Early-life influences of low-calorie sweetener consumption on sugar taste

Consumption of Low-Calorie Sweeteners among Children Aged 6 Months to 5 Years in the United States, NHANES 2017-2020

BACKGROUND

Although the American Academy of Pediatrics advises against low-calorie sweeteners (LCS) consumption by children <5 y due to potential health and development concerns, the extent of this consumption among these children is unknown.

OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study was to describe the intake, sources, and dietary patterns associated with LCS consumption among United States infants and preschoolers.

METHODS

We used cross-sectional 24-h dietary recall data (day 1) among 1497 children aged 6 mo to 5 y from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2017-2020 prepandemic. Complex survey procedures and sampling weights were applied to compare LCS consumption patterns (prevalence and frequency [times/day] of any LCS, any LCS-containing beverages [LCSBs], and any LCS-containing foods [LCSFs], with each occurrence of consumption = 1 "serving") across demographic subgroups and to assess the associated nutrients and % of total energy intake (TEI).

RESULTS

Thirty-one percent of children aged 6 mo to 5 y consumed ≥1 LCSB and/or LCSF on a given day. The prevalence of LCS consumption increased with age, 10.5% (6 to <12 mo) to 34.3% (2-5 y). Among LCS consumers, mean serving frequency was 1.4 times/d, with no differences by age or sex. Of all LCSBs servings consumed, 64.0% were fruit drinks; 57.8% of all LCSFs servings were non-Greek yogurt. As consumption levels increased from no LCS to >1 serving/d, intake of the following also increased: total sugar (+1.8% TEI, P-trend = 0.04), added sugar (+1.1%, P-trend = 0.048), sodium (+304 mg, P-trend = 0.04), and fiber (+0.8 g, P-trend = 0.01). In contrast, protein intake was lower (-0.7% TEI, P-trend = 0.02). Those consuming 1 LCS serving/d consumed more total energy than LCS nonconsumers (1606 compared with 1401 kcal), but TEI did not increase further with >1 LCS serving/d (1607 kcal). LCS consumption was not associated with carbohydrate or fat intake.

CONCLUSIONS

LCS consumption, primarily from fruit drinks and non-Greek yogurt, is prevalent among United States preschoolers, and this consumption is associated with greater intake of total sugar, added sugar, and sodium.

Does sweetness exposure drive 'sweet tooth'?

It is widely believed that exposure to sweetened foods and beverages stimulates the liking and desire for sweetness. Here we provide an updated review of the empirical evidence from human research examining whether exposure to sweet foods or beverages influences subsequent general liking for sweetness (‘sweet tooth’), based on the conclusions of existing systematic reviews and more recent research identified from a structured search of literature. Prior reviews have concluded that the evidence for a relationship between sweet taste exposure and measures of sweet taste liking is equivocal, and more recent primary research generally does not support the view that exposure drives increased liking for sweetness, in adults or children. In intervention trials using a range of designs, acute exposure to sweetness usually has the opposite effect (reducing subsequent liking and desire for sweet taste), while sustained exposures have no significant effects or inconsistent effects. Recent longitudinal observational studies in infants and children also report no significant associations between exposures to sweet foods and beverages with measures of sweet taste preferences. Overall, while it is widely assumed that exposure to sweetness stimulates a greater liking and desire for sweetness, this is not borne out by the balance of empirical evidence. While new research may provide a more robust evidence base, there are also a number of methodological, biological and behavioural considerations that may underpin the apparent absence of a positive relationship between sweetness exposure and liking.