Epileptic spasms in clusters with focal EEG paroxysms: A study of 12 patients

Epilepsy surgery for children with epileptic spasms: A systematic review and meta-analysis with focus on predictors and outcomes

To conduct a systematic review of the literature regarding rates and predictors of favorable seizure outcome after resective surgery for epileptic spasms (ES) in pediatric patients. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses standards were followed. We searched PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane CENTRAL for articles published on the prevalence or incidence of epileptic spasm since 1985. Abstract, full-text review, and data extraction were conducted by two independent reviewers. Meta-analysis was performed to assess overall seizure freedom rate. Subject-level analysis was performed on a subset of studies to identify prognostic indicators. A total of 21 retrospective studies (n = 531) were included. Meta-analysis of all studies demonstrated a pooled seizure freedom rate of 68.8%. Subject-level analysis on 18 studies (n = 360) demonstrated a significant association between duration of spasms and recurrence of spasms after surgery, with an estimated increased risk of 7% per additional year of spasms prior to operation. Patients who underwent resective surgery that was not a hemispherectomy (i.e., lobectomy, lesionectomy, etc.) had an increased recurrence risk of 57% compared to patients who had undergone hemispherectomy. Resective surgery results in seizure freedom for the majority of pediatric patients with epileptic spasms. Patients who undergo hemispherectomy have lower risk of recurrence than patients who undergo other types of surgical resection. Increased duration of spasms prior to surgery is associated with increased recurrence risk after surgery. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Children with epileptic spasms (ES) that do not respond to medications may benefit from surgical treatment. Our study reviewed existing research to understand how effective surgery is in treating ES in children and what factors predict better outcomes. Researchers followed strict guidelines to search for and analyze studies published since 1985, finding 21 studies with a total of 531 patients. They found that, on average, nearly 70% of children became seizure-free after surgery. Further individual analysis of 360 patients showed that longer duration of spasms before surgery increased the risk of spasms returning by 7% per year. Additionally, children who had less extensive surgeries, such as removal of only a specific part of the brain, had a 57% higher risk of seizure recurrence compared to those who had a hemispherectomy, which removed or disconnected half of the brain. Overall, the study concludes that surgery can often stop seizures, especially when more extensive surgery is performed and when the surgery is done sooner rather than later.

Electroclinical Features of Infantile Epileptic Spasms Syndrome

Epileptic spasms are a unique, age-dependent manifestation of epilepsies in infancy and early childhood, commonly occurring as part of infantile epileptic spasms syndrome. Developmental stagnation and subsequent decline may occur in children with epileptic spasms, partly due to the abundant high-amplitude interictal epileptiform and slow wave abnormalities. Early recognition and treatment of epileptic spasms, along with the reversal of the electroencephalography (EEG) findings, are critical for improving outcomes. Recognizing hypsarrhythmia and its variations is key to confirming the diagnosis. The various patterns of hypsarrhythmia are not etiology specific, but could indicate the severity of the disease. Several scoring systems have been proposed to improve the inter-rater reliability of recognizing hypsarrhythmia and to assess EEG progress in response to treatment. Ictal patterns during spasms are brief and composed of slow waves, sharp transients, fast activity, and voltage attenuation, either in isolation or more commonly as a combination of these waveforms. Ictal patterns are commonly diffuse, but may be lateralized to one hemisphere in children with structural etiology. A subset of patients with epileptic spasms has a surgically remediable etiology, with readily identifiable lesions on neuroimaging in most cases. Asymmetry in epileptic spasms, concurrent focal seizures, and asymmetric interictal and ictal EEG findings may be present, but a lack of focality in electrophysiological findings is not uncommon. Intracranial EEG features of epileptic spasms have been described, but the utility of intracranial EEG monitoring in surgical candidates with overt focal epileptogenic lesions on magnetic resonance imaging is questionable, and surgery could be performed using noninvasive data.

Resective epilepsy surgery for West syndrome: The Hypsarrhythmic Asymmetric Scoring Scheme is a determining predictor of seizure outcome

OBJECTIVE

It has been suggested that asymmetric hypsarrhythmia is associated with structural etiology. We devised the Hypsarrhythmic Asymmetric Scoring Scheme (HASS) to quantify the degree of hypsarrhythmic asymmetry in a retrospective series of patients who underwent surgical treatment at our center. The present study aimed to investigate the role of HASS in predicting the postsurgical seizure outcomes.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed the records of 46 children with hypsarrhythmia who underwent resective epilepsy surgery between 2018 and 2020 and were followed up for at least 1 year after surgery. Hypsarrhythmia severity in each hemisphere was quantified and scored. The HASS score was calculated as the difference between the two hemispheres. Univariate results were submitted to logistic regression models to identify independent predictors for favorable surgical outcomes.

RESULTS

Of the 46 patients who underwent resective surgery, Engel's class I-Ⅱ outcomes were achieved in 34 (73.9%). The Engel I-Ⅱ group had a significantly higher HASS score than the Engel Ⅲ-Ⅳ group (p<0.001). Multivariate analysis showed that the HASS score was the only significant predictor of good outcomes (p = 0.011). Further receiver operating characteristic analysis showed that a threshold of 7 yielded a better seizure outcome with a sensitivity of 97.06% and specificity of 83.33%.

SIGNIFICANCE

As the first hypsarrhythmia scoring system specially designed for presurgical evaluation, the HASS score may contribute to predicting the postsurgical seizure outcome from the electroencephalography perspective.

The severe epilepsy syndromes of infancy: A population-based study

OBJECTIVE

To study the epilepsy syndromes among the severe epilepsies of infancy and assess their incidence, etiologies, and outcomes.

METHODS

A population-based cohort study was undertaken of severe epilepsies with onset before age 18 months in Victoria, Australia. Two epileptologists reviewed clinical features, seizure videos, and electroencephalograms to diagnose International League Against Epilepsy epilepsy syndromes. Incidence, etiologies, and outcomes at age 2 years were determined.

RESULTS

Seventy-three of 114 (64%) infants fulfilled diagnostic criteria for epilepsy syndromes at presentation, and 16 (14%) had "variants" of epilepsy syndromes in which there was one missing or different feature, or where all classical features had not yet emerged. West syndrome (WS) and "WS-like" epilepsy (infantile spasms without hypsarrhythmia or modified hypsarrhythmia) were the most common syndromes, with a combined incidence of 32.7/100 000 live births/year. The incidence of epilepsy of infancy with migrating focal seizures (EIMFS) was 4.5/100 000 and of early infantile epileptic encephalopathy (EIEE) was 3.6/100 000. Structural etiologies were common in "WS-like" epilepsy (100%), unifocal epilepsy (83%), and WS (39%), whereas single gene disorders predominated in EIMFS, EIEE, and Dravet syndrome. Eighteen (16%) infants died before age 2 years. Development was delayed or borderline in 85 of 96 (89%) survivors, being severe-profound in 40 of 96 (42%). All infants with EIEE or EIMFS had severe-profound delay or were deceased, but only 19 of 64 (30%) infants with WS, "WS-like," or "unifocal epilepsy" had severe-profound delay, and only two of 64 (3%) were deceased.

SIGNIFICANCE

Three quarters of severe epilepsies of infancy could be assigned an epilepsy syndrome or "variant syndrome" at presentation. In this era of genomic testing and advanced brain imaging, diagnosing epilepsy syndromes at presentation remains clinically useful for guiding etiologic investigation, initial treatment, and prognostication.

Seizure initiation in infantile spasms vs. focal seizures: proposed common cellular mechanisms

Infantile spasms (IS) and seizures with focal onset have different clinical expressions, even when electroencephalography (EEG) associated with IS has some degree of focality. Oddly, identical pathology (with, however, age-dependent expression) can lead to IS in one patient vs. focal seizures in another or even in the same, albeit older, patient. We therefore investigated whether the cellular mechanisms underlying seizure initiation are similar in the two instances: spasms vs. focal. We noted that in-common EEG features can include (i) a background of waves at alpha to delta frequencies; (ii) a period of flattening, lasting about a second or more - the electrodecrement (ED); and (iii) often an interval of very fast oscillations (VFO; ~70 Hz or faster) preceding, or at the beginning of, the ED. With IS, VFO temporally coincides with the motor spasm. What is different between the two conditions is this: with IS, the ED reverts to recurring slow waves, as occurring before the ED, whereas with focal seizures the ED instead evolves into an electrographic seizure, containing high-amplitude synchronized bursts, having superimposed VFO. We used in vitro data to help understand these patterns, as such data suggest cellular mechanisms for delta waves, for VFO, for seizure-related burst complexes containing VFO, and, more recently, for the ED. We propose a unifying mechanistic hypothesis - emphasizing the importance of brain pH - to explain the commonalities and differences of EEG signals in IS versus focal seizures.

Status Epilepticus Manifested as Continuous Epileptic Spasms

Objective: The etiology and outcome of status epilepticus with continuous epileptic spasms have not been fully understood; and only rare cases have been reported in the literature. Here, we described 11 children, who manifested continuous epileptic spasms with various etiologies and different outcomes. Methods: This is a case series study designed to systematically review the charts, video-electroencephalography (video-EEG), magnetic resonance images, and longitudinal follow-up of patients who presented continuous epileptic spasms lasting more than 30 min. Results: Median age at onset was 2 years old, ranging from 2 months to 5.6 years. The etiology of continuous epileptic spasms for these 11 cases consisted of not only some known electro-clinical epilepsy syndromes like West Syndrome and Ohtahara Syndrome, but also secondary symptomatic continuous epileptic spasms, caused by acute encephalitis or encephalopathy, which extends the etiological spectrum of continuous epileptic spasms. The most characteristic feature of these 11 cases was prolonged epileptic spasms, lasting for a median of 13.00 days (95% CI: 7.26-128.22 days). The interictal EEG findings typically manifested as hypsarrhythmia or its variants, including burst suppression. Hospital stays were much longer in acute symptomatic cases than in primary epileptic syndromic cases (59.67 ± 50.82 vs. 15.00 ± 1.41 days). However, the long-term outcomes were extremely poor in the patients with defined electro-clinical epilepsy syndromes, including severe motor and intellectual developmental deficits (follow-up of 4.94 ± 1.56 years), despite early diagnosis and treatment. Continuous epileptic spasms were refractory to corticosteroids, immuno-modulation or immunosuppressive therapies, and ketogenic diet. Conclusion: Continuous epileptic spasms were associated with severe brain impairments in patients with electro-clinical syndromes; and required long hospital stays in patients with acute symptomatic causes. We suggest to include continuous epileptic spasms in the international classification of status epilepticus, as a special form. Further investigations are required to better recognize this condition, better understand the etiology, as well as to explore more effective treatments to improve outcomes.

Concordance between the interictal focal EEG pattern and MRI lesions as a predictor of a favorable surgical outcome in patients with epileptic spasms: a Chinese study

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the electro-clinical features, etiology, treatment, and postsurgical seizure outcomes in patients with intractable epileptic spasms (ESs).

METHODS

The authors retrospectively studied the medical records of all patients who had presented with medically intractable ESs and had undergone surgery in the period between October 2009 and August 2015. The interictal electroencephalography (EEG) pattern, MRI studies, magnetoencephalography findings, and postsurgical seizure outcomes were compared.

RESULTS

Twenty-six patients, 12 boys and 14 girls (age range 3-22 years), were eligible for study inclusion. Of these 26 patients, 84.6% (22) presented with multiple seizure types including partial seizures (PSs) independent of the ESs (30.8%); ESs followed by tonic seizures (30.8%); myoclonic seizures (19.2%); tonic seizures (19.2%); ESs followed by PSs (19.2%); focal seizures with secondary generalization (15.4%); atypical absence (11.5%); PSs followed by ESs (7.7%); and myoclonic followed by tonic seizures (7.7%). Seventeen patients underwent multilobar resection and 9 underwent unilobar resection. At the last follow-up (mean 36.6 months), 42.3% of patients were seizure free (outcome classification [OC] 1), 23.1% had > 50% reduction in seizure frequency (OC2-OC4), and 34.6% had < 50% reduction in seizure frequency or no improvement (OC5 and OC6). Predictors of favorable outcomes included an interictal focal EEG pattern and concordance between interictal EEG and MRI-demonstrated lesions (p = 0.001 and 0.004, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

A favorable surgical outcome is achievable in a highly select group of patients with ESs secondary to structural lesions. Interictal EEG can help in identifying patients with the potential for favorable resective outcomes.