Distress Trajectories in Black and White Breast Cancer Survivors: From Diagnosis to Survivorship

You can't spell distress without stress: Expanding our perspective of the intersection between mental and physical health in cancer survivors

Although many breast cancer survivors adjust to cancer treatment and survivorship, a sizable subgroup of women do not do so, resulting in psychological distress. Over time, this psychological distress can contribute to immune dysfunction and accompanying worsened physical symptoms as women navigate survivorship. Dr. Kiecolt-Glaser's work and mentorship has been integral to our understanding of breast cancer survivors' immune risks, and how behavioral factors may enhance these risks. As a postdoctoral fellow in the Stress and Health Lab, under Dr. Kiecolt-Glaser's mentorship, my research focused on understanding how distress is associated with immune functioning and physical health in breast cancer survivors. In this paper, we highlight Dr. Kiecolt-Glaser's influence on our careers as a strong female research and mentor, the work completed under her mentorship, and how the field of psychoneuroimmunology can continue to expand her research to better understand how distress in the cancer context confers long-term health risks.

Depression and Anxiety Among English- and Spanish-Speaking Patients With Breast Cancer Receiving Radiation Therapy

PURPOSE

An estimated 30% and 40% of patients with breast cancer experience depression and anxiety, respectively. However, distress experienced by patients with breast cancer receiving radiation therapy may vary among patients and vary at different time points. This study sought to describe the changes in levels of depression and anxiety experienced by English- and Spanish-speaking patients throughout a course of radiation therapy for breast cancer, along with the effect of different variables to better understand potential gaps.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Eligibility criteria included English- and Spanish-speaking females, aged 18 or older, undergoing radiation therapy treatment for breast cancer at 2 institutions. Pre- and posttreatment surveys were completed before and after delivery of radiation therapy. Sociodemographic characteristics collected included race, ethnicity, marital status, education level, longest residency location, religion, housing, and food insecurity. The survey ended with the standardized PHQ-4 questionnaire to assess anxiety and depression. Results were analyzed using the analysis of covariance procedure.

RESULTS

A total of 160 participants completed pre- and posttreatment surveys, with an initial response rate of 100% (169 patients), though 9 were lost to follow-up. Most of the participants were nonwhite (50%), primarily married (42.5%), and had a high school or associate's level education (46.9%). The total baseline distress mean (BDM) was 2.96 and the final distress mean was 2.78. English-speaking patients comprised 82.5% (n = 132) of the sample and had a BDM of 2.91 with an adjusted change mean decrease of 0.45. Spanish-speaking patients comprised 17.5% (n = 28) of the sample, with a baseline distress mean of 3.21 and an adjusted change mean increase of 1.03 (P = .002). Housing (P = .017) and food insecurity (P = .0002) also showed increasing distress with increased insecurity at baseline.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients who speak Spanish, identify as Hispanic, or are experiencing food and housing insecurity are at an increased risk for depression and anxiety, and could benefit from more support during their course of radiation therapy to minimize distress.

Effects of a Phone-Based Support Program for Women With Breast Cancer Undergoing Chemotherapy: A Pilot Study

Introduction

The increasing number of women with breast cancer undergoing chemotherapy may result in long-lasting, adverse physical side effects and reduced quality of life.

Objective

This study aimed to develop and assess the feasibility and preliminary effects of the Phone-Based Support Program for women with breast cancer undergoing chemotherapy. The primary outcome was self-care self-efficacy; secondary outcomes were symptom distress and quality of life.

Methods

This pilot study was conducted at a tertiary hospital in Jiangsu province, China, from February to March 2023. The Phone-Based Support Program was delivered to 20 participants through the smartphone application WeChat, consisting of learning, discussion, ask-the-expert, and personal stories components. Outcome measures were assessed at three time points: preintervention, postintervention, and follow-up.

Results

The Phone-Based Support Program was feasible and could improve self-care self-efficacy, decrease symptom distress, and promote quality of life. The program was well-accepted, and participants engaged actively in the online discussion and sought expert advice.

Conclusions

The Phone-Based Support Program showed feasibility and effectiveness in improving self-care self-efficacy, reducing symptom distress, and enhancing quality of life.

Intervening in the Cancer Care System: An Analysis of Equity-Focused Nurse Navigation and Patient-Reported Outcomes

BACKGROUND

Nurse navigation can improve quality of cancer care and reduce racial disparities in care outcomes. Addressing persistent structurally-rooted disparities requires research on strategies that support patients by prompting structural changes to systems of care. We applied a novel conceptualization of social support to an analysis of racial equity-focused navigation and patient-reported outcomes.

METHOD

We applied an antiracism lens to create a theory-informed definition of system-facing social support: intervening in a care system on a patient's behalf. Participants were adults with early-stage breast or lung cancer, who racially identified as Black or White, and received specialized nurse navigation (n = 155). We coded navigators' clinical notes (n = 3,251) to identify instances of system-facing support. We then estimated models to examine system-facing support in relation to race, perceived racism in health care settings, and mental health.

RESULTS

Twelve percent of navigators' clinical notes documented system-facing support. Black participants received more system-facing support than White participants, on average (b = 0.78, 95% confidence interval [CI]: [0.25, 1.31]). The interaction of race*system-facing support was significant in a model predicting perceived racism in health care settings at the end of the study controlling for baseline scores (b = 0.05, 95% CI [0.01, 0.09]). Trends in simple slopes indicated that among Black participants, more system-facing support was associated with slightly more perceived racism; no association among White participants.

DISCUSSION

The term system-facing support highlights navigators' role in advocating for patients within the care system. More research is needed to validate the construct system-facing support and examine its utility in interventions to advance health care equity.

Racial disparities in treatment-related cardiovascular toxicities amongst women with breast cancer: a scoping review

PURPOSE

Black women often experience poorer breast cancer-related outcomes and higher mortality than white women. A contributor to this disparity may relate to the disproportionate burden of cancer treatment-related cardiovascular (CV) toxicities. The objective of this review is to identify studies that report racial differences in CV toxicity risk.

METHODS

Medline and Embase were searched for studies that assessed CV toxicities as the outcome(s) and included Black and White women with breast cancer. Studies were selected based on inclusion/exclusion criteria and through the use of multiple reviewers.

RESULTS

The review included 13 studies following a review of 409 citations and 49 full-text articles. All studies were retrospective and 8/13 utilized data from the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results-Medicare linked database. Trastuzumab was the most frequently studied treatment. The proportion of Black women in these studies ranged from 5.5 to 63%. A majority of studies reported a higher risk of CV toxicity amongst Black women when compared to white women (93%). Black women had up to a two times higher risk of CV toxicity (HR, 2.73 (CI, 1.24 to 6.01)) compared to white women. Only one study evaluated the role of socioeconomic factors in explaining racial differences in CV toxicity; however, the disparity remained even after adjusting for these factors.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a critical need for more longitudinal studies that evaluate multilevel factors (e.g., psychosocial, biological) that may help to explain this disparity.

IMPLICATIONS FOR CANCER SURVIVORS

Black cancer survivors may require additional surveillance and mitigation strategies to decrease disproportionate burden of CV toxicities.

The Effect of Race and Area Deprivation on Symptom Profiles over the Course of Early-Stage Breast Cancer

Purpose

This study compared common symptoms (fatigue, pain), overall physical functioning and changes over time between Black and White women receiving early-stage breast cancer (ESBC) chemotherapy.

Methods

A longitudinal, repeated measures comparative design was employed. Time points of symptom measurement (PROMIS domains) at baseline, mid and end point were adjusted as per patient chemotherapy schedule.

Analyses

Linear mixed models were applied.

Results

There were 147 patients, 36% Black 64% White (54±12 years) recommended to receive early-stage breast cancer chemotherapy with adequate data for symptom analysis.

Pain

Main effect of race was significant (F(1, 390) = 29.43, p<.001) for pain with Black patients experiencing significantly higher pain scores compared to White patients at pretherapy (Mean Difference; MD=3.7, p=.034), midpoint (MD=5.8, p=.002), and endpoint (MD=7.8, p<.001).

Fatigue

Fatigue significantly increased (deteriorated) at endpoint (MDT1-T3= 8.7, p<.001) for Black patients. Among White patients, fatigue significantly increased at midpoint (MDT1-T2= 5.7) and at endpoint (MDT1-T3=10.1, p<.001; MDT2-T3=4.3, p= .017). Physical function: Black patients had significantly lower physical function scores compared to White patients at midpoint (MD=4.0, p=.027). Physical function decreased by endpoint in Black (MDT1-T3=7.8, p<.001), and White patients (MDT1-T3=7.7, p<.001).

Conclusion

Symptom burden significantly increased over the course of chemotherapy for all patients. Scores for pain and physical function were higher overall for Black patients and deteriorated at a greater rate for Black vs. White women over the course of chemotherapy. This assessment holds implication for proactive assessment and mitigation strategies.

Racial and ethnic differences in post-traumatic stress trajectories in breast cancer survivors

PURPOSE

To describe differences in post-traumatic stress (PTS) symptoms over time among racial and ethnic minoritized breast cancer survivors (BCS) with comorbid diabetes.

DESIGN

In a multisite longitudinal study, post-traumatic stress was evaluated at baseline, 6 and 12 months through self-reported questionnaires (Impact of Events Scale-Revised [IES-R]).

PARTICIPANTS

One hundred and seventy-eight post-treatment BCS with diabetes were recruited from three tertiary medical centers.

FINDINGS

Relative to non-Hispanic White women, minoritized women reported higher total IES-R scores at all time points. In the adjusted model, Latina women reported persistently higher IES-R total scores and Latina, and 'Other' women reported higher avoidance scores.

CONCLUSIONS

Minoritized BCS with comorbid diabetes report higher rates of cancer related PTS that persist over 12 months.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PSYCHOSOCIAL PROVIDERS

Post diagnosis PTS evaluation and support is important in survivorship and primary care practices. Linkage to socially and culturally sensitive community support may be warranted.

Emotional distress in cancer survivors from various ethnic backgrounds: Analysis of the multi-ethnic HELIUS study

PURPOSE

Insight into emotional distress of cancer survivors from ethnic minority groups in Europe is scarce. We aimed to compare distress levels of survivors from ethnic minorities to that of the majority population, determine whether the association between having cancer (yes vs. no) and distress differs among ethnic groups and investigate sociocultural correlates of distress.

METHODS

Cross-sectional data were derived from HELIUS, a multi-ethnic cohort study conducted in the Netherlands. Of 19,147 participants, 351 were diagnosed with cancer (n = 130 Dutch, n = 75 African Surinamese, n = 53 South-Asian Surinamese, n = 43 Moroccan, n = 28 Turkish, n = 22 Ghanaian). Distress (PHQ-9, MCS-12) and correlates were assessed by self-report. Cancer-related variables were derived from the Netherlands Cancer Registry.

RESULTS

Survivors were on average 7 years post-diagnosis. Survivors from South-Asian Surinamese, Moroccan, Turkish and Ghanaian origin reported more distress than survivors from Dutch origin (effect sizerange : 0.44-1.17; adjusted models). The association between having cancer or not with distress differed in direction between Dutch and the non-Dutch ethnic groups: Non-Dutch cancer patients tended to have more distress than their cancer-free peers, whereas Dutch cancer patients tended to have less distress than their cancer-free peers. For Moroccan and Turkish patients, the acculturation style of separation/marginalization, compared to integration/assimilation, was associated with higher depressive symptoms. In analyses pooling data from all ethnic minorities, lower health literacy, lower emotional support satisfaction and younger age at the time of migration were associated with higher depressive symptoms. Lower health literacy, fewer emotional support transactions, and more frequent attendance at religious services were associated with worse mental health.

CONCLUSION

Cancer survivors from ethnic minorities experience more distress than those from the majority population. Culturally sensitive supportive care should be considered.

Racial Differences in Breast Cancer Therapeutic Toxicity: Implications for Practice

Disparities in treatment intensity can contribute to racial disparities in overall breast cancer survival. A natural extension of measuring racial disparities in treatment intensity is consideration of the distribution of treatment toxicities, symptoms, and distress that lead to chemotherapy dose reductions, holds or early termination. There is growing evidence that therapeutic toxicity during early-stage breast cancer treatment may be greater among Black women than White. Important components of symptom management involve the communication of symptoms, the self-care abilities of the patient, the patient's perception of the clinical encounter, and the patient centeredness of the clinical encounter. Racial differences in the symptom reporting, the clinical "reception" and response to symptoms, the prescribed management, and the patient adherence to symptom management requires further investigation. Further research must also consider the structural inequities, as well as institutional and interpersonal racism that contribute to racial differences in cancer symptom burden leading to potential decreases in dose intensity of potentially life-saving early cancer treatment. See related article by Hu et al., p. 167.