Necrosis, sarcolemmal damage and apoptotic events in myofibers rejected by CD8+ lymphocytes: Observations in nonhuman primates

Human MuStem cells are competent to fuse with nonhuman primate myofibers in a clinically relevant transplantation context: A proof-of-concept study

We previously reported that human muscle-derived stem cells (hMuStem cells) contribute to tissue repair after local administration into injured skeletal muscle or infarcted heart in immunodeficient rodent models. However, extrapolation of these findings to a clinical context is problematic owing to the considerable differences often seen between in vivo findings in humans versus rodents. Therefore, we investigated whether the muscle regenerative behavior of hMuStem cells is maintained in a clinically relevant transplantation context. Human MuStem cells were intramuscularly administered by high-density microinjection matrices into nonhuman primates receiving tacrolimus-based immunosuppression thereby reproducing the protocol that has so far produced the best results in clinical trials of cell therapy in myopathies. Four and 9 weeks after administration, histological analysis of cell injection sites revealed large numbers of hMuStem cell-derived nuclei in all cases. Most graft-derived nuclei were distributed in small myofiber groups in which no signs of a specific immune response were observed. Importantly, hMuStem cells contributed to simian tissue repair by fusing mainly with host myofibers, demonstrating their capacity for myofiber regeneration in this model. Together, these findings obtained in a valid preclinical model provide new insights supporting the potential of hMuStem cells in future cell therapies for muscle diseases.

Establishment of Skeletal Myogenic Progenitors from Non-Human Primate Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells

Pluripotent stem (PS) cells enable the scalable production of tissue-specific derivatives with therapeutic potential for various clinical applications, including muscular dystrophies. Given the similarity to human counterparts, the non-human primate (NHP) is an ideal preclinical model to evaluate several questions, including delivery, biodistribution, and immune response. While the generation of human-induced PS (iPS)-cell-derived myogenic progenitors is well established, there have been no data for NHP counterparts, probably due to the lack of an efficient system to differentiate NHP iPS cells towards the skeletal muscle lineage. Here, we report the generation of three independent Macaca fascicularis iPS cell lines and their myogenic differentiation using PAX7 conditional expression. The whole-transcriptome analysis confirmed the successful sequential induction of mesoderm, paraxial mesoderm, and myogenic lineages. NHP myogenic progenitors efficiently gave rise to myotubes under appropriate in vitro differentiation conditions and engrafted in vivo into the TA muscles of NSG and FKRP-NSG mice. Lastly, we explored the preclinical potential of these NHP myogenic progenitors in a single wild-type NHP recipient, demonstrating engraftment and characterizing the interaction with the host immune response. These studies establish an NHP model system through which iPS-cell-derived myogenic progenitors can be studied.

Myogenic Cell Transplantation in Genetic and Acquired Diseases of Skeletal Muscle

This article will review myogenic cell transplantation for congenital and acquired diseases of skeletal muscle. There are already a number of excellent reviews on this topic, but they are mostly focused on a specific disease, muscular dystrophies and in particular Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy. There are also recent reviews on cell transplantation for inflammatory myopathies, volumetric muscle loss (VML) (this usually with biomaterials), sarcopenia and sphincter incontinence, mainly urinary but also fecal. We believe it would be useful at this stage, to compare the same strategy as adopted in all these different diseases, in order to outline similarities and differences in cell source, pre-clinical models, administration route, and outcome measures. This in turn may help to understand which common or disease-specific problems have so far limited clinical success of cell transplantation in this area, especially when compared to other fields, such as epithelial cell transplantation. We also hope that this may be useful to people outside the field to get a comprehensive view in a single review. As for any cell transplantation procedure, the choice between autologous and heterologous cells is dictated by a number of criteria, such as cell availability, possibility of in vitro expansion to reach the number required, need for genetic correction for many but not necessarily all muscular dystrophies, and immune reaction, mainly to a heterologous, even if HLA-matched cells and, to a minor extent, to the therapeutic gene product, a possible antigen for the patient. Finally, induced pluripotent stem cell derivatives, that have entered clinical experimentation for other diseases, may in the future offer a bank of immune-privileged cells, available for all patients and after a genetic correction for muscular dystrophies and other myopathies.

Stem cell therapy for muscular dystrophies

Muscular dystrophies are a heterogeneous group of genetic diseases, characterized by progressive degeneration of skeletal and cardiac muscle. Despite the intense investigation of different therapeutic options, a definitive treatment has not been developed for this debilitating class of pathologies. Cell-based therapies in muscular dystrophies have been pursued experimentally for the last three decades. Several cell types with different characteristics and tissues of origin, including myogenic stem and progenitor cells, stromal cells, and pluripotent stem cells, have been investigated over the years and have recently entered in the clinical arena with mixed results. In this Review, we do a roundup of the past attempts and describe the updated status of cell-based therapies aimed at counteracting the skeletal and cardiac myopathy present in dystrophic patients. We present current challenges, summarize recent progress, and make recommendations for future research and clinical trials.

Human Muscle Precursor Cells Form Human-Derived Myofibers in Skeletal Muscles of Nonhuman Primates: A Potential New Preclinical Setting to Test Myogenic Cells of Human Origin for Cell Therapy of Myopathies

This study aimed to verify if human myogenic cells could participate in muscle regeneration in macaques. This experimental setting would grant researchers a model that could better evaluate the effects of cell therapies in myopathies with a better translation to human patients. Human muscle precursor cells (MPCs) were cultured in vitro and transduced with ß-galactosidase. The cells were subsequently injected into 1-cm3 muscle regions of 6 macaques immunosuppressed with tacrolimus and dexamethasone. Allogeneic ß-galactosidase+ MPCs were injected in other regions as positive controls. Some cell-grafted regions were electroporated to induce extensive muscle regeneration. MPC-grafted regions were sampled 1 month later and analyzed by histology. There were ß-galactosidase+ myofibers in both the regions grafted with human and macaque MPCs. Electroporation increased the engraftment of human MPCs in the same way as in macaque allografts. The histological analysis (hematoxylin and eosin, CD8, and CD4 immunodetection) demonstrated an absence of cellular rejection in most MPC-grafted regions, as well as minimal lymphocytic infiltration in the regions transplanted with human MPCs in the individual with the lowest tacrolimus levels. Circulating de novo anti-donor antibodies were not detected. In conclusion, we report the successful engraftment of human myogenic cells in macaques, which was possible using tacrolimus-based immunosuppression.

Cell therapy to improve regeneration of skeletal muscle injuries

Diseases that jeopardize the musculoskeletal system and cause chronic impairment are prevalent throughout the Western world. In Germany alone, ~1.8 million patients suffer from these diseases annually, and medical expenses have been reported to reach 34.2bn Euros. Although musculoskeletal disorders are seldom fatal, they compromise quality of life and diminish functional capacity. For example, musculoskeletal disorders incur an annual loss of over 0.8 million workforce years to the German economy. Among these diseases, traumatic skeletal muscle injuries are especially problematic because they can occur owing to a variety of causes and are very challenging to treat. In contrast to chronic muscle diseases such as dystrophy, sarcopenia, or cachexia, traumatic muscle injuries inflict damage to localized muscle groups. Although minor muscle trauma heals without severe consequences, no reliable clinical strategy exists to prevent excessive fibrosis or fatty degeneration, both of which occur after severe traumatic injury and contribute to muscle degeneration and dysfunction. Of the many proposed strategies, cell-based approaches have shown the most promising results in numerous pre-clinical studies and have demonstrated success in the handful of clinical trials performed so far. A number of myogenic and non-myogenic cell types benefit muscle healing, either by directly participating in new tissue formation or by stimulating the endogenous processes of muscle repair. These cell types operate via distinct modes of action, and they demonstrate varying levels of feasibility for muscle regeneration depending, to an extent, on the muscle injury model used. While in some models the injury naturally resolves over time, other models have been developed to recapitulate the peculiarities of real-life injuries and therefore mimic the structural and functional impairment observed in humans. Existing limitations of cell therapy approaches include issues related to autologous harvesting, expansion and sorting protocols, optimal dosage, and viability after transplantation. Several clinical trials have been performed to treat skeletal muscle injuries using myogenic progenitor cells or multipotent stromal cells, with promising outcomes. Recent improvements in our understanding of cell behaviour and the mechanistic basis for their modes of action have led to a new paradigm in cell therapies where physical, chemical, and signalling cues presented through biomaterials can instruct cells and enhance their regenerative capacity. Altogether, these studies and experiences provide a positive outlook on future opportunities towards innovative cell-based solutions for treating traumatic muscle injuries-a so far unmet clinical need.

Sarcolemmal Complement Membrane Attack Complex Deposits During Acute Rejection of Myofibers in Nonhuman Primates

We have previously studied in nonhuman primates several aspects of the acute rejection of myofibers, including the histological characteristics, the mechanisms of myofiber elimination by the T cells, and the development of anti-donor antibodies. Here, we report the participation of the complement membrane attack complex (MAC) in this context. We used muscle sections of macaques from experiments of allogeneic muscle precursor cell transplantation with confirmed rejection of the graft-derived myofibers. Sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin, alizarin red and for immunodetection of MAC, CD8, CD4, C3, C4d, and immunoglobulins. The prominent finding was the presence of sarcolemmal MAC (sMAC) deposits in biopsies with ongoing acute rejection or with recent acute rejection. The numbers of sMAC-positive myofibers were variable, being higher when there was an intense lymphocyte infiltration. Few sMAC-positive myofibers were necrotic or had evidence of sarcolemma permeation. The immunodetection of C3, C4d, and immunoglobulins did not provide significant elements. In conclusion, sMAC deposits were related to myofiber rejection. The fact that the vast majority of sMAC-positive myofibers had no signs of necrosis or sarcolemmal permeation suggests that MAC would not be harmful to myofibers by itself.

De Novo Circulating Antidonor's Cell Antibodies During Induced Acute Rejection of Allogeneic Myofibers in Myogenic Cell Transplantation: A Study in Nonhuman Primates

Background

Transplantation of myogenic cells has potential applications in the treatment of muscle pathologies. Excluding purely autologous cell transplantation, graft viability depends on an adequate control of acute rejection (AR). To contribute in understanding AR in this context, we analyzed whether de novo circulating antibodies against donor’s cells are detected during induced AR of graft-derived myofibers in nonhuman primates.

Methods

We allotransplanted satellite cell-derived myoblasts in macaques immunosuppressed with tacrolimus. To induce AR of graft-derived myofibers, we administered tacrolimus for 4 weeks to allow complete myofiber formation, and then we stopped tacrolimus administration. Cell-grafted sites were biopsied at tacrolimus withdrawal and then every 2 weeks and analyzed by histology until AR completion. Blood samples were taken before immunosuppression, at tacrolimus withdrawal and then every 2 weeks to detect antibodies against the donor’s cells by flow cytometry.

Results

There was an increase of antibodies against the donor’s cells related to AR in all monkeys. This increase was variable in intensity, and preceded, coincided or followed the histological evidence of AR (focal accumulations of lymphocytes) and/or the loss of myofibers of donor origin, and remained until the end of the follow-up (up to 8 weeks after tacrolimus withdrawal).

Conclusions

Flow cytometry detection of de novo circulating antibodies against the donor’s cells was consistently associated with AR. A clear increase in this antibody detection indicated current or recent AR. Smaller increases in comparison to the preimmunosuppression values were not associated with AR.

Satellite cell therapy - from mice to men

Satellite cells are rare mononuclear skeletal muscle-resident cells that are the chief contributors to regenerative myogenesis following muscle injury. Although first identified more than 50 years ago, it is only recently that the murine satellite cell has become molecularly defined with the ability to prospectively isolate these cells from their niche. Human satellite cells are considerably less well understood with relatively few studies having been performed on them. In this review, a critical evaluation of this literature is provided along with a discussion of the practical and methodological issues involved with research on human satellite cells. The therapeutic potential of these and other cells types is also discussed, and the various challenges that face satellite cell therapy are addressed.