Mechanisms of sickle cell alloimmunization

An overview of red blood cell and platelet alloimmunisation in transfusion

Post-transfusion alloimmunisation is the main complication of all those observed after one or more transfusion episodes. Alloimmunisation is observed after the transfusion of red blood cell concentrates but also of platelet concentrates. Besides alloimmunisation due to antigens carried almost exclusively by red blood cells such as those of the Rhesus-Kell system, alloimmunisation often raises against HLA antigens; the main responsibility for that, apart from platelet transfusions, lies with residual leukocytes in the products transfused, hence the central importance of effective leukoreduction right from the blood product preparation stage. Alloimmunization is not restricted to transfusion, but it is also observed during pregnancies, carrying out microtransfusions of blood from the fetus immunizing the mother through the placenta (in a retrograde way). Preexisting maternal-fetal immunization can complicate a transfusion program and intensify the creation of alloantibodies in several blood and tissue group systems. The occurrence of autoantibodies, created by several pathogenic reasons, can also interfere with the propensity of certain recipients of blood components to produce alloantibodies. The genetic condition of individuals is in fact strongly linked to the ability or not to recognize antigenic variants foreign to their own biological program and mount an alloimmune response. Some hemoglobin diseases, in carriers of which transfusions can be iterative and lifelong, are complicated by frequent alloimmunizations and amplification of the complications of these alloimmunizations, imposing even stricter transfusion rules. This review details the mechanisms favoring the occurrence of alloimmunization and the immunological principles for the production of molecular and cellular tools for alloimmunization. It concludes with the main preventive measures available to limit the occurrence of these frequent complications of varying severity but sometimes severe.

Indications for transfusion in the management of sickle cell disease

The transfusion of red blood cells (RBCs) is a crucial treatment for sickle cell disease (SCD). While often beneficial, the frequent use of transfusions is associated with numerous complications. Transfusions should be offered with specific guidelines in mind. Here we present updates to the indications for transfusion of RBCs in SCD. We review recent publications and include expert perspectives from hematology and transfusion medicine. For some clinical indications, such as ischemic stroke, the role of transfusion has been well studied and can be applied almost universally. For many other clinical scenarios, the use of transfusion therapy has less conclusive data and therefore must be tailored to individual needs. We highlight the roles of RBC transfusions in preventing or mitigating neurological disease, in reducing perioperative complications, in managing acute chest syndrome, and in optimizing pregnancy outcomes in SCD. We further highlight various transfusion techniques and when each might be considered. Potential complications of transfusion are also briefly discussed.

Initial experimental experience of triple-knockout pig red blood cells as potential sources for transfusion in alloimmunized patients with sickle cell disease

BACKGROUND

Blood transfusion remains important in the treatment of patients with sickle cell disease (SCD). However, alloimmunization after blood transfusion is associated with patient morbidity and mortality. Triple-knockout (TKO) pigs (i.e., pigs in which the three known xenoantigens to which humans have anti-pig antibodies have been deleted) may be an alternative source of RBCs for these patients because many humans have no preformed antibodies to TKO pig RBCs (pRBCs).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In an in vitro study, plasma from alloimmunized (n = 12) or non-alloimmunized (n = 12) SCD patients was used to determine IgM/IgG binding to, and CDC of, TKO pRBCs. In an in vivo study, after an estimated 25% of blood volume was withdrawn from two capuchin monkeys, CFSE-labeled TKO pRBCs were transfused. Loss of TKO pRBCs was monitored by flow cytometry, and 7 weeks later, 25% of blood was withdrawn, and CFSE-labeled monkey RBCs were transfused.

RESULTS

The in vitro study demonstrated that plasma from neither alloimmunized nor non-alloimmunized SCD patients bound IgM/IgG to, or induced CDC of, TKO pRBCs. In the in vivo study, survival of TKO pRBCs in the two capuchin monkeys was of 5 and 7 days, respectively, whereas after allotransfusion, survival was >28 days.

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, (1) in the present limited study, no antibodies were detected that cross-reacted with TKO pRBCs, and (2) TKO pigs may possibly be an alternate source of RBCs in an emergency if no human RBCs are available.

Alteration of humoral, cellular and cytokine immune response to inactivated influenza vaccine in patients with Sickle Cell Disease

Introduction

Patients suffering from Sickle Cell Disease (SCD) are at increased risk for complications due to influenza virus. Annual influenza vaccination is strongly recommended but few clinical studies have assessed its immunogenicity in individuals with SCD. The aim of this study was to explore the biological efficacy of annual influenza vaccination in SCD patients by characterizing both their humoral and cell-mediated immunity against influenza antigen. We also aimed to investigate these immunological responses among SCD individuals according to their treatment (hydroxyurea (HU), chronic blood transfusions (CT), both HU and CT or none of them).

Methods

Seventy-two SCD patients (49 receiving HU, 9 on CT, 7 with both and 7 without treatment) and 30 healthy controls were included in the study. All subjects received the tetravalent influenza α-RIX-Tetra® vaccine from the 2016–2017 or 2017–2018 season.

Results

Protective anti-influenza HAI titers were obtained for the majority of SCD patients one month after vaccination but seroconversion rates in patient groups were strongly decreased compared to controls. Immune cell counts, particularly cellular memory including memory T and memory B cells, were greatly reduced in SCD individuals. Functional activation assays confirmed a poorer CD8⁺ T cell memory. We also document an imbalance of cytokines after influenza vaccination in SCD individuals with an INFγ/IL-10 ratio (Th1-type/Treg-type response) significantly lower in the SCD cohort.

Conclusion

SCD patients undergoing CT showed altered immune regulation as compared to other treatment subgroups. Altogether, the cytokine imbalance, the high regulatory T cell levels and the low memory lymphocyte subset levels observed in the SCD cohort, namely for those on CT, suggest a poor ability of SCD patients to fight against influenza infection. Nevertheless, our serological data support current clinical practice for annual influenza vaccination, though immunogenicity to other vaccines involving immunological memory might be hampered in SCD patients and should be further investigated.

Hyperhemolysis Syndrome in Patients With Sickle Cell Disease

Sickle cell disease is a genetic disease commonly affecting people of African, Indian, and Mediterranean descent. Patients with this chronic disease often require lifelong red blood cell transfusions. Formation of alloantibodies and autoantibodies are well-known complications that can arise with multiple transfusions. Another rare, but serious complication associated with transfusion is hyperhemolysis syndrome. The acquisition of new and/or rare alloantibodies can make it more difficult to find compatible blood products for patients with sickle cell disease. Genotyping and national donor registries are useful tools for finding appropriate blood products for these patients. This review will describe the clinical and laboratory findings of sickle cell disease, including hyperhemolysis syndrome. The challenges associated with locating compatible blood for patients with various red blood cell antibodies will be reviewed.

Selecting red blood cell units to perform RBCX in patients with sickle cell disease

Red blood cell exchange (RBCX) is a standard option for treating or preventing complications in patients with sickle cell disease (SCD). According to the patient's blood volume, the amounts of red blood cells (RBC) to be exchanged and the practices of the apheresis and clinical teams, such treatment requires numerous red blood cell units (RBCUs) (3-15 RBCUs per procedure). To perform RBCXs safely and prevent the risk of alloimmunization, appropriate RBCUs must be selected and transfused to replace the sickled RBCs. Understanding of alloimmunization in patients with SCD strengthened the development of recommendations for preventing the risk of alloimmunization. This review describes the alloimmunization risk, the methods used to decrease the risk, and our own experience.

Complement activation during intravascular hemolysis: Implication for sickle cell disease and hemolytic transfusion reactions

Intravascular hemolysis is a hallmark of a large spectrum of diseases, including the sickle cell disease (SCD), and is characterized by liberation of red blood cell (RBC) degradation products in the circulation. Released Hb, heme, RBC fragments and microvesicles (MVs) exert pro-inflammatory, pro-oxidative and cytotoxic effects and contribute to vascular and tissue damage. The innate immune complement system not only contributes to the RBC lysis, but it is also itself activated by heme, RBC MVs and the hypoxia-altered endothelium, amplifying thus the cell and tissue damage. This review focuses on the implication of the complement system in hemolysis and hemolysis-mediated injuries in SCD and in cases of delayed hemolytic transfusion reactions (DHTR). We summarize the evidences for presence of biomarkers of complement activation in patients with SCD and the mechanisms of complement activation in DHTR. We discuss the role of antibodies-dependent activation of the classical complement pathway as well as the heme-dependent activation of the alternative pathway. Finally, we describe the available evidences for the efficacy of therapeutic blockade of complement in cases of DHTR. In conclusion, complement blockade is holding promises but future prospective studies are required to introduce Eculizumab or another upcoming complement therapeutic for DHTR and even in SCD.

Recipient priming to one RBC alloantigen directly enhances subsequent alloimmunization in mice

Individuals that become immunized to red blood cell (RBC) alloantigens can experience an increased rate of antibody formation to additional RBC alloantigens following subsequent transfusion. Despite this, how an immune response to one RBC immunogen may impact subsequent alloimmunization to a completely different RBC alloantigen remains unknown. Our studies demonstrate that Kell blood group antigen (KEL) RBC transfusion in the presence of inflammation induced by poly (I:C) (PIC) not only enhances anti-KEL antibody production through a CD4⁺ T-cell-dependent process but also directly facilitates anti-HOD antibody formation following subsequent exposure to the disparate HOD (hen egg lysozyme, ovalbumin, fused to human blood group antigen Duffy b) antigen. PIC/KEL priming of the anti-HOD antibody response required that RBCs express both the KEL and HOD antigens (HOD × KEL RBCs), as transfusion of HOD RBCs plus KEL RBCs or HOD RBCs alone failed to impact anti-HOD antibody formation in recipients previously primed with PIC/KEL. Transfer of CD4⁺ T cells from PIC/KEL-primed recipients directly facilitated anti-HOD antibody formation following (HOD × KEL) RBC transfusion. RBC alloantigen priming was not limited to PIC/KEL enhancement of anti-HOD alloantibody formation, as HOD-reactive CD4⁺ T cells enhanced anti-glycophorin A (anti-GPA) antibody formation in the absence of inflammation following transfusion of RBCs coexpressing GPA and HOD. These results demonstrate that immune priming to one RBC alloantigen can directly enhance a humoral response to a completely different RBC alloantigen, providing a potential explanation for why alloantibody responders may exhibit increased immune responsiveness to additional RBC alloantigens following subsequent transfusion.

Complement serves as a switch between CD4+ T cell-independent and -dependent RBC antibody responses

RBC alloimmunization represents a significant immunological challenge for patients requiring lifelong transfusion support. The majority of clinically relevant non-ABO(H) blood group antigens have been thought to drive antibody formation through T cell-dependent immune pathways. Thus, we initially sought to define the role of CD4+ T cells in formation of alloantibodies to KEL, one of the leading causes of hemolytic transfusion reactions. Unexpectedly, our findings demonstrated that KEL RBCs actually possess the ability to induce antibody formation independent of CD4+ T cells or complement component 3 (C3), two common regulators of antibody formation. However, despite the ability of KEL RBCs to induce anti-KEL antibodies in the absence of complement, removal of C3 or complement receptors 1 and 2 (CR1/2) rendered recipients completely reliant on CD4+ T cells for IgG anti-KEL antibody formation. Together, these findings suggest that C3 may serve as a novel molecular switch that regulates the type of immunological pathway engaged following RBC transfusion.

Sickle Cell Disease Clinical Trials and Phenotypes

Sickle cell disease, one of the world’s most common genetic disorders is prevalent in sub-Saharan Africa. The trans-Atlantic slave trade accounted for the gene movement from Africa to the Caribbean and United States of America and lately, migration has resulted in the introduction of the gene to the United Kingdom and other parts of Europe. Different haplotypes exist, however the differences in these haplotypes are not sufficient to explain the different clinical variations within the same region or different settings.

A Conceptual Framework for Optimizing Blood Matching Strategies: Balancing Patient Complications Against Total Costs Incurred

Alloimmunization is currently the most frequent adverse blood transfusion event. Whilst completely matched donor blood would nullify the alloimmunization risk, this is practically infeasible. Current matching strategies therefore aim at matching a limited number of blood groups only, and have evolved over time by systematically including matching strategies for those blood groups for which (serious) alloimmunization complications most frequently occurred. An optimal matching strategy for controlling the risk of alloimmunization however, would balance alloimmunization complications and costs within the entire blood supply chain, whilst fulfilling all practical requirements and limitations. In this article the outline of an integrated blood management model is described and various potential challenges and prospects foreseen with the development of such a model are discussed.

Transfusion-associated hazards: A revisit of their presentation

As a therapy or a support to other therapies, despite being largely beneficial to patients in general, transfusion it is not devoid of some risks. In a moderate number of cases, patients may manifest adverse reactions, otherwise referred to as transfusion-associated hazards (TAHs). The latest French 2016 haemovigilance report indicates that 93% of TAHs are minor (grade 1), 5.5% are moderate (grade 2) and 1.6% are severe (grade 3), with only five deaths (grade 4) being attributed to transfusion with relative certainty (imputability of level [or grade] 1 to 3). Health-care providers need to be well aware of the benefits and potential risks (to best evaluate and discuss the benefit-risk ratio), how to prevent TAHs, the overall costs and the availability of alternative therapeutic options. In high-income countries, most blood establishments (BEs) and hospital blood banks (HBBs) have developed tools for reporting and analysing at least severe transfusion reactions. With nearly two decades of haemovigilance, transfusion reaction databases should be quite informative, though there are four main caveats that prevent it from being fully efficient: (ai) reporting is mainly declarative and is thus barely exhaustive even in countries where it is mandatory by law; (aii) it is often difficult to differentiate between the different complications related to transfusion, diseases, comorbidities and other types of therapies in patients suffering from debilitating conditions; (aiii) there is a lack of consistency in the definitions used to describe and report some transfusion reactions, their severity and their likelihood of being related to transfusion; and (aiv) it is difficult to assess the imputability of a particular BC given to a patient who has previously received many BCs over a relatively short period of time. When compiling all available information published so far, it appears that TAHs can be analysed using different approaches: (bi) their pathophysiological nature; (bii) their severity; (biii) the onset scheme; (biv) a quality assessment (preventable or non-preventable); (bv) their impact on ongoing therapy. Moreover, TAHs can be reported either in a non-integrative or in an integrative way; in the latter case, presentation may also differ when issued by a blood establishment or a treating ward. At some point, a recapitulative document would be useful to gain a better understanding of TAHs in order to decrease their occurrence and severity and allow decision makers to determine action plans: this is what this review attempts to make. This review attempts to merge the different aspects, with a focus on the hospital side, i.e., how the most frequent TAHs can be avoided or mitigated.

Medical and economic implications of strategies to prevent alloimmunization in sickle cell disease

BACKGROUND

The pathogenesis of alloimmunization is not well understood, and initiatives that aim to reduce the incidence of alloimmunization are generally expensive and either ineffective or unproven. In this review, we summarize the current medical literature regarding alloimmunization in the sickle cell disease (SCD) population, with a special focus on the financial implications of different approaches to prevent alloimmunization.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A review of EMBASE and MEDLINE data from January 2006 through January 2016 was conducted to identify articles relating to complications of SCD. The search was specifically designed to capture articles that evaluated the costs of various strategies to prevent alloimmunization and its sequelae.

RESULTS

Currently, there is no proven, inexpensive way to prevent alloimmunization among individuals with SCD. Serologic matching programs are not uniformly successful in preventing alloimmunization, particularly to Rh antigens, because of the high frequency of variant Rh alleles in the SCD population. A genotypic matching program could offer some cost savings compared to a serologic matching program, but the efficacy of gene matching for the prevention of alloimmunization is largely unproven, and large-scale implementation could be expensive.

CONCLUSIONS

Future reductions in the costs associated with genotype matching could make a large-scale program economically feasible. Novel techniques to identify patients at highest risk for alloimmunization could improve the cost effectiveness of antigen matching programs. A clinical trial comparing the efficacy of serologic matching to genotype matching would be informative.

Emerging strategies of blood group genotyping for patients with hemoglobinopathies

Red cell alloimmunization is a serious problem in chronically transfused patients. A number of high-throughput DNA assays have been developed to extend or replace traditional serologic antigen typing. DNA-based typing methods may be easily automated and multiplexed, and provide reliable information on a patient. Molecular genotyping promises to become cheaper, being not dependent on serologic immunoglobulin reagents. Patients with hemoglobinopathies could benefit from receiving extended genomic typing. This could limit post transfusional complications depending on subtle antigenic differences between donors and patients. Patient/donor compatibility extended beyond the phenotype Rh/Kell may allows improved survival of transfused units of red blood cells (RBC) and lead to reduced need for blood transfusion and leading to less iron overload and reduced risk of alloimmunization. Here we discuss the advantages and limitations of current techniques, that detect only predefined genetic variants. In contrast, target enrichment next-generation sequencing (NGS) has been used to detect both known and de novo genetic polymorphisms, including single-nucleotide polymorphisms, indels (insertions/deletions), and structural variations. NGS approaches can be used to develop an extended blood group genotyping assay system.

Transfusion as an Inflammation Hit: Knowns and Unknowns

Transfusion of blood cell components is frequent in the therapeutic arsenal; it is globally safe or even very safe. At present, residual clinical manifestations are principally inflammatory in nature. If some rare clinical hazards manifest as acute inflammation symptoms of various origin, most of them linked with conflicting and undesirable biological material accompanying the therapeutic component (infectious pathogen, pathogenic antibody, unwanted antigen, or allergen), the general feature is subtler and less visible, and essentially consists of alloimmunization or febrile non-hemolytic transfusion reaction. The present essay aims to present updates in hematology and immunology that help understand how, when, and why subclinical inflammation underlies alloimmunization and circumstances characteristic of red blood cells and – even more frequently – platelets that contribute inflammatory mediators. Modern transfusion medicine makes sustained efforts to limit such inflammatory hazards; efforts can be successful only if one has a clear view of each element’s role.

The HLA-DRB1*15 phenotype is associated with multiple red blood cell and HLA antibody responsiveness

BACKGROUND

Once a patient has produced a red blood cell (RBC) antibody, there is an increased risk of additional antibody formation after subsequent RBC exposure. Recently, we observed that HLA-DRB1*15 was overrepresented in 379 multiple RBC antibody responders compared to controls or 562 patients with a single RBC antibody (odds ratio [OR], 1.7; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.3-2.3). In this study we evaluated whether the HLA-DRB1*15 represents a responder phenotype against HLA and/or RBC antigens.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

HLA-DRB1*15 frequencies in single and multiple antibody responders were compared between three groups of individuals: 1) those with HLA antibodies, 2) those with RBC antibodies, and 3) those with both RBC and HLA antibodies.

RESULTS

A total of 3959 immunized patients (female-to-male ratio, 2.3) had been HLA-DRB1 typed. Among the 3275 individuals with HLA antibodies, the frequency of the DRB1*15 phenotype differed significantly from 19.7% in patients with a panel reactivity (PRA) of not more than 20% to 26.9% in patients with PRA of more than 80% (OR, 1.5; 95% CI, 1.2-1.9). This association between DRB1*15 and multiresponsiveness was mainly due to pregnancy-induced HLA immunization. In the 257 individuals with RBC and HLA antibodies, the frequency of DRB1*15 was 4.2 times (95% CI, 1.1-16) higher in those with multiple RBC antibodies and HLA-PRA of more than 50% compared to only single RBC responders with PRA of less than 20%.

CONCLUSION

The HLA-DRB1*15 phenotype is associated with broad RBC and HLA immunization.