On the dimensionality of formal thought disorder

Evidence for the factor structure of formal thought disorder: A systematic review

Disorganised speech, or, formal thought disorder (FTD), is considered one of the core features of psychosis, yet its factor structure remains debated. This systematic review aimed to identify the core dimensions of FTD. In line with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA), a systematic review was conducted on the FTD factor analytic literature. Sixteen studies were identified from PsycINFO, PubMed and Web of Science between October 1971 and January 2023. Across the 39 factor analyses investigated, findings demonstrated the prominence of a three-factor structure. Broad agreement was found for two factors within the three-factor model, which were typically referred to as disorganisation and negative, with the exact nature of the third dimension requiring further clarification. The quality assessment revealed some methodological challenges relating to the assessment of FTD and conducted factor analyses. Future research should clarify the exact nature of the third dimension across different patient groups and methodologies to determine whether a consistent transdiagnostic concept of FTD can be elucidated.

Depressive symptoms are specifically related to speech pauses in schizophrenia spectrum disorders

Depression is a common and debilitating mental illness associated with sadness and negativity and is often comorbid with other psychiatric conditions, such as schizophrenia. Depressive symptoms are presently primarily assessed through clinical interviews, however there are other behavioural indicators being investigated as more objective methods of depressive symptom assessment. The present study aimed to evaluate the utility of assessing depression using quantitative speech parameters by comparing speech between 23 schizophrenia/schizoaffective patients with clinically significant depressive symptoms (DP) 19 schizophrenia/schizoaffective patients without depressive symptoms (NDP) and 22 healthy controls with no psychiatric history (HC). Participant audio recordings were transcribed and analyzed to extract five types of speech variables: utterances, words, speaking rate, formulation errors and pauses. The results indicated that DP patients produced significantly more pauses within utterances, and had more utterances with pauses compared to NDP patients and HCs (p = <.05), who performed similarly to each other. Word, speaking rate and formulation errors variables were not significantly different between the patient groups (p > .05). The findings suggest that depressive symptoms may have a specific relationship to speech pauses, and support the potential future use of speech pause assessments as an alternative and objective depression rating and monitoring tool.

Dimensions of Formal Thought Disorder and Their Relation to Gray- and White Matter Brain Structure in Affective and Psychotic Disorders

Factorial dimensions and neurobiological underpinnings of formal thought disorders (FTD) have been extensively investigated in schizophrenia spectrum disorders (SSD). However, FTD are also highly prevalent in other disorders. Still, there is a lack of knowledge about transdiagnostic, structural brain correlates of FTD. In N = 1071 patients suffering from DSM-IV major depressive disorder, bipolar disorder, or SSD, we calculated a psychopathological factor model of FTD based on the SAPS and SANS scales. We tested the association of FTD dimensions with 3 T MRI measured gray matter volume (GMV) and white matter fractional anisotropy (FA) using regression and interaction models in SPM12. We performed post hoc confirmatory analyses in diagnostically equally distributed, age- and sex-matched sub-samples to test whether results were driven by diagnostic categories. Cross-validation (explorative and confirmatory) factor analyses revealed three psychopathological FTD factors: disorganization, emptiness, and incoherence. Disorganization was negatively correlated with a GMV cluster comprising parts of the middle occipital and angular gyri and positively with FA in the right posterior cingulum bundle and inferior longitudinal fascicle. Emptiness was negatively associated with left hippocampus and thalamus GMV. Incoherence was negatively associated with FA in bilateral anterior thalamic radiation, and positively with the hippocampal part of the right cingulum bundle. None of the gray or white matter associations interacted with diagnosis. Our results provide a refined mapping of cross-disorder FTD phenotype dimensions. For the first time, we demonstrated that their neuroanatomical signatures are associated with language-related gray and white matter structures independent of diagnosis.

Investigating the diagnostic utility of speech patterns in schizophrenia and their symptom associations

BACKGROUND

Speech disturbances are a recognised aspect of schizophrenia that may have potential utility as a diagnostic indicator. Recent advances in quantitative speech assessment methods have led to more reproducible and precise metrics making this possible. The current study sought firstly to characterise the speech profile of schizophrenia patients using quantitative speech measures, then examine the diagnostic utility of these measures and explore their relationship to symptoms.

METHODS

Speech recordings from 43 schizophrenia/schizoaffective disorder (SZ) patients and 46 healthy controls (HC) were obtained and transcribed. Cognitive and symptom measures were also administered.

RESULTS

Compared to HCs, SZ patients had higher incidences of aberrance across five types of quantitative speech variables: utterances, single words, time/speaking rate, turns and formulation errors, but not pauses. Based on two machine learning algorithms, 21 speech variables across the same five speech variable types (again not including pauses) were identified as significant classifiers for a schizophrenia diagnosis with 90-100% specificity and 80-90% sensitivity for both models. Selective relationships were also observed between these speech variables and only positive, disorganisation, excitement and formal thought disorder symptoms.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings support pervasive speech impairments in schizophrenia patients relative to HCs, and the potential diagnostic utility of these speech disturbances. Continued work is needed to build the evidence base for quantitative speech assessment as a future objective diagnostic tool for schizophrenia. It holds the promise of improved diagnostic accuracy leading to increased treatment efficacy and better patient outcomes.

Formal thought disorder in patients with first-episode schizophrenia: Results of a one-year follow-up study

Formal thought disorder (FTD) refers to abnormal speech patterns that can be characterized by deficiencies in thought organization and direction. The present study aimed to assess the factor structure of FTD and to examine its relationship with cognition and clinical features at first admission in patients with first-episode schizophrenia. We also examined the course of FTD during the twelve months after first admission. We assessed FTD using the alogia items of the Scale for the Assessment of Negative Symptoms and FTD items of the Scale for the Assessment of Positive Symptoms in 160 drug-naïve patients. A three-factor structure as a disorganization factor, poverty factor, and verbosity factor were found in principal component analysis. The poverty factor was correlated negatively with executive functions, attention, and global cognition. The poverty factor was also correlated with global functioning. Admission FTD factor scores were not related to global functioning and work/study status at one year. The positive-FTD score decreased from admission to the third month, but no change occurred from the third to the twelfth month. The negative-FTD score did not differ throughout the follow-up. Our findings showed that FTD had three factors. Each factor had a different relationship with cognition and functioning.

Questioning the status of aberrant speech patterns as psychiatric symptoms

Speech disturbances manifest in various psychiatric conditions and demonstrate temporal variability in relation to acute and stable symptom periods. They can be externally assessed, which facilitates their potential use as an objective marker of illness stage. Continued research will have positive implications for diagnostics and long-term management in clinical settings.