The importance of an integrated genotype-phenotype strategy to unravel the molecular bases of titinopathies

Inferring disease course from differential exon usage in the wide titinopathy spectrum

OBJECTIVE

Biallelic titin truncating variants (TTNtv) have been associated with a wide phenotypic spectrum, ranging from complex prenatal muscle diseases with dysmorphic features to adult-onset limb-girdle muscular dystrophy, with or without cardiac involvement. Given the size and complexity of TTN, reaching an unequivocal molecular diagnosis and precise disease prognosis remains challenging.

METHODS

In this case series, 12 unpublished cases and one already published case with biallelic TTNtv were collected from multiple international medical centers between November 2022 and September 2023. TTN mutations were detected through exome or genome sequencing. Information about familial and personal clinical history was collected in a standardized form. RNA-sequencing and analysis of TTN exon usage were performed on an internal sample cohort including postnatal skeletal muscles, fetal skeletal muscles, postnatal heart muscles, and fetal heart muscles. In addition, publicly available RNA-sequencing data was retrieved from ENCODE.

RESULTS

We generated new RNA-seq data on TTN exons and identified genotype-phenotype correlations with prognostic implications for each titinopathy patient (whether worsening or improving in prenatal and postnatal life) using percentage spliced in (PSI) data for the involved exons. Interestingly, thanks to exon usage, we were also able to rule out a titinopathy diagnosis in one prenatal case.

INTERPRETATION

This study demonstrates that exon usage provides valuable insights for a more exhaustive clinical interpretation of TTNtv; additionally, it may serve as a model for implementing personalized medicine in many other genetic diseases, since most genes undergo alternative splicing.

Titin copy number variations associated with dominant inherited phenotypes

BACKGROUND

Titinopathies are caused by mutations in the titin gene (TTN). Titin is the largest known human protein; its gene has the longest coding phase with 364 exons. Titinopathies are very complex neuromuscular pathologies due to the variable age of onset of symptoms, the great diversity of pathological and muscular impairment patterns (cardiac, skeletal muscle or mixed) and both autosomal dominant and recessive modes of transmission. Until now, only few CNVs in TTN have been reported without clear genotype-phenotype associations.

METHODS

Our study includes eight families with dominant titinopathies. We performed next-generation sequencing or comparative genomic hybridisation array analyses and found CNVs in the TTN gene. We characterised these CNVs by RNA sequencing (RNAseq) analyses in six patients' muscles and performed genotype-phenotype inheritance association study by combining the clinical and biological data of these eight families.

RESULTS

Seven deletion-type CNVs in the TTN gene were identified among these families. Genotype and RNAseq results showed that five deletions do not alter the reading frame and one is out-of-reading frame. The main phenotype identified was distal myopathy associated with contractures. The analysis of morphological, clinical and genetic data and imaging let us draw new genotype-phenotype associations of titinopathies.

CONCLUSION

Identifying TTN CNVs will further increase diagnostic sensitivity in these complex neuromuscular pathologies. Our cohort of patients enabled us to identify new deletion-type CNVs in the TTN gene, with unexpected autosomal dominant transmission. This is valuable in establishing new genotype-phenotype associations of titinopathies, mainly distal myopathy in most of the patients.

Biallelic truncating TTN variants in M-band encoding exons cause a fetal lethal titinopathy

To report two novel TTN variants associated with fetal recessive titinopathy, thereby broadening the range of TTN variants that can lead to titinopathy. Clinical information on the fetus and parents was gathered, and genomic DNAs were extracted from the fetal tissue and family members' peripheral blood samples. Exome sequencing on fetal DNA was performed and following bioinformatics analysis, the suspected pathogenic variants were confirmed through Sanger sequencing. Prenatal ultrasound performed at 29 weeks of gestation revealed hydrops fetalis, decreased fetal movements, multiple joint contractures and polyhydramnios. Intrauterine fetal death was noted in the third trimester. Exome sequencing revealed compound heterozygous variants in the TTN gene: a paternally inherited allele c.101227C>T (p.Arg33743Ter) and a maternally inherited c.104254C>T (p.Gln34752Ter) allele. These variants have not been previously reported and are evaluated to be likely pathogenic according to the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines. We report a fetus with hydrops fetalis and arthrogryposis multiplex congenita associated with a compound heterozygote in the TTN gene. Our report broadens the clinical and genetic spectrum associated with the TTN-related conditions.

The crucial role of titin in fetal development: recurrent miscarriages and bone, heart and muscle anomalies characterise the severe end of titinopathies spectrum

BACKGROUND

Titin truncating variants (TTNtvs) have been associated with several forms of myopathies and/or cardiomyopathies. In homozygosity or in compound heterozygosity, they cause a wide spectrum of recessive phenotypes with a congenital or childhood onset. Most recessive phenotypes showing a congenital or childhood onset have been described in subjects carrying biallelic TTNtv in specific exons. Often karyotype or chromosomal microarray analyses are the only tests performed when prenatal anomalies are identified. Thereby, many cases caused by TTN defects might be missed in the diagnostic evaluations. In this study, we aimed to dissect the most severe end of the titinopathies spectrum.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective study analysing an international cohort of 93 published and 10 unpublished cases carrying biallelic TTNtv.

RESULTS

We identified recurrent clinical features showing a significant correlation with the genotype, including fetal akinesia (up to 62%), arthrogryposis (up to 85%), facial dysmorphisms (up to 73%), joint (up to 17%), bone (up to 22%) and heart anomalies (up to 27%) resembling complex, syndromic phenotypes.

CONCLUSION

We suggest TTN to be carefully evaluated in any diagnostic process involving patients with these prenatal signs. This step will be essential to improve diagnostic performance, expand our knowledge and optimise prenatal genetic counselling.

Titin related myopathy with ophthalmoplegia. A novel phenotype

Titin-related myopathy is an emerging genetic neuromuscular disorder with a wide spectrum of clinical phenotypes. To date, there have not been reports of patients with this disease that presented with extraocular muscle involvement. Here we discuss a 19-year-old male with congenital weakness, complete ophthalmoplegia, thoracolumbar scoliosis, and obstructive sleep apnea. Muscle magnetic resonance imaging revealed severe involvement of the gluteal and anterior compartment muscles, and clear adductor sparing, while muscle biopsy of the right vastus lateralis showed distinctive cap-like structures. Trio Whole Exome Sequencing (WES) showed compound heterozygous likely pathologic variants in the TTN gene. (c.82541_82544dup (p.Arg27515Serfs*2) in exon 327 (NM_001267550.2) and c.31846+1G>A (p.?) in exon 123 (NM_001267550.2). To our knowledge, this is the first report of a TTN-related disorder associated with ophthalmoplegia.

Long-term favorable prognosis in late onset dominant distal titinopathy: Tibial muscular dystrophy

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Tibial muscular dystrophy (TMD) is a dominant late onset distal titinopathy. It was first described in Finnish patients 3 decades ago. TMD patients with several other TTN mutations occur in many European populations. In this retrospective study, we were able to obtain longitudinal follow-up data of the disease progression over 15 years in 137 TMD patients.

METHODS

We retrieved clinical data retrospectively from three examinations spanning a period of 15 years. The data were analyzed in R. Frequencies, percentages, and median values were used to describe data. Probability values were determined with the chi-squared test.

RESULTS

In the cohort, the first symptoms were walking difficulties (97.8%) and weakness in distal lower limbs (98.5%). The progression of the weakness in distal lower limbs was moderate, and in the proximal lower limbs and proximal upper limbs it was mild. The distal upper limbs were not affected. Magnetic resonance imaging results indicated fatty degeneration preferentially in lower leg anterior muscles, gluteus minimus, and hamstring muscles. Serum creatine kinase values in the cohort were mostly normal (40.7%) or mildly elevated (53.7%). The data suggest that 50% of patients need walking aids by the age of 88 years.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite individual variability of severity, the overall disability due to walking difficulties and upper limb weakness remained moderate even at very advanced ages, and cardiomyopathy did not develop due to the titin defect alone. The acquired results promote the correct identification of TMD, and the obtained trajectories of disease evolution can be used as natural history data for any therapeutic intervention.

Clinical and functional characterization of a long survivor congenital titinopathy patient with a novel metatranscript-only titin variant

Congenital titinopathies are an emerging group of a potentially severe form of congenital myopathies caused by biallelic mutations in titin, encoding the largest existing human protein involved in the formation and stability of sarcomeres. In this study we describe a patient with a congenital myopathy characterized by multiple contractures, a rigid spine, non progressive muscular weakness, and a novel homozygous TTN pathogenic variant in a metatranscript-only exon: the c.36400A > T, p.Lys12134*. Muscle biopsies showed increased internalized nuclei, variability in fiber size, mild fibrosis, type 1 fiber predominance, and a slight increase in the number of satellite cells. RNA studies revealed the retention of intron 170 and 171 in the open reading frame, and immunoflourescence and western blot studies, a normal titin content. Single fiber functional studies showed a slight decrease in absolute maximal force and a cross-sectional area with no decreases in tension, suggesting that weakness is not sarcomere-based but due to hypotrophy. Passive properties of single fibers were not affected, but the observed increased calcium sensitivity of force generation might contribute to the contractural phenotype and rigid spine of the patient. Our findings provide evidence for a pathogenic, causative role of a metatranscript-only titin variant in a long survivor congenital titinopathy patient with distal arthrogryposis and rigid spine.

Fetal akinesia deformation sequence syndrome associated with recessive TTN variants

Arthrogryposis multiplex congenita (AMC) [also known as multiple joints contracture or Fetal Akinesia Deformation Sequence (FADS)] is etiologically a heterogeneous condition with an estimated incidence of approximately 1 in 3000 live births and much higher incidence when prenatally diagnosed cases are included. The condition can be acquired or secondary to fetal exposures and can also be caused by a variety of single-gene disorders affecting the brain, spinal cord, peripheral nerves, neuromuscular junction, muscle, and a variety of disorders affecting the connective tissues (Niles et al., Prenatal Diagnosis, 2019; 39:720-731). The introduction of next-generation gene sequencing uncovered many genes and causative variants of AMC but also identified genes that cause both dominant and recessive inherited conditions with the variability of clinical manifestations depending on the genes and variants. Molecular diagnosis in these cases is not only important for prognostication but also for the determination of recurrence risk and for providing reproductive options including preimplantation and prenatal diagnosis. TTN, the largest known gene in the human genome, has been known to be associated with autosomal dominant dilated cardiomyopathy. However, homozygote and compound heterozygote pathogenic variants with recessive inheritance have rarely been reported. We report the effect of recessive variants located within the fetal IC and/or N2BA isoforms in association with severe FADS in three families. All parents were healthy obligate carriers and none of them had cardiac or skeletal muscle abnormalities. This report solidifies FADS as an alternative phenotypic presentation associated with homozygote/compound heterozygous pathogenic variants in the TTN.

A spectrum of clinical severity of recessive titinopathies in prenatal

Variants in TTN are associated with a broad range of clinical phenotypes, from dominant adult-onset dilated cardiomyopathy to recessive infantile-onset myopathy. However, few foetal cases have been reported for multiple reasons. Next-generation sequencing has facilitated the prenatal identification of a growing number of suspected titinopathy variants. We investigated six affected foetuses from three families, completed the intrauterine course of the serial phenotypic spectrum of TTN, and discussed the genotype-phenotype correlations from a broader perspective. The recognizable prenatal feature onset at the second trimester was started with reduced movement, then contracture 3-6 weeks later, followed with/without hydrops, finally at late pregnancy was accompanied with polyhydramnio (major) or oligohydramnios. Two cases with typical arthrogryposis-hydrops sequences identified a meta-only transcript variant c.36203-1G>T. Deleterious transcriptional consequences of the substitution were verified by minigene splicing analysis. Case 3 identified a homozygous splicing variant in the constitutively expressed Z-disc. It presented a milder phenotype than expected, which was presumably saved by the isoform of corons. A summary of the foetal-onset titinopathy cases implied that variants in TTN present with a series of signs and a spectrum of clinical severity, which followed the dosage/positional effect; the meta-only transcript allele involvement may be a prerequisite for the development of fatal hydrops.

Using gene panels in the diagnosis of neuromuscular disorders: A mini-review

The diagnosis of inherited neuromuscular disorders is challenging due to their genetic and phenotypic variability. Traditionally, neurophysiology and histopathology were primarily used in the initial diagnostic approach to these conditions. Sanger sequencing for molecular diagnosis was less frequently utilized as its application was a time-consuming and cost-intensive process. The advent and accessibility of next-generation sequencing (NGS) has revolutionized the evaluation process of genetically heterogenous neuromuscular disorders. Current NGS diagnostic testing approaches include gene panels, whole exome sequencing (WES), and whole genome sequencing (WGS). Gene panels are often the most widely used, being more accessible due to availability and affordability. In this mini-review, we describe the benefits and risks of clinical genetic testing. We also discuss the utility, benefits, challenges, and limitations of using gene panels in the evaluation of neuromuscular disorders.

Use of animal models to understand titin physiology and pathology

In recent years, increasing attention has been paid to titin (TTN) and its mutations. Heterozygous TTN truncating variants (TTNtv) increase the risk of a cardiomyopathy. At the same time, TTNtv and few missense variants have been identified in patients with mainly recessive skeletal muscle diseases. The pathogenic mechanisms underlying titin‐related diseases are still partly unknown. Similarly, the titin mechanical and functional role in the muscle contraction are far from being exhaustively clarified. In the last few years, several animal models carrying variants in the titin gene have been developed and characterized to study the structural and mechanical properties of specific titin domains or to mimic patients' mutations. This review describes the main animal models so far characterized, including eight mice models and three fish models (Medaka and Zebrafish) and discusses the useful insights provided by a thorough characterization of the cell‐, tissue‐ and organism‐phenotypes in these models.

Novel dominant distal titinopathy phenotype associated with copy number variation

The aim of this study was to analyze patients from two distinct families with a novel distal titinopathy phenotype associated with exactly the same CNV in the TTN gene. We used an integrated strategy combining deep phenotyping and complete molecular analyses in patients. The CNV is the most proximal out-of-frame TTN variant reported and leads to aberrant splicing transcripts leading to a frameshift. In this case, the dominant effect would be due to dominant-negative and/or haploinsufficiency. Few CNV in TTN have been reported to date. Our data represent a novel phenotype-genotype association and provides hypotheses for its dominant effects.

An Integrated Clinical-Biological Approach to Identify Interindividual Variability and Atypical Phenotype-Genotype Correlations in Myopathies: Experience on A Cohort of 156 Families

Diagnosis of myopathies is challenged by the high genetic heterogeneity and clinical overlap of the various etiologies. We previously reported a Next-Generation Sequencing strategy to identify genetic etiology in patients with undiagnosed Limb-Girdle Muscular Dystrophies, Congenital Myopathies, Congenital Muscular Dystrophies, Distal Myopathies, Myofibrillar Myopathies, and hyperCKemia or effort intolerance, using a large gene panel including genes classically associated with other entry diagnostic categories. In this study, we report the comprehensive clinical-biological strategy used to interpret NGS data in a cohort of 156 pediatric and adult patients, that included Copy Number Variants search, variants filtering and interpretation according to ACMG guidelines, segregation studies, deep phenotyping of patients and relatives, transcripts and protein studies, and multidisciplinary meetings. Genetic etiology was identified in 74 patients, a diagnostic yield (47.4%) similar to previous studies. We identified 18 patients (10%) with causative variants in different genes (ACTA1, RYR1, NEB, TTN, TRIP4, CACNA1S, FLNC, TNNT1, and PAPBN1) that resulted in milder and/or atypical phenotypes, with high intrafamilial variability in some cases. Mild phenotypes could mostly be explained by a less deleterious effect of variants on the protein. Detection of inter-individual variability and atypical phenotype-genotype associations is essential for precision medicine, patient care, and to progress in the understanding of the molecular mechanisms of myopathies.

Centronuclear myopathy due to a de novo nonsense variant and a maternally inherited splice-site variant in TTN: A case report

Next-generation sequencing has resulted in an explosion of rare de novo TTN variants. The clinical interpretation of these de novo variants in patients with recessive titinopathy is very difficult. Here, we provided a useful way to identify compound heterozygous mutations with a de novo one.

The Increasing Impact of Translational Research in the Molecular Diagnostics of Neuromuscular Diseases

The diagnosis of neuromuscular diseases (NMDs) has been progressively evolving from the grouping of clinical symptoms and signs towards the molecular definition. Optimal clinical, biochemical, electrophysiological, electrophysiological, and histopathological characterization is very helpful to achieve molecular diagnosis, which is essential for establishing prognosis, treatment and genetic counselling. Currently, the genetic approach includes both the gene-targeted analysis in specific clinically recognizable diseases, as well as genomic analysis based on next-generation sequencing, analyzing either the clinical exome/genome or the whole exome or genome. However, as of today, there are still many patients in whom the causative genetic variant cannot be definitely established and variants of uncertain significance are often found. In this review, we address these drawbacks by incorporating two additional biological omics approaches into the molecular diagnostic process of NMDs. First, functional genomics by introducing experimental cell and molecular biology to analyze and validate the variant for its biological effect in an in-house translational diagnostic program, and second, incorporating a multi-omics approach including RNA-seq, metabolomics, and proteomics in the molecular diagnosis of neuromuscular disease. Both translational diagnostics programs and omics are being implemented as part of the diagnostic process in academic centers and referral hospitals and, therefore, an increase in the proportion of neuromuscular patients with a molecular diagnosis is expected. This improvement in the process and diagnostic performance of patients will allow solving aspects of their health problems in a precise way and will allow them and their families to take a step forward in their lives.