Pregnancy outcome after chelation therapy in Wilson disease. Evaluation of the German Embryotox Database

Adverse pregnancy outcomes and effect of treatment in Wilson disease during pregnancy: Systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Wilson disease (WD) is a rare disorder of copper metabolism, leading to liver and neurological disease. Existing literature on WD in pregnancy is scarce, limiting preconception and obstetrical counselling. In this systematic review with meta-analysis, we determine the prevalence of various adverse pregnancy and neonatal outcomes in WD, as well as evaluate the impact of WD treatment on these outcomes.

METHODS

Scopus, MEDLINE and EMBASE were searched until 12 May 2023, for studies of pregnant individuals with WD and at least one pregnancy or neonatal outcome of interest. Meta-analysis of single proportions was conducted to pool prevalence data for each outcome. Outcome rates were compared between treated and untreated groups in a meta-analysis of dichotomous events.

RESULTS

Sixteen studies, published from 1975 to 2022, were included in the systematic review. Thirty-seven percent of pregnancies reported at least one adverse pregnancy outcome. Spontaneous abortions (20%), liver diseases of pregnancy (4.5%) and preterm births (2%) were the most frequent adverse pregnancy outcomes in patients with WD. The prevalence of spontaneous abortions was significantly lower in pregnant individuals with WD who received treatment during pregnancy (OR: .47, 95% CI: 35%-63%). The prevalence of any adverse pregnancy outcome was also significantly lower with treatment (OR: .53, 95% CI: .37-.76), which appears to be mostly driven by the reduction of spontaneous abortions.

CONCLUSIONS

There is low to moderate quality evidence to suggest that preconception and obstetrical counselling for patients with WD should include a discussion on the potentially high frequency of adverse pregnancy outcomes in this population, as well as the importance of continuing WD treatment during pregnancy to ensure satisfactory pregnancy course and potentially minimize the risk of spontaneous abortions.

The Maternal and Fetal Outcomes of Pregnancy in Wilson’s Disease: A Systematic Literature Review and Meta-Analysis

Wilson’s disease (WD) is a rare, treatable genetic disorder with multi-organ symptoms related mainly to copper accumulation. Most patients become aware of the disease as young adults, thus knowledge on fertility, pregnancy course and outcome is very important both for patients and physicians. The aim of this study was to perform a systematic review and meta-analysis of pregnancy outcomes in women with WD. This systematic literature review was performed according to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Studies were identified by searching the PubMed database (up to 12 January 2022) and by screening reference lists. We found 49 publications, including 13 retrospective studies and 36 series and case reports on pregnancy outcomes in WD patients. In total, descriptions of 449 pregnant women with 822 pregnancies were retrieved. Successful deliveries were achieved in 78.3% (644/822) of all pregnancies. Spontaneous abortions were observed in 21.7% (178/822) of pregnancies, more frequently in patients who were untreated 68.6% (96/140). Analyzing maternal outcome, 2.2% (18/822) of pregnancies were associated with the aggravation of neurological symptoms. Symptoms of hepatic deterioration were observed in 4.6% (38/822) of cases. These were usually transient and recovered after pregnancy; however, death due to liver failure was observed in 0.2% (2/822) of cases. Birth defects occurred in 4.7% (39/822) of pregnancies. The available meta-analysis showed statistically significant positive associations between anti-copper treatment and pregnancy outcome. Our results document the significance of anti-copper treatment as the main factor leading to successful pregnancy, as well as positive outcomes for women with WD.

Wilson Disease in Children

The silver anniversary of the discovery of the Wilson disease gene ATP7B was a couple of years ago, and we continue to make progress both in our understanding of copper transportation using animal models as well as earlier diagnosis by availing of genetic testing. Wilson disease is multisystemic and the hepatic manifestations are seen more frequently in childhood, whereas neurologic manifestations are more common in adults; presentation may range from subtle changes to end-stage liver disease with or without encephalopathy as well as neuropsychiatric manifestations. Treatment remains with zinc and chelating agents such as D-penicillamine and trientine but newer agents and gene therapy are in clinical trials. Liver transplantation becomes necessary when medical therapy is not enough. Molecular diagnosis and genetic counseling is important.

Investigation and management of Wilson's disease: a practical guide from the British Association for the Study of the Liver

Wilson's disease is an autosomal-recessive disorder of copper metabolism with hepatic, neurological, psychiatric, ophthalmological, haematological, renal, and rheumatological manifestations. Making a diagnosis can be challenging given that no single test can confirm or exclude the disease, and diagnostic delays are common. Treatment protocols vary and adverse effects, including paradoxical neurological worsening, can occur. In this Review, we provide a practical guide to the diagnosis of Wilson's disease. We include recommendations on indications for testing, how to interpret results, and when additional investigations are required. We also cover treatment initiation, ideally under the guidance of a specialist centre for Wilson's disease, and the principles behind long-term management. This guidance was developed by a multidisciplinary group of Wilson's disease experts formed through the British Association for the Study of the Liver. The guidance has been endorsed by the British Society of Gastroenterology and approved by the Association of British Neurologists.

Wilson's Disease: An Update on the Diagnostic Workup and Management

Wilson's disease (WD) is a rare autosomal recessive disorder of hepatocellular copper deposition. The diagnostic approach to patients with WD may be challenging and is based on a complex set of clinical findings that derive from patient history, physical examination, as well as laboratory and imaging testing. No single examination can unequivocally confirm or exclude the disease. Timely identification of signs and symptoms using novel biomarkers and modern diagnostic tools may help to reduce treatment delays and improve patient prognosis. The proper way of approaching WD management includes, firstly, early diagnosis and prompt treatment introduction; secondly, careful and lifelong monitoring of patient compliance and strict adherence to the treatment; and, last but not least, screening for adverse effects and evaluation of treatment efficacy. Liver transplantation is performed in about 5% of WD patients who present with acute liver failure at first disease presentation or with signs of decompensation in the course of liver cirrhosis. Increasing awareness of this rare inherited disease among health professionals, emphasizing their training to consider early signs and symptoms of the illness, and strict monitoring are vital strategies for the patient safety and efficacy of WD therapy.

Reproductive function of long-term treated patients with hepatic onset of Wilson's disease: a prospective study

RESEARCH QUESTION

Wilson's disease (WD) is a disorder of copper metabolism that can cause hormonal alterations. The impact of WD and its therapies on fertility is not well defined. The aim of this study was to evaluate ovarian reserve and sperm parameters in long-term treated WD patients with hepatic onset.

DESIGN

WD patients with hepatic onset treated for at least 5 years were compared with healthy controls. Men underwent spermiogram and sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF) analysis. Women were tested for serum FSH, anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) and sonographic antral follicle count (AFC) in the early follicular phase. Ovulation was monitored with ultrasound and progesterone serum concentrations in the luteal phase.

RESULTS

The WD group included 26 patients (12 males), the control group 19 subjects (9 males). All patients apart from four (one male) were responders to WD treatment. Sperm count and morphology were comparable between cases and controls. Sperm motility (total and after 1 h) was significantly lower in cases (44.78 ± 21.65%; 47.85 ± 21.52%) than controls (61.88 ± 11.03; 69.44 ± 11.02%, P = 0.03 and 0.01, respectively). The only non-responder had severe oligo-astheno-teratozoospermia. SDF values were normal in cases and controls. AMH, AFC and FSH did not differ between cases and controls. LH was significantly lower in cases (3.36 ± 1.65 mIU/ml) than controls (6.25 ± 1.03 mIU/ml, P < 0.0001). A non-responder woman who developed neurological signs had a 7-year history of infertility.

CONCLUSIONS

WD patients with hepatic onset, diagnosed early and treated, have no impairment in fertility potential even if males show reduced sperm motility and females lower LH values. Only patients with poor disease control have some evidence of impaired fertility.

The study of Wilson disease in pregnancy management

Introduction

Pregnancy management in women with Wilson disease (WD) remains an important clinical problem. This research was conducted to investigate how to avoid worsening of WD symptoms during pregnancy and increase pregnancy success in women with WD by identifying the best pregnancy management approaches in these patients.

Patients and methods

The clinical data of 117 pregnancies among 75 women with WD were retrospectively analyzed. Related information of the fetus was also recorded and analyzed. At the same time, regression analysis was performed for data of 22 pregnant women without WD, as normal controls.

Results

Of a total of 117 pregnancies among the 75 women with WD and 31 pregnancies among the 22 control womenincluded in this study, there were 108 successful pregnancies and 9 spontaneous abortions. Among the 108 successful pregnancies, 97 women a history of copper chelation therapy before pregnancy; all 97 women stopped anti-copper therapy during pregnancy. The nine women with spontaneous abortion had no pre-pregnancy history of copper displacement therapy. The incidence of lower limb edema was higher in the WD group than in normal controls (P = 0.036). Compared with the control group, there was a higher proportion in the WD group of male infants (P = 0.022) and lower average infant birth weight (t = 3.514, P = 0.001).

Conclusion

It is relatively safe for women with WD patients to become pregnant. The best management method for pregnancy in women with WD may be intensive pre-pregnancy copper chelation therapy and no anti-copper treatment during pregnancy.

Pregnancy and Wilson disease: management and outcome of mother and newborns-experiences of a perinatal centre

Background

Wilson disease is an autosomal recessive genetic disorder affecting copper transport leading to hepatic and/or neuropsychiatric manifestation. Untreated Wilson disease in females may cause sub fertility or spontaneous miscarriage. Although the literature shows an increasing number of successful outcomes after treatment, pregnant patients with Wilson disease still need close monitoring and interdisciplinary management.

Methods

In a retrospective study patient charts of 32 pregnancies in 22 women with Wilson disease were reviewed retrospectively for the initial clinical manifestation, medical treatment prior and during pregnancy, maternal and fetal course and outcome.

Results

A total of 32 pregnancies in 22 patients were analyzed. The majority of our patients did not have any deterioration of symptoms of Wilson disease prior to and during pregnancy. One pregnant patient decided to stop her anticopper medications while pregnant with fatal outcome for both, mother and foetus. None of our newborns showed major birth defects or side effects in this cohort after maternal chelation treatment.

Conclusions

Reproductive status and pregnancies of women with Wilson disease may be problematic. Pregnant women need close monitoring and multidisciplinary management. Anticopper therapy during pregnancy and breast feeding are safe. Treatment should be maintained during pregnancy and the pregnant women should be treated by a multi-disciplinary team. With adequate medical treatment and close monitoring before and during pregnancy, a successful outcome of mother and newborn can be achieved.

Pregnancy in Wilson's disease: Management and outcome

Wilson's disease (WD) is a rare inherited disorder of copper metabolism causing toxic hepatic and neural copper accumulation. Clinical symptoms vary widely, from asymptomatic disease to acute liver failure or chronic liver disease with or without neuropsychiatric symptoms. Continuation of specific medical treatment for WD is recommended during pregnancy, but reports of pregnancy outcomes in WD patients are sparse. In a retrospective, multicenter study, 282 pregnancies in 136 WD patients were reviewed. Age at disease onset, age at conception, and WD-specific treatments were recorded. Maternal complications during pregnancy, rate of spontaneous abortions, and birth defects were analyzed with respect to medical treatment during pregnancy. Worsening of liver function tests was evident during 16 of 282 (6%) pregnancies and occurred in undiagnosed patients as well as in those under medical treatment. Liver test abnormalities resolved in all cases after delivery. Aggravation of neurological symptoms during pregnancy was rare (1%), but tended to persist after delivery. The overall spontaneous abortion rate in the study cohort was 73 of 282 (26%). Patients with an established diagnosis of WD receiving medical treatment experienced significantly fewer spontaneous abortions than patients with undiagnosed WD (odds ratio, 2.853 [95% confidence interval, 1.634-4.982]). Birth defects occurred in 7 of 209 (3%) live births.

CONCLUSION

Pregnancy in WD patients on anticopper therapy is safe. The spontaneous abortion rate in treated patients was lower than that in therapy-naïve patients. Although the teratogenic potential of copper chelators is a concern, the rate of birth defects in our cohort was low. Treatment for WD should be maintained during pregnancy, and patients should be monitored closely for hepatic and neurological symptoms. (Hepatology 2018;67:1261-1269).

Drug safety in pregnancy: the German Embryotox institute

Since 1988, the German Embryotox institute combines individual counselling of pregnant women and their health care providers (HCP) with research on drug safety in pregnancy. In addition, Embryotox offers web-based information which covers the most important and most frequently requested pharmaceutical substances. In contrast to ready-made drug risk information in package leaflets and other product information, individual counselling considers different clinical settings such as (1) looking for a drug of choice or planning pregnancy under medication, (2) risk assessment of a particular drug that has already been taken during an (unplanned) pregnancy and (3) evaluation of an adverse pregnancy outcome in association with a particular medication. Using the three established developmental toxicants valproic acid, isotretinoin, and renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system (RAAS) inhibitors as an example, the need of detailed information is illustrated. Through the risk communication process, pregnancy outcome data are routinely collected by Embryotox. This approach uses the advantages of a pre-existing communication structure and of dealing with motivated responders. Engagement in the treatment plan facilitates receiving reliable data on drug exposure as well as detailed follow-up data. Based on these patient records, prospective datasets are evaluated in observational cohort studies in comparison to non-exposed control cohorts. In addition, retrospective datasets received as suspected adverse drug reactions from multiple German sources allow a screening for signals of teratogenicity and distinct patterns of developmental toxicity. Clinical expertise in specialties such as teratology, paediatrics, embryology, obstetrics and human genetics are required to ensure high-quality assessment of drug safety in pregnancy.