Mechanical characteristics of the bone-graft-cement interface after impaction allografting

Methodology, selection, and integration of fracture healing assessments in mice

Long bone fractures are one of the most common and costly medical conditions encountered after trauma. Characterization of the biology of fracture healing and development of potential medical interventions generally involves animal models of fracture healing using varying genetic or treatment groups, then analyzing relative repair success via the synthesis of diverse assessment methodologies. Murine models are some of the most widely used given their low cost, wide variety of genetic variants, and rapid breeding and maturation. This review addresses key concerns regarding fracture repair investigations in mice and may serve as a guide in conducting and interpreting such studies. Specifically, this review details the procedures, highlights relevant parameters, and discusses special considerations for the selection and integration of the major modalities used for quantifying fracture repair in such studies, including X-ray, microcomputed tomography, histomorphometric, biomechanical, gene expression and biomarker analyses.

Effect of synthetic bone replacement material of different size on shear stress resistance within impacted native and thermodisinfected cancellous bone: an in vitro femoral impaction bone grafting model

Antibiotic carrier particles of variable size might influence mechanic properties within impacted thermodisinfected and native cancellous bone different. Herafill®G containing calciumsulfate and calciumcarbonate provides high local concentrations of gentamicin being important for revision surgery in infected joint replacements. Native and thermodisinfected cancellous bone derived from 6 to 7 months old piglets was used for in vitro impaction bone grafting and supplemented each with Herafill®G granules of two different sizes. Micromovement of implants related to shear force was measured in 29 specimens distributed in 6 groups. Thermodisinfected cancellous bone revealed a significant higher shear force resistance than native bone with a mean difference of 423.8 mdeg/Nm (p < 0.001) ranging within 95% confidence interval from 181.5 to 666.0 mdeg/Nm. Adding small granules to thermodisinfected bone did not reduce shear force resistance significantly since adding large granules to native bone improved it by 344.0 mdeg/Nm (p < 0.003). Shear force resistance was found higher at the distal region of the implant compared to a proximal point of measurement throughout all specimens. Less impaction impulses were necessary for thermodisinfected bone. Thermodisinfected cancellous bone might achieve a higher degree of impaction compared with native bone resulting in increased resistance against shear force since impaction was found increased distally. Supplementation of thermodisinfected bone with small granules of Herafill®G might be considered for application of local antibiotics. Large granules appeared more beneficial for supplementation of native bone. Heterogeneity of bone graft and technical aspects of the impaction procedure have to be considered regarding the reproducibility of femoral impaction bone grafting.

Influence of antibiotic pellets on pore size and shear stress resistance of impacted native and thermodisinfected cancellous bone: An in vitro femoral impaction bone grafting model

Introduction

Morphology and mechanic properties of impacted cancellous bone are affected by carrier substances which provide high local concentrations of antibiotics.

Methods

Bone chips were taken from the femoral head of 6-7 months old piglets. One half was thermodisinfected and the other remained native. Ten specimens each were mixed with Herafill® antibiotic pellets and a control group of each 10 specimens respectively was examined. The cancellous bone was impacted according to Exeter technique and the implants were cemented. The distribution of the particles and the pores were defined with three dimensional computertomographic scan and shear force resistance was measured until failure.

Results

Shear force resistance was not measured significantly less for thermodisinfected (2.7 Nm) compared with native bone (3.5 Nm) and addition of antibiotic pellets reduced shear force resistance in both groups since this was significant for the native group. The average pore volume of the native bone specimens appeared significant smaller compared to the thermodisinfected group (p = 0.011) and the pore volume showed a negative correlation with shear force resistance (p = 0.044). Pore volume around the pellets was found significantly increased and it appeared smaller for native bone. The number of pellets located next to the implant showed a negative correlation with shear force resistance (p = 0.034) and the negative correlation increased for pellets below the tip of the shaft model (p = 0.024).

Conclusion

Adding antibiotic pellets to native and thermodisinfected impacted cancellous bone increased pore volume since the area around the pellets showed increased porosity which correlated with reduced shear force resistance. Computertomographic three dimensional measurement of porosity might predict shear force resistance of impacted cancellous bone and improve impaction of bone grafting intraoperatively.

[Influence of thermodisinfection on impaction of cancellous bone : An in vitro model of femoral impaction bone grafting]

BACKGROUND

The reconstruction of bony defects during endoprosthesis revision surgery using "impaction bone grafting" leads to the possibility of a longstanding osseous integration to achieve good clinical results. Native allogeneic cancellous bone is often used for the procedure. This study examines the influence of thermodisinfection on the impaction behaviour of cancellous bone of different geometries and on the cement distribution.

METHODS

The cancellous bone was obtained from the femoral heads of 7‑month old pigs. One half of the head was thermodisinfected while the other remained native. Bone chips with sizes of 3-5, 5-8 and 8-10 mm were produced. The impaction was performed in a cylinder model with an internal diameter of 30 mm and with standardized impaction force using an impactor with a weight of 1450 g. The best particle combination was used for the subsequent computer tomography examination of the cement distribution and the contact surface to the bone in different parts of the shaft in seven investigations. For statistic measurements two-dimensional variance analysis including repetitions of measurement and Bonferroni correction, the LSD post-hoc-zest and the Mann Whitney U Test were used. The error probability was set at α = 5%. The SPSS® for Windows software was used for the statistical analysis.

RESULTS

The distribution of the cancellous and compacted bone also along the shaft revealed no significant difference between thermodisinfected and native cancellous bone at different levels (p > 0.05). Impacted native cancellous bone showed less inclusion of air, which resulted in a better distribution of density compared with thermodisinfected bone overall (p < 0.001). In the distal shaft area the cement volume was significantly larger in conjunction with the native bone. The overall area of cement penetration appeared to be significantly larger for native cancellous bone (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

The impaction of thermodisinfected and native cancellous bone showed greater deformation of the processed bone without any significant difference in the maximum density reached at different levels. Cement volume and cement penetration were pronounced proximally in native and processed cancellous bone. The cement distribution was significantly more distal for the native bone. Distally, the stabilization of the shaft appears to be increasingly dependent on the density of the impacted spongiosa, while proximally, the penetration of the cement into cancellous bone seems to correlate with porosity.

Biomechanical analysis of a synthetic, biodegradable impaction graft substitute

Impaction bone grafting in revision arthroplasty is a common and successful procedure to restore primary bone stock. Reducing the amount of bone needed to fill large grafts has been a driving force for the use of synthetic materials that can act as extenders or substitutes. To this end, we evaluated the mechanical properties of a new class of biodegradable polymer beads with and without donor bone to determine its suitability for use in impaction grafting. Biodegradable methacrylated anhydride beads were synthesized using thermal polymerization techniques. The mechanical properties of the beads were then tested in an impaction grafting test chamber and compared with morsellised porcine allograft. The beads, porcine allograft and a 50/50 combination all had similar mechanical properties, both in compression and relaxation. Pure polymer beads compacted significantly less than pure allograft and retained macroporosity after impaction. Our results suggest that the biodegradable beads have sufficient mechanical properties to be considered as an impaction grafting substitute or extender. Their ability to fill space whilst retaining macroporosity may be advantageous for tissue ingrowth and remodeling.

Influence of cement penetration and graft density on stem stability in impaction allografting: a finite element study

BACKGROUND

Excessive stem migration is often problematic after impaction allografting. The mechanisms responsible for migration are not known, but achieving a dense graft bed has traditionally been believed to be essential for stem stability. When the stem is cemented into the allograft bed, however, the graft becomes infiltrated with bone cement. Extensive cement penetration into the graft has been observed in previous studies, resulting in regions of cement-endosteum contact.

METHODS

This study explored the effects of graft density and cement penetration on stem motion using a finite element model that was validated against experimental data.

FINDINGS

Cement penetration has a considerable stabilizing effect on stem motion, whereas graft density is important only when there is no cement-endosteum contact. Stem migration can be attributed primarily to slippage at the endosteum and stem-cement interfaces rather than to shear failure within the graft.

INTERPRETATION

Partial cement penetration to the endosteum increases the likelihood of meeting clinical requirements of early implant stability, particularly when a dense graft bed cannot be achieved.

The role of vibration and drainage in femoral impaction bone grafting

Vibration is commonly used in civil engineering applications to efficiently compact aggregates. This study examined the effect of vibration and drainage on bone graft compaction and cement penetration in an in vitro femoral impaction bone grafting model with the use of 3-dimensional micro-computed tomographic imaging. Three regions were analyzed. In the middle and proximal femoral regions, there was a significant increase in the proportion of bone grafts with a reciprocal reduction in water and air in the vibration-assisted group (P < .01) as compared with the control group, suggesting tighter graft compaction. Cement volume was also significantly reduced in the middle region in the vibration-assisted group. No difference was observed in the distal region. This study demonstrates the value of vibration and drainage in bone graft compaction, with implications therein for clinical application and outcome.

Impaction grafting with a bone-graft substitute in a sheep model of revision hip replacement

An experimental sheep model was used for impaction allografting of 12 hemiarthroplasty femoral components placed into two equal-sized groups. In group 1, a 50:50 mixture of ApaPore hydroxyapatite bone-graft substitute and allograft was used. In group 2, ApaPore and allograft were mixed in a 90:10 ratio. Both groups were killed at six months. Ground reaction force results demonstrated no significant differences (p > 0.05) between the two groups at 8, 16 and 24 weeks post-operatively, and all animals remained active. The mean bone turnover rates were significantly greater in group 1, at 0.00206 mm/day, compared to group 2 at 0.0013 mm/day (p < 0.05). The results for the area of new bone formation demonstrated no significant differences (p > 0.05) between the two groups. No significant differences were found between the two groups in thickness of the cement mantle (p > 0.05) and percentage ApaPore-bone contact (p > 0.05).

The results of this animal study demonstrated that a mixture of ApaPore allograft in a 90:10 ratio was comparable to using a 50:50 mixture.

Cement penetration and primary stability of the femoral component after impaction allografting

This study explored the relationship between the initial stability of the femoral component and penetration of cement into the graft bed following impaction allografting.

Impaction allografting was carried out in human cadaveric femurs. In one group the cement was pressurised conventionally but in the other it was not pressurised. Migration and micromotion of the implant were measured under simulated walking loads. The specimens were then cross-sectioned and penetration of the cement measured.

Around the distal half of the implant we found approximately 70% and 40% of contact of the cement with the endosteum in the pressure and no-pressure groups, respectively. The distal migration/micromotion, and valgus/varus migration were significantly higher in the no-pressure group than in that subjected to pressure. These motion components correlated negatively with the mean area of cement and its contact with the endosteum.

The presence of cement at the endosteum appears to play an important role in the initial stability of the implant following impaction allografting.

Stability of fused versus nonfused THA femoral impaction grafts

Impaction grafting for THA involves compacting morselized cancellous bone (MCB) into a cavitary defect to build up bone stock. Ideally, the MCB subsequently remodels into a new contiguous cancellous lattice. A recent laboratory model of MCB fusion allows simulating an impaction graft construct in this ideal eventual clinical state. The purpose of the present study was to determine the relative stability of femoral impaction graft constructs in which the MCB has fused versus that for MCB in the freshly impacted nonfused condition. Cemented femoral impaction graft constructs were created in composite femurs. For fused constructs, the MCB was mixed with an amine epoxy that causes the MCB to set up into a contiguous structure biomechanically comparable to intact cancellous bone in compression. The constructs were loaded with 500,000 physiologic gait cycles. Three-dimensional motion was measured between the femur and the stem. The fused femoral impaction grafts were much more stable than the nonfused grafts at the proximal stem location, but MCB fusion had only a modest effect on distal stem stability. These results indicate that most of the opportunity to reduce femoral stem micromotion and migration lies proximal, and that steps to enhance impaction graft remodeling and fusion are most effectively focused proximally.

3D non-linear analysis of the acetabular construct following impaction grafting

The study investigates the short-term behaviour of the acetabular construct following revision hip arthroplasty, carried out using the Slooff-Ling impaction grafting technique; using 3D finite element analyses. An elasto-plastic material model is used to describe the constitutive behaviour of morsellised cortico-cancellous bone (MCB) graft, since it has been shown that MCB undergoes significant plastic deformation under normal physiological loads. Based on previous experimental studies carried out by the authors and others, MCB is modelled using non-linear elasticity and Drucker Prager Cap (DPC) plasticity. Loading associated with walking, sitting down, and standing up is applied to the acetabular cup through a femoral head using smooth sliding surfaces. The analyses yield distinctive patterns of migration and rotation due to different activities. These are found to be similar to those observed in the clinical setting.

Constitutive models for impacted morsellised cortico-cancellous bone

Constitutive models are developed, based on the results of confined compression testing, to describe the visco-elastic, and non-linear elasto-plastic behaviour of morsellised cortico-cancellous bone (MCB). It is found that the elastic modulus, E of MCB can be expressed as a linear function of the applied pressure, p. E varied from 3 to 30N/mm(2) for pressures up to 1N/mm(2). The visco-elastic behaviour of MCB can be described using a fourth-order Prony series. The plastic behaviour of MCB can be described using a Drucker Prager Cap (DPC) yield criterion, in which consolidation behaviour is described using an exponential function. The developed relationships allow MCB to be included in a realistic manner in finite element models, for example of the acetabular construct, following revision hip arthroplasty, carried out using the Slooff-Ling impaction grafting technique.