zn doping is optimal for the conversion of CO2 to CO. The core@shell models with Ag, Pd and Pt provided higher selectivity for formic acid and formaldehyde. The Cu-Pt and Cu-Pd showed lowest overpotential for methane formation.

Mechanism of Catalytic CO2 Hydrogenation to Methane and Methanol Using a Bimetallic Cu3Pd Cluster at a Zirconia Support

For very small nanocluster-based catalysts, the exploration of the influence of the particle size, composition, and support offers precisely variable parameters in a wide material search space to control catalysts' performance. We present the mechanism of the CO₂ methanation reaction on the oxidized bimetallic Cu₃Pd tetramer (Cu₃PdO₂) supported on a zirconia model support represented by Zr₁₂O₂₄ based on the energy profile obtained from density functional theory calculations on the reaction of CO₂ and H₂. In order to determine the role of the Pd atom, the performance of Cu₃PdO₂ with monometallic Cu₄O₂ at the same support has been compared. Parallel to methane formation, the alternative path of methanol formation at this catalyst has also been investigated. The results show that the exchange of a single atom in Cu₄ with a single Pd atom improves catalyst/s performance via lowering the barriers associated with hydrogen dissociation steps that occur on the Pd atom. The above-mentioned results suggest that the doping strategy at the level of single atoms can offer a precise control knob for designing new catalysts with desired performance.

Mo3(C6O6)2 monolayer as a promising electrocatalyst for the CO2 reduction reaction: a first-principles study

Mo3(C6O6)2 monolayers are potential electrocatalysts for CO2 reduction reaction (CRR). The electrochemical performances can be further improved by coordinating with hydroxyl groups, which show improved performance for the production of methane.

Impacts of the Catalyst Structures on CO2 Activation on Catalyst Surfaces

Utilizing CO2 as a sustainable carbon source to form valuable products requires activating it by active sites on catalyst surfaces. These active sites are usually in or below the nanometer scale. Some metals and metal oxides can catalyze the CO2 transformation reactions. On metal oxide-based catalysts, CO2 transformations are promoted significantly in the presence of surface oxygen vacancies or surface defect sites. Electrons transferable to the neutral CO2 molecule can be enriched on oxygen vacancies, which can also act as CO2 adsorption sites. CO2 activation is also possible without necessarily transferring electrons by tailoring catalytic sites that promote interactions at an appropriate energy level alignment of the catalyst and CO2 molecule. This review discusses CO2 activation on various catalysts, particularly the impacts of various structural factors, such as oxygen vacancies, on CO2 activation.

Screening of transition metal doped copper clusters for CO2 activation

Activation of CO₂ is the first step towards its reduction to more useful chemicals. Here we systematically investigate the CO₂ activation mechanism on Cu₃X (X is a first-row transition metal atom) using density functional theory computations. The CO₂ adsorption energies and the activation mechanisms depend strongly on the selected dopant. The dopant electronegativity, the HOMO-LUMO gap and the overlap of the frontier molecular orbitals control the CO₂ dissociation efficiency. Our calculations reveal that early transition metal-doped (Sc, Ti, V) clusters exhibit a high CO₂ adsorption energy, a low activation barrier for its dissociation, and a facile regeneration of the clusters. Thus, early transition metal-doped copper clusters, particularly Cu₃Sc, may be efficient catalysts for the carbon capture and utilization process.

CO2 activation and dissociation on In2O3(110) supported PdnPt(4-n) (n = 0-4) catalysts: a density functional theory study

Converting CO2 into valuable chemicals via catalytic reactions can mitigate both the greenhouse effect and energy shortage problems, thus designing efficient catalysts have attracted considerable attention over the past decades. In this work, a density functional theory (DFT) calculation was carried out to investigate the CO2 activation and dissociation processes on various PdnPt(4-n)/In2O3 (n = 0-4) catalysts. The PdnPt(4-n)/In2O3 models were initially built, and the interface sites of PdnPt(4-n)/In2O3 for CO2 adsorption were confirmed among cluster sites and substrate sites. The CO2 adsorption geometries, charger transfer, and projected density of states (PDOS) were analyzed to study the CO2-PdnPt(4-n)/In2O3 interactions. From the adsorbed *CO2, the transition states (TSs) for CO2 dissociation to form *CO and *O were gained to reveal the characteristics of the activated CO2δ-. Overall, according to the adsorption energy Eads results, the bimetallic PdPt3/In2O3 and Pd3Pt/In2O3 catalysts showed the strongest and weakest CO2 adsorption stabilities, respectively, while the Pd element addition decreases the barriers for CO2 dissociation with the priority order of Pd4 > Pd3Pt > Pd2Pt2 > PdPt3 > Pt4. The Brønsted-Evans-Polanyi (BEP) relation between activation barriers (Eb) and reaction energies E was obtained for the CO2 dissociation mechanism on PdnPt(4-n)/In2O3 catalysts with the equation of E = 0.20Eb + 0.40. Finally, the optimal Pd2Pt2/In2O3 catalyst for CO2 activation and dissociation was proposed. This study provides useful information for CO2 activation and conversation procedures on bimetal-oxide catalysts, and helps to take the optimal design of PdPt/In2O3 catalysts for the CO2 reaction.

Adsorption and Activation of CO2 on Small-Sized Cu-Zr Bimetallic Clusters

Adsorption and activation of CO₂ is a key step in any chemical reaction, which aims to convert it to other useful chemicals. Therefore, it is important to understand the factors that drive the activation process and also search for materials that promote the process. We employ the density functional theory to explore the possibility of using small-sized bimetallic Cu-Zr clusters, Cu_4-nZr_n, with n = 1-3 for the above-mentioned key step. Our results suggest that after adsorption, a CO₂ molecule preferably resides on Zr atoms or at the bridge and triangular faces formed by Zr atoms in bimetallic Cu-Zr clusters accompanied with its high degree of activation. Importantly, maximum activation occurs when CO₂ is adsorbed on the CuZr₃ cluster. Interestingly, we find that the adsorption energy of CO₂ can be tuned by varying the extent of the Zr atom in Cu-Zr clusters. We rationalize the high adsorption of CO₂ with the increase in the number of Zr atoms using the d-band center model and the concept of chemical hardness. The strong chemisorption and high activation of CO₂ are ascribed to charge migration between Cu-Zr clusters and the CO₂ molecule. We find an additional band in the infrared vibrational spectra of CO₂ chemisorbed on all of the clusters, which is absent in the case of free CO₂. We also observe that the energy barriers for the direct dissociation of the CO₂ molecule to CO and O decrease significantly on bimetallic Cu-Zr clusters as compared to that on pure Cu₄. In particular, the barrier heights are considerably small for Cu₃Zr and CuZr₃ clusters. This study demonstrates that Cu₃Zr and CuZr₃ clusters may serve as good candidates for activation and dissociation of the CO₂ molecule.

Ab initio screening of Pt-based transition-metal nanoalloys using descriptors derived from the adsorption and activation of CO2

In this study, we report an ab initio screening, based on density functional theory calculations, of Pt-based transition-metal nanoalloys using physicochemical descriptors derived from the adsorption and activation of CO2 on 55-atom nanoclusters, namely, PtnTM55-n, with n = 0, 13, 42, 55, TM = Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Ru, Rh, Pd, Ag, Os, Ir, Au. From the adsorption on the unary and binary nanoclusters, at the chemisorption regime (bent CO2), we identified a linear correlation between the interaction energy and charge transfer from the nanoclusters towards CO2 and the bent CO2 angle; moreover, the interaction energy is enhanced for larger values of the molecular charge and angle. The alloying of Cu55, Ag55, and Au55 with Pt provides a path to change the CO2 adsorption from physisorption (linear, non-activated) to chemisorption (enhanced interaction energies, bent, activated), while the strong interaction energy of CO2 with Os55, Ru55, and Fe55 can be decreased by alloying with Pt using different structural configurations, i.e., the trends are similar for core-shell and segregated structures. Thus, based on our results and analyses, we can select different combinations of PtnTM55-n nanoalloys to yield the desired interaction strength and magnitude of the charge transfer towards the activated anionic CO2, which can help in the design of nanocatalysts for CO2 activation or different chemical reactions in which charge transfer plays a crucial role.

Novel Heterogeneous Catalysts for CO2 Hydrogenation to Liquid Fuels

Carbon dioxide (CO₂) hydrogenation to liquid fuels including gasoline, jet fuel, diesel, methanol, ethanol, and other higher alcohols via heterogeneous catalysis, using renewable energy, not only effectively alleviates environmental problems caused by massive CO₂ emissions, but also reduces our excessive dependence on fossil fuels. In this Outlook, we review the latest development in the design of novel and very promising heterogeneous catalysts for direct CO₂ hydrogenation to methanol, liquid hydrocarbons, and higher alcohols. Compared with methanol production, the synthesis of products with two or more carbons (C₂₊) faces greater challenges. Highly efficient synthesis of C₂₊ products from CO₂ hydrogenation can be achieved by a reaction coupling strategy that first converts CO₂ to carbon monoxide or methanol and then conducts a C-C coupling reaction over a bifunctional/multifunctional catalyst. Apart from the catalytic performance, unique catalyst design ideas, and structure-performance relationship, we also discuss current challenges in catalyst development and perspectives for industrial applications.